9 ms·
> Viewers today expect incredible production value. Not really, no. I expect interesting movies, and I'd say being an interesting movie doesn't have anything t
by paganel 10y ago
> Viewers today expect incredible production value.
Not really, no. I expect interesting movies, and I'd say being an interesting movie doesn't have anything to do with CGI. I'm a film buff through and through and it almost literally pains me when I see that people involved in the movie industry don't seem to understand what their problem is: they don't make films for grown-ups anymore.
The only outlet that has provided interesting movie-like content in the last 10-15 years was television. There's almost no CGI in shows like The Wire, The Sopranos, Black Mirror (to just name a few), shows that have made me casually think about them while I was riding the tramway and the like years after I had last seen them.
I miss great movies.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoGreat movies require great writing, and then good-to-great acting. CGI? None is fine, but if there is any, it also needs to be good-to-great.
- mortenjorck 10y agoIndeed, bad CG can ruin an otherwise great movie. My go-to example is the high-concept 2008 Mexican Sci-fi thriller Sleep Dealer - had the director simply chosen to have the biggest action setpieces happen off-screen or be otherwise implied, it might have been enough of a success to make back its modest 2.5M investment, but the abysmal CG they were able to get on that budget brought the whole film down.
- flukus 10y agoI enjoyed babylon 5 a couple of years ago which has poor special effects by today's standards. The bad CGI did not detract from it at all.
- Keyframe 10y agoHey, it had poor visual effects by its day's standards as well! Great writing though.
- flukus 10y agoI thought they were cutting edge at the time,everyone else was still using scale models weren't they?
- Merad 10y agoIt was cutting edge technology, but looked inferior to the physical models used by shows like Star Trek TNG or DS9 (I say sadly as a huge B5 fan).
- pluma 10y agoI was a Star Trek fan back in the day and the effects were one of the reasons I never gave the show a fair chance. It just looked so low quality compared to the practical effects in other shows.
- Keyframe 10y agoIt wasn't cutting edge at the time. I started doing pro VFX about that time. What was revolutionary with their VFX though was that they were using Lightwave (and Amigas, presumably PCs later too) which cheapened their VFX workflow by a significant margin. Workstations and software at the time were a significant cost. Like, REAL SIGNIFICANT.
- npsimons 10y ago> Great movies require great writing, and then good-to-great acting. I would argue against that last part; great movies do require great writing, but you can get good to great performances out of mediocre actors if you have a great director. No amount of good acting will overcome a bad director.
- Alex3917 10y ago> they don't make films for grown-ups anymore. In NYC there is an entire indie film district with four or five theaters within a few blocks. There is still good stuff being made, just not by Hollywood.
- aswanson 10y agoIs there a distro channel you can recommend to get access to some of this work?
- rockostrich 10y agoLook for indie movie theaters in your area. I'm a little spoiled in that the town I grew up in had an amazing indie film theater (Cinema Arts Centre) and now I live in NYC where I can go to the IFC Center or Sunshine Cinemas to see indie films.
- adamqureshi 10y agoCinema Arts Centre In Hton? i live here and its great! lol
- hisham_hm 10y agoJust look for French and Italian movies, for starters.
- dgfgfdagasdfgfa 10y agoOf course, unless you prefer an independent community that does not revolve around French and Italians movies. :)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 10y agoBad recommendation. French movies also have their own industry just as poisoned as Hollywood.
- RodericDay 10y agoSnowpiercer was stellar. 40 million.
- vlunkr 10y agoBut what percentage of viewers do you represent?
- sametmax 10y agoIt hursts. But you are right.
- Throwaway23412 10y agoA pretty small percentage, obviously. The top grossing movies of 2016 were Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, Finding Dory, Captain America: Civil War, The Secret Life of Pets, and The Jungle Book. All of these movies would be impossible to do without CGI. Viewers want movies to be spectacles. If we're watching something in a theater, we have high expectations of the production value. Otherwise, why even waste the time and money going to a theater? We can watch the "good", low production value movies at home.
- aswanson 10y agoI think the home is starting to turn into the movie theater. It's fairly common to see 4k 55" TVs in people's homes; I'm wondering how far they can take the sizes for a residential area. The accompanying sound systems for these home theaters are high quality as well. I guess it's an arms race to out-spectacle what you can get out of an increasingly performant screen from Samsung, et al.
- vlunkr 10y agoThis is a good point, the experience at the theater used to be drastically different that what you'd get at home (VHS, non-widescreen, stereo audio, etc), but the gap is certainly closing. Combine that with highway robbery concession prices, being surrounded by a bunch of strangers... the theater is starting to look less appealing.
- jonhohle 10y ago> Rogue One: A Star Wars Story… would be impossible to do without CGI. It's a prequel to a movie that had exactly one computer generated element in it, which was a wireframe model that took so long to render that they couldn't re-render it when the final design changed. They _chose_ not to make it without CGI. It wouldn't have been impossible. edit: I'll just leave this right here - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0034928/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0034928/
- aswanson 10y agoI'll take low-effect, nice plot Ex Machina over pretty much every over-CGI'd, Power Ranger plot scifi/superhero Hollywood film in recent memory.
- santaclaus 10y agoEx Machina had hella CGI, it won an academy award for their visual effects!
- justinjlynn 10y agoIf it's done right, CGI disappears.
- hueving 10y agoBut the costs certainly don't. :)
- objclxt 10y agoEx Machina's budget was around $15 million, that's extremely low.
- bananaboy 10y ago"Zodiac" is a great example of that[1]. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-sZS8OVyVr4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-sZS8OVyVr4
- RileyKyeden 10y agoI didn't realize how much of the sets in Game of Thrones are done on computer until I watched a making-of for one of the seasons. Even knowing, I can't tell when watching.
- lmm 10y agoEx Machina had huge amounts of effects. CGI is a case of "When you do things right, people won't be sure you've done anything at all."
- ganley 10y agoThe best movie I've (finally) seen in recent months was El Mariachi. He made that for like $8K. Assault on Precinct 13 (the original one): $150,000. The list goes on and on. The Way of the Gun, a more recent favorite of mine with a bunch of big actors in it: $8.5M. Another factor might be exorbitant star salaries. However, I think that's a symptom, not the disease. The real problem is that Hollywood is greedy. They won't touch a $10M film with no big stars in it because it's not likely to make an 8-figure profit.
- dragonwriter 10y agoSounds like the real problem is that audiences disproportionately respond to big stars, so Hollywood disproportionately favors them.
- mark-r 10y agoNot really. It's just that spending that amount of money on a movie makes you really risk averse; you go for the actor with the good resume rather than the brilliant newcomer with no track record.
- kbenson 10y ago> The Way of the Gun I'm fairly surprised that they were able to make that one so cheaply. Not only is it full of well known names, it was extremely well done (it's also a favorite of mine). I imagine most people involved didn't take their normal rate (or worked on residuals).
- wvenable 10y agoI think the real issue isn't that those movies don't have value to consumers, it's that anything other than an "event" movie doesn't get people into theatres. We can happily watch visual media with complex stories and characters from our living room. Then, of course, there is the whole point about international distribution mentioned in the article. Movies for grown-ups literally don't translate well into other languages.
- flukus 10y agoWhy do we need to get people into theatres? I think half the reason they still exist in any great number is because they get time limited exclusivity. Now that a lot more people have huge TV's and decent sound systems theatres are even less compelling. I'd much rather much just about any movie from the comfort of my couch, sitting in my undies (depending on company), with popcorn I made for 20c and the sound not drilling into my skull.
- wvenable 10y agoTheaters used to be the only way to watch movies, then they became just the best way, and now they're just an experience separate from home viewing. Theaters exist because they're the biggest consumers of movies and, because they're the biggest consumers, studios give them limited time exclusivity exists to benefit their continued existence. It's a bit of a catch 22 and change is slow. I watched Rogue one in a regular non-3D theater and the projection was not great. The black levels were horrible. The actual 24fps (x2) frame rate bothered me. I expect to watch it again at home, streamed from Netflix, and have better viewing experience.
- hermitdev 10y ago> Theaters used to be the only way to watch movies, then they became just the best way, and now they're just an experience separate from home viewing. When I can choose between going to a theater and paying +$10 just for the ticket and extremely marked up prices for popcorn and a soda (close to another $20) for a single individual, or I can wait 3-6 months, watch it in the privacy of my home without people bringing crying babies to an R-rated movie, talking during the movie, texting or otherwise using their phones during a movie, yeah, I'm going to wait until I can get it at home. The reasons movie theaters suck basically boils down to: 1. it's expensive, and 2. other people suck, are assholes, are completely self-centered and common courtesy no longer exists.
- racl101 10y agoAgreed. I don't think there's any CGI in Pulp Fiction (1994) and it cost around $9 million to make in 1994 dollars. It made around $200 million worldwide. Whiplash (2014) , a more recent movie with little to no CGI, cost $3.3 million to make and made around $49 million worldwide. The point is that people want interesting, well written movies with great stories. If that warrants CGI sure, but it's not a requirement. A boring movie is not good. But a boring and expensive movie is terrible and that's what's mainly being put out: boring and expensive movies. As far as movies with huge production budgets for every great movie with a justified fair amount of CGI there's tens of crappy ones many that break even or don't make their money back. Creatively speaking there's probably never been a worse time for big Hollyood movies.
- jonhohle 10y agoPulp Fiction was one of the first movie that came to my mind as well. It's a beautiful movie (visually), and could be made today for the same cost as it was in 1994. Looking back at movies from several decades ago, the credit scroll had a few hundred people at most. Now there are a few hundred animators for something like Arrival. Interestingly, Arrival's credits list about the same number of people as Terminator 2. Both excellent movies, but one is small and intimate, and the other grand and explosive - same size crew, much higher balance on visual effects in Arrival vs. practical engineering and effects in T2. Would Arrival have been significantly different or less effective if made with 1991 technology? Probably not. "[They] were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should."
- baddox 10y agoHow "accurate" are credits lists though? Couldn't it be that the credits simply list every employee of every company that did any contract work for the film? It seems plausible that many of the people listed didn't even work a full day on the film.
- pfranz 10y agoCredits aren't accurate at all. When you "subcontract" out something, it usually includes a fixed number of credits no matter how many people worked on it.
- joe_the_user 10y ago> "I expect interesting movies" I'd say you want an interesting but expect incredible production values Which is to say I don't think it's a situation of expect in the sense of demanding but rather "expect" in the sense of "habituated to". Production values might not be the explicit choice of that many people but a good proportion of people would choose X movie with high production values over X movie without. And that's something that's reliable. Things like plot, character and dialog are hit-and-miss if you are looking for quality. Not that they can't sell but they can't reliably sell. Altogether, "grooming" gets added to everything because it can reliably move people's choices a little bit. Other factors may influence people more, other factors may be what people say they want but a lot of these factors are less reliable, there are a lot of factors where a change might turn as many people off as it attracts but surface unambiguous can be added. And there-in lies the secret of the mass-market surface appearance arms race (similar to the music "loudness wars").
- bostik 10y ago> I'd say you want an interesting but expect incredible production values Smoke was an interesting movie, and cost $7M. (It didn't make much more but it wasn't a failure.) Moon was a fantastic movie, and cost $5M. The little CGI it had was pretty obvious but didn't affect the viewing experience. (It also made near-zero returns.) Requiem for a Dream was - and remains - an outstanding film. It flopped in box office but must have made pretty penny on home sales. Dead Man is an interesting movie, and still one of my favourites. It works on the audience for the same reason Apocalypse Now does: episodic films in general are considered "artsy" and hard to chew, but turn them into thoughtful road movies and the audience enjoys the experience. Pan's Labyrinth is just damn good. It cost €13.5 to make, and grossed $37M. Home sales must have added even more since then. All the films above are both interesting and, in terms of bloated Hollywood budgets, were cheap to make. I would take any one of them over the perfumed sewage that floods the film theaters. And for reference, I did see Doctor Strange in a cinema so I do have a metric for calibration. My opinion stands.
- Ericson2314 10y agoLol, winter oscar-bait season is supposed to be their offering to that market. Too bad all those movies are the same too.
- kn0where 10y agoDepending on the episode, Black Mirror uses tons of CGI, but it's usually subtle and the focus is always the story, which is simply served by the effects, not the other way around.
- ouid 10y agoif you expect anything but production value in a movie, you haven't been watching movies recently.
- cowardlydragon 10y agoCGI exists for international viewers... Who can't appreciate nuanced localized plotlines.
- amelius 10y agoYou're right. But I did enjoy movies like The Martian (2015), and Gravity (2013).
- npsimons 10y ago> they don't make films for grown-ups anymore. This right here is the truth, and it's been known for a while: > " Adults were treated as adults rather than as overgrown children hell-bent on enshrining their own arrested development." > "That leaves one quadrant—men under 25—at whom the majority of studio movies are aimed, the thinking being that they'll eat just about anything that's put in front of them as long as it's spiked with the proper set of stimulants. That's why, when you look at the genres that currently dominate Hollywood—action, raunchy comedy, game/toy/ride/comic-book adaptations, horror, and, to add an extra jolt of Red Bull to all of the preceding categories, 3-D—they're all aimed at the same ADD-addled, short-term-memory-lacking, easily excitable testosterone junkie." > "the degree to which children's genres have colonized the entire movie industry goes beyond overkill. More often than not, these collectively infantilizing movies are breeding an audience—not to mention a generation of future filmmakers and studio ecutives—who will grow up believing that movies aimed at adults should be considered a peculiar and antique art. Like books. Or plays." From http://www.gq.com/story/the-day-the-movies-died-mark-harris http://www.gq.com/story/the-day-the-movies-died-mark-harris which was written in 2011.