15 ms·
Let Consumers Sue Companies
- jseliger 9y agoThis is a great idea. Contracts of adhesion that dominate our lives should not automatically and totally be stacked in favor of companies.
- pfarnsworth 9y agoLetting consumers continue to sue is not the answer. It only incentivizes more litigiousness, which is part of the things that are ruining American society. What we need instead is for the government to pursue these crimes on our behalf. The fines should be draconian with no options for them to dilute it the way the SEC does. And the fines should go towards some fund that specializes in charities instead of going to government coffers so that we don't incentive behavior like civil forfeiture.
- nkrisc 9y agoConsumers exercising their rights through the courts is ruining American society? Wow, what a world we live in.
- tertius 9y agoWritten by a lawyer, what do you expect...
- walterbell 9y agoRegulatory capture?
- vivekd 9y agoSo letting people who were legitimately wronged receive justice and fair compensation in court for that wrong is "litigiousness" and therefore bad? First, I think you misunderstood what litigiousness means. Second, merely labeling something as litigious doesn't make it a bad thing. Litigiousness refers to frivolous lawsuits not legitimate ones. However large corporations have done a campaign of trying to label everything litigious to try and save money. Personally, I like the fact that courts exist to let people redress wrongs. If regulation was so effective at stopping bad behavior, how did banks, one of the most regulated industries in the world, manage to open up phony bank accounts for customers with no regulatory involvement? In fact how did they cause the financial crash with no regulatory intervention? Regulation is a bad joke and I'm convinced it's just a PR stunt by the government to make it look like it's doing something.
- xphilter 9y agoWouldn't the counter be true, then? By not letting consumers sue, it only incentivizes more corrupt business practices?
- chrisbennet 9y agoI agree that we need "the government to pursue these crimes..." If the government did that, the need for consumers to continue to sue will mostly go away. Once we have real government protection of consumers the need for consumers to take justice into their own hands (so to speak) by suing would go away all by itself. In the meantime, let consumers protect themselves.
- darpa_escapee 9y ago> It only incentivizes more litigiousness, which is part of the things that are ruining American society. Can you expound on this? Any examples?
- hedora 9y agoI never understood why binding arbitration was legal for non-negotiated contracts. Also, by reading this you agree all disputes between us will go through an arbitration firm of my choosing.
- slededit 9y agoThe courts actually prefer it as a lower cost alternative.
- vivekd 9y agoThe courts do prefer it, but from a legal perspective, as an adhesion contract with boiler point terms, the arbitration clause shouldn't have been enforceable.
- DannyBee 9y agoIt is definitely lower cost (and the vast majority of arbitration clauses end up allowing choice of arbitrator by plaintiff, or arbitrator is randomly selected with a couple chances to reject)
- bradleyjg 9y agoIt's not up to the courts. Congress passed a law, the Federal Arbitration Act, which explicitly instructs the courts to treat arbitration provisions at least as favorably as any other contract provision. In the absence of a conflicting Constitutional provision, the courts have no choice but to enforce the statute Congress passed.
- amelius 9y agoI was under the impression that class-action lawsuits were already a possibility for consumers.
- ascagnel_ 9y agoContracts in the US are allowed to include clauses forbidding class-action suits and mandating binding arbitration in their place.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- redm 9y agoI don't disagree with the sentiment of the article given the examples provided, i.e. Wells Fargo. That said, given the climate for frivolous lawsuits brought by "shakedown" attorneys, it opens the flood gates for something far worse. Maybe a better compromise is to allow for binding arbitration UNLESS the company is found guilty of fraud or other illegal activity, such as Wells Fargo. Alternatively, perhaps tort reform to prevent frivolous lawsuits would remove the need for arbitration.
- xphilter 9y agoDo you have any stats on "frivolous lawsuits brought by 'shakedown' attorneys"?
- ythn 9y agoCouldn't patent trolling also fall into this category (the category of legal "shakedowns")? If so, there are some stats on that. https://www.unifiedpatents.com/news/2016/5/30/2015-patent-dispute-report https://www.unifiedpatents.com/news/2016/5/30/2015-patent-di...
- darpa_escapee 9y agoI've never seen patent trolling fall into this category, probably because patent trolling is a viable way for firms to make money and being held liable for consumer injuries isn't.
- michaelt 9y agoWhile patent trolling is a legal shakedown, I don't see the relevance to binding arbitration?
- xphilter 9y agoAs the other commentator mentioned, how is this related to consumer lawsuits?
- ahhhhhhhhhh 9y agoThe court system should be able filter (and if that's a problem they should solve it on their end), we shouldn't just throw out an entire avenue because some people abuse it
- rayiner 9y agoClass actions can be effective where the class members are relatively large, sophisticated entities. E.g. the data-breach class action brought by banks that is mentioned in the article. But in the consumer-protection space, we should consider alternatives. Where the class members are individual consumers, litigation ends up being lawyer-driven. Cases settle for pennies on the dollar of potential damages, and end up serving neither to compensate consumers nor really to deter illegal conduct. Notably, in the EU, the tendency is to have more "ask for permission before doing something" regulation, and less "ask for forgiveness after doing something wrong" litigation. E.g. unlike in the U.S., there are laws setting forth detailed safety requirements for consumer products, and agencies responsible for enforcing those requirements. I suspect that approach yields the desired level of product safety at lower cost than the American approach. Similar approaches could, of course, be applied to consumer financial products.
- revelation 9y agoThere are also laws that mean you can't put whatever in a ToS and have it be a binding contract. If any clause is considered surprising it's void. It mostly fixes the whole "read this and click continue" insanity because it makes any clause that isn't law anyway unviable.
- mpweiher 9y agoYup. Seems common sense, really. And click-through contracts are usually also void, at least in Germany.
- reacweb 9y agoYes. I am in France and IANAL. When you act as an individual, you are a consumer and as a result, you can always ignore EULA. But beware if you act as a company (even a single people one). It becomes a binding contract.
- bradleyjg 9y agoIt's a chicken and egg problem. Let's the see the effective government regulators start regulating before withdrawing the admittedly flawed class action lawyer-regulators.
- wimgz 9y ago“only a lunatic or a fanatic sues for $30.” A bit off topic here but this is IMHO a great challenge for AI: making a lawyer affordable for the masses when they are bullied by banks, airlines, etc. If it costs you $5 , why not sue for $30 ?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- throwaway76543 9y agoBecause the risk of paying litigation expense is in the four, five or six figures. Chasing a return with a potential risk of loss several orders of magnitude higher is insane.
- clavalle 9y agoI think the point is that the potential risk starting so high is keeping people from seeking proper justice.
- throwaway76543 9y agoYes, that is my point
- guntars 9y agoIt's not if the other side is using AI lawyers, too. Heck, throw in an AI judge and you got yourself very efficient dispute resolution.
- will_brown 9y agoWhy not create an AI bank instead so you never suffer the $30 loss anyway? And we could say turn to the blockchain and smart contracts which market themselves as replacements for both real money and real lawyers, but we saw what happens when real techies write the smart contracts (case in point $150M DAO scam and then a fork of the blockchain itself), so we are definitely going to need to replaces software makers and coders with AI too.
- DannyBee 9y agoI'd love to understand what the end hope is. Very few class action lawsuits have resulted in any sort of permanent change. Also note the whole reason for class action lawsuits was efficient justice, and class action lawsuits are a fairly recent creation, so that's not entirely surprising. However the lawsuits that tend to change things tend to be "government vs". Maybe it gives consumers a good feeling to be able to sue everyone, but is it actually helping anything? Even in the past, people were not able to sue the telecoms or banks into having good customer service, or into not doing illegal things. Rarely, if ever, have they recouped the profits these companies made doing whatever. Instead, all the companies just treat it as "cost of business". I'm not sure it's really been a vehicle for effective change anymore. Certainly arbitration won't be either, but maybe groups of super annoyed people may have better luck forcing the government into action than people placated by class actions where the government can wash its hands say "well, they already took care of it!"
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoPerhaps this is a situation where we shouldn't let the perfect get in the way of the good. Class actions return money to wronged parties. That's good so we should remove the arbitration cruft that is preventing that.
- DannyBee 9y agoI guess i don't think the situation was good! They didn't return anywhere near a good amount of money to wronged parties. Lawsuits were being settled for not even pennies on the dollar. (arbitration also isn't cruft, but it's definitely getting an undeserved bad rap) Actually, the situation i long for is before the creation of the LLC, where shareholders were responsible for paying for the corporations lawsuits. LLCs are fairly recent invention, and also one that hurt consumers a lot. IMHO, No better way to get wells fargo to stop doing illegal things than have the people who own X% be forced to pay for it. That'll change a board right quick.
- matt4077 9y agoWho do you think ends up paying, if not the owners of the company? As long as the company isn't bankrupt, incorporation doesn't change anything. Full liability of owners isn't feasible in the current system, because it would expose every single investor to unlimited liability.
- mxfh 9y agoJust look at how the EU consumer protection directives are working over here. You're simply not allowed to waive your guaranteed rights as a customer in some sort of EULA or TOS. And if you are forced to, the whole contract is void in it's entirety and you're free to walk away from it.
- waqf 9y agoAlthough bear in mind that class-action law suits, which are the focus of this article, are typically not a right you have in the EU in the first place (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class_action#Class_actions_outside_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class_action#Class_actions_out...).
- kevin_b_er 9y agoAt least in Europe a court of law can judge their dispute.
- mxfh 9y agoOne caveat you typically have with them, is that you forfeit your right to file a lawsuit for individual damages. So I see hardly any advantage for the individual customer who got some individual issue of magnitude and is forced to choose between this or arbitration outside of the juidical system.
- neoeldex 9y agoIANAL, but I don't think it's possible to forfeit your right to sue. Maybe under some conditions, but never in the generic way.
- neoeldex 9y agoThat would defeat the purpose, since it's usually not possible to go against EULA's or TOS. If you're forced to sign a contract the contract is void, but when a specific line in a contract (or similar) is not correct according to law, not the entire contract is void, just the lines which are wrong. One can never be forced to sign a contract. F.I, in the Netherlands it's often stated in rent agreements that pets are not allowed, but this is not permitted to be in the contract by a judge, since such statements are too generic and restrictive.
- leoharsha2 9y agoI sued a company where I worked. They were not paying my final dues after I left the company. It took me 1 year and lots of visits to court just to get my final dues. Finally after a year of all such waste of time, they came to me and asked for a settlement to which I agree and I got part of my money. In India, even if you know you will win the case, it is not worth it. It will take your mental peace. Although I highly recommend to sue companies in other countries, In India we should think twice before suing anyone.
- damnfine 9y agoIf they also had to hire consuel and appear in court, the burden was equally large on them. If everyone sued, the burden would cause change. Acceping things as they are is how you keep things bad.
- ryanbrunner 9y agoExcept that in the plaintiff's case, he is devoting 100% of his time while court is in session, while the company is devoting a fraction of their resources.
- richardknop 9y agoThis isn't already possible? That's not right that companies can hack the law like this. Consumers should be able to sue.
- kazagistar 9y agoCitizens United was the end of democracy in Americal, and this is yet another piece of the fallout.
- rayiner 9y agoThe Federal Arbitration Act, codifying Congressional preference for arbitration instead of court proceedings, was enacted in 1925.
- flexie 9y agoIn the EU you cannot bind consumers by such arbitration clauses: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A31993L0013 http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A3... Consumers can usually sue corporations at a court in their own jurisdiction. Many European countries also allow class action law suits. Yet, we have few law suits against corporations. There are other reasons for this: - consumers are not awarded punitive damages, - court fees are higher (usually a percentage of what you ask for), - if the consumers lose they pay not only their own lawyer, but (to an extent decided by the court) also the lawyer representing the corporation, - many European countries have consumer "watchdogs" / ombudsmen, i.e. public entities that have the authority to start cases against corporations, - many European countries have a variety of consumer complaint boards that handle small claims efficiently and at low cost. Few who know consumer matters in both the US and the EU would trade the European system for the American.
- dclowd9901 9y agoThe EU system seems to be very anti-consumer. Or is that what your summary statement is intended to elicit? (tough to tell, as it could mean either/or is the better system)
- kogepathic 9y ago> The EU system seems to be very anti-consumer. I disagree. It is true that it is harder for EU consumers to sue a corporation, but in general I feel that consumer rights are generally stronger in the EU than in North America (OP's point about consumer watchdogs), so there is less reason for an EU consumer to sue a corporation. IANAL, but I'd say the EU system is anti-litigious, not anti-consumer.
- odabaxok 9y ago> I feel that consumer rights are generally stronger in the EU than in North America I agree with this, I feel the same. However, it seems to me, that if there is a customer related problem already in place, US will find it and react to it faster. To put an example here, all of the major automotive recalls of the last few years were exposed in the US, while Europe reacted to them with a delay (Volkswagen diesels, Takata airbag, Toyota accelerator pedal).
- Khol 9y agoThe oddest takeaway from this for me is that these arbitration clauses are banned for contracts for members of the military.
- socrates1998 9y agoI agree, these arbitration clauses are just another way corporations get away with screwing over consumers.
- clavalle 9y agoCapture of the machine of the justice system by the wealthy is one of the most impactful and persistent market distortions in human history. If people cannot bring the power of government to enforce appropriate costs against players with more market power government of the People, by the People, and for the People has failed.
- innocentoldguy 9y agoIt isn't just a capture of the justice machine by the wealthy, though I agree this is the case too. It is also an issue with the government, courts, and the laws themselves. How is a citizen supposed to petition the government over injustices and grievances, and be dealt with fairly according to the law, when the government itself sets the financial barriers to entry so high? How can a poor person get justice when the courts are set up to favor lawyers over citizens? You can represent yourself in court, of course, but any mistakes you make in not filing the right form here or declaring the right motion there will most likely result in a huge injustice being done by the courts, simply because you, as an average citizen, don't know how to navigate all the legal minutia. Have the wealthy really captured the courts, or have the government, judges, and lawyers set up a situation in which only the rich get justice?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- necessity 9y agoDon't do business with companies that have such contracts? If there is no choice in a given sector then the issue is a monopoly not the contracts.
- s73ver_ 9y agoThat's not usually a choice, and it's not due to monopoly. Just about every company out there is adding these clauses to their contracts. And consumers have no power to combat them.
- thejerz 9y agoYou have the power not to enter into the agreement. No one is forcing you to download a song from iTunes or open an account at Wells Fargo. If you don't like the terms, don't enter into the agreement.
- s73ver_ 9y agoThat's not really power. And again, I see absolutely no valid reason why these terms should be allowed. There is zero reason why a company should be able to ask you to sign over your rights. They're rights for a reason. You're supposed to have them.
- david-cako 9y agoYour suggestion is effectively a suggestion that anyone who wants to not implicitly agree to such terms simply doesn't participate in the developed world. This makes zero sense. It's on par with saying "dude just turn off javascript". Is the answer to political corruption buying a boat and taking refuge in the pacific ocean, or is actually correcting the problem?
- necessity 9y ago>This makes zero sense. It's on par with saying "dude just turn off javascript". That's what you actually should do, I use NoScript and it's perfectly fine. Stop bitching and demanding people force others into the things YOU want.
- coolaliasbro 9y ago"First, opponents claim that plaintiffs are better served by acting individually than by joining a group lawsuit." Then why should it matter if plaintiffs want to act collectively (ie, put themselves at a disadvantage according to the quote above)--wouldn't that benefit the opponents?
- rrggrr 9y agoFACT: products liability law reduced accidental deaths in the workplace. (source: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm4822a1.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm4822a1.htm) There is no reason similar laws wouldn't work for consumers privacy. Tort law needs to be applied aggressively to data privacy.
- 6502nerdface 9y ago> FACT: products liability law reduced accidental deaths in the workplace. (source: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm4822a1.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm4822a1.htm) There is no reason similar laws wouldn't work for consumers privacy. Tort law needs to be applied aggressively to data privacy. How exactly does that source support the FACT? The words "liable" and "liability" appear nowhere in it. They credit the reduction in workplace fatalities to a number of factors, including technology, expanded enforcement powers of federal inspectors, mandatory standards, and the creation of OSHA and NIOSH. They make no mention of product liability or tort laws.
- rrggrr 9y agoRelax sparky. The chart demonstrates the decline only. Don't go looking to government to praise the private sector or free market solutions when their budget depends entirely on the opposite being true. At 40,000 inspections/yr it wasn't much OSHA with their tiny, often negotiated fines that caused the decline. ANSI is pretty much the gold standard for safety, not OSHA regs, so their non-mandatory standards don't get a lot of credit. It wasn't a magical fairy tapping a gossamer wand atop a dangerous machine. It was thousands of plaintiffs attorneys suing the shit out of manufacturers who designed and sold products that could be made more safely. It was the tort laws that let them to sue. It was the insurance companies who extracted hefty sums to write products liability policies on manufactured machinery. And it was the innovators who used sensors, locking mechanisms, new training methods and private inspection procedures that have made the US a workplace safety leader. The government legislated accountability. The free market made it happen. It can be the same with data privacy.
- s73ver_ 9y agoThere is no valid reason why a company should require someone to sign away their rights, and it absolutely should not be allowed. Otherwise individuals might as well not have those rights at all.
- exabrial 9y agoCall me cynical, but it seems most class action lawsuits end up paying $100m to a lawyer group and $5 to each individual :/
- ct520 9y agoThere's this one cool site to query outcomes of arbitration. No bueno. http://levelplayingfield.io/ http://levelplayingfield.io/
- samstave 9y agoProbably not the perfect topic for the following question, but close enough for me to ask; What is the deal with class action lawsuits WRT the monies lawyers get vs the plaintiffs. I was a victim of fraudulent banking practices in 2008/2009 which resulted in the illegal foreclosure of my home in San Jose. I "won" my class action lawsuit and was "awarded"$1,100 for my victory on having a $489,000 house stolen from me by the bank. (Never missed a payment, never late, had credit score of 780 - this experience ruined me) So I "won" that legal battle - but was unable to have my credit score fixed through the win... So the question is: class-action lawsuit victories look to me to be a complete sham, so why would we value them as anything other than a "fuck you for not having enough money" enterprise - and where do the lawyers get off on their "right" to profit off such actions at the expense of others?
- asdfffsdjnn78 9y agoThis is not a good answer. It'll keep ending up a run around in the courts and deals will be cut, "business as usual" abstractions will be allowed to stand as excuses for unethical, and often ruinous behavior. Let consumers sue people involved directly. This isn't magic. People are going in a room and making decisions that, in scenarios where its ending up in court, damaging to others. They should not be shielded by "business as usual", or fines, that they 1) have a direct hand in setting limits of 2) pass off the company (often endangering workers futures). This suing abstract ideas doesn't hold white collar criminals accountable directly. It protects them directly. Which is be design. We decided there is no divine right under-pinning our leaders claims to power. See how there is no relying on abstract ideas as shields or "just following orders" when it comes to how we persecute the proles. This isn't magic. People go in a room, make decisions, fallout occurs. It's un-elected bullshitters that don't actually build the things we need, telling us how it is. It's allowing a certain segment special privilege where none has been bestowed.
- Animats 9y agoIn 2010, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which I direct, was authorized to study mandatory arbitration and write rules consistent with the study. After five years of work... Talk about a schedule overrun. That project should have been finished in 2011.
- iamatworknow 9y agoI work in an industry tied closely to the actions of the CFPB, and they've had a lot on their plate ever since they were founded. They continuously get attacked by industry groups (formally through lawsuits and informally through what is more or less industry propaganda). I wouldn't be shocked if they spent the majority of their time and resources just defending their right to exist.
- wbracken 9y agoAlternative viewpoint: https://www.consumerfinancemonitor.com/2017/08/22/director-cordrays-op-ed-disregards-many-inconvenient-facts/ https://www.consumerfinancemonitor.com/2017/08/22/director-c...
- Pica_soO 9y agoI wish there was a way to preemptive lawsuit a industry, before it even undertakes a operation. Basically, a group of people bets with lawsuits on the damages done to society by a industrial operation, forcing anyone to endeavor such operations to build a huge deposit of settlement and legalfees to cover the threat - on for example cutting down "rainforrest". As state actors have proven lousy wardens on these goods of society, maybe the interest of private stakeholders might put such a bounty on the head of damaging activity's, that these cease or be replaced with less "dangerous" replacement endeavors, previously not viable in a market economy that rewards distributed short term damages to everyone.
- nmca 9y agoThat is an interesting idea.
- tareqak 9y agoA slightly related issue that I find somewhat unsettling is how easily big companies that are being sued by state or federal governments are able to settle in out of court proceedings. From my understanding, the argument for allowing settlements is to help one or both parties somehow save face, time, or money. However, what everyone (including people who are not affiliated with either party) loses out on is the possibility to establish a precedent. Some of the cases that come to mind are the HSBC case where some people who were following the court proceedings started to sense and publicly state the real possibility of actual criminal wrongdoing (https://www.wsj.com/articles/hsbc-agrees-470m-settlement-over-alleged-u-s-mortgage-abuses-1454689803 https://www.wsj.com/articles/hsbc-agrees-470m-settlement-ove...). Compare that to a guilty plea by BNP Paribas here (https://www.theguardian.com/business/2014/jun/30/bnp-paribas-pleads-guilty-criminal-charges-sanctions https://www.theguardian.com/business/2014/jun/30/bnp-paribas... and https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/bnp-paribas-sentenced-conspiring-violate-international-emergency-economic-powers-act-and https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/bnp-paribas-sentenced-conspir...). In comparison, see what happens to an individual (https://www.cnbc.com/2014/03/19/soc-gen-rogue-trader-kerviel-heading-for-jail.html https://www.cnbc.com/2014/03/19/soc-gen-rogue-trader-kerviel...), and how people try to avoid it (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-06-09/ex-socgen-banker-charged-in-insider-case-tied-to-airgas-takeover https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-06-09/ex-socgen...). TL;DR: Big companies get to settle all to easily in cases brought forward by government attorneys without admitting guilt or wrongdoing, which is in contrast individuals (even wealthy ones) who often basically become the targets of what effectively becomes (sometimes faux) moral crusade. Companies end up: 1. Doing something that breaks the law, but in a sufficiently obfuscated manner. 2. Getting caught by government usually via the observation and study by keen citizens and/or outright whistleblowers. 3. Involving their legal team to both prepare for fighting the case, and to give PR guidance and statements. Marketing and salespeople downplay the concerns from both consumers and customers. 4. When the case becomes sufficiently uncomfortable, settle it with government for some fraction of the total estimated damages and not admit to wrongdoing. 5. Write off the settlement amount in the most tax-friendly manner possible via in-house or third-party accountants. 6. Get praise internally and externally for being scrappy and disrupting the establishment/government/noun-used-as-a-pejorative (yes, you too dear HN contributor/lurker). 7. Rinse and repeat 1-6. I think a few of the things that Uber and AirBnB have had to settle essentially map to the steps I outlined above. Note: a. The sources above that I cite might not be the best ones to support my claim, but the general issue and the unwillingness to resolve it properly remain. b. I realize that step 6 is mean/snarky/typecasting. My aim was to remind the reader that audible/silent praise/rebuke do have power, and that doing nothing does register as a signal in some situations.
- whatnotests 9y ago> Let our glorious comrades sue the imperialist companies. Fixed that for you.
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to HN? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html