11 ms·
10,000 Games projects have been successfully funded on Kickstarter
- overcast 10y agoI REALLY need to stop backing projects. It's almost getting ridiculous how many board games are coming my way this year. Kingdom Death was craziness.
- teej 10y agoThis seems like the perfect opportunity to ask: do you have any recommendations of board games for a couple that loves them?
- Clanan 10y agoNot the parent but I'll chime in. It really depends on the type of games you enjoy. Mechanic-heavy ("eurogames") vs. more themed ("ameritrash"), cooperative, competitive, etc. BoardGameGeek is a great site for reference. Off the top of my head, my wife and I enjoy: Ticket to Ride, Splendor, Ascension, Lost Cities, Settlers of Catan, Elder Sign.
- Filligree 10y agoI don't have nearly as much experience, but Ghost Stories is one of my favorites.
- jashper 10y agoCheck out 7 Wonders Duel (the 1v1 version) ; my girlfriend and I play it all the time, it's surprisingly well-balanced
- acomjean 10y agoI'll second 7 Wonders Duel as a good two player. Other 2 players we like Patchwork and 7 Tiny Epic Gallaxies
- sdenton4 10y agoRace for the Galaxy is amazingly good with two players. Especially with the first expansion. (The following expansions are kinda meh, though.) Jaipur is a great made for two players game. I'll also endorse the recs for Elder Sign, seven wonders duel, and Splendor. I love love love Pixel Tactics, though it's a bit too aggressive for my partner...
- thaumasiotes 10y agoTo play with each other or as part of a group? There's a deep, deep division between 2-player games and 3+ player games.
- rkho 10y agoI recently picked up Scythe and loved it enough to buy every possible add-on and piece upgrade for it :)
- 2muchcoffeeman 10y agoTwilight Struggle
- omni 10y agoPeople on HN love to hate on Reddit but /r/boardgames is a great community where you can find many, many answers to questions like this. https://reddit.com/r/boardgames https://reddit.com/r/boardgames
- finiter 10y agoIn particular, see their wiki page for exactly this question: https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/wiki/wsig https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/wiki/wsig
- overcast 10y agoCaverna, Food Chain Magnate, Dead of Winter, Blood Rage, Fury of Dracula, Arkham Horror Card Game. Are you into miniatures? You can go seriously deep down the rabbit hole with that stuff.
- dugditches 10y agoDo users of Kickstarter/Patreon have a set 'budget' for supporting? Or is just spur of the moment where something you really want to support comes up and you do so? What's the process where you back something with a 'large' amount but then a new project that needs the support more, that you feel more strongly about comes along?
- sersi 10y agoI have a budget of $150/month that I allocate to Patreon/Kickstarter. If I spend a bit more over a month because there were multiple projects that caught my fancy, I try to spend less the next few months. I mostly spend money on projects that I believe would have a lower chance of happening without kickstarter. For patreon, I mostly fund comics and webnovels. Sidenote, I dislike Patreon. They have a great idea but the interface is really awful and it hasn't improved much. I wish someone more worthy had had that idea first because with the network effect, it would be hard for a competitor to get traction.
- makomk 10y agoAfter they left everyone's personal data on a computer with a web-facing root Python shell for a week after being warned about it and it got leaked, I refuse to do business with Patreon full stop.
- Dylan16807 10y agoPatreon is a budget. It's not really comparable to kickstarter unless you're doing weird one-off juggling.
- overcast 10y agoI'd like to say there is a budget. It's mostly whatever looks interesting budget. But I DO limit myself to only board games.
- n2dasun 10y agoI'm in the same boat.
- JoeDaDude 10y agoThe board game industry, being a niche market, has long used pledge programs in which consumers commit to buy a game before it is manufactured. Kickstarter has taken over a lot of this, so some fraction of the Kickstarter games were made by established game publishers rather than individuals or new enterpreneurs.
- 1123581321 10y agoI don't think many pre-existing board game pledge programs moved to Kickstarter, though am happy to be corrected. The most prominent pledge system is GMT's and it is still thriving. Most non-Hasbro/AEG/Asmodee board game publishers are smaller than GMT.
- JoeDaDude 10y agoGood observation, so perhaps it is better to say that there are some established publishers use Kickstarter as a de-facto pledge program. Granted, these publishers are not the major players like GMT or Decision Games. Some smaller players that do rely on Kickstarer are Mayday Games [1], Worthington Games [2], and Queen Games [3]. [1] https://www.kickstarter.com/profile/maydaygames/created https://www.kickstarter.com/profile/maydaygames/created [2] https://www.kickstarter.com/profile/1456271622/created https://www.kickstarter.com/profile/1456271622/created [3] https://www.kickstarter.com/profile/1016374822/created https://www.kickstarter.com/profile/1016374822/created
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lcw 10y agoI wonder why EA, Blizzard or the likes hasn't set up a site where you can vote on idea's for games like Lego Ideas has done for making lego sets. That's basically what's happening here except people are putting their money where their mouth is. It's like crowd sourcing idea, and they could probably make more desirable games. That said the companies would charge a premium and know they would get it.
- Impossible 10y agoSquare-Enix runs a site like this where indie game developers can post games and if they are voted up they help with publishing and crowdfunding (https://collective.square-enix.com https://collective.square-enix.com). Not exactly what you're suggesting but it has some similarities.
- chadgeidel 10y agoProbably because of intellectual property reasons. If someone suggests an idea it requires a lot of legal wrangling to get the rights to produce it. Once you start going down that road, then you have to justify budgets, ROI, compensation, etc. Additionally, if any game is made that even remotely resembles any part of the proposal, that opens up the potential for a lawsuit. It's basically the same reason that authors won't read your unpublished book and screenwriters won't read your unpublished screenplay.
- chii 10y agoEA could've simply make you agree to sign over all rights prior to adding/voting for said idea. The real problem with such a system is really just the vast majority of ideas are crap. But even the good ideas are difficult to execute - i m sure they aren't low on ideas, but execution prowess.
- nemothekid 10y agoSince you mentioned EA and Blizzard, I assume you are talking about AAA games (as there are plenty of india games on Kickstarter). Those games have budgets into the hundreds of millions of dollars, and I'd imagine that kind of money would be very difficult to crowdfund.
- danso 10y agoWould love to see this broken down into categories, e.g. Table Top vs. Video Games, and sub-categories, e.g. iOS/Android vs PC/Console. I've never backed a KS board game, but as an outsider/layperson, that category sounds like an unmitigated runaway success with huge-money-campaigns [0] like Kingdom Death ($12M) and Exploding Kittens ($8.7M), and then humble projects that later became huge, such as Cards Against Humanity ($15K) [1]. But I have backed video games and pay more attention to that category in general. So while I'm aware of great successes like FTL, Undertale, Shovel Knight, and Pillars of Eternity, the category of video game projects seems seems to be much more infused with skepticism and even hostility because of high profile failures like Mighty No. 9 and Clang [2]. Hell, one of the earliest high profile KS failure that I remember hearing about was Code Hero back in 2011 [3] Obviously, selection/survivor bias is in play here. I read tech blogs so I'll hear more about video game controversies than those of board games. But I feel -- as is the case for software development in general -- there are inherent challenges to video game development that make it seem more risky. Yes, board games have to deal with hardware-manufacturing issues, but it's hard to imagine anything like Star Citizen's creep scope happening to a board game campaign (not that SC is a failure, but its development has definitely evoked feelings of cynicism). [0] https://www.kickstarter.com/discover/advanced?category_id=12&sort=most_funded&seed=2484017&page=1 https://www.kickstarter.com/discover/advanced?category_id=12... [1] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/maxtemkin/cards-against-humanity https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/maxtemkin/cards-against... [2] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/260688528/clang https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/260688528/clang [3] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/primerist/code-hero-a-game-that-teaches-you-to-make-games-he https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/primerist/code-hero-a-g...
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> I've never backed a KS board game, but as an outsider/layperson, that category sounds like an unmitigated runaway success As someone with some direct experience with kickstarted board games, a few are smashing successes and quite a lot are, in terms of play, nothing special. I personally wouldn't want to back a campaign, because the odds are overwhelming that the final product wouldn't be something I'd really want to own. There are enthusiasts who take the opposite approach -- they back everything because sometimes you get a real gem.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bdcravens 10y agoHow many of those 10,000 projects failed to launch?
- Simon321 10y agoNone, that's what the word 'successfully' means.
- chaostheory 10y agoDoes being funded means that all the projects released games? Some successfully funded game Kickstarters failed to release anything.
- LoSboccacc 10y agothat's precisely what the article means. succesfully founded != succesfully released
- bdcravens 10y ago"successfully" isn't the word in contention here. Many projects on Kickstarter fund but fail to launch. From the article: "10,000 Games projects have been successfully funded on Kickstarter." Here's an older list of games that successfully funded but didn't launch: http://kotaku.com/12-successful-kickstarters-that-never-delivered-1687019268 http://kotaku.com/12-successful-kickstarters-that-never-deli... So successfully funding doesn't mean successful launch.
- frik 10y agoIs there a top 100 list ordered by metacritics score or some other currated top 100 list of those Kickstarter funded games? Beside Wasteland 2 and some adventures from former Lucasart developers I don't know any of the KS games.
- Pester 10y ago> Beside Wasteland 2 and some adventures from former Lucasart developers I don't know any of the KS games. You haven't heard of Pillars of Eternity?
- on_and_off 10y agoFTL, Rimworld, the Banner Saga, Hyper Light Drifter, Shovel Knight, SuperHot : there are many great (and original) games that have been funded through kickstarter.
- OSButler 10y agoKickstarter still feels like such a grey area to me. Only a few of the games I've backed ended up in a product that I would've bought, if it was a regular released game. Nowadays, I prefer waiting until the actual release version is available and then decide whether to buy it or not, but I'm not funding any more kickstarter games due to all the bad experiences.
- jedikv 10y agoThat's the most pragmatic approach. I don't give money to something untested and with no guarantees of getting a working/high-quality product (which aren't covered by regular consumer rights).
- LoSboccacc 10y agoI've always been cautious on these sites since failure is always an option. I tend to fund mostly games that have no chance of being made otherwise, for being niche or part of my weird passions (I love logistic survival games, there were none good being produced, backed factorio) I prefer to back those even if they fail than back mainstream succesful projects that would have been made anyway.
- Semaphor 10y agoFWIW, I've had more successes than problems with games. 11 games I'd have bought anyway [1] (mostly RPGs), 1 failure (The Mandate. Should have known, overly ambitious) 4 that are way overdue but still active (Star Citizen, InSomnia, Popup Dungeon and After Reset), 3 that are still in planned development (Vigilantes, Stygian and D:OS2) and only 2 games I didn't enjoy at all and normally wouldn't have bought (Jagged Alliance: Flashback, Satelite Reign) [1] Wasteland 2, Shadowrun Returns, Pillars of Eternity, Antharion, Balrum, Torment: Tides of Numenera, Balrum, RimWorld, Lords of Xulima, Blackguards, Shadowrun: Hongkong edit: And 100% sucess rate with tabletop/card games
- on_and_off 10y agoThe Mandate by Perihelion Interactive ? it's dev is still ongoing.
- jokoon 10y agoI wonder if people would be interested in an open source, open world, multiplayer 3d engine. Not something too fancy though, just the bare minimal. I guess it's not interesting... Or maybe some game developers would fund such engine?
- flohofwoe 10y agoApologies but this made me chuckle a bit. If you want to pull this off in a 'commercial environment' (where people actually need to be paid) you just asked for a couple hundred million dollars, with at least 5 years until the engine is production-ready, and a >95% chance of total failure. I'm not saying it's impossible in an open source environment of course (after all, Linux happened). But you need to start small, need to show steady progress over a couple of years, and if it works, be ready to spend the rest of your life with it ;)
- tmsbrg 10y agoWithout the multiplayer there's OpenMW: https://openmw.org/en/ https://openmw.org/en/ Without the open world there's DarkPlaces (based on Quake), with games like Xonotic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xonotic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xonotic Both are really good considering it's hard to make something like this tbh. Not sure if there's anything good that has all 4 of those things, though ;). People often underestimate just how much work game engines are. And also how useless they are without an actual game on them.
- cyphar 10y ago> Without the multiplayer there's OpenMW: https://openmw.org/en/ https://openmw.org/en/ From what I understand there are rumours that multiplayer is something they plan to develop after their 1.0 (feature-parity with the original Morrowind engine). There are already people making patchsets that add some form of multiplayer support.
- Pica_soO 10y agoI wonder, if you can by the stretch goal complexity ahead of time, how endangered a kickstarter project is to die of scope-creep.
- shados 10y agoI've had very mixed results with videogames on kickstarter. One took hundreds of thousands of dollars and used it on an unrelated game then went belly up. One is looking great and produced an awesome beta, but it's been years beyond the target date. Board games are a totally different story. Kickstarter started the the golden age of board games. Some of the best board games ever made come from there. They're almost always successful projects (not always good games, but they deliver at least). And that's not counting all the cool tabletop stuff like wyrmwood accessories. So now I only back board games. And I'm super happy with what I'm getting.
- GlennS 10y agoI've had an opposite experience. Most of the video games I've backed have turned out well, but the only board game I backed was quite meh. The board game was Mottainai. We did play it a few times, but my girlfriend found a strategy that works really well but makes the game boring (always just pray on your turn) on her first try. Data for video games: Great: FTL, Torment: Tides of Numenera. I didn't back the Pen and Paper RPG Numenera which Torment is set in, but it sounds really good. Good: Chaos Reborn, Sunless Sea, Dreamfall Chapters, Elite Dangerous, Broken Sword, Pillars of Eternity Bad: Godus. He made several of my favourite ever games, but Peter Molyneux is not getting a pre-order from me again. I can only assume that someone else was the talent at Bullfrog and Lionhead. Not finished yet: Battletech, Maia (early access is available and looks good) Never made: Unwritten. This was a victim of the US medical system. A refund was offered. Failed to meet target (therefore payment not taken): Ars Magica Video Game, The Ship: Full Steam Ahead, Nexus 2.
- LeoNatan25 10y agoThe more interesting statistic is of such and such "released" games, how many of those have fulfilled the satisfaction of supporters. With traditional mainstream "AAA" titles coming out in such buggy and disappointing states, this could be a differentiation. The problem is, I think KickStarter-backed game development has been even worse for the most part.
- abiox 10y agoi wonder what percentage of these game kickstarters actually resulted in a respectable finished product.
- elif 10y agoKickstarter made possible my favorite game, which is innovating and responding to players in a way I never thought was possible when I first funded it. By not needing a publisher, investors, deadlines, etc. They have been liberated, and it's so exciting to have no idea where the game is going next. Something about monthly sprints with fixed monthly releases, and completely public bug tracking/standup notes/public discussion forums makes for a really refreshing player experience that goes way beyond the game itself.
- SpikeDad 10y agoWhen Kickstarter was allowed to become an advertising platform for future product development it failed. Sorry but I'm not dropping a dime with some well established company looking to have free money printed for them to eliminate their risk and transfer it to regular folks. When Kickstarter starts taking responsibility for failed projects with at least some funds being returned, especially their 10% fee then I'll perhaps consider it again. Their logo should be someone shrugging their shoulders - that about their typical response when there's a problem.
- Grue3 10y agoAnd how many successfully completed? 100?
- synicalx 10y agoI'll start backing things again when the products I back actually start to ship/get finished. Hell I'll settle for some sort of guarantee that they'll ship what they promised ON TIME, and if they don't I get my money back. Until then, I'll stick to buying things that actually exist.