15 ms·
It's nice to see non-union employees treated well and paid well, not because of any negative feelings toward unions or unionization, but because I think it show
by pc86 9y ago
It's nice to see non-union employees treated well and paid well, not because of any negative feelings toward unions or unionization, but because I think it shows that you can be a successful capitalist without trying to suck every ounce of productivity and profit out of your lowest-paid employees.
- dx034 9y agoWhile I fully agree that it's great to see employees treated well, Whole Foods is not an example that you can be a successful capitalist this way. They worked well for a while but the reason they got bought now is because they struggled over the past years. Probably unrelated to their treatment of employees (US groceries is very competitive at the moment) but AMZN didn't buy a hugely successful company.
- bjelkeman-again 9y agoThe day I sell a company for $13Bn I will declare myself successful. Not everything is going to be a a half a trillion dollar company.
- atonse 9y agoI think what they might be talking about is that Whole Foods has had a rocky few quarters and might be forced to sell, where they wouldn't have sold in a different circumstance.
- dx034 9y agoNot if you bought it for $20bn. Wholefoods is publicly owned and the price that Amazon pays is below their price a few years back. It's not about size, $13bn is a lot of money. But Wholefoods needed a strategy or buyer, otherwise they would've faced serious problems in a few years.
- RobAley 9y agoIf I had $20bn to buy it in the first place, or be in the position where I could even raise that kind of capital, I would already be successful (in my mind at least).
- hollerith 9y agoOK, but WF stock is held mostly by ordinary people (or by pension funds acting on behalf of ordinary people) and the argument being made above is that there are signs that the reason WF ended up being owned by a company without WF's reputation for good treatment of employees is that selling the company was the only way for WF's management to meet their fiduciary responsibility to those ordinary people who hold WF stock.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoWhole Foods doesn't have one owner. It's a publicly traded company.
- lukas099 9y agoHow much have they paid in dividends since they cost $20bn?
- e12e 9y agoThis is a great question. Are there any open and fee apis where one can look up a publicly traded stock and get out dividends paid out over a time period? Surely that's at least as interesting as the rise and fall of the stock price.
- pc86 9y agoIt's a $13 billion sale. I struggle to see the scenario under which that is considered a failure. Most start-ups that get $120k from YC are considered a success here. Someone selling their struggling CRUD app to Amazon for $13 million would probably be considered a success here. But the $13 billion sale of a public company is a bunch of hemming and hawing about what the stock was worth a few years ago. I'm not saying it couldn't have been more successful. I'm not saying Amazon won't completely destroy the culture (they may, they may just let it continue as is and use it as Amazon Fresh logistics hubs as some have speculated). But I don't see how this isn't a great example of how you can treat your employees well - better than almost anyone else at the same level - and make a lot of money while doing it.
- markshead 9y ago> I struggle to see the scenario under which that is considered a failure. Wasn't Whole Foods valued at over $20 billion a few years ago? If you bought Whole Foods stock at that point (either as an outside investor or an employee) it might feel like Amazon is buying it for $13 billion because Whole Foods has been having trouble staying competitive in the market. Of course, if you actually started the company $13 billion may be a very big success if your goal was to sell.
- emodendroket 9y agoMaybe, but the fact that they were just acquired by a company notorious for abusing its low-level employees shows the limitations of this model (as did the pressure they began to face from investors to tighten up on that front when they started to become less profitable).
- Joakal 9y agoTreating them above market or not, Amazon acquired the company for billions and not because Whole Foods was doing badly.
- emodendroket 9y agoIt says right in this article (and in others that have been published recently) that they were under pressure from investors.
- VT_Drew 9y agoGood old investors, so short sighted, they only care about the next 3 months. Whole Foods probably would have been better off as private company, especially with the culture they were trying to create.
- ThrowawayR2 9y ago> Good old investors, so short sighted, they only care about the next 3 months. Yeah, darn those investors. How dare people with pensions, 401k's, IRAs, and other investments expect some kind of return on their investment? It's disgraceful. /s EDIT: The sentiment against investors is rather ironic considering the amount of equity collectively held by HN readers.
- kesselvon 9y agoshort-term boosterism is the cause of more than a few problems in our economic system
- DiNovi 9y agowell, he was pressured by his board to sell, so, not the most successful.
- creepydata 9y ago>I think it shows that you can be a successful capitalist without trying to suck every ounce of productivity and profit out of your lowest-paid employees. Another example of this is Wegmans - http://www.cbsnews.com/news/could-this-be-the-best-company-in-the-world/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/could-this-be-the-best-company-i... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/05/13/why-wegmans-really-is-the-best-supermarket-in-the-u-s/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/05/13/why-w... http://www.adweek.com/brand-marketing/why-do-so-many-people-go-crazy-wegmans-169396/ http://www.adweek.com/brand-marketing/why-do-so-many-people-... http://m.csmonitor.com/Business/The-Bite/2016/0225/Why-is-Wegmans-so-beloved http://m.csmonitor.com/Business/The-Bite/2016/0225/Why-is-We... “Our employees are our number one asset, period,” Kevin Stickles, the company’s vice president for human resources, told Reuters in 2012. “The first question you ask is: ‘Is this the best thing for the employee?’ That’s a totally different model.”
- jimbokun 9y ago"Alec Baldwin spoke on David Letterman about his mother's refusal to leave upstate New York because there are no Wegmans stores in Los Angeles." Ha, I think that's one of the most ringing endorsements of a business I've ever read.
- wlesieutre 9y agoHaving moved from an area with Wegmans to one without, I can sympathize. They're in Massachusetts, New Jersey, and New York, but Connecticut is a sad dead spot in the middle.
- matt_s 9y agoWegmans is also privately owned so there aren't "activist" shareholders that want hockey-stick growth.
- quadrangle 9y agoSame with Trader Joe's, thankfully
- 9y ago
- rmc 9y agoIn the 1880s Bismarck increased the modern welfare state (it was called State Socialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_Socialism_(Germany) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_Socialism_(Germany) ). The idea was that, if the poor people can get some form of social welfare from the existing state, they're less likely to support a proper socialist/communist revolution. Sounds like that. People won't unionise when they don't think they need to.
- vnchr 9y agoInteresting comparison. In this case, people aren't unionizing for essentially the opposite reason. Rather than state provided social welfare, their needs are satisfied through this capitalistic solution. Employees are empowered and rewarded through their work.
- throwaway91111 9y agoI'm not sure if you can call this capitalistic, though. WF as a commune could likely share many of the benefits or exceed them even without requiring shareholders to satisfy. Instead, a devotion to profits will ensure they are given the minimum to execute their job well. It'll be interesting to see what bezos does with it for sure.
- wooter 9y agoname a single commune as successful or operating at the scale of Whole Foods or Amazon. in history.
- Retric 9y agoWhole foods is vastly larger than the majority of organizations world wide. Remember the world GDP is only ~80,000 billion so there is a rather small number of Organizations with 10 billion per year in Revenue. But, if your just mean billion plus dollar orgs then something like : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Farmers_of_Alberta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Farmers_of_Alberta is an interesting comparison. Further, measuring the success of such organizations is hard especially when they are not trying to make a profit. I mean how do you measure something like the US Democratic and Republican parties?
- javiramos 9y agoI agree. I just heard this [1] podcast about the Oneida company. It was one of the first companies to show that paying and treating the lowest-paid employees very well and being very profitable are not mutually exclusive. [1] http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/06/09/532303452/episode-777-free-love-free-market http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/06/09/532303452/episo...
- fivestar 9y agoOf course it's not--you just have to have leaders who don't want 100X what the average employee makes! It's about greed, it's always been about greed. And it's so much worse than that, really. A lot of public companies are being strip-mined of their true wealth by the insiders. Pump the stock, gut the company, screw the investors.
- brian_herman 9y agoMaybe sucking every ounce of productivity is by treating your employees well and paying them well?
- jaggi1 9y ago> suck every ounce of productivity and profit out of your lowest-paid employees. Isn't it the same company that comited a fraud by selling products that weighed less than what they were charged for ?
- Shivetya 9y agoI think many over estimate how much better off people are with unions in grocery level employment and similar. while unions can be beneficial in some areas of employment it is not a miracle worker or guarantee of better outcome.
- icantdrive55 9y agoIt shows in the attitudes of the employees. Amazon got a bargain. It's too bad WF sold though. My hope is it doesn't turn into Safeway. I literally pick the line with the least angry Checker. The CEO said he would bring down the price of the basics, and he delivered. The price of milk, eggs, sugar, most 360 products are cheaper than Safeway. They do have a lost liter of wine that's pretty good. It's usually hidden though. It's $2.40/bottle. Forget the name. Three something? Plus--I think Bezo is predicting the future. There will be very rich people that will always be buying. I don't have a rosy view of our future. I don't want to live in a society that gets used to steping over the homeless in order to buy groceries, and sundry items. Oh yea, I will never understand that cosmetic/nutrition isle. $30 for shampoo? On a selfish note, I wish I trusted my gut a year ago. I wanted to buy Whole Foods, and Amazon stock. Just figured I can't take a risk.