9 ms·
Not only are the bills coming due, but bureaucratic complacency has put people in charge who will not be honest about the state of the dams. See https://www.li
by btilly 10y ago
Not only are the bills coming due, but bureaucratic complacency has put people in charge who will not be honest about the state of the dams. See https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/oroville-tallest-dam-biggest-lie-united-states-scott-cahill https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/oroville-tallest-dam-biggest-... for a good analysis.
The problem is fundamental to human organizations. People like hearing what they want to hear. And any organization without disasters for long enough will lose barriers to having sycophants who say that rise to positions of power. The necessary result is a growing disconnect with reality.
As Feynman warned, "For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." People and organizations tend to remember this after absorbing the lessons from a disaster.
But a generation or two of no disaster returns sycophants to power. Guaranteeing that the next preventable disaster will some day come.
That day may come very soon indeed.
- devoply 10y agoReminds me of New Orleans. They told you the levies were gonna break. They are now telling you the dams are gonna collapse. It's gonna happen and then we'll deal with the problem after the catastrophe.
- ctdonath 10y agoI remember reading "New Orleans is going to flood" annually for 20+ years. Then it did.
- nikanj 10y agoThat's a good 20 years of someone getting their christmas bonus because they didn't waste budget on repairs
- Xorlev 10y agoAnd then they lost their homes. So there's that.
- throwanem 10y agoThink the folks who made out on the deal lived below sea level when they could afford not to?
- HarryHirsch 10y agoRemember the Susquehanna floods of 2011 following Tropical Storm Lee? FEMA had been sounding the alarm about the expected height of the 100-year flood for years and was going to redraw the flood maps, with much expanded flood plains. The plans found much popular resistance, because homeowners would have to pay mandatory flood insurance, and home values would be lower in a designated flood plain. Senator Chuckie Schumer put himself in front of the mob and successfully prevented the new floodplain designations from coming into force. Then the river flooded. If you were in the floodplain it was epic, if you were not it was nothing. The way I see it now is that developers will do what they can get away with and politicians will do whatever helps them stay in office. People really need to take responsibility for not being in the way of failing infrastructure, it's the only thing that works in our political system.
- nradov 10y agoGovernment employees typically don't get bonuses for such actions.
- alaxsxaq 10y agoWe've known about these risks for a very long time. In 1889, the South Fork Dam failed, after repeated concerns about its integrity, killing 2,209 people. I'm not sure about the economics, but I suspect that analysis would show that dealing with the outcome of failure is cheaper than trying to prevent it.
- joe_the_user 10y agoIndeed, It may require a series of truly extreme disasters. The US has become unimaginably prosperous and that power can be wielded to mislead and misguide and protect those who would siphon off its wealth for their purposes. And even to allow those the disasters which have occurred to benefit this same group - the "lesson" of the September 11th attacks was that we needed an even larger military-industrial complex and so-forth ad-infinitum. Fear so far has only kept one group in power and not even made that group itself fearful of the actual disasters looming but only fearful of losing that power.
- sandworm101 10y agoA generation or two without disaster? The US has seen many disasterous infrastructure failing in recent years. New orleans levies. That bridge in texas. The new york hurricane. The gas leak in LA. Train derailments (also in canada a couple years ago). I cannot see another disaster, even a failed dam, making all that much difference.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- irrational 10y agoThat bridge in one of those northern midwest states that starts with an M or a W.
- vkou 10y agoI-90 sinking in Seattle. Although, thankfully, nobody was hurt.
- wiredfool 10y agoYeah, well, that was ... special. The bridge was built as a bunch of concrete cells without watertight doors between them. The contractor was installing watertight doors, which meant sawing holes in the concrete. They couldn't let the cut water into the lake due to environmental reasons. So it was stored in the cells, reducing the freeboard. Then with most of the doors installed and open, a big storm blows up. Bridge is riding lower in the water due to the cut water. Water comes in and floods from cell to cell, and soon you've got a bunch of tugboats holding the surviving bridge from busting off its remaining anchor lines. That wasn't a case of decaying infrastructure (other than it was a retrofit), that was a case of construction mishap, along with a side of "If you had meant to sink a bridge, I don't suppose you could do anything more to hurry it along other than drilling a hole in the bottom(1)". (1) Which I've done/supervised, without the subsequent sinking of the bridge.
- maxerickson 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I-35W_Mississippi_River_bridge#Collapse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I-35W_Mississippi_River_bridge...
- taurath 10y ago> The problem is fundamental to human organizations I can't help but think about all the other countries who actually invest in their infrastructure and in public needs and have far better outcomes and social cohesion than the US. There's something wrong with this countries system of governance I feel.
- jwatte 10y agoBut the rich ruling class is richer and more powerful in the US. Thus, the US way is more successful (for the aristocracy.)
- kalleboo 10y agoIt does seem like the US ends up with extra poor outcomes with their government. Here in Japan, the government is surely also corrupt, with "bridges to nowhere" and construction contracts assigned on a buddy-buddy basis. But at least here that corruption still nets us well-maintained roads and top-notch train infrastructure... just arguably too much of it and at a high cost. In the US they end up with the high costs but none of the good infrastructure...
- saryant 10y agoIs Japan really the poster child for ethical corporate/government relationships given the TEPCO debacle around Fukushima?
- hackuser 10y ago> bureaucratic complacency It also could be a problem of elected officials and public complacency. Not to be partisan, but one political party has staunchly opposed almost all government spending and has single-mindedly reduced taxpayer investment in everything they could. That same party (maybe not the parent), as part of the campaign to reduce government activity, says government is unavoidably incompetent and blames that for all problems. Part of that is blaming "bureaucrats" (a bad word, apparently). Perhaps the problem is those elected officials. In this case I don't know, but a LinkedIn post by someone I don't know, filled with hyperbole, is not credible evidence either way.
- jahnu 10y ago> staunchly opposed almost all government spending That's their public position but they actually did the opposite. Steering the money away from what's needed to special interests.
- hackuser 10y ago> they actually did the opposite There have been massive cuts in large numbers of federal programs, and also at the state-level where the GOP has control.
- 1_2__3 10y agoAh yes the ol' "blame the electorate".
- coldpie 10y agoIf you vote for the party that promises to defund your public services, don't be surprised when your public services are defunded.
- Bartweiss 10y agoIf you vote for the party that doesn't promise that, then they lose and a bridge falls on you, that's not surprising either. A case like this is an argument against democracy as much as a criticism of voters. We can't assert majority rule and then say that bad outcomes are just karmic.
- killjoywashere 10y agoHaving bought a house in New Orleans 5 weeks before Katrina and watched the sycophants of the levee board move back in like nothing ever happened, this haunts my life. The replacement, Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authority, at least on the face of it, doesn't suck as bad: of 9 members, 5 must be engineers, 1 must be a civil engineer, and 1 must be a geologist. I'll take a technocrat over a bureaucrat any day. I say that as someone in US Federal government. I see a lot of both. A bureaucrat can literally be some secretary who was around to apply for a job that "had to be filled", and there are only so many people in these cities to fill the jobs. Oh yes. Let that sink in. By comparison, technocrats are generally experts in their field, often sought after by the agency because they're forced to by a mandate, and to person, for whatever insane reason, was willing to take a massive pay cut to render some public service.
- selimthegrim 10y agoIf it makes you feel any better, I just watched half of the Ninth Ward yell themselves hoarse at the Army Corps of Engineers at a community meeting over the planned expansion of the Industrial Canal (for MR-GO traffic (rolls eyes))
- killjoywashere 10y ago> If it makes you feel any better Not sure. Wouldn't a bump in canal traffic be good for the city?
- selimthegrim 10y agoWhat is the Ninth Ward going to see out of it? Didn't they say that with MR-GO, which turned out to be a complete boondoggle (and worse during Katrina)?
- dragonwriter 10y agoJust as a bureaucrat can be be some secretary who was around to apply for a job that "had to be filled", what you call a "technocrat" (actually, a bureaucrat in a position with a mandatory certification) can be someone who has that mandatory certification and is too incompetent to get any job that pays better than the vastly below-market public-sector payscale.
- M_Grey 10y ago"The burned hand teaches best. After that advice about fire goes to the heart." A whole generation is going to learn a bunch of lessons that have been forgotten, among them that infrastructure doesn't maintain itself. It's sad, because even in the best possible scenarios, a lot of the most helpless and disadvantaged are bound to suffer. At least with infrastructure failure at the level of dams, the destruction and death will be fairly democratic.
- Bartweiss 10y ago> A whole generation is going to learn a bunch of lessons that have been forgotten, among them that infrastructure doesn't maintain itself. This is a really strange framing. A lot of my friends went into either environmental/civil engineering or local politics. They spend their days fighting tooth and nail for money and support to fix infrastructure that they know is crumbling, and they don't get it. There's nothing ignorant or generational about what they're doing. If I were going to do the generation-warfare thing, my argument would be that younger people are more attuned to this problem because they're going to be around for every single collapse and catastrophe that's building up. They're just not in control of the money it would take to fix they problem, and had no chance to prevent it in the first place. More broadly, though, this is better framed as a left/right struggle, or a bureaucrats/technicians struggle, or a politicians/citizens struggle, or virtually anything except a generational issue.
- M_Grey 10y agoI wasn't thinking about young people... they're not the only generation on the planet, and not the one who've been making the bad calls re: infrastructure either.
- Bartweiss 10y agoI apologize, I read an implication in that wasn't warranted. I think what led me to that was the idea that older generations have already seen infrastructure crises, so only younger ones would be learning something new. But I guess that's not really the case, is it? Has there been a major infrastructure crisis in the last ~100 years?
- Spooky23 10y agoI'm biased, as I work in civil service. Frankly, the reality is often coming from the bureaucracy. We all chuckle about government absurdity, but many of the true experts in these areas are in these bureaucracies, and get silenced when their work conflicts with the narrative the political administration wants. As costs have grown in healthcare, public safety and other areas, other functions get starved of attention. I will guarantee you that in all of these cases, people who know what they were talking about were advising about these issues or unable to do their jobs due to de-funding... especially when republicans have had their fingers in things. We lost a lot when the postwar and 1960s generation aged out of the workforce. The folks in charge of government agencies in the 1960-2000 timeframe were better educated and more competent. The politicians, even the machine people, had a better fundamental respect for what government did and does. I'll tell you from an anecdotal perspective that the people in my state who inspect dams and bridges give a shit about their jobs and are not complacent. I know a few people in each category. They have a frustrating job, but do it well.
- vacri 10y agoFor an example of what you're saying: a friend of mine has a father who use to work in my state (Victoria, Aus) Surveyor General's office. The surveyor general's office knew what the land was like all over the state, what good farmland was, or what was best for other kinds of development... including what land was worth at market rates. Then a 'business friendly' government came along and abolished them, because "developers know better than these guys, who just provide red-tape obstacles". Fast-forward 20 years, and there's no pattern to developments, meaning things are built without concern to infrastructure or services, plus lots of prime farmland has been lost (so much for the 'economic forward-thinking' of that 'business-friendly' government). It turns out that the government actually needs that knowledge, because the state government is now hiring back whatever surveyors they can find again from the old days, and at grossly inflated private contractor rates. They lost the expertise, the professionalism, and their value for money, all for short-term business thinking. Not all government positions are filled with 'jobsworth' drones - there's a lot of vital stuff out there in ye olde bureaucracy.
- 10y ago
- tn13 10y agoBureaucracy and honesty does not go hand in hand! I am more worried that when a disaster strikes it will not only destroys lives but then the government resolve to increase taxes and regulation fighting windmills will destroy even more lives. Just like how 9/11 has put America into a perpetual mega expensive war with no objectives.
- specialist 10y agoYoung me took a very different lesson from Feynman's investigation of the Space Shuttle Challenger disaster. The fundamental human problem is governance in the face of entropy and information overload. Also known as the The Politics of Attention. I'm still trying to understand the width and breadth of failure. Starting with Drucker's Managing in Turbulent Times thru Norman's Design of Everyday Things up to now's study of Why Smart People Do Stupid Things. Sadly, I have no idea how to mitigate it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogers_Commission_Report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogers_Commission_Report
- M_Grey 10y agoYes you do, everyone does, we just don't want to accept it. The problem with humanity is humans, and human nature. The solution is that we're going to stop being that kind of human, either because we're going to die, or change ourselves in fundamental ways. Humanity as humanity, has no future.