36 ms·
Man jailed 16 months, and counting, for refusing to decrypt hard drives
- guard-of-terra 10y agoThe people who do this now will become old and helpless to, and it is our purpose to forget nothing and make sure their final years are thoroughly ruined.
- 2bluesc 10y agoWhich people? Those instituting the policies or those accused of the crimes?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- guard-of-terra 10y agoYou see, 35 years ago you signed this order on d'tention over hard drive 'ncryption? That's unconst'tutional, you know. Here we've got the relevant law. So now we have to w'draw a 35 years worth of pay that you received aft'wards. That's the law that say that, too. We'll start by taking your house 'way. Also we our records show you gave $100k to your daughter 15 years ago. I'm 'fraid we have to put a debt on her for that sum, with 'nterest. Here's the rel'vant court order.
- ghurtado 10y agoWhy do you do that with apostrophes? It makes your comment harder to read and doesn't add anything to it.
- sixQuarks 10y agoI think he's doing a southern accent
- kpil 10y agoIt's the future! ( You must also imagine a wobbly fade before reading the comment. )
- throwanem 10y agoHe's not. He might be trying, but if so then one has to question whether he's ever heard such an accent before.
- ghurtado 10y agoSounds like the (very crude) interpretation of a foreigner who's never been to the US.
- coldtea 10y agoHow's that different than "revenge fantasy" fiction? Slim chances of anything like that happening. Besides, there are such people in every generation. They just change what they target (after all it's about the control and the profit, not about particular victims. E.g. now they can afford to play it non-racist, since why should they care much about suppressing blacks in particular, when they can now fuck the whole population?).
- guard-of-terra 10y agoI don't know about such a fiction but I guess that would be it. If we are persistent and unforgetting, this might become a reality one day. We should find "such people" in every generation and make sure they don't have a chance to do such mistakes to pay for them later, but on the question of payment we should be adamant. The trick here is to not be conflict-averse and not be a slave of own wallet but to care about justice even after the years.
- ghurtado 10y agoYou don't seem to have a clear understanding of the distinction between justice and vengeance.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoHow would you ever persuade people to respect principles underlying the law when you fail to punish people who are the law? Modern justice is all like this: We know this guy perpetrated, but it was some time ago and he's well connected and it's awkward for us so we're going to "hate his sin" but without any effect on his well-being. But you, dear listeners, please behave. Ah, on unrelated note, we jailed a poor person for 10 years for a fraction of damage because it was politically convenient.
- ghurtado 10y agoThose are all justice problems, but you are proposing to fix them with "revenge" type solutions. Is this maybe a cultural thing? Is vengeance a commonplace solution to problems in your culture?
- dang 10y agoYou've posted plenty of uncivil comments to HN and we've given you plenty of warnings. If you continue to do this we are going to ban you.
- BigChiefSmokem 10y agoLet him go then.
- sokoloff 10y agoWhat about the possibility that this guy (or someone else similarly situated) might legitimately not have the password to unlock the volume? I have old hard drives and computers in my basement for which I'm quite sure I don't recall the root password. Edited to add: I'm not coming out pro-child-pornography, but I think the EFF has it 100% correct here. From the article: The Electronic Frontier Foundation told the court in a friend-of-the-court brief (PDF) that "compelled decryption is inherently testimonial because it compels a suspect to use the contents of their mind to translate unintelligible evidence into a form that can be used against them. The Fifth Amendment provides an absolute privilege against such self-incriminating compelled decryption."
- BigChiefSmokem 10y agoThen his lawyer can argue that, but instead they are arguing the Fifth Amendment. The question is rather, does the Constitution render the court order illegal?
- michaelmrose 10y agoThey have no obligation to believe him or release him in that case even if he did forget it.
- sokoloff 10y agoWhich is problematic, as now the penalty for forgetting a passphrase can become life in prison.
- tajen 10y agoMost people don't realize that child pornography is "any visual depiction of sexually explicit conduct involving a minor". Under a bad cop, any sexually explicit pic of a person can be deemed "under 18 years of age", unless you have the actor's ID on file. And there are many, many underage actors. Even if you buy legal porn which claimed actors were above 18, you are guilty. Especially if you've bought it. Here's how: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_fabrication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_fabrication In other words, I've ceased to believe people convicted of child pornography were paedophiles. The condemnation is simply unrelated to the moral standards of the person. Hence, if he has any picture on this hard drive, he's right to plead the 5th.
- dleslie 10y agoDoesn't America have some rule against being compelled to provide evidence of your guilt?
- personjerry 10y agoIt's mentioned right in the article - Fifth Amendment
- dleslie 10y agoAh, that's what that is. The amendments are not recognizable to me by number alone.
- dbg31415 10y agoOversimplified: 1st - We can say whatever the fuck we want. We can religion. We don't have to fight for our right to party. 2nd - We can have guns. 3rd - We don't gotta share our beds with soldiers. 4th - We don't gotta open the door for the cops. 5th - We don't gotta say shit to the cops. 6th - We can have lawyers. 7th - We can have jury trials. 8th - When we fuck up, the punishment for me is the same as it would be for you. 9th - If there isn't an explicit law against it, then we can do it. 10th - If it's not explicitly made a federal issue in the constitution, then it's a state issue. Reading these... it's hard not to be very proud of how much they got right back in 1791. And pissed off at how much they aren't getting right today.
- mhurron 10y agoThere are limits to that and the Government keeps attempting to increase the limits of the 5th amendment in regards to electronic documents. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2016/06/07/the-fifth-amendment-limits-on-forced-decryption-and-applying-the-foregone-conclusion-doctrine/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201... Above is another article on the same case.
- ZoFreX 10y agoYes, with exceptions. One exception being the "foregone conclusion doctrine".
- godelski 10y agoFrom what I understand our legal system was designed to fail "open". Or rather that we are willing to let a guilty person go free rather than an innocent person go to jail. I know everyone wants to have a perfect justice system but we have to ALSO decide which direction we would like it to fail until that time comes (never). In essence cases like this are more about this question. When the system fails, which direction do we want it to fail in?
- godzillabrennus 10y agoThat was before the for profit prison industry became a cancer that incentivized keeping non-violent people in prison.
- e40 10y agoI think that's most of it, but I also think there's been some weird shift in the way police and prosecutors behave over the last decade. Much has been written how we now effectively have debtor's prisons. People are fined and imprisoned because they can't pay the fines. The crazy part for me is that this has all happened while the crime rate has been steadily going down, so there's not even a justification for it (from a crime standpoint).
- jamessb 10y agoAs a starting point, see the Wikipedia article on Blackstone's formulation [1]: "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer". It refers to an interesting article, "n Guilty Men" [2]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_formulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_formulation [2]: http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/guilty.htm http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/guilty.htm
- godelski 10y agoThanks, these are interesting reads.
- bluejekyll 10y ago
- danbruc 10y agoThis is probably a lot less black and white then it might seem at first. If there is sufficient evidence, one can obtain a search warrant and this forces you to possibly act against your own best interest by allowing the police to search your home. On the other hand you can usually not be forced to testify against yourself. So this becomes the question where decrypting a hard drive lies on this spectrum. Is it more like testifying against yourself or is it more like allowing the police to search your home? Assuming one agrees with the way testifying against yourself and searching your home is currently handled by the law.
- parhurs 10y agoObviously the former. The home search is analoguous with handing the hard drive to the police (they're free to search it). Giving the key is analogous to voluntarily digging up a secret stash in your back yard. And I disagree with it not being black and white, if you didn't already notice that. Rights are rights.
- danbruc 10y agoAs I just wrote in other replies, I was probably wrong with regard to search warrants. Therefore my argument that sometimes you already have to act against your best interests falls apart unless someone can point at a better example than a search warrant. Rights are rights. But we make up those rights. If there is a right to not to incriminate oneself that applies in all circumstances, then I am of course with you, you should not be forced to decrypt the hard drive. My point was that I am not sure if such a right applying in all circumstances exists and I thought the search warrant scenario proved that to not be the case but that turned out to be wrong.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- skrause 10y ago> one can obtain a search warrant and this forces you to possibly act against your own best interest by allowing the police to search your home. In Germany you never have to actively help the police even if they come with a warrant. They can't even compel you to open the door of the house or a physical safe. They will of course come in anyway and send you the bill for the locksmith, but it's your perfect right to just sit there and do nothing. So with the hard disk encryption it's actually exactly the same: You don't have to help in any way, but of course the police can still take the drive and try to decrypt it. If they can't decrypt, well, bad luck. Not your problem, you don't have to help.
- BigChiefSmokem 10y agoWhy post when you haven't read the article?
- coldtea 10y agoBecause he cares more about the general case and the discussion here, than about the particular article?
- braveo 10y agoThe context of the discussion is the topic of the article, whether or not he's interested in the general discussion, he needs to be willing to read a fucking article. Or are we to believe this person is somehow well informed when they can't be bothered to read a short, simple article?
- coldtea 10y agoWe are just to be courteous and not rude. You'd be surprised how many people skim through or just read the title of the article, and then participate on the discussion. But that's orthogonal to them giving valuable comments and insights in the discussion, since, as you'll surely have noticed, the context of the discussion is almost never the article -- it's only used as a starting point, and discussion them jumps to several different tangents. Like, you know, any actual human discussion that's not finely constrained and regulated by some panel.
- dleslie 10y agoI read the article, it mentions the amendments by number but I don't have awareness of them by number alone.
- brokenmachine 10y agoPeople who are not from America probably can't be expected to know US constitutional amendments by number.
- dang 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13630087 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13630087 and marked it off-topic.
- planetjones 10y agoAs expected on HN I am not surprised to see people defending one's right to privacy and encryption. However, what's the solution then ? If all the "bad guys" who distribute illegal material do so encrypted volumes and refuse to give up the decryption key then what do we do ? It's a different world now; the police can't just take a drill out and open the safe.
- remotebug 10y agoGather evidence instead of hoping you can convict someone of evil-doings based on their own records?
- iamdave 10y agoIf all the "bad guys" who distribute illegal material do so encrypted volumes and refuse to give up the decryption key then what do we do ? "Bad guys" still have fifth amendment protection. You prosecute, satisfy the burden of proof and hope a jury convicts. That's what you do. Outside of that, if you really want this changed, petition your representative to repeal the fifth amendment, I suppose?
- jordache 10y agoneed to stop thinking from an american centric perspective.
- iamdave 10y agoThis is in response to a news story that happened in the United States, I thought we were remaining in that context. And if I'm to think outside of an American-centric viewpoint, what governing body do you point to that would protect someone's rights from being forced to provide evidence against themselves when being charged with a crime? or Is this something that ought not be considered either?
- herbst 10y agoI think it is right to think in a american context here because no other western country would hold someone for so long just because he probably forgot his password. This is obviously a american issue.
- AckSyn 10y agoHe shouldn't have to decrypt his hard drives, and I support his decisions. The problems with this are numerous. First of all no one has any duty to provide the police with evidence as a 5th amendment protection. It's not a "right" for the police at all to have. Imprisoning someone for failure to disregard their constitutional rights is absurd. They have no evidence to hold him period.
- BigChiefSmokem 10y agoBut I bet something led police to the hard drive in question in the first place. I wonder what "that" something was. In the U.S. you can be arrested and held for Reasonable Suspicion (or Probable Cause)
- michaelmrose 10y agoNot indefinitely
- onion2k 10y agoWhatever that was it clearly wasn't a criminal act or he'd have been charged for whatever it was. No further evidence has come to light after 16 months. That's far beyond "reasonable suspicion." If the police can't find evidence of a crime then this guy should be released, even if he's the reason they can't find it.
- chatterbeak 10y agoWhich means he probably just downloaded something. Not even resent it out.
- sjy 10y agoIncorrect – the defendant had an iPhone which contained indecent recordings of his niece, and had previously admitted to family members that he had a problem with child pronography, showing them a large collection on the computer that was connected to the hard drives he now claims to have forgotten how to decrypt. This is explained in government brief[1] which was linked in the article. [1] https://arstechnica.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/fedsrawls.pdf https://arstechnica.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/fedsrawls...
- spaceboy 10y agoI thought the U.S had better key disclosure law[1] than other countries? Personally I would rather not self-incriminate myself by revealing a key, no matter how draconian and lengthy the sentencing was. Why, you ask? Well I consider all my own personal data likened to an extension of my own mind, and revealing a key is like slicing a thin part of my brain and attempting to pick its contents. Never a gentlemanly thing to do in any circumstance. In terms of being stopped and searched when traveling, I just carry a TailsOS bootable live USB. My laptop doesn't have a hard-drive and boots entirely from my TailsOS USB stick. I did not enable any persistent storage and any bookmarks I need to remember, I simply remember them by rote, like in that movie The Book of Eli[2]. My threat model is such that I don't want anybody knowing my business when traveling. The intrusiveness should only go so far as one question, like "Business or Pleasure?" and that's all. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law#United_Stat... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Book_of_Eli https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Book_of_Eli
- hdhzy 10y agoVery interesting. You don't have any need for persistent storage that exceeds the amount of information that can be remembered? (E.g. work artifacts, photos, passwords)
- ryan-c 10y agoRemote storage is an option.
- Zombieball 10y agoI don't want to assume on spaceboy's behalf, but I think all you need is to remember a master password to some sort of (online) password manager. From there you could use cloud services (eg. Dropbox) to access such documents. Securing cloud hosted documents is obviously another discussion.
- spaceboy 10y agoI have tried deterministic password managers, but as with most solutions they have flaws and tradeoffs[1] to consider. [1] https://tonyarcieri.com/4-fatal-flaws-in-deterministic-password-managers https://tonyarcieri.com/4-fatal-flaws-in-deterministic-passw... [2] Also related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13016132 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13016132
- intrasight 10y agoWhy don't they let him out on bail until the court is able to hear the case?
- kabdib 10y agoHe might encrypt something again! :-) It's a contempt-of-court thing; he's been order to take an action, and hasn't. (He might not remember the encryption passphrase, in which case the question is really, "Does he rot?" and so far the answer appears to be "Yup").
- externalreality 10y agoNot sure what the man's crime is here. Does he even remember his keys after sixteen months in the slammer? I don't even remember my Gmail password after 16 days of vacation. Basically, like the article says, it like not opening a safe for an inquisitor: you are damned if you do, you are damned if you don't. Encryption is nothing new people, you are just putting your data in a safe. We have a tendency to misconstrue, willfully misinterpret, or altogether ignore the law when it comes to prosecuting individuals who we believe to be standing on much lower moral ground. We do so because we want so badly to punish the accused that we are willing to reduce or eliminate greater good that some privacy laws are aiming to provide (i.e. Trumps silly travel ban which is based on his hatred of Muslims built upon imaginary news stories and personal exaggerations of particular recent events -- all laws out the window)
- mirimir 10y agoThis was pretty much inevitable :( > Encryption is nothing new people, you are just putting your data in a safe. Well, you could also be held indefinitely for refusing to provide the combination for a safe. If there were safes that could keep them out indefinitely, anyway. I suspect that they nailed him using ICAC's Black Ice app. It's a hacked version of the Freenet client that logs peer IPs, and tracks hashes that they handle. So his mistake was assuming that deniability was adequate, and failing to hit Freenet via Tor. Edit: 2016-05-26 - Police department's tracking efforts based on false statistics: https://freenetproject.org/news.html#20160526-htl18attack https://freenetproject.org/news.html#20160526-htl18attack
- slantaclaus 10y agoThanks for the background, but somebody has to say it: his failure was looking at child pornography.
- mindslight 10y agoThis is not an activity I want to engage in or even associate with people who do, but a nonviolent private activity is not a reason to violently persecute someone, especially to this degree.
- ust 10y agoProfessor Orin Kerr has wrote about this exact case extensively, and provides a good insight into all legal aspects. I think it is well worth a read, especially the part about the 'forgone conclusion'. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2016/06/07/the-fifth-amendment-limits-on-forced-decryption-and-applying-the-foregone-conclusion-doctrine/?utm_term=.2d6d76adb715 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...
- Kostchei 10y agoRight. Well that changes things. There is some evidence of the contents. I wonder if there are hash values for those 20,000 CEM files and if they are still on freenet. If so LE could aquire, via the hashes, from the network, and prove, without opening the drives, what the contents are. At least it becomes a strong circumstantial case. If you were relying on a single file you could claim the odds of hash collision etc, but after a few hundred I think you are well past that. There is a pattern of behaviour here. *edit - aquire not require..
- iopq 10y ago> If so LE could aquire, via the hashes, from the network, and prove, without opening the drives, what the contents are. Except those files may have been deleted already. You can't prove that you will find anything incriminating on that drive.
- EGreg 10y agoThis is a good reason to have TrueCrypt hidden volumes and other forms of steganography. You can decrypt and still have more stuff that looks like random junk. No one can be sure you decrypted everything. The best idea however is to have sensitive stuff stored encrypted on freenet, and log in using incognito browser sessions.
- ryan-c 10y ago> No one can be sure you decrypted everything. What exactly do you think they're going to do if they don't believe you've decrypted everything?
- EGreg 10y agoNo idea. They don't know anymore if ANYONE decrypted everything. They would do whatever they do right now when they don't know things - about anyone.
- ryan-c 10y agoSo, you don't think they would, believing there is another layer of encrypted data that you could decrypt, lock you up until you "comply"?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Elijen 10y ago"I forgot the password" Problem solved.
- Spivak 10y ago"I'm sorry sir, as personal encryption is classified as a munition there is a legal requirement that you must take proper care to ensure that you are able to respond to all lawful requests for decryption. This carries a penalty of 2-5 years in prison and a fine of $10,000."
- gojomo 10y agoBeing charged, convicted, and sentenced in that way could be a preferable result – compared to indefinite detention without charges or trial!
- michaelmrose 10y agoThis is a terrible precedent people don't always throw away old computers and are bad at remembering passwords
- Spivak 10y agoI'm not saying that this would actually become a reality but its just to point out that technology alone can't solve what is really a human problem. Assuming that the courts maintain the 'safe' metaphor over the 'speech' metaphor for encryption I would expect a court to have some criterion like the the following. The prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that: (0. That the search of the encrypted data is lawful) 1. There is actually encrypted data on the drive. 2. The data has not been modified or corrupted. 3. That the defendant actually knows the password. Because you're completely right that people do forget their passwords all the time. You could being thousands of IT people on the stand who will rant all day about how their users cant remember a stupid eight character password without a post-it note. So the prosecution would have to give evidence that shows that the defendant is lying and knows the password. For example, if they're trying to access the defendant's computer the could show a video of them logging into it right before it was seized.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- geuis 10y agoLaws protecting the worst of us protect the rest and best of us.
- sologoub 10y agoModern encryption isn't that much difference in basic concept to a cipher, such that it takes data in readable form and makes it unreadable. In Apple/Gov dispute on the San Bernardino iPhone case, Gov brought up the Burr case from 1807, arguing that a 3rd party could be compelled to decipher the contents, provided there was no self-incrimination (Apple argued Burr did not apply): http://www.macworld.com/article/3046095/legal/burrs-cipher-sir-the-1807-treason-case-that-featured-in-the-applefbi-conflict.html http://www.macworld.com/article/3046095/legal/burrs-cipher-s... Does anyone know if there has been an attempt to equate decryption to deciphering in US courts?
- enneff 10y agoAren't decrypt and decipher synonyms? What is their distinction, if any?
- sologoub 10y agoNot sure from the mathematical point of view. Not a lawyer, but the Burr case seems to imply that the secretary could be compelled by court to translate the cipher (literally decipher) the letter, provided in doing so he was not going to incriminate himself. If translating a cipher and decrypting a drive is held equivalent, then the subject of this article is likely protected, irrespective of how reprehensible the alleged crime is...
- ommunist 10y agoHumanity is really close to produce tech that quite literally reads minds. Since those are not easily encrypted, what prosecution awaits judges so much obsessed with illicit topics, like the one discussed in this article? Either we'll have an orwellian "thoughtcrime" to become reality, or we change the legal system. For the moment, it is obvious that American legal system and basic information technology are quite different worlds.
- jwatte 10y ago"My hard drive contains only the finest random bytes. There is nothing to decrypt. Please prosecute me for lying if you can prove otherwise."
- Jillboy 10y agoI'm assuming when they boot up (their copy of) the hard drive, it prompts for a passphrase, and if you type an incorrect one it'll tell that it's incorrect (as opposed to simply outputting garbage). That's the most common case anyway. If that's the case, and it likely is, then that's pretty concrete proof that there IS something to decrypt. edit: Actually, the article says that the hard drive was encrypt with Apple's FireVault, so there you go.
- payne92 10y agoIf he were being forced to divulge the physical coordinates of a hidden thumb drive, it's highly likely he'd get Fifth Amendment protection. But being forced to divulge the virtual coordinates of his hidden data is somehow different...
- thescriptkiddie 10y agoI like that metaphor. Encrypting data isn't so much like locking it in a safe as it is hiding it somewhere in the key space. The safe metaphor breaks down because you can drill a hole in the safe to see if there is anything inside. But you can't prove that some encrypted data exists any more than you can prove that a particular item is sitting around somewhere on Earth.
- megous 10y agoWhy don't they sue him based on what they already have. They have to have something strong enough to justify holding him for more than a year already, so wtf?
- cdevs 10y agoWe should jail oj until he tells us he did it?
- cdevs 10y agoWe need John ham in that black mirror Christmas episode..
- ioquatix 10y agoGood to know that File Vault actually works.
- dwaltrip 10y agoI have a related, seemingly analogous situation that I'm curious about. If a suspect might have physically buried important evidence hundreds of miles of way in the middle of nowhere, such that it is effectively impossible to find, can the courts "compell" the suspect to give up any knowledge of this, in a similar fashion as the man in the article?
- anigbrowl 10y agoNo. But proximity carries a great deal of weight for purely practical reasons - when you already know you have the goods then it's maddening to not know how to access them. Not an endorsement of the reasons for the guy's drive being impounded, which I'm ignoring completely for this example.
- realo 10y agoI have a question... Suppose the suspect Alice only has a portion of the key. Someone else (Bob...) has the remaining key bits. Alice is busted, and 'compelled to give the key', and DOES provide her portion of the key. Bob is never found. Then Alice would be indefinitely imprisoned, even if she would have actually complied with the court order. It seems unethical, to me. Bonus question: Alice pretends that Bob exists, but actually he does not, but police cannot prove that. What then? A possible answer to the first question: Alice is not compelled to provide the key. She is compelled to decrypt the drive. Obviously she can't do that without Bob. Alice is screwed and will spend the rest of her life in prison. Seems harsh.
- saycheese 10y agoUsing the same two-key method, attorney–client privilege might be of use, though not sure: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attorney–client_privilege https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attorney–client_privilege
- gresrun 10y agoIANAL, but it would fail to meet the basic criteria, as the communication was not for the purpose of securing legal advice and, the prosecution would argue, the communication was made for the purpose of committing a crime.
- Retr0spectrum 10y agoIANAL, but what if the same keys were also used to encrypt client-attorney communications?
- MichaelBurge 10y agoThey compel you to release everything, but don't allow the client-attorney communications to be used as evidence.
- externalreality 10y ago
- Zikes 10y agoIs the ACLU not at all involved in this case? Shouldn't they be?
- TheBobinator 10y agoThere's a burden of proof here the court needs to meet before holding the defendant in contempt. For starters, it's reasonable to assume the defendant owns the hard drives in question if they're in their possession, irregardless of their testimony otherwise. Given that piece of information: 1: The court has to prove the disks are actually encrypted. It is not merely enough for the cops to pick up the disks, see some garbled data, and determine it's encrypted. Now if you're using a file level encryption protocol that leaves enough un-encrypted stuff on disk that you can identify the filesystem and the file encryption, then you've met the requirement. If you are using full disk encryption, especially something designed to hide the data and filesystem from anything but a forensics package and even a forensics package see's garble, then there's effectively no way to tell the disk is actually encrypted or with what. AND 2: They have to prove the defendant, at some point, had the encryption key. That requires proving the method of encryption and key generation. With a door lock, you know there's a key. With a safe combo, you know the combo could be 12 digits and broken up between a dozen people. With an encryption system, any combination of things you know, are, or have could be part of the key. Compelling the defendant to reveal all of that is absolutely a violation of their 5th amendment rights. Example: Lets assume we're using windows EFS. Lets further assume analysis of EFS indicates the user named "YOU" owns the account. Furthermore, lets assume there are files that have date modified dates within the end users folder that indicate they had logged in the day prior to the search warrant being served. You give the court the "I don't remember" line. In that case, forgetting the password is destruction of evidence, not contempt. If a key escrow is used and they can prove it, same deal, destruction of evidence.
- GTP 10y ago> With an encryption system, any combination of things you know, are, or have could be part of the key. Compelling the defendant to reveal all of that is absolutely a violation of their 5th amendment rights. In the article is stated that he could actually compel to the order by decrypting himself the hard drive without telling the key to anyone. Could you please read my other comment about this topic? I need further explanation about the legal basis for a different behavior when is involved a physical key or a combination.
- ZoFreX 10y ago
- Esau 10y agoTo me, this is incredibly perverse: no one should be forced to assist the government in their own prosecution.
- keithnz 10y agoSeems to me the 5th should protect him. Question is, is that a good thing? Should law enforcement have a right to search through court orders? In a world of unbreakable locks it seems very hard to get justice unless the law can do proper searches. If we end up in a world of unbreakable encryption everywhere, seems to me, criminal activity will have huge benefits. If we can't control crime, we can't have a just society. We can't protect a individuals rights if they are undermined by criminals. Of course, it's also hard if the state has too much power to protect and individuals rights. But somewhere we need pragmatic compromises.
- 9mit3t2m9h9a 10y agoIf the only trace a criminal activity leaves is on a single encrypted drive, is it important if it gets prosecuted or not? The police does parallel construction to avoid admitting access to illegally collected evidence, civil forfeiture to punish people for things police doesn't like without having to prove anything, etc — incentives for police to step over the rules are a larger problem than unbreakable encryption right now.
- orbitingpluto 10y agoI have problems remembering a password if I don't use it for a month or two. After 16 months, I'd probably have no idea.
- upofadown 10y ago>"...Instead, the order requires only that [Rawls] produce his computer and hard drives in an unencrypted state." This language makes it sound like the government is specifically asking the defendant to take an affirmative action to produce the evidence required to incriminate himself. That would be the same thing as issuing an order with the intent to compel an accused murder to tell the police where the body is. I really don't understand how a court could issue an order based on such an argument.
- krick 10y agoJust yesterday [0] someone (multiple people, actually) was claiming fingerprint locking on phones is unsafe based on fact the 5th amendment doesn't protect your fingerprints, but does protect your right to not reveal your password. [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13622684 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13622684
- victor9000 10y agoIt seems like the state is holding the accused captive for failure to produce unencrypted hard drives. But how can the state prove that the accused has the ability to fulfill this request?
- Miner49er 10y agoThey can't. He told them he doesn't know the keys for the drives, and the judge doesn't believe him.
- downandout 10y agoI'm curious why he doesn't just claim that he forgot the key. There's no way to prove conclusively that he's lying, and a judge cannot jail someone for disobeying a court order that they have no way of obeying. If he's told them he knows it and just won't give it to them, then this bridge is probably burned, but it's probably his only shot. Absent a ruling from the Supreme Court on this issue, they can and will hold him until he complies, dies, or has already served the maximum possible sentence for the crimes he is suspected of committing.
- fred_is_fred 10y agoDon't doubt that a judge can't or won't hold you indefinitely if they think you are lying. This guy was held for 14 years because the judge was convinced he was hiding assets in a civil case (divorce): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._Beatty_Chadwick https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._Beatty_Chadwick I mention this because there are parallels. In each case the man would say "I don't have the (key|money)" and in each case the judge can effectively sentence them to indefinite jail.
- m-j-fox 10y agoMy idea is to just hand over the password, which is 'asdf'. If the password fails it's because whoever is in possession of the computer has already logged on and changed the password -- no longer my responsibility.
- hysan 10y agoWhat happens if the drives develop bit rot over those 16 months preventing them from ever being decrypted? Based on the wording of what he is in contempt of, it sounds like he would sit in jail until death. To me, it sounds like the prosecution is trying to play a word game to get around 5th amendment protections.
- digler999 10y agoinvestigators image drives, they dont work with the originals.
- hysan 10y agoI know that, but read the exact wording they used to define why he is in contempt and what he has to do. That's the important part. But I'll play along with your pedantic game. First, the wording says to give over his computer and hard drives. What if those hard drives failed? He can't handover the literal hard drives anymore. Ok, you say it can be any hard drive then. The court will provide replacements and the disk images. If investigators providing those materials is allowed as a means to allow Rawls to complete said task, that means Rawls is allowed access to materials the court (or prosecution or him or some other entity) deems necessary. Not a big deal, right? Wrong. Going down that rabbit hole can lead to a slippery slope where courts can abuse the power of the wording to indefinitely contain anyone given that they assign them a task that "can" be completed with the given materials. However, the feasibility of the task may or may not be reasonable. It's the twisting of the law through evasive language that is the problem here. They are deliberately avoiding the 5th Amendment by deploying language that skirts the letter of the law and ignores the intention/spirit of it.
- INTPenis 10y agoSpeaking from experience of 1 month vacation I'm not sure I'd be able to decrypt after 16 months of not touching a keyboard. My most important passwords (passphrases for gpg used by password managers and luks) are in my head and muscle memory. When I update passwords I tend to have them written down until I've typed them enough times. So after a months vacation I often struggle to remember my work password for example. While using phrases makes all this easier these days, 16 months is a long time to presumably spend without your keyboard.
- 123younas786 10y agohttp://lootumaza.com/kodi-dsplayer-17-0-1-free-download/ http://lootumaza.com/kodi-dsplayer-17-0-1-free-download/
- yellowapple 10y ago"The authorities say it's a 'foregone conclusion' that illicit porn is on those drives. But they cannot know for sure unless Rawls hands them the alleged evidence that is encrypted with Apple's standard FileVault software." Then it ain't a "foregone conclusion". If it was, they wouldn't need him to unlock the drives; they could prosecute him with the evidence they used to arrive upon that "foregone conclusion".
- GTP 10y agoI don't reside in the USA and I don't know the US law. After reading a certain amount of comments seems that the heart of the discussion is the fifth emendament. I agree that if the 5th emendament protects you from giving the combination of a safe logically follows that the same applies for encription passwords. But I don't agree with the root of this argumentation: if a court has a valid reason to think that a safe contains evidence that is relevant for the lawsuit, why should make any difference if the safe is locked with a physical key or with a combination? Somebody who has a different opinion could please explain me his point?
- Zelmor 10y agoHere we have an example of a forceful, totalitarian state. Where they cannot keep up their laws due to technological progress, they threaten you with violence and boredom (boredom as in sitting in a cage as long as you refuse to comply). In communist era Eastern Europe, secret police used to send in beautiful prostitutes and/or agents to deal with people held in captivity. Get a man to erect his penis. When that happened, strong men stormed the room, grabbed the victim, and inserted a glass rod into his penis. Then smashed it. I would not like to go into details on what they did to women. You can look that up. Land of the Free - as long as you do not encrypt your shit, that is
- mtgx 10y agoRemember when Obama passed the law that allows for indefinite detention without charge? And how his supporters said "Yeah, but it's not like he would use it"? I think it's already used all the time across the country now. A law that "is not supposed to be used" should not exist. If it exists, then it will be used. I'm sure this is some kind of Murphy law or something.
- sjy 10y agoThis case is about a federal statute that dates back to 1789.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoOn the other hand there's no misinterpretation involved in recognising Mohammed as being a murderous war-lord who condoned rape and pillage; and also being the Islamic model of a perfect person.
- dang 10y agoWe warned you before about religious flamewars on HN. We won't ban you this time, even though it's nauseating to see a comment like this on HN, because your recent history looks reasonably in keeping with the site rules. But if you post anything like this again, we will. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13630895 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13630895 and marked it off-topic.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoFWIW I think you need to move your allegations of flamewars up-thread. It was a pretty measured response to the comment IMO, viz: >"Yet, that doesn't stop Christians from misinterpreting the Muslim concept of jihad" It's an explanation for the misinterpretation of jihad by non-Muslims. Why that comment should be allowed without the historic nature of Mohammed - based on Koran and Hadith, at least - being noted seems a little, shall we say, biased. It's not a solely Christian thing to interpret jihad as [potentially] a bloody mode of aggression, it's inter alia an atheist, hindu, and indeed fundamentalist Muslim thing too. AFAIR I've not been an initiator of something that could be interpreted as flamewars; your objection is noted. I assume [flagged] means this is invisible to the thread? AFAIA there's no other way to respond, so please note that I'm not trying to disobey your edict, but instead to place my comment in context.
- ohstopitu 10y agoWe seriously need self destructing time based keys. Once a device does not have a password in a time defined by the user - all of it is wiped. It goes without saying that this should be off by default but definitely a good feature.
- iUsedToCode 10y agoPolice could just make a backup of a snapshot.
- smokedoutraider 10y agoAre we just ignoring that he is a pedo, and likely has incriminating garbage on his laptop?
- digler999 10y agowhat's being ignored is the constitution. which is an even more grave injustice than child abuse.
- stillsut 10y agoI really hate to be writing this but it seems like the only solution... Doesn't this whole situation and the threat thereof go away for 99.9% of the population if we decriminalize possession / "viewing" of child pornography? [Note: you could still be severely prosecuted for making it] There doesn't appear to be anything else in the digital realm that can get you in such legal trouble. The only other thing I could think of is national defense espionage, or rogue WMD plans. And on these counts, 99.9% of people are going to be very difficult to put a plausible frame job for these crimes. Sure the 0.1% with security clearance could be framed here, but as far as I understand, that's a personal decision and risk each person go to make for themselves. If you deny the prosecution the ability to use reasonable suspicion of CP to search, or compel a decryption of your digital files, it's going to be a long time before another case like this.
- sean2 10y agoNo, plenty of other stuff is illegal; just off the top of my head: Possession of copy-righted material Possession of hacking tools Evidence of hacking Data from corporate espionage Accounting fraud Fraud (e.g. fake credit info) Evidence of other crimes (e.g. account books of drug deals) Plans to commit other crimes The list goes on. It just so happens the FBI is obsessed with CP, but if you decriminalize that, we'll have the same problems with other crimes.
- stillsut 10y agoThis is a helpful brainstorm. But let me explain why I think these are far less worrisome. Take corporate espionage: sure proprietary files from my employer could end up on hard-drive. But that would mean the FBI is willing to in addition to frame me, pay someone to go in and steal from my company. That's the type of thing that get's someone's boss's boss canned. Do you see how high the conspiracy is going here? And do you know how messy this type of action gets when you need all these different nefarious actors executing FrontPageHeadline news if caught. As far as the Drugs.xls, or the MobsterAccountPayable.xls, there already exists much legal room to disqualify a one-off document, without some kind of physical evidence - e.g. a guy wearing a wire says "Hears the money to pay Tony the Muscle" and you say "cool" or the guy who runs a storage facility says thats the guy who came in two months ago and rented that locker where the drugs were found. That's why the police are so obsessed with getting these type non-digital evidence: because a conviction on pure digital grounds is almost impossible with a halfway decent lawyer. The thing about CP it doesn't have to be congruent with any other aspect of your life or be verified by anything physical or any witness. Even the motive/rationale is he had disturbing sexual impulses deep in his heart and its common sense that he wouldn't revel these to anyone so let's just assume he does.
- data4science 10y agoSo much for my plan to: 1. Reformat a hard drive with DBAN 2. Name the new drive: the_art_of_the_deal_2_from_future 3. Start a LLC named Marty McFly 4. Mail said drive from said entity to the White House