21 ms·
How the Airlines Became Cartels
- bootybuttcheeks 10y agoI stopped reading when they compared Amtrack to airlines, the author needs to find another profession.
- usaphp 10y agoCan you explain what's wrong with that?
- bootybuttcheeks 10y agoCan't compare the two, intense amount of competition and demand for airlines services Worldwide.
- cmdrfred 10y agoAmtrack is essentially the US postal service of passenger rail. "Founded in 1971 to take over most of the remaining U.S. passenger rail services, it is partially government funded yet operated and managed as a for-profit corporation." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amtrak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amtrak
- nostromo 10y agoAh yes, the federal government will make air travel better... Just as they have made airports themselves a delight! I'm having a hard time taking this argument seriously. While I may not enjoy air travel, the most abusive part of flying is the part run by the federal government, namely the TSA and CBP. If they want to improve the air travel experience, start there.
- augustt 10y agoI myself like the not-crashing-and-dying part run by the FAA.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- baursak 10y agoWho are the actual airports, as in the buildings, facilities, runways, parking, etc., run by? Who are the actual flights run by, as in traffic control? Who are the roads leading to the airport managed by?
- nostromo 10y agoAll of those functions in the US, other than air traffic control, are run by the local government.
- baursak 10y agoAre you suggesting that local governments should be handling border patrol and passenger screening, or would have been doing it better?
- nxc18 10y agoThe amount of stuff that gets past the TSA is pretty strong evidence that yes, local government probably could do a better job at basic security/screening. Anyone who really wants to get away with something needs to worry about a 100 other agencies before they worry about the TSA. Really there's very little evidence that the TSA has had any practical success, despite huge expense. I've traveled internationally and I've seen huge containers of cosmetics walked right through the TSA, only to be stopped on simple inter-terminal x-ray/metal detector inspection in Zurich. Just because we have it now doesn't mean we need to have it; TSA regulation is clearly in the useless category.
- baursak 10y agoI agree with you that TSA (since we quietly dropped CBP from the conversation) is pretty inefficient and on the border of useless. However, you haven't really answered WHY you think that local government would do a better job. You just stated it without evidence. I'm also curious how it would work practically. If I fly around the country frequently, will I need to be aware of all the differences in screening processes at each local destination? Will airlines need to comply with security standards across all localities, instead of dealing with a single agency?
- Brendinooo 10y agoFactual error in the piece: USAir eventually merged into American, not United.
- joelrunyon 10y agoYup. Continental merged with United. They need to get the facts right. 2 stories on the front page now peddling outrage over United. HN is better than this.
- grzm 10y agoIf you think a submission is inappropriate for HN, please flag it. Each of us plays a role in the curation of HN.
- mwytock 10y agoWhat about Southwest, JetBlue or Virgin? Or in Europe, RyanAir and EasyJet? It seems there is at least some competition, United is just not a very good airline.
- nextstep 10y agoNew airlines can usually undercut older airlines because they don't have the same liabilities (pensions, debts from bad business practice over the years, etc.) and so they are usually great for a few years but then they evolve into the same shitty carriers that they compete with. In JetBlue's case, they were initially given a large tax break by NYC/JFK. When that subsidy expired they immediately started to charge for bags, reduce perks like better snacks, etc. http://money.cnn.com/2015/06/30/pf/jetblue-checked-bag-fee/ http://money.cnn.com/2015/06/30/pf/jetblue-checked-bag-fee/
- mwytock 10y agoI see, that's interesting. It does seem to be a tough business, but I guess don't see why it's not "naturally competitive" (as the author claims)
- tyingq 10y agoMany of the "old" airlines have filed bankruptcy several times, which gives you a sort of do-over on employee contract terms, pensions, etc. They've been able to shed debt that way and be more "new". Southwest has some of the highest labor costs in the industry, having never filed bankruptcy.
- SilasX 10y agoThat's a problem with the regulations regarding pension funding, not a general new-company advantage. It should never have been possible for a company to give a pension as compensation that in any way that coupled the pension to their future viability.
- tyingq 10y agoI don't think any regulations forced airlines to make poor pension decisions. Airlines and unions managed to do that themselves, for the most part.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 1_2__3 10y agoI eagerly await a comment section full of armchair economists and recent college grads explaining how the free market will fix all of this and how the problem is things just need to be more fre-er and market-er. How it's just that it's not a TRUE free market, and if it was all of this would sort itself out. The problem is we have decades of real world experience and data to draw from and it does not make the free market position compelling. In fact if we take ideology out of the equation it's pretty obvious most of the recommendations in the article are absolutely reasonable (unless you think the invisible hand solves all).
- epistasis 10y agoMarkets are such an essential tool for our society, but they're also easy to get wrong. Markets require regulation, whether it's in the form of contract enforcement or setting standardized terms for communication in the market. Any time there's a power differential, we need regulation. That's why I wish we could get past this mindless anti-regulation political trend into a "smart regulation" political trend. Whenever I see "regulations are bad" these days it's always associated with mindless deregulation; deregulation is a difficult thing that must be done carefully, and it has to be adjusted later on to adjust for all the unforeseen consequences. Regulations are not bad, it's needless regulations that are bad.
- YCode 10y agoThere's a degree of irony in that the reason air travel is so safe is because air travel safety is so heavily regulated.
- clarkmoody 10y agoOh, you know, because the quickest way to go out of business is to kill your customers...
- kartan 10y ago> Oh, you know, because the quickest way to go out of business is to kill your customers... Why use more fuel than needed in a flight, if you are going to get there anyway? Is that safety measure so important? Without regulations this will be more common: "Colombia's Civil Aeronautics agency concluded in its investigation that the plan for the flight operated by Bolivia-based charter company LaMia did not meet international standards." "Neither the company nor Bolivian authorities should have allowed the plane to take off with the flight plan submitted, said Freddy Bonilla, air safety secretary for Colombia's aviation authority." http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/international/chapecoense-plane-crash-cause-human-error-not-enough-fuel-colombia-a7497026.html http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/international/ch... Also, Tabaco happens. Kill your customers, get new ones.
- diminish 10y ago>> Elsewhere in the travel industry — hotels and car rental agencies, for example — these abuses do not exist because there is actual competition. But airlines are simply not naturally competitive. Is this really so? I tend to believe that, smartphones with camera and the cam apps are having their wonder in that they fix "abuses" of companies and institutions by bring them to light. Maybe hotels and car rental agencies don't have much do disguise but still can abuse, like in poor car maintenance for car rentals, or food quality or cleaning for hotels.
- clarkmoody 10y ago> For air travel is far from a free market. Indeed. > And one seat is pretty much like another — as economists say, there is little product differentiation — so in a competitive free-for-all, everyone goes broke. False. Perfect competition leads to zero profits, which is not the same a "broke." > For starters, planes should not be permitted to fly so full. > Also, we need rules limiting penalties for changing flights. > The Federal Trade Commission or the Justice Department’s Antitrust Division should take a close look, and if rules like these don’t do the trick, the biggest carriers should be broken up. > There is a middle ground between an abusive cartel and a ruinous free-for-all in the skies. It’s known as regulated competition. Author notes the lack of a free market in air travel, prescribes a bunch of additional regulations, then hints that a free market would be "ruinous." As far as I know, we've never tried free markets in air travel.
- draw_down 10y agoReally dislike this style of commenting.
- pitaj 10y agoThen either flag it, or tell us what you dislike about it.
- logfromblammo 10y agoIt's not even zero profits. It's zero economic profits, meaning that your accounting profit can be positive, without considering the opportunity cost of not investing in other businesses. You make money, just not more money than skipping the hard work part and investing everything you have in a robot-managed index fund. In theory, commoditized industries are ruled by entry and exit of firms, based on how the capital costs and economies of scale affect marginal cost of production. When the political process creates friction for the entry and exit of those firms, you get problems in the commodity markets. You have to allow big companies to fail, and have smaller firms take their place then merge-and-acquire or otherwise destroy each other until the magic optimal size for that industry is reached. I'd probably have all airports auction off 5-year leases for 20% of their terminal gates every year, and base the number of takeoff and landing slots an airline can use per day on the number of gates it currently leases.
- misterbwong 10y agoI hate the airlines too but holding up Amtrak[1] as the model isn't going to win you any points. The reason airlines "hate" passengers is because they basically break even on shuttling economy passengers and look at economy passengers as more of a cost than a profit center. Sure they're making more money now because of all the tacked on fees, but those are a relatively recent trend. The real profit is from business/first passengers and from the miles/credit card game they play. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/03/01/amtrak-loses-a-ton-of-money-each-year-it-doesnt-have-to/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/03/01/amtra...
- djsumdog 10y agoThere's a good Wendover video on airline classes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BzB5xtGGsTc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BzB5xtGGsTc And another great one about AmTrak in relation to flight: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fwjwePe-HmA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fwjwePe-HmA
- nitwit005 10y agoThanks, the Wendover video was quite well done.
- scurvy 10y agoThe article is factually wrong in a few places. USAir did not merge with United. The NYT has slipped so far.
- scurvy 10y agoDownvotes because you don't like the fact that USAir actually didn't merge with United? Or is HN just turning into a subreddit now?
- hehheh 10y agoComplaining about downvotes is one of the worst things you'll see on reddit, there's no need to bring it here. Pedantry is also not very useful but I guess it's not worth "downvoting" over.
- jonknee 10y agoIt's an opinion piece by someone who doesn't work at the NYT, but if you write them I'm sure they'll include a correction. That tidbit also had no bearing on the argument.
- milquetoastaf 10y agoIt's on the front page of their website. The NYT is a rag now.
- jonknee 10y agoThere is something incorrect in an opinion piece. It should be corrected, but is not a scandal.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoUm, why is this downvoted? USAir, in fact, did not merge with United, it merged with American Airlines.
- pinaceae 10y agoAs with a lot of other things, the US is simply a child. A child slowly learning what it is to be a country, a government, a society. You can see it in many areas, especially in ones other, more mature countries and regions, hold as vital to the public good. Health Care. Transportation. Communication. Environment. etc. Just look at how the EU governs passenger rights. None of the utter SHIT that is ok in the US would fly. Same with data privacy - look at the upcoming GDPR law and compare to what ISPs can do in the US. And look at the stick they attached to it - a fine of 4% of total, global revenue. Boy I hope Facebook and Google have their checkbooks ready. The citizen comes first, never a corporation. You can't skip a couple hundred or even a thousand years of development though. A society needs to learn its lessons, takes ages. That the US is fueled by immigrants from less developed nations does not make it easier, those lessons need to be re-learned all the time. Societal memory does not exist as it does in say, Germany.
- epistasis 10y agoI think it's important to realize that unlike the analogy of maturation from child to adult, which is typically viewed as a one-way process, a better analogy may be a pendulum that swings both ways. Let's recall that the article is saying that 40 years ago the situation was different.
- pinaceae 10y agoAbsolutely - but the lack of societal memory and cohesion wiped out all the progress. Ultimately there is a lack of a unified societal contract, ironic in a country so focused on its constitution. What is the purpose of government, rules and society? A lot of the issues in the US stem from this lack of common ground. And I believe, at the root is poor education and a sense of me vs. the newly arrived. A constant struggle to keep your spoils and not wanting to share with new people who haven't contributed yet. The US is not a coherent country and society (yet). Still confused as to its purpose. And yes, Trump is a great symptom of this. The UK has this personality crisis right now, the empire is gone and a lot of newcomers have shaken up society. Brexit is a similar outcome. It needs to find its core, but as a conglomerate it is hard. Common traditions should help - but when the Queen dies, it will shake them up even more.
- acalderaro 10y agoAfter reading, the author makes some valid points, and also some not so valid points. one of the particularly valid points is that airlines shouldn't be allowed to overbook. By offsetting this with no-refund policies, it seems like a win-win negotiation. It may not be "free market," but it makes logistical sense as it takes resources to re-route passengers and deal with the negative PR from booting passengers. One of the not-so-valid points is the author's statement that "It makes no sense to allow airlines to charge an astronomical fare just because a flight is nearly full, and a dirt-cheap fare for an advance booking." The fundamental idea of supply and demand is that when supply is high and demand is low (when a flight is immediately listed), prices are lower than they would be when supply is low and demand is high (last minute interest in a semi-full flight). While most economic models have varying degrees of subjectivity, this is not one of them. Ideologies are brilliant for discussion, but in practice, they fail to capture every possible variable and account for the impact when arriving at an outcome. Some amount of procedure (i.e. regulation) improves operations and efficacy. By the same token, too much regulation stifles operations. Transportation is less of "creative" business, and more of a "procedural" business. As such, it can benefit from regulated procedures. The key is not to hide behind a wall of ignorance and ideology, but instead try to find the procedures that optimize the output for consumers and businesses.
- Johnny555 10y agoone of the particularly valid points is that airlines shouldn't be allowed to overbook. By offsetting this with no-refund policies, it seems like a win-win negotiation Nearly every industry overbooks (airlines, hotels, even restaurants) and it saves consumers money in the long run. The problem is that when it happens, the airline shouldn't be allowed to involuntarily deny boarding to anyone, they should be required to offer a high enough reward that someone takes it voluntarily.
- mikeash 10y agoI see no problem with overbooking, as long as they're transparent about it and compensate people. Overbooking is common in many industries. The article holds up hotels and car rental agencies as examples of how it's done better, but those overbook too. Car rental agencies in particular don't really know how many cars they'll have available at any given time because their contracts are so flexible, so your "reservation" is really just a planning tool so they can try to shuffle inventory around. (The TV documentary series "Seinfeld" did an episode on this.)
- MS_Buys_Upvotes 10y agoI love watching the evolution of HN sometimes. Outrage of the Week (TM) story, nothing to do with hacking or technology - 62 points in under an hour. Mind bending. Let the circle jerk begin.
- jonknee 10y agoOn the other hand it's a huge legacy industry that everyone hates and agrees there should be a better way. It sounds like taxis or hotels to me and those are quite on topic discussions at HN.
- joelrunyon 10y agoSouthwest has a fundamentally different business model involving standardized fleet sizes & limited routing. Plus, if he's complaining about stopovers + layovers, Southwest has these on almost every flight. He's stating a lot of things that would be nice, but the fact of the matter is that a lot of people still fly Spirit Airlines - despite their constant low ratings - because it's costs $50 bucks. The real discussion should be about fare transparency as a bunch of airlines are rolling out basic economy fares that don't include food, limit space even further and don't accrue points, etc. Instead of making a new, nicer tier class, they're taking away items from the basic economy fares and maintaining the same pricing.[1][2] The fact that none of these pieces are talking about this makes me think these are outrage opinion articles by talking heads rather than people who regularly fly [1] https://thepointsguy.com/2017/03/is-basic-economy-really-a-deal/ https://thepointsguy.com/2017/03/is-basic-economy-really-a-d... [2] https://thepointsguy.com/2017/02/united-selling-basic-economy/ https://thepointsguy.com/2017/02/united-selling-basic-econom...
- mikeash 10y agoAs usual, people don't know their own desires. Ask people what makes them choose an airline and they'll probably tell you a tale about reputation, service, legroom, amenities, what have you. Now stick them in front of a computer and tell them to buy a ticket with their own money and watch them pick the cheapest option regardless of the rest. It's a race to the bottom because that's what people really want. When the rubber meets the road, most people want a horrible, cheap experience. Why do airlines overbook flights? Because people would rather save $5 with a chance of being bumped than pay a little extra. Obviously, we'd all love direct flights with sixteen feet of legroom, a hundred free checked bags, gourmet meals, free access to a library of every movie and TV show ever made, and for a price of $3.50. But that's not going to happen, because amenities cost money. When we're faced with the tradeoff, we favor low prices. Once I truly realized this, I became a lot less annoyed with many airline shenanigans. Yeah, it's pretty annoying that as a tall guy I barely fit into the seat. But it's what I paid for. If it was that important to me, I could pay extra for more space. I don't, because, like most people, I prefer cheapness above all else. You can get a much nicer experience if you pay for it. If you don't feel like paying for it, then what are you complaining about? Not particularly related, but this line from the article caught my eye: "It makes no sense to allow airlines to charge an astronomical fare just because a flight is nearly full, and a dirt-cheap fare for an advance booking." What planet is this guy from? Of course it makes sense to charge high fares for a scarce product in high demand, and low fares for an abundant product in low demand.
- taxicabjesus 10y agoThe airline industry is crippled by its debt load. They borrow money to buy a plane, and hopefully make money flying it around to make the payments. When the plane is finally paid off, it's ready to be replaced. I had an anecdote about a Hawaiian Airlines' maintenance problem: http://www.taxiwars.org/2015/03/airplane-maintenance.html http://www.taxiwars.org/2015/03/airplane-maintenance.html
- hendzen 10y agoWrong. There is actually a niche of financial engineering used to work around this problem known as aircraft securitization. Airlines don't buy the planes directly, they set up separate corporate entities (SPVs) that purchase the planes with cash generated by issuing bonds. The airline then leases the plane from the SPV and the bondholders are paid with the lease payments. The collateral in this case is usually the plane itself, and if the bonds go bad the bondholders are first in line for any payments from liquidating the SPV collateral. Also, the debt stays off the books of the airline.
- Darthy 10y agoIronically, it's regulations that brought us this mess. Specifically that an airline is allowed to cap bump compensations at $1300. Without that cap, there would have been takers and no need for violence. Really free markets would have solved this.
- joelrunyon 10y agoI don't think that's a gov't regulation. That's likely an internal United standard. Delta just raised their minimum to $10k-ish if you read the article...
- cmdrfred 10y agoActually it is, if someone is bumped from a flight the most they can legally ask for (anyone is free to give anyone money if they wish) is $1400 (I believe) or 4X the value of the ticket whatever is less. Delta offered this maximum, and was declined by all passengers. Then Delta called government law enforcement offers to enforce existing regulation and remove the passenger. Without this regulation there would have been no maximum for damages in violation of their contract, thus the passenger could of sued for a potentially unlimited amount. Thus Delta might of been inclined to offer more as their losses would possibly be higher than the maximum in the regulation. Having a maximum, and having government law enforcement enforce said maximum certainly contributed to this issue. Now due to the losses in stock price Delta has reevaluated it's risk/reward on terms of bumping passengers and decided its more cost effective to offer more. This is a perfect example of how the free market can correct these sort of things without the government getting involved at all.
- joelrunyon 10y ago1. This was United, not Delta. The Delta mention in my comment was their response to an industry incident 2. No one ASKED for any money. United was trying to get people to voluntarily bump by offering X - no one accepted (because the next flight didn't leave for a day). United should have realized that if they really wanted to get their employees on the flight & not have an international incident, they could go a bit higher... 3. Here's the rule: > If the substitute transportation is scheduled to get you to your destination more than two hours later (four hours internationally), or if the airline does not make any substitute travel arrangements for you, the compensation doubles (400% of your one-way fare, $1350 maximum). All of this is out the window anyways with the Dao case since it wasn't even an overbooked flight - one with too many ticketed passengers - but one where they were trying to get employees to another airport (which they could have easily booked on another airline due to internal agreements).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bluetwo 10y ago16 years since a domestic carrier has had a major loss of life in the US. Some might say that proves regulation is no longer necessary, but I would argue that it shows that it works.
- jcdavis 10y ago> 16 years since a domestic carrier has had a major loss of life in the US. Only if you exclude regionals, which doesn't make sense.
- komali2 10y agoThat's a broad brush to paint. Nobody here is complaining about the FAA (the regulatory agency that, when it comes to safety, keeps airlines honest). Airlines know they can't play games there.
- rb808 10y agoAirlines are hardly cartels. Cartels make obscene amounts of money, airlines currently make a little money but historically lose. The main issue is price sensitivity. People would rather pay less and suffer rather than pay full premium prices. As a result people largely get what they're asking for.
- ajmurmann 10y agoMost people also got too infrequently and have too few choices. I get on an airplane at least six times a year and that used to be much more frequent. Because of timing I have done most of my flying recently on Virgin which I fortunately loved (of course that option is gone soon because they got acquired by Alaska who I severely dislike). On the route I fly most my options come down to Virgin, Alaska and United. So at best If haver to fly there times to be able to make a somewhat educated decision about which airline I prefer. That's assuming that my schedule and availability even allowed all three as actual options. Only very few passengers fly that frequently. And now that's actually down to two choices. Given that lack of information and infrequent exposure it's almost impossible to make a decision based on anything but price and convenience of schedule. Even if I've flown a airline on a certain route, the experience on a longer route, especially internationally might still be completely different (and it frequently is). It's really hard for a market to properly function under such conditions.
- harryh 10y agoIn July, I am taking a vacation to Los Angeles. I haven't been to LA in 10 years or so and I'm unlikely to go back any time soon. One or two of the nights that I am there I would like to go out to a somewhat fancy dinner. But I haven't been to any of my options and I'm very unlikely to visit any of them more than once. Because of my inability to try out all my choices I can see how it's hard for the market of nice restaurants in LA to function properly. Clearly the government should step in and decide what they should cook and how much they should charge for it. There are lots of goods where people don't personally test all the available options where markets work just fine. People can rely on all sorts of recommendations to make informed choices. With the internet this is easier than ever. For everything from LA restaurants to airlines.
- bogomipz 10y agoI had question about the following statement: >"With the hub-and-spoke system used to defend airlines’ pricing power, there are fewer nonstops" I hadn't considered the hub and spoke system as a means of defending pricing power before. Is the idea that since there are more flights by that airline into its hub region they can offer better fares to passengers? Is that right? But don't passengers generally try to avoid flights with lay overs? The logic is escaping me.
- Bagger288 10y agoIt's about supply and demand and fuel efficency. A small airport between Albany and NYC won't have enough people to fill a plane capable of flying to LAX efficiently from a fuel perspective, so they'll take a flight to NYC first then the LAX on a bigger plane that can spend less per person per mile to get there. Larger planes tend to be more fuel efficient (assuming all seats filled) than smaller ones which is why hub and spoke model makes a lot of sense. The 787 is actually abnormally fuel efficient for its size and it's opening up many direct routes that were previously not economical since it's a smaller plane that costs the same per mile per person as much larger planes.
- bogomipz 10y agoSure I understand about the logistical concerns and population densities but how do these spokes allow them to "defend their pricing power"? Is it simply that that they can charge customers in those small secondary markets a premium on fares into the hub areas? Is that the pricing leverage?
- Bagger288 10y agoThey can lessen competition by not building a big hub in an airport that that's already a hub for a competing airline. If they avoid stepping on each others toes with hubs there are less airlines to compete on price with. If Minneapolis is a hub for Delta, then they have a virtual monopoly for all the smaller airports in the area that need to first fly to Minneapolis before the final destination.
- adam_gyroscope 10y agoIf you are interested in the history of the airline industry up through the 90s, you should read Hard Landing. It's an excellent overview of how we got to where we are in the United States, and the meat of the book is about deregulation. Note that "deregulation" in the airline industry (primarily) means the government no longer controlled which airlines flew which routes. Before deregulation, route ownership was decided by an oligopoly that would and could set high-margin prices on routes since the control of those routes was a) assured by the government and b) agreed on by all the major carriers. After deregulation, airlines competed primarily on price. While this lead to the hub-and-spoke system and the low-fare carriers we see today, it also meant that almost anyone could fly anywhere in the US and abroad for (relatively) little money and a high amount of safety. As an aside, airline reservations technology benefited immensely from deregulation, and the carriers that controlled the reservations systems ended up killing of the carriers that didn't (see, for example, Eastern Airlines). If you're interested in the tech of the airline industry, I recently gave a talk about this at Systems We Love: https://systemswe.love/archive/san-francisco-2016/life-of-an-airline-flight https://systemswe.love/archive/san-francisco-2016/life-of-an...
- whatitis 10y agoThat's how it is. Get off the plane. Resistance will be met with force.
- fulafel 10y agoMost air travel is unethical in the current global warming situation, and it's growing at an alarming pace. Governments should try to reverse the trend ASAP.
- rayiner 10y ago> For air travel is far from a free market. The article starts with this premise, but fails to offer a shred of support for the idea. > When the airlines were deregulated in 1978, economists led by Alfred Kahn, then chairman of the Civil Aeronautics Board, argued that airlines and airline tickets were really like any other free-market product. He called them “marginal costs with wings.” Nearly 40 years of deregulation have disproved that premise. Airline deregulation has been a massive success. Inflation-adjusted ticket prices have fallen by 50% since 1978: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/02/how-airline-ticket-prices-fell-50-in-30-years-and-why-nobody-noticed/273506 https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/02/how-air.... Moreover, airline deregulation had an unexpected side-effect. It led to the creation of modern parcel carriers like FedEx, who could not have existed within the old regulated system: https://www.mercatus.org/publication/unleashing-innovation-deregulation-air-cargo-transportation https://www.mercatus.org/publication/unleashing-innovation-d.... > And one seat is pretty much like another — as economists say, there is little product differentiation — so in a competitive free-for-all, everyone goes broke. That's kind of the whole point of competitive markets--to drive prices for undifferentiated goods toward the marginal cost of production. > By 1988, 85 percent of airline markets had only two airlines competing, and they closely monitored each other’s fares, so that true price competition was rare. Using markets without weighting by population makes no sense. There are tons of airports in the U.S., most in places that don't have very many people. In the markets with the most passengers, there are 4-5 of what the GAO terms "effective competitors": http://www.gao.gov/assets/670/664060.pdf http://www.gao.gov/assets/670/664060.pdf. > An industry that is not naturally competitive went from being a regulated cartel, to a brief period of ruinous competition, and then to an unregulated cartel — with predictable effects on the quality of service. This restored profitability, but at awful costs both to customer convenience and to economic efficiency as well. The article argues that the airline industry is a cartel, and suggests that happened by 1988 (see above). But the airline industry lost $51 billion between 2000-2011, and recorded net losses every year before that since 1981. > With the hub-and-spoke system used to defend airlines’ pricing power, there are fewer nonstops. Passengers waste time and often miss connections, while airlines waste fuel. This is handwaving. If the hub-and-spoke system wasn't a net efficiency win, nothing would stop one of the numerous low-cost airlines from coming in and using a different system. > But in an industry that is not naturally competitive, tweaking market incentives will not fix what’s broken. For starters, planes should not be permitted to fly so full. That leaves no room for contingencies. Another hand-waving assertion. > There should also be rules on how many passengers an airline can cram into a plane, and what extras it can charge for. And there should be limits on price gouging. It makes no sense to allow airlines to charge an astronomical fare just because a flight is nearly full, and a dirt-cheap fare for an advance booking. More handwaving assertions. These things aren't "price gouging" in need of regulation any more than its "price gouging" for Apple to charge $100 more for a 32 to 64GB upgrade that costs it $10-15. > Would rules like these destroy the airlines’ business model? Ask Amtrak, which hauls three times the passengers between New York and Washington as all airlines combined, and doesn’t punish you for canceling a ticket. I used to ride the Northeast regional every workday for almost two years. Even on that segment, the only profitable part of Amtrak's entire system, Amtrak is using cars that were all built between 1973 and 1982 (which themselves were a slight retooling of a 1960s design). Despite Amtrak not paying for its own CapEx, its infrastructure is near collapse, with key infrastructure like the Baltimore & Potomac tunnel operating far past the point of obsolescence.
- adolph 10y agoThe recent United Airlines bumping debacle Here, let me fix that lie for you: The recent United Airlines initiated police assault and battery on a passenger
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoNo, that's not at all what happened. What happened was that United needed to re-accommodate a customer who was being disruptive and belligerent. And that lie might have worked, except for a fairly recent invention called a "smartphone". How that clown CEO still has a job is beyond my comprehension.
- corford 10y agoThe market response (at least in Europe, after liberalising the common airspace) has been the rise and utter domination of LCC airlines. Point-to-point flights, standardised aircraft, super low fares and great coverage. The success of the model is now creeping in to medium/long haul routes with Norwegian (and very recently IAG) leading the charge. If you talk to airlines, the "cartel" they fear are the distribution gatekeepers (GDS providers and OTAs like Priceline and Ctrip). This world is rapidly changing too though with the arrival of NDC and airlines investing in their own direct to channel APIs (a practice, incidentally, pioneered by LCCs).
- dingaling 10y ago> The success of the model is now creeping in to medium/long haul routes I'm an old enough fogey to remember the launch of Laker SkyTrain back in the early 1980s that brought unbelievably low fares to the trans-Atlantic market, compared to the big airlines participating in the IATA 'tariff agreement' cartel. But Laker also discarded all the ticketing restrictions, you just bought your one-way fares and any extras you wanted. It was those airlines, such as TWA and BA, that ran SkyTrain into the ground by pricing in response with fares that were uneconomical for them; Laker held-on for several years but eventually went bust,and fares returned to 'normal'. So it's with great satisfaction to me that 30 years later the heirs of those airlines are scared of the modern-day Lakers.
- lhopki01 10y agoI wonder why deregulation within the EU led to such different results than the US? The article makes a point about how there were many mergers in the US which probably has reduced competition. However, this doesn't explain the fact that in the EU it has been newcomers like Ryanair and Easyjet that have really made the big changes.
- corford 10y agoI don't know enough about the US market to have an informed opinion, though there are a few differences I'm sure play a part: 1. Lots of different languages and cultures in the EU make it easier for startup airlines to quickly grow from their local base. So, for example, you see WizzAir and BlueAir competing successfully with Ryanair and Easyjet in Eastern Europe. Transavia from the Netherlands, Norwegian from Norway, Vueling and Volotea from Spain, Germanwings/Eurowings from Germany. 2. The population distribution in Europe lends itself ideally to the LCC model (point-to-point networks and sector times under 5 hours). We have lots of regional cities with sufficient populations to warrant basing a few aircraft and opening up profitable routes. That's why Europe has the densest regional/secondary route network in the world. 3. The LCC explosion really started in the early 2000's (despite Easyjet first flying in ~1995 iirc). It exploded thanks to a perfect storm of airspace liberalisation, cheap aircraft leases 'post 9/11', widespread internet adoption (so LCCs could cut out travel agents and GDS fees) and booming EU economies fuelling consumer demand for flights and travel. The open question is whether or not Europe will see consolidation within the LCC market but I personally don't think it will any time soon. LCC passenger count is still growing at ~6%/year.
- acchow 10y agoI find it so frustrating that there is only 1 airline flying the SFO-YYZ route. Virgin canceled theirs in 2011 I guess because they couldn't make any money. But looking at AC fares, it's clear a single carrier is making too much money on this monopoly. How do we get free markets to work in a system like this? 50 passenger self-flying planes?
- thedogeye 10y agoHow can we say US airlines are a free market when it's illegal for a non-US owned airline to operate domestically between US cities?
- antisthenes 10y agoAirlines market is much closer to a monopolistic competition than a cartel/oligopoly structure. Not that I would trust a random journo to know the economics, but this is the NYT. This is why journalism is dying - instead of checking up the science and basic definitions behind the article (by shooting a quick email to Krugman, perhaps), it's just an article that gets views by piling on the hate bandwagon against United and dragging the rest of the airlines with it. The headline is wrong. If you want a typical cartel/oligopolistic market - look at the telecoms.
- uiri 10y agoFew passengers are literal no-shows. Some airline booking ploys result in passengers being literal no shows. This occurs when a round trip fare is cheaper than a one way fare (so the passenger is a no show for the return trip), or a trip from A to C with a layover in B is cheaper than a trip from A to B (so the passenger is a no show for the B to C flight). I've done the latter, where my internship is at A, my family is at B and I go to University at C. I book a trip C-A at the start of the summer and then a return trip A-C with a layover in B after my internship ends but some time before the next semester starts.
- mschuster91 10y agoWell, at least unlike other cartels, there is a significant amount of regulation - the FAA has very strict rules to keep airlines from cutting corners (e.g. maintenance requirements, certifications of airworthiness but also pilot licensing). Other industries with less regulations tend to kill people due to cutting corners (e.g. the Takata airbag scandal, Ford acceleration issues).
- al452 10y agoSummary of this utterly incoherent article: airlines are terrible because <insert some random claims about economic history>, and we can fix them by <insert some randomly chosen regulations we could invent>.
- davidf18 10y agoFrom the article: > "There is a middle ground between an abusive cartel and a ruinous free-for-all in the skies. It’s known as regulated competition." The author has an agenda. There are two problems: 1. Is the airline consolidation permitted by the Obama administration going from 6 airlines to 4 with the consolidation of US Air into American and Continental into United. It is baffling why the Obama administration allowed this which only meant higher costs for consumers. 2. Airline gates and takeoff/landing times lots are a scarce resource at major airports, limiting competition and adding costs to flights. Speeding up the implementation of the GPS guided flight control systems and in the longer term building more runways will help release the scarcity for increased competition. Many airports (e.g.. Chicago's O'Hare) was built years ago with no surrounding houses and people built and decided to live near the airport. Then they complain about airplane noise. They knew what they were getting into. There needs to be federal regulations that override local control prohibiting runway construction which harms to national economy. Fixing problems like this is to understand the economics and where the market inefficiencies or market failures occur and addressing them so that we again have efficient markets. Air travel is a commodity and should be low cost except for these market failures, market inefficiencies. In summary: 1. Break up American and United to restore the status quo prior to the consolidation. 2. Speedup investment in the ongoing conversion to GPS controlled air traffic control. Financial allocation from Congress which could be paid for by taxes on airplane tickets. 3. Federal legislation overriding local laws which create a shortage of runways in key high traffic airports.
- nostrademons 10y agoMy understanding is that Continental, United, USAirways, American, Northwest, and Delta (the latter two also having merged) would've all ceased to operate had they not been allowed to merge. As of 2005 United, USAirways, Northwest, and Delta were all bankrupt; at that moment in time, 4 out of the top 6 U.S. carriers were operating in Chapter 11 bankruptcy. American entered bankruptcy in 2011, and Continental was reportedly in financial difficulties at the time. Had they not merged and instead entered Chapter 7, we might have gone down to 2-3 active airlines. And we're already seeing renewed competition in domestic air travel: JetBlue and Alaska are coming up fast and threatening established carriers. JetBlue is my wife's favorite airline to fly on; she's gotten pretty good service on some very low fares. I don't really see this as a market failure. People expect capitalism to give them great products at low prices all the time; it doesn't work like that. Capitalism just means that when things get too out-of-whack, the market adjusts and fixes it. Airlines were crazily unprofitable in 2008-2010; the market reaction was consolidation & mergers, such that airlines are now crazy profitable and give shitty service. The market reaction to that is that new competitors are springing up, saying "I can do better", and people are flying on them. Vote with your dollars and in another 5-10 years United will be bankrupt again.
- wu-ikkyu 10y ago>cartel: an association of manufacturers or suppliers with the purpose of maintaining prices at a high level and restricting competition. With the above definition, couldn't any industry/company bailed out by the government (i.e. United Airlines, AIG, Citigroup) be considered a cartel due to the fact that they are not allowed to be overtaken by competitive market forces?
- hkmurakami 10y agoPrice fixing is a defining element.
- wu-ikkyu 10y agoAt what point does setting your own prices become price fixing?
- jeffbax 10y agoI would seem prudent for an article complaining about deregulation and market solutions to mention the fact that: > "Foreign companies and individuals—think Richard Branson and Virgin Atlantic Airways—are forbidden by U.S. law from owning more than 25% of a domestic airline. That’s why Virgin America could be sold last year to Alaska Airlines over the express wishes of Virgin’s famous founder: He just didn’t have enough votes." http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-welch-united-competition-20170413-story.html http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-welch-united-comp... So while it may have become a cartel, like the drug cartels, policy really matters. I find it disingenuous to complain about a "naturally non-competitive market" like the NYT does, and not acknowledge the un-natural acts of policy keeping it such.
- chx 10y agoWhat this article is missing is the power of pilot unions. http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines