17 ms·
Chicago taxi industry sliding towards collapse
- hammock 9y agoI have heard this from several taxi drivers. As a passenger cabs have all but disappeared from the streets compared to a few years ago
- basseq 9y agoI'm left wondering... so what? The "personal transportation" market has massively changed. Whether it's for the better or worse simply doesn't matter. Veteran Chicago cabbie John Aikins,67, who is facing foreclosure on two medallions for which he owes more than $330,0000, said he has little hope that the industry can be saved. "It feels like the city is just watching us collapse," Aikins said. "Right now, there are a few people, the elderly and some others who refuse to take Uber because they are uncomfortable with it, that keep us going. But how many of those people are out there to sustain us?" Chicago, by way of example, does not "owe" the cab industry anything. And, in fact, likely needs to make their own changes to manage the quickly-depreciating medallion model. The government in no way insured that medallions would be a winning business investment. And, harshly, those defaults (on the secondary market, no less) likely won't have much economic impact. I'm firmly behind Judge Richard Posner: "Were the old deemed to have a constitutional right to preclude the entry of the new into the markets of the old, economic progress might grind to a halt."
- basseq 9y agoSecond thought: The medallions give "the exclusive right to pick up passengers who hail them on the street". But that's just happening as much. But even "the elderly" are likely not going outside (in Chicago) and sticking their hand out. They're being dispatched, where you wouldn't need a medallion in the first place (right?).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- monksy 9y ago> "the elderly" They are. There are many active elderly people in Chicago.
- greglindahl 9y agoGoogle [bank taxi medallion exposure] and you'll discover a few banks that are going to go under. Not a significant problem in the big picture, but it is still a problem for more than just medallion owners.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoGood riddance. Taxi medallions are a market in rent-seeking, investing in it should mean you lose your shirt.
- Neliquat 9y agoSo a cab driver who wants to drive (legally!) for a living deserves to be broke because of the system they are forced into? That is pretty heartless. These are honest people who many times took a loan to secure their familys future, and you think they should lose their shirt? Do some reflection dude.
- pravda 9y agoI do feel a little bit of schadenfreude at the predicament of NYCs biggest medallion speculator: http://pix11.com/2017/06/07/nyc-taxi-king-accused-of-failing-to-pay-5-million-in-taxes-intended-for-mta-improvements/ http://pix11.com/2017/06/07/nyc-taxi-king-accused-of-failing... Now some medallion owners are trying to get gov't money to bail them out: https://www.scribd.com/document/346690906/Letter-to-Governor-Cuomo-on-Taxis#from_embed https://www.scribd.com/document/346690906/Letter-to-Governor...
- tstactplsignore 9y ago>Whether it's for the better or worse simply doesn't matter Yikes- I have only a little sympathy for the taxi industry, but it is very scary that you do not believe we should be concerned with whether market forces improve society or not. I think it is extremely important to the vast majority of people that any enormous change in transportation occurs for the benefit of society - the ideology that capitalism is an end into itself is extreme and fringe, and we shouldn't be afraid to call it out as such.
- sharemywin 9y agoAs much as I'd like to agree with you, calling it "fringe" might unfortunately underestimate the number of people that support.
- bitJericho 9y agoWe'll see what you think of the cab industry when uber raises their prices by 3 times in order to become profitable, after the cabbies all gone.
- brianwawok 9y agoAs long as Lyft is around, they can't.
- incongruity 9y agoYou're right. There are no markets in which a few dominant players capture significant profits because there are only a few dominant players who exploit barriers to entry or network effects to stay on top... Except pharma, telecom, energy, airlines and one or two others...
- cortesoft 9y agoOther than pharma, you just mentioned 3 industries that have very low margins. They aren't making a ton of money on their monopolies.
- ams6110 9y agoPlease don't quote by indenting. It's unreadable on mobile.
- djsumdog 9y agoThat man took out a loan for a medallion, with the idea that he should be able to sell it once he retires. The medallion is now worthless. If Chicago cares about the cabbies, individual owners should be paid dollar for dollar the value of those medallions, even if no one else will buy them in the future. (Does Chicago buy back the medallions, or do you have to have to sell them to someone else? Is the 300,000 the market value he paid to someone else, or is that what the city charges?) The US government bailed out the banks in 2008, and all those people at the top got to keep their millions while so many people lost their homes (mostly due to fraud). These people watched their industry change while being locked into a sinking ship .. unable to do anything about it. These people need a bailout.
- wizu 9y ago> If Chicago cares about the cabbies That's the thing though, they don't. And why would they? These cabbies made a bet that the medallion would not lose value until they sold it, and they lost that bet. How is this different from any other small-time business going bankrupt?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- unethical_ban 9y agoSure. Next thing, the Treasury immediately stops honoring $20 bills. Hey, what chumps we were, accepting cash! The analogy holds: A city government had a system where a good had artificial scarcity and intrinsic value from stable government policy. Then, it suddenly changed. I'm all for ride-hailing changing our public transit dynamic, but I can't fault the players of the old system too much for saying "What the hell about my retirement, my end of life?"
- averagewall 9y agoI don't think the city stopped honoring anything or changed any rules. The medallion buyers were just speculating and didn't see the future well. No different from people who buy property for retirement then there's a recession and the surrounding population declines and it becomes worthless. Investment is gambling. Everyone knows that. You're supposed to diversify. Humble wage earners don't have that problem. Drivers who rent medallions don't have that problem. Only the risk taking ones who took loans for something that might lose value do.
- GnarfGnarf 9y agoI take your point. However there is one case where traditional cab companies provide a benefit. When a city issues permits for the lucrative airport business to one specific cab company, it is with the understanding that there will be cars waiting for passengers around the clock, even during unprofitable times of the day. If the cab business becomes a free-for-all, there will be no one waiting at the airport at 3:00 AM. Granted, there isn't a lot of traffic at certain times, but the public interest is best served when there are always cabs available.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoIn this example, you are asking for the cab companies to calculate an average fare which will allow them to operate at a loss during the night. The cab company is taking the risk that their assumptions about how much to charge during the day will offset their losses at night. However, for this scenario, why does a cab company need to take on this risk? Why is the risk of not having a cab at a cheap price not borne by the person who needs it at 3AM? This seems like a problem that is sufficiently solved by the market, where cabs will charge appropriate pricing to make it worth their while, and if another company finds they can correctly price their fares so that they can offer the same pricing day and night, then customers will choose them.
- GnarfGnarf 9y agoThe municipal government mandates that the company who wins the bid for the airport franchise, is committed to always having a cab at the airport. The public good is served above the expediencies of corporate profit.
- WCityMike 9y agoAt least in Chicago, public transit options exist.
- wand3r 9y agoSo the "benefit" was instead of allowing people to notify them in advance; the daytime market subsidized cars waiting mostly idle at 3am.
- gehwartzen 9y agoHow did Uber get around not having to buy medallions for their drivers? What prevented someone from operating a for profit ride program even before Uber without a medallion?
- clock_tower 9y agoUber broke the taxi laws and dared regulators to stop them -- and they mostly won that dare. (Remember all that talk about disruption?)
- gehwartzen 9y agoCouldn't medallion holders then sue whomever issues them since they aren't enforcing the rules/terms under which they were originally sold?
- clock_tower 9y agoI'd guess that they probably could.
- criddell 9y agoThey did and the 7th circuit ruled that the businesses were different enough that they can be regulated differently. The supreme court declined to hear the case, so that's how it was left. It's the last two paragraphs of the article.
- sanswork 9y agoUber generally didn't break taxi laws since most cities only give medallion owners monopoly over unbooked pickups. Uber generally broke car service laws by not requiring their drivers to have the local registrations.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> What prevented someone from operating a for profit ride program even before Uber without a medallion? Uber scaled fast while ignoring local regulations. Both parts are important. We've seen from e.g. Zenefits [1] that state regulators are powerful. Local regulators, on the other hand, are slower moving. Previously, a disruptor might assemble a few happy customers before the regulators slammed down on them. Uber's ability and willingness to scale fast changed that. By the time the local regulators were ready to slam down, entire cities of constituents wanted and liked the service. That changed the political calculus. Uber, and consumers, won. [1] https://venturebeat.com/2017/04/11/zenefits-fined-1-2-million-by-ny-regulator-for-unlicensed-insurance-sales/ https://venturebeat.com/2017/04/11/zenefits-fined-1-2-millio...
- cmurf 9y agoChicago owes a fair and equal competing market and what they've done is permit two totally different regulatory paradigms to exist at the same time: conventional taxes, and new taxies, sometimes also called ride sharing which is obviously bullshit to get around being called a taxi and regulated as a taxi. Uber and Lyft rides are also investor subsidized, and that is likewise market distorting. The city of Chicago, like many other cities, simply doesn't know what to do. They lacked the knowledge and/or the courage to either regulate Uber and Lyft etc just like taxis; or end the taxi monopoly and take some role with handling the total collapse of the medallion market (partial buy back perhaps). But any of these meallion owners should investigate a hair cut negotiation with their lenders or talk to a bankruptcy attorney. There is no good reason for these people to be in debt on a useless asset. It's every bit as much their mistake to loan, as it was the lenders mistake to lend.
- sanswork 9y agoAlmost all cities had a category of licensing for car services that were not taxis long before uber showed up. The only difference between uber and these other car services was the ease at finding a car.
- valuearb 9y agoWe should buy back medallions because these vultures overpaid for them and drove medallion prices into the stratosphere because of the ability to overcharge riders they gave? Medallions owners ripped off people in Chicago long enough. They should sow what they reaped.
- dingo_bat 9y agoWhy is Veteran Chicago cabbie John Aikins not driving for Uber?
- pyrale 9y ago> Whether it's for the better or worse simply doesn't matter. I guess it matters to those upon which the worse is imposed. By that, I mean not only the taxi drivers. From an individual standpoint, those who get to drive for Uber are happy to get jobs, but looking at the problem at the scale of the workforce, replacing one jobless man and one well-paid man by one less paid man and a jobless man is a net loss.
- averagewall 9y agoAnything's a net loss if you choose the scope arbitrarily. It's not just two guys losing money. It's also the customers saving money and getting better service. If you see a taxi company as some kind of employer of last resort or an unemployment benefit without the shame, then perhaps it's a net loss, but why not just call a benefit a benefit and hand out cash to un/underemployed people. If you have to take a pound of flesh to prevent abuse, then have them break rocks or something to earn their payments.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y ago> I'm left wondering... so what? Well, ~10,000 people, mostly male, are going to be left not only unemployed, but heavily indebted. That combination cannot be good for social stability. If you are a resident of Chicago, you should care. This problem won't go quietly into the night. > The government in no way insured that medallions would be a winning business investment. People who recently took out loans to purchase a car to work for Uber are going to be facing the exact same problem if and when they roll out their autonomous fleet. That's around 200,000 nationwide. I care about these things because I want the society I live in to continue to be relatively peaceful. And America is certainly well equipped, there are as many guns are there are people. Situations like these are how bloody revolutions start. Everyone has fears about AI's running amok. I fear what people will do when AI's take their jobs.
- valuearb 9y agoThis is bs. Entrepreneurs go bankrupt all the time, it's the "creative destruction" part of capitalism, risk and reward. And 10,000 people in the chicago would be a drop in the bucket. But it's not 10,000 people. Lots of those medallions are owned by businesses, and they leased the medallions to drivers. Most drivers can switch to Uber/Lyft if they have or want to buy their own cars, or get other jobs. Driving a cab wasn't lucrative, the owners of the medallions were the ones reaping the monopoly profits. The best part of the shattering of these monopolies was the lesson it gives others investing in government shielded businesses. Hopefully they will fear their own bankruptcies soon.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoYour bias is causing you to come to some faulty conclusions. I did not quote the number of medallions given out by the city (which by the way is around 7000 [0]). I specifically stated the number of people employed as taxi drivers, which as of Dec 2016, is 9500. [1] > Most drivers can switch to Uber/Lyft if they have or want to buy their own cars, or get other jobs. Although some of them can probably use their primary car for Uber/Lyft, many of them will have to take out a loan/increase their debt to get a car they can use for ride-hailing. Perhaps you aren't aware, but losses in sub-prime auto loans have reached their highest levels since the 2008 financial crisis. Given that taxi drivers make on avg about $35,000, it's safe to assume that many only qualify for subprime and will add to this problem. And this is happening all across the country. To your other point, get another job: Doubtlessly some people will be able to retrain. Just as surely, a number of people will not be able to adapt. Being a driver is about as low skilled as labor gets, so there are hardly any where their previous experience can transfer. So what jobs? Retail > Driving a cab wasn't lucrative, the owners of the medallions were the ones reaping the monopoly profits. The best part of the shattering of these monopolies was the lesson it gives others investing in government shielded businesses. I don't really care about the superiority of dynamic startups vs government shielded monopolies and honestly I think the financialization/commodification of parts of the economy such that people make bets on things instead of contributing productive value is not a good thing. But I digress, I'm more concerned with the shattered pieces left over in the creative destruction. 9500 formerly employed people with little future job prospects. That is .2% of working adults. It's not a huge amount, but it's not a drop in the bucket, especiallly when the city is again raising taxes and these individuals are going to need government assistance. As us in the tech industry innovate and move forward, we aren't following the patterns of the past. When software eats industries, it destroys jobs a magnitude more than it creates. Let's be clear, coal isn't coming back and neither is manufacturing (BTW, the US is still the world's 2nd largest manufacturer and the leading advanced manufacturer, a fact that goes unnoticed) I personally don't find meaning or validation in life by having a job, but many do and UBI is a stopgap at best, but we really don't have any other solution at this point. That's what scares me....and people making rhetorical, ideological rants with no regards for facts. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_the_United_States#Chicago https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_the_United_States#... [1] http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-chicago-taxi-driver-decline-met-20161214-story.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-chicago-taxi-driver-de...
- alkonaut 9y agoHow are they making so much less money than Uber? Simply by paying drivers more? Because if they don't have things like booking, pre-paying via apps etc then of course they are losing business - but in that case why don't they? I don't use Uber over taxis simply because I can get the exact same service from a taxi, but the drivers are better off in terms of pay and schedule (as far as I know).
- shapov 9y agoI don't use Uber over taxis simply because I can get the exact same service from a taxi That's just not true. Just off the top of my head: * 3-4 clicks and I have an Uber on its way vs. Having to talk to a dispatcher. Time saved. * I know ahead of time how much the fair will be vs. at the end of the ride. * I simply get out of the car once I reach my destination. I don't have to deal with paying, calculating tip, etc... * Uber cars tend to be newer and in much better condition. Now, I am not advocating for Uber, but lets not kid ourselves that the two experiences are even comparable from the customer's point of view.
- alkonaut 9y agoI'm talking about where I get a cab where there is app dispatch+ (pre) payment. And no medallions. Obviously taxi companies that still operate like it's 1990 are going to go extinct - my question was why are they operating like it's 1990?
- brianwawok 9y agoAs a monopoly, you usually have no reason to change. You make piles of money with no extra work, why innovate? Uber/Lyft is eating their lunch. Now they need to innovate or die. Very likely they die at this point.
- alkonaut 9y ago> As a monopoly, you usually have no reason to change. But they don't have a monopoly and haven't for several years. I mean changing from phone dispatch to apps has to be done in 6-12 months not 6-12 years otherwise yes they will go under. So what you are saying is that they are too slow to change? What's the reason for that? Is it that the taxi operators are small businesses and they are a too diverse group to be willing to take large risks/investmentst together such as for improving their common dispatch? In that case - the system is almost a perfect storm. So would you agree that at challenges to traditional taxi in medallion-cities include: - Small taxi companies (single car to maybe 100 cars) rather than large operators (1000 cars or more) that would have the money to evolve when needed - Expensive medallions causing overhead compared to Uber/Lyft - Long history of monopoly causing an unfamiliarity with rapid changes - (Possibly) regulative hurdles to overcome before you could e.g. pre-charge for a ride or dispatch with an app rather than phone?
- TY 9y agoAnectodal evidence from my trip to Chicago last week. The same trip cost me twice as much when I took a taxi vs Lyft. So guess what I'm going to take the next time...
- bitJericho 9y agoIn a taxi your ride was insured if the driver got in an accident. Your cabbie is certified, and less likely to be crazy. Also half your lyft/uber ride is paid by a VC.
- jseliger 9y agoless likely to be crazy. Having taken many cabs and many rides via Uber, Lyft, and Juno, I'm not sure why you'd claim this. The drivers for ride-sharing services are far safer, saner, and more careful than cab drivers. The reason is not hard to ascertain: at the end of almost every trip drivers and riders rate each other.
- weberc2 9y agoThis seems to match my experience.
- bdalgaard 9y agoI think there are similar related downsides that could be said about ride-sharing too. If we are giving anecdotal experience then I will say that ride-sharing drivers in Chicago are much more likely to blow through yellow/red lights or park in a cross-walk. The reason is not hard to ascertain: I can easily call 311 on a taxi as a pedestrian with the taxi number. Personally, I see a lot of people happy killing all of the problems with taxis (particularly in Chicago) but I fear that we are "throwing the baby out with the bathwater". Taxis in Chicago have a ton of problems, but I still have concerns about ride-sharing too.
- techsupporter 9y agoSame problem in Seattle, especially with the complete disregard for lane use. Uber and Lyft drivers seem to think that "bus only" is secret code for "all TNC drivers stop here for passengers, especially at peak times." My personal favorite is how hazard lights have morphed into "I can do whatever I want, just go around me by veering a car / this 60' bus into oncoming traffic." One of these days I'm going to start spending one of my days off just standing at a random major intersection and emailing SDOT/SPD and posting on Twitter the license plate numbers of every Uber/Lyft driver behaving badly.
- degenerate 9y agoGood, it's about time we let some crappy things die. Bailing out the banks and GM got me furious many years ago. Imagine if the government stepped in and saved Altavisa / Pets.com, and all the other dot-com boom companies? What good would that have done? Nothing. Let 'em burn and innovation will rise from the ashes.
- dev360 9y agoI've never been furious about Taxis before I heard of the medallion system in Chicago and New York.. Sounds like something the mob would cook up together with crooked politicians as an alternative source of revenue.
- logfromblammo 9y ago> ...something the mob would cook up together with crooked politicians... It's Chicago. The crooked politicians are their own mob. Vice crime may be contracted out to the local gangs, but the rackets are kept strictly in-house. That way, when you want to buy a senate seat, there's no pesky middleman in the way to jack up prices. You can just go straight to the governor and hand him an envelope of cash under the table.
- y_u_no_rust 9y agoIllinois is just more effective at catching and prosecuting criminals like that.
- brianwawok 9y ago+ 10000, the taxi system in chicago was _SO_BAD_ Can remember one case where I got a 5am ride to the airport. I suspect the guy was driving a friends cab, as his face did not match the registration. He blew through all stop signs we came across. There were no working seatbelts in the cab. I was literally afraid for my life. Oh and of course his credit card machine was broke, and he had no change, so I have to pay with 20s and get no change back.
- 9y ago
- jostmey 9y agoI used to live in Chicago. The city taxi service was horrible--the drivers were grumpy and sketchy. They would always try to take the expensive way around. I hated the taxi service so much that to get around the airport restrictions I would ride the train out to the first stop so I could order an Uber ride.
- shostack 9y agoI lived in Chicago for most of my life until somewhat recently. Things I observed during that time: - A driver stating, seemingly out of nowhere to my friend and I, "we should just take all of the gays out back and shoot them" - Multiple times scheduling a morning pickup for a flight, not having it arrive, and being told by the uncaring operator the alternative was to wait so long I'd miss my flight, or gamble with trying to find a free cab during rush hour on Belmont (a losing proposition) - Too many counts to list of the CC machine "being broken" to try to force me to pay cash, including being intimidated at one point to stop at an ATM to get cash to pay - Having a driver show me the gun he kept under his seat for "driving through the South Side" - The joy of not being able to ever get a cab during busy events in extreme weather of all types because there was no way to reserve the ride - Various smells, ripped seats, miscellaneous fluids in the floor mats, leftover food/alcohol/condom, etc. - A cab driver who picked me up at my home to go to the airport who then kicked me out part way there because I was on the phone with my mother and he refused to turn down his radio when I requested (which is in the friggin 'Passenger's Bill of Rights' posted in the back of the cab). He then loudly threatened me with physical violence once I exited the vehicle. I ended up asking the cab company to not fire him once I complained because I was so scared that he was unhinged, and the last thing I wanted was an unemployed, unhinged angry guy knowing where my wife and I lived Good riddance. Uber has its own issues, but they have proven what the market wants. And it sure as hell isn't the current cab system Chicago has.
- logfromblammo 9y agoNever have I ever trusted a cab company to schedule a pickup. I have used airport shuttle companies, and limousine/livery companies (this was before Lyft and Uber). Both were overwhelmingly cheaper than a cab, and they actually show up on time. When I lived in Chicago, I'd always use the blue line to ORD or orange line to MDW. Whenever I actually wanted a cab in Chicago, I could never get one. I suspect that was mainly down to my looks. Not so much sketchy as unattractive, and possibly willing to counter the broken card swipe machine gambit by paying with nickels and then forgetting to leave a tip. And of course there's just something about a vehicle that smells like it was recently dusted with finely-ground cumin that makes me want to walk. So, no sympathy here. They can choke on those medallions.
- joejerryronnie 9y agoIt appears the basic reason for a taxi medallion system is to regulate the industry and control supply to prevent a flood of random drivers being unleashed on an unsuspecting populous. Uber/Lyft business model: Unleash a flood of random drivers on an unsuspecting populous. Not that I agree with the taxi medallion system as it's ultimately been used to grant political favors and prop up unnatural monopolies but it is interesting how the negative consequences supporting the argument for why the taxi industry should be regulated are actually the competitive advantages of the ride hailing companies. . . well, that and unfettered access to VC subsidized fares, but who's counting?
- philipkglass 9y agoIt appears the basic reason for a taxi medallion system is to regulate the industry and control supply to prevent a flood of random drivers being unleashed on an unsuspecting populous. I'm fine with regulations to enforce safety. I'm not fine with the "control supply" aspect. Medallions shouldn't be rationed any more than driver's licenses in general; just require people to pass standard tests and documentation requirements to get a medallion. It's unfortunate that medallion systems seem to fuse a justification that clearly serves the public interest with one that serves the public to a much lesser degree, or even not at all.
- verall 9y ago> VC subsidized fares Although the conveniences granted by rideshare apps are a big deal, I think this is a huge component. At this point, in a busy(er) city, ridesharing is still very competitive, and prices are subsidized-low. Living in Austin, right before the city vote to require fingerprinting drivers, which Uber was heavily lobbying against, I could get an uberpool basically anywhere within the city for between $1 and $3. I'm just hoping that once companies start to raise prices more VCs come swooping in, kind of like still happens with growing websites. As a consumer, the cost of switching is very low.
- weberc2 9y ago> Unleash a flood of random drivers on an unsuspecting populous. Not sure if it's a "flood", but the volume of drivers is self-adjusting for the demand. As to the quality of drivers, I have no reason to believe Uber/Lyft drivers are worse than taxis. Chicago taxis drive like lunatics, but this hasn't been so much my experience with Uber/Lyft drivers, who seem to be a cross-section of Chicago drivers. And I don't know that the populace has been meaningfully "unsuspecting". So all in all, this seems like a net positive--one less thing for the government to spend money regulating in the long run and a better system for everyone else (probably the former caused the latter, but anyway...).
- sharemywin 9y agoAs much as I think the taxi system needed replaced, I'm not sure how I feel about companies breaking laws to innovate. If we go down that path are the south american drug cartels just ahead of their time.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoIt really depends on the law. "You need to pay $300k for the right to get paid to drive people from point A to B" is a really terrible law.
- SilasX 9y agoThe law was more like, "You must have a medallion to operate a cab. We only issued 10k medallions (or whatever). The medallions are transferable. We're not issuing new ones." Combined with the supply of cab labor, that had the effect of, "if you want to operate a cab, you need to buy one from an owner at the current absurd market price".
- heisenbit 9y agoWhich worked as long as the prices were going up. Isn't it ironic that taxi drivers having gone in debt to buy a medallion are now financially destroyed by a company spending more than it takes in? Medallion asset bubble destroyed by Uber valuation bubble.
- shostack 9y agoIs Lyft breaking the law? They operate in Chicago, so in theory would be a viable alternative to Uber.
- brianwawok 9y agoThey did when they launched, they would do airport pickups despite a law against that.
- wayn3 9y ago
- nserrino 9y agoI probably won't ever take a taxi again, but have some sympathy for the cab drivers who put their life savings in medallions. The city effectively promised them the exclusive right to give taxi rides, but didn't do anything about a non-medallion entity doing that same thing. They put hundreds of thousands of dollars into something meaningless.
- tw04 9y agoDo you also feel bad for the slumlord who spends a million dollars on a property that eventually gets condemned because he didn't take care of it? Had taxi company owners not used those medallions as an excuse to provide absolutely horrendous customer service, they wouldn't have ever had to worry about uber/lyft/whatever in the first place. I've never taken uber or lyft because it's cheaper, I've taken it because I get a clean, comfortable ride, with a driver who isn't a complete jerk. I've mentioned it here before, but also why I won't take uber anymore unless it's my last option - their CEO has the same attitude I saw in those taxi drivers and I'm not about to give monetary support to "that guy". NOTHING the government did has EVER prevented cab companies from providing the same service these startups provide.
- weberc2 9y agoWell, besides completely strip their incentive to innovate or otherwise provide more than a marginally useful service...
- nserrino 9y agoTrue but there are good taxi drivers out there too, who bought a $300k thing that is now worth nothing. Anyway that is why I said "some sympathy", because obviously the service was lacking. But I blame that more on a government restriction on those services that (previously) didn't incentive good service, not individual taxi drivers.
- neom 9y agoIt's more like a bunch of people bought houses on a street and 2 really rich people bought an equal number of the rest, one maintained theirs and did their best and the 2 rich people let theirs become crack dens and devalued everything else. Additionally, the taxi industry wasn't exactly filled with educated people who knew how to build software. It's an awful system, but it is what happened, and that should be considered.
- webwanderings 9y agoAll Chicago taxicab drivers are driving Uber, Lyft and anything else running on the smart phones. The people who invested and saved through government backed medallion business, are loosing. Don't fool yourself in thinking that the stranger you're sitting in Uber with, could potentially be your co-worker. He's your former cab driver.
- YPCrumble 9y agoEven better, he's my former cab driver who cares about his customer service rating staying high!
- jbmorgado 9y agoThe difference is that when my former cab driver sits to drive an Uber/Lyft he knows he will be rated at the end and he also knows he can't rip me off in the fare or refuse to pass a receipt in the end. Most of all, is the accountability I care for. The accountability that he didn't had to care about as a taxi driver but that cares very much when he drives an Uber.
- kylehotchkiss 9y ago"including changing rules so taxi drivers aren’t required to replace their vehicles as often" So.. to save this industry let's make it less enticing? I'm not saying Ubers and Lyfts are always nice, new cars; but they usually aren't models from before 2010 either. Call us posh, but if you can get a ride in a nicer car for the same price, that would be a thing to consider when picking a mode of transport?
- fitchjo 9y agoI do feel a bit for those individuals that bought a taxi medallion recently and are unlikely to be able to pay it off due to the change in dynamics; on the other hand, the only reason the price of the medallions were so high was that the market dynamics were being manipulated (by controlling the supply). The risk that those market dynamics could change should have been included in the price of the medallion - if someone did not properly consider whether that risk was appropriately priced when purchasing a medallion, that is their fault. The only real costs they talk about that are different for a taxi versus uber aren't significant (1,176 taxi fee and 1,000 every two years for the medallion renewal) and do provide them a competitive advantage (being able to pick up rides hailed on the street.
- wffurr 9y agoI still don't understand why taxis need a medallion from the city to operate, but Uber and Lyft drivers don't. The quote from Judge Posner at the end of the article is totally inane, and has to be out of context.
- gmarx 9y agoaccording to the article the medallion allows you to roam the street and look for someone to hail you. Uber and Lyft were ruled by the court to be more like arranged rides (limo service). It likely makes sense if you consider the original purpose of the medallion. I think (need to check again) that it was not to create monopolies but to reduce the danger that ramped up in the early days with unlimited numbers of cabs roaming the streets, zooming and cutting each other off to get a fare. If you call for a ride that public safety concern is gone
- dang 9y agoIsn't it interesting how the Uber threads fill up with rage against Uber and the taxi threads fill up with rage against taxis? We are large we contain multitudes.
- mullen 9y agoIt is possible to hate both and that's why I take Lyft.
- bobbington 9y agoHopefully this is the start of artificial, government imposed barriers being torn down. Hopefully someday anybody will be able to be a lawyer or plumber, or anything else they want without government requiring a competition and innovation killing license. Thanks Uber!
- Jimmie_Rustle 9y ago| The union is calling on the city take several actions to provide relief for the city’s struggling taxi industry, including changing rules so taxi drivers aren’t required to replace their vehicles as often Right! Let's loosen the rules and allow the cabs to be in worse condition than they already are, that will get the customers back! /s
- wavefunction 9y agoWell, we bail out banks who make shoddy investments. That's my only counter to the idea that medallions are going to ruin some lives soon.
- criddell 9y agoMost restaurants fail and we don't bail them out. I think the big banks are a special case because letting them fail may be more expensive than bailing them out.
- mschuster91 9y agoA point that I have yet to see in the debate: while everyone seems to like the "old cab industry" going downhill (which may very well be deserved, given shady practices like racial discrimination, detours etc.), no one seems to think about the ultimate consequence: People without smartphones or credit cards will have no way of getting individual point-to-point transportation any more. This especially includes old people (who e.g. rely on cabs to transport them to doctors, grocery stores etc), people who do not want smartphones or cellphones in general due to privacy reasons (e.g. tracking by network operators, or not wanting everything they do on their phone fed to Google), and minors who do not have a credit card - when I was young I always had 50€ in cash with me so I could fetch a cab home when public transport failed. Also, there are many people who do not want to use Uber, Lyft etc. for ethical or other reasons - it is unclear if the driver has proper insurance for his vehicle, it is not regulated how long the driver has been behind the wheel (it's easy to end up in a crash when driving tired, I speak from personal experience), it's not regulated how much money the drivers make (owner-operated businesses usually don't fall under minimum wage regulations) and for what it's worth it's not guaranteed that the vehicle is technically fit to be on the road (which cabs usually are, with yearly inspections by independent auditors in Germany, for example).
- randyrand 9y agoChicago taxis are some of the worst. God I hated them. I wonder why they're not doing well?!
- pessimizer 9y agoThey should just do what Uber did: be heavily invested in by the mayor's brother.
- kevindong 9y agoThe Uber/Lyft systems are very robust (in the sense that I have no trouble getting drivers to take my ride requests at any time) in Chicago. That being said, I cannot imagine the drivers are making a decent living driving. Anecdotally: as long as I don't go during rush hour (i.e. 7-9am or 4-6pm on weekdays), I can get from anywhere in the densely populated sections of Chicago (basically, anywhere within 5 miles of the loop) to another section for ~$3~5 via Uber Pool/Lyft Line. At that price point, it's competitive with taking public transit. I'm interning in Chicago this summer and I've already taken pool/line 10 times, each for ~$3~4 and taking ~20 minutes and going about ~3 miles. Uber/Lyft's algorithms for matching riders up is actually pretty good in my experience, but even then let's assume that each driver has two riders per trip, each paying $4 and each trip taking 20 minutes. In which case, they'd have 6 riders per hour for a total revenue of $24/hour before Uber/Lyft's cut and accounting for their own expenses. I refuse to believe they can actually make a living by driving this way.
- djohnston 9y agoI'm a big fan of ride sharing and I share your frustration with taxis, but I do think they have a point here. The judge says: "Were the old deemed to have a constitutional right to preclude the entry of the new into the markets of the old..." If you're willing to admit that it's the same market, the taxes and fees from the city should be lifted. It's absolutely unfair otherwise.
- schrags08 9y agogood riddance.
- jmclnx 9y agoIf you read the article, most medallions are owned by individuals, were it seems at most 1 person owns 4 medallions. And the cabbies were able to make a living wage. In this specific case we have 2 national companies paying just above minimum wages taking over the industry in Chicago, probably incentiveing local pols not to change regulations. So once again the little guy gets crushed.
- spo81rty 9y agoThe fact that someone would pay $300k for the right to drive a taxi blows my mind.
- didibus 9y agoI highly recommend people read this 2011 reuters article: http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2011/10/21/why-taxi-medallions-cost-1-million/ http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2011/10/21/why-taxi-me... Given the regulations, Medallions would make you 50k profit a year. You could suspect a bubble, but the math holds up. Though that profit calculation is dependent on the fare regulations and limits on medallions.
- valuearb 9y agoSo awesome that the Monopoly Medallion holders are filing for bankruptcy.
- sausman 9y agoWas probably going to happen eventually since Lyft and Uber offer a better product, but it's interesting that the big ride sharing companies aren't profitable yet either.
- gator-io 9y agoJust waiting for Uber to screw over their own drivers with autonomous vehicles and see if these same arguments will be presented.
- amuta01 9y agoDo you need personal or business loans without stress and quick approval? If so, please contact us, as we are now offering loans at prime rate. Our loan is safe and secure, for more information and applications, please reply to this email. (Even_Financial@financier.com) the name and quantity required. Opportunity to loan your door step Do you need an urgent loan? Do you need a commercial loan? Do you need a loan for your investment? Do you need a loan to fund your problem? Do you need a Personal Loan? Contact Us Today :: ( Even_Financial@financier.com )