20 ms·
Tesla Says Model 3 on Track as Quarterly Loss Beats Estimates
- simonsarris 10y agoFrom their letter (link to below if you want to read) > Later this year, we expect to finalize locations for Gigafactories 3, 4 and possibly 5 (Gigafactory 2 is the Tesla solar plant in New York). Should be an exciting conference call. (5:30pm EST) http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/ABEA-4CW8X0/3944011801x0x929284/22C29259-6C19-41AC-9CAB-899D148F323D/TSLA_Update_Letter_2016-4Q.pdf http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/ABEA-4CW8X0/394401180...
- oska 10y agoGigafactory 3: Europe Gigafactory 4: Asia Gigafactory 5: Where? Another one in the US?
- D_Alex 10y agoAustralia. Please. We have the land, we have the lithium, we have the sunshine and we have a massive car market - 1.2 million cars sold in 2016. We also have a good automotive manufacturing base... about to go into idle mode. Aussie federal and state governments have been very willing to support local manufacturing, and I'm sure they'd love to hear from Tesla.
- oska 10y agoI was going to suggest Australia as a possible contender for the 5th factory however while we have some supportive state governments we also have an incredibly unsupportive federal government that is hostile to electric vehicles and renewable energy and storage. And I think that's obvious to anyone looking on from outside. So while this current federal government is in power it's one more opportunity we're going to miss (and be left behind on).
- taneq 10y agoWe also have an absolute ton of solar power on very cheap land, and our power grid is in a death spiral to the point where going off-grid is going to be a clear financial win in the next 10 years. By the time a new factory is up and running, this is gonna be a really good market for battery storage.
- justin66 10y agoAre the same people who tend to be hostile to electric vehicles and renewables friendly to mining? Parking a gigafactory near the nation's lithium might persuade a lot of people to take a chance on Tesla.
- aerovistae 10y agoIt's fun to read Mark Spiegel's twitter feed. I've never seen someone so desperately try to force a theory. I wonder why some people want to see Tesla fail so badly.
- bluehawk 10y agoI can sorta understand how he got there. Historically, making a car company is very, very hard. It's a tough industry to crack into. So when you see a startup car company with a hugely inflated stock that has a (based on historical data) very low chance of success, it makes a lot of sense to bet against it. But as it succeeds, you have to keep doubling down on the idea that it can't possibly deliver on it's promises and will fall on it's face eventually. At some point he slipped from making a reasonable bet to frothing at the mouth a bit.
- johngalt 10y agoThe market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent. -Keynes
- paulpauper 10y agoIt's possibly related to the fact his fund is bearish on the stock market, which as been a losing proposition for the past 8 years. Maybe he is short Tesla. Tesla as well as the bull market keeps defying the odds. Optimism pays.
- kaykay 10y agoMight have shorted Tesla
- paulpauper 10y agoi think so ..I think it's hubris ..I stopped listening to most 'experts' long ago..
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago> I wonder why some people want to see Tesla fail so badly. A regressive mindset.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mabbo 10y agoPeople get upset by the 'superhero' status of Elon Musk. Nerds everywhere worship the guy, buy his cars, watch his SpaceX launches. But honestly, let him have it, I say. He's earning it. He's taking huge risks and succeeding where others weren't willing to try.
- tradersam 10y agoEspecially with SpaceX. He's pushing his engineers hard to get some pretty cool stuff done, and hopefully humanity benefits from it in the long run.
- codecamper 10y agoIt's technology. Once it exists, it will continue existing. Every generation must use it wisely and ethically.
- soperj 10y agoHow were the pyramids built?
- true_religion 10y agoLots of technology is non obvious, even simple tech. The wheel wasn't widely known in the Americas. Large wheel wagons like you see in rickshaws were not widely known in the West.
- Retric 10y agoIt really does not matter as we could build them today with a lot less effort. It would cost something like $5 billion today and would take ~2,000 people ~5 years. Which is relatively speaking a lot less expensive. Put another way, Bill G could build ~17 of them in his lifetime and not be broke.
- kbenson 10y ago
- SaintGhurka 10y agoIs it just me reading too much financial news or does "beats estimates" sound like it was better than estimates? Loss was 69 cents vs 53 cents expected. Revenues beat estimates, though.
- CarVac 10y ago>The fourth-quarter loss, excluding some items, was narrower than the $1.14 a share average estimate Straight from the article.
- SaintGhurka 10y agoSo I was reading this from marketwatch: "Adjusted loss of 69 cents a share, worse than expected." "Analysts expect an adjusted fourth-quarter loss of 53 cents a share" Now I don't know what to believe. Edit: I guess it depends on who's doing the estimating. The linked article says "The fourth-quarter loss, excluding some items, was narrower than the $1.14 a share average estimate among analysts surveyed by Bloomberg."
- codecamper 10y agoCould be companies estimate their earnings each year. And then analysts do their own estimates. guided vs consensus
- eldavido 10y ago"Loss" is the wrong word for this. We need better terminology. A more accurate statement would be something like, "The tangible value of the company's assets, as far as anyone can reasonably ascertain with any degree of certainty, declined by 53 cents per share this quarter". The question is whether the company is making good investments. If you believe its infrastructure investments will provide long-lived, strategic advantages which support the reduction of cost (increasing margins and free cash flow), decreased time to market (making more revenue accessible, more quickly), or other things, these "losses" are hardly bad things. [1] [1] Of course, this assumes the company has access to continued financing on good terms, which seems to be the case.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Wizardgold 10y agoIt seems the financial side of a company have to make a guess at position they expect to be in when they report to the shareholders. So long as they beat the estimates then everyone is happy. The guess does have to be with enough forward movement to show the company is worth investing into. It's all a bit of a tightrope to get it right enough the money stays in play so the company can continue doing what they want to do.
- paulpauper 10y agoPeople who lose money shorting Tesla are losing their shirts for the same reason as those who shorted Amazon: cash flow + growth matters more than profitability, PE ratios, or EPS. Tesla's car business is cash flow positive but the quarterly losses are due to infrastructure investments. This is how finance can be more subtle than meets the eye. Tesla's car business is very profitable: Tesla also reported an automotive gross margin excluding SBC and ZEV credit (non-GAAP), of 22.2% in the quarter, up from 19.7% a year ago, but down from 25.0% in Q3... huge growth: Looking at the future, Tesla said it expects to deliver 47,000 to 50,000 Model S and Model X vehicles combined in the first half of 2017, representing vehicle delivery growth of 61% to 71% compared with the same period last year. reinvesting operating profits into investments: The company also expects to invest between $2 billion and $2.5 billion in capex ahead of the start of Model 3 production and continues "to focus on capital efficiency while also investing in battery cell, pack and energy storage production at Gigafactory 1. It also forecast that both Model 3 and solar roof launches are on track for the second half of the year. This company is firing (no pun intended) on all cylinders
- Someone1234 10y ago> People who lose money shorting Tesla are losing their shirts I don't follow. Tesla is down 1.4%. People who shorted Tesla made money today. Plus a lot of people made money shorting Amazon over Amazon's life. Shorting a stock has less to do with a company's business plan/success and more to do with predicting the market itself and how they'll respond to various quarterly results (and the likelihood of such results). Tesla is mostly just prop in the stock market "game."
- goatforce5 10y agoIt's currently up 1.65% in after hours trading.
- Someone1234 10y agoThe person above claimed that people "lost their shirts" shorting Tesla. Clearly if they were down within normal trading hours, some of those shorts would have paid out. That was what I was responding to. The fact that Tesla rebounded after hours is neither here nor there. The shorts may have already paid out.
- kgwgk 10y agoFor a negative look at the results: http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-02-22/tesla-beats-it-burns-record-1-billion-cash-flow-delivers-10-fewer-cars http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-02-22/tesla-beats-it-burn...
- teslaberry 10y agohalf the people on this board are too young to remember the 2008 collapse because they weren't old enough to see the bubble which helped build up from 2004-2008. tesla is indeed garbage as a stock. however, it is trending, and it's value is supported by major insider banks which loot the treasury and the economy at large. in this case, goldman sachs. so the stock CAN keep going up, but not because the company is profiteably making cars. stock prices in a bull market are about buyers and sellers talking bullshit about the company while sellers dry up. bear markets are about those who HOLD the stock holding it for dividends . if we had a market where those who owned tesla for dividends were repsponible for perpetuating a market price---------indeed it would be closer to a 4 billion dollar company than a 44 billion dollar company.
- brilliantcode 10y agoWas about to buy near expiry put options for a very cheap price...I'll be staying away from TSLA and looking at macroeconomic trends instead. Timing earnings without informational edge, it's gambling.
- brilliantcode 10y agoUpdate: Seeing the TSLA tank yesterday, I decided I will never self doubt myself again and resume gambling.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoThe reason so many people think Tesla is expensive is because some are valuing the company relative to Ford and GM, but others are looking at Tesla Energy and valuing the company not just in automotive but in GE's business, and even in Exxon's business. GM + GE + Exxon = $765 billion Tesla at $45 billion is still just 6% of that market. There's a lot of uncertainty there, so only a small slice of that $765 billion is getting priced into Tesla's stock, but it's enough to make the people comparing to Ford wonder what the heck is going on.
- cowsandmilk 10y agoWhy do you believe GE is relevant here? GE is a conglomerate that has major businesses like aviation and healthcare that are wholly unreleated to Tesla Energy. For 2016, those made up $9.2B of GE's $17.6B industrial segment profit, so over 50%.
- vkou 10y agoMaybe because Ford and GM shouldn't be in Exxon's business, just like how Google shouldn't be in Exxon's business, and Bank of America should probably not be in Exxon's business? Energy is an undifferentiated low-margin commodity. (Unless you're getting sweetheart resource extraction rates.) Especially when it comes to grid energy - there is zero synergy between being a producer of it, and selling products that consume it.
- mtgx 10y agoI hope Model 3 can beat the Bolt in range. That would be a nice surprise. I wouldn't say it's necessary, but the Bolt has already gotten a lot of press, with some even saying it's what's making EVs "mainstream", even though they're only selling like hundreds of them at a time right now, and that probably won't change anytime soon considering GM loses $9,000 for each unit sold. Plus, I hear all the time how the dealerships try to dissuade people from buying a Bolt and turn them towards buying an ICE car instead. I also hope Musk reconsiders his strategy of not making much cheaper EVs "because everyone will pay to be driven by an autonomous vehicle soon". I think he's way overestimating how soon that will happen. I don't think most people, even in the U.S., where a "Tesla Network" may actually be viable, let alone in the rest of the world, will do that by 2025, if not 2030. That leaves a lot of wasted opportunities for Tesla to become a "market leader" in EVs - or rather to maintain its EV leadership in the market. By 2025, there will definitely be EVs from Renault and others that cost less than $20,000 and have 200-mile ranges. At half the price of a Model 3, those cars are going to gain a lot of market share, fast, even if Tesla's numbers continue to grow as well. I know Musk has already mentioned that Model Y will be cheaper, but we don't know just how much cheaper. Hopefully, it will be like $25,000. That would be a nice price-point for an EV by 2020. But I think Tesla needs to go down to $15,000 or at least 18,000 by 2025, as well, even if for that price point and by that moment in time, those cars can't be "Level 5" - although if Model 3 will have that hardware, I think so will the $15,000-18,000 car by 2025 (it will probably need to be more like 2023, and announced in 2021, though, as a lot of EVs will start to come out in 2021-2022).
- ZeroGravitas 10y ago"GM loses $9,000 for each unit sold." I'd be careful with figures like this. It's possible they are investing with the idea to ramp up production and get to profitability with scale, or with predicted reductions in battery price. It's also possible that the way CAFE rules calculate an average over a manufacturers entire fleet mean that by taking a loss in one place they can earn or save money in another.
- mikeash 10y agoI recall this sort of figure being thrown around for the Volt, and it was calculated by taking the full cost of R&D and allocating it equally to each unit sold so far, which is idiotic. But a lot of people hate alternative fuel cars and so it got a lot of traction.
- refurb 10y agoLooks like the stock is down 2.4% from yesterday. Folks are taking a closer look at the numbers. One analyst specifically took aim at the fourth quarter results, calling out the beat as "phantom" given the exclusion of the SolarCity acquisition from consensus estimates.[1] [1]http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-02-23/market-sours-teslas-phantom-beat-stock-slides http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-02-23/market-sours-teslas...
- oli5679 10y agoThe trade I'm interesting is simultaneously shorting Tesla and Daimler. Sceptics emphasise the difference between Tesla's market cap (£40 bn) vs its current sales (75,000) and profits (close to -$1bn). I can imagine a state of the world where they grow dramatically and justify this price tag, but in that case I see serious problems for Daimler. Similarly, if Daimler flatlines and doesn't see a crash in sales of Mercedez, I'm seriously pessimistic about Tesla.