24 ms·
Too many people are buying cars using financial products they do not understand
- barrkel 9y agoI think it may be easy to buy a relatively bad PCP deal, because of the difficulty in comparing like for like when there's a lot of variables in the deal. But I'm not sure that PCP is often a bad deal compared with outright purchase (whether on finance or not), because it creates a lot of certainty, particularly with good gap insurance, and doesn't require a lot of capital.
- valuearb 9y agoPCP should be the best way to purchase, just like leases should be. You just pay depreciation/cost of ownership/cost of financing, and don't have to worry about getting out of the car when you want a new one. But like leases, it sounds like the problem with the PCP is the financial complexity. The option at the end of a lease has actual value, and it's difficult for a consumer to value it properly. The interest being charged is also hidden, making it easy to hit you with a far higher rate. If you could buy a car on a PCP where the finance costs and end contract purchase price were reasonable and market competitive, it might be great. After all, a car shouldn't always be a forced savings plan where you are required to own it after 4 or 5 years.
- ethbro 9y ago> What auto finance needs — what most consumer finance needs — is for key information to be made simple and salient. Competition cannot work if consumers struggle to understand what they’re being sold and what it will cost. And if you agree with that, then let me tell you a story about the healthcare industry...
- chestervonwinch 9y agoHealthcare, phone plans, internet/cable plans, vehicles ... they're all variations on the (financial) security (for the seller) through obscurity.
- DanBC 9y agoA better title might be "too many people are buying cars using financial products they do not fully understand."
- dang 9y agoThat's good because it's the article's own summary. Thanks.
- IkmoIkmo 9y agoSome examples would've been nice.
- jordanb 9y agoSo I guess the whole car thing is probably going to be this cycle's mortgage bubble? Considering car sales are falling off a cliff I guess we're in 2007 right now.
- dazc 9y agoOnly if people start losing their jobs in high numbers.
- pasquinelli 9y agoPeople might lose their job if their car gets repossessed.
- maxerickson 9y agoNo one buys a car expecting the value to go up so the vehicle market probably won't unravel in a collapse (vehicle debt is also about 1/10 the size of the mortgage market).
- djmobley 9y agoAt the high-end of the market, lots of people do, in fact, buy cars expecting them to appreciate in value. Manufacturers are increasingly offering limited edition cars to cater to this kind of investment.
- selectodude 9y agoYeah, nobody is financing Porsche 918s.
- cynicalbastard 9y agoyes they are. rich people get loans to buy expensive things instead of giving up the cash, often collateralized by their other toys/stock/trust fund/whatever. rich people also overspend, over-leverage, and overindulge just like everyone else. the difference is they call up their banker and accountant instead of filling out a form at the dealership. if you're expecting an asset like a 918 or 911RS or R to go up in price, you'd be stupid to not leverage your cash at a low interest rate and put the rest of it to work somewhere else. at this point it becomes a business move, not a trip to the mall. it's like financing a construction project. do you think they buy jets and yachts and big homes in cash also? of course not. they setup holding companies and finance the purchases, and then charter or rent the asset out to make some of the money back and to pay the crew of people that run these types of properties. that's why you can rent an amazing vacation home for $1k a night, or spend a few days on that yacht with a bunch of friends for $5k, or rent a ferrari for a few hundred bucks. rich people are exceptionally good at monetizing and leveraging facets of their life that look like giant expenditures to you or i. poor people try to emulate this behavior, and meet their financial ruin, because they aren't savvy or rich enough to make it work.
- dazc 9y agoPeople are buying cars they can't really afford because the monthly payments seem to be affordable. I think they know it's an expensive way to have a nice car but the alternative (because they don't have the capital) may be buying an old banger or having no car at all.
- loeg 9y agoThe article seems to be talking about short term (2-3 year) interest-only leases. There's a middle ground your comment hasn't mentioned. Instead of leasing or buying a used car, consumers can finance a new car (e.g. 5 year loan). It requires slightly higher monthly payments to cover the principal, and you can't switch cars as frequently, but you have ownership of the car (and freedom from payments) after the loan ends. I tend to think that buying used is a much better value, especially in areas that don't regularly salt their roads. But it's good to know about all available options.
- DanBC 9y ago> Instead of leasing or buying a used car, consumers can finance a new car (e.g. 5 year loan). It requires slightly higher monthly payments to cover the principal, and you can't switch cars as frequently, but you have ownership of the car (and freedom from payments) after the loan ends. Yes, and it's important to know that hire-purchase has existed in the UK for years as a method to buy cars, and this new product hasn't, and there's some confusion from the public about the type of product they're buying.
- usaphp 9y agoBut the main reason people get short term leases is so that they can switch cars often and drive a new car all the time. They don't want to deal with selling a car, fixing it, worrying about it losing value after accident, with short term lease you pay a premium for an option to drive a new car and less worry about things
- bsamuels 9y agohow does road salting affect the value of leasing versus financing a used car?
- watertorock 9y agoSounds a bit like mortgages circa 05
- EternalData 9y agoI liked the term "junk finance". There's a subset of financial products that are essentially the equivalent of going to McDonalds every day, and ordering a Big Mac to go.
- Shivetya 9y agoWhile car contracts can be unnecessarily confusing they are not the only opportunity for reform. Service contracts need simplification as well, whether your agreement for internet or cell service, to merely using one of the online streaming services. There is a lot of boiler plate in there that could be minimized with some good changes to the law. This story is UK based, is there no Truth In Lending type act to help simplify these contracts into terms people can readily understand? A recent car purchase I made in Georgia (US) was very easy to understand, all the numbers on one sheet.
- desas 9y agoUsually taking out finance and making some investment decisions requires that you are given a Key Facts Illustration, which looks roughly equivalent.
- evilDagmar 9y agoI was under the impression that the whole point of auto-financing was to get even even more money out of the consumer. When I bought my last car, I just bought it outright (because it wasn't particularly expensive) which appeared to baffle the dealership. I was actually a little concerned that the dealership told me it was the largest check they'd ever seen (for ~$14k). Getting people to sign off on a contract they don't really understand is a great way to get more money out of the consumer than they'd otherwise spend.
- endianswap 9y agoThat seems insane that it'd be the biggest check they've seen. I've bought an 80k BMW and an 80k Jaguar outright, and they both shrugged at me paying by check. BMW let me use a personal check, Jaguar wanted a bank check (easy enough). Edit: A normal down payment for a luxury car of any brand can easily be 20k up front.
- leeoniya 9y agodid you get the impression that the parent purchased a new luxury car at a dealership in Beverly Hills? :/
- GuiA 9y agoYou went to a BMW/Jaguar dealership, whereas OP most probably went to a smaller dealership aimed at a less affluent population.
- shados 9y agoThat heavily depends on where you go and the area. Not the same as a car, but when I went to get the check for the down payment on my home (which was 6 figures), I went to my bank which happened to be in a pretty upscale neighborhood were houses were significantly more expensive on average than what I was buying. So when I asked the teller to give me a multi-hundred-thousand dollar check, they didn't even blink. "Please enter your pin number sir. There you go sir, have a nice day". I assume this is very similar. A place selling BMWs is probably used to seeing newly minted millionaires on a daily basis.
- jacquesm 9y agoThis goes for many things outside of cars. Insurances, Mortgates, student debt, lottery tickets, consumer debt, credit cards and so on. In general people are sitting ducks when it comes to being fleeced by parties with a plan. I always wonder why schools don't even teach the beginnings of finance to everybody. You'd almost think there is a reason why it explicitly is not being taught.
- valuearb 9y agoThese products sell because people want them. They want low payments. They want to flip houses for massive gains in short periods. The facilitators aren't fleecing them as much as just meeting their needs. Anyone who tells you that you can't afford that car or that home prices won't appreciate to the sky tomorrow isn't going to get your business. And my school and my kids school teaches basic finance. No one ever remembers it because most kids aren't interested in it.
- bo1024 9y ago> The facilitators aren't fleecing them as much as just meeting their needs. That's a misleading statement, unless you replace "needs" with "wants".
- kerbalspacepro 9y agoI feel like the difference between "needs" and "wants" is an elementary distinction we make on a day-to-day basis. But when we're talking about firms and economics, the distinction does not exist except as labels for the amount of elasticity in demand something has.
- bo1024 9y ago...but, when we're talking about individual human beings, who may be misinformed and shortsighted, the distinction is pretty important.
- TrickyRick 9y ago
- PuffinBlue 9y agoMaybe I didn't understand the deal I bought a car with, or maybe it's an unusual deal, but I'm happy with it. My car costs me a set amount per month that I can afford, an amount that is actually equal to the monthly depreciation it would face anyway (on average) over a three year period (including the initial low value deposit I paid, this is still true). Even if I bought it outright, which I couldn't afford to do, I'd 'lose' the same amount of money _in total_ thanks to that depreciation. Effectively I'm 'renting' the car for the same 'cost' as owning it, just without the upfront payment. Further, GAP insurance purchased at a one off price of about £100 (which was far more tricky to make sure I got the correct thing) will cover any difference in the 'hand back' price at the end of my term and the value of the final payment. So basically if the car does depreciate below the value of the final payment then the GAP insurance will make up the difference. Likewise if I have an accident etc. I reject the idea that PCP deals are like 'buying and selling a series of homes using interest-only mortgages'. Cars lose value, always. Whether you buy it outright or not, it'll depreciate in value (save for some hyper rare beasts you aren't going to be buying on PCP anyway). But the article doesn't address this point at all as far as I can see and it's an important part of the value proposition of using these types of deal.
- pmuk 9y agoI agree. I helped my younger sister buy a car on a PCP recently, and I think they are actually a reasonable deal. It is my understanding that finance company guarantees the future value (GMFV) and that the final payment is optional, e.g. you can always hand the car back at the end of the term if it is worth less the the balloon payment.
- jacquesm 9y agoThat final payment combined with the trade-in value is structure such that the dealer is the only party that will give you a good price on the vehicle and you'll get a new car instead of buying out the old one.
- ZeroGravitas 9y ago
- MikeTaylor 9y agoThe two-step plan for effortlessly being better off than you otherwise would be (I won't say getting rich): 1. Buy the cheapest car you're OK with. 2. But the best house you can afford. This is simple. Cars (especially new cars) depreciate super-fast; and houses have appreciated at crazy rates at least for the last few decades. Don't put your money in a fancy car.
- kcanini 9y agoI thought house prices were relatively flat, on a long-term, inflation-adjusted basis. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Case%E2%80%93Shiller_index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Case%E2%80%93Shiller_index
- davidshepherd7 9y agoIt depends on the country, in the UK (which this article is about) prices have been increasing above inflation for years. http://landregistry.data.gov.uk/app/ukhpi/explore http://landregistry.data.gov.uk/app/ukhpi/explore
- sunstone 9y agoI bought a prius recently and where they were hoping to make the money was on the extended warranty. I demurred on that so I got a 3 year 0% lease. In addition when you consider the prius' high gas mileage, low maintenance, high lifetime (over 500k miles) and high resale value it's a great deal if you're planning on driving quite a bit.
- no_wizard 9y agoI don't think that this would be as large scale an issue in the United States at least if public transportation was as good as say, Japan's. That would put a lot of pressure on the industry indirectly to be more transparent to the average consumer. I would think anyway. I don't have anything except anecdotal evidence and a gut feeling to back this up. I think car ownership being needed outside the major 12 cities (Lookin' at you NYC!) that have good public transit is a national crime in and of itself.
- wnevets 9y agoObligatory john oliver episode on the subject https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4U2eDJnwz_s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4U2eDJnwz_s
- forinti 9y agoWhich is why contracts should include warnings, as Senator Elizabeth Warren proposed. Dangerous equipment should have warnings so that you don't lose your fingers and financial tools should have warnings so that you don't lose your shirt. A decade ago I bought a Fiat (in Brazil) and was offered financing at 0,99% a month. This was worth it, as fixed income investments were paying more than 1% a month. Except that the administrative fees made the effective rate something like 1,99% (which was not worth it). The salesperson argued that I could pay the fees in installments too. It made me angry that they are allowed to do this to people who can't do the maths.
- tnecniv 9y ago> Which is why contracts should include warnings, as Senator Elizabeth Warren proposed. How would this work? Isn't the contract itself supposed to be the warning? Obviously contracts can contain a lot of legalese and potentially unenforceable language that makes them difficult for most people to interpret, but that language is also necessary to specify the contract at the level of detail the law requires. If you require a warning for the contract, how do you ensure that the warning is sufficiently authentic?
- rsynnott 9y agoIn Ireland, mortgage offers at least have to have plain-English warnings, illustrations of the numbers involved in paying it off, etc. Never got a PCP, but I assume it's similar. The problem is, people don't read them. To be useful, you'd arguably need to give the borrower an exam in what they're signing (which might be a good approach). PCPs, in particular, are complex as far as consumer finance goes, and a lot of people seem to sign them thinking they're a normal loan. An analogy seem to be the (now thankfully almost obsolete) endowment mortgages, where you took out an interest-only mortgage coupled with an investment product which was theoretically meant to pay off the principal on maturity. These ran into difficulty when inflation dropped to practically zero for a decade, and lots of people who had them thought they just had repayment mortgages...
- ghufran_syed 9y agoI feel like there is a natural tension between adults having the right to make their own decisions, and 'protecting' them from making bad decisions. Maybe what we need is a two-part market for financial services, a tightly regulated one where only regulator-approved, simple products can be sold, and one with much looser regulation, but that only those consumers willing to take a financial literacy exam are eligible for (with the financial firm being responsible for checking, and contracts being void if sold to unqualified buyers). After all, even brokers and traders have to take an exam before they are allowed to trade more complicated financial instruments (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Series_7_exam https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Series_7_exam). We also don't allow people to drive a car without proving they can do so reasonably safely. The public could reasonably assume that the government might provide guarantees for products in the first group, in the way they do for bank accounts. Products in the second group would explicitly be excluded from any government guarantee - if you passed the exam, and want to risk your own money, totally up to you, but don't come expecting your fellow citizens to bail you out if things go terribly wrong later. So for example, interest-only home mortgages are almost always a bad choice for most consumers, so they would probably be in the second group. So you could still get them if you really wanted one, but you would have to prove you knew what you were doing, and were willing to give up any hope of a government bailout.
- mynameishere 9y agointerest-only home mortgages are almost always a bad choice for most consumers Just for future reference, if anyone lets you make an infinitely leveraged 500,000 dollar bet that you can walk away from at any time, you take that bet.
- CamTin 9y agoOn the other hand, if someone offers to let you make an infinitely leveraged 500,000 dollar bet that you can walk away from at any time provided you are OK with the consequence of being unable to access another mortgage loan or to rent (because of outstanding housing debt), then probably don't take that bet.
- lxmorj 9y agoHeadline has too many words. Feel free to remove "cars using"
- cperciva 9y agoTechnically people are selling financial products they don't understand.
- andrewflnr 9y agoThe bit about banning complex contracts is funny, especially contrasted with the alternative of having machine readable versions. My guess is that a machine readable format sufficient to express all the complexities of these contracts, especially conditional payments, is going to be Turing-complete, or pretty close to it. Anyway, it's going to be really hard to do that third-party comparison. The obvious solution is to only allow contracts that can be analyzed in some tractable logical framework... but limiting complexity is where we started.
- lacampbell 9y agoThe idea of not paying cash for a car is insane to me. A could justify a loan for a house, or even an education. But a car?! I just don't even understand this mindset.
- NTDF9 9y agoI got it at a time when I was just out of college with only $6000 in my account...so yeah, people like me need financing.
- draw_down 9y agoI noticed that the people saying this type of financing is a good deal, were comparing it against just buying a new car outright. But, you don't have to buy a new car.
- awqrre 9y agothat is not the biggest problem in the way we buy cars...
- aiyodev 9y agoI can't believe the car bubble isn't a bigger story. I know a waitress who is single, can barely afford an apartment, can't afford internet service, and who just financed a brand new Jeep. This reckless lending is setting the country up for catastrophe. The next economic downturn will cause people to lose their homes and their cars.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cperciva 9y agoI'm not familiar with this particular structure, but it sounds like the sequence of cash flows are: 1. Customer receives car. 2. Customer pays monthly amount based on the prevailing interest rate and predicted depreciation of the car. 3. Customer returns car after X years, at which time the depreciated value of the car along with the payments they've made pays for the car they received X years earlier. Can someone explain to me how this is functionally different from a fixed-term lease?
- dazc 9y agoThe traditional way of financing a car purchase in the UK is a hire purchase agreement where a large deposit (usually half the value of the car) is paid upfront. This can be cash but is often covered by the part exchange value of the customer's existing car. At the end of the term the customer owns the car outright. And, from the outset, he has some equity in the car by means of the large deposit. The author of the article is talking about contract hire schemes where there is a monthly payment but, crucially, the deposit required is often only 2 or 3 months advance rental. At the end of the term the customer owns nothing and can be liable for minor damage. The contracts also can have a mileage restriction which is well below average. So, sure, it's no different to a fixed term lease. These have been widely available to businesses for some time in the UK. The change is that offering these deals to the general public has now become much more common. The author is suggesting that people are not sufficiently financially sophisticated to understand the implications of this arrangement if their circumstances change unexpectedly. I disagree. I think most people know what they are getting into but now they have the opportunity to drive a new car they would never have been able to afford otherwise any concerns are put to the back of their mind.
- jychang 9y agoIs the lack of car leases a UK-only thing, then? In the USA, car leases are extremely common. People understand that they have to return the car after the lease. Hell, even the common advice given is "buy a Toyota, lease a BMW" where the assumption is that consumers should buy reliable cars like Toyotas, whereas BMWs/Mercedes/etc that come with more reliability issues after the warranty period should merely be leased.
- hartror 9y agoTim Harford does a fantastic podcast called 50 things that made the modern economy. It is some of the usual suspects but mostly things you would not have considered before. Highly recommended. http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p04b1g3c/episodes/player http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p04b1g3c/episodes/player
- Pica_soO 9y agoMy aunt lectures at a nursing and hospital-school. Many of her pupils are stuck in the "Car"-Deal. They all leased or lend a expensive car to show off, got into accidents or expensive repairs, could not pay off the accumulating debt, and now are basically indentured in debt-slavery to the car industry with half of their monthly paycheck.
- pzh 9y agoI thought full insurance would be an unwaivable requirement in those cases of leasing. How could they be in debt for accidents?
- buro9 9y agoIn the UK a new car purchase/lease requires comprehensive insurance for the duration of the lease. Only after the lease has expired and you've purchased could you opt for 3rd party, fire and theft insurance. The maximum exposure during the period of a lease is whatever the excess on the policy is. The GP comment can't be applicable to the UK.
- Pica_soO 9y agoMost people dont know, but insurances regularly wriggle themselves out of anti-debt-insurance that are usually sold with leasing contracts.
- buro9 9y agoIn the UK this does not happen. You are required to get your own fully comprehensive insurance, and can select from the whole market. The vehicle will not be released to you from the car dealership without proof that you possess such insurance. Please declare which country you are talking about, as the article described the UK and your claims are not true with regard to the UK.
- sugarrush 9y ago
- caub 9y ago"Too many people are buying cars" simply
- Twisell 9y agoIsn't the European version of the APR exactly designed to overcome that problem? (It's mandatory for every loan in the European Union) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annual_percentage_rate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annual_percentage_rate
- alkonaut 9y agoIt's very good for the loan part of the equation, but it's still often hard to compare lease plans when the depreciation etc is factored in. After all, some kind of unknown valuation of the condition of the car will happen after N years and it's nearly impossible to know beforehand what cost that will incur.