16 ms·
Bay Area professionals indicted for H-1B visa fraud
- tsunamifury 10y agoAuto plays an ad at full volume. -- closed.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- FesterCluck 10y agoSince I consider the content an important read, here's a text-only google cache link: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/03/25/bay-area-tech-executives-indicted-for-h-1b-visa-fraud/&num=1&strip=1&vwsrc=0 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
- pm90 10y agoFrom the article: > The indictment charges that from 2010 to 2016, Dynasoft petitioned to place workers at Stanford University, Cisco and Brocade, but the employers had no intention of receiving the foreign workers named on the applications. Should be noted that this is only the most brazen, harebrained scheme that has been uncovered and is being convicted. Not that its not important; but it may be more useful overall to go after the Big Co's that are doing everything technically legally but are still using H1B in ways it was not meant to be used. Edit: Also just realized, when you say "Bay Area Tech Executives" it almost sounds like you're talking about Larry Page; but these "executives" were only officers of a shell company (seemingly) meant exclusively for committing visa fraud.
- skrebbel 10y ago> Edit: Also just realized, when you say "Bay Area Tech Executives" it almost sounds like you're talking about Larry Page I'm sure that was the author's intention.
- Animats 10y agoThis is progress. Give a copy of this to your employer if they start talking about replacing you with an H1-B.
- chrisper 10y agoThis makes no sense. If you are getting replaced then it's through an outsourcing company. Your employer wouldn't even be doing the fraud. It's the outsourcing company.
- TuringNYC 10y agoIn many cases, the employers are also engaging in tangential fraud. A common situation is for employers to post impossible experience requirements at an impossibly low salaries...obviously no qualified candidates come through...and then claim they searched domestically unsuccessfully. The kicker is that the H1 resource often then hired lacks most of the impossible requirements. The H1 system is completely gamed by both outsources and employers with legions of people at both places gaming the paperwork. It really needs a total overhaul. I'm not against foreign workers, but we should be getting the best foreign workers, not just the cheapest ones we can find. A good system might be a reverse auction system where H1s are allotted first to the highest offer and goes down until allotments are filled. Then, perhaps employers would consider all the local graduates and reserve H1 spots for exceptional talent we need from overseas.
- lsjdfkljdfwkwdf 10y agoSore loser, you deserve losing your job
- sctb 10y agoWe ban accounts that make personal attacks like this, so please don't (no matter what you're responding to). https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- FesterCluck 10y agoI've personally witnessed the hiring of a contractor from India at a small development company simply to save on funds. There were plenty of skilled workers in our pool to fill the position, the owner simply didn't want to pay the price. Weeks into his employment the developer came to me and asked if there was anyone he could report work complaints to. I gave him contact information for the state's employment agency. It took another week before I realized that he needed to be informed that the state agency protects him whether he's a citizen or not, and that he wasn't trying to report a former employer. I know many talented people who have come to the US on H-1B clean and have been successful. I, too, do not blame the workers. The employers are abusing the system, and if it continues there must be much stricter oversight.
- iliketosleep 10y agoSo long as a loophole exists that satisfy the conditions of being relatively easy to exploit, weakly enforcement, and offer significant competitive advantage (i.e. savings on salaries), companies will exploit it. Finding loopholes in the system to enhance profits and be more competitive is part of a game. So I find it difficult to blame employers. The problem lies in policy and enforcement; something is very wrong if it makes sense from a business and risk management perspective to break the rules.
- toyg 10y agoWhenever people moan about enforcement of white-collar-crime laws, I can't help but think about the last scene in The Wolf of Wall Street: after a short stint in prison, DiCaprio's scummy businessman is still rich and admired, while the FBI guy who took him down shares a cheap subway ride with other poor, tired and depressed workers. Incentives are wrong all over the place, Reaganism made authorities fundamentally powerless. Why would any civil servant sweat prosecuting big businesses, when he can just close an eye and wait for a revolving door to appear shortly after?
- iliketosleep 10y agoYou've highlighted a contradiction in the general public which I find quite disturbing. The worship and admiration of the very people (or even companies, in some cases) who screw them over.
- deepnotderp 10y agoIt's annoying that SV tech companies get a bad rap with the H-1B even though that the real people abusing these visas are clearly outsourcing firms like Tata and Infosys.
- throwawaysv001 10y agoTrue.. Im Indian.. I came to the US on a H-1B.. My wife is on a H-1B.. We both are employed in the bay area and make close to 450K per annum.. with about $1.5M in stocks vesting in the next few years..
- yummyfajitas 10y agoIt's not Tata and Infosys either. Those guys are too big to avoid playing more or less by the rules. The actual people playing games like this are small time bodyshops. It'll be two cousins from Ahmedebad starting a shop in the US and hiring a bunch of locals via their personal network. They then attempt to socially isolate their employees, getting them set up in the local Guju community, so they don't talk to outsiders and discover their true market worth.
- WalterBright 10y agoI'm not sure how anyone could be prevented from using google to research how much they are worth. Edit: To clarify, I am commenting on the parent's remark that employers are preventing employees from finding this out.
- patio11 10y agoWould you believe that I took a $30k a year programming job as a legal immigrant in the knowledge that it would require 60+ hour weeks because it was my impression that it was the best option available to me? "I'm clearly not Google material; I can barely get this J2EE app working", "I perceive that I am working uphill against racism in hiring managers", "I owe my sponsor for this job because they treated me fairly", "Literally no one in my friend group or family has a better job than this at my age", "I suppose this is what 'paying my dues' means and I have been aggressively cultivated to do so since before I could read", "My BATNA is deportation", "Well they are offering a 50% premium on a grad student stipend", etc, can do an awful lot of work.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- la6470 10y agoGuys nothing is gonna happen .. h1b abuses will continue as before so will l1 and b1 visa abuses, your jobs will be shipped to Mexico China India and Machineland. There has to be an international agreement that any company that sells to USA Europe China and India need to pay a special tax that will allow universal basic income for residents of those countries. That is the price for accessing the largest markets in the world that companies should pay.
- hrshtr 10y agoIn bay area there are quite a handful of such firms which fake person resume and help them find out the job. What surprises me is that employer does catch the difference in experience while interviewing and bunch of positions are filled. These firms file h1b shown more experience than what a person does actually have and make good money out of such schemes :(
- callalex 10y agoPlease rephrase your comment in complete, comprehensible English sentences.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago"In the bay area there are quite a handful of such firms which fake a person's resume and help them get a job. What surprises me is that the employer does catch the difference in experience while interviewing and a bunch of positions are filled (anyway?). These firms file h1b applications showing more experience than the person actually has and make good money out of such schemes :(" It seemed mostly comprehensible to begin with. I think a discussion of immigrant visas is actually a really poor place to insist on only hearing from people who speak perfect english.
- ireadfaces 10y agoCan we spare Larry page? Or next time someone searches H1B fraud, Google will show 'Larry page' as suggestion.
- Buge 10y agoI would think Larry Page of all people should be able to fix that problem.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 59nadir 10y agoIf we keep writing Larry Page, will Larry Page show up when one googles "H1B fraud"? Will Larry Page actually be ranked higher based on the many mentions of Larry Page?
- briandear 10y agoI think Larry Page would have a higher Page Rank at least?
- camillomiller 10y agoStop it! We're keyword stuffing this Page with Larry Page.
- 10y ago
- org3432 10y agoOther than anecdotal stories, are there stats from a reputable source on how widespread this is and what the real impact is?
- mavelikara 10y agoDelighted to see more of these parasites getting indicted. Here they are plotting to keep more of their employees enslaved in long GC backlogs https://youtu.be/lj1bHpPvSuE https://youtu.be/lj1bHpPvSuE
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- diogenescynic 10y agoThey also need to start going after the lawyers at the immigration firms who knowingly assist in fraud and even coach the applicants how to respond to USCIS questions. There is rampant fraud going on. I've seen it firsthand and know dozens of others in the industry who have as well.
- mavelikara 10y agoThey have started doing just that. From [1]: An immigration attorney for two information technology companies today admitted that she submitted phony documents and obstructed a federal investigation as part of a scheme that fraudulently obtained foreign worker visas, U.S. Attorney Paul J. Fishman announced. Sunila Dutt, 39, of Ashburn, Virginia, pleaded guilty before U.S. District Judge Kevin McNulty in Newark federal court to an information charging her with conspiracy to commit visa fraud and obstruct justice. Like you said, they need to do more of those though. [1]: https://www.justice.gov/usao-nj/pr/virginia-immigration-attorney-admits-visa-fraud-obstruction-justice https://www.justice.gov/usao-nj/pr/virginia-immigration-atto...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- notliketherest 10y ago"Dynasoft Synergys" did anyone else LOL
- Neliquat 10y agoBuzzword bucket naming strikes again...
- writer77 10y agoBeyond this, there's an entire system that has undermined American software engineers. Schools are incentivized by the ridiculous out of state/country fees they get when they accept international students for their Masters programs, regardless of a students actual abilities or whether the three year Indian/China/U.K. Bachelors sufficiently prepares them. These people always graduate, because money. Corporations, who love hiring people who can't leave them for another employer then gobble them up legally by requiring a masters degree in job description. And once they gain a big enough foothold in a company, the Good Ole Boy Club effect happens and they mostly hire their own.
- vxNsr 10y ago>> Schools are incentivized by the ridiculous out of state/country fees they get when they accept international students for their Masters programs, regardless of a students actual abilities or whether the three year Indian/China/U.K. Bachelors sufficiently prepares them. These people always graduate, because money. I've personally worked in a University Department that was tasked with marketing to international students and can say that this is entirely true. To the point that the school reserved a certain number of spots exclusively for out of state/international under the guise of diversity. In most schools it's not even where you think it is, recruitment and admissions had little to no control over us. We had a direct line to the top and were actually the ESL program, we gave students who graduated (the ESL program) a guaranteed spot in whichever college they wanted within our university, and we would take basically anyone who paid. So if you wanted to short circuit the regular admissions process and are willing to pay you'd apply to our ESL program >> spend 4-6 months there >> pass through because $$$ >> enter your bachelor program of choice at a fairly high state school.
- silentguy 10y agoIn a way overseas students subsidize the education of local american students in exchange of access of job market. It seems like a fair deal to me.
- johnnyb9 10y agoJust because they pay full tuition doesn't mean domestic students pay less. If anything they are subsidizing the salaries of the people working at the universities.
- ComodoHacker 10y agoI wonder why people here praise free competition on a global market as a primary value when they talk about their products and services, but support competition limiting when it comes to the labor market in their own country.
- baddox 10y agoPure self-interest, I would imagine.
- mvpu 10y agoIt's not about competition limiting, it's about unfair pricing and abuse. It's not fair to replace a local worker with a foreign worker because they're cheaper. And, there are tons and tons of staffing firms who systematically abuse the H1B program - they funnel workers from different countries (especially India), often mistreat them / threaten them / underpay them.
- paradite 10y ago> It's not fair to replace a local worker with a foreign worker because they're cheaper. I think you just disagreed with the concept of globalization. Granted that human resources are more complex than other resources. However, judging by your use of term "unfair pricing" on human, you seem to make no distinction between them in this discussion.
- Klockan 10y ago> It's not fair to replace a local worker with a foreign worker because they're cheaper. Why not? I'd argue that it is more unfair that an American worker gets paid many times more than an Indian worker even when they do exactly the same job. Letting those Indian workers come to America and compete on more equal terms is among the fairest things you can do.
- anjc 10y agoFair to who?
- rattray 10y agoThe title is a bit sensationalist and misleading; "Bay Area staffing executive indicted for H-1B visa fraud" would be more accurate. One of the two people indicted is the CEO of a staffing company ("Dynasoft Synergy" in Fremont); the other has worked at a couple companies including Cisco, not explicitly in an executive capacity.
- dang 10y agoThanks. We've changed the title to make it less misleading.
- elastic_church 10y agoThe charge alone will deter alottttt If you think rumors spread fast in the states, wait till you see asymmetric information spread through India
- known 10y agoIt's even worse https://qz.com/889524 https://qz.com/889524
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- thinkcomp 10y agoThe case docket is here: https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/34ncju6ac/california-northern-district-court/usa-v-murugan-et-al/ https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/34ncju6ac/california-north...
- LeicaLatte 10y agoclick.bait()
- anjc 10y agoEvery time a thread comes up on whether H-1B visa fraud exists there a cohort of posters who maintain that they've never seen it and that people who say that it happens are just racist and xenophobic. Remember this thread, and ones like it.
- bobosha 10y agoActually a significant number are little more than knee-jerk racism with "all 'em jerbs are belong to me" attitude. Ohh and anecdotes galore how horrible h1bs are, and how an american white knight had to come save the day. Remember this too.
- anjc 10y agoI don't have to remember it, it's the stock response dished out to people who've actually been affected by it and have seen it first hand.
- Velox 10y agoThis thread is great. Whenever H-1B threads come up on HN, I prepare for the onslaught of what can only be described as hatred. It's the view of many people on this site that all H-1B holders are "cheaters" of the system, and they don't deserve to get a job in the US. As a former H-1B holder, the threads always made me feel guilty, and feel bad about wanting to work for a well regarded, successful company. It's nice, and refreshing, to see that it's not the view of everyone, and that H-1B holders are equals and deserve the same rights as everyone else.
- yardie 10y agoYou're confusing this site with Slashdot.I don't think any HNers believe that all H1-B holders see cheaters. We do realize the H1-B scheme is relatively easy to cheat. I have seen both sides to this. I've worked with brilliant developers on H1-B visas who were brought in as the system intended. I've also seen lots of job postings that were tailored to meet the requirements of a H1-B position, i.e. Poorly formatted, unintelligible, word salad with impossible requirements. Disneyland firing their IT staff and replacing all of them with an exclusive H1-B outsourcer raised all kinds of alarms. It was stories like these that made the government scrutinize those visa schemes further. Glad to see people going to jail for it.
- Amezarak 10y agoI don't think I, or most other people who are against the H1B visa system, have anything against H-1B holders themselves. They're obviously everyday people who are doing what's right for themselves and taking a big risk that generally pays off pretty well for them. If I was in their place, I hope I would have the cojones to do the same thing. Picking up and moving to another country is a big deal. What I have a problem with is the companies who employ them. The intent of the H1-B visa is for companies to be able to hire workers with skills they can't hire for in America. The reality is that 99% of H1-B programmers are hired because they're cheaper or some other anti-labor reason. There is not a shortage of programmers in the US - I'll grant there could be in Silicon Valley or California - these companies are not looking very hard for programmers, and they're more willing to get someone from a foreign country than pay for relocation for someone from say, Iowa, or to open an office there. So, frankly, I see virtually every tech company hiring H1-Bs as committing immigration fraud in order to screw over people like me. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H1b#No_labor_shortages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H1b#No_labor_shortages - basically sums it up. Unlike other people in this thread, I don't give a fig for free markets, except to the extent they make people's lives better, which they do have a decent track record of doing in many instances. Since I live in America and only the US government has direct power over the lives of Americans, I judge US government policy by that criteria. It seems clear to me a global free market for labor is the worst thing imaginable for Americans in the short term, and the world population in the very long run. Free immigration is a handout to corporations, who want to expand the labor pool as much as possible so they can play us all off against each other on a grand scale. It disgusts me enough to watch corporations and businesses play off state and national governments against each other for tax incentives and subsidies. I'm not interested in programming being a minimum-wage job or living under any more of a global techno-corporate system than I already do.
- bobosha 10y agoI know what you are going to say: "There are plenty of IT jobs, just not enough at the salaries, us american programmers feel entitled to"
- faragon 10y agoIs there any study analyzing performance between H-1B tech workers and remote tech workers? (i.e. how being in the same building or working in different time zone affects planning and performance)
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoThe problem with H1-B's is what in Spain we call "ni chicha ni limoná" - which means that it is something half-baked or half-way from being A or B. H1-B seems to increase competition among workers, but in fact it does not, because H1-B workers are captive workers. They don't enjoy the same rights as their local counterparts. They can't leave the company and start applying for other jobs. This leads to abuse from businesses.
- sulam 10y agoThey certainly can apply for other jobs! True they can't quit and then look for work. I know some people do that, but most don't. The ones that do are usually very senior with good savings, so they can afford to take a few months off while they do their job search. Regular schmoes take a sick day to go interview.
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoThanks for clarifying, I reckon my comment was probably not clear enough.
- everybodyknows 10y agoBusinesses, the smaller ones run by honest founders, are in a way the most tragic of all the H-1B victims. Not shielded by layers of middle management, they see with their own eyes the way H-1B really works -- the lies they would have to tell to hire the low-priced labor. They want to be honest and law-abiding, to be the kind of parents their children can respect. But business has been unprofitable and is not improving, and tuition, mortgage, taxes are due at the end of the month. How would any of us act, in their place? The choices are: 1. Hire H-1B, or 2. "The right thing" -- chapter 7 bankruptcy.
- virtuabhi 10y agoIn the threads where we discuss H1B visa holders taking American jobs, can we also consider that American companies are selling their products in countries from where H1B workers come from? Google's Android biggest growth region is India. Why shouldn't then Indians work in Google? Maybe Google should move its headquarters from MV to Bangalore. Alphabet can remain in US. Or another US company, lets say Pepsi, outsources its IT work to an Indian company, Infosys. And everyone in India is drinking Pepsi. Why is it wrong that IT work in Pepsi is done by Infosys? Should India ban Pepsi because Pepsi Inc. has more non-Indians than Indians? I am not surprised that EU is actively fining US companies like Google and Apple, and China does not allow US companies in the first place. And if xenophobic and protectionist polices continue in US, then I am afraid that countries like India will have to do the same like EU or China.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- eanzenberg 10y agoThat's fine, have them open an office in India and hire locally. Ever wonder why they don't on a massive scale?
- dboreham 10y agoThey do. One of the justifications for the H-1B and similar programs is that it benefits the US economy by having work that could have been performed overseas, done domestically, and moves the associated smart, high taxpaying people inside the country.
- ma2rten 10y agoGoogle has a big office in India. https://qz.com/403654/google-is-doubling-its-headcount-in-hyderabad-heres-how-to-get-hired-there/ https://qz.com/403654/google-is-doubling-its-headcount-in-hy...
- virtuabhi 10y agoYes, I have wondered about that. As I said in the comment, you will see more companies moving out of US if xenophobia and protectionist policies are not contained. Also, if you are software engineer have you ever wondered why your salary is close to $100k rather than, say $50k? Think about this. It might be due to the fact that even after being located in US, your company can sell its good and services all around the world.
- throw2bit 10y agoI am on H1B, but my job in US is being threatened by fake H1Bs from India who are willing to work on salaries lesser than mine, particularly from the state called Andhra Pradesh in India. There are many one room consultancies all over the US which runs fake payrolls and even apply something called "Future Greencards" for people who are willing to pay money. These Andhra consultancies can be found in abundance in New Jersey, Edison, and on West coast. There is even a temple in Andhra Pradesh where you can go and pray to get selected in H1B. Even though I was a legitimate H1B worker, when the rules become strict to counter these fake H1Bs, I might also get affected, so I moved to Canada with Express Entry, which is based on skills. Fake H1Bs cannot fake IELTS exam and Canada does thorough verification and police clearances. So that its Express Entry system is not abused like H1B system of US.
- zerr 10y agoBut 6-figure salaries are quite rare in Canada (for engineers).
- effingwewt 10y agoCost of living is cheaper, and what does losing a couple thousand a year matter compared to job and housing security?
- throw2bit 10y agoAnother typical scheme - There are many Indian IT managers who got GreenCard around the Y2K rush. Now they are settled US citizens working in big corporation's IT depts. They setup these one room consultancies as a side business and because of their strong ties to India, they source unskilled graduates from India thru fraudulent H1B satellite "offices" in India (many fraudulent satellite H1B offices are there in Bangalore & Hyderabad in India), since H1B is a lottery, no scrutiny of candidate's skills are done by USCIS. They take the applicant's "word" for it. Now when the big corporations have IT openings, these managers wont publish the openings in job portals. They recruits these H1Bs from their own consultancies with a high billing rate, indirectly making profits. They also take a cut from the H1Bs salary on a monthly basis as a "fees" for brining H1Bs to US.
- umbs 10y agoI don't think the H1-B abuse is straightforward. IMO, many institutions (private and government) are deeply entangled in this. 1. There are many poor universities promising MS degrees in CS (here in California, there's Silicon Valley University, ITU etc). Not casting aspersions, but I doubt the quality of education from them. 2. Students can't get funding/scholarship. They tend to do odd jobs to make ends meet (many are illegal as students can't work outside of campus). They get in to severe debt. 3. Once they get a degree, clock is ticking to get a H1B. Note that recent OPT extensions give them breathing time. But nonetheless, they must get H1B to stay in country. 4. This is where one room consultancies come in to picture. They sponsor H1B and legally allow staying in US. 5. Students start working at lower end of pay spectrum. A friend of mine is willing to work for $20 - $25/hour (after commissions to consultancies) even after 10+ years of experience. The friend is in web application testing. 6. Sticking with consulting firms, it takes long time to break the "low income" cycle as projects are short lived, pay is low and job insecurity is high. So, #3 and #4 are serving each other. Private universities gets income from students. US consulates in Asia give visas with, probably, tax dollars in mind. I even suspect private universities have some sort of lobbying that allow students from Asian (or other) countries to come for education. So, my point is, this H1-B visa thing is quite deep and goes way back to universities and students coming for education.
- Thunder123 10y agoThese Indians are some low down dirty dogs they will scam and cheat the system all day long even putting dirty dog supervisors in place to cover their filthy behavior.
- Thunder123 10y agoThese lowdown dirty dog Indians are the most treacherous scam running bastards ever only the dirty chinese can give them a run for their top dirty dog status these Indians will promote indian supervisors to help cover the stealing and scamming going on God is my witness these Indians are some dirty dogs indeed.
- caltrain 10y agoUnrelated: Elon Musk was on H-1B before Paypal days.
- s0me0ne 10y agoNow if we could get companies on intern fraud that would be great. Interns are not legally supposed to take jobs from real workers, be unpaid (unless you are a non-profit), or be used for real work right away (like things that might be used 9 months from now possibly). But their main purpose is to teach them, not to be used for cheap/free labor.