14 ms·
Pirate Bay Founder: ‘I Have Given Up’ (2015)
- subie 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eTOKXCEwo_8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eTOKXCEwo_8 Really great doc about the Pirate Bay team.
- catenthusiast 10y agoWe shouldn’t be glorifying criminals like this. I hope we can move to an online culture that is more respectful of content-creators.
- literallycancer 10y agoUS law isn't universal.
- cmdrfred 10y agoAnd even under US law, telling someone they give out pirated movies on 5th street (or providing a link to one) isn't illegal.
- steevenwee 10y agoEspecially copyrights laws, that are outdated (to say the list) for to be used on a digital products.
- shrimp_emoji 10y agoIn some parts of the world, being a free Westerner is a crime. I guess I should feel contrite.
- RugnirViking 10y agoSuch as?
- johnfn 10y agoIt's funny to me that even on a community like HN, suggesting rights for content creators gets you downvoted immediately without explanation. As a content creator myself, I side very strongly with you. Well, I don't think we should be jailing the Pirate Bay guys - that's quite extreme - but we definitely shouldn't be idolozing them either, as we often do. To be honest, all the people who try to moralize piracy be saying "oh content creators never would have made any money off things that were torrented anyways" or today's rationalization du jour remind me of slave owners that came up with post-hoc rationalizations for why slavery was totally fine. I'M NOT COMPARING FILESHARING TO SLAVERY. I'm just saying that in both cases, people made whatever decision they wanted to make and screw whoever it effected, and then once they had done that they scrambled to come up with some reason why it was actually okay. I find myself wishing for a karmic equalization such that everyone who espouses those rationalizations could feel the pain that I - like every content creator - has to bear for them. I know it will never happen, but it's an idealistic dream of mine.
- shrimp_emoji 10y ago>"oh content creators never would have made any money anyways" Are you referring to the "lost sale fallacy"? That's one argument, but another is that the content creators DO make money anyways. Particularly, if you make your content affordable (see textbook prices) and usable in whatever way I want (e.g., I can't play iTunes shows in MPC and have to rely on the platform I bought them on), my incentive to pirate your content goes down dramatically. Doing the latter is absurd, though; how do you protect your content from being shared? I don't know either. I guess I'll pirate decrypted copies of it. It IS "wrong", I don't pretend otherwise, but it's cutting the Gordian knot of unfavorable economic paradigms. Kind of like slavery. Except way less worse. See lost sale fallacy.
- baddox 10y agoI think the best example is Steam. A common sentiment online is "I don't pirate games any more because Steam makes it so easy to buy them, plus there are often incredible sales." I share this sentiment. A large part of Steam's success is that they built a better product than the one offered by piracy. That's worth paying for. Granted, this isn't a cure-all. I'm sure some people still pirate games, and it's probably impossible to estimate how many represent "lost sales." Moreover, games are one of the trickier things to pirate, often requiring some technical knowledge (using disk images, keygens, cracks, etc.). Music is obviously much easier to pirate.
- bitJericho 10y agoCopyrights past 7ish years is criminal. I won't respect and support a government and set of laws designed only for the wealthy.
- wrigby 10y agoI agree that life+70 is too long, but just 7 years seems pretty short. I'm interested in hearing your rationale for choosing that number.
- Retric 10y agoCopyright is not the same as trademarks. Disney can keep people from using mickey mouse without life + infinity which seems to be the current system. Movie adaptions for example could be prevented even if the book is in the public domain. 7 years seems short, but revenue capture must balance with the cost to society of copyright. Thus, ~80% of the revenue for 200x the freedom is a viable trade off. PS: Remember the constitution explicitly says it's to promote the creation of new content NOT extract money from existing content. Having an author extract residuals for 50 years discourages new works.
- wrigby 10y agoI think this would be more compelling if you demonstrate that 7 years is long enough to generate 80% of the revenue. For many artistic works, it can take years to produce them (writing a book for instance), and many don't gain traction for years either. Film adaptations of books are a great example. A real-life example: The Notebook (the book) was published in 1996. The Notebook (the movie) was released eight years later, in 2004. With a seven year copyright, the book would be in public domain, and the author may not see a dime from the movie. Is that fair? Is paying the author of the book royalties from the film's revenue a burdensome cost to society? I assert that the author of the book should be able to earn money from the wildly successful film adaptation of his movie, whether he's directly involved with the production of the film or not. I'm sure there are a lot of subtle technicalities I'm missing, but I think the core of this argument stands. I'm in favor of reducing the duration of copyright, but I think something in the region of 30 years is a more reasonable amount of time than 7 years. Regarding the constitution, I think that the means of promoting creation of new works is the ability for creators to profit off of their works. By reducing the potential for profit, you reduce the incentive to create. I can see how overly-restrictive copyright law can inhibit creativity, but I think a 7 year period swings too far in the opposite direction.
- lucideer 10y agoUntil / unless you have a solution for the exploitation of content-creators by content-controllers / content-owners / content-distributors, preaching about respect for them is moot. In contrast, "criminals like this", do net zero or negative harm to content-creators.
- virmundi 10y agoSuch rights are part of a social contract only. When the US decided to implement such a contract, the original duration was 14 years plus another 14 if the owner of the work was still alive [1], and pursed the next term. We've now got to 70 years after the rights owner's death. A question that a lot of pirates have is "does this make sense at a policy level?" Add to that many pirates also purchase more media, the question become more interesting. While I don't condone or use such technology (I'd rather own it and not have to watch our for an enforcer), I don't buy things. If I can't purchase it legally, I don't want it. I've gotten to the point that the whole topic makes me not want to purchase or consume media anymore. I still do, but it's becoming more of a chore with each passing day. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Act_of_1790 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Act_of_1790
- agumonkey 10y agoHow is inheritance dealt with ? a family and lineage will surely want to benefit from an ancestor wealth as long as possible be it 14, 70 or even more years.
- virmundi 10y agoI don't see why society needs to care specifically about their desires. The only reason for copyright at all is we think it's best for the person creating a work to have exclusive rights to said work for a period of monetizing. If they have exclusive rights, a person is probably more likely to pursue creation and innovation. It is my contention that the current duration promotes rent seeking, which is against the spirit of the 1790's act.
- agumonkey 10y agoVery good point.
- cr0sh 10y agoWhen the owner of a work is a corporation (eg. Disney), and corporations are considered legal persons (in many ways - including their religion!), then 70+ years starts to make sense in a certain (but ugly) way...
- douche 10y agoBittorrent filled a hole when it was pretty much impossible to legitimately obtain digital content, at any price. When was the last time you torrented a music album? Thanks to iTunes and Spotify and Youtube, you don't really need to anymore. When was the last time you bothered torrenting a cracked PC game? It's not worth the effort, when you can pick it up on a Steam or GOG sale for the cost of a Big Mac and fries. TV and movies are to some extent still locked away like that, particularly movies. I hope that somebody is making an effort to back up that cultural heritage before the cellulose rots.
- tinus_hn 10y agoSpotify wouldn't have existed if the music companies' hand hadn't been forced by piracy.
- toast0 10y agoSpotify is basically launchcast, but with more customers, and launched 7 years later. Internet based music piracy and personalized radio came into popular availability at around the same time, because people started having connections fast enough to download or stream songs.
- xanderstrike 10y agoSpotify succeeded where others failed because the RIAA basically picked it as a winner.
- imh 10y agoAdd to that, I don't even know where I can buy a digital copy of most movies. I know I can sorta rent rights to them on amazon, google, etc, but to actually be able to use it as I please and copy from device to device? Itunes is the only one I know to be close to that.
- Asooka 10y agoWe ARE respectful to content-creators, we're disrespectful to the insane copyright term limits and the trigger-happy lawyers at RIAA and MPAA. If filesharing were going to kill media producers it would have already happened.
- tertius 10y ago> We ARE respectful to content-creators You claim this... Yet say the following. > If filesharing were going to kill media producers it would have already happened. So you claim respect yet you refuse to reward the creator for their work. "You Keep Using That Word, I Do Not Think It Means What You Think It Means."
- anigbrowl 10y agoNo you're not. You just pay lip service but I don't see any evidence of actually trying to help out. Where are the great tech grants for the arts, or the artist-residence programs at tech companies, or any kind of support whatsoever? You respect content creators in the esense that you enjoy watching their content and say things like 'This Artist is great!'. That's it. The tech industry has provided useful new tools for artists that didn't exist before, but last time I looked Photoshop and similar products ain't free, far from it.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoTaking culture and locking it away until living memory has expired is what should be criminal. However, if a person chooses to commit a tort and breech copyright and all this third-party did was tell that person where to find someone to help - that certainly shouldn't be considered criminal in any democracy. When the content owning cabals stop lobbying against things like format-shifting then they'll have a moral leg to stand on. Get back to us then.
- s73ver 10y agoIt'd help your argument if you could come up with a moral leg for your side to stand on. What's moral about saying that you should get the works of others without paying their asking price?
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>What's moral about saying that you should get the works of others without paying their asking price? // Art, which copyright protects, has a unique place in culture. Cultural works owe much to their use, an anthem becomes an anthem after it is penned because it is adopted by the culture and used as an anthem. It doesn't happen in a vacuum. Yes, when a creator, such as myself, creates a work they deserve to get recompense for it if it adds value to society - just as any other worker deserves recompense for their value generating work. But creators operating in the cultural space demand something from the demos, they demand protection, through the creation of laws, in order to ensure they can exploit their works for financial gain. There is nothing wrong with any of this so far. And use of copyright to stimulate creation in the field of the useful arts is noble, it is right to ensure those adding worth to society get recompense. But copyright has been corrupted far beyond that aim, it has been used as a rod to beat the demos with until it both accepts not being able to access culturally significant works and having to pay many times over for the work of the creators - often not even too the creators. There's no reason that we, the demos, should support legislation that stops us using works where the artists/singer/composer has received many 10s of years of average wages already. That's not a fair deal. And we certainly shouldn't be paying for completely unrelated executives to mint it because their predecessors bought the rights 70 years ago; that doesn't stimulate artistic creation. We're being ripped off and those who suppose to represent the demos instead represent the interests of media corps and their own retirement opportunities. The copyright lobby needs to go first in demonstrating they have a moral high ground because the default is no copyright. Copyright is supposed to be a contract with society, where we gift them a limited term monopoly, without that gift the creators of copyrightable works have no recourse in law to ensure their works aren't duplicated ad liberandum. That may be morally void, but that's the default - a strong case needs to be made to maintain the status quo without returning to that default.
- mirimir 10y agoI get your point. But just what is it to be a criminal on the Internet? I mean, copyright law in Russia emphasizes fair use far more than does copyright law in the US. Laws about pornography are very different in Japan vs the US vs Saudi Arabia. Also, regarding Pirate Bay, the MPAA etc who persecuted them are arguably the major criminals involved. Because they have abused their power to defraud artists, and to fix the prices of CDs and DVDs.
- megous 10y agoI couldn't care less about content creators. I'll start caring a little bit when they stop stealing from me every single time I buy a SD card, or HDD, or DVD, or whatever that has some storage in it that will never see any of their material. Until then... Piracy is also a form of protest and a valid one. It's a shame that when they make something worthwhile at times, I'll pirate it too, but if they want to be indiscriminate, I'll not bother discriminating either. To clarify: I live in a country where we have to pay tax to content creators organization every time we buy something with storage. And it's not an insignificant amount. Justification being: "It can be used for storing copyrighted material (music and movies)."
- s73ver 10y ago"I couldn't care less about content creators." Then stop consuming content. "Piracy is also a form of protest and a valid one." No more than me coming up and taking your stuff, or me hiring you and then refusing to pay you.
- gremlinsinc 10y ago>>So, we should just let it crash and burn down, pick up the pieces and start over? Yes, with the focus on the big war on this extreme capitalism. I couldn't vote, but I was hoping Sarah Palin won last time in the US elections. I'm hoping Donald Trump wins this year's election. For the reason that it will fuck up that country so much faster then if a less bad President wins. Our whole world is just so focused on money, money, money. That's the biggest problem. That's why everything fucks up. That's the target we have to fix. We need to make sure that we are going to get a different focus in life. [09:20] Hopefully technology will give us robots that will take away all the jobs, which will cause like a massive worldwide unemployment; somewhat like 60 percent. People will be so unhappy. That would be great, because then you can finally see capitalism crashing so hard. There is going to be a lot of fear, lost blood, and lost lives to get to that point, but I think that's the only positive thing I see, that we are going to have a total system collapse in the future. Hopefully as quick as possible. I would rather be 50 then be like 85 when the system is crashing. -- ^^ THIS THIS THIS. This is what I hoped for when Bernie Sanders lost, and it looks like it's coming to fruition, Trump is king, and America's going to shit pretty darn fast, soon things will get so bad that people wake up and demand real change. I don't think all capitalism is bad, I think unchecked corporate/chrony capitalism is. Was a time in America where we had capitalism but every dollar over like $10 mill was taxed at near 100% --so that CEO's would instead pay their employees more, or hire new ones and grow the company instead of pad their pockets.
- DannyB2 10y agoThe problem is human greed. Even if you burn everything down and rebuild, the problem of greed remains. Oh, and lust for power. See all of human history. Those who fail to learn history are doomed to repeat it. (Usually in summer school.)
- nickthemagicman 10y agoIf greed was the only driving force in human history we wouldn't have democracy, philosophy, sciences, etc. There's plenty of other powerful counteracting forces to greed in the human psyche and society, like justice, social consciousness, and fairness. It takes education and awareness, I think to really feel like those are important. And America is increasingly becoming less educated and aware.
- demonshalo 10y agoOooh the good old democratic myth. Perhaps Carlin was right all along (which he usually is): "Inside every cynical person is a disappointed idealist". Sunde was one of my heroes growing up in Sweden when I was a socialist and believed in the collective's ability to fight for the sake of what is deemed as "good". But, like every child, I had to eventually grow up and realize that most things are about trade-offs in this world - which is far better of a deal than most think it is. > "I'm a socialist. I know Marx and communism did not work before, but I think in the future you have the possibility of having total communism and equal access to everything for everybody." I realize now, looking back at the ideas Sunde holds and in turns the ideas that I held for a long time, that I was naive. Sunde, like everyone else in that camp fails to realize what is right in front of their eyes. Capitalism will not self-destruct. Socialism prevented capitalism from self-destructing and instead empowered it by showing everyone that capitalism, with all its flaws and disgusting habits, is the only system that is able to empower and uplift more people from poverty than all other systems COMBINED. I understand his position yet I can't help but facepalm every time I hear someone say "equal access to everything for everybody". This statement is perhaps, one of the stupidest things that have EVER been uttered by a human yet it is something that I used to deeply believe in. Makes me kidna wonder where I would be today had I kept believing in fairy tales...
- mi100hael 10y ago> Makes me kidna wonder where I would be today had I kept believing in fairy tales... Probably watching Bernie hand over your life-savings worth of donations to the same Clinton & DNC that predictably cheated him out of a win.
- demonshalo 10y agosounds about right!
- dieppe 10y ago> Socialism prevented capitalism from self-destructing and instead empowered it by showing everyone that capitalism, with all its flaws and disgusting habits, is the only system that is able to empower and uplift more people from poverty than all other systems COMBINED. I disagree. Capitalism has not empowered people (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx%27s_theory_of_alienation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx%27s_theory_of_alienation) and does not uplift people from poverty. Human kind is now able to produce so much that extreme poverty should not even exist anymore. We're able to produce thousand times as much goods per worker as in the 1700s, and yet do we live (and by we I mean all the workers, not just us with high-level jobs in rich countries) that much better than at that time? We produce enough food for hunger to disappear on a global scale, and yet we prefer to burn or stock what cannot be sold because we care more about the exchange value of things than the lives it could save. We could use machines instead of workers in mines (like in Congo), but we prefer to send workers through toxic muds because we care more about profit than the lives of these workers. I do agree that capitalism is a system that has had a significant impact on our ability to produce more goods, and that in some countries we can see a positive impact (mostly due as you said to socialism and the fact that workers actually fought to soften their living conditions), but look at it globally. And look at recent years too, with poverty skyrocketing even in the most "advanced" countries.
- sremani 10y agoPeople esp. promoting Marxism, do not even footnote mention the human cost of Soviet gulags or Mao's cultural revolution. If Marxism is so awesome, why did the Chinese reform in 1979, did any one care to understand? What was the state of China and Russia in these periods? Capitalism has flaws and number of them, no doubt, but best of options available on table. The only way out is improving Capitalism, not subverting it, but if that is your choice, many nations tried that and have failed miserably. If you love Price Controls, go ask Indian farmers the havoc it creates If you want fixed exchange rates, go look at Venezuela and black markets If you want subsidies, look at Venezuela or any n number of nations, where smuggling is rampant The alternative paths are taken the better ones ended up as dead-ends and the worse ones, swallowed people like quagmires.
- xj9 10y agoyou are talking about some specific brands of communist thought. Mao had some ideas. Lenin had others. lots of other groups have tried different ideas to varying degrees of success. there are a lot of schools of thought who strongly disagree on each-other's methods. one particular disagreement is on the utility and viability of a "vanguard party" or "dictatorship of the proletariat". history has shown us that it doesn't work. capitalism is useful. collective action is powerful. individual empowerment is important. Capitalism v. Communism is a good dialectic, but framing it as a war is stupid. it isn't about winning for one side or the other, its about building an economic system that maximizes our happiness and potential in an efficient way.
- sremani 10y ago>>varying degrees of success. Examples and references on this one. This cop out is amazing from Marxist apologists, you show 40 countries with 40 flavors of Communism for a span of 40 years basically screwing their societies, the answer always seems to be "that is not real communism". Not buying it! If you have goods to sell, show them!
- humble_dev 10y agoWell I am big believer in so-called techno communism. The problem with communism in past was that people had to do dirty work, if we automate every possible job and create basic income we will end-up with some sort of communism. It wasn't possible to implement true communism in the past and still I think we are not ready to implement it just yet, but 50 100 or maybe 200 years from now communism will be superior, another problem with past implementation of communism was lack of democracy. We need true democratic communism based on technology and freedom.
- zackmorris 10y agoI firmly agree that the free and open internet is in a slow state of decline. The speed at which people are willing to accept that decline without even realizing it’s happening is pretty staggering, and certainly not the responsibility of one person to fix. I’m wondering though if maybe the community can remedy that by bolstering the techniques that are still good. Off the top of my head: * Eliminate the notion of a second class netizen: WebRTC, STUN etc to overcome the mistake of NAT (which still exists in IPv6) * Separate content from source: distributed hash table (DHT) in place of subresource integrity (SRI) * Encryption everywhere: letsencrypt.org and other providers, with fast start (begin sending encrypted data before full handshake to eliminate startup delay) * Trust networks that can be trusted to work: Diaspora, possibly others (I am the least familiar with this aspect of P2P networks) * Nearly free backbone: cell phone hotspots and rooftop boxes that can run a meshnet at full bandwidth, using existing DHT and CDN concepts to cache data blocks locally I’ve written these from easiest to hardest to the best of my ability. Maybe part of the reason the web is failing is that its fundamental software and hardware were created under assumptions that cater more to system administration or the profit motive than they do to full self-actualization of the user. Few of these infrastructure improvements will come from the corporate sector, but they’re needed as a foundation for a real web 2.0 that isn’t a walled garden.
- nafizh 10y ago" I couldn't vote, but I was hoping Sarah Palin won last time in the US elections. I'm hoping Donald Trump wins this year's election. For the reason that it will fuck up that country so much faster then if a less bad President wins. Our whole world is just so focused on money, money, money. That's the biggest problem. That's why everything fucks up. That's the target we have to fix. We need to make sure that we are going to get a different focus in life."