15 ms·
Expanding Fact Checking at Google
- grenoire 10y agoDoes anybody have any examples on how fact checking is automated? Is it a mix of natural language processing and database cross-checks?
- kuro-kuris 10y agoI reckon they use a mix of NLP and ontologies.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dukeluke 10y agoWhat is to keep these fact checking organizations free from manipulation & spreading g propaganda? Will Google use this feature to further their own interests alone? If the answer to that is 'no,' how can we be sure they won't?
- croon 10y agoJust publish proof that their fact checking is lying?
- skylan_q 10y agoRumours spread fast. Corrections to rumours don't fully negate the rumours. Journalists are also held less accountable than even elected officials these days.
- croon 10y agoWait, are you arguing for or against fact checking?
- skylan_q 10y agoI'm for it. I'm saying that it doesn't really solve the problem of lies in mass media and the impact of the lies. It's a mitigating factor at best, a polarizer at worst.
- croon 10y agoSure, but the cost of free press is that basically anyone can publish whatever crap they want. Fact checking is a good tool (critical thinking and self-verification would be better). What can save time over time is to know which publications continously publish the most verifiable truths. Albeit always reading with vigilance. In what way would fact checking be polarizing?
- skylan_q 10y agoFact checking is a good tool (critical thinking and self-verification would be better). Humans don't act this way and don't respond to it. The media isn't out to inform people through content, but to program people through delivery. The only result of this will be to have people say "SEE! GOOGLE SAYS IT'S TRUE/FAKE!" And they'll share the headline on Facebook/Twitter and be done with it. People don't act rationally anymore, especially when it comes to media. Media outlets have agendas. The press hasn't been free in a long time. https://medium.com/@SarahRRunge/amazon-the-washington-post-and-the-cia-d68a4ee802e#.f389arnut https://medium.com/@SarahRRunge/amazon-the-washington-post-a...
- dingo_bat 10y agoWhich can get censored by the same algorithms.
- croon 10y agoThrough that outlet, theoretically, sure. Wouldn't stop it though.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bnolsen 10y agoConsidering the fake news movement is itself in large part propaganda google has chosen sides in this already and absolutely shouldn't be trusted.
- andybak 10y agoSorry. You'll have to explain yourself in a bit more depth. At first reading that sounds like confused nonsense which I'm sure doesn't give your argument the merit it deserves.
- curt15 10y agoPizzagate is a pretty classic example of "fake news". How is criticism of it in any way "propaganda"?
- rfrank 10y agoThere's been over 1500 pedophilia and sex trafficking arrests since Trump took office. It may be less fake than you think.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- andybak 10y agoSadly the answer to this and many similar questions about society, politics and power is and always will be "we can't be sure". Eternal vigilance and a dedication to the open society and Enlightenment values are the best we can do.
- mattchew 10y agoWe can't be sure, and they won't always be perfectly honest, but if you're billing yourself as a fact checker, you're trying to appeal to people who are interested in the truth in the first place. You can apply some spin and get away with it (and this will happen) but if you tell flat out lies, people will notice. This isn't a panacea, but it is a step in the right direction.
- hueving 10y agoYou can significantly lie in your narrative by choosing what to fact check.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- godzillabrennus 10y agoSo few companies have so much power with generating and spreading information. This is a good time for the industry to organize a new open and transparent Wikileaks style organization to make the decisions on what's fake or not.
- grenoire 10y agoThen who monitors the monitoring organisation? A centralised solution to information oligopolies cannot work.
- skylan_q 10y agoAgreed. An important part to this is transparency of the members working on this as well. Almost every fact-checker I've read up on has a conflict of interest on many of the "facts" they're checking.
- lisivka 10y agoOnly court can prove that something is fake or not fake. Other solutions are vulnerable. Extreme example: Russian plane was shoot at Black sea in 2001, and Ukraine is blamed by every article in internet you can find, but not by court. I'm 100% sure that every fact-check organization, except court, will confirm mainstream «fact».
- madmaniak 10y agoFact Checking is a new word for censorship.
- maxerickson 10y agoHow dare they make a business decision to have standards for accuracy on their platform. The nerve of giant corporations in our corporatist world! The nerve!
- skylan_q 10y agoHe's right, though. Google itself cannot be trusted. The size of the organization itself along with how many state actors it's colluding with should set off alarms.
- leereeves 10y agoCensorship is often hidden behind innocuous phrases like "standards for accuracy". It was fairly obvious when the media started talking about "fake news online" that the endgame was censoring the Internet.
- maxerickson 10y agoYeah, totally obvious. Robust freedom of speech doesn't mean that idiots get to have an equal voice. In fact, I think it depends on idiots quickly getting ignored, even in vile, pernicious, institutionalized ways.
- leereeves 10y agoSo you're arguing in favor of censorship? Who decides who gets ignored in "vile, pernicious, institutionalized ways"?
- maxerickson 10y agoLet me know when it becomes illegal to start up a news aggregator. Until then, it's whoever makes better news aggregators.
- avar 10y agoHow will a system like this handle developing news stories after the fact? E.g. in the Québec mosque shooting there were initially two suspects, and many news articles that had accurate information at the time look incorrect in retrospect. Would those all be marked as BS retroactively by such a system, or is it enough that the news article used the best available facts at the time? How will it handle granularity? It's very hard to write any news article that's 100% correct about everything. Will the entire article be marked as non-factually accurate due to the slightest mistake, or will they be highlighting specific factual inaccuracies in the content itself?
- icebraining 10y agoIt seems like the system doesn't actually fact check stuff, it just marks an existing article as a "fact check". Or to put it in another way, it's "fact check", not "fact checked".
- skylan_q 10y agoCheap labor. There's plenty out there. Google will tell them what the facts are and they'll promote/hide stories based on truthiness.
- skylan_q 10y agoGoogle was good. Then Google was bad. Then the Democrats lost the election and Google was good again.
- icebraining 10y agoEven terrible people and organizations can be smeared. Whether Google is good or not is irrelevant to whether your particular accusation is baseless. As I pointed above, it doesn't seem like Google is even marking stuff has "checked", but marking articles as being themselves "fact checks".
- skylan_q 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- daxfohl 10y agoI'm curious whether there is a correlation between people's political affiliation and their likelihood to use fact checking services.
- hueving 10y agoIt likely changes with the party in control (i.e. members of the party in control won't spend much effort fact checking their own and fact checking a minority group doesn't matter much).
- Neliquat 10y agoI have friends who blindly spout nonsense from the right and left sides. I would postulate that both do to a similar extent, and it depends on the issue.
- daxfohl 10y agoCorrelation is probably there but indirect: education level, age, etc influence the affiliation and their likelihood to use fact checking services.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoThis presents an issue that we've seen a lot of this political season... Anonymous sources, how do you "fact check" them? This season has been full of supposed leaks from the FBI, White House staffers, intelligence community, DOJ, and beyond. But a single publication claiming something with an anonymous source isn't fact check-able. Then what you see is second publications posting the same story (particularly dedicated political sites like Politico/The Hill) but their only source is the first publication. Then a third publication runs it only saying that X Y and Z reported the story, implying that it is true just by virtue of the level of attention. Everyone is talking about "alt news" (typically far right news) which is legitimately problematic, but few have been discussing the problematic way anonymous sources have been used and reported. It isn't too dissimilar from this XKCD except replace Wikipedia with third tier publications and broadcasters[0]. You can seemingly get a story verified just by repeating it enough, that's a problem. [0] https://xkcd.com/978/ https://xkcd.com/978/
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Anonymous sources, how do you "fact check" them? Reputation. Some journals, and some reporters, have earned my benefit of doubt. They tend to be--where I've been able to verify--direct to their anonymous sources and do everything in their power to verify what was said. This process takes effort, for the journalist and the reader.
- pluma 10y agoExcept then nonsense like the "PewDiePie is a nazi" articles happens (originally WSJ but then propagated by other "reputable" newspapers) and it becomes obvious even "trustworthy" sources aren't reliable. All media is biased because all media is gathered and edited by biased people (or as I like to call them: people). The only thing fact checking can help cutting down on is actual fake news -- hoaxes and blatantly obvious lies. The "fake news" label however is applied so broadly now that you can have two contrasting reports standing side by side calling each other fake news when neither side is able to report on the full picture and both sides skew the few factoids they have in accordance with their biases or use inflammatory language. I have yet to see a journal or reporter who consistently reports facts as presented while checking for authenticity and motive. It seems like certain organisations have learned that they can bypass a lot of accountability by "leaking" information anonymously rather than using official press releases (e.g. the "intelligence" sources during the late stages of the presidential election campaigning, none of which any agency seems to consider worth hunting down as a security risk like any of the real "leakers" before). The closest I've seen is a constant chorus of "we don't know the specifics yet", which predictably doesn't perform well when competing with "news" sources that just forward unsubstantiated tweets and anonymous "eyewitness accounts".
- venomsnake 10y agoAnd we have artificial downranking of pirated content after June in UK. Is google indexing or stewarding the web. I feel the later. And really don't like it.
- ssharp 10y agoNearly all fact-checking organizations are considered to be biased and untrustworthy by a sizable percentage of the population. I'm skeptical that this will actually lead to change in people's critical thinking as applied to processing news and news sources. A recent poll showed that more Americans trusted Donald Trump, someone who has not gone a day in his short tenure in office without him or someone on his staff telling a verifiable lie to the press, to tell them the truth compared to the U.S. media.
- merpnderp 10y agoBut has the news gone a day without telling a verifiable lie? I read an article yesterday running down the list of organizations (quoted and linked) mocking Trump for referring to a terrorist attack the night before in Sweden. The full transcript shows Trump never mentioned a terrorist attack. It's not that Trump is so trustworthy it's just that one person can't possibly lie as much as thousands.
- theWatcher37 10y agoWe live in a world where obama can get the number of US states wrong and get a pass, and trump mentioning a segment he saw last night on FOX is the end of the world. Interestingly enough the media parroted the "debunked" claim when the article was using statistics from Sweden's own government. Rape is up 70% since 2005. Grenade attacks are also a thing in Sweden now, which is absolutely unacceptable.
- erelde 10y agoAnd you are not believing stats released by one of the least corrupt democracy of the West. There was one grenade launched in Sweden in August last year. There's at least 1 killed by a semi auto in the US per day. Sweden has near zero homicide rate. edit: it seems there was more than 'one' explosions in Sweden, but looking at the wikipedia article history linked below doesn't fill me with confidence considering how the language used has changed between august when the article was made and now. Also note how the wikipedia editors write about organized crime using old grenades from WWII and not migrants bombing Swedish people.
- dingo_bat 10y agoBad move. A search engine should not be valuing certain websites more just because they proclaim to be "fact checkers". For example, politifact is usually trusty but some of their judgements are highly questionable. But Google will trust them and display their link prominently, even when it might be total bullshit.
- camiller 10y agoYeah, but this isn't their search site, this is their news site. Google has become more than just a search engine.
- dignati 10y ago"We’re also launching the fact check tag in these countries on news mode in Search" So now it's also integrated into Google Search
- camiller 10y agoI can honestly say I have never went into "news mode" on the main search site before. If I know I want to search for news stories I go to news.google.com and search there. At any rate you have to choose "news mode", it is not in the normal search screen.
- jayrox 10y agoI try to keep my facts in check, any examples of questionable politifact judgements?
- spiderfarmer 10y agoEven if some were questionable, it doesn't mean there's a hidden agenda. Unlike the real 'fake news' outlets, where truth is intentionally skewed, hidden or muddied, with the intent of attracting the most eyeballs.
- 10y ago
- rokosbasilisk 10y agoWhoa. I have a bad feeling this will lead to antitrust suits. Its highly suspicious its launching in france and germany while their populist movements are growing.
- u_wot_m8 10y agoThere's tape of Merkel telling Zuckerberg to censor migrant crimes on Facebook.
- dagw 10y agoImagine how much more persuasive this comment would have been if you'd just taken a few more seconds add and hand full of links to provide evidence and context to your statement.
- spiderfarmer 10y agoZuckerberg was talking about his opinion that "hate speech" doesn't have a place on Facebook and that they "need to do some work". Merkel merely asked "are you working on this"? Somehow Infowars turned this into the following headline: "Mark Zuckerberg Caught on Hot Mic Saying Facebook Will Censor Anti-Migrant Posts" Other, more credible outlets said that Merkel was "pressing" Zuckerberg. Like asking a question puts so much pressure on someone. I for one would like to see headlines like this rewritten, "Saved you a click" style. People often read nothing more than the headline. Words matter.
- RyanZAG 10y agoIgnoring the blatant lies by Infowars, this still seems pretty bad. Giving Zuckerberg the power to identify "hate speech" and work with politicians on it can only lead to abuse in the long run.
- soundwave106 10y agoI'm not a fan of hate speech laws personally as a general concept, but Germany does have some pretty strong laws on their books regarding hate speech (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volksverhetzung https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volksverhetzung). So Zuckerberg may not really have a choice here (https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/28/technology/facebook-germany-hate-speech-fake-news.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/28/technology/facebook-germa...).
- paganel 10y agoWish this was up and running back in 2003, when the invasion of Iraq started based on fabricated evidence on WMD.
- MK999 10y agoThen the media would just hide behind the fact that the fabricated evidence was coming from the intel agencies.
- gorhill 10y agoFAIR (Fairness and Accuracy In Reporting) has been at work since 1986 -- see their archives for 2003[1]. "Fake news" is not a new issue, this has always existed, and the real antidote is the same now as it has always been: critical thinking. [1] http://fair.org/extra-issues/ http://fair.org/extra-issues/
- will_pseudonym 10y agoIf it was up and running back in 2003, the fact checkers would have been saying that there were WMD's in Iraq.
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoThat's doubtful. My understanding is that most bodies outside of the special pentagon task force established by the WH at the time were skeptical.
- netcraft 10y agoI feel like this is something that maybe should be handled outside of search engines / aggregators themselves. I'm imagining some sort of community around a browser extension - the ability to vote for tags / add comments to any url, using the extension would allow you to see what others think. Would need moderation and would have to really get a critical mass before it would be useful. Perhaps the ability to have multiple "communities" you subscribe to with their own groups and ratings e.g. the "Fact Checkers" community rates this article one way, the "Reddit Politics" community rates it a bit differently, etc.
- MaxfordAndSons 10y agoSome sort of community around a browser extension you say? Check out https://hypothes.is/ https://hypothes.is/ it's a project to allow universal annotation of web content, which could conceivably enable just such a process of decentralized, community-moderated fact checking. Wouldn't that be nice! Of course, given what's happening on Wikipedia lately, I'm not totally convinced it could work, but hey, at least someone's trying.
- netcraft 10y agovery cool, thank you for pointing this out. I want to play with it some more, but I think one of the things that isnt fully thought out is that some url's will inherently change over time - the front page of the NYT for instance shows comments from over a year ago that obviously don't apply now - even comments from an hour ago may reference content that is no longer there. I don't have an answer for the problem but its something thats got to be thought about. Similar problem would be canonicalization of urls.
- username3 10y agoInstead of fact checking, they should show opinions from every side of issues across the spectrum.
- Angostura 10y agoThat's what they do now. It's why I know that vaccines cause autism, and global warming is a myth.
- kazagistar 10y agoOpinions and facts are distinct. Opinions separate out into categories of "agree", "disagree", "don't care", etc. Facts separate out into very different categories of "true", "untrue", "unsubstantiated either way", etc. Yes, its good to be exposed to a broad spectrum of opinions. Yes, different sources can select different true facts to push an agenda and substantiate their own cause, and it is thus important to get true facts from multiple sources to get a complete picture. No, it is not a good idea to put unsubstantiated "facts" or outright untruths on equal footing as the truth.
- username3 10y agoYou have to put all "facts" out there to show they are untrue. Who determines the "facts"? Conspiracy theorists get confirmation bias when you ignore them. Facts are not hard to check. No one knows when and why fact checkers disagree. Fact checkers can't check intentions of a speaker nor do they follow up.
- wallace_f 10y agoAssaults on free speech always come with arguments of moral righteousness. A service to the public needs to actually credibly serve the public. A bakery cannot refuse to cater a wedding, ever if they find the clients repulsive because they are two dudes, or whatever reason they have. Google should not be permitted to discriminate or censor search results, even if they find the clients repulsive because they are 4chan users, or whatever reason they have.
- widdma 10y ago> Google should not be prohibited to discriminate or censor search results[...] You're right, filtering results would be a concerning step. I guess this is why they've added a fact check tag rather than a filter. I think it's a good solution. But then again, free speech doesn't mean you have the right to have your results shown on the first page of Google. If they change their algorithm to preference articles with fact checking, is it the same as someone refusing to make a wedding cake for two dudes?
- wallace_f 10y agoI know, I just used the 4chan example because it's an example of censorship that they're already doing. I haven't gone through to check the legitimacy of Google's fact checking efforts although I have a feel it's going to be awful.
- brogrammer_1 10y agoGoogle is not public service though, it's a multi-billion dollar advertising corporation. They are totally at liberty to do whatever the hell they like, however much they want to portray themselves as non-evil and in the public interest.
- wallace_f 10y agoSo you're also vehemently against public accommodation, fair housing and other equal-treatment laws? Or you're doublethinking.
- EGreg 10y agoI think The goal shouldn't be to detect fake news. The goal should be to detect whether a specific claim is true or false. For that, you simply need a site, like a crowd sourced fact checking sites, where people are required to source their arguments precisely, unlike fake news which doesn't. Then you have a resource to turn to, similarly to how fact checkers are used in the face of fake news. After that, you can build an engine to crawl news articles or have them submitted, and detect the claims being made. Those claims can be either auto-matched to existing ones or create new ones (deduplication) and then the site has a fresh new stream of claims to fact check. StackOverflow could build this site on their existing engine. If someone here knows them, can you reply and put me in touch?
- yosefk 10y agoWasn't the whole point of Google replacing things like Yahoo directories, curated manually, with fully automated algorithms? Being able to find quality information on "Bill Clinton" algorithmically and not settle for the page "Bill Clinton Sucks" as their early paper discussed? And aren't we in the age of AI, everything is solved even more now with NNs than it was with PageRank? Why then prop up human-chosen sources like snopes and politifact? Is the AI too dumb or does it hold the wrong political opinions?
- gerbilly 10y ago>Why then prop up human-chosen sources like snopes and politifact? Is the AI too dumb or does it hold the wrong political opinions? There's not much AI behind it. I mean it's more complicated than that but a page's rank is based on number of incoming links. What's interesting is that the net seems to be partitioning along various demographic lines: rural/urban, left/right etc, each creating their own subspace of 'credible' sites based on the pagerank algorithm. In fact it's a self reinforcing cycle because of personalized searches. Once google gathers enough information about you based on your search history it will present you with results tailored to your opinions and tastes. It's unfortunate because in the 90s we talked about the web breaking down barriers, but in some cases it's walling people in. Sometime in obvious ways like with actual walled gardens like facebook, but also in more insidious ways such as personalized searching.
- _yosefk 10y agoYou mean the great advances in Deep Learning we keep reading about did not revolutionize search? Still PageRank?
- chrramirez 10y agoThis kind of actions are important now more than ever for western societies. We have to remember that Russia is committed to destroy democratic institutions using fake news as one of its tools. Using fake news is an old trick to distort reality. In the pass it was done controlling state media or a good part of it. Now is making it into your Facebook feed.
- losteverything 10y agoI'll decide what I'll believe and what is fact. Not an algorithm or search engine. It seems like Google is trying to make the old statement " its printed it must be true" new. "Its fact check on Google it must be true." The joy of reading online is coming under attack.
- wu-ikkyu 10y agoIntroducing TaaS: Truth as a Service. Brought to you by your omniscient Corporate Overlords. Because you're not smart enough to find the Truth for yourself!
- tlrobinson 10y agoI'd much prefer if Google let me opt in to the fact checking organizations I trust. Of course then some idiots will pick Infowars as their fact checker.
- facetube 10y agoHow about showing the country of record from WHOIS? Most of the severe offenders I saw in 2016 were e.g. Washington Post knockoffs using a Panama "WHOIS guard" mailing address, or sites that were literally registered to a street address in Macedonia (e.g. usapoliticszone.com). These are the sorts of sites that were tricking Trump devotees en masse in private groups (on Facebook and across the broader internet). Surely having a real mailing address listed in WHOIS isn't too much to ask for a news organization? Google performs real verification on mailing addresses of Maps business listings – the technical infrastructure to hard-verify WHOIS mailing addresses seems to already exist.
- fcg221 10y agoI thought that this article might be about fact-checking the excerpts from web sites that Google sometimes presents as an answer to a Google search. One egregious instance of such a result that needs fact-checking is for the search "Is Donald Trump a citizen?"[1], for which this featured snippet appears at the top: Donald Trump is NOT Natural Born. Donald John Trump, Senior, was born in Queens, New York on June 14, 1946. He presents himself as a person eligible to the Office of President of the United States, yet, he does not have the parentage necessary to be a "natural born citizen." Donald Trump - NOT Natural Born - Natural born, The National Society ... natural-borncitizens.com/donaldtrumpnotnaturalborn.html I doubt that Google wishes to represent this excerpt, from a website whose views are on the fringe (to say the least) as fact. Perhaps Google should be more careful about automatically displaying snippets pulled from websites as fact. [1] https://google.com/search?q=Is+Donald+Trump+a+citizen https://google.com/search?q=Is+Donald+Trump+a+citizen?
- chimeracoder 10y agoSimilarly, as recently as a couple of months ago, searching "Firefox" in Google yielded an ad for a malware site masquerading as Mozilla. Google does make some effort to prevent these, but it's clearly not enough - that particular example happened for literally years.
- dogma1138 10y agoAm I the only one who doesnt want Google to fact check the news? Like yes propaganda is a problem but so is the ministery of truth. Fake news stories have always existed the problem now is that we don't get news anymore we get policy driven editorials. Fixing fake news is a red herring I much rather get opinion pieces and corrected speech out of prime time news. But that's what you get for decades or people being offended by factual headlines.
- cnnsucks 10y agoGoogle News... I follow events in Venezuela. I routinely see teleSUR garbage (Chavista's Pravda) mixed in with credible reporting on Google news. And not just the benign news these state organs always conflate with their agenda pieces; the pure Bolvarian conspiratorial left-wing dreck stuff is there too, offered as "news" by Google News. Been seeing this for years. One guess whether teleSUR propaganda is going to suffer any "fact checking" downmods as a result of Google's sudden desire to protect us all from Trumpian untruths.
- ksk 10y agoI think this is going down the wrong path. I would not trust an advertising company to fact check, or even link to fact checking tools.
- lenovouser 10y ago1984 here we come. Was nice playing with you, humans - until next time! Oh, there is no next time? Well...
- caseysoftware 10y agoGoogle used to be about "organizing the world's information." It's disappointing to see they've become "organizing the world's information that we want you to see."
- samdoidge 10y agoWhat would a fact checker say about Iraq & WMDs prior to the US invasion?
- mattlevan 10y agoExpanding fact checking at Google? Fine. DuckDuckGo[1] it is for me, then. [1] https://duckduckgo.com/about https://duckduckgo.com/about
- kabes 10y agoBut a lot of news around elections is about predictions of the future which you can't really fact-check. A lot of other news these days is in the form of 'opinions', which you also have to accept for what they are.
- eplanit 10y agoIt's almost funny how the underlying premise is ignored: that there is really no such thing as "news" in terms of the information we consume -- all these sources are just a segment of the Entertainment industry. So-called News organizations make their money the same way a game show does: advertising. There is no built-in economic reward for being a great truth-teller. Attract more eyeballs and you make more in advertising, period. Especially in these days of so many forms/channels of communications, this all promotes echo chambers of bias, which is sad but true. The idea of automated "fact checking" should be sending chills down everybody's spine.