8 ms·
Naked mole rats can survive 18 minutes without oxygen
- siddharthgoel88 10y agoWhy do people do such things or even talk about such stuff? This is so depressing that such experiments are conducted to just know the fact how long a rat can survive :(
- markholmes 10y agoNo kidding. What a sad experiment, to deprive an animal of oxygen and see how long until it stops breathing.
- gambiting 10y agoMaybe you missed the part where they say that these animals naturally live in oxygen-deprived environment in their nests? They stop breathing because they evolved to do so in those situations. Would you say it's sad to freeze carp to see at what point they stop breathing, even though carps naturally do that every winter?
- nkrisc 10y agoWhat would be an alternative way to learn this that would be more acceptable to you?
- Cyph0n 10y agoThe state of medicine today is built on top of similar experiments. Countless people -- yes, people, not just animals -- have died for us to discover so much about the human body and its inner workings. It's unfortunate that most people are either oblivious to this fact, or simply take the immense work going on behind the scenes for granted. Keep this in mind next time you visit the hospital ;) Performing this experiment could have far-reaching implications. Perhaps it ends up helping scientists understand whether or not such an adaptation could transfer to humans. Or maybe it ends up being crucial in helping us understand the function of a seemingly unrelated process in the human body. It's important to note that ethics committees nowadays are extremely strict when it comes to using live subjects, humans or otherwise, so rest assured that the experimenters did their best to minimize the suffering of the rats. If they didn't, their work would probably never be accepted for funding and/or publication.
- marricks 10y agoWhen you talk about people dying for science is it Marie Curie and the radiation poisoning, or Nazi's testing hypothermia? One is someone boldly (of her own volition) pushing the bounds of science, the other is an oppressive group performing horrendous experiments. Perhaps cancer patients on the verge of death opting for a potentially life extending drug? When humans test on humans (in modern societies where things haven't gone horribly awry), care is given as to whether it's safe for the individual and would help them. Consent is a big word you'd never hear in an animal study. Animal testing is weighed against what benefits "science" in some way and some sort of "unnecessarily cruel" metric which doesn't seem to account for much. Anecdotally, my girl friend is a neuroscientist and has heard about things going on in labs that would make your skin crawl. One study that came to mind is on rats defending their territory based on how much food they were given, led to rats basically ripping each-other apart on camera. We say these things are okay, and important, but when I think that almost 13,000 animals were killed, beagles, cats, monkeys, rats, just so we could have splenda, I think that whatever we value non-human life at must be so trivially small.
- Cyph0n 10y agoWhat I had in mind were the people who volunteered for experimental medical procedures. Transplants, blood transfusions, neurosurgery, skin grafts, etc. The techniques were only perfected through the suffering and death of a vast number of nameless people. > Animal testing is weighed against what benefits us in even the slightest way and is some sort of "unnecessarily cruel" metric. > We say these things are okay, and important, but when I think that almost 13,000 animals were killed, beagles, cats, monkeys, rats, just so we could have splenda, I think that whatever we value non-human life at must be so trivially small. That is a deeply philosophical argument. We can obviously agree that -- all things being equal -- a human's life is worth more than an animal's life. But exactly how much more valuable is it? Can we accurately quantify how many mice can die so one human can live? Does it depend on the animal and its intelligence, at least as we perceive it? The questions can go on and on with no end in sight. Now, I'm honestly not intimately familiar with what goes in the life sciences, particularly when it comes to experimenting on live subjects. Nonetheless, I am convinced that modern ethical standards are a good way to set universal limits to what can be done to animals in a laboratory setting, while also ensuring that we as humans benefit from the results. The alternatives would be either to delay the discovery of new procedures because we don't want to hurt animals, or to just experiment on humans directly. Neither of these sounds like a better option to me.
- maturz 10y agoI thought the egg-laying, duck-billed, beaver-tailed, otter-footed, electrorecepting, venomous platypus was the strangest mammal.
- slazaro 10y agoNaked mole rats are very interesting, if I remember correctly, they behave just like social insects (bees, termites, ants, etc.) in many ways, but they're mammals.
- Prego 10y agoChris Angel?
- dhc02 10y agoCan't some whales go hours? I mean these guys are still strange, but this headline is terrible.
- kej 10y agoYeah, sperm whales can do 90 minutes and the longest recorded beaked whale dive is over two hours. Heck, the human record is something like 20 minutes, by some free diver.
- ddeck 10y agoTo clarify, the static apnea record breathing normal air beforehand is just under 12 minutes. The record you are referring to involves breathing pure oxygen beforehand, is 24 minutes, and is nonetheless amazing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Static_apnea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Static_apnea I'd always thought the egg laying, electrolocating Platypus was the strangest mammal: "The platypus feeds by neither sight nor smell, closing its eyes, ears, and nose each time it dives. Rather, when it digs in the bottom of streams with its bill, its electroreceptors detect tiny electric currents generated by muscular contractions of its prey" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platypus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platypus
- daxfohl 10y agoFWIW geckos need quantum mechanics just to walk.
- stickfigure 10y ago...and I, for one, welcome our new platypus-gecko hybrid overlords!
- kakarot 10y agoDon't sharks do this, too?
- 10y ago
- Proven 10y agoNice job for sadists (I mean the lab people)
- nouveau0 10y agoDo they have to be naked for this?
- stevenwoo 10y agoCan someone explain how the mole rats that stop breathing and are revived after simply reintroducing oxygen into the container? How does the O2 get into the animals lungs/blood stream if the animal stopped breathing?
- Someone 10y agoThey stop breathing, but don't die. Presumably, when whatever mechanism they use to measure oxygen concentration tells them that oxygen levels are high enough, they start breathing again.
- ralfd 10y agoYes, obviously, but parent asked how!
- BugsJustFindMe 10y agoOne guess would be sufficiently positive air pressure to passively inflate their lungs. Or that they don't stop breathing completely, just almost.
- amelius 10y agoGuess: diffusion?
- tkyjonathan 10y agoHumans are gonna need this soon with how climate change is going..
- agumonkey 10y agoUh weird, they survive through glucose metabolysm instead of the aerobic pathway.. which is exactly what cancer cells do to operate with their bad blood supply. NM rats are cancer free yet live like one.
- nolok 10y ago> NM rats are cancer free yet live like one. Well you know what they say; if you can't beat them, join them.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoRegarding the set of things that look like cancer, I recently realized that human hair is quite like cancer. It just grows and grows and grows, seemingly without limit. So are the fingernails.
- Sharlin 10y agoBut hair and fingernails are not alive. They are just extrusions of dead material. 3D printing, basically. Plus all hair has a growth limit after which it's discarded. Head hair of course has a longer limit than other hair.
- agumonkey 10y agoThey don't degenerate, translocate or interfere negatively (although they can curl to the point of biting back). Also these cell don't adapt.
- BugsJustFindMe 10y agoI guess this is kinda cool, but you have to look past the headline. 18 minutes without oxygen isn't far-fetched for humans. The Guinness world record for "longest time breath held voluntarily (male)" is a bit over 24 minutes. So, yeah, that line in the article that says "no warm-blooded mammal can...come close to the naked mole-rat’s 18-minute record" seems to be painfully and stupidly wrong. The interesting part is not that they survive for 18 minutes. The interesting part is that they do fine at 5% oxygen and that seemingly they (almost?) hold their breaths involuntarily after they pass out at lower levels.
- e12e 10y agoNot to mention Dolphins, seals and great whales?
- pvaldes 10y agoyup, Sperm whales can hold their breath for 90 minutes they divert voluntarily all the blood to focus in the most important organs only.
- eutectic 10y agoPerhaps the article meant it was impressive for their body size.
- rullelito 10y agoWhy is this more impressive at smaller scale?
- eutectic 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kleiber%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kleiber%27s_law
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoPut simply, smallers organisms run hotter...have a higher metabolic rate. If you've ever felt the heartbrat of a cat, chicken, or hamster youll notice that it is significantly higher than your own, thus they require more oxygen relative to their size. Interestingly, the article points out that they become someone anaerobic metabolizing fructose, which doesnt require O2, throughout the body as a source of energy instead of glucose Many people assume metabolism is proportional to surface area based on the argument above. This idea was first proposed by Max Rubner in 1883. In the 1930’s, Max Kleiber proposed that metabolism increases according to body mass raised to the power 3/4. If metabolism were proportional to volume, the exponent would be 1. If it were proportional to surface area, the exponent would be 2/3. But Kleiber’s law says it’s somewhere in between, namely 3/4. Its not clear which, if either, theory is correct. But both agree t
- drcongo 10y agoHow long can they survive when dressed?
- letsbechefs 10y agoThey metabolize fructose, rather than just holding their breath. And they can survive for over 5 hours in a low oxygen environment. https://m.phys.org/news/2017-04-naked-mole-rats-oxygen.html https://m.phys.org/news/2017-04-naked-mole-rats-oxygen.html
- ivanhoe 10y agoIn addition to all of these strange features listed in the article, they're also the only poikilothermic mammal. Most of the time their body temperature is not regulated and it changes with the environment. But unlike reptiles or fish, if the outside temperature goes too high or too low, naked mole rats can switch back to normal homeothermic behavior and self-regulate the body temperature as needed. This way they can survive extreme conditions, and still when conditions are right they can save a lot of energy and survive long periods of hunger without going into hibernation.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoId always thought they werr just cold blooded. This is so much more interesting!
- tropo 10y agoPicture a snake trying to invade the naked mole rat tunnel system. There is almost no oxygen. Maybe normal parasites also die from lack of oxygen.