18 ms·
Why I left Medium and moved back to my own domain
- tyingq 9y ago"Writing comments to Medium posts feels awkward because each comment is treated as a blog post." This is also awkward from the reader point of view. Trying to follow a comment chain on medium is frustrating as it only shows the first level, diving in switches pages, and often, a need to press a second "load all comments" button. Then the back button to wind your way back up. Is there some sound reasoning for why it was set up this way? Some benefit I'm not seeing?
- kensai 9y agoMaybe to have the UI less cluttered. Just assuming here.
- alttab 9y agoThey are probably trying to focus on the content first - and the discussion second. It might be a resource issue, because of all the content publication outlets there are they have to make that the best. Right now, someone can easily post a Medium article here, or on Reddit, and get two different discussions on the same content each with their own features and community standards - without mixing them or trying to define what it means to start a response thread on Medium. Because Medium's focus is most likely on being a publication platform, they probably see comments and responses to comments as Medium articles within themselves within the context of that thread. The UI seems clunky in comparison to HN or Reddit, or even Digg, but that may be "the point." If so, I still think they got it wrong, but only because they need to more formally execute against this vision. Today, authors who understand this paradigm right a "response blog post" and link to the one they are responding to and provide context before making a long form response. I think Medium is trying to capture this, but they haven't yet.
- untog 9y agoI suspect it's because they didn't/don't want people to comment in the usual way - you can highlight text on an article and leave short comments in the relevant place if you want to do that. I think the comments section at the end was intended more as a place for lengthy reaction posts. It's why comments have "recommend" rather than "like" as a button. I might "like" someone saying "great post!" but I'm not going to "recommend" it. It often feels like Medium has made a product for what they want online discourse to be, rather than what it actually is. I don't hate them for trying.
- freehunter 9y agoCommenting on articles is a terrible method of interaction. Anti-spam is hard, and spammers always win. Trolls always win. Comments rarely add much to the discussion from the article, and they're often hard to follow. There's no reason to leave a comment saying "great post!". It's spam. It's unnecessary. Blogs are a wholly inappropriate place for back-and-forth discourse to happen simply because if I have a blog, it's my blog. It's not a discussion board. I inherently have the advantage, I control the conversation, and it's all about me. I have the ability to delete comments I disagree with. That's not discourse, that's an echo chamber. I completely agree with Medium. Just because blog posts have historically had comments doesn't mean it's the right choice. The minute people accepted "pingbacks" as a valid form of comment was the moment comments died. V!AGR@ and P3N15 type spam sealed the deal.
- arkitaip 9y agoBlogs belonging to software tend to be very valuable. People will share insights or tips long after the blog post has been written, often extending the shelf life of the code or software.
- vilmosi 9y ago> Commenting on articles is a terrible method of interaction. Anti-spam is hard, and spammers always win. Trolls always win. But that's practically what HN is, yet I like to believe it's a good platform without too much spam or trolls.
- rasz 9y agomore page impressions = more ads
- yahelc 9y agoCan't be this, since they don't have on-page ads.
- cyberferret 9y agoI really miss the old 'sidebar' comments that they used to have when Medium first came out. It was a great way to post a short one or two line observation, and see it appear right next to the line/paragraph you were wanting to talk about. While I am on 'things I miss in Medium', I miss the old 'Collections' paradigm they used to have - I enjoyed picking Collection categories where I could browse topical stories (e.g. Programming, Fantasy, Food etc.) - but I especially miss being able to post stories of my own into a collection. I thought I used to get FAR better engagement with fans of a particular collection that way. Now I have to beg around for a curator of a 'Publication' on Medium to post my articles on their 'Magazine' in order to get to a special interest group on there.
- kerkeslager 9y agoIt's quality over quantity.
- dredmorbius 9y agoTreating individual contributions on a discussion as atomic-but-related strikes me as a good design move. Trending a bit toward Usenet. (That said, I find Medium increasingly annoying.)
- drieddust 9y agoI wrote one line comment and started getting these notifications as if I wrote a post. I felt embarrassed for misleading the reader with one line post. Confused the hell out of me.
- Mikho 9y agoMedium feels like long-form Twitter with all these replies treated as posts. This is a terrible experience. Especially when you follow RSS feed of somebody on Medium and comments & replies are delivered and treated in the feed the same way as posts. I guess it's due to the fact that Ev was also Twitter founder and has only one construct in his head as to posts and replies.
- vertebrate 9y agoSee also: http://practicaltypography.com/billionaires-typewriter.html http://practicaltypography.com/billionaires-typewriter.html
- MikusR 9y agoHN really need to add Matthew Butterick's sites to spamlist.
- Jaruzel 9y agoWhy so? I just skimmed read the linked page (after pasting the URL manually...) and it doesn't seem any worse than other articles posted here.
- MikusR 9y agoBecause if you follow the link you get http://practicaltypography.com/graylist.html http://practicaltypography.com/graylist.html. That page has about the same amount of content as a typical spam page.
- Jaruzel 9y agoHe's just blocking high traffic referrers. Which I agree is odd. It's not like his site is media heavy.
- jessaustin 9y agoHe attempts to monetize without resorting to ad networks. A laudable goal, even if the methodology is idiosyncratic.
- ewanm89 9y agoWhy lose flexibility and switch to medium in the first place?
- BartSaM 9y agoProbably the usual - it was new cool and convenient.
- skylark 9y agoPeople use Medium because they want to be heard. Marketing is hard (although this author doesn't seem to have problems with that.)
- gtaylor 9y agoI don't use medium, but also don't need much flexibility. The content is my focus and priority.
- colept 9y agoBecause when I switched to Medium my blog posts went from ~50 impressions to 1000+ impressions Exposure.
- JoshMnem 9y agoI don't understand why people write programming blogs on Medium. I think that managing a live website with its own server (rather than only working on other people's projects) is a very important skill. If you don't want to manage WordPress, try a static site generator like Metalsmith: https://github.com/segmentio/metalsmith https://github.com/segmentio/metalsmith Deploy on Digital Ocean or Linode for $5/month. Free hosting options include Github Pages and Netlify.
- BartSaM 9y agoOr even $2,5 Vultr if you are on a budget.
- simik 9y agoThey are constantly "Temporarily sold out", at least in European regions.
- BartSaM 9y agoThey are available, but only in NY and one more (not sure which). I have confirmed this with their support. I am not sure if they are planning to introduce them in other regions anytime soon. I think NY is pretty much a good global location for America + Europe markets.
- cupcakestand 9y agoAgree that for a western English audience NY is the best location reaching both the US and EU with a ok latency.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- daveguy 9y agoAnother free option: gitlab pages with built in ci configurations for a bunch of different static generators. All you have to do is commit for updates.
- ngsayjoe 9y agoI recently wanted to move my Tumblr personal blog to Medium however after a few days of nightmare and still unable to setup a custom domain despite having paid $75 fee i requested a refund and closed my account. Their customer service and documentation kind of sucks!
- sixQuarks 9y agoMoral of the story: Try to never rely on another company's platform for your business. It's hard enough creating a successful business, but to add a layer of risk on top of that is not smart.
- francis-io 9y agoUsing something like Jekyll to create a static blog lets you put it on AWS S3. For all but the highest traffic sites the bandwidth cost is trivial and you totally remove all the issues with uptime and securing a server.
- copperx 9y agoSame applies to GitHub pages.
- francis-io 9y agoI originally tried github pages, but had issues with getting an SSL cert working with Cloudflare. I ended up using AWS Certificate Manager to add an auto updating cert to CloudFront.
- copperx 9y agoDo you have a login? Or why would you need SSL on a static page?
- gpmcadam 9y agoYou can use HTTPS to secure many things, not only login details. Not least of all, the privacy of your users/readers. There's also integrity of your site, and many more future proof reasons. These days, there's no reason _not_ to use HTTPS, really. https://developers.google.com/web/fundamentals/security/encrypt-in-transit/why-https https://developers.google.com/web/fundamentals/security/encr...
- DamonHD 9y agoExcept for the difficulty of managing and keeping up to date with TLS (I'd have to upgrade my RPi's OS for example, to do it well), and the fact that it actually reduces performance for small simple sites with local readership, even with HTTP/2 for example. http://www.earth.org.uk/note-on-carbon-cost-of-CDN.html http://www.earth.org.uk/note-on-carbon-cost-of-CDN.html Edit: I note that I got downvoted, though no reply with reasons. I accept that it is currently widespread dogma/fashion that everything should be HTTPS, and there are some good reasons for it, but as someone that has worked in what might be called 'real' security in on-line finance for example, I fear that HTTPS-everywhere is as much security theatre or cargo cult as taking your belt off at the airport scanners...
- Entangled 9y agoMedium is a blog platform and a news aggregator. I use it mostly for consuming news by using tags of interest. Good luck with that writing your own blog on your own server. Oh, and the daily newsletter is a delightful joy. Discoverability is key to the success of Medium. https://medium.com/tag/swift/latest https://medium.com/tag/swift/latest https://medium.com/tag/kotlin/latest https://medium.com/tag/kotlin/latest https://medium.com/tag/python/latest https://medium.com/tag/python/latest https://medium.com/tag/java/latest https://medium.com/tag/java/latest Or by topic https://medium.com/tag/design/latest https://medium.com/tag/design/latest https://medium.com/tag/UX/latest https://medium.com/tag/UX/latest https://medium.com/tag/AI/latest https://medium.com/tag/AI/latest
- cupcakestand 9y agoWhy should I discover content on Medium? This job is done by HN and Reddit and unfortunately Facebook if I am on FB. I don't have time to get sucked in another feed.
- corobo 9y agoSpecific content. For example I follow the Laravel tag on medium, I've not seen anything regarding Laravel on HN in a fair while.
- ben_jones 9y agoBecause most aggregators become biased and limited silos either intentionally to sell advertising or otherwise via community moderation, power users, etc. The same stuff always bubbles to the top or is buried at the bottom. Variety is key.
- shinzui 9y agoThe best part of reading technical content is the discussion in the comments – Medium makes that impossible.
- penpapersw 9y agoI've seen many technical articles link to an HN post for discussion instead of using Disqus or hosting on something like medium.
- Qub3d 9y agoI get it, too. HN is a threaded comment system, which we've been iterating on since the USENET days. Not that threaded comments are the solution for everything, but it excels at visually separating each of the distinct discussions that may arise around a given topic.
- s3nnyy 9y agoI feel one of the main reasons Medium is so successful is that they cracked discoverability and rank high on Google for any topic (sort of like Wikipedia). Hence, I am hesitant to move away from it although I really want to build a sustainable, long-term business on my own domain. Any ideas on this?
- dullgiulio 9y agoHow did they cracke discoverability? Some posts are famous and rank higher, I haven't noticed a general rank boost. Also, I have stumbled upon a lot of blogs on own domains that turned out to be Medium hosted. I assume these don't get any advantage on Google?
- s3nnyy 9y agoI am not sure if I am overvaluing Medium but I feel that I owe the existence of my recruiting agency to them: - In November 2014 I published "8 reasons why I moved to Switzerland to work in tech" (https://medium.com/@iwaninzurich/eight-reasons-why-i-moved-to-switzerland-to-work-in-it-c7ac18af4f90 https://medium.com/@iwaninzurich/eight-reasons-why-i-moved-t...) - I immediately started getting CVs from people who googled "work in Switzerland in tech". Then, I asked local startups and firms if they would pay me if I find them engineers. This worked out and now I run https://www.coderfit.com https://www.coderfit.com. - After 2.5 years I still get a couple CVs a week due to the blogpost on Medium. If one only has one or two blog posts (like me in the beginning), Medium is probably the best place to write. But now, since I want to grow my business, it feels like a waste not using my own domain. (Fun fact: It took me three days to write this blogpost, and according to Medium 22k people (truly) read it and some even moved to Zurich with their families and their life completely changed. However, it took me one year each to write my bachelor's and master's thesis and the professor and his assistant (maybe) read it...)
- LightMachine 9y agoThat's a scary thought.
- 9y ago
- tomerbd 9y agomay I ask which theme you use? it looks very nice..
- tomeehan 9y agohttps://wordpress.com/theme/revelar https://wordpress.com/theme/revelar
- tomerbd 9y agoi did some google search for "gatsby themes" "gatsby disqus" almost nothing useful turns out.. any ideas?
- denisehilton 9y agoDoes medium allow you to monetize your content and put ads? If it's not the case then why do people write for Medium. What's there to gain?
- cupcakestand 9y agoTo the point criticism of Medium, very detailed and the OP is picking the right issues of Medium. While Medium looks so beautiful and clean at first glance it really disappoints when you use it on a daily base both as a creator and as a user. Everytime I use Medium, I am surprised that Medium is successful. Its appearance feels definitely premium and significantly of higher value than any other blog system but the usability is a nightmare. So we are back to square one. Which blog system should we use? SSG on Github Pages?
- gboudrias 9y ago> Which blog system should we use? Hosting your own WordPress site? It's simple and easy. Why did anyone ever want to be on Medium in the first place? Most likely for the name association and the visibility that comes with it. I think we have a responsibility to promote self-reliance as part of technological culture. If we want people to move away from centralization (which I do), we have to teach by example (which I do).
- user5994461 9y agoHow easy do you think it is? Have you done it? I found that self hosting wordpress is incredibly complex and expensive. Wordpress.com does a great job though, nothing to manage.
- Someone 9y ago"Hosting your own WordPress site? It's simple and easy." I would think that, for at least 90% of those publishing on Medium, that's neither simple nor easy. Even ignoring that, hosting your own Wordpress site means taking responsibility for keeping it up to date, security-wise. That hurdle alone probably makes most bloggers use some third-party blogging provider.
- gboudrias 9y agoIt's just an example, there are many choices, some of which are presumably even simpler. But yes there will be some responsibility involved, I think that falls into healthy technical culture as well. It's the difference between taking care of something and getting someone else to take care of it. At the end of the day, someone has to do it, and we shouldn't always simply trust others with it just because it's easier.
- pmontra 9y agoAbout the dickbars: 1) I uBlock them on my phone and tablet. Unfortunately there are plenty of random sites on Medium with their own domain. I don't follow any of them and get there from HN or similar sites. Blocking all of them doesn't make sense because I'll probably never get back to that domain. I agree with the author, the button in the middle of the page really sucks. 2) On desktop, the button and the dickbar never show because I'm running with NoScript and they are a JavaScript thing :-) The author misses another inconvenient feature of Medium, the login. It's either by oAuth (I don't remember which providers) or by email. That means they send me an email with a link to click to login. In theory it's ok, because obviously email is safer and more convenient than a password stored in a password manager (/sarcasm). The first time I used it the mail didn't arrive until the day after, so I've been primed against it. Probably almost everybody just login with Facebook or something so, quoting the author, "I’m not a part of his [Ev Williams] vision".
- Sylos 9y agoIn case you're not aware, NoScript also exists for Android: https://noscript.net/nsa/ https://noscript.net/nsa/ Not quite as functional as its bigger brother, but an option nonetheless.
- tuxracer 9y agoNoScript is also integrated into https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.brave.browser https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.brave.brow... This uses Chrome so there's likely higher compatibility with mobile sites
- Sam_Harris 9y agoMedium made a choice to put an unclosable popup on every page when vied on a mobile device.
- linopolus 9y agoI never understood how writers of any kind would let Medium (or Tumblr, or ...) rip all control off their hands.
- pmlnr 9y agoThirst for (fast/instant) fame.
- dhruvkar 9y agoI don't think this is an either/or situation. Medium's value is in exposing new, (arguably) high-quality content to its readers. Every so often, when you write an extra high-quality article, post it on medium as well, with a way for the reader to subscribe. It'll expose new readers to your writing and you still keep your content on your own platform.
- crispytx 9y agoMy blog is hosted by Medium on my own domain and I think it kicks ass. All of the issues the author brought up in his post seemed pretty minor to me. Just my opinion, but Medium has the best blogging software out there, by far.
- skyisblue 9y agoOne thing that really annoys me is embeded gists don't render in medium's mobile app.
- nvr219 9y agoPrivacy Badger blocks most medium sites for me :)
- bhalp1 9y agoAt https://dev.to https://dev.to we have a similar product to Medium in a lot of ways. One thing we try to do is offer the benefits of Medium in terms of distribution, but also encourage users to easily make their own site the canonical source, because we don't want to force vendor lock in when you get to this point. I'd like to think we also do a good job dealing with a lot of the UX issues that the author outlines :)
- owens99 9y agoMedium is blocked in China. And there are as many people learning English in China as the entire US population. That's the biggest deal breaker for me.
- erikb 9y agoI find the first part particularly interesting. I always contemplated of whether or not I should start blogging. And for me it always seemed an obvious choice between whether or not I want to host my own blog, which would mean a lot of energy and money investment, or if I should start a medium page, possibly losing control over my texts and page views. When you now say that it's a hassle to setup and even costs money, why should anybody use Medium? Do people not know how much you already gift a page if you let them host your content? They should pay you and not the other way around.
- zabil 9y agoIt's not easy to run a team (engineering) blog with static site generators. Authoring in markdown, reviewing, external contributions etc takes up a lot of time. With medium we've encouraged the team to run personal blogs and add interested articles to the team publication. It's a bottom up approach. In return, we get viewer-ship when medium recommends our articles on other (medium) blogs or via tags. Medium has a sense of community. Speaking strictly for myself, running your own site is tad selfish, it lacks as sense of community. Right now medium does that, We'd only move out of medium if there's something that does it better.
- abiox 9y agoi generally avoid medium.com blogs because the ui is bad. i hate the comments system.
- TheAceOfHearts 9y agoPersonally, I never write comments on blog posts, but I participate in communities like Hacker News and a couple random subreddits. I prefer including links to Hacker News or Reddit in the blog post. I'm not interested in handling authentication, moderating users, or dealing with spam. News aggregators usually do a great job with all those points. The Webmention [0] spec solves this problem, but sadly, it hasn't been widely adopted. :( [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Webmention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Webmention
- edem 9y agoThe OP forgot to mention the worst (IMHO) problem: Medium does not support multi-language content (more here: https://medium.com/@oleksiy/multilingual-content-management-a-challenge-that-faces-bloggers-and-a-punch-for-medium-ea1ecb3e357a https://medium.com/@oleksiy/multilingual-content-management-...). If I write posts in English or Hungarian it is okay. But when I start to write in both my readers will see unreadable gibberish when they come to my page and half of the content will be noise for them and it can't be helped. That's why I do it the other way around. I have my own domain and page which runs on a custom Jekyll / GitHub Pages setup and I import stories to Medium from my page. This way I can keep using medium and get more readers for free but Medium will display the "Originally posted at ..." line at the bottom. Win-win! You should try this out and use Medium for what it is useful for.
- maxraz 9y agoSetting up a domain was difficult. Really?
- amelius 9y agoThis is good. Medium is, in a sense, the anti-internet. It centralizes where no centralization is needed.
- Mikho 9y agoSwitched long time ago to Blogger--free to use your domain, change template design as you like as much as you like, connect external widgets like Disqus (my blog to check how Blogger may look: http://blog.babich.me/ http://blog.babich.me/). Also, a huge thing is integration with Google Photos and Google Drive. You may insert in a post photos from your Google Photo right by selecting them inside an image addition menu--no need in hustling with links, just look through Google Photos inside Blogger. BTW, it's possible to see photos uploaded via Blogger in Google Photos folder inside Google Drive (Google Photos app itself does not show photos uploaded via Blogger). You also may connect FeedBurner (Google company) in Blogger settings and collect subscription emails and also automatically send emails to subscribers via FeedBurner when a new post is published. BTW, every tag used for tagging posts in Blogger becomes dedicated RSS feed. So, if you write about different topics (e.g. coding and travel), it's easy to set up for people to follow RSS or subscribe via email only to a topic they are interested in and not everything you write. And it's all free! Medium feels like long-form Twitter with all these replies treated as posts. This is a terrible experience. Especially when you follow RSS feed of somebody on Medium and comments & replies are delivered and treated in the feed the same way as posts. I guess it's due to the fact that Ev was also Twitter founder and has only one construct in his head as to posts and replies.
- Rjevski 9y agoOne of the things I hate the most about Blogger is their stupid JS template where on mobile swiping left/right (to move the page if you're zoomed in) switches to the next/previous post instead.
- Mikho 9y agoI just rewrote the template completely. It's not that hard. So I do not have to deal with standard templates issues.
- asavadatti 9y agoYes but since it is owned by Google I'm afraid that they will shut it down on a whim
- xerophyte12932 9y agoIrony: I am getting a "This site can be reached".
- pgeorgep 9y agoInteresting read. Personally, I prefer Medium for the convenience.
- Goladus 9y agoWhy remove all your posts from medium.com? Why not post to both wordpress and medium.com?
- reboog711 9y agoI haven't followed the progression of Google search indexing, but in the old days, the 'rule of thumb' was that having the same content on two different domains would hurt your rankings.
- luord 9y agoI had no interest in using medium, but this is one extra little reason for not fixing my unbroken pelican+GitLab pages setup.
- alanh 9y agoNot to be a horrible self promoter (it's just the ideas I care about), but my 2012 discussion of the problem with new blogging platforms still applies, from a general perspective, to Medium: https://alanhogan.com/the-problem-with-new-blog-platforms https://alanhogan.com/the-problem-with-new-blog-platforms. (tl;dr is that eventually you will grow out of virtually any non-Wordpress platform, especially one you don’t control yourself.)
- alanh 9y agoA commentator on Arslan's post mentions “Medium’s foolproof wysiwyg editor.” This surprised me. I find their WYSIWYG editor to be incredibly frustrating, counter-intuitive, limiting, and obnoxious. Allow me to belabor only the last point. Imagine typing the following sentence (I’m using pipe | to show the cursor): Clifford is a big dog. But it's missing something, so you move your insertion point: Clifford is a big| dog. and you type “<space>red.” In any sane editor, the result will be exactly what you typed: Clifford is a big red| dog. But on Medium, the result is: Clifford is a big red|dog. Clifford is a big reddog? Ffffff. This happened because when you typed the first space after “big”, the result was not the insertion of a space but in fact the same as if you had hit the "right arrow" key: Clifford is a big |dog. Not cool. I have a strong habit of inserting words with the surrounding spaces already inserted. How dare Medium forbid me to type the way I want? I know that Medium does this because they are on a crusade to kill the usage of two spaces after sentence. That doesn’t excuse insane frustration of the editing process. No wonder most Medium posts don't look like they have ever experienced the most cursory proofreading!
- illuminea 9y agoFrom a branding and long-term point of view, it's really important to "own" your content by hosting it on your own domain and even server space. The advantage of a platform like Medium is that it can increase the reach of your content, but it's too risky to go all in with them since who knows how long they'll be around, or what limitations they might add down the line. But there's a way to have your cake and eat it too: you can publish first on your self-hosted WordPress site, and then republish automatically on Medium with a canonical tag pointing back to your WordPress site. This means you get the SEO and control benefits of WP, and the reach benefits of Medium. I wrote a guide on how to make this magic happen: https://illuminea.com/ultimate-guide-to-wordpress-medium/ https://illuminea.com/ultimate-guide-to-wordpress-medium/. Of course this post is also reposted on Medium with the canonical tag :) https://medium.com/@miriamschwab/6425c2d5e5c4 https://medium.com/@miriamschwab/6425c2d5e5c4