33 ms·
Tim Cook assures employees that Apple is committed to the Mac
- cududa 10y agoI'm sure they are.. the real question is will there ever be upgradeability again, and how fast will spells between refreshes be?
- stevenelliottjr 10y agoDon't count on it.
- nodesocket 10y agoI mean really the only component you're ever going to be able to upgrade is RAM right? Are you suggesting it should be possible to swap out CPUs in iMacs?
- rbritton 10y agoUpgradeability also includes things like the hard drive and card expansion slots. Those both let you extend the useful life of a computer a bit.
- lisper 10y agoBut you can already upgrade your hard drives through the USB interface. Nowadays that's plenty fast enough even for external SSDs. You don't really need SATA any more.
- rbritton 10y agoThat is actually my biggest gripe with the current model Mac Pro ("trash can"). If I'm using a desktop computer, I want everything to be enclosed in a single unit as much as possible. I have and still use the previous model of Mac Pro ("cheese grater"), and I have six internal hard drives, maxed out RAM, and several PCI cards. None of that is possible with any current model Mac except maybe the RAM.
- akoster 10y agoI don't own a MacPro for that reason. I ended up building a desktop PC and using it as a hackintosh (though I gave up a couple years ago and now use a 15" rMBP more often).
- kitsunesoba 10y agoFor disks USB is alright but it's always been kinda flaky compared to SATA or PATA. The only external port I've used for external HDs that's been as stable as internal connections was FireWire, which unfortunately never really took off. I could definitely see why professionals or otherwise demanding users might prefer internal disks over external ones.
- HillaryBriss 10y agotrue. of course, a lot of the external SSDs on the market are bound by SATA interface like speeds anyway (even if they have fast external ports). so they won't be as fast as the internal flash memory in, say, a new iMac. the comparison is roughly: 500 MB/s vs 1700 MB/s http://www.apple.com/imac/performance/ http://www.apple.com/imac/performance/ an alternative to the garden variety external SSD would be an external PCI-E card housing (e.g. sonnet or akitio) connected through a Thunderbolt cable. now that's a lot faster. but, for that we buy an external housing in addition to the actual storage that goes into the housing. so this is more expensive than computers which let us install a PCI-E storage card directly inside the case. which Macs don't let us do easily or at all.
- toyg 10y agoExcept when anything slightly unexpected happens (sleep etc), your external drive is not cleanly unmounted and you risk heavy data loss, whereas internal drives are always handled properly.
- elastic_church 10y agocard expansion slots lol. have you seen the new macbook pro?
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoNot drives too?
- tomatoman 10y agoWhy not hard drives?
- nodesocket 10y agoYour right... and drive. I actually upgraded my mid 2010 iMac to a 512GB solid state disk. Made soooooo much of a difference. Literally went from almost unuseable to back to my daily workhorse. I can't remember how much time from power-on to login screen was with the original drive, but ballpark a handful of minutes. Now with the new SSD it takes less than 10 seconds.
- protomyth 10y agoIn the old PowerMac you could switch out the CPU. I seem to remember a clone that you could put a dual processor card in also.
- akoster 10y agoA relative gifted me an old PowerMac 8600/200, which originally came with a pre-G3 PowerPC 604e CPU, but had been upgraded to a G4 by swapping out the ZIF CPU card. It definitely gave a circa 1997 machine (original OS was either MacOS 7.6 or 8.0) a new lease on life and the ability to run OSX 10.2 Jaguar, (albeit slowly and after a serious RAM and HDD upgrade).
- kalleboo 10y agoI upgraded my PowerMac G4 Quicksilver to dual-CPU
- marssaxman 10y agoYes indeed - the Umax S900. I used to have one, with dual 200MHz PowerPC 604e processors, hooked up to a 256GB SCSI RAID array. That felt pretty bad-ass back in 1997/1998.
- vbezhenar 10y agoWhat's wrong with swapping CPUs?
- sengork 10y agoIt'd be interesting if Apple resurrected the old fan-less Cube design/concept for the desktops: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_Mac_G4_Cube https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_Mac_G4_Cube The time is right now especially given the age and non-expandability of the Mac Pro.
- wl 10y agoI think the reason why we're stuck with the current Mac Pro is because Apple learned the wrong lesson from the Power Mac G4 cube. It was beautiful but few people bought it because you could get the more powerful and expandable Power Mac G4 for less money. This time around, Apple didn't build the the tower nearly everyone in this market would have bought instead of the trash can.
- gurneyHaleck 10y agoVery true. The Mac Pro is eternally reminiscent of a trash can, and it feels hazardous leaving it out in the open, because maybe someone might actually mistake it for one and drop an empty coffee cup in it. The lack of expandability makes it feel like a doomed purchase, and costing more than $2,000 means spending on something that might prove obsolete in a year (or possibly less) feels extremely frivolous. Extensible hardware allows us to rationalize a big purchase with the mindset that there's an intent to future-proof with an investment that allocates room for growth. That concept does not exist with the Mac Pro form factor at all. The purchase is not even slightly user-servicable. Only a subscription to a service/maintenance agreement (read: applecare) provides nigh-full-replacement insurance. And basically, you're just paying for the privilege to gamble. You'll never get to change your old toy into a new toy.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dba7dba 10y agoI wish Apple never had their success with iTunes and iPhone. It was like winning lottery for them. And you know what happens when someone wins lottery. They forget about their roots and in the end, only ruin remains.
- jasoncchild 10y agoFantastically dramatic assessment! I'm curious just what aspects of the pre-iPhone Apple were preferable?
- mulmen 10y agoOff the top of my head I can think of a couple: 1) OSX was a viable operating system that was first class in the Apple ecosystem. 2) Laptops and desktops that were actually better than the competition including models geared toward power users.
- jasoncchild 10y agoThanks! I've not much personal experience of pre-iPhone Apple. I'm curious about why OSX is no longer viable.
- mulmen 10y agoOSX/MacOS is still viable but it doesn't receive the attention it once did. It feels second-rate compared to the mobile OS. I get the feeling one day Apple is going to release the new MacBook and it will just be an iPad with a keyboard.
- gurneyHaleck 10y agoAn iPad with a keyboard. God help us all. And looking back on ye olden MacOS 9, prior to OSX, there were things that just felt nice about the interface that no longer hold sway. Clicking on an icon gave an immediate response. The mouse cursor felt more precise. Compare to these nightmarish touchpad/button slabs (and worse still, touchscreens), mouse movement and pointer precision were lightyears beyond the way things seem to work lately. I have to retry things a solid 1/3 of the time, because some kind of gesture or taptic garbage tripped me up, and pushed me into an unintended outcome. I have to focus, and concentrate on finessing my hand motions and pressure or I am punished by mistakes that need an undo. When I'm in a rush, life is hell. This makes me hate life. No zealously decorative animations meant (on an unstressed system with low CPU/RAM load) the menus flashed before you like lightning. Text was crisp, unshaded pixels, with no font smoothing. There were no transparency overlays, and so everything was high contrast. Nothing was EVER lagged by network traffic except browser images and FTP/SMB shares. (and doom deathmatches) Most of this was also true of Windows 2000 at the time. Had operating systems stood frozen (particularly GUIs), while terabytes of disk space, gigabytes of RAM and dozens of CPU cores had inflated our hardware resources, I've often held the belief that we'd like our computers more, and fewer people would be as obnoxiously incompetant with computers as we see. I'm probably wrong, but the idea feels right.
- hkarthik 10y agoThis comes at no surprise. I predicted that at some point desktop computers used by designers and software engineers would start approaching workstation class pricing (around 4K USD or more) as laptops took over. This will reflect the depressed demand as more people are able to get what they need done via a laptop. Apple might be one of the few manufacturers able to sell desktops at a loss, and justify it since the Makers are the ones using them to generate demand for other, higher margin products like phones, tablets, and laptops. The PC market also exhibits this trend, but at a slower pace because PC gamers keep prices a little more depressed. However now that high end GPUs are approaching $1000 each, it's probably happening there too.
- bluedino 10y agoWhat do you need a Pro for that you can't do on a 15" MacBook or iMac? Serious video editing and 3D graphics. That's about it. For 95% of us the portables get the job done.
- _ph_ 10y ago3D graphics - the graphics of the Mac Pro have not been refreshed in 3 years. Lots of memory. More CPU than the iMac. Better storage. Multiple screens. Better cooling. I have a MB Pro and an iMac, and while they are great devices, a proper desktop mac is something I miss.
- analog31 10y agoI wonder if a problem is maintaining a commitment to the Mac when the computer market is no longer committed to desktop / laptop computers in general. It seems that the world has kinda topped out on what they (we?) need, which is some kind of modestly functioning computer with a keyboard for "work," and a phone for everything else.
- pdimitar 10y agoThe "death of the desktop computers" is greatly exaggerated. It's simply that a well-built future-proof PC can easily last you 5 years. I have the 2nd generation i7 and after 5 years of usage, I only added 16GB RAM and a better GPU (since I play demanding games). Might add 2x 512GB SSDs but I guess I'll just switch the motherboard and CPU in order to be able to use the NVMe models. Anyway. The market might have platooed on the profit margins several years ago but that doesn't mean that the PC and gaming laptop branches aren't VERY much alive and kicking, and even gathering steam lately.
- protomyth 10y agoI thought the whole "crazy ones" theme was about Apple building things that helped people change the world. Somehow that's morphed into Apple changing the world. I think might be a problem.
- chrischen 10y agoConsidering 99.99% of silicom valley uses macs as their primary development machines, they've pretty much monopolized the first goal.
- protomyth 10y agoThere is a whole world outside Silicon Valley that does amazing, world changing things and buying stats show Apple doesn't own them.
- zdean 10y agoSteve Jobs had a very different idea of what changing the world meant and who was doing it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GMQhOm-Dqo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GMQhOm-Dqo
- sumedh 10y agoI thought I have seen pretty much every Steve Jobs video but I missed this one. Thanks.
- ant6n 10y agoSo there are only about 100 non-mac development machines in total in the Silicon Valley?
- bootload 10y ago"The desktop is very strategic for us. It’s unique compared to the notebook because you can pack a lot more performance in a desktop — the largest screens, the most memory and storage, a greater variety of I/O, and fastest performance." So desktop is high end, MBP commodity?
- itazula 10y agoTo certain user communities, "almost." I know I am looking forward to seeing the new iMac. Having a good portable device is secondary to me. My 2012 MacBook Air would be fine except for the lack of memory (only 4GB). So, I will probably purchase the new MacBook Pro without the touchbar, and then sell my MacBook Air.
- enjo 10y agoThe latest rev pushed me to a PC for the first time in like 15 years. It's partly because I didn't love the new Macbook Pro, but also cause hey..change is fun sometimes. I'm very happy with my new Surface Book. I never thought I'd like the touchscreen as much as I do. I LOVE being able to go to tablet mode for calls and stuff where I sort of want to just wander around. The pen has completely changed how I do flow-charting and wire-framing. The new Linux subsystem thing is a god-send. It was completely seamless for me to transition from the Mac to Windows pretty much solely because there wasn't really a transition. All our provisioning and development scripts just worked. It's been fun to do a bit of gaming on it too :) The touchpad is really the only thing that I think compares poorly. Apple really nails that whole experience. After a few weeks I'm getting better with it, but it's still painful compared to the precision and certainty I had on my Macbook Pro. I'm sure I'll be back on a Macbook someday (cause hey, change is fun) but no regrets right now.
- jkahn 10y agoA few months ago I made a similar transition - to a Surface Pro 4. I'd been on Mac since 2009. Before that, Windows and Linux. I think you sum it up well - there are some rough edges in the Windows world, but there also are in the Mac world. I find I hardly use my iPad now.
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoOddly enough I find the track pad on the Surface Pro 4 keyboard to be the absolute BEST track pad I've ever used on a PC (even better than the one I played with on the Surface Book) which is...just absurd and odd. But hey I thought it was interesting just how much I liked it compared to everything else.
- 72deluxe 10y agoI found that the gestures were odd, coming from a MacBook. I also notice that my MacBook's touchpad (whilst great in macOS) being absurdly dumb when I reboot to Windows on the same hardware.
- 10y ago
- jrnichols 10y agothe whole desktop line is in serious need of a refresh. at least some new Mac Mini units. it's been over two years now. I bought the mid-range Mac Mini, and it's identical to what's in the Store today. That whole line needs more RAM, newer CPUs, and SSD across the board. :|
- gurneyHaleck 10y agoBut don't actually LIKE the mac mini. It's not something I particularly want. I do kind of want the huge cinema displays. But they're expensive. I do kind of want the cylindrical mac pro. But it's expensive. Apple's laptops are the sweet spot. I want them. The price is right. And they have performed. Tablets and touchscreens suck compared to a solid laptop. Mac minis are borderline indistinguishable from any other mac during use. But they've always been coasters. Lazy susans. Arm rests. Furniture. The only time you think about it being a mac mini is when you cycle power, or when you imagine opening it up, and adding more power because multi-tasking. Providing the mac pro at closer to mini prices would be cool. The polished metal cyclinder is kind of cool. But it's hard to find fetish items that endure six months these days. The death march of cell phone upgrades has seen to that. Once they started soldering and epoxying internals, well... I start to feel guilty about polluting the environment with electronics waste, and I start googling recycling programs.
- FireBeyond 10y ago"Apple's laptops are the sweet spot. I want them. The price is right." Is it, though? After evaluating the 2016 13" (and having owned a 2012, 2014 and early 2015), I now have the Kaby Lake XPS 13". $1799 for a _similarly_ (because yes, I know it doesn't have Touch ID, or the display - but build quality is similar, the display is better - 3200x1800, more connectivity options) specced model that costs $2499 from Apple. $700 is a decent chunk of change, and yes, over the course of a couple of years life, for a developer, it's not earth shattering. But it is nearly 40% more expensive, for questionable value.
- gurneyHaleck 10y ago
- shmerl 10y agoOK, if they are so committed, where is OpenGL 4.5 and Vulkan support? Why is Safari so behind that it's now called "the new IE"? Talk is cheap, let them actually do something.
- ekianjo 10y agoThey wont support Vulkan since they have Metal.
- shmerl 10y agoEventually they might. Or at least if they'll be relevant at that time.
- pjmlp 10y agoNo need when Unreal, Unity, Crytek and every other game engine that matters already support Metal.
- Lio 10y agoI've not heard of any games or VR software released to the market that use Metal yet. I've heard it mentioned about projects still in development but so far that's all. Do you have any examples of things using it?
- pjmlp 10y agoSome games: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/vainglory/id671464704?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/vainglory/id671464704?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/gb/app/sky-gamblers-storm-raiders/id574375380?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/gb/app/sky-gamblers-storm-raiders/i... https://itunes.apple.com/gb/app/radiation-island/id923760656?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/gb/app/radiation-island/id923760656... https://itunes.apple.com/de/app/asphalt-8-airborne/id610391947?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/de/app/asphalt-8-airborne/id6103919... Adobe After Effects https://blogs.adobe.com/creativecloud/after-effects-cc-2015-3-in-depth-gpu-accelerated-effects/ https://blogs.adobe.com/creativecloud/after-effects-cc-2015-... Adobe Premier Pro https://blogs.adobe.com/creativecloud/up-next-for-premiere-pro-cc-and-media-encoder-cc/ https://blogs.adobe.com/creativecloud/up-next-for-premiere-p...
- lisper 10y agoWhat I really want is for my state (SSD, RAM, maybe the CPU, but probably not the GPU) to be easily detachable from my human interface devices (keyboard, mouse, display). I want to be able to use a desktop in one place, then unplug a small unit which contains the aforementioned state (i.e. the equivalent of a sleeping laptop but with no keyboard or display), carry that someplace else, plug it in to a different set of HID devices, and pick up exactly where I left off. And, of course, one possible set of HID devices would be something like a present-day laptop so that I can continue working while en-route. But there is no reason why the business end of a computer needs to be in the same enclosure as the HID, and a lot of reasons why it should not be. I can do much of this now with a USB3 SSD, but the problem is that there is no way to "sleep" such a configuration. To change locations I need to shut down in one place and reboot in another.
- dopeboy 10y agoThis is exactly what I want. Well articulated.
- meesterdude 10y agoI do this with a vertical docked MBP. I mostly am on my own display/keyboard, but when i need to go somewhere i can just sleep it and go.
- lisper 10y agoYes, that's what I do too. But if I could detach the keyboard and display then I could fit what remains in my pocket instead of having to shlep it around in my backpack.
- Clubber 10y agoIf they could do this with a phone (x86/x64), or at least something with a cellular radio, they would hit it out of the park. I want a laptop that is just a dock with a phone slot in it. A desktop as well. Slide the phone in and instant form factor change with ports, GPU, extra HDD/SDD, etc.
- 10y ago
- yakult 10y agoWhat I take away from this is that they've devoted so little resource to Mac internally that people in the know are asking inconvenient questions, hence the need for this article. You don't hear him assuring people about the iphone.
- Clubber 10y agoI think they spend a whole lot of energy on the iWatch and it didn't pan out the way they hoped.
- toyg 10y agoThat and the iPad Pro were real duds. Good concepts, underwhelming execution ("let's just slap iOS on a big-ass screen, it will do").
- jacobolus 10y agoThe larger size iPad Pro is an amazing drawing tablet, I’m really glad to have one. I’d recommend one to anyone trying to take notes with a pen, make sketches, design anything (from furniture to web apps), work as an illustrator, etc. I find the pen and display to beat anything else available right now, unless you need a very large display. There’s definitely room for software to catch up for other types of uses, but that’s more a matter of third party developers stepping up. (And the general poor market / software ecosystem on the iPad, with relatively weak sales of pro apps in general.) Don’t expect it to be a laptop replacement. (I know some people who have had success with this, but for me the uses of iPad and laptop are almost entirely non-overlapping.) It’s also great for watching video, and I have friends who have enjoyed playing games on one.
- toyg 10y ago> that’s more a matter of third party developers stepping up. I think the hardcore sandboxing iOS forces doesn't really work well with "Pro" workflows. Say you want to edit a Word document and insert a picture - unless both your word processor app AND image-editing app are somehow integrated with dropbox / icloud, you can't do it; if you don't want to store your multi-gb image on "the cloud", you can't work with it; etc etc. Are these use-cases for laptops only? Yeah, maybe; but that's the sort of thing the iPad Pro was supposed to do. I was (and still am) a big supporter of laptop-replacing tablets, but Apple didn't really manage to pull it off with this device. MS seems to have nailed it better, and I'll probably get a Surface-like as soon as prices come down a bit.
- draw_down 10y agoThen they should act like it.
- jbarham 10y agoI sold my MacBook Air a year ago and don't really miss it. I do my day-to-day development work on a very small Lenovo desktop PC running Ubuntu connected to two Dell 23" IPS screens. It's fast, silent and cheap & easy to upgrade w/ standard PC parts. And since all my servers run Ubuntu there's very little context-switching needed between my dev & live environments. For light photo editing work I use a Windows PC. I'm interested in doing more serious photo editing and the best practise industry expert recommendation is to buy a custom made PC (e.g., https://imagescience.com.au/knowledge/build-a-powerful-pc-for-photoshop-and-other-imaging-applications https://imagescience.com.au/knowledge/build-a-powerful-pc-fo...). I don't follow hardware that closely but recent developments around e.g. the amazing speed of NVMe drives and AMD's Zen architecture make the PC hardware space look pretty exciting. The new MacBook's Touch Bar seems like a gimmick in comparison.
- bane 10y agoI kind of feel like, once you're talking publicly about things like if you are committed or not, you probably aren't and are trying to keep people from fleeing while you figure out what to do or while some long-term strategy kicks in.
- pdimitar 10y agoAgreed, I have the exact same feeling for this case as well. "We have so many amazing things in store that I am so excited about" <-- recycled and beaten to death CEO lingo. I mean, he might be telling the truth (I am not gonna argue what I don't know!) but the wording is just awful and comes off as corny and forced by your PR department. Actions speak louder than words. The new MBPs are the most meh Apple laptops ever. The iPhone 7/Plus are the laziest iPhones ever made, too. Rehashes losing legacy ports and trying to impose new ones (although USB Type-C is the best decision they've made in the last several years; I think they should've went with the same port for the iPhone as well). And losing battery life. Damn. I was never an active Apple user. I bought my first iPhone and Macbook at March 2016 (the 12" Macbook and the 6S Plus; I sold the iPhone only 4 months later but that's a separate topic). But I did consider Apple because part of the Windows ecosystem -- and the entire Android ecosystem -- are disappointing me a lot lately. I was really curious what will Apple bring with the iPhone 7/Plus and the new MBPs. Severe disappointment followed. I'll give them until the next iPhone release. If they can't excite me, oh well, guess it's time to sift again through the trash yard that Android has become lately.
- WWLink 10y agoOnly answering this because of the ecosystem comment. I wish manufacturers would make products that work well with anything. Like Apple watches with Android phones and vice versa, Apple TV running Amazon's Prime TV app, Amazon's Prime TV box running Apple's TV app, etc. All of these ecosystem-exclusive things are annoying and in some ways I believe holding technology back a little.
- MagnumOpus 10y agoWe all wish that and they are not just holding back things "a little" but by massive amounts. But alas companies are usually not in it to advance technology, but to make shedloads of money. Lock-in, incompatible ports, moats are all by design to reduce customer attrition from inferior products by some margin. Peter Thiel's "From 0 to 1" opened my mind to this. SV VCs also don't care about your tech too much - but they are insanely focused on what your "moat" is. I.e. lock-in, patents, network effects etc.
- JohnTHaller 10y agoThe statement doesn't mention the outdated, underpowered, and overpriced Mac Pro specifically, which would have been helpful to the Mac faithful. A few folks I know in the video space switched to Windows because you can build a rendering rig that's over twice as powerful for less than half the price.
- elastic_church 10y agoits okay for Apple, everyone that doesn't do any video rendering buys Macs because they still think they're better at it.
- draw_down 10y agoExactly, their treatment of the Pro is a dead giveaway. It's long past time to kill or update it.
- sliken 10y agoI'm sure 6 months ago apple would have said they are working on "great" laptops. But we ended up with half ish the battery life promised, 16GB ram max, and needing dongles to connect to monitors, mouse, cameras, or external disks.
- EduardoBautista 10y agoThat dongle situation will be resolved in a year and for the better.
- eropple 10y agoI really have my doubts, because most of the gear I have won't be changing by then. The "solution" will remain for me to have two sets of cables for most of my gear: USB-B/C to USB-A and USB-C cables (because I'm not replacing my desktop anytime soon). That's a bad solution.
- lethargic_meat 10y agoThe ram limitation, similar to the limitations on processor are Intel's fault, not Apple. Mac's latest version uses LPDDR3E which tops at 16G. For 32G you would need LPDDR4 or LPDDR4E and a processor compatible. http://fixmibug.com/if-the-macbook-pro-32-gb-of-ram-the-design-would-be-committed-because-the-battery-according-to-schiller.html http://fixmibug.com/if-the-macbook-pro-32-gb-of-ram-the-desi... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_DDR https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_DDR https://ark.intel.com/products/88972/Intel-Core-i7-6920HQ-Processor-8M-Cache-up-to-3_80-GHz https://ark.intel.com/products/88972/Intel-Core-i7-6920HQ-Pr...
- untog 10y ago...so why didn't Apple use them?
- ps 10y agoBecause it would require the change of design as Phil supposedly stated. However attaching lightning proboscis and "revolutionising" keyboard by removing key(s) obviously is a piece of cake and a way to go. Seriously. They do not care about RAM as Pro users clearly do and we feel betrayed. I wonder if and when will anti-touch display stubbornness vanish as it kind of did when they introduced stylus (sorry, Pencil).
- imagetic 10y agoI personally think the iMac has been an amazing all-in-one package. It's simplicity gives it an appeal that has made it a near-perfect tool for casual users who want to avoid the quirkiness of Windows. The iMac also scales up to heavy-hitting design work and I rarely see a lot of complaints until you get to render heavy applications or try to do multi-track and high resolution video editing and motion graphics, which it isn’t really designed to do. But it's an amazing screen and overall it's very capable and well rounded. The current Mac Pro has some serious flaws though. The concept was neat, but it wasn't proven in the pro market. Video Production is becoming increasingly demanding as camera resolutions climb. Since the release of the Mac Pro, a lot of people started jumping ship and going to Windows. Today, if you're buying a Mac Pro, it’s probably not because it's an amazing machine, but because you aren't ready to leave OS X (MacOS) yet. That’s is a hard pill to swallow after years of relying on the dependability of the Mac desktop. Maybe they’ll give it a refresh, but I don’t see the tower with PCI capabilities coming back. As for the Mac Mini, the only thing that was good for was a small server or media center, at least to me. And they abandoned that a long time ago.
- tracker1 10y agoMy friend really likes his, though his biggest complaint keeping him off, is he wants a matching 5K display, so he can have dual displays off his iMac, which isn't an option, and apple killed their display line. For me, the highest end mini is almost enough, as I really don't want a built in display at all... The mac pro is too overpriced (more than it was when last refreshed) and there's no new mac pro in sight... and to be honest, I really want a mid-range "Mac" (not pro, not mini), effectively i5-i7 iMac hardware without a built in display, hell build it off an itx platform board in a fancy case, then allow the pricing to rule itself out... I mean, keep the developers happy and making apps for their iOS devices... yeah, we'll build other stuff too, but really they need to figure out that a lot of actual software developers (the people that make the stuff that makes their platforms worthwhile) aren't happy with the options available.
- DerekL 10y agoI agree. I don't know if Apple would do it, but it would be great if they offered a Mac Pro with iMac style chips (i5 and integrated graphics at the low end) with prices starting at $1000 or $1500. Using the same case as the Xeon Mac Pros might save some money and keep things simpler. Then they could make the Mac mini smaller and cheaper, like a scaled-up Apple TV. SSD only, no hard drive, 2 or 4 USB 3 ports, Ethernet and HDMI, starting at $399.
- eva1984 10y agoLol, are you committed to MacBook too, Cook? Look at what a Joke you have created.
- Girlang 10y agoNone of the new desktop machines are useful for us. We want NVIDIA Pascal graphics cards and lots of RAM. (128GB or more) You just can't get that with Apple hardware.
- legodt 10y ago"Cook cites the far better performance of desktop computers, including screen sizes, memory, storage and more variety in I/O" A bold statement considering that the only I/O on the current iMac is 4x USB, 2x thunderbolt, Ethernet, SD card, and a 1/8 jack- a collection of ports bested by all but the most anemic computers Edit: fixed port thanks to HillaryBriss. I was actually too generous in my original listing of ports
- HillaryBriss 10y agonot sure about the USBC i'm seeing Thunderbolt 2 on the back of the iMac http://www.apple.com/imac/specs/ http://www.apple.com/imac/specs/
- suprgeek 10y agoI think this "assurance" pretty much confirms for me that Apple has internally begun to shift even more resources away from the Mac and the Macbook. The very weak nature of the response which really does not provide any specifics what-so-ever is very typical when the underlying reality matches the rumor but the guy in charge just can't say it yet. Tim Cook is Apple's Ballamer - An ops. guy, great for the bottom line but fundamentally stuck in the past.
- scott_karana 10y ago> Tim Cook is Apple's Ballmer - An ops. guy, great for the bottom line but fundamentally stuck in the past. "Stuck in the present" might be a bit more fair :)
- fiatpandas 10y agoThe response is weak and uninformative because it's posted on an internal message board, which might as well be a public Reddit thread as far as an exec is concerned. Did you expect him to post a picture of Jony Ive posing in front of 25 iMac ID prototypes? If he says anything else he's said too much.
- tonyjstark 10y agoI think you're are a bit unfair to Ballmer, recently he admitted that they were late to the game but he was pushing for hardware and was not supported by the board[1]. Not everything MS is doing is becaus Ballmer is gone but also because Ballmer prepared Microsoft for it. [1]https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-04/steve-ballmer-says-smartphones-broke-his-relationship-with-bill-gates https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-04/steve-bal...
- ohitsdom 10y ago> everything MS is doing is becaus Ballmer is gone but also because Ballmer prepared Microsoft for it. There is very little evidence for this. An argument can be made for laying the ground work for Azure, but Ballmer had nothing to do with MS's recent efforts in open source and other exciting newer initiatives in the company.
- gigatexal 10y agoYeah I'll believe it when I see it. First the Mac Pro languishes and then the lackluster upgrade to the MacBook Pro ... I dunno.
- cwyers 10y ago> “Some folks in the media have raised the question about whether we’re committed to desktops,” Cook wrote. “If there’s any doubt about that with our teams, let me be very clear: we have great desktops in our roadmap. Nobody should worry about that.” Having them in the roadmap only does so much, though; people need to buy computers now, and having some unspecified (but "great") computers that will come out at some unspecified later date isn't the same as having up-to-date computers now, and it doesn't show that when those computers in the roadmap do materialize, that they won't be left fallow for years as these were.
- aschwabe 10y agoWell then how 'bout an ARM version with a touch screen, battery that lasts three days and the ability run IOS apps in a container...
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 10y agoApple is opposed to touchscreen laptops. iOS is optimized for touch gestures. You won’t see iOS apps intended for actual use on ARM MacBooks.
- Animats 10y agoUh oh. That's the sort of thing CEOs say just before they kill the product line.
- dijit 10y agoI was working for Nokia in Finland when Stephen Elop came along to quell fears that he was shutting down Maemo/Meego R&D. He was just as vague as Tim Cook is being and there is certainly an air of nostalgia when reading this. I don't believe this bodes well for the product line at all.
- anjc 10y agoWhat was the internal perception of Elop as CEO at the time? And of the push towards Windows Mobile? Did people see the writing on the wall or did everyone see promise? I still remember seeing the promo videos for the...920 I think it was, and being utterly blown away. The promos were so good that whole communities dedicated themselves to proving that they were fake.
- kriro 10y agoI have moved from genuinely wanting to buy the new MBP pre-announcement due to technical reasons (battery life, screen) to only needing to buy it due to iOS development lock in. Reminds me very much of the process I went through with Windows based PCs (except back then it was gaming). I think I'll just go back to a Linux laptop (all other boxes are so the laptop has always been the odd-box) and will say goodbye to the iOS world. I mostly do web anyway and can live with non-native or no Apple apps at all.
- manmal 10y agoFellow iOS dev here. I had a similar sentiment first, but this new MBP is a very fine machine. It's blazing fast and I don't need a touchscreen (I might even buy a touchbar-less version if they made one at 15"). The dongle thing will resolve itself in the next 2 years, with more peripherals going wireless or replacements with USB-C ports. Will you really let go of Sketch and all the other great tools from 3rd party devs just because you don't like dongles & touchbar?
- SXX 10y agoMacOS now work well enough in QEMU.
- GreaterFool 10y agoOf course they are committed to Mac! Just have a look at the numerous updates to their flagship product: Mac Pro. Oh wait...
- jlgaddis 10y agoToo late. I just spent ~$4,000 over the weekend on components to build myself a shiny new desktop. It'll be running Linux, just like my primary laptop does, and so I imagine I'll probably sell my one-year-old MacBook Pro before long as well. It was nice knowing you, Apple.
- jaxondu 10y agoLooks like damage control by CEO. There wouldn't be so much backslash towards latest MacBookPro if Apple were to keep all Mac models on annual refresh.
- scholia 10y agoOr if Apple allowed users to upgrade their own machines....
- overgard 10y agoThis is just a press release pretending to be an internal memo. Clever. Glad they're still committed to making desktops though.
- welly 10y agoI think my next Mac will be a desktop because the current lineup of Macbooks do absolutely nothing for me and my current Macbook will be going to the great Apple Store in the sky sooner rather than later. And perhaps an Android tablet for being on the move.
- oceanswave 10y agoHolding out for the MacBook Pro Plus
- tonyjstark 10y agoMacBook Pro S
- raverbashing 10y agoActions speak louder than words There wouldn't be a need to explain themselves if they were putting out competing products
- chmaynard 10y agoSeems ironic. When I worked there, all Apple employees had a Mac on their desk and probably used it on a daily basis. Yet the CEO thinks he needs to assure the employees that Apple is still committed to improving them.
- m12k 10y agoIt's actually kind of amazing to see the discourse shift against Apple and the new MacBook Pro to the point where it seems almost self-reinforcing. Like someone turned the reality distortion field on backwards or something. I've been wanting a mac laptop the size and weight of a MacBook Air 13" but with a retina display for years, and the ability to connect usb, power and external display with just a single cable is just icing on the cake. The TouchBar - meh, but using TouchID to unlock 1Password is handy if not revolutionary. But the point is, by most standards the new MBPs are great laptops for most professionals, especially software developers - solid build quality, fast, great screens, long battery life and lightweight. Sure, there are undoubtedly some people who really need to plug a ton of USB-A devices every day or need more than 16gb to run a ton of VMs or something, and for those it must be an unwelcome regression. But honestly, I have a hard time believing that can make up more than 5-10% of the market of the previous models. I can't really see how that can explain the public opinion turning against them to quite the extent that it has. I'm guessing it's a combination of several other factors: 1) Apple hasn't made a really revolutionary product since Jobs died. (Apple Watch was an honest try, but the product category was as dead a fish as the nay-sayers predicted). We expect these people to produce magic every x years, and they are long over-due with their next miracle. They put out an evolutionary product but it gets judged against the revolution that we were longing for. 2) Microsoft's entry into the laptop market has been with some surprisingly solid, and even innovative products (e.g. the Surface Book). They might not quite be revolutionary, but they are at least more so than the new MBP is. And their willingness on taking on niche markets (e.g. a Cintiq-killer for graphic designers) is contrasting with Apple's 'regression to the mean' where niche audiences are increasingly being neglected in favor of the less demanding mainstream consumer. Those 5-10% Apple just pissed off might not make a big difference on the bottomline themselves, but they are part of the hip trendsetters that used to be the poster child for the mac platform.
- jest3r1 10y agoIt's easy to explain. Price. I've been wanting a mac laptop the size and weight of a MacBook Air 13" ... how about the size and weight and price?? They removed a bunch of ports, reduced battery life and upped the price. USD $1799 to $2799 (with touch bar). Pricing is out of reach. Especially if you live outside of the USA where exchange rate kills it completely. I love the 13" Macbook Air, just wish they would add retina, retain the ports, AND the price point.
- tajen 10y agoSo many questions here. I'm sure Blackberry's CEO once said "Blackberry is not dead" – when the CEO worries about it, it means there's huge worries about it throughout the company. Were macOS leaders leaving in mass or something? Also, there's not a single fact in Tim Cook's statement. It's not "We're investing in X or Y". It's not "Stay for 6 months and you'll be so stunned with our next release". It's not "We're planning a Macbook in 1 year to shut down criticism about last Macbook". It's "Please don't jump ship pleaaaaaase". OTOH I'm super happy that Tim Cook noticed that there was a problem with the new Macbook and acknowledges it. It makes me hopeful, maybe he's going to take the right actions. > the Apple Watch led to ResearchKit, which led to CareKit That's the very wrong names to drop if Tim Cook wants to illustrate "How Apple employees get excited with anything". I haven't heard of them, and I follow IT news pretty thoroughly. They're rather an illustration that Apple employees are focussed on little things, the middle-management is too free to wander off in lower-innovation areas. The first thing I've learnt about innovation is first you need to execute well. People expect touchscreens, USBs/jack/Fn keys, a bug-free core system, 1-To HDDs, popular games... It's not innovation, it's just execution, which serves as a basis before going 10 steps ahead of everyone. I just don't see why the statement is directed to employees. What's wrong with Apple's credit in the eyes if the the employees, are they getting demotivated? Isn't it rather the fanbase who needs convincing? Was the communique leaked on purpose to reassure the market? Next thing you know, Apple removes the Control key.
- DoofusOfDeath 10y ago> Next thing you know, Apple removes the Control key. I'm pretty sure Apple would never give up Control.
- bitwize 10y agoIt's one thing to be committed to the Mac. But do they see the Mac as a Mac, or do they see it as an iPad Super? If they're going to commit to the iPad Super at the expense of the Mac that professionals have come to rely on, they are going to have a seriously disgruntled user base.
- marcoperaza 10y agoPersonally, luxury laptop lines don't make sense for me at this point. There was a time when it was the only way to get decent hardware, but those days are long gone. Four years ago I spilled water on my 2009 17" MBP (RIP) and Apple wanted $1200 for the repair. Instead, I spent ~$1300, including three-year accident-protection insurance where they show up at your house THE NEXT DAY, on a Thinkpad T530 and I couldn't be happier with it. Quad-core i7, discrete Nvidia GPU, 15" 1080p display, 2 USB 2.0 ports, 2 USB 3.0 ports, ethernet, displayport, firewire, DVD drive, 300GB HDD. I've since upgraded to a 500GB SSD (and put the old HDD where the DVD drive was) and to 16GB of RAM. Due to the internal metal frame, I'm sure I could drop the thing repeatedly without consequence. Yeah, it's not thin and weighs 1.5 pounds more than a 15" MBP. The extra-capacity battery I ordered it with is losing some capacity, but good thing I can just pop it out for a new one with the flick of a switch. This computer will still be kicking ass in four more years. EDIT: I dug up the invoice: http://imgur.com/a/cT55A http://imgur.com/a/cT55A . $1380 including the three-year warranty/accident-insurance. Apparently I can put a mobile broadband card in this thing, cool! Further edit: Perhaps I overstated in my first sentence. I really don't mean to put down Macs. I loved my 17" MBP and the 13" company-issued MBP I used at an internship in 2013. Their screens, even pre-retina, are beautiful. The OS and hardware worked perfectly together, e.g. smooth touchpad actions like scrolling and zooming. Though I haven't used the new machines everyone is complaining about, my experiences with Apple hardware have only been great. But what I value in a computer just doesn't align with the value that premium ultra-thin laptops provide.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mej10 10y agoSome people literally get joy out of using things that are well designed and don't feel cheap. When it is a device you are going to use constantly for work and other things then it becomes very easy to justify buying a "luxury" laptop. I used the same iMac for 5 years (only added an SSD) and have used the same MBP for 4 years and it still has a lot of life left.
- pronik 10y ago
- jannotti 10y agoI was just struck at how Trumpian this sounds: "If there’s any doubt about that with our teams, let me be very clear: we have great desktops in our roadmap. Nobody should worry about that." Though I also notice the Obamian "let me be very clear". Tim Cook for President?!
- emodendroket 10y agoWhen you have to make these assurances it kind of makes me think the opposite.
- allworknoplay 10y agoThis sycophantic gladhanding drives me up the wall. >> ...it does result in truly impressive results from time to time, like the recent AirPods, which are an incredible weaving together of Apple’s hardware and software teams to produce something that works so much better than what came before it’s laughable. If apple focused on great hardware and software like it did through the 2000s rather than unnecessary, un-asked-for "courage" bloat, people wouldn't be asking these questions in the first place.
- 1_2__3 10y agoYes, wireless headphones in 2016 are clearly something only the geniuses at Apple can fathom.
- dbg31415 10y agoIf Apple was really committed to the Mac, they'd be committed to the Mac. * iPhone, iPad, Mac Buyer's Guide: Know When to Buy || http://buyersguide.macrumors.com/#Mac http://buyersguide.macrumors.com/#Mac iMac - 2nd longest stretch since update (434 days as of today) Mac Mini - longest stretch since update (796) Mac Pro - longest stretch since update (1,097) The Mac Pro is especially out of date... with $1,500 home-build PCs running circles around it.
- scoobydont3 10y agoAn Apple a day keeps the productivity away!
- greedo 10y agoCommitted to the Mac sounds great, but it's not just hardware updates that are lagging. macOS software applications aren't updated/maintained as much as they should be.
- binthere 10y agoWindows usually feels ugly if you have a bad monitor (which is pretty much 99.9% of the monitors available in the market today). I've recently bought an Asus Rog Swift monitor and I couldn't be happier with Windows. https://www.amazon.com/27-inch-Monitor-PG278Q-Response-Display/dp/B01C83BE6U?th=1 https://www.amazon.com/27-inch-Monitor-PG278Q-Response-Displ... UI itself is just a matter of preference and I don't mind Windows 10 UI, you can hide most of the things you find ugly.
- antaviana 10y agoMy main issue with macOS is that it is terribly slow with HDD. For example, if you launch Office or any other heavy application on a HDD macOS, the app start time is the range of tens of seconds (unacceptable), but if you do so on a SSD macOS the app start time is the range of seconds (acceptable). IMHO, there are two solutions to this issue: a) Change the macOS filesystem so that it is at par with ntfs in terms of I/O performance. b) Keep the current macOS filesystem with its performance issues, but make HDD effectively obsolete by releasing a lineup of SSD-only Macs at an attractive price point so that users are compelled to change their old HDD systems.
- russelluresti 10y agoIn other news, CEO lies to employees. Oh wait, that's not other news at all.