14 ms·
I love the way he's compared the people who tell you to turn off auto-updates with anti-vaxxers; it's quite an apt analogy. Microsoft shares part of the blame
by CydeWeys 10y ago
I love the way he's compared the people who tell you to turn off auto-updates with anti-vaxxers; it's quite an apt analogy.
Microsoft shares part of the blame here for pushing features that the user clearly doesn't want through updates (especially to the major OS version). Look at the recent ads in Windows file explorer for one example. A lot of the advice to turn Windows Update off is a misguided response to Microsoft's own bone-headed moves in recent years to install bullshit that the user doesn't want.
I still sort of regret installing Windows 10 to this day because of the obnoxious Cortana bar it foisted upon my start menu that I can't get rid of. And yet not installing Windows 10 would've left me less secure with an OS hitting EOL for security updates much sooner.
Microsoft definitely shares some of the blame for this precisely because they have automatically "opted in" their users to stuff they don't want during past updates. Stop the bullshit, Microsoft.
- vezycash 10y agoYou can remove the Cortana bar.
- xg15 10y agoBy removing all kinds of search, yes.
- nisa 10y agoNo. You can still have local search. Unfortunatly this seems to only possible with a GPO rule.
- CydeWeys 10y agoYeah, see, I don't even know what a GPO rule is, and I'm more technically inclined than 99% of the users out there. I'm sure there are some people that can totally customize Windows 10 to their liking and get rid of all of the anti-user stuff, but it's such a small proportion of the overall home userbase as to be statistically insignificant.
- Asooka 10y agoI don't feel it's quite an apt analogy, since anti-vaxxers have fully imaginary fears of adverse consequences (vaccines causing autism), while people who disable windows update do it after suffering real adverse consequences of forced updates. A good firewall would protect from WanaCrypt and everything else distributed via opening SMB ports on random IPs over the internet (correct me if I'm wrong), so you should be safe even if you've disabled Windows Update for a legitimate reason. A legitimate reason like "this Windows runs on a medical/factory/etc. device that CANNOT go offline to install updates willy-nilly".
- pawadu 10y ago> A good firewall would protect from WanaCrypt The attack could come from the internal network (it spreads first via email). Also, don't forget the upnp shenanigans
- mseebach 10y ago> A good firewall would protect from WanaCrypt No, unfortunately not - it spread using SMB internally on LANs, but travelled internet-to-LAN by "regular" phishing. It downloads its payload off the internet, but most good firewall would allow that (was the WannaCry payload detectable by virus scanners at the time of the infection? A "good" firewall might be one expected to intercept and scan all downloads). > A legitimate reason like "this Windows runs on a medical/factory/etc. device that CANNOT go offline to install updates willy-nilly". "Cannot go offline" implies that it's operationally critical. If you operate such devices, it is an absolute imperative that you have a procedure for taking them offline regularly for updates (not "willy-nilly" and anyone using that word about running a two-year out of date OS on a critical device is objectively not qualified to run them - and anyone buying such a device that can't be upgraded isn't qualified to buy them (and anyone making such a device...)).
- Silhouette 10y agoIf you operate such devices, it is an absolute imperative that you have a procedure for taking them offline regularly for updates In some contexts that simply isn't a viable strategy. As an extreme example, consider something like an implanted medical device that needs to run 24/7 for the rest of a person's life, which can only be replaced via surgery under hospital conditions, and for which any failure is already a life-threatening event. Of course that kind of device probably isn't going to be running an OS like Windows, but it makes the point. In fact, the USSS has reportedly had the standard wireless update facility disabled in such devices for prominent public figures who might be at risk of being attacked that way. Some equipment used in hospitals or to run other essential infrastructure might be within the realms of running a "normal" OS like Windows but still be in a position where any time out of service is extremely expensive in one way or another, so routinely disrupting operation to apply updates still isn't acceptable. There are also contexts where the device is regulated and making any change at all requires re-approval -- a legitimate and serious conflict when faced with this kind of security risk if the situation when a regulated device goes out of spec can also be serious. You need different security strategies for this kind of environment, which rely more on external controls. You can't just say everything must be able to come out of service at frequent intervals for security updates, and you can't just handwash the problem away by calling people who understand the issues "unqualified". It's a far more complicated problem than that, and often there are no completely satisfactory arrangements.
- eiji 10y agoTaskbar > Context menu > Cortana > ( Hidden / Show icon / Show search box )
- capitalF 10y agoA better option is to open "gpedit.msc", then open "Local Computer Policy -> Computer Configuration -> Administrative Templates -> Windows Components" Then spend an afternoon going through each option, setting enabled/disabled for everything you don't want or don't recognize. You can easily disable entire subsystems like Cortana, tips, telemetry, camera, biometrics, error reporting, games, Homegroup, Defender, Windows Store, and a whole bunch of other garbage.
- thro1111111 10y agoDo they stay deactivated even after updates?
- mattmanser 10y agoYes, because they're intended for corporate IT to use.
- saiya-jin 10y agolast time I checked with people suffering from Windows 10, the shit still keeps annoying them, even after all is disabled. something changed on that front?
- fwn 10y agoCrudely, gpedit.msc needs to be installed by hand in the home version of windows 10. So, this should work - but only in the pro Version.
- Mithaldu 10y agoWhich is priced the same as the home version if you buy it via other vendors.
- nugget 10y agoThe cleverest move was to integrate Cortana with local file and application search, which many users likely use as a universal command line/shortcut (hit windows key and just start typing). I find that when I disable Cortana, local search becomes severely degraded. If anyone has any tips on how to fix this, I'd appreciate them.
- brainfire 10y agoWhat do you mean by "degraded"? Does anyone else have this problem?
- emodendroket 10y agoI never noticed.
- phr4ts 10y agoThe degradation is intentional. In Windows phone, speech to text and quiet hours doesn't work, and the accuracy of shape writing is significantly reduced, when Cortana is switched off. Ms is trying to turn Cortana into the Google play services of Windows So they can consensually(forcefully) collect data from every windows device.
- Tarean 10y agoI'd guess that means speech to text and shape writing run at least partially on servers? Not hugely surprising but it seems really bizarre that quiet hours would need it. Probably some integration with cortanas contact database so that some people's messages come through? Even that seems incredibly lazy and ill thought out.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoThere's no need to guess, at least in the PC version of Windows 10 Microsoft explicitly says this is the case. No one should be surprised that this is the case for Windows, given that other speech/shape recognition is similarly degraded with cloud support turned off.
- noja 10y ago> I love the way he's compared the people who tell you to turn off auto-updates with anti-vaxxers; it's quite an apt analogy. This is a good analogy, but does it work in different circumstances? (Apologies for the derail) Over on Android, the apps have got so big (and the storage was until recently so small) that automatic updates _cannot_ be installed - the new apps are too big, the phone is full. What do we do then?
- yorwba 10y agoIn my case, buy a large SD card to put the apps on, then find out that only the primary storage can hold apps. I think this limitation has been lifted in more recent Android versions, but - of course - I can't upgrade. Moving all my photos and ebook .pdfs off did alleviate the burden somewhat, but hasn't completely solved it. My current workaround for very large apps is to uninstall, redownload, install. Apparently, holding both the update and the installed app uses much more space than doing a fresh install.
- majewsky 10y agoAlternatively, buy an SD card, then notice that your phone does not have an SD card slot.
- digi_owl 10y agoBest i can tell, what Android does is download a delta patch. Then apply that to a local copy of the previous APK. If that goes well, it attempts to install the new APK alongside the old install. And if that works out, the user data is switched over and the old install and APK removed. So at certain points during the install you need to have enough space for two full installs of the app, and the APKs they came in.
- vetinari 10y agoSony has fairly unique system: Install an app, move it to the SD card, the update will install it back to internal memory. You have to move it again, manually. And again, and again, after each update. Or just leave them all on the internal system, until a system utility wakes up to the fact that there is not enough space, and suggest moving apps to the sdcard. After few rounds of updates, rinse and repeat.
- torrent-of-ions 10y agoAlso for forcing restarts for everything. Back when I cared I needed to I used to use ksplice to patch linux without rebooting. If Microsoft made something like this it would stop people switching off the updates.
- masklinn 10y ago> Also for forcing restarts for everything. And not restoring jack shit. I wouldn't mind Windows Update so much if it could competently restart my applications and restore my Explorer windows, but the only thing it does every fucking time is make the taskbar icons disappear until I force-restart the Explorer process. Though I would still mind it a lot for the insanely slow and unhelpful update process at shutdown, every update requires half an hour of shutdown as the machine does who the fuck knows what with an unhelpful throbber telling you it's at 30% of some arbitrary process you've no idea about and which looks exactly as if the entire thing had crashed.
- parrellel 10y agoGod, it's even worse for academic / engineering use. Nothing is better than running a simulation for twenty hours and waking up to a nice blank desktop. /s
- CydeWeys 10y agoWow, yeah, that'd be a nightmare. I hadn't even considered that use case. I was just thinking of typical desktop use cases. In a similar vein, imagine that you're ill-advisedly using a Windows server to host your node for cryptocurrency mining, and then it restarts when you're not around. You could lose serious amounts of money from that.
- torrent-of-ions 10y agoWhy are you even using Windows for this?
- 9y ago
- sangnoir 10y ago> Microsoft shares part of the blame here for pushing features that the user clearly doesn't want through updates (especially to the major OS version). Look at the recent ads in Windows file explorer for one example. A lot of the advice to turn Windows Update off is a misguided response to Microsoft's own bone-headed moves in recent years to install bullshit that the user doesn't want. Vaccinations are awesome, but Microsoft's heavy-handed bundling is similar to how the CIA was using vaccinations as cover to collect DNA[1] samples in Pakistan. This inadvertently led to a distrust of vaccinations[2] which harmed the efforts to eradicate Polio (or biological WCry, if you will). Additionally, Microsoft abused the update system to download an entire, multi-GB OS (Windows 10) on systems running on Windows 8, "just in case they will want to upgrade". This was very expensive for people on metered bandwidth. Microsoft should separate critical updates from the less critical ones and give users the ability to opt-in for critical updates only. 1. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/jul/11/cia-fake-vaccinations-osama-bin-ladens-dna https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/jul/11/cia-fake-vacci... 2. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/10/health/cia-vaccine-ruse-in-pakistan-may-have-harmed-polio-fight.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/10/health/cia-vaccine-ruse-in...
- belorn 10y agoIf we look in the past we also have snake oil which is said to be a major cause for mistrust for doctors and medicine. Government had to step in and issue regulations in order for the public to regain trust and vaccinations is one of the very few remaining trust issues between the public and medicine. If we want people to regain trust in auto-update there need to be something that prevent abuse. If that is regulations, liability laws, or just industry practice will be up to the future to decide. Until then a person will have to rational decide on auto-update as past people did with the uncertainty of not know what is snake oil and what is real.
- nonbel 10y ago>"Until then a person will have to rational decide on auto-update as past people did with the uncertainty of not know what is snake oil and what is real." You are far too confident in current medical practice.
- keldaris 10y agoPersonally, I run a single Win10 desktop (all of my laptops are Linux-only) that I update roughly annually, by allocating an entire day for going through the updates one by one and getting rid of any Microsoft malware along the way. I am far more concerned about Microsoft's own malware than any ransomware floating around the Internet. Of course, I've also had SMBv1 disabled for many years (there's no reason to retain support for it unless you need to support WinXP machines, in which case you have my condolences), the desktop sits on an isolated subnet with a very restrictive router and firewall in front of it and all telemetry, Cortana and other malware has been eviscerated via group policy and other settings, along with router-level blocking of telemetry and update servers. I fully understand that my case is atypical and the average user isn't going to follow comparable precautions, so I don't actively recommend my approach to anyone else, but it works great for me. Apart from wasting about a day per year on maintenance, I'm as happy with the OS itself as I've ever been with any Windows version, and it fulfills my Windows development and occasional gaming needs just fine. Obviously, I'm much less happy with Microsoft as a company for forcing me to go through such lengths to make their OS into something I'm comfortable using.
- nu5500 10y agoReally? You're more concerned about the software being provided to you by Microsoft, who is at least presumably trying to keep you as a satisfied customer and provide a secure operating system then you are for faceless hackers connected to the Internet who's whole objective is to either out right steal people's money, disrupt people's lives, or else subvert your computer in order to launch attacks on other users?
- kwhitefoot 10y ago> Microsoft, who is at least presumably trying to keep you as a satisfied customer You surely jest! Individual users are not customers of Microsoft in any meaningful sense. Microsoft sells the OS mostly to companies who install it on machines so that the end user buys a computer with Windows already installed. If MS wanted to keep me as a customer they would have provided a proper upgrade path for all the millions of lines of VB6 code that are out there and they would create an IDE that has a usable editor.
- bigbugbag 10y agoThe anti-vaxxers analogy is utter nonsense and reads like a poor attempt at hitting the credibility of people disabling windows update. The anti-vaxxer movement makes no sense outside the backfire effect, in almost all cases it has little to no basis or justifications. On the other hand there is a long history of very valid reasons of distrusting windows update and disabling it. Using windows update to force people into windows 10 is only one of the most recent examples that windows update is by Microsoft and for the interest of Microsoft not the user. This is totally different from the system update you have with apt and Debian.
- throwaway2048 10y agoId say the comparison would actually make sense if vaccines DID give you autism.
- a2decrow 10y agoBut they don't. Autism is the product of having a differently wired brain than a non-autist does. It's something you're born with, not something you can get later. Certain medications used by pregnant women can result in children being autistic, but I seriously doubt that this extends to any vaccines as well. Perhaps some really exotic ones maybe, but common vaccination definitely not. Source: I am autistic, read up on it to be able to better deal with it and am dealing with it on a daily basis. And truth be told, I don't know if I'd be better or worse off without it. It doesn't make my life unlivable and I guess the understanding of autism of most people is too much based on rumor-mongering and hearsay, than any actual facts.
- ebiester 10y agoThat's a mistranslation of the above post. The poster intended to say that Microsoft's updates can be legitimately harmful whereas modern vaccines aren't.
- a2decrow 10y agoThanks for pointing it out. It's one of the downsides of autism that understanding the intent of other people can be hard or impossible, so I'm always grateful for hints like that.
- atemerev 10y ago> I love the way he's compared the people who tell you to turn off auto-updates with anti-vaxxers; it's quite an apt analogy. No, it isn't. Anti-vaxxers think that vaccines are harmful (or useless). Most users think security updates are important, they just don't want to be interrupted.
- _pmf_ 10y ago> Anti-vaxxers think that vaccines are harmful (or useless). Vaccines are harmful; it's just that the positive effects vastly shadow the negative effects in the general case.
- atemerev 10y agoYou are technically correct (everything is harmful, and vaccine application is probably associated with some amount of micromorts — but so is, say, getting up from the bed). However, vaccines are very safe (safer than many everyday activities), and negate much more micromorts. Thus, I believe that your technically correct appeal doesn't contribute anything useful to this particular discussion.
- saiya-jin 10y agoIn same vein of logic, neither does yours. People who have these comments in discussions with hundreds of posts must have either bad day or some deeper issues. Had a colleague, he took a rabies shot (X-th in his life) and got 1:3,000,000 strong reaction from which he directly died. Feel free to explain to his small kid some micromorts crap. FYI it didn't change my opinion on vaccines, fiancee is a doctor and keeps me updated on usual stuff (tetanus, tick-transmitted stuff, hep a+b and some odd stuff if required for vacations). But it makes you think how rare those reactions really are.
- oneeyedpigeon 10y agoDoes Windows classify updates as bug-fix, security-patch, feature-update and allow different policies to be set for each? Because it seems like that might help.
- Silhouette 10y agoThey used to. Now all you can get on the 7/8 generations without jumping through hoops is a "monthly roll-up" that includes both security and other updates mixed together. To do otherwise, you either need to turn off updates altogether and download and install the ones you want manually, or you need to be in a managed environment that does something similar via centralised deployment. Windows 10 goes a step further and is intended to push all updates to non-managed systems whether you want them or not. This is why the anti-vaxxer analogy is foolish and frankly rather offensive. Managing updates is about risk, and the risk from Microsoft screwing up your entire system with updates was demonstrably very high before. For example, anyone who was using the default settings to trust Microsoft's suggested updates got changed automatically to an entirely new OS not so long ago -- a new OS, incidentally, which has also had compatibility problems with various hardware, which also has significant privacy concerns particularly in places like doctors' surgeries or other environments managing sensitive information, and which is also infamous for disrupting normal day-to-day work by changing things and/or rebooting at undesired times. I know plenty of smart, well-informed people who work in IT and made an active decision to reduce or disable updates on some of their Windows systems for these kinds of reasons. Whether they would have advised home users with no technical knowledge to turn updates off completely is a different question, but it's not an entirely unreasonable policy given Microsoft's recent track record of abusing automatic update processes.
- developer2 10y ago>> Microsoft shares part of the blame here for pushing... the major OS version Microsoft lost every single ounce of credibility with the way they force-loaded Windows 10. Turning off Windows Update isn't enough anymore. The only solution is to dump Windows. Install Linux, or buy Apple hardware. It's unfortunate, but Microsoft will never recoup the trust it lost with the push of Windows 10. Microsoft cannot be trusted.
- Shorel 10y agoHistorically that's one of the least anti-customer things MS has done. We old timers remember worse.
- vocatus_gate 10y agoNo. "Some of the blame"? Try "all of the blame." Windows Updates used to be pro-user. Now they're pro-Microsoft (pushing things Microsoft wants) and anti-user (routinely pushing 'features' no one wants or asked for). I disabled it a long time ago and haven't looked back. Get back to me when MS starts remembering their customers are human beings again.
- danielbln 10y agoLast year my Windows 10 box decided to just restart to apply updates. Problem is, I was still using the machine and was strapped into VR gear. Suffice to say I was not pleased.
- josefx 10y ago"pro user" is an interesting way to put it. If I remember correctly it was heavily integrated with IE in the past to push browser share. Want to update your system? Open buggy old IE5/6. Want to get rid of IE? What antitrust? IE is part of essential Windows functionality after all, we can't get rid of it. > Get back to me when MS starts remembering their customers are human beings again. Oh, they know. Their whole abusive process is build around milking that fact for all it is worth.
- Qwertious 10y agoThe comment said Windows update was pro-user, not Microsoft.
- josefx 10y agoWell we can argue wether a knife is pro or con user when Microsoft stabs said user in the back with it. Microsoft would say that it provides a secure (tm) resting place for the users hat and is not only very pro-user in doing so but also important for the continous operation of said hat. My point is just that, Microsoft used Windows Update to push unwanted software in the past and as such Windows Update was never entirely a pro-user software, something always undermined by Microsofts willingness to put its own goals above its users needs.
- MikusR 10y agoAds in explorer in a sense as Ads in Firefox. If you navigate to Onedrive in explorer you get information that it's a service you can get more storage for.
- jakub_g 10y agoIt would also help if Windows 10 didn't restart the machine automatically in the least favourable time, when you just went to make yourself a tea while having a zillion of programs opened, and the process didn't end up with a blue screen (both happened to me in the last few months; ok ok they allow now to choose "inactive hours" or whatever it's called, but initially you had a choice between "restart now" or "restart in 10 minutes", really dark pattern to impose things on users). But yeah I get a notif when the update is available and I install it whenever possible. Regarding unwanted features, have you tried Classic Shell / Classic Start Menu? Literally first thing I install on a new Windows installation.
- Posibyte 10y agoThis is the main reason I highly considered turning off updates as well. Twice in the last year I've had to go on-call for work to fix a critical issue some point in the late evening for Windows 10 to close all my programs, progress unsaved, without warning and spend several minutes (half an hour on one of them) doing updates. At that point, Windows 10 became a liability, and that laptop still doesn't have automatic updates turned on anymore. (It still gets routine manual updates, but it's definitely not ideal.)
- mtgx 10y agoYes. Don't tell people to not use Windows updates. That's bad advice from a security point of view. Tell them to not use Windows, period. That's (typically) good advice from a security point of view (of course you still have to install updates on other other operating systems.)
- leifus 10y agoWindows Registry Editor Version 5.00 [HKEY_CURRENT_USER\SOFTWARE\Policies\Microsoft\Windows\Windows Search] "AllowCortana"=dword:00000000
- pfarnsworth 10y agoI turned off Windows Update precisely because it tried to force and trick me into upgrading to Windows 10. This is their fault for making people distrust what Windows Update should be, and whoever made that decisions at Microsoft should get fired.
- ak39 10y agoSame story here. :-(
- rsync 10y ago"I still sort of regret installing Windows 10 to this day because of the obnoxious Cortana bar it foisted upon my start menu that I can't get rid of. And yet not installing Windows 10 would've left me less secure with an OS hitting EOL for security updates much sooner." Running an MS OS has been a one-way ticket to owned for roughly 18 years now.[1] You are fragile to these things because you choose to be - not because this is a necessary condition of participating on computer networks. This ransomware attack was based on an SMB vuln. One of the stuxnet vectors was an autorun vuln.[2] Would you wake the fuck up and see that it is 2017 and you're getting owned by SMB and autorun vulns ? [1] Melissa virus was 1999, BO2k was 2000. [2] Has any single file caused more mayhem in the world than autorun.inf ? The net negative effect of autorun.inf on the world must be in the tens of billions of dollars by now.
- helthanatos 10y agoYou can make the Cortana bar disappear
- marcosdumay 10y agoWould you still have the same opinion on anti-vaxxers if vaccines were actually harmful? We avoid taking a big amount of medication that would fix some problem just because it's harmful (and even medication that is less worse than the disease).
- BrandoElFollito 10y agoTry installing Classic Shell. Brings back a sensible start menu without Cortana et al.