16 ms·
Investing Is More Luck Than Talent
- jacques_chester 10y agoEven the Steve Jobs example of a super-talented individual relies on luck. In the universe where he didn't meet Steve Wozniak, Steve Jobs was probably consistently in the top 3 Mercedes salesmen in California. Not to mention: merely being born in a wealthy country during a period of relative peace is so much luckier than the lot of humans throughout history that it is almost worthy of bad science fiction.
- fleitz 10y agoWhich would be true if wealthy countries in times of peace were randomly distributed rather than being as a result of culture
- jacques_chester 10y agoI am talking at an individual level. Despite what some folk might wish to believe, Steve Jobs probably came to exist because his parents had sex.
- drinkjuice 10y agoCulture which the people born into have no affect on prior to being born into them, so what would that change about the point? It's not like the US has this super peaceful culture either, so I'm not even sure about what culture has to do with it at all. But even if that made perfect sense it would change nothing about the original point.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coliveira 10y agoWealthy countries are not randomly distributed, but where you are born is randomly distributed, with a bias to the poor side.
- jpttsn 10y agoYou're born in close proximity to your mother. The veil of ignorance is a mental model; in reality, there is no lottery stork that places children randomly.
- valuearb 10y agoIf Wozniak never met Jobs, Woz would just be a super valuable engineer working for some large company. Jobs always would have found someone to build things for him, and would have been a super successful entrepreneur. His product development instincts/ability was off the charts, both in how he motivated people, how he managed the process, and how he created end goals.
- jacques_chester 10y agoThe pool of Wozniakian engineers is limited. And it used to be very, very limited. If it wasn't Jobs, it'd be someone else, and we'd be just as sure that the other ubermensch was Destined To Succeed No Matter What.
- valuearb 10y agoWozniak had nothing to do with the success of the Macintosh, iPod, iPhone, and iPad, or the NeXT OS that runs on them. Steve Jobs was successful with Woz, he was successful without Woz, he was successful when handed a near bankrupt Apple and forced to turn it around. He was even ultimately successful with NeXT, despite a few bone headed decisions.
- jacques_chester 10y agoThese are not events with independent probability. Without Wozniak, there was no Apple.
- valuearb 10y agoJobs had a clear entrepreneurial bent and desire to build technological products. He would have found another engineer and likely his first company is not quite as successful, but very likely the rest of his life isn't much different.
- valuearb 10y agoBTW: The Mac motherboard was designed by Burrell Smith, who was pulled out of Apples service department, later when on to found Radius. Woz was an amazing engineer but Jobs had a knack for finding amazing engineers and getting them to build his ideas.
- ikeboy 10y agoIQ, country, time born, etc are all forms of luck, of course, but it's worth distinguishing that luck from luck of experience that happens later in life.
- jacques_chester 10y agoThe difficulty is that we draw the distinction using available examples of successful individuals and companies. This sample is fantastically biased due to survivorship. Without a complete record of all the failures of equivalent intelligence, drive, experience etc, it's not possible to fairly attribute to luck or to personal characteristics.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- readhn 10y agoThere is no investment. There is only speculation. Speculation that the asset price will increase. Speculation that your purchase will return higher value in the future. In order to be successful at speculation you do have to have certain talents and character traits. Study most successful speculators of or times and you will see certain patterns and common traits.
- xyzzy4 10y agoThat's not true in the long term. For example if you buy a house and then rent it, you will eventually earn back the cost of buying it, unless there is some kind of disaster in the market. Stocks are really no different.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoThe quality of tenant is also somewhat based in luck. If they are a pain in the ass then the time lost may outweigh the cash gained.
- notpc 10y agoEspecially when you end up getting sued for exercising prudence in who you lease to. "Disparate impact"!
- sctb 10y agoThis account has been using this site primarily for political or ideological purposes, and that's not what it's for. Please don't continue on like this.
- notpc 10y agoGiven that certain opinions are very unpopular around here, why should I be forced to use my primary account to post on political topics? If you look through the comment history of this account, I think you'll find that the posts are all very civil.
- valuearb 10y agoThis article basically repeats old economic saws of dubious validity. The counter argument is Warren Buffett. Last I looked at it (going back to his Buffett Partnership days), he beat the market every year but one for his first 30 or 40 years. Even better, he was beating the market by an average of 20% a year during his partnership days, and something like 10% a year during his first 20 years running Berkshire Hathaway. It's not only statistically impossible for Buffett to be a fluke, it's statistically impossible for him not to possess a a skill providing a substantial edge in market investing. Not a "1% a year" type skill. Nowadays and for the last 20 years or so, Buffett has been managing hundreds of billions of dollars. The immense size of his portfolio restricts his opportunities to a far smaller pool of potential investments and his edge over the market has clearly declined because of that restriction. But he's still beating the market the vast majority of the time.
- solipsism 10y agoIt's not only statistically impossible for Buffett to be a fluke I'm curious, do you have any evidence of this? "Statistically impossible" means "zero probability". If that's really your argument then you need to back it up. Perhaps you mean, "improbable"?
- ahelwer 10y agoObvious counterpoint: it's statistically "impossible" for Buffett specifically to beat the market in the way he has. Is it similarly impossible for some person to beat the market in the way he has? Let's call this hypothetical individual Warren Buffett.
- valuearb 10y agoRead super investors of Graham Doddsville, Buffett wrote it and demonstrated there are dozens of value investors with similar results to him, and they all adopt an extremely similar strategy but apply it in very dissimilar investments. And the coin flipping paradigm is wrong. The odds of beating the market by 10%+ a year is not a 50-50 proposition. It's more like a 1 in 10 chance. So re-run your stats with Buffett going 50 for 53 on 1 in 10 shots.
- ikeboy 10y ago>If the ratio of 50,000 were to hold for other traits, it would imply individuals who are 53 miles tall, have IQs of 5 million points, and live to be 4 million years old. That's just not how to do statistics, sorry. First of all, one of those is not like the others: IQ is normalized, the others are not. There are so many assumptions about linearity and distributions here that would need to be a lot more rigorous before anything like this could be said. See http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/02/06/department-of-awful-statistics-income-inequality-edition.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/02/06/department-... for an actual interesting point regarding income and bell curves.
- dhfhduk 10y agoIQ is normalized, but that doesn't change the shape of the distribution. It changes the scale, but not the shape. I agree there's a lot of details that need to be done to make this more rigorous, and I was hoping that the article would be more thorough. But this has been on my mind a lot lately. Basically, most human [behavioral] traits are normally distributed, or something close to it, which is radically different from income distributions. At some point, the shape of an income distribution must become inconsistent with what we know about the shape of human trait distributions and wages under fair labor markets, etc. It should be possible to test whether or not an income distribution is consistent with a given trait and market model, and to compare them statistically. I appreciate McCardle's writing, and read that in the past, but think it's sort of tangential to the points being raised here. Furthermore, many of her arguments aren't supported by the data. That is, income inequality really exists across a wide range of professions. If anything, I suspect there's some demographic effects involved (for example, older, very well-established individuals with a "lock" in a given labor market, shutting out younger individuals). They also don't even get into cheating as another factor that's nonrandom and might be construed as a "skill" but is arguably unrelated to "real" market value. All of this is consistent with arguments that the biggest predictor of returns is length in the market. That is, you're better off putting things in a very diversified index portfolio than anything else. Someone else mentioned Buffet. Even if things were random, with enough people, you'd still end up with people who look like they're not benefiting randomly. Anyway, I'm not really trying to question Buffet's investing skill. I'm sure that it's not totally random, but I suspect that there is a big element of randomness also. And income per se is different from investment skill per se.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoIf your takeaway from this is most, if not all, investment is pure speculation, you are either very naive or willfully ignorant. I'm nit saying talent per se is a signifixant factor, but this view suffers frim the sane nakady that a lot if wconomic theories do... an idealized situation/world where everyone plays by the rules. To some individuals, life is not a game, but a winner take all conflict and they will Kobayashi Maru the situation whille others are still playing a game of chance
- atemerev 10y agoThis article deliberately confuses normal distribution, which applies to such things as height or IQ, and power law distribution, which applies to wealth, social connections, city sizes etc. I think nobody is surprised about the fact that the largest cities are more than million times larger than the smallest settlements. Or that that top 1% of the largest cities includes the sizable proportion of human population.
- ry4n413 10y agoSays the professor who has never worked in the investment industry.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Applejinx 10y ago"How big can this “talent differential” be and still stay statistically consistent with the power law wealth distribution we see in the real world? It turns out that it can’t be more than about 1 percent.2 A larger talent differential would produce a wealth distribution that is even more extreme than the real one, and that would not follow a power law." I thought this article looked like it was going to be very obvious, but that passage got my attention. I'm all for experiments of this nature: one day AI will be doing it as a matter of course, on a massive scale. Lines up with my observation, too: talent makes a difference, and it's about 1% over time. Kind of like compound interest. You can win out if you're very persistent and very determined and you fail a lot, because you're shooting for that 'luck' moment. There's no telling where it will strike, because it's luck! You have to stay in there and not go broke because it's luck, there's very little correlation between merit and success. I suspect if you went by tenacity rather than 'talent', the number might be a lot more than 1%. But bozos can be tenacious too, which is a daunting thing to consider.
- sametmax 10y agoAnd it's why you see successful bozos as well.
- pcmaffey 10y agoYup. People dismiss this because they assume the number of tries to be relatively small. But in truth, we're making dozens of decisions every day. Compound that over a career and a 1% advantage adds up to huge potential, for those determined enough to keep trying at it.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoTalent prevents you from shooting yourself in the foot, which gets you to breakeven. Luck takes you up from there. Time turns unlikely events into inevitabilities.
- hvd 10y agogreat way to tell the masses and countless business school grads that its not even worth trying. Any astute investor will support articles like this since it reduces competition. Thinking is bad. Long live index funds.
- downandout 10y agoIn the short term, investing may indeed be more luck than talent, however this article strives to imply that market-beating results are essentially pure luck, which simply isn't the case over time. Over time, the best investors will always wind up with market-beating returns, and the worst investors will always wind up with market-trailing returns. Like any game with significant short-term variance, those with the greatest skill might not be readily apparent from a small sample size of results - I might beat Phil Ivey for a day or even a month at a poker table. But if we play long enough, I literally have no chance of being ahead of him. The same holds true for investors. Articles like this seem like a cop-out for failed investors, and perhaps an argument for using index funds. If it's all luck, then your own failings aren't your fault. But that view doesn't apply to most areas of life, including and perhaps especially when it comes to investing decisions.
- matt4077 10y agoYou're just asserting, i. e. "which simply isn't the case over time". The article build a model that appears reasonable, and from which follows that any talent allowing returns above 1% of the market would lead to a wealth distribution different from the one observed in reality.
- downandout 10y agoSince you don't like my comment, if you read some of the other comments in this thread, you'll see that the model built in this article actually isn't reasonable at all (as I said). A small percentage of investors have achieved results that aren't possible through pure luck. So you are, in a word, wrong. Thanks for the downvote though.
- rat87 10y agohttp://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/03/04/469247400/episode-688-brilliant-vs-boring http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/03/04/469247400/episo... > In 2006, Warren Buffett posed a challenge. He bet that the smartest hedge fund managers out there couldn't beat the world's simplest, most brainless investment. In this show, we tell you who's winning. (index funds)
- Bud 10y agoPretty funny that this apparently got flagged. Perhaps a couple entitled investors didn't like this particular message.
- snarf21 10y agoAlthough I completely agree that luck is a major factor, the author loses me when he takes his hypothetical "lucky people get 30% gain, unlucky people get 10% loss" and builds on top of that as if it was a provable fact. It is okay to use this as a mechanism to illustrate that this matches the power law distribution that we see in reality. This part makes sense as an intellectual exercise. Applying 1% on top of that as talent and rerunning it, stayed within power law distribution but making talent larger would break it. The faulty logic to me is what makes the "lucky 30% gain, unlucky 10% loss" fact? It seems much more likely that there is an 8% base (index funds, e.g.) with luck playing a +-10% and talent being another ~7% (as a hypothesis). Also, remember his "game" to prove luck > talent only ran for 20 years. I'm curious if I plugged this into a spreadsheet and ran for 50 years if I couldn't get the same power law distribution with greatly different factors. Mainly, it requires a lot of luck AND talent.
- myf01d 10y agoIt certainly needs considerable amount of luck to earn the first big $ on your investments, but you should be ruthless, sociopath, cold blooded, patient and hard-working to continue growing & become like Icahn or Buffet.
- Zigurd 10y agoThe cold-bloodedness just helps justify oneself. It won't change outcomes.
- sgustard 10y agoThe richest eight people now have the same wealth as the poorest 50 percent. Most of that wealth comes from investing (rather than labor). There is no probability model that would lead to this result; eventually someone on a "hot streak" is bound to lose. What we're seeing is that luck may give some random people a boost at first, but that boost is sufficient to let them take all the winnings over time. The rich get richer. Investing success and wealth building follow a Darwinian rather than a probabilistic model.
- taeric 10y agoI'm not sure I follow. A basic Pareto distribution could easily lead to this setup. Now, are we seeing that the powers that be are finding ways to keep their wealth? Almost certainly. But, consider that the same fact for "top 8 have as much as bottom half" was probably true in the Rockefeller years. Difference is that, in American until recently, we had schemes to prevent a landed gentry, or class based society. But to claim that this is somehow new or unheralded in history seems to ignore a lot of history.
- myf01d 10y agoYes, and just once you get big using good luck like Amazon or Facebook, you invest your profits to hire the best people to make sure that no one else can threaten your empire in the foreseeable future.
- harmegido 10y agoGates, slim, Ellison, the Kochs, and the Waltons were all in the top eight from a quick search I did. None of those gained the majority of their wealth through investing.
- ci5er 10y agoBuffet and Carlos Slim did, did they not? After starting out in trading (for ~30 years, no?), Carlos Slim got bigger with Telmex (while I don't know how much collusion was involved with that; I assume it couldn't have been none, which probably isn't fair of me) before going large with investing again... The rest of the list includes Ingvar Kamprad, Bezos, Zuckerberg and Amancia Ortega, and none of them gained the majority of their wealth through inheritance or investment either. Now, their kids on the other hand... :-)
- deepnotderp 10y agoDon't firms like Renaissance and Virtu destroy this notion?
- physguy1123 10y agoI assume you're referring to the Virtu statement that they only lost money on one day? That's true (or nearly true) of good HFT shops in general. The type of trading that HFTs do (market making, short term predictions) is generally less risky than long term investments. Also, the risk/reward of this trading is realized over minutes, not over weeks/years. So just as a hedge fund might have an unprofitable week but a good year, an HFT has a bad 20 minutes but over the whole day comes out on top. For Renaissance, maybe they are truly smarter than the rest of the market or at least able to act on good trades before anyone else. I wouldn't discount foul play though.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deepnotderp 10y agoI'd really be interested to know about the foul play angle, but firms like these buy drone and satellite data, surely they have some information advantage?
- vostok 10y agoOne could make the argument that their use of basket options was not uncontroversial.
- physguy1123 10y agoWell, the thing is that other extremely good firms buy drone and satellite data, and other firms also pay the top rate to extremely good people, and etc. So either RenTech is somehow consistently wildly smarter than the rest of the industry through some completely unknown secret, or something else is up. They might be using insider information, they might have a deal with someone news firms* to get news early, they might use illegal order execution techniques. There's a whole slew of things they might be doing to get an advantage. Maybe they use funds other than Medallion (the super good one) as a testbed for strategies and deploy the really good ones to their best fund. FWIW, I don't think funds started by anybody who left there are as successful so the secrets aren't leaving. * A friend of mine in the hft industry told an interesting story to me. A high-speed news wire was very predictive of when orders relevant to the news would get run over - except backwards in time. The news was consistently a few minutes late. So either the high-speed news wire was laughably worse than the competition or somebody was getting news early through illicit means.
- imaginenore 10y agoThat's demonstrably false. How would you explain quants? All the financial firms that exist solely because of how good they are at buying and selling securities?
- scottmsul 10y agoI've read a bit into econophysics. In stat mech, the exchange of energy between atoms is assumed to be random. When the exchange of energy is random, the resulting distribution of energies is a Gibbs distribution, which means that the probability of atoms with higher energies falls off exponentially. The application is that if you replace energy with money, and atoms with people, then the same equations hold for a model of people who randomly exchange money. Therefore if investments were truly random, you would expect the distribution of investors' wealth to follow an exponential distribution, not a power law! This directly contradicts the article. Interestingly enough, the bottom 99% follows an exponential distribution, while the top 1% follows a power-law, and the transition is very sharp (eg, wealth plots have a "kink" in them). Brief introduction to econophysics for the mathematically inclined: https://arxiv.org/abs/0709.3662 https://arxiv.org/abs/0709.3662
- nerdponx 10y agoI wonder if opportunities follow an exponential distribution. Then it's a matter of having the talent and ambition to capitalize on those opportunities. Although I don't know if a "talent distribution" exists such that its joint distribution with an exponential yields a power law.
- lend000 10y agoVery interesting. I'd be curious to see a subset of this data related to venture capital, where there seems to be a high proportion of 'professional investors' -- although funding from friends, family, and personal savings certainly plays a role in Angel rounds.
- throwaway729 10y agoIs there any reason to believe that econophysics provides a better model of reality than the article's informal model?
- dsacco 10y agoWell there are several things that are incoherent about the article's application of this model. 1. Coin flipping is not a fit analogy, despite the fact that it's parroted in financial discussions ad nauseum. Take this quote from the article, for example: Maybe the string of investment and managerial decisions that made one person’s company successful, and that seem so very wise in retrospect, were actually just the entrepreneurial equivalent of flipping a coin 20 times and getting all heads. The chances of that happening are about 1 in 1 million, so if enough people try it, someone is bound to get lucky and look like a coin-flipping genius—purely by chance. What? How do you map the theoretical probabilities of individual entrepreneurial decisions to the chance of a heads or tails on a coin flip? Is the chance of getting into YC 50%? Is the chance of securing venture capital in a Series A round 50%? How about? This is before we even consider that the theoretical chance for each decision will obviously not be the same for everyone, whereas a coin flip is. This is important because it's not falsifiable if we can't map decisions to probabilities. It's also important because the numbers could be wildly different. If each entrepreneurial decision has a 50% chance of success, that might result in a 1 in 1 million chance of getting rich. But what if the actual chances of success for each entrepreneurial decision in lieu of the coin-flip mapping result in a 1 in 4 quadrillion chance of success? One result indicates that essentially all successes could be due to chance, the other suggests the opposite. 2. The author uses very fuzzy measurements with no empirical basis in reality to support the model. For example: To make the game more realistic, assume that if investors’ wealth declines below some level they have to drop out of the game, and are replaced by newly rich players emerging from the middle class. Eventually, the game will reach a kind of equilibrium—one in which the number of players going up is always balanced by the number going down, so that the overall distribution of wealth reaches a steady state and doesn’t change anymore. Wait a second, why are we assuming that this game reaches an equilibrium? We can't just use textbook economics here - there is no reason to assume the "game" won't be weighted towards more players dropping out than moving up or vice versa. 3. The author tries to repair the issues with chance being theoretically equal in my first point with the following: Still, it is possible to get a crude sense of the effect of talent by modifying the investment game to include two types of players. Normal investors are just like those in the first game: They flip a coin with heads yielding a return of 30 percent, and tails producing a loss of 10 percent. But the talented investors are more skilled at playing the market: They earn slightly more than 30 percent when the coin comes up heads, and lose slightly less than 10 percent when the coin comes up tails. Now we set the players loose and ask an empirical question: How big can this “talent differential” be and still stay statistically consistent with the power law wealth distribution we see in the real world? Where are these numbers coming from? How are these a rigorous, empirical model of talent and the subsequent chance differential? By this point in the article the entire game is becoming so "in the clouds" that it doesn't have any basis in reality anymore. It's like I came up with a "law" based on one extremely convoluted thought experiment and attempted to extrapolate it to the entire market in real-world conditions. Basically, the author's model is narrow in some places, vague in others and overall does not empirically prove the premises it attempts to build upon. He hand waves the (extremely common) power law distribution as a sort of magic wand that smooths away all the lack of rigor. There's just not much evidence that the model reflects the real world.
- ImTalking 10y ago> We all know stories of ambitious and talented people like Steve Jobs or Bill Gates, who grew companies and created great wealth. True. Yet both were extremely lucky at the beginning. We all know the story but Gates' mother knew IBM President John Opel, his father was a prominent contract lawyer, and IBM originally wanted CP/M but Gary Kindall missed the meeting to fly his plane. And Microsoft retaining the rights to the OS was, in hindsight, a very grave mistake. Jobs had the charisma and drive, but without Woz I'm sure we wouldn't be talking now about Apple. But given the opportunity that this initial luck gave them, they absolutely maximised it, so good on them.
- charlesdm 10y agoBut they could've still made something of themselves, even if that opportunity didn't pan out? They might not have become billionaires, but I don't think it's unrealistic to assume both would've done well in life.
- leed25d 10y agoPeople have been bullshitting us for centuries that market investing is a game of skill. If it really comes down to luck then it is gambling, and it should be treated (legally) as such.
- chki 10y agoBut even if investing is about luck it is still not comparable. Investing was originally (well ... kind of.. ) people betting on which ships would come back from the new world. And it were only those bets that made the game possible, established a new market and caused enormous changes in the world. Investing is not people playing some made up game - but people playing a heavily complicated game which is also known as: the real world. This makes it fundamentally different. Even if it might be very much based on luck, I would bet on the ship with the more experienced sailor/better crew etc. and would not call that gambling.
- charlesdm 10y agoRight. And because of luck you always have the same poker players winning at tournaments, taking home the cash? I personally don't believe investing in the market is gambling, but even if it were, that doesn't necessarily mean you can't consistently make money from it. Some of it is luck, some of it skill. Investing in general is about probability. An example: I am working on a deal right now. If it goes through I put $100k at risk by investing in an asset. Absolute worst case I can resell that asset for $50k, but I can probably sell it on for $100k. Best case if everything pans out I make $3m. The chance of that happening is probably around 50%. Those are odds I like. Lots of upside, almost no downside. Some publicly traded stocks are like that.
- drumdance 10y agoWell, some argue that poker is a game of skill. Bluffing, looking for tells etc. Everything I've read is that when you get to the championship level, everyone already is good at understanding probabilities. It's psychology that makes the difference. In fact, just last night I talked to a woman who does really well at poker because she randomly pretends to be a "dumb broad" on some hands.
- m3kw9 10y agoLuck is when preparation meets opportunity.
- DeBraid 10y agoOne of the best 'Talks at Google' via Michael Mauboussin "The Success Equation: Untangling Skill and Luck" Thesis: where absolute talent/skill is high, variance in relative talent is low, thus luck > skill. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1JLfqBsX5Lc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1JLfqBsX5Lc
- ariwilson 10y agoIf you can't optimize for talent, you should optimize for costs. Investing in low cost passive index funds is best for most people's low risk plans (retirement, house, etc).
- paulus_magnus2 10y agoDubious article relying on Gell-Mann Amnesia. We'd easily spot the fallacy if it read "engineering correct software Is More Luck Than Talent"
- acd 10y agoThere is a book where monkey throws darts at a dartboard beats professional investors. There is also a similar where cats pick stocks with their whiskers and beats the pros. A Random Walk down Wall Street http://www.forbes.com/sites/rickferri/2012/12/20/any-monkey-can-beat-the-market/#1a7d51bb6e8b http://www.forbes.com/sites/rickferri/2012/12/20/any-monkey-... http://www.marketriders.com/investing/why-googles-investment-advice-is-good-for-all/ http://www.marketriders.com/investing/why-googles-investment...
- mack1001 10y agoAmong the 1% there exists multiple deep and consistent insider networks where stock tips and wealth creation ideas are exchanged. So the 1% crowd thrives from being in that position.
- estefan 10y agoI doubt the top 1% got rich by insider trading.
- edblarney 10y ago"I doubt the top 1% got rich by insider trading." First - there is tons of 'insider trading' going on. It's easy to do, and hard to prove. Second - though maybe not 'insider' in the illegal sense - but once you have a lot of wealth, you have access to information and systems that others do not. Warren Buffet made huge bank of a loan to Goldman during the crises. He was one of the few to have the cash and the reputation. Buffet can take advantage of so many situations that very few others can. So that's a lot of leverage. I'm not saying anything against them, but big finance is an 'insiders game'.
- cies 10y agoMaybe "insider trading" is often rebranded as "luck".
- erikb 10y agoDo the rich really keep getting richer? I would assume that as you have more money you don't just have more opportunity but also more competition. There are lots of people who try to take your money one way or another without any return.
- mixmax 10y ago>Do the rich really keep getting richer? Yes, that's basically the findings of Thomas Pikkety. His tome "Capital in the 21st century" goes through great lengths to find and explain the numbers behind the finding.
- erikb 10y agoDone now with Pikkety. Well, he summarizes it very simplified. I think his model doesn't necessarily mean that the person who was rich 10 years ago is richer now. It still works out if for example each year a start-up of the same size has a 5% bigger exit than the year before, but 10 years later the founder of the first exist is broke and homeless already. What I mean is it doesn't, afaik, consider fluctuation in each group. Also many economists criticise that money is only measurment of wealth, and some are quite hard to represent in $.
- amelius 10y agoAt least with investing you can spread your risk. In contrast, if you are a programmer at a startup, you typically have all your eggs in one basket. In other words, more talent than luck.
- known 10y ago"I'm a great believer in luck, and I find the harder I work the more I have of it" --Thomas Jefferson
- cs702 10y agoHere's Warren Buffett's response, published on May 17, 1984[1]: "I would like you to imagine a national coin-flipping contest. Let’s assume we get 225 million Americans up tomorrow morning and we ask them all to wager a dollar. They go out in the morning at sunrise, and they all call the flip of a coin. If they call correctly, they win a dollar from those who called wrong. Each day the losers drop out, and on the subsequent day the stakes build as all previous winnings are put on the line. After ten flips on ten mornings, there will be approximately 220,000 people in the United States who have correctly called ten flips in a row. They each will have won a little over $1,000. Now this group will probably start getting a little puffed up about this, human nature being what it is. They may try to be modest, but at cocktail parties they will occasionally admit to attractive members of the opposite sex what their technique is, and what marvelous insights they bring to the field of flipping. Assuming that the winners are getting the appropriate rewards from the losers, in another ten days we will have 215 people who have successfully called their coin flips 20 times in a row and who, by this exercise, each have turned one dollar into a little over $1 million. $225 million would have been lost, $225 million would have been won. By then, this group will really lose their heads. They will probably write books on “How I turned a Dollar into a Million in Twenty Days Working Thirty Seconds a Morning.” Worse yet, they’ll probably start jetting around the country attending seminars on efficient coin-flipping and tackling skeptical professors with, “If it can’t be done, why are there 215 of us?” By then some business school professor will probably be rude enough to bring up the fact that if 225 million orangutans had engaged in a similar exercise, the results would be much the same — 215 egotistical orangutans with 20 straight winning flips. I would argue, however, that there are some important differences in the examples I am going to present. For one thing, if (a) you had taken 225 million orangutans distributed roughly as the U.S. population is; if (b) 215 winners were left after 20 days; and if (c) you found that 40 came from a particular zoo in Omaha, you would be pretty sure you were on to something. So you would probably go out and ask the zookeeper about what he’s feeding them, whether they had special exercises, what books they read, and who knows what else. That is, if you found any really extraordinary concentrations of success, you might want to see if you could identify concentrations of unusual characteristics that might be causal factors. Scientific inquiry naturally follows such a pattern. If you were trying to analyze possible causes of a rare type of cancer — with, say, 1,500 cases a year in the United States — and you found that 400 of them occurred in some little mining town in Montana, you would get very interested in the water there, or the occupation of those afflicted, or other variables. You know it’s not random chance that 400 come from a small area. You would not necessarily know the causal factors, but you would know where to search. I submit to you that there are ways of defining an origin other than geography. In addition to geographical origins, there can be what I call an intellectual origin. I think you will find that a disproportionate number of successful coin-flippers in the investment world came from a very small intellectual village that could be called Graham-and-Doddsville. A concentration of winners that simply cannot be explained by chance can be traced to this particular intellectual village." [1] https://www8.gsb.columbia.edu/articles/columbia-business/superinvestors https://www8.gsb.columbia.edu/articles/columbia-business/sup...
- edblarney 10y agoThis article represents a disingenuous premise. It's also grossly mis-titiled. 'Wealth' is mostly not generated by speculative investing. And yes - most 'investing' is luck, but investors already know that. But declare that some kid who worked his pants off through school, got into a half-decent Uni, and went on to get a high paying job - to his brother, who didn't do much in school, and took a job at their fathers auto-shop earning a respectable but relatively small salary - in terms of 'luck' is just unfair.
- MR4D 10y agoInteresting article, but like many things I've read on this topic, it still focuses on the "cause" being luck. I'm not so sure that's correct (not convinced it's wrong, either, but hey...) For instance, if I look at Zuckerberg or Gates, they had access to an amazing network (happened to both be at Harvard). That network allowed good ideas to explode in value. If Zuckerberg were at a community college in a poor section of the country, I'm not sure his idea would have captured the same value. Similarly, had Gates' mother not been on several boards, Microsoft would never have gone anywhere (clearly the introduction to high-level IBM executives through her board connections was paramount in his success). I don't discount luck - I think it's very important. But luck comes about from your surroundings, and having access to a network like these two had will tilt the luck in your favor much more than if you have a weak network. If economists focus on the networks, they will have better solutions to addressing inequality. One final note - I don't think inequality is necessarily bad - rather, it is the inability to move up (or not evening having the chance to move up) that is the real problem.