12 ms·
23andMe is raising about $200M, led by Sequoia
- jbob2000 9y agoAll of that money and work just so people can say "yep, I might die in a few years because I have X". Wouldn't it be better to put $200mil into curing the illnesses rather than putting a product on the market to scare people into treatment they may or may not need?
- dforrestwilson 9y agoWell planning appropriately for genetic issues would seem to have some value attached wouldn't it? Unexpected medical costs can have a huge impact on a person's finances.
- david-cako 9y agoThis sounds like it runs contrary to the commonly held belief that it would be much cheaper on a macro level for people to consume more expensive, less shitty (i.e., all starch, salt, and sugar) food than for us to exist in our current global heart disease and diabetes epidemic. Preventative measures are supposed to be the way to go, from what I've heard. Spending money on telling people how to eat correctly obviously goes against corporate interest, so it doesn't usually happen.
- tvural 9y ago$200M usually isn't enough for even one drug - $500M is on the low end, and not all drug development works out. So it's plausible that the money is better allocated here than in treatments. But also, from the article: "Based on some of 23andMe’s newer hires, we wouldn’t be shocked to see the company dive into drug development, either."
- jdale27 9y agoThe real goal is to build a database of genotypic and phenotypic data and use that to identify drug targets. In other words, curing the illnesses.
- TuringNYC 9y agoPrevention, or early intervention, is often less expensive and less painful than curing. Cures are also not always 100% and can be in the form of recurring treatments. Simple example is heart disease -- the cost of prevention is far lower than the cost of treatment.
- ggambetta 9y agoExcellent! Can't wait to find 100s more "3rd to 5th cousins" :D
- encryptThrow32 9y agoWhy would anyone willingly hand over their DNA to a third party like this?* 23andME HAS handed your most personal data over to the authorities. *(Same reason people willingly install wiretaps in their houses aka Alexa and Google Home)
- harveywi 9y agocf. billions of Facebook users.
- ballenf 9y agoI bought a kit and then never used it because of all the detailed info they required in order to create a profile and the risk you reference. Wasted $$, but still feel like I dodged a bullet by not submitting. Could have created a fake profile and lied on questions, but that didn't seem like a good enough protection. It wouldn't be too hard for a nefarious party to link the results back to me.
- rconti 9y agoI leave my DNA all over the place.
- amelius 9y agoYes, but nobody knows it's yours.
- 9y ago
- ComputerGuru 9y ago23andMe became a joke after their stupid handling of the FDA situation that resulted in them being nothing more than a glorified dna-based ancestory.com Wait until 23andMe has their next sale and get the kit for $99 to have your DNA sequenced, then spend 5 bucks to get a _real_ dna-based medical profile from Promethease.
- ggambetta 9y agoThat's only US, though. You get health reports if you do it in the UK.
- GordonS 9y agoYes, you don't get very many tho, and they actually removed most of them around a month ago! It's basically pointless for UK customers too now
- WillPostForFood 9y agoAnyone tried proxying in to see if US users can get health reports via UK IP address?
- jdminhbg 9y agoThey have your address from sending your kit to you, I have to imagine it's based on that.
- manmal 9y agoIn Austria, I can't get any health related reports (yet?).
- dsacco 9y agoWhat do you mean? My 23andme profile shows carrier status and genetic health risk reports. Is there something else that was removed?
- dekhn 9y ago
- DanielBMarkham 9y agoI accidentally discovered my biological family using 23andme. My wife took the test for fun, and I thought it would fun also. Being adopted, I never cared to look up my biological family. I'm 52, so I assumed they were all gone by now. Within five minutes of getting my results back I was in touch with a first cousin. A couple of days later? Three bio half-sisters, who live in my area. This was quite a shock! I went from taking a test on a lark to having a bunch of new bio relatives. I'm fine with it now, but at the time it was quite a bit to get used to. I'm still sorting through where to go from here. Try to find a bio father? (Nobody knows who he might be), or just leave things alone? One conclusion I have reached: all of this adoption stuff, which used to be extremely secret in some areas, is coming to come out over the next few decades. Being an adult, I'm fine with however my biological history plays out, but I imagine there are a lot of kids and teenagers that could really have a huge suprise in store for them. Strange times we live in. (And thanks to the 23andme folks for giving me an adventure I hadn't asked for but is turning out to be quite fun and interesting)
- folli 9y agoHow does this actually work? I assume your first cousin and half-sisters that came up in the screening also performed the test. Do you automatically agree that 23andme can use your data to search for relatives and give them out your information?
- DanielBMarkham 9y agoMy first cousin did the test a while ago. When she took the test, she agreed to share her results with anybody that might be interested. After I took the test, I was guided through a series of prompts and opt-ins that asked me about what I was comfortable sharing. At one point, there was a checkbox to allow my information to be used as part of something (I think) called a DNA Family Finder. I checked that, then there was a section of the website to go to. On that page there was 50-60 people who had already taken the test and agreed to be part of the search. Most were crazy, far-removed relatives like 4th cousin twice-removed. But at the top was a possible first cousin. To be honest, even when I saw it I didn't do the math. On her side, she received an email that said she had new matches, then messaged me through the site. "I guess you've hit the jackpot!" she said Of course, by being first cousins, it meant we shared grandparents. It also meant that one of her aunts or uncles was one of my biological parents. We chatted for a bit, my telling her I really didn't want to cause any family pain and her reassuring me that it was a long, long time ago (1960s). As it turned out, one of her aunts was a "black sheep" of the family and had gotten into all sorts of social trouble. The other aunts and uncles weren't in an easy place to have had kids. (Insert detective story here)
- krrrh 9y agoI really liked the old 23andme and was an early customer. I felt it did a good job of presenting scientific conjecture with notes on confidence and how to use the data. It gave me some encouragement to cut down on my caffeine consumption, and to exercise more to try to influence specific gene expression, and if I was a carrier for a serious genetic disease, I definitely would want access to that information. I logged in recently after not looking for a few years and was so disappointed with what the site has become--essentially ancestry astrology with the defaults presenting a preposterous level of precision on your racial mix. I'd like to think that this was just a result of inflexible regulation from the FDA, but I suspect that they are also bending to market demand for meaningless information like how 1 or 2 of your 64 great-great-great-great-grandparents happened to share some genetics with a bunch of people from the Asian steppes. On the other hand... I do enjoy reading about identitarians of all stripes having emotional crises when they learn that they can't claim purebred status.
- Trundle 9y agoThis might be useful for people yearning for the good old days. http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/12/how-to-use-23andme-irresponsibly/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/12/how-to-use-23andme-irre...
- subcosmos 9y agoI run a nonprofit project that gives more of the advanced data back to 23andMe users. I try my best to avoid the ethical/legal grey areas by not giving any kind of disease predictions, and instead provide a search service that links your genome to academic papers. These citations and references are what I miss the most from 23andMe's old reports. Would love feedback! https://www.infino.me/genetics https://www.infino.me/genetics
- krrrh 9y agoIt looks interesting. Would be great if you had the option to upload raw 23andme data rather than just connecting to the account, as some people probably have concerns with giving up their identity along with the information.
- Mrtierne 9y agoPresents such an interesting case for privacy. Down the rode if we can make changes to our genetic code will it really matter?
- gargarplex 9y agoJust FYI, you can export your 23andme data and upload it to Promethease who will then cross-reference it with findings in SNPedia. Kind of fun :-)
- thebiglebrewski 9y agoWow so much pessimism in this thread! I love 23and me and bought it for my girlfriend and parents too, they also loved it!
- brookside 9y agoThis comment would be worth more if you explain why you love 23and me.
- thebiglebrewski 9y agoHaha ok, sorry my comment wasn't valuable to you. I like that I found out I'm 5% Asian and .1% Mongolian - it's a fun parlor trick to tell my friends I'm PROBABLY RELATED TO GENGHIS KHAN My girlfriend is descended from many different cultures. She really liked seeing to some degree what percentages she was. Yes, we know it's not super accurate, but it gave her an idea. We compared results on some of the tests, like proclivity to be addicted to caffeine, which were surprisingly accurate. I wanted to know more about my ancestry so I had my parents get tested. I think it's really valuable to not only validate my genetic data, but also to see if it matches up with theirs/if they can provide more detail. I also have a hope that my future descendants will benefit from having this information on file (yes tinfoil hat peeps, it does also mean that the Trumpborg will be able to target them). Hope that helps!
- maxerickson 9y agoI think there's a selection effect where the people who think it is an issue are more motivated to post.
- thebiglebrewski 9y agoTru story.
- jakelarkin 9y agoIf 23andMe is eventually acquired/reaped, what is the worst thing the new owner can do with the data? to ensure long-term stewardship of the data, a company that holds genetic info should be a non-profit owned by the DNA providers, along the lines of a mutual insurance company.
- bluetwo 9y agoSell to law enforcement to find relatives of suspects.
- Spooky23 9y agoSell it to an insurance company, who in the future may be able to discriminate against you due to your genetic characteristics. Sharing fundamental characteristics of yourself with random cloud service providers is probably one of the dumbest things I can think of.
- Trundle 9y agoThey're already discriminating. It's a large part of their job. I much rather they do it accurately than inaccurately.
- maxerickson 9y agoIf insurance companies are able to take advantage of genetic information, won't they just pay people to gather it? Like, for $500 someone could follow you around for several days waiting for the 1 lapse where you leak a little DNA into the public environment. Or you know, they will just discriminate against people that refuse to share their DNA. The narrow wedge where they are forbidden from requiring DNA but free to discriminate based upon it is still a pretty fucked up world.
- idoh 9y agoIt's not really plausible that they would hire people to secretly gather it from you. Maybe they just make it a requirement for getting the insurance at all, that seems cleaner and more scalable.
- andrewtbham 9y agoIf you want the original information offered by reports... Get your genome sequenced and download it, then go to https://www.snpedia.com https://www.snpedia.com and look up genes your interested in.
- jjtheblunt 9y agoor use promethease.com which does that for $5
- outoftacos 9y agoI love the creepy questions they keep mailing me years after the test even though I've opted out of everything and tried to unsubscribe from everything they ever send. Kind of wish I had went with a different company for this, or just skipped the test. I don't trust these folks at all, I'm sure Halliburton or Monsanto or whoever will eventually buy them out, just weird and creepy all around.
- Osmium 9y agoI used 23andMe, and was a happy customer, but asked them to delete my data after -- I wasn't comfortable with them keeping that information (on a long enough timescale, everyone is hacked... or there may be regulatory issues with health insurance one day etc.) I do wonder if they really deleted my data though? Would pay 10x what 23andMe asks for a similar service if they gave you only an offline copy of your data, didn't store it on their servers, but also an offline app to analyze your results. There are some open source solutions[0] out there but they're not as user friendly yet. [0] https://github.com/mentatpsi/OSGenome https://github.com/mentatpsi/OSGenome, https://www.snpedia.com https://www.snpedia.com
- zeep 9y agoWhat you need, is a home kit that allows you to do it all yourself (a dumb kit so that the data stay safe with you)
- Osmium 9y agoI don't know, lab tests in a hospital go off to be analyzed somewhere. I think there's a healthy middle ground between "do it all yourself" and "let's store the results on a server connected to the internet indefinitely." I agree that an affordable SNP chip you could use at home would be amazing though.
- jonknee 9y agoOr a kit that isn't attached to your real identity (fairly easy to do with 23andMe, they don't require ID verification).
- zeep 9y agoIf your family members attach theirs to their real identities, they might be able to figure out which one is yours.
- zeep 9y agoHow come can't they raise more than this with all the precious information that they collect?
- faramarz 9y agoI really hope all of you who got your DNA sequenced did not give your real names; insurance companies will eventually get a hold of this data and use it against you.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoIn the US, that would be illegal under GINA[1]. 1: https://www.genome.gov/10002328/genetic-discrimination-fact-sheet/ https://www.genome.gov/10002328/genetic-discrimination-fact-...
- dguaraglia 9y agoWhile I appreciate you pointing this out, there's nothing to re-assure this will remain in place with a few more years of administrations like the current one.
- Asdfbla 9y agoAre they still using microarrays? Curious how far those can get you these days. Enough to detect common SNPs, but there's such a wide variety of other important genomic regulators that require whole genome sequencing to detect. I guess they know what they are doing though, I was just curious if they have extended their technology. Good that the FDA at least prevented those pseudoscientific predictions and they focus on research now.
- hidflect 9y agoI've heard that this company copyrights your DNA in case it has some useful attribute.
- pc86 9y ago[citation needed]
- otec 9y agoGood luck investing into this as a private individual. ICOs are the future.
- all_blue_chucks 9y agoIf they aren't offering Whole Exome Sequencing at this point, they're no longer a leader; they are far behind the industry.
- marcell 9y agoWhat companies offer this, and what is the cost?
- all_blue_chucks 9y agohttps://genos.co/sequencing.html https://genos.co/sequencing.html
- selimthegrim 9y agoYou can get your 23andme data imputed by DNA.land to approximate the results
- beaugunderson 9y agoFull Genomes Corporation will do a 30x coverage full genome for $1150; I'm a customer and purchased mine back when it was $1850. They sequence through Novogene in China. They also gave me my BAM files and raw FASTQ reads (~300gb of data). I have not found anyone else who will do that. https://www.fullgenomes.com/ https://www.fullgenomes.com/
- folli 9y agoInteresting! Can you recommend this company? Do they also provide kits to sample the DNA?
- beaugunderson 9y agoYes, I do recommend them, and yes, they provide you the sampling kit. In my interactions with them they went beyond what I expected of them every time.
- Ultimatt 9y agoIf anyone's wondering what you can use 23andMe data for longer term day-day you might want to sign up for news from the company I work for ;) https://www.genetrainer.com/ https://www.genetrainer.com/
- russellbeattie 9y agoAs a 45yo man who recently discovered via 23andMe that my dad wasn't my biological father, let me state that the ready availability of cheap DNA testing that has suddenly happened over the past few years is going to have some interesting effects on our social structure. I shudder to think about its impact in countries where familial lineage is a really big deal. Just 10 years ago, it took a real effort to do this sort of thing, but now you can have your entire DNA history - and potential familial connections - within weeks. And, as with anything that relies on network effects, each additional 'node' in the graph increases it's value in proportion to the square of the number of connected users of the system: Meaning that finding lost/unknown relatives will become easier and easier. What's amusing is how the major services - 23andMe, Ancestry.com, MyHeritage.com - avoid suggesting that you are 'half' related to anyone. After discovering my history, I joined the other sites and was confused when MyHeritage discovered someone that it had a 'high confidence' was my first cousin, because we shared a relatively high 11.6% DNA. It turns out she was my half-niece. This possibility wasn't listed anywhere on their site. Have you joined 23andMe? You know that person that shares some of your DNA and is potentially your 2nd-4th cousin? They might actually be a half-relative instead, but these services are avoiding that designation for obvious commercial reasons. The problem, I think, is that this is actually a lot more common than it seems, and they are really misleading their customers. Anyways, if you have a suspicion (as I had) that you might be the 'black sheep' in your family for reasons other than the genetic lottery, it's easier than ever to confirm your suspicions, and that will definitely affect lives for real.
- baddox 9y ago> I shudder to think about its impact in countries where familial lineage is a really big deal. I empathize with individuals who experience hardship from this, but I find it difficult to oppose the inevitable long-term effect, which is to make familial lineage less of a big deal. To me, that seems like a really good thing.
- sbinthree 9y ago23andMe is pretty useful. It flagged my maximum-possible risk for Celiac, which after a few months weaving through the Canadian medical system was confirmed by diagnoses. Best $200 I ever spent. That said, the other data on ancestry and obvious things like my eye colour wasn't very useful. For more useful speculative genetics, try plugging your 23andMe data into this: https://promethease.com/ https://promethease.com/