12 ms·
North Korea nuclear test: Hydrogen bomb 'missile-ready'
- annon23 9y agoThis is the only way to prevent a USA invasion, glad for NK
- annon23 9y agoIf you don't believe me.. go take a look a Syria, Irak, Lybia, soon Venezuela.
- chvid 9y agoSorry you are being downvoted. But what you write is the perspective of North Korea. And within some underlying assumptions it is perfectly relational. Nrk is spending massive amounts on military but probably is losing to South Korea. Nuclear weapons offers nrk a way out of being outspent. The west accepted Pakistan as a nuclear power; my guess is that we will accept nrk as well.
- alacombe 9y agoCommon point of all of these countries: they're bloodthirsty dictature enslaving / mass-murdering their population.
- icebraining 9y agoThankfully the US invasions put a stop to all the murders /s
- jryle80 9y agoWhat Syria, Iraq and Libya all have in common -- dictators with brutal policies that naturally create a lot of domestic enemies. Did US try to influence those countries? definitely yes. Playing dirty? of course. But that's world politic for you. Single out the US isn't helpful for the discussion. Do you think Russia, China, EU have all just stayed away from all of the conflicts? How about Iran, Israel, Saudi Arabia, even Turkey? Ask South East Asia countries what they think of China; or ex-USSR states of Russia; or Sri Lanka of India. North Korea has the support of China and holds South Korea ransom. They don't need nuclear weapon for self defense.
- joshmn 9y agoThey don't have oil. They're fine. (yes I do know they have vast mineral resources)
- duncan_bayne 9y agoAs much as I hate the NK regime I have to agree with this. If I were on the USA's shit list I'd be trying to become nuclear capable as quickly as possible to prevent "regime change".
- alacombe 9y agoHow about you try not to enslave your population in the last communist totalitarian dictatorship in the world ? What course of action make you think treating your population like shit is wise ? It consumed the Stalinist USSR, what do you expect will happen when you keep pissing off the whole world ?
- jacquesm 9y ago> It consumed the Stalinist USSR, what do you expect will happen when you keep pissing off the whole world ? At a guess, once you are a nuclear power, absolutely nothing.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoExactly nothing, if you have the capacity to nuke the capital cities of the whole world. To be clear: I think the Government of NK is monstrously evil, and I wouldn't shed a tear if their population rose up and lynched them. But their behaviour in seeking nuclear weapons is rational, because history has shown that non-nuclear dictatorships with valuable resources get invaded.
- crispinb 9y agoGiven the DPRK's secrecy, there's always tealeaf-reading involved in any interpretation of its behaviour. Many DPRK-watchers do suggest that the neocon drive to regime change in general, and the 2011 Libyan intervention in particular, cemented its determination to gain a credible nuclear deterrent. If the US had a normal President, this might be rational enough. As things stand, we're a whisker away from a war which will incinerate millions, kill the world economy stone dead for decades, and prevent all progress on the many critical issues facing our dying planet.
- mirimir 9y agoWhich war? The one with NK, or the one with Russia?
- crispinb 9y agoWar with NK could break out any day or hour if we're unlucky. With Russia? Not impossible, particularly if someone badly stuffs up in Syria, but far less likely.
- fiblye 9y agoYou say a normal president would help, but a "normal president" was behind the shit in Libya that you said cemented NK's determination. No matter what kind of president America has, our reckless foreign intervention through the past few decades is to blame.
- crispinb 9y agoI didn't say a normal president would 'help', nor did I defend the US's MIC. I said nuclear deterrence as a rational response on the part of the DPRK depends on the assumption of a normal functioning President. Given the incumbent, the DPRK may have made a miscalculation that will end in ashes.
- Hasknewbie 9y ago> If the US had a normal President The president is a non-issue on strategic matters, he has no knowledge on this, he knows it and the people around him know it. If you watch him, you'll see him do the typical alpha-male thing solely for his crowd, then the generals will tap him on the shoulder, whisper something in his ear, and after that he will do and say what he's told. Happened for Syria, happened for Iraq, happened for Afghanistan, and it will be the same for NK.
- hoodoof 9y agoThis guy seems to have his cards flat out on the table, open to all, that he wants nuclear war and he will start it as soon as his weapon systems can deliver it. Hard to see how to avoid such an outcome when that's all he wants and all he's planned and planning for. And when it comes of course then the U.S. will be blamed and it will be on for all. And NK has spent many many years preparing for conventional war with SK so all the artillery and weapon systems are going to be dug underground and hidden. U.S. style bombing won't have much of on outcome and we've seen from Iraq, Afghanistan and Vietnam that boots on the ground wars don't go anywhere good. Great. Just great. As if the world wasn't already sufficiently fucked from global warming.
- Trill-I-Am 9y agoHe doesn't want nuclear war, he wants to go legitimate like Mao and the Chinese did. He wants NK to be treated like a legitimate world power, even if it's at the butt of a gun.
- noobermin 9y agoIt would be true if it was his father. The Nuke program was always a bluff to get more economic aid. For Un? We don't know...we do know he has attempted to purge those critical of him in his own inner circle. Unfortunately, I don't think our leader is that sane either.
- jackvalentine 9y agoIt seems pretty straight forward to me - Un needs nuclear weapons to ensure NK remains an independent state that can defend itself. > we do know he has attempted to purge those critical of him in his own inner circle. Similarly, when your hold on power isn't through any kind of legitimacy except a fading family legacy you need to be strong and eliminate the competition. He's not insane, he's just playing a very brutal game with higher stakes than you or I will know in our lifetimes.
- flamedoge 9y ago
- testolog 9y agoThat nuclear technology from Russian, also you can to see "topol-m" and mobile launcher of korea.
- baklavabook 9y agoNorth Korea is supported by China. Without China's support, North Korea government will not be able to get all the technologies, parts, and fuels it need to survive. It will have collapsed. We (US) and the world support China by allowing manufacturing to be migrated to China, an authoritarian government which has horrific track record of censorship, human rights abuse, pollution, etc. We need to stop, and punish China
- funwithjustin 9y agoThey're also heavily supported by Russia.
- baklavabook 9y agoUS has already been punishing Russia via sanctions
- eps 9y agoIt's the other way around. Sanctions are the reason why Russia is supporting NK.
- yeukhon 9y agoIt is one reason, but not the only reason. NK and China both have borders connecting to Russia's border. This was extremely critical during WW2 as Japanese had full control of Korea (i.e. both present day of NK and SK), and Japanese already took over the northern part of China (they began to invade China in 1931). Russian and Japanese were never at ease because they were afraid the other would strike first (they did have multiple battles throughout WW2). Russia has no big problem with China (their economy really does benefit a lot doing trading with China, although Russia is not happy China is making tons of money from defense contracts, whose technology basis came from the old Russia Federation), so to keep the American military busy they can't turn their back on NK completely. They certainly do not like NK at all, but they need NK there for now. Until NK is out of bound, China will tune down and continue pressure Kim in the back channel. But trust me... Chairman Xi, he is absolutely a tiger. For all the superpowers, their best game is flexing muscle. They enjoy talking on stage, and drinking wines behind door.
- baybal2 9y agoKim is becoming less sure of his grandpa's defence treaty with China. Yet, NK is a Chinese proxy state. All what it did to harm SK and Japan goes on in total synchronicity with political climate in Beijing
- mark024 9y agoUkraine's invasion also encouraged countries to get nuclear armed, Ukraine gave their nuclear weapons in exchange for US/UK guaranties which proved to be worthless, another Obama legacy, a pussy of a president.
- icebraining 9y agoThere were no US/UK guarantees of protection. The Budapest Memorandum just gives the US casus belli, not an obligation to use it. The administrations that negotiated it made that clear. In any case, Ukraine didn't actually control the warheads, and it's silly to assume Russia would just allow them to build their own arsenal using those materials.
- nether 9y agoWe'll just have to learn to live with it. American exceptionalism is a farce.
- icebraining 9y agoWhat American exceptionalism? There are seven countries besides the US and NK with nuclear weapons, including China itself.
- adsthrowaway12 9y agoDoes anyone remember in 1999, the Bosnian war. Where the US bombed the Chinese embassy? Who is to say, that if HK nuked Guam. That the US launches missiles and a few of those hit China (by mistake). I mean, in this instance a first strike in key locations. Would mean that China couldn't retaliate as quick. Thoughts?
- alacombe 9y agoI don't think the US would launch anything without China's tacit approval of non-retaliation.
- adsthrowaway12 9y agoChina already stated that if the US first strike, they would retaliate. But if HK first strike, then they would be neutral.
- drawkbox 9y agoEvery 10 years or so North Korea starts to run out of money from the last deal (1994, 2003). A big money maker has been concessions for not pursuing nukes [1]. The money must almost be dried up from the last one, thus the posturing. In the end this stems from a lack of coherent plans after invading Korea back in the day. We are lucky Vietnam didn't end up the way Korea did or we'd have the same situation still today. The middle east may also turn into something like this. The US has to learn to win wars by economically winning over people and giving them more opportunity and freedoms, like Marshall plans back after WWII, ones in which we were also paid for but benefitted all. We are greatly failing at rebuilding after invasions and this is another example of how that has blowback. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agreed_Framework https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agreed_Framework
- adsthrowaway12 9y agoThe ME won't turn into something like this. The US heavily influences, finances and arms the ME, so there aren't any leaders who need to pursue this type of tactic. Additionally, Marshall plans won't help the ME at all. I'm going to leave it there. You can look up the reasons why it won't work.
- yeukhon 9y agoMy chime on why MP doesn't work in ME is simply because no one really asked US to come. The never-ending ethnic conflicts cannot be resolved by Marshall Plan. MP worked in WW2 because the entire Europe was buried in ashes, everyone hated the Nazi, everyone was in the same boat, everyone's life was at stake, so the only thing people wanted right post-war was to rebuild life, and nothing more (but of course soon countries split part...) ME today? Unless, for example, you can tell Sunni and Shi to STFU and just love each other as Islam teaches them (sorry for the Shi and Sunni folks here), then expect no change. The same goes to Israel and Palestine, China and Tibet, China and Japanese over some stupid islands (for controlling the sea and oil). Stop this BS, and move on...
- adsthrowaway12 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sargun 9y agoWhat if we just invited the Kim family over? Brought them to some state dinners, and conferences, or some such? They're not great people, the stick doesn't seem to be working. What's the worst that'll happen?
- tomjen3 9y agoI doubt they would come. If they came we might not let them go.
- rwmj 9y agoI also doubt they'd come or be invited, but if they did, they would be protected by the Vienna Convention (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diplomatic_immunity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diplomatic_immunity http://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/conventions/9_1_1961.pdf http://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/convention...). The US could break that, but not without serious consequences for their own leaders and diplomats abroad. Could the ICC issue an arrest warrant? Yes (https://academic.oup.com/jicj/article-abstract/7/2/315/902208/Does-President-Al-Bashir-Enjoy-Immunity-from https://academic.oup.com/jicj/article-abstract/7/2/315/90220...) if only the US was a participant in the ICC.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- randallsquared 9y ago> the stick doesn't seem to be working. The US has only used the carrot for decades, though, where NK is concerned.
- Synaesthesia 9y agoOn the contrary it has been consistently belligerent. At least since George W Bush
- SubiculumCode 9y ago
- hwillis 9y agoUsing the 6.3 Richter scale, the energy released would be ~43 kilotons of TNT. I think that's a pretty good guess- they seem kind of skeptical of the 6.3, but there may be some additional energy that wasn't transferred into the quake, like heat loss/air pressure. I plotted a 43.2 kiloton airburst bomb over LA using NUKEMAP[1], which is under heavy load right now (surprise surprise). tl;dr: 166k fatalities, 341k injuries, 270 m fireball and 100% fatalities within 1km. Almost all structures destroyed within 2.5 km, and 3rd degree burns within 3.2 km. Still far from a "real" nuke, but significantly more impressive than their last tests. It's about 1/10th the size of the biggest fission bomb the US made, the Mark 18. Our current missiles are ~475 kilotons per warhead, with 12 warheads per missile (several hundred times more destructive). [1]: https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=43.2&lat=34.0453902&lng=-118.2525158&hob_ft=0&casualties=1&zm=13 https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=43.2&lat=34.0453902&...
- jsnathan 9y ago> Using the 6.3 Richter scale, the energy released would be ~43 kilotons of TNT. That's curious. Every yield estimate I've seen so far was substantially higher than this. Could you explain how you arrive at this number?
- tscs37 9y agoI'm curious as well, my estimates based on data from a 5MT explosion being about 6.8 on the scale and various formulas, I'd get into the megaton range, then again, other methods do arrive at a sub-100kT range too.
- MichaelMoser123 9y agoJeffrey Lewis says that its a megaton, that would make them part of the club. https://twitter.com/ArmsControlWonk/status/904197086815543296 https://twitter.com/ArmsControlWonk/status/90419708681554329... (the guy from http://www.armscontrolwonk.com/ http://www.armscontrolwonk.com/ says so) Interesting if India and Pakistan will decide that they now need to acquire and test thermonuclear weapons of their own. (unexpected side effects?)
- rawnlq 9y agoMorbid question: If you want to guarantee 11 9s of durability in a world where nuclear war doesn't have negligible probability, do you need to start building data centers inside of nuclear bunkers? Would that even help with EMP attacks? https://xkcd.com/705/ https://xkcd.com/705/
- rwmj 9y agoThere is at least one such data center: https://www.thebunker.net/ https://www.thebunker.net/ Is it useful? Not so much. Your data might be safe but after a nuclear war you'd have a hard time accessing it unless you were also in the bunker with it.
- yeldarb 9y agoMake that at least two. This one is in Iowa: http://www.infobunker.com/overview.shtml http://www.infobunker.com/overview.shtml
- e12e 9y agoThere's one under Stockholm in Sweden too - might not survive a direct hit, but would probably survive anything that the network connection survives... https://www.bahnhof.net/page/datacenter-pionen https://www.bahnhof.net/page/datacenter-pionen
- baq 9y agoYou want a badass underground Faraday cage to survive an atmospheric EMP and if you're a target of a direct nuclear bunker buster, there isn't much you can do obviously. I have a hard time imagining what good would a working commercial data center would do in case of a nuclear war, though :)
- Synaesthesia 9y agoSouth Africa, we’re quite far away from global conflict zones and have a very low chance of natural disasters like earthquakes, hurricanes or volcanoes too.
- anfractuosity 9y agoIs there a particular signature from a seismograph that would indicate this isn't solely a fission bomb?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bb611 9y agoNo, but experts in the field tend to believe a yield this large is explained by a hydrogen bomb: > That means it's probably "only" a few hundred kilotons depending on depth. 8/ Still a staged TN weapon. But I need to sleep. 9/ https://twitter.com/ArmsControlWonk/status/904197086815543296 https://twitter.com/ArmsControlWonk/status/90419708681554329...
- anfractuosity 9y agoCheers, that's very interesting. I just found this too (from 2016), which backs up what you're saying https://www.wired.com/2016/01/science-can-tell-if-north-koreas-test-was-really-an-h-bomb/ https://www.wired.com/2016/01/science-can-tell-if-north-kore... It seems according to that, you could only tell from the radionuclides emitted as to what type of bomb it was. Interestingly there was a 500kt fission bomb - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivy_King https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivy_King (but I assume experts must have a particular reason for thinking the DPRK detonation was a type of hydrogen bomb).
- hellox32x64 9y agoUnlike USA, North Korea is a real power and they don't do empty threats. Americans can only cry like babies to Chinese about Korean nuclear weapons, but as a very weak so called "power" they can't do absolutely anything against NK. Go and repeat your afghan "success". You can't even fight weak talibans LOL.
- hellox32x64 9y ago16 years of war in Afghanistan showed that american military is absolutely the WEAKEST MILITARY EVER.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoYou are obviously a troll, but I'd like to point out that the U.S. military difficulties in the middle east are not for lack of military might, but for the retraints the U.S. places on its military power to retain moral and ethical legitimacy in a post WW2 world. If the U.S. instead decided that the lives of non-combatants in the middle east civilians mattered less than total dominance, any town harboring terrorists would be leveled flat with carpet bombs. This is not an argument that the US military endeavors are always moral and ethical, as they are not, clearly. However, there is a far cry between what takes place in Afghanistan, and how, for example, Rome ensured the peace in their territories: Roads lined with crucifixes.
- tech6 9y agoDoes anyone know how NK is able to successfully fully develop Nuclear and missile tech inspite of sanctions. I believe many countries like Iran Iraq have been trying without success for many years
- wsgeek 9y agoGoogle Bill Clinton North Korea deal... there ya go.
- rst 9y agoThat deal had North Korea's weapons-grade production facilities shut down for eight years, despite US foot-dragging on our side (we'd agreed to supply reactors that were not suitable for weapons production, and then the GOP Congress refused to fund that). So, what restarted weapons-grade plutonium production there? The George W. Bush administration effectively abrogated the deal, claiming that the DPRK had a separate active nuclear weapons program, based on evidence about as sketchy as what they provided to argue that Saddam Hussein had one. (He didn't.) The Yongbyon plutonium-production reactor was back in operation within a month. Clinton's deal was imperfect, but it worked a whole lot better than get-tough shit from his Republican successor. Ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agreed_Framework https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agreed_Framework
- mythrwy 9y agoThat's some serious revisionism. Bill Clinton's administration allowed NK to obtain nuclear weapons while supplying them with food and fuel. Their approach didn't work at all and is how we wound up in this state. For the record not blaming the administration (Republican administration have done things equally or more stupid so not a partisan taking point, it's just they can't be excused for the dramatic failure on this because someone prefers Democrats). Likely it seemed the best course of action, they expected at least some compliance, but NK did not abide by it's agreements at all. https://www.armscontrol.org/factsheets/dprkchron https://www.armscontrol.org/factsheets/dprkchron <edit> NK also made commitments to Putin to suspend the ICBM program in exchange for aid which they also violated. So again, Clinton is not the only one burnt by them. But saying the Clinton administration's approach was a success is not right. It was very much an unsuccess.
- giardini 9y agoI think North Korea is getting lots of help: their rockets are from Ukraine (or perhaps Taiwan) and now a hydrogen bomb? If it truly is an H-bomb, then did some other nation gave it to them? In any case, NK is moving in the wrong direction. If we don't stop them, Japan will.
- kumarvvr 9y agoYeah, as long as they have nukes, even a single working one, no one will touch them. Kim Jong Un is no fool. His iron grip on power comes from his ability to steer the nation towards a situation where there is adequate amount of fear about the chaos of interfering with it.
- gribbly 9y ago>Kim Jong Un is no fool. Eh, do you actually think Kim Jong has any power in North Korea ? I see him as a pure figurehead, with all power in the hands of top military brass.
- kumarvvr 9y agoDosen't seem like it. He seems to be in total control. It's not far fetched to think so. In any case, on what basis do you say that he is only a figurehead?
- gribbly 9y agoThat his supposed power is entirely based upon the North Korean military, I see him as nothing but a puppet.
- kumarvvr 9y agoWell, his family's cult of personality ensures that the military will tow the line. It's not unheard of in history for one person to have absolute control over a large military force. Hitler comes to mind.
- tomxor 9y ago> The North has previously claimed to have miniaturised a nuclear weapon "The North" What is this game of thrones?
- exabrial 9y agoI'm empathetic to China's position... having a war that close the homeland is bad for business. They have some difficult decisions ahead of them. [If someone was threatening Canada or Mexico, we'd probably intervene for purely geo-political reasons, for example] What I don't understand is Russia's alliance, I'm hoping someone can explain. NK seems a lot less of geo-political importance for Russia than it is for China.
- f137 9y agoRussia's position is "Nk is sonovabitch, but it trolls US, let's support it"
- synicalx 9y agoI'd be more inclined to think of it as an "enemy of my enemy is my friend" kind of a relationship. The USSR has historically supported North Korea as well, so the expectation and past relationships at various levels are still going to be there regardless of what the Russian government looks like these days.
- exabrial 9y agoI thought China's wording in their statement had interesting wording: "If the U.S. and South Korea carry out strikes and try to overthrow the North Korean regime and change the political pattern of the Korean...." They particularly mention "regime change" and use the "and" word, not "or" word. Given there is a language and cultural difference, I may be reading into this too much, but nevertheless I thought it was intersting.