24 ms·
Maybe today’s Navy is just not very good at driving ships
- Fjolsvith 9y agoThey are testing autopilot?
- rectang 9y agoAnd/or maybe Navy higher-ups, having resolutely learned nothing from the airline industry and crew resource management, pretend that there is no such thing as sleep deprivation.
- komali2 9y agoCulture of self flagellation. Somehow the finance industry, Japan, and Taiwan all still haven't learned from this. From the way my investment banker roommate talks about it, they almost seem to get off to it.
- scarmig 9y agoDo you think tech in Silicon Valley is somehow above that, though?
- komali2 9y agoMaybe? I've only been here about 2 years. First half was a bootcamp, which while intense certainly allowed for enough sleep (I would leave the bootcamp at 8pm, get home ~9, gives me an hour to relax, wake up at 7, and commute for an 8am arrival). Second half has been at a company with a very pro-family-time CEO, and as a bachelor that just means a lot of time to explore this awesome new city :) So I haven't yet experienced the "utter madness startup" I guess?
- CobrastanJorji 9y agoSame thing happens with doctors in the US. Doctors should know that after the first 12 hours, the doctor's not as good at doctoring anymore.
- dv_dt 9y agoThe discussion about work hours here typically seems to put effectiveness after 4-6 hours as dropping off for programming, for pilots regulations allow 8 work hours (with 10 required hours off, and at least 8 of those consecutive uninterrupted sleep). It makes one wonder at the working conditions of doctors and sailors.
- JBlue42 9y agoToss in architects, visual effects artists, kinda of whatever job you want in the US, especially if there's no history of a union. As someone else said, there's a lot of ego involved too. Given that a lot of it is "brainwork", it's the only physical way they might be able to feel they're testing themselves against something. Most of it in those jobs is just production-churn and an attempt by the higher-ups to save money on things that a) were bid low and b) have shitty margins.
- wpietri 9y agoYes. Although in talking with doctor friends, it turns out there's an interesting counter-force. A major source of errors is handoffs. I've certainly seen this when in the hospital with family; new doctors would frequently ask me for historical information, including about what other doctors had said or done. I was fine giving it, but what if I hadn't been there?
- dx034 9y agoDo they work with checklists? That seems to be the number one reason why crews in aviation can work with such low error rates. Handoffs with strict checklists would probably cause lower error rates.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoYes, they do have a lot of checklists, but it's one thing to create a checklist for an airplane with very strict requirements for validation and maintenance and another to create a checklist for a human being.
- DontGiveTwoFlux 9y agoMedicine as well. Medical residents can have shifts that are 24 hours long.
- mavhc 9y agoWell, as long as they only let people with jobs that can kill people be sleep deprived, it'll be ok
- mikeash 9y agoI understand that medicine is tricky because the handoff from one doctor to the next can be dangerous for patients. You have to balance continuity with exhaustion. That's not to say that they necessarily have the right balance now, but it's a hard problem.
- arjie 9y agoI've heard doctors say this, but they never cite evidence. But there is a wealth of evidence that says that doctor performance drops significantly with motor performance being harmed so much as to increase the number of errors and excess movements. I'll add the citation at the end, but it's not about the single study; it's about the fact that there is little evidence to the contrary and lots of evidence saying it's the case. If this were a drug, we'd be prescribing it every which way. And most importantly, know that this is not necessary. American doctor supply is restricted by the AMA. America could suck the best doctors out of many other nations if it so desired and its healthcare practitioners would be better rested, more mentally well, and far less error prone. http://www.bmj.com/content/323/7323/1222.1.short http://www.bmj.com/content/323/7323/1222.1.short
- brownbat 9y ago> I've heard doctors say this, but they never cite evidence. Seems pretty well researched by a quick google. Maybe they're eliding the support not because it's an assumption, but because it's so thoroughly established they take it for granted? http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa1405556#t=articleBackground http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa1405556#t=article... https://psnet.ahrq.gov/primers/primer/9/handoffs-and-signouts https://psnet.ahrq.gov/primers/primer/9/handoffs-and-signout... ... > But there is a wealth of evidence that says that doctor performance drops significantly with motor performance being harmed That's true too, but I worry you're trying to rebut (X & Y) with evidence for Y. If we find ourselves slipping into a battle of emphasis, maybe we face a problem of optimization?
- drblast 9y agoMy experience in the Navy made me lose all respect for the "leadership" there. It's a place where careers are established by doing everything except that which involves any actual thought or problem solving. The culture is risk-averse to a fault, but at the same time have nearly zero capability to accurately asses risk or fix problems beyond punishing people when things inevitably go wrong. Official "risk assessments" are performed before every dangerous undertaking, with numbers that are pulled out of someone's ass, along with additional "risk mitigation" numbers that are also pulled out of someone's ass so that leaders have cover when an accident happens. "We performed all the necessary risk assessments and were still a go." Let me give you an example. Underway replenishment is when one ship will pull alongside a supply ship and transfer fuel and supplies from the supply ship. It's very dangerous because the ships are within 300 feet of each other for hours on end. A risk-assessment is done and briefed the night before. Those are a PowerPoint presentation with a grid of things that can go wrong on the Y-axis. There are two columns, "risk" and "mitigation," and in line with each disaster are the probability conflated with the severity of that happening. Not actual numbers, just words like, "severe," "marginal," "likely," etc. Those are color-coded between red and green. One of those things is always "crew preparedness" or similar. The risk of having an unprepared crew that didn't get a lot of sleep is shown as, for example, "severe" and colored red. The briefer will say, "well this is a severe risk, so we're making an announcement that everyone needs to get plenty of sleep tonight and that mitigates that risk down to "tolerable." Actually this is more technical than what actually happens most of the time, which is that you'll hear things like, "we've mitigated the yellow risk down to a green." The entire ship's company of NCO's and officers will watch that presentation and nod their heads along. There is never one of these that results in a decision not to do something. And there you have it. I've taken you through the entire risk mitigation strategy for the Navy, that happens nearly every day. Does anyone know the actual probabilities of disaster? If so, they're not saying. Are they changing existing procedures or spending additional money to fix problems based on actual numbers? Hell no. Really severe problems are dealt with in the following manner; a "zero tolerance" policy for that problem existing will be created, and when disaster strikes, it's a career-ending event for whatever scapegoat is standing there. Problem solved! By the way, don't join the Navy. EDIT: Also, the "too much technology" portion of the article is laughable. Part of the problem is that technology that the rest of the world uses to avoid these sorts of things is seen as anathema to the luddite SWO community, and rather than embrace anything that could help automate error-prone tasks, they pay lip service to it and continue doing extraordinarily stupid things for tradition's sake. Aircraft carriers are driven by issuing voice commands to (mostly undertrained) helmsman in an environment where any additional noise could result in a misunderstood command and disaster. Or the helmsman gets tired of standing for a five hour watch every day and accidentally turns left instead of right like she's told. Imagine driving a car by telling the driver what to do from the passenger seat. Not just a "turn left up there," but "turn the wheel 15 degrees to the left, ok, now turn the wheel back to center, ok, now turn it back three degrees to the right because you oversteered..." It's insane.
- bdunbar 9y agoThey forget their own history, too. A battle in 1942 was lost, badly, because the USN crews were zonked from a routine that gave them almost no chance for sleep.
- arethuza 9y agoSpeaking of WW2 I've seen claims that one of the factors that helped the RAF win the Battle of Britain was there culture of pilots taking time away from the battle to rest up, relax and generally recover in between periods of intense fighting. e.g. "Talking shop" was definitely frowned on in a culture of apparent gentlemanly amateurism. The Luftwaffe was more "professional" and worked their crews much harder and didn't take time to relax and had a culture of focusing 24 hours a day on the job.
- bdunbar 9y agoInteresting. I'm not sure I could do that: I'd want to talk shop, badly. I read - years ago - that the most active combat was in the area around London. Not a small area, but it allowed RAF to move squadrons to lower threat areas for reconstitution and rebuilding before rotating them back to a hot area.
- clan 9y agoPennies saved on education. Cutting out 6 months of basic training. We live in a world managed by spreadsheets. Common sense is not in vogue.
- djKianoosh 9y agothe problem with common sense is that it's not that common
- PirateDave 9y agoDuring my time of service this was an oft repeated bastardization of Admiral Nimitz' quote: Common sense was an uncommon virtue.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- komali2 9y ago>After 2003, each young officer was issued a set of 21 CD-ROMs for computer-based training — jokingly called “SWOS in a Box” — to take with them to sea and learn. Young officers were required to complete this instructor-less course in between earning their shipboard qualifications, management of their divisions and collateral duties. I'm trying to find the "seaman's schedule" someone in the navy posted on reddit, but it basically demonstrated that between watches and other ship duties, there was on average 5 hours of sleep a day a seaman could get, usually at random hours, and not always consecutively. Curious when in that schedule they could slot in "watching video lectures," and whether they'd be able to even stay awake during them, let alone focus.
- Spooky23 9y agoMeanwhile, they probably take 100 hours a year of stupid compliance training about drug use, not killing sea turtles, etc.
- panzagl 9y agoAll delivered in Adobe Flash...
- droopyEyelids 9y agoAn officer's schedule shouldn't be compared to an enlisted persons's
- keenerd 9y agoAt the very least they should have included an "America's Navy" simulation game.
- pureGuano 9y agoThis may be a good time to review "How Complex Systems Fail" http://web.mit.edu/2.75/resources/random/How%20Complex%20Systems%20Fail.pdf http://web.mit.edu/2.75/resources/random/How%20Complex%20Sys...
- Jtsummers 9y ago“We do not put a premium on being good mariners,” Hoffman said. “We put a premium on being good inspection takers and admin weenies.” This is a problem across the DoD, not just the Navy. I've seen it first hand in both military and civilian sides of the USAF. It's comparable to the degradation of the US public schools with extensive testing. The tests that start as attempts to evaluate and quantify effectiveness become the goals themselves, rather than measures of the true goals.
- mrexroad 9y agoGoodheart's Law [1]: "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- zentiggr 9y agoLet's popularize this amongst the ranks of management, senior administrators and every other supervisor.... and especially the groups that help create the tests and stats and 'merit' systems.
- ashark 9y agoI think it's a consequence of taking away individual judgement and becoming, it seems, terrified of letting a person make a decision, because sometimes they're bad at it, or have biases, or whatever. Organizations are afraid of individuals deciding things, and individuals are eager to push their decisions onto a "process" or "policy" because if they actually make a decision and anything goes wrong—whether or not the decision was a good one given the information they had—they're toast, fired if they're lucky, publicly demonized and blackballed and fined and jailed if they're not. The individual cost of a decision that is bad—even if it's only bad in hindsight—is too often way out of proportion to the harm it caused, so why risk it? I don't know why it's happening, but it sure explains a lot of things across much of US society. Politics, business, education, parenting. I wouldn't be surprised if it's part of what's behind the frightening US "cost disease" phenomenon from the Slate Star Codex post that was discussed here a few months back.
- TYPE_FASTER 9y agoThat's a really good read. If the Navy really tried to replace helm and watch time with DVD courseware, they are in trouble. How do you teach a cadet how to get used to fading light and natural night vision via a 30min lesson? Kind of related: http://www.yachtingworld.com/blogs/elaine-bunting/comment-how-the-team-vestas-wind-crash-really-happened-and-the-surprisingly-simple-things-we-can-learn-from-it-62634 http://www.yachtingworld.com/blogs/elaine-bunting/comment-ho... A professional navigator put a Volvo Ocean Race boat onto a reef, due mostly to not looking at paper charts.
- fredgrott 9y agoThey could of did what the US Army did in coming up with a game simulating real-life conditions...you could simulate fading light, navigation going out,and whole host of things requiring exercise of good judgment..might even up numbers of recruits for the US Navy as a whole..
- AdamJacobMuller 9y ago> fading light and natural night vision Have instructions in the video to dim the screen? </sarcasm>
- smacktoward 9y agoBut the thing about fading light is that it fades on a predictable schedule every day for free. There's no opportunity for anyone to get paid! Replacing training in natural light with a set of DVDs solves this problem nicely.
- sschueller 9y agoFunny how some media is jumping the gun and blaming others of using offensive weapons and GPS jammers when the truth is a lot simpler and self made.
- fotbr 9y agoIt is always easier on one's psyche to blame someone else than to acknowledge that you screwed up. The same holds for teams and tribes, and fans of those teams or tribes. Look at nearly any sporting event. You'll commonly see the losing side, or fans of the losing side, blaming anything and everything they can - biased officials, cheating on the opposing side, the weather, etc. The US media, even though they may not like the current administration, is reluctant to start saying "the navy screwed itself". It may very well be the truth. From what I've been around in the other services, I can state that the thinking and approach to training and education isn't unique to the navy. If you're the the US media, calling them out on it risks being yourself labeled as anti-american, or adding more "evidence" to someone's already existing opinion. That can cost viewer eyeballs, and in turn, advertising dollars.
- gonewest 9y agoSo far 3 out of 3 reader comments at the bottom of that article somehow interpret the root cause as being the Navy's focus on diversity goals? Seriously?
- rch 9y agoThose comments are coming directly from Facebook, so they probably didn't even attempt to read the article.
- nnfy 9y agoWhen time is a finite resource, and it looks like these guys are overworked and under slept, prioritization is more important, and here people are dying, literally, possibly because seamen spend time in PC classes that they could be spending sleeping or learning more immediately useful, life saving skills. Another posted claims 5 hours of sleep. This is the military. It should be conflict prepared. Hardened. Diversity training should be an extremely low priority, if it is taught at all. I'd argue that it severely undermines the u.s. military by wasting time and crushing morale, for white men and minorities alike. I've seen the effects in the corporate world. The biggest opponent was a 30-year female in middle-upper management who was worried that people would start to presume that she only got her role via quota or diversity initiatives. Political correctness is almost antithetical to war and therefore military.
- SolarNet 9y agoOr as the article said, there were budget cuts 12 years ago (e.g. under Bush) that turned 9 months of specialized training specifically about this skill into a set of CDs. But sure, blame political correctness.
- nnfy 9y agoBudget cuts, not time cuts. My solution of better time prioritization still stands. Gender and race sensitivity training is the last thing a fighting force should be spending time studying, IMO. This is the military, this is about war, feelings be damned. This is the last place to be walking on eggshells, afraid to criticize or speak out because you're worried about being perceived as racist or sexist. What happens when a male or female is not strong enough to do his or her job? I can't say myself, but I have anecdotes from friends in the forces. The job still gets done...some people just need to work harder. Those of us who are suddenly less equal... And when this post inevitably gets flagged, you will see that HN is part of the cultural problem. This is just as bad for the corporate world, I've seen that first hand. We still live in a world where we are moments from death, where people can and will take advantage of you. It is extremely myopic and sheltered to think that the world will pause to give you a chance to meet your diversity quota, and fight with restraint against for your now potentially weakened fighting force. Maybe this is a "flame war" topic because there is a much larger [suppressed] counterculture on the HN community than anyone is prepared to admit?
- markbnj 9y agoThe article makes a lot of sense. If you know ships than it's not difficult to imagine how timidity - an unwillingness to literally "rock the boat" by making a course or engine revs change, waking up a senior officer, etc. - could lead to a situation where two vessels are converging past the point where anything can be done about it. In the merchant fleets, and in yachting circles where more competent sailors are involved, the people in control of vessels are taught that the best way to avoid a collision at sea is to make big, early changes to course and speed that the other vessel can clearly recognize and act on. It's possible that's the one sort of action the current culture discourages.
- nnfy 9y agoIs it possibly good navy "opsec" not to telegraph maneuvers?
- zaphar 9y agoI can't imagine that would be the case in the context of at least this latest collision. On a civilian waterway. They don't appear to have been on maneuvers. And by all accounts one of the most crowded waterways you can sail through. That does not seem like the context in which you would want to not telegraph maneuvers. Either way it's still a training and culture issue if they can't recognize the difference between the two contexts.
- cconover 9y agoIf they're not actively engaged in a naval exercise or actual warfighting requiring them to maneuver outside the Navigation Rules[0], they are subject to the rules the same as any other vessel - and even then, that's a pretty hard argument to make without actual shots fired in anger. Considerations are made in the rules for special requirements for lighting of naval vessels that, by the nature of their design, are unable to comply with the rules. However, the rules regarding avoiding collision apply to everyone, at all times. [0] https://www.navcen.uscg.gov/pdf/navRules/CG_NRHB_20151231.pdf https://www.navcen.uscg.gov/pdf/navRules/CG_NRHB_20151231.pd...
- xg15 9y ago
- mv4 9y agoEveryone's talking about the human element, but - isn't collision warning the kind of problem that can be relatively easily solved with technology today? Especially when large, relatively slow moving objects are involved - with no attempts at stealth?
- scott_s 9y agoThis NYT article from a few days ago covers this question, Naval Vessels, Shadowy by Intent, Are Hard for Commercial Ships to Spot: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/25/world/asia/navy-collision-uss-mccain-oil-tanker.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/25/world/asia/navy-collision... Specifically: Unlike the aviation industry, the shipping industry has not instituted emergency avoidance systems. Regulations in the United States, Europe and other large aviation markets require that the newest planes have electronic systems that communicate with each other almost instantly when a collision appears likely and recommend a coordinated response. One pilot might be told, for example, to “climb, climb,” while the other might be told to “descend, descend.” By contrast, collision avoidance systems in ships do not have the ability to coordinate actions with each other, experts said. Introducing that capability would be difficult.
- mannykannot 9y agoThe Navy has its reasons for not advertising the location of its ships, but that does not seem to rule out a warship's systems from identifying a developing collision risk. The International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea (aka "rules of the road", informally) has a final clause that says each ship's commander should take action to avoid an imminent collision, regardless of whatever other rules apply. In this regard, I would have thought that the inertia of large commercial ships might actually simplify the analysis. I recall reading a comment elsewhere by a former US Coastguard sailor who said that his ship's captain tried, wherever possible, to not be the stand-on vessel in any encounter, as to be so imposes an obligation to maintain course and speed; that way, he had some freedom of action. I doubt that this is possible in the busiest shipping lanes, however.
- 9y ago
- Theodores 9y agoMaybe it is just luck, like the flipping of a coin. There have been obviously avoidable incidents in the past, where you wonder how anyone could be so stupid. I remember submarines crashing mysteriously or surfacing under a fishing boat in the last decade or so. When the sextant arrived I am sure that there were accidents and people wondering if sailors had lost their skills, overly reliant on tech.
- astrodust 9y agoThe Japanese tuna boat incident was a mistake that could have been avoided, but at least precautions were taken, as sloppy as they were. They were doing an emergency surfacing exercise and did surface to check for ships before doing it. The chance of randomly hitting a tiny boat when surfacing are astonishingly slim. It was a bunch of factors, but mostly bad luck. I doubt a captain could hit a boat like that on purpose of they tried, there's just too many variables. As a surface ship ramming into a boat is entirely avoidable. Those things aren't invisible, and those destroyers have ridiculous amounts of sensor equipment, active and passive.
- wohlergehen 9y agoGenuine question: All the commercial vessels continually broadcast their position, speed and bearing, right? Even if the military vessel does not do so, it should be able to receive all commercial vessels telemetry... So how can it possibly crash into one?
- iramiller 9y agoAlong the same lines all these ships have sophisticated radar systems and can generally track where other vessels are regardless of whether or not they are broadcasting their positions. No one would expect such niceties during wartime.
- jandrese 9y agoExhaustion and inexperience according to the article. You try navigating safely on 3 hours of sleep over the past three days doing a job you weren't trained for.
- soneil 9y ago> Genuine question: All the commercial vessels continually broadcast their position, speed and bearing, right? Correct. AIS uses regular broadcasts, it’s not challenge-response. > Even if the military vessel does not do so, it should be able to receive all commercial vessels telemetry... Correct. Having an AIS receiver instead of an AIS transponder is a very typical setup for smaller sailboats or daysailors. If they’re not ready for the cost, complexity or power budget of a transponder, they can still pick up a receiver+plotter for $200, which will get them a little lcd with a map of traffic, CPA alarms, etc. Another $200 turns it into a transponder so that you show up on the other guy’s screen too. > So how can it possibly crash into one? The million-dollar question I guess. We manage to avoid it with a $400 radio and one pair of eyeballs on deck.
- cconover 9y agoYes, AIS is utilized by all ships, and even though military vessels are permitted to not broadcast in the clear their AIS data, they can still receive other ships' AIS broadcasts. That being said, you still need competent mariners on the bridge who can look at their instruments - AIS, ECDIS/chartplotter, radar - as well as use their own eyes looking out the window to interpret that information and made a prudent decision. As the Navigation Rules[0] are written, all vessels must maintain a proper lookout, and electronic systems by themselves are not a substitute. Once a mariner determines that risk of collision exists, regardless of whether they are the stand-on or give-way vessel, they must take sufficient action to avoid collision. Additionally, depending on what the situation between the two vessels is (meeting, crossing, overtaking), they are required to exchange sound signals to indicate their maneuvering intention and acknowledgement by the other vessel of that stated intention, or may make those arrangements by radio in lieu of sound signals. All of that requires prudent, competent mariners who can recognize what is happening around them, and their responsibilities in any situation involving another vessel. [0] https://www.navcen.uscg.gov/pdf/navRules/CG_NRHB_20151231.pdf https://www.navcen.uscg.gov/pdf/navRules/CG_NRHB_20151231.pd...
- navyguy 9y agoThe article puts focus on Officers, but same is true with Enlisted Sailors. I was an Electrician who was sent out to the fleet with 1 week of electrical training. When I arrived to the fleet I did know the names of the tools I would be using, but Navy was very confident that I could be trained onboard to solve complex problems. Luckily, I had a Chief who had gone through the old Electrical school and was a capable Electrician. I got to learn a lot from him and by the time I finished my contract I felt like I had become a good enough Electrician. I am afraid when these guys who had proper Electrical training retire, what will happen to the fleet ? This problem is very rampant in the Navy for almost every discipline.
- egberts1 9y agoGood GOD! The strait is one of the most densest maritime traffic in the world. Just try driving 23 knots passing each other as if you can change ships without getting your feet wet.
- mikey_p 9y agoSounds eerily similar to the concerns raised around the USS Iowa disaster: > "We're shorthanded. Chiefs with seventeen years of service are quitting. I've got to teach these kids to push the right button, or they'll blow us to kingdom come! My butt is on the line!" > Ziegler was especially concerned about his center gun crew. The rammerman, Robert W. Backherms, was inexperienced, as were the powder car operator, Gary J. Fisk, the primerman, Reginald L. Johnson Jr., and the gun captain, Richard Errick Lawrence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Iowa_turret_explosion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Iowa_turret_explosion
- willyt 9y agoCrew resource management is non-existent: Listen to the officer of the watch shout down the other person in the lead up to the USS Porter collision. http://gcaptain.com/intense-bridge-conversation-porter/ http://gcaptain.com/intense-bridge-conversation-porter/
- cconover 9y agoThis is an area where I think the Coast Guard does a decent job. We have a program called Team Coordination Training[0] which, while monotonous and annoying to those who have to take it every year, aims to instruct students on the importance of clear, non-punitive communication between all members of a crew or team to ensure maximum situational awareness. Some implementations of the training are better than others, but the intent is good, and is a more useful tool than generic risk assessment models that are frequently blown off in practice. [0] https://www.uscg.mil/safety/cg1131/tct.asp https://www.uscg.mil/safety/cg1131/tct.asp
- willyt 9y agoTotally. In the audio you can hear in the junior guys voice that he has no respect for his superior officer but is also terrified of him. The officer doesn't have a feel for how his ship handles and doesn't seem to fully understand the COLREGS either.
- treetoppin 9y agoI was a Junior Officer on a Coast Guard cutter for a year and a half. Without a doubt it comes down to command climate. Our Captain had "Standing Orders" that every deck watch officer was required to follow. This is required for all Coast Guard vessels, and I imagine for all Navy vessels as well. Included in these were reasons to call the Captain, where if certain parameters were met you had to call the Captain (and if its late at night that meant waking him/her up, explaining a situation over the phone, and providing a valid recommendation in accordance with the navigation rules of the road). The JOs I knew who made shitty and dangerous deck watch officers were those who would try to skirt the rules in order to avoid calling the captain. If the standing orders said to call the captain and provide a solution to avoid coming within two nautical miles of another vessel, and the radar was providing closest point of approach solutions that bounced between 1 nm and 2 nm, they would interpret that as not being necessary to call the captain. So why would a deck watch officer not want to call the captain? Well if the captain refuses to ever admit to being wrong, chews people out for tiny things, tells people not to disturb them, or overall doesnt support their junior members then people become less worried about safety and more worried about covering their ass. A lack of training, crew fatigue and bad command end up with bad decisions being made, and when bad decisions are made at that scale people can die.
- jayess 9y agoLikely another example of how bureaucracies become complacent, increasingly incompetent, and begin to structurally fail until some sort of catalyzing external event forces a restructuring and systemic reset. As the saying goes, nothing changes until it has to. The military is a bureaucracy like any other, from personal experience. The problem with government bureaucracies is that there's no market pressure to fix things. Failure is rewarded and even encouraged since there is no real consequence.
- empath75 9y agoI worry that the us is going to have some kind of Pearl Harbor type event that our military is not going to be capable of defending against. A lot of people assume that our forces are invulnerable but a large part of the peace we've been able to project has been because it's rewarding to work with us and risky to work against us. The current political situation seems to be reversing that calculus and the consequences could be dire.
- random023987 9y ago> I worry that the us is going to have some kind of Pearl Harbor type event that our military is not going to be capable of defending against. That's going to be when $4 billion aircraft carriers are sunk by $250,000 sea-skimmer anti-ship missiles launched by the dozens.
- Animats 9y agoThey're not very good at maintaining ships, either, says the report from an admiral ordered to study this in 2010.[1] [1] https://www.scribd.com/document/43245136/Balisle-Report-on-FRP-of-Surface-Force-Readiness https://www.scribd.com/document/43245136/Balisle-Report-on-F...
- Chiba-City 9y agoI worked in State/AID around folks doing commodity exports. Never underestimate the amount of sheer inbound "order taking" from endlessly needy Congressional staffers living on trading favors. I later worked around "developers" whose only Fu was tricks for passing lie detector tests to screw up projects in lead lined bunkers. I suppose the dress up, TV pageantry and fancy looking machines make disorderly bumbling infinitely costly operations look orderly. Our trade presses are mostly very open about the dysfunctions, but few waving flags pay much attention.
- Sophistifunk 9y agoLet's hope so. Otherwise it's either a) incredibly shoddy software, or b) somebody else's stuxnet. Either one of those options are very bad things.
- nradov 9y agoSome other navies have separate career tracks for bridge and engineering officers. This allows officers who want to focus on driving ships more time to actually practice the skill before taking command. http://gcaptain.com/separate-equal-look-officer-training-us-navy-merchant-marine/ http://gcaptain.com/separate-equal-look-officer-training-us-...
- nowarninglabel 9y agoPlug for David Marquet's book "Turn the Ship Around" about his time improving training / operations on a submarine he commanded. Every one had to announce their intention to do an action before actually doing it, this gave others the chance to identify when someone was going to take an incorrect action before it happened. It's a really great, short read that I'd highly recommend and gives some more background into the operational issues with the Navy.
- robotresearcher 9y agoThat approach works even if you are doing an action alone. Stating clearly: "I am pushing my commits to production", or even trivial stuff like "I am feeding the cats". You (a) get a chance to realize if that's a stupid thing to do,(b) get to notice if your action doesn't match your stated intent, and (c) have a better chance of remembering that you did it. It really helps me, particularly when there's a lot going on to distract you. See also the Japanese train guards and drivers, who point at stuff they are attending to, even when no one is looking. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pointing_and_calling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pointing_and_calling
- huhweirdyhat 9y agoSeems almost like explicit mindfulness training.
- dboreham 9y agoI am going to type "cd /; rm -rf *<cr>"
- thechao 9y agoAnd having said it aloud, we can fix the mistake: cd /; sudo rm -rf *<cr>
- flatfilefan 9y agohaven't got root?
- Stranger43 9y agoIt might be yet another case of the US preparing for the war it wants to fight while ignoring the skills it need to operate in the real world. The US doctrine have always been fleet warfare with large formations of US ships sailing alone on the open sea or in some water they have complete dominance over. which is exactly the opposite environment to where the recent accidents have happens as the us is forced to operate single ships under IMO rules something I suspect is not a big part of the west point curriculum as no self respecting naval officer is going to be caught dead doing coast guard type work The interesting and often forgotten thing here is that the Royal Navy who are way better sailors, and have far less cultural aversions towards playing coast guard then the USN failed miserably at a very similar mission in the icy waters around Iceland doing the 70ies and 80ies when Iceland decided to extend their economic exclusion zone beyond what the UK fishing fleets were willing to abide by. The problem is that nobody in Washington want the US navy to start a shooting match within range of china's coastal missile batteries so none of the warships equipment is applicable for any confrontation. so all they can really do if the Chinese coast guard decide to board some "allied trawler" fishing in what China calls Chinese waters is lurk about a 1000 yards away and yell on the radio.
- dboreham 9y agoAlways good to see a Cod War reference..
- DugFin 9y ago>The US doctrine have always been fleet warfare with large formations of US ships sailing alone on the open sea or in some water they have complete dominance over One of the problems with the US Navy over the last 70+ years has been a tendency act as if they're still fighting WW2. It shows up in a lot of places in interesting ways. Another example is the USMC's fixation with hot beach amphibious assault, a tactic which is completely outdated with the advent of modern air power, and which hasn't actually been utilized since the Incheon landing in 1950.
- bdunbar 9y ago- In 1991 4th Brigade was kept afloat in the Gulf, forcing the Iraqi army to devote resources to protecting beaches in and around Kuwait, and away from the border where the actual assault took place. Then they snuck the brigade ashore and added them to the striking power across the border. Absent the ability to assault across a beach, those Iraqi divisions would have been on the border.
- sytelus 9y agoWhile people are blaming sailor lousiness and training, I have to ask why humans are even controlling these ships? For all non-war maneuvers shouldn't these ships be self-sailing? Don't these high tech ships have basic obstacle detection? People should be blaming technology (or lack thereof) onboard these ships. There should be "sail-by-wire" equivalent on ship where humans with their limited sensory inputs and computational capability are only allowed to provide relatively high level goals. Ships computer should be able to deal with obstacles and remaining within safety parameters. I'm sure they have this system but it just didn't worked as expected and that should be the core of the problem.
- throw7 9y ago1. 2003 - cuts to training, 6 month "SWOS Basic" training eliminated. 2. reliance on technology, no basic seamanship skills 3. Iraq and Afganistan wars, more need to support ground ops 4. Officers care about Cover Your Ass.
- valuearb 9y ago"“Most department heads I had were afraid to go to the captain with anything that might look bad for them — they did everything they did to protect their own reputations and wanted nothing to hamper them from eventually getting in the CO seat themselves,” said former Lt. Jonathan Parin, who served onboard the destroyer James E. Williams." Maybe the Navy's standard reaction of snap-firing the Captain and any involved officers after any significant problem or accident leads to small problems being covered up until they become big problems?
- jjcc 9y agoThere are around 51,400 merchant ships trading internationally[1]. US Navy has roughly 430 ships in active service or reserve. A naive estimate that a ship hit another ship purely by accident: 99% of chances the other ship will be a commercial vessel. Only probability of 1% would involve a US Navy ship. If it happen twice, it's 0.01%, 3 times, 1 millionth, now we have 4 times in one year. There need to be some explanation. Maybe there are many deadly collisions never show up in news so we don't know, or US Navy never follow the rules that civilians follow, or US navy has been attacked but just don't know how it's attacked. [1]https://www.statista.com/statistics/264024/number-of-merchant-ships-worldwide-by-type/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/264024/number-of-merchan... [2]http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/a15297/us-navy-entire-fleet/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/a15297/u...
- TorKlingberg 9y agoI would assume collisions between two merchant ships don't make the news the way a collision involving a US navy ship does. You can't do statistics based on what you read in the news without considering selection bias.
- willyt 9y agoYou can view stats for UK flagged ships or ships operating in UK waters here: https://www.gov.uk/maib-reports https://www.gov.uk/maib-reports
- al_chemist 9y agoThere are billions of cars worldwide. I have two cars on my narrow driveway. It is statistically impossible to hit the other one while I park the first one. I have much higher probability to hit a car in China.
- 24gttghh 9y agoIt's three actually; one of the CG's (USS Antietam) hit a shoal after dragging anchor in a Strong Breeze, a 6 on the Beaufort scale. Albeit the captain was still blamed for not preparing his ship to account for the winds[0]. [0]https://www.stripes.com/news/pacific/navy-probe-blames-captain-s-judgment-in-uss-antietam-grounding-1.480879#.WaWDED6GMfJ https://www.stripes.com/news/pacific/navy-probe-blames-capta...
- musgrove 9y agoMy roommate's dad in HS was the Secretary of Defense back in the 1970's (James Schlesinger) and I remember him telling me that ships inadvertently come within 1/4 mile of hitting each other all the time. That seems pretty close when you're steering a giant aircraft carrier. Of course, that was along time ago, but still...doesn't seem like much has changed.
- TomK32 9y agoI bought my first boat, 31ft, with no more than three weeks of experience. Yes, more exp would be a great idea.
- martin_bech 9y agoIsnt it called sailing, not driving?
- mmmBacon 9y agoI had friends in college in the 1990s who were in the NROTC program. At the time I recall it was a big deal and discussion on campus that the Navy was removing/canceling requirements for celestial navigation. I think the reason cited was the prevalence of GPS. Here's a great article about how astronomers at Vanderbilt helped the Navy reintroduce celestial navigation back into the NROTC curriculum. >>>In the 1990’s increasing reliance on navigation technologies including GPS caused the Navy to drop celestial navigation from its officer training curriculum. Now, increasing awareness of the vulnerability of these systems to hacking and other types of disruption has prompted it to reintroduce the requirement. https://news.vanderbilt.edu/2017/07/26/vanderbilt-astronomers-help-nrotc-midshipmen-learn-celestial-navigation/ https://news.vanderbilt.edu/2017/07/26/vanderbilt-astronomer...
- yardie 9y agoCelestial navigation isn't difficult. I learned the basics in an afternoon. It requires a sextant, a calculation book, and a really good timepiece. If you've noticed that really expensive watches have a maritime theme it's because accuracy costs money in an era before NTP servers and GPS. In a small sailboat rocking in 3-4 foot waves I was accurate to ~50 miles. The crew member who taught me was accurate within a mile. He was also 65 and felt the GPS was almost as accurate as his sightings :-)
- mikekchar 9y agoThis may be a question that has been answered, but I haven't seen it in any news services I've looked at. Has blame been assessed for these collisions? If I understand correctly, they've been running into container ships, so by the "big boat gets the right of way" rule, I guess the military ship is at fault. So far I haven't heard the results of any investigations, though. I seems incredulous, to be honest, and I'm really hoping that we'll eventually get some explanations -- even if it's human error. The article itself seems a bit speculative and I was hoping for more concrete information.
- hudibras 9y agoI'll lay this down as timestamp'd predictions for future reference. 1. The McCain collision was the result of the merchant ship not seeing (visually or on radar) the McCain and turning directly into the path of the Navy ship. In that location, there would have been little warning for McCain, and with the combined speeds of the ships easily over 40 knots the damage would be devastating. McCain will still shoulder some of the blame, the CO and OOD will be reprimanded, but ultimately this will be seen as a "normal" collision that unfortunately happens every so often. 2. The Fitzgerald collision, however, will be found to be caused by gross negligence on the part of the Navy ship, and at least two officers (the Officer of the Deck and the Tactical Action Officer) will be court-martialed. There's no excuse for that collision, with that geometry, in that part of the world, and with such little warning (not waking the CO, for example).
- kpmariner 9y agoWe have a federal service academy that is excellent at training mariners (and engineers), the United States Merchant Marine Academy at Kings Point. Full Disclosure, I went there. I hated my time there, but they put out great mariners. We spent a year of our schooling working on merchant ships, driving them, docking them, loading, unloading, and a fuck-ton of paint chipping. Then we spend two semesters driving every ship you can imagine in a 360 degree ship simulator. Navy Ships are the most maneuverable ships in the ocean. It baffles my mind that they could run into something even in a busy area like the South China Sea. You can see a tanker on your radar for 10nm at least! The thing that blows my mind is that out of all of my friends who went Navy after graduation, probably 15 or so, NOT ONE of them is driving ships. They all got sent down to the engine room to become well rounded. Why the fuck did uncle same spend 200 grand training us to drive ships just to stick them down in the engine room! Rant over.
- 24gttghh 9y ago“A radar can tell you something is out there, but it can’t tell you if it’s turning,” Hoffman said. “Only your eyes can tell you that. You have to put your eyes on the iron.” I get this is HN, but there is something to be said for being able to get the job done without digital aids/hindrances; especially in fluid wartime scenarios.
- notruthallowed 9y agoWhat they really need to focus on is removing the trans bigotry, forget driving ships, we need diversity!