16 ms·
Putin signs law that prohibits technology providing access to banned websites
- iamben 9y agoThis article is very light on the details, but the fact that someone has actually gone ahead and done this will mean other leaders / politicians will now be thinking - "oh right, this is actually something we may be able to do." Another few feet down that slippery slope.
- dabber 9y ago> the fact that someone has actually gone ahead and done this[...] Well it's not exactly a novel idea. China, North Korea, Iran, Iraq, Oman, Turkey and others have implemented bans or heavy restrictions for quite some time now.
- Spooky23 9y agoI'm sure it's coming to the US to ensure that subscribers aren't avoiding ISP rate limits.
- codefined 9y agoI saw an article from about 15 years ago that said Comcast blocked VPNs for a few weeks as a "test". Apparently the test was stopped because a large amount of businesses complained that they required VPNs to access their internal data. I imagine it might be trickier for the US to implement such a plan vs. a country like Russia.
- throwaway7645 9y agoYea...VPN is a pretty basic security measure no?
- strictnein 9y agoFirst, no, this isn't coming to the US. Second, this doesn't make any sense. How would you avoid rate limits by using a VPN? The ISP is still sending and receiving all of that data for you.
- ac29 9y agoStep 1) Rate limit high bandwidth use sites to discourage use Step 2) Block VPNs to prevent circumvention of your rate limts Step 3) Profit? I don't see this happening, but I think that's what the comment you were responding to is suggesting.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoWhy not just rate limit VPNs?
- toyg 9y agoYou are not thinking politically enough. If I rate-limit VPN outright, I'm an ugly dictator bent on destroying privacy. If I rate-limit popular bandwidth-intensive traffic, I'm just a guy trying to keep network usage fair for every user. If that involves limiting VPNs as well, they are simply collateral damage, the end justifies the means, and I'm still a good guy.
- derefr 9y agoThey're using the wrong terminology, then; "ISP rate limits" refers to artificial bandwidth restrictions placed—at the data-link layer—on the last mile of a connection, to either upsell better plans or as proactive, aggressive form of QoS traffic-shaping to prevent oversubscribed head-end nodes from actually having to deal with multiple saturated downstream links they don't have the capacity to multiplex. You're talking here more about avoiding the preferential site-by-site traffic-class-based shaping that goes on when Net Neutrality is not enforced. Which doesn't really happen, because it's far easier to just have a thinner peerage link between the ISP and the content-provider in the first place, and then do regular QoSing on that thin pipe with priority to the people on better plans. (The result is exactly like telephone service on New Year's Eve: local calls go through just fine, but long-distance calls mostly fail because the POTS peerage links are saturated.)
- codedokode 9y agoUS doesn't need to block anything because many Internet companies' headquarters (domain name registrars, SSL certificate providers, cloud providers, OS developers, messengers, search engines, video publishing platforms) are located in USA and therefore are the subject of US laws. For example, US doesn't have to block access to online casinos - they just order the banks and financial institutions not to work with such sites. But Russia doesn't have such authority over Facebook or Skype. It cannot issue a NSL to Google for example. Therefore they are looking for other methods of controlling those companies (such as laws requiring to keep russian users' data in Russia). China blocks many foreign web services and as a result they have their national messengers, search engine, social networks that will comply with national laws. I do not approve Russian or China (especially China) policies, I just want to notice that Internet being an international medium without borders and customs creates new problems for applying national legislation (like taxation or spreading information violationg the laws).
- Spooky23 9y agoI was referring to the act of interference, not the motivation behind it. The government may not need to decrypt or block most traffic, but telcos will want to extract a levy for various uses of their circuits. Using the argument used against Netflix, why should your employer just be able to benefit from pushing ActiveSync down to your phone without paying Verizon?
- vacri 9y ago> other leaders / politicians will now be thinking Since when have western leaders ever taken policy direction from Russia?
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoDid you notice the last US presidential election?
- Spivak 9y agoDuh? If it's forbidden to access certain websites in a country then logically so is any service that enables such access. VPN services can't exactly hide behind being an impartial carrier since they sell themselves as tools precisely for circumventing censorship, tracking, region locking, and providing anonymity. I've said it before and I'll keep saying it, this is a political problem that can't be solved through more tunnels.
- lgierth 9y ago> VPN services can't exactly hide behind being an impartial carrier since they sell themselves as tools precisely for circumventing censorship, tracking, region locking, and providing anonymity. I really wish some VPN providers would try advertising themselves as desirable technical solutions to the technical shortcomings of many ISPs -- e.g. my ISP here doesn't give me native IPv6, and has a crappy last mile. OpenVPN-over-UDP helps with both. VPNs can also simply protect against attacks on public networks in e.g. cafes, libraries, airports. > this is a political problem that can't be solved through more tunnels Yes, but they help in that they increase people's headroom for informing and acting.
- lgierth 9y ago> VPNs can also simply protect against attacks on public networks in e.g. cafes, libraries, airports. To expand on that, you could argue this for any network, even home and company networks -- who knows which of the many windows computers and android phones of my colleagues/family are bots?
- gruez 9y agoNot really against remote code execution type exploits, more like password/session stealing attacks.
- petre 9y agoWhat if I use a VPN to access my company's network?
- aleksi 9y agoThat case is explicitly allowed by this law.
- Theodores 9y agoSo much like China then. Fine for email getting through on all@internationalcompany.com from the Chinese office, just an added hassle for the IT department to setup.
- kmeaw 9y agoThen you would be fine if your VPN provider: a) either relies only on ISPs following Russian laws; b) or technically enforces restrictions specified in Russian blacklist.
- aleksi 9y agoor c) you use VPN provided by your company and it's used for work. If you can access restricted sites with it, neither you nor your company is responsible.
- y_u_no_rust 9y agoGood news, the internet has become a cancer I'm glad russia is seeing the light I'm hopeful the united states will get there too
- erikj 9y agoI don't think it's possible to reliably enforce this ban.
- lgierth 9y agoWe need something that tunnels over HTTPS/Websockets, and utilizes domain fronting [1] with e.g. Google Cloud or Azure. Ideally it'd also work over WebRTC in unreliable mode, but I'm not sure that works with domain fronting. [1] https://bamsoftware.com/papers/fronting/ https://bamsoftware.com/papers/fronting/ // edit: why the downvotes?
- jerheinze 9y ago> We need something that tunnels over HTTPS/Websockets, and utilizes domain fronting [1] with e.g. Google Cloud or Azure. Ideally it'd also work over WebRTC in unreliable mode, but I'm not sure that works with domain fronting. The Tor Browser already comes with the meek transport[1] that uses domain fronting, one with Amazon and the other with Azure. There's also a recent PT titled snowflake[2], that uses WebRTC to connect to short lived proxies that people can make by just running some JS code in their browser, it's currently available in the alpha builds for Linux and Mac. Note that meek is expensive, and the Tor Project pays for each byte. It should only be used when no other PT works. [1] : https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/meek https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/meek [2] : https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/Snowflake https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/Snowflake
- int_19h 9y agoThe problem is that any website that allows domain fronting is itself illegal under this new law, and can be blocked on those grounds.
- lgierth 9y agoThe idea of domain fronting though is that the fronting website is "expensive" to block that the censor won't do it. As with everything else, this isn't a 100% technical solution, it has a political component of how expensive the fronting website is to block.
- vbezhenar 9y agoThe important thing is that people are not charged in crime if they try to circumvent the bans. So it's still race in technology field. They'll ban VPNs, we will find ways to hide our VPNs. As long as regular user won't be prosecuted for trying to access prohibited information, those laws doesn't matter much IMO.
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y ago“The strictness of Russian laws is compensated by the optionality of compliance.”
- cybice 9y agoAs a Russian wanna say its true.
- dageshi 9y agoaka If you do something to piss off someone important enough you're always guilty of something.
- olegkikin 9y agoAlso "For my friends everything, for my enemies the law".
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoAlso known as "rule by law", not "rule of law."
- CamperBob2 9y agoHow'd that work out under Stalin? The 'optionality' was all in how well-connected you were, and that could literally change in a heartbeat.
- nmbr213 9y agoEvery time Gosduma passes some law restricting citizen's freedom for the sake of security we have morons bleating "Don't worry, guys, the strictness of Russian laws is compensated by the optionality of compliance". Yet in the past few years we had hundreds of people jailed and/or fined for the content they posted on social media or even for reposts and likes. Yet the morons do not learn. Can't wait for Yarovaya's law to come in full effect.
- petre 9y agoThat translates to arbitrarily sending people to jail.
- usaphp 9y agoLink to official document: http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/0001201707300002?index=0&rangeSize=1 http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/00012017073000...
- gist 9y agoWondering if this document essentially states that a Socks 5 proxy is banned for the same reasons.
- Elhana 9y agoIf you start advertising it as a way to bypass blacklist and open it to the world, it will probably get banned.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kytwb 9y agoEverytime I read posts about VPNs and ban attempts, I can't resist to link to the Streisand project: https://github.com/jlund/streisand https://github.com/jlund/streisand. Used that when there were crackdowns on VPNs (Astrill, Express, etc.) while I was living in China and it never disappointed.
- int_19h 9y agoThe bigger news, IMO, is that Putin also signed the messenger law. To remind, this demands that all IM services that operate in Russia must provide technical means to de-anonymize the users, by linking their accounts to a phone number, a service contract number where the contract has identifying information, or other similar scheme. They're also required to be able to block any materials censored in Russia. If these are not complied with, the regulatory agency can block the service entirely.
- codedokode 9y agoMesengers are also required to block information that is being spreaded in a violation of russian laws.
- natehartman 9y agoYou can take my VPN when you pry it from my cold, dead hands.
- tw04 9y agoI mean, we're talking about Russia here. People run themselves over to death with their own cars all the time, it can happen to you too.
- natehartman 9y agoYou can take my VPN when you pry it from my cold, dead hands.
- bedros 9y agowhat are they going to ban next https?
- CommanderData 9y agoWaiting for the "can't stop me using VPNs L0Lz" comments.. VPN use for a free and open Internet is abnormal - not a long term solution to issues like censorship. They're already out of reach for normal users. Companies will offer better ways to block or detect usage for lucrative gov contracts. Simply making it illegal will detour most people. I don't understand why VPN crackdown is thought to be impossible. ISPs have a good idea of what normal traffic looks like and a very good map of the Internet. The Internet may be big. To an ISP, is it really that big? Netflix, Google, YouTube, Dropbox etc are normal. Your companies VPN IP are normal. That's unusual! Open connection to a DNS port? sending large amounts of data? its encrypted? No one has accessed that digital ocean IP before on this network! Lets throttle, interrupt it periodically or flag that user. Someone else sending large amounts data to a known VPN IP range? block, throttle, close connection, police knock on door etc. policy change, not more VPNs.
- Kenji 9y agoExactly. It baffles me how people think political problems can be solved with technological workarounds. What's next, being gay is illegal again so "just hide your relationship lulz"? Sometimes, I feel like a part of the crowd here is like a bunch of toddlers who try to work around some rules the parents made and feel clever at the same time.
- deathhand 9y agoAhem..You are talking to a bunch of technologists. Technologists who believe that technology can actually change the world. We can see tech's influence from Arab Spring[1] to Defcon's recent vandalism[2]. We make up the people pushing the buttons behind the scene. In the name of humanity I know I will try everything to keep the Internet free and open and I hope many like minded people will to. Free sharing of ideas is the best way for us to advance. This is why you and OP's comment are detracting and unproductive. We made this. We run the show. [1]https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ghazali_Sulong/publication/234040341_The_Role_of_Modern_Technology_in_Arab_Spring/links/0fcfd50e7b3ecbdd28000000/The-Role-of-Modern-Technology-in-Arab-Spring.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ghazali_Sulong/publicat... [2]https://www.cnet.com/news/everything-looks-like-a-hack-when-youre-paranoid-at-defcon/ https://www.cnet.com/news/everything-looks-like-a-hack-when-...
- woodandsteel 9y agoThis is hardly surprising. Putin is an autocrat who wants to become a full-scale, ruler-for-life dictator. And so to achieve that end he has been steadily chipping away at freedoms and human rights.
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoHe's also concerned that the US government and their assets will use this to undermine the country that he is charged with defending. Which isn't really irrational, because many anonymity tools have been funded by the US government for exactly this reason. It's not a reasonable tradeoff and I disagree with him, but one can easily see why someone in his position would be concerned about this for reasons other than attempting to secure a dictatorship. The fact is the US government has a well documented history of undermining elections, and then funding rebellion and civil wars if the election doesn't turn out how they hoped. When leaders attempt to shut down mediums used for propaganda/psyops/adversary coordination, they get to play the fascist dictator card against them, which is pretty convenient.
- 1001101 9y agoPutin is up for reelection spring '18. With all of the symmetric responses going on between the US and Russia at the moment (tit for tat game), one can only expect shenanigans.
- c-smile 9y agoFor the brevity: "the law, already approved by the Duma, the lower house of parliament" so it is a collective decision of Russian lawmakers.
- ilaksh 9y agoI do not make political comments because it seems unsafe. So I am not commenting about Russia here or any other country. https://www.reddit.com/r/darknetplan/ https://www.reddit.com/r/darknetplan/ and https://www.reddit.com/r/Rad_Decentralization/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Rad_Decentralization/ may be interesting from a purely technical perspective.
- korkota 9y agoThe important part of this news has been omitted. FSB will monitor compliance with the law.
- codezero 9y agoI'm really curious how this affects HN users in Russia now. Is this a concern for you all? Or is it just a blip? Do you think it affects your less technical friends and family in any way?
- shmerl 9y agoAll the more farcical was his recent claim in Q&A session with school students, that Russia has no Internet censorship.
- jageen 9y agoIs it also means that no tor-browsing, No wikileaks from Russia ? Did this affect to ransomware collector too?
- Fjolsvith 9y agoWow, sounds like he doesn't like net neutrality either.
- nmbr213 9y agoFunny thing: two month ago, when Ukraine blocked access to Mail.ru Group's (which is owned by Kremlin linked bussinessman Usmanov) websites (Vkontakte, Odnoklassniki, russian 4chan (sort of)), state-owned TV ran a couple of infomertials teaching people how to bypass blocks using VPNs and anonymyzers.