19 ms·
Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016)
- JonRB 10y agoThis link is just timing out for me. HN hug of death?
- Rmilb 10y agoFullhn.com has it saved.
- Neliquat 10y agoAs a home brewer, any of these styles, even 10% or higher is easily accomplished by any seasoned brewmaster. And for the quantity of beer brewed, and number of breweries, there must have been many. I must say that I cannot agree with the authors conclusion surrounding strong beer, as I have one in my fridge, made with barley and rye in the old way at 10.7 as determened by hydrometer. It kicks like a mule but is very drinkable.
- throwaway91111 10y agoWhile I agree with you, people would often water down their beer and liquor, so the brewed strength is not necessarily what people drank.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Neliquat 10y agoTrue, but not likely with beer except in the case of rations from what I understand. Its not quite like watering down wine or rum.
- nradov 10y agoSupposedly in the old British Royal Navy, watering down the daily rum ration was a common punishment for minor infractions. The offending sailor still received the same quantity of rum, just with twice as much water added. I can't imagine what the captains thought they were accomplishing.
- smallnamespace 10y agoWell, the quality of the water (as well as provisions) on a ship starts declining drastically once you're at sea for an extended period. I can't imagine any sailor actually wanting to drink the water, except out of pure necessity.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wavefunction 10y agoWatering it down as a punishment doesn't seem to make a lot of sense. I have read that the rum ration was mixed with fruit juice both to extend the drink and likely to attempt to combat scurvy. This is where 'grog' comes from, which is rum mixed with fruit juice.
- dagw 10y agomade with barley and rye in the old way I'm assuming you're adding brewers yeast as well. My understanding is that beers made in this period where brewed purely with natural fermentation, making it much harder to reach these higher strength.
- Neliquat 10y agoKind of. All our cultured yeasts were once wild. Brewers cultivate their own yeast or use others. The most common way is to keep some after an especially good batch, and use it until it 'ages' and enough generations of yeast have passed to change the flavor. I actually brewed my second beer this way, saving the yeast from a bottle fermented chimay.
- mikekchar 10y agoIt really depends. For example, take lambic beer production. This is a spontaneously fermented beer from Pajottenland, near Brussels. You can easily hit 8-9% alcohol. The key is that the microflora that innoculates the wort was living in the barrels. When you had a "good" barrel, you would keep brewing in it. When the barrel went "bad" you would destroy it and burn it. The entire brewery would be a source of yeast and in some breweries it was considered very bad form to clean. Even today, there are some Belgian breweries where you can get fired if you kill a spider (the spiders catch fruit flies that can bring in wort spoiling bacteria). Once you had a good, stable population of yeast/bacteria you could maintain it simply by overwhelming other beasties. When I first started homebrewing, I didn't know that much and I must have gone nearly 10 years without ever disinfecting anything. I had a definite "house flavour" in my beer, but it was far from bad. Anyway, these days, in order to get up to 10% (or higher) alcohol level, you will go with a single strain with high alcohol tolerance. But there are several traditional multi-strain cultures that do a very good job and have a very interesting flavour profile. Quite frequently you'll have one strain that ferments quickly and drops out fast with a second one that is "powdery" and hangs in suspension for months. Finally you will have a "chaining" yeast that will drag the "powdery" yeast out of suspension. You end up with having most of the flavour profile of the first yeast, while the powdery yeast will bring the terminal gravity down and the last yeast will brighten the beer. Some really famous yeast cultures (like Worthington Whiteshield) are composed of 5 or more strains working in concert. It is truly amazing what people accomplished just with selective techniques. Having said that, some styles that are currently quite high alcohol were traditionally much sweeter. Bock styles were drunk by monks during lent. These beers had to be sweet enough to sustain them, because they ate nothing else during that period. A friend of mine who did quite a lot of research in the area (because he wanted to do the same thing... :-P) reckoned that historical bocks were probably only 3-4% alcohol.
- mrob 10y ago10% is easy with modern equipment and yeast, but remember that pure yeast strains didn't exist until Emil Hansen isolated one at the Carlsberg Laboratory in 1883 [1]. In Early Modern times people used whatever yeast happened to grow locally, saved between batches as "barm" (flocculated yeast). Selection pressure with this propagation technique is primarily for flocculation ability, and it produces strains much more flocculant than wild strains. These strains have lower attenuation because they drop out of suspension before all the sugar is fermented. Try reaching 10% ABV with a traditional English strain like Fermentis Safale S-04 - it's pretty much impossible. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emil_Christian_Hansen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emil_Christian_Hansen
- colin_mccabe 10y agoDespite what Fermentis claims, I don't think S-04 is that "traditional." It's a beast of a yeast and it will keep going and going. 10% is pushing the upper end of its range, but more because of the limited alcohol tolerance of the yeast than because of anything else. It makes sense if you consider where it came from-- it was supposedly used in the tower fermenters of the old Whitbread brewery. Where the most important thing was a cockaroach-like ability to survive and keep fermenting no matter what, as new wort was fed into one end of the system and fermented beer came out the other end. I don't like s-04 because it throws lactic acid, which tastes like someone squeezed a lemon into the beer. Not what I want in an English ale. If you want traditional, go with something like Danstar Winsor. But be warned, the yeast can't ferment maltotriose, and it struggles with gravities above 1.040. As to what early moderns did-- well, they could have just put sugar in the wort if they wanted to push up the ABV. I guess that wouldn't apply back in the middle ages though (not sure what you are considering early modern).
- SFJulie 10y agoI was told by a biologist that old houses were full of airborne yeast (saccarome cervisirae) which origins where the «Chaumes» roof. [confirmed by a link in the paperspace] https://books.google.fr/books?id=GcqQCgAAQBAJ&pg=PT68&lpg=PT68&dq=toit+de+chaume+et+levure+de+biere&source=bl&ots=0lxAI0sLBc&sig=3PO4zjstinLdHYPfaLvcHhfUgZo&hl=fr&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiCgviO3e7RAhXF7hoKHS7tDdMQ6AEIGjAA#v=onepage&q=toit%20de%20chaume%20et%20levure%20de%20biere&f=false https://books.google.fr/books?id=GcqQCgAAQBAJ&pg=PT68&lpg=PT...
- gadders 10y agoThe author should try going to Belgium. In our recent trip to Brugge it was hard to find a beer under 10% and ones above that were common.
- throwaway91111 10y ago(Second reply of mine, sorry). Apparently one reason high ABV alcohol was hard was because yeast started dying off after 7%. A better source than I can be: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/14fvf8/comment/c7cqiz1 https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/14fvf8/comme... While I can't vouch for the comment itself, I can vouch for the availability of people on that subreddit to ask similar questions and demand sourced answers.
- soundwave106 10y agoThe higher the abv, the higher the pressure on yeast, yes. But from what I can tell, at least by the time brewers were recording their recipes using hydrometers, beers up to around 10% were very possible. For instance, Brew Your Own references some strong stout beers made in 1868 (recorded by a "G. Amsinck") here. (http://byo.com/bock/item/1623-when-stout-was-stout http://byo.com/bock/item/1623-when-stout-was-stout) I plugged the OG (original specific gravity) and FG (final specific gravity) into a specific gravity to alcohol calculator, these are the results: Dublin Stout: OG: 1.092, FG: 1.019 (ABV: 9.6%) Treble Stout: OG: 1.096, FG: 1.031 (ABV: 8.0%) This is not typical -- the Dublin stout is more like a strong export style. Ray Daniels in "Designing Great Beers" provides both more references from G. Amsinck as well as a table derived from "The American Handy-Book of the Brewing Malting and Auxillary Trades" (1908). For more common "porter", the ranges was more typically, say OG: 1.06 FG: 1.02 (about 5% roughly). Ray Daniels' book likewise references historical Scotch ales similarly. At the high end, massive Scotch ales were present in the nineteenth century (with OG in the 1.120 range, FG in the 1.050 range, and an ABV of 9%). Also more common Scotch ale too. It is true that by modern standards many of these beers would be relatively sweet, not as fermented. I personally would guess that even without pure cultures, if you used a fairly simple and probably even known technique back then -- make a big beer, and put that big beer on top of the yeast cake of a finished small beer -- 10% is pretty doable. (The 20+% some craft brewers can go for, however, is probably not. :) )
- throwaway91111 10y agoHmm, I think time frame is at play here--I had forgotten the early modern constraint! Nonetheless this is a great resource for more reading--cheers!
- aardvark291 10y agoTLDR: * Because beer was consumed as a source of energy rather than as an alternative to water, and high alcohol content was favored, it seems like the answer is "Yes." * However, it's unclear whether early brewers could make drinkable beer at high ABV, throwing this conclusion into doubt.
- pkulak 10y ago* But even if they couldn't hit the high ABV numbers, they were still drinking at least 3% beer pretty much all day long. From what I've read, this behavior pretty much continued straight through until prohibition in the States. Usually a cider before about lunch, then beer and spirits.
- village-idiot 10y agoFrom what I understand prohibition was the result of revolutionary drinking habits meeting up with increasing supplies of industrialized and cheap high alcohol beer and spirits.
- ctdonath 10y agoAs urban populations grew, rural grain farmers soon found that transporting spirits was a far more profitable per-volume process than raw dry grains. BTW: that eventually led to institutionalizing the Southern US's illegal "moonshine culture", which as the automobile became commonplace started using cars for smuggling spirits, which then led to car racing (smugglers had powerful vehicles and talented drivers) which eventually manifested as NASCAR.
- ctdonath 10y agoI'm noticing this thread is completely missing the point that common fruit drinks (high calorie, nutritious, safe origin), which was a convenient way of storing fruit (just squeeze & filter), would immediately start fermenting. Other than water (often unsafe) or milk (goes bad quickly), about the only shelf-stable beverages were self-fermenting.
- sgt101 10y agoI made cyder at home a couple of years ago (about 8 gallons). I had 2 pints at one sitting, I have no memory of the evening past about 10pm and when I woke up my first thought was that I had had a stroke. The rest of the stuff is still sitting in the shed.
- vidanay 10y agoI'll tell you a story that happened to me One day as I went down to Cork by the sea The sun it was hot and the day it was warm, Says I a quiet pint wouldn't do me no harm I went in and I called for a bottle of stout Says the barman, I'm sorry, all the beer is sold out Try whiskey or paddy, ten years in the wood Says I, I'll try cider, I've heard it was good. Oh never, Oh never, Oh never again If I live to be a hundred or a hundred and ten I fell to the ground and I couldn't get up After drinking a quart of the Johnny Jump Up http://thebards.net/music/lyrics/Johnny_Jump_Up.shtml http://thebards.net/music/lyrics/Johnny_Jump_Up.shtml
- pavel_lishin 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u56R_qHTLVI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u56R_qHTLVI
- lightedman 10y agoYou might need to distill off the methanol that might be present, if you're blacking out. Had a similar problem with some homebrew wine where a glass tossed me to blacking out (yet I can toss back a half pint of vodka without too much issue.) Turned out there was a good amount of methanol in there.
- Balgair 10y agoThey were most certainly tossed off their butts in the antebellum US at least: "Drink was everywhere in early America. “Liquor at that time,” recalled the Massachusetts carpenter Elbridge Boyden, “was used as commonly as the food we ate.” Americans drank in enormous quantities. Their yearly consumption at the time of the Revolution has been estimated at the equivalent of three-and-a-half gallons of pure, two-hundred proof alcohol for each person. After 1790 American men began to drink even more. By the late 1820s imbibing had risen to an all-time high of almost four gallons per capita."[0] That 1820s number, if you do the math, was ~1.4 shots of Everclear or 3.5 shots of modern 80 proof whiskey per day for the average citizen. Wikipedia [1] has some more info on the boozing of people in those antebellum days. Suffice to say, it was a lot of booze. You can debate the strengths of these particular spirits and beers and people's drinking habits, but form what written evidence we have, the US was a nation populated by either a lot of very tipsy people, or a lot of sober people and some very drunk people. [0] http://www.teachushistory.org/second-great-awakening-age-reform/articles/historical-note-temperance-reform-early-19th-century http://www.teachushistory.org/second-great-awakening-age-ref... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuisine_of_Antebellum_America#Alcohol_in_the_antebellum_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuisine_of_Antebellum_America#...
- maxerickson 10y ago4 shots of whiskey is quite a lot but for many people wouldn't lead to anything resembling drunk if consumed over a period of several hours.
- cypherpunks01 10y agoYep! I think that's what commenter's statement is intended to mean: "the US was a nation populated by either a lot of very tipsy people, or a lot of sober people and some very drunk people".
- maxerickson 10y agoBut even tipsy wouldn't be the case for people that were drinking such amounts everyday.
- mayneack 10y agoDan Carlin's Hardcore History podcast has an episode on how drugs and alcohol affected some major historical events: http://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-20-blitz-history-under-the-influence/ http://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-20-blitz-h...
- schnevets 10y agoI have always noticed contradictions within the history of booze. I can't understand how anyone who has ever tried well-water can believe that misconception about choosing beer over water. Also, an old U.S. History textbook in high school suggesting to us that the Temperance Movement was a reaction to people suddenly discovering strong alcohol. This article confirmed my suspicions on both of those events.
- SamBam 10y ago> I can't understand how anyone who has ever tried well-water can believe that misconception about choosing beer over water. But for urban folk in the middle of London, or New York, was the water they were consuming as fresh as what you're imagining when you think of "well water?" Even if it was drawn from nearby wells, and not from dirty cisterns, was their sewage system good enough to keep it from getting contaminated? I don't know so much about water cleanliness, and the article suggests it may not have been that dirty, but I wouldn't assume that it was all as clean as a perfect little rural well.
- astrodust 10y agoWell water? Early municipal water systems were disgusting. The stuff that flowed in through the taps was barely filtered and mostly untreated. http://shifting-grounds.net/pre-history/water-condition.html http://shifting-grounds.net/pre-history/water-condition.html If it was a choice between bilge water and beer, I'd pick beer every time.
- ctdonath 10y agoI grew up on well water. It was fine. Problem is when it isn't fine, such as in an "urban" area where there's lots of people drawing water and lots of people dumping contaminants indiscriminately (common then). They may have "discovered" strong drinks at a point when the expanding American corn-farming industry discovered that moving whiskey was a whole lot more profitable per volume than dried corn.
- FabHK 10y agoCholera was transmitted via contaminated water, remember John Snow's famous map showing the affected families during an 1854 outbreak in London were near one particular pump: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1854_Broad_Street_cholera_outbreak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1854_Broad_Street_cholera_outb...
- zxcvvcxz 10y agoVery interesting read. Assuming I descended from these people, I wonder if I could build up such a tolerance, because it sure doesn't seem that way on the rare occassions I do drink. Does anyone have links to a similar history of coffee? When and how it originated, effects it had on the people, etc.
- clock_tower 10y agoFernand Braudel has some pretty interesting material about coffee in passing, in The Structures of Everyday Life. One thing he discusses is how alcohol, coffee, and tobacco all substituted for each other to an extent: where coffee consumption spread in France, for example, wine consumption fell.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoIf I had to hazard a guess, I would say that all three were primarily social activities - you'd go and meet your friends for a drink at the bar, or some coffee at the coffeeshop, or to smoke cigars at a lounge. If your friends are all drinking coffee, you're likely going to start seeking a caffeine buzz rather than an alcohol one.
- clock_tower 10y agoThat sounds about right. To judge by The Structures of Everyday Life (my source for talking about all this), even "drinking to get drunk" was something done socially. Taverns were the ruin of the peasantry when they spread into the French countryside; there were enormous taverns just outside the walls of Paris, where the whole city gathered to drink too much wine and dodge the city's heavy taxes on it; and English society got blitzed on gin in the 18th century (a drinking epidemic even by early-modern standards), but specifically on gin sold by the glass and drunk on the spot, in the company of other patrons.
- benbreen 10y agoBrian Cowan's The Social Life of Coffee [1] is the best book on the history of coffee that I know of. Fascinating story, in part because coffee's history with humans is far more brief than that of alcohol or opium. There's basically an order of magnitude difference between the former and the latter (1k years of consumption vs 10k). I also agree with the Braudel recommendation. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Social-Life-Coffee-Emergence-Coffeehouse/dp/0300171226 https://www.amazon.com/Social-Life-Coffee-Emergence-Coffeeho...
- espeed 10y agoAre modern-day people perpetually drunk on mass-media opiates from consuming up to a gallon of behaviorally-engineered dopamine shots each day?
- wtbob 10y ago> Are modern-day people perpetually drunk on mass-media opiates from consuming up to a gallon of behaviorally-engineered dopamine shots each day? Yes?
- aaron695 10y ago> Were early modern people perpetually drunk? It's an idiotic premise. Turn up to work drunk and see how well you do. Who the hell would want to do a labourer's job drunk. Who would hire someone drunk? Imagine the whole workforce drunk? Even tipsy, seems worse, the afternoon sucks after lunch drinks. I think if you look at current 3rd world countries they are not far off culturally to 'Early Modern People' There's a huge crutch on alcohol, it kills a lot of people. But most people are not drunk (or tipsy) most of the time.
- douche 10y agoYou can sweat out a lot of beer doing brute-force manual labor. Especially if it's relatively low-test beer - it's pretty hard to drink it fast enough to get tipsy. I mean, the daily ration of beer in the Royal Navy, when they were in English waters and not on hard stuff, was one gallon per man per day. And they were scampering around in the mastheads...
- aaron695 10y ago> it's pretty hard to drink it fast enough to get tipsy Exactly. > was one gallon per man per day. It'd be interesting to see how it was consumed. I'd imagine most sailors rarely took their entire ration and it'd be after shift as a binge. I like this quote - "You mustn't imagine that naval ships were sailed by crews of drunken sailors," says Dr van der Merwe, general editor at the National Maritime Museum. "Everybody drowns if sailors are drunk all the time." http://news.bbc.co.uk/today/hi/today/newsid_8859000/8859506.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/today/hi/today/newsid_8859000/8859506.... This is like the myth of split sleep, I don't know why people think these things are possible. We know how we live, we know how really poor people live and these things just don't fit, they are illogical but people still believe them.
- dpark 10y ago> one gallon per man per day No it wasn't. There was never a time that a whole gallon per day was a normal rum ration. It was a gallon of beer, later a half pint of rum. A half pint of strong rum is still a lot to consume every day, but it's nowhere near a gallon. Over time it was reduced until it turned into basically a shot, and then even that was stopped. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rum_ration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rum_ration
- mannykannot 10y agoI was a bit taken aback by this statement: "[Dr.] James [Sumner], a historian of science and technology... argues that ‘alcohol by volume’ was rarely used as a measure of strength for beers and wines until the work of nineteenth-century French chemists such as Joseph Louis Gay-Lussac, and that it’s therefore ahistorical to apply it to earlier cultures and beverages." To me, this is like saying that because trilobites did not make measurements of ocean pH, it would be wrong for us to estimate the acidity of Cambrian oceans. Is there more to this than just an absurdly dogmatic backlash against Whig historiography?
- benbreen 10y agoThat's a good question. Reading it charitably, one could interpret that to mean either 1) we can't reliably estimate alcohol by volume prior to the 19th century because there weren't reliable tools to measure it or 2) pre-19th century people didn't think in terms of ABV, and that this may have meant that they experienced drunkenness differently on a subjective level. I'm generally anti-Whig but I'm with you on this one in hoping that there's more to it than that.
- mannykannot 10y agoThe article does mention some more quantitative methods for estimating potency, including working from recipes. Dr. Sumner may have reasons for doubting the efficacy of these methods. On reflection, I suspect that the article has mixed up two different arguments by Dr. Sumner, one about the estimates of potency, and a different one about how or whether we should judge these allegedly inebriated societies. Of course, Hogarth (among others) had something to say at what I think was a slightly later time, about the effects of cheap gin.
- twinkletwinkle 10y agoCompared to the paragraph before it, I think he's just saying our estimates of ABV may be wildly off because we don't have a great historical basis for them. Our modern notion of what constitutes wine or liquor is based in part on ABV ranges. If we say "ancient peoples drank wine nonstop", someone might think you're talking about a ~15% ABV beverage, when that isn't necessarily true.
- NamTaf 10y agoI absolutely love that they're trying to reach a broader public engagement of their historical academic work through innovative events such as the pub nights. I mean it's pretty easy for this when your research is into brewing habits of early modern people but it marks a significant depature from the lofty circles of academia and helps to really engage Joe Public with historical research and academic discovery in an easily accessable way. I think that's an absolutely fantastic goal to shoot for. Scientific (and in a broader sense, academic in general) outreach is really important and beneficial for society as a whole, so I'm only too happy to read about how some people are trying to do that!
- derefr 10y ago> beer was more important as a source of energy (via calories both from grain and alcohol) > they were likely to have been pushing for ‘sweetness and body’ rather than maximum alcoholic strength So, basically, people drank beer like they drink soda-pop today, and wanted the same things out of it (sweet, fizzy, not necessarily alcoholic, goes well with food.) Anyone know what those people of the Early Modern era had to say about coffee? Were people who drank coffee, but not beer, considered teetotalers?
- rbanffy 10y agoIIRC, coffee was introduced to Europe at about the end of the Dark Ages. I don't think it's a coincidence.
- aidenn0 10y agoIn my early 20s I could drink 5% ABV beer all day long and never get too drunk to pass a field-sobriety test.
- barking 10y agoI would really love to know the prevalence of liver disease then vs now. Because now it is apparently at a record high or so we are being told all the time.
- martinald 10y agoProblem is life expectancy was so low then it would be hard to do a proper comparison, and most cases of liver failure happen in later life.
- Touche 10y agoHow did they avoid massive weight gain?
- slfnflctd 10y agoA lot more physical activity. I think it's fairly well established that ~ 90% of people worked in agriculture (without machinery, of course) as recently as the 18th century.
- ctdonath 10y agoExercise. People had to physically work a whole lot harder than we do. Local travel was mostly by foot. Heating the house meant hauling & shoveling coal or wood. Food & clothing was far more labor intensive. Entertainment was far more likely physical; even watching a show meant traveling to the theater. Contrast today, where the thermostat keeps temperatures comfortable automatically, car/bus/taxi takes most people everywhere, prepared food is cheap (heat via microwave), work for the HN crowd is sitting/reading/typing, and entertainment is staring at a glowing wall.
- panglott 10y ago"James S. goes on to point out that while you can achieve the percentages suggested by Craig using modern barley, malting techniques, yeast, and equipment, such ‘show-stopping’ figures were unlikely to have been achieved by even the commercial producers of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries." This is a key point. Malting is tricky: The barley seed must be germinated, since the enzyme that converts starch to fermentable sugars is produced by the sprouting seed. Then the germinated seed must be sterilized in a way that prevents too much of the starch from being converted but also does little damage to the grain. This can be done with drying, toasting, and smoking, but it requires a lot of process control to get a uniformly "pale" malt rather than a darker caramel or chocolate malt where some of the starches and sugars have been caramelized. The development and popularization of pilseners and other light, clear beers in the 19th century was driven by techical advances in malting. 18th century malts were certainly less advanced, more uneven in quality, with a higher proportion of caramelized and toasted sugars and consequently a lot of body and a lower alcohol content.
- LoonyBalloony 10y agoReminded me of the theory that early humans ate tons of psychedelic fungus and that is what helped us create the neural pathways towards sentience. (if you think we are sentient now that is) Between that, and the cannabis receptors in our brains, perhaps we're not supposed to be sober. Maybe everything is going to shit in the world because we as a species are going through a collective withdrawal from the substances that made us in the first place. Edit: I think this is the documentary that I saw that referenced weaker beer. http://www.pbs.org/kenburns/prohibition/watch-video/#id=2082675582 http://www.pbs.org/kenburns/prohibition/watch-video/#id=2082...