17 ms·
Scientists engineer mice genomes to lengthen their lifespans by 30 percent
- pat2man 10y ago> The technique, which requires genetic engineering, cannot be applied directly to people, but the achievement points toward better understanding of human aging and the possibility of rejuvenating human tissues by other means. Still a ways off for human use but definitely interesting research.
- devoply 10y agoYou have to understand all the rich people in the world are scared of death and will pay anything to avoid it for as long as possible. So if aging can be reduced or cured we will be able to do it and probably relatively soon. And this quest is as old as civilization, maybe even older: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qin_Shi_Huang https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qin_Shi_Huang "He ruled until his death in 210 BC after a futile search for an elixir of immortality"
- lisper 10y ago> all the rich people in the world are scared of death and will pay anything to avoid it for as long as possible This is generally true of poor people as well.
- devoply 10y agoYes, but poor people can't pay. That's why they can't solve anything. Google can spend a billion dollars on this. Multiple billions can be easily spent on this. And it's a great time for that. So much excessive capital. So many millionaires and billionaires. All going to die. What can scientists do to help them?
- api 10y agoRich people would get this first, but there'd be so much demand that unless there was something intrinsically expensive about a life extension tech (e.g. it required surgical intervention) you'd see geometric decreases in price. Then the patents would expire and it'd get mass produced in India for $0.05/pill.
- kbenson 10y ago> Then the patents would expire and it'd get mass produced in India for $0.05/pill. Forget patents. This is the sort of thing that will flood the black market, and could conceivably be a target for eminent domain. In any case, it will make it out to the public in some manner if it becomes a reality, I'm sure of that.
- striking 10y agoWe're looking for extended life for some people, without being able to guarantee a regular life for all. What a world.
- arithma 10y agoOne is easier than the other I am afraid.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoNo, ultimately we're looking for unlimited life for everyone. We will not sell anyone to the dark.
- mynameisvlad 10y agoHowever, this technology would ostensibly over time get commoditized and available for everyone, like practically every other piece of technology so far.
- wwweston 10y agoThat's what we'd like to believe about ourselves. But until we're post-scarcity -- as long as other people are competition for limited resources (land, food, water, health care, even attention) -- I wouldn't be too quick to believe it.
- dghughes 10y agoGrow a new genetically engineered body from your stem cells then transplant your head. Maybe wait and see if that Russian head transplant experiment is a success.
- lisivka 10y agoHead will die anyway. Death sequence is embedded in the cell, to prevent unlimited growth. You can extend your lifespan by 30% by removing aged cells, so stem cells will divide and produce a slightly younger cells, which reverse lot of age related malfunctions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- photoJ 10y agoLets hope so!
- lisper 10y agoCareful what you wish for. Aging and death are woven deeply into the fabric of society, indeed, into the fabric of life itself. Old growth needs to be periodically swept away to make room for new growth. The only logically possible outcome of immortality is that sooner or later the entire biomass of the planet is consumed by immortals, at which point all growth must stop. Imagine being the last person born into such a world, doomed forever to be the youngest, least experienced, least powerful member of a static society where no one ever ages and no new people are ever born. Is that really a life you would want to lead?
- ClassyJacket 10y agoOr, we could limit reproduction for those that choose not to age, so that you can only reproduce when you're next in line with and someone dies, keeping a consistent population.
- lisper 10y ago> you can only reproduce when you're next in line with and someone dies A system similar to that has historically been employed in lines of royal succession, where the number of thrones available places a hard limit on how many people can be kings. It has generally not ended well.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoWell, yes, it does introduce a motivation for murder, I'll give you that.
- woofyman 10y agoThe immortals will be risk averse and stay inside their highly secured compounds.
- grabcocque 10y agoMightier and bloody wars will not be caused than when we finally figure out how to cure ageing.
- sqeaky 10y agoWhy? Any other thing we have invented has generally reduced war by increasing resources available to all, at least since industrialization. There are a few exception, but they were generally intended to be weapons, it seems hard to imagine an aging based weapon.
- abakker 10y agoReducing aging will likely reduce the resources available to all, by reducing the rate of population decline relative to the growth.
- sqeaky 10y agoBy that logic because we have extended life expectancy with hygiene, education, medicine and global transport that we should be producing less resources per person. Lets look at food for example: https://ourworldindata.org/food-per-person/ https://ourworldindata.org/food-per-person/ Well that clearly isn't the case... Something subtle must be wrong with your clearly intuitive observation. I think the cost of educating and raising the next generation to the point where they are productive and having them to relearn the lessons of those that died early is simply more costly than what it takes to support an aging population.
- abakker 10y agoYes, but the production is not evenly distributed among every person. Really, the people who are actually farming are getting much more productive, but because they are better able to manage resources. However, there is probably a limit on the absolute yield per acre, as an example. It may yet be double what we do now(which is double what we did in 1970), but most farmers I've talked to think that they probably won't hit the FDA's target of doubling yield/acre by 2050. Managing soil chemistry is too problematic. It is simply hard to add back enough mass to the ground as we extract in food/year.
- nopinsight 10y agoA Scientific American article on the same research with a useful comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13187302 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13187302 Interesting bits: "In living mice they activated the four genes (known as “Yamanaka factors,” for researcher Shinya Yamanaka, the Nobelist who discovered their combined potential in 2006). This approach rejuvenated damaged muscles and the pancreas in a middle-aged mouse, ... " "... These (other) approaches can reverse some aspects of aging, such as muscle degeneration—but aging returns when the treatment stops, he adds. With an approach like the one Belmonte lays out in the new study, theoretically “you could have one treatment and go back 10 or 20 years,” he says. If aging starts to catch up to you again, you simply get another treatment."
- dominotw 10y agobeen hearing this since dawn of humanity. next.
- Mao_Zedang 10y agoworld is flat as well. next.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- daemonk 10y agotldr for biologists out there. They made a transgenic mouse line of doxycycline inducible Yamanaka factors in progeria (LAKI) background. Too high induction lead to mortality and teratomas, which is known. They cyclicly induced the Yamanaka factors and found it reversed signs of aging (prolong lifespan by ~30%)
- leereeves 10y agoThey didn't test this (or haven't yet) against normal aging in mice, only mice with progeria (unusually rapid aging)?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- JohnJamesRambo 10y agoWhy did they use the mice with the progeria gene? Wouldn't the results be more impressive in wild-type mice? Were they just trying to get around the 2-3 year lifespan of a lab mouse faster?
- lvs 10y agoOh they did, in fact, but the results in WT mice were not as easy to overhype. The effects were extremely minor to nonexistent in aged wild-type animals (Fig S7 from the paper). Unfortunately, press releases and the subsequent news articles -- as usual -- have totally oversold what this paper means.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- RushAndAPush 10y agoSo what you're saying is that the mice that didn't have their genome edited didn't have a drastic life extension? I assume the improvements only occurred in the mice that had their genomes edited to reduce Yamanaka factors because they then artificially replaced the Yamanaka factors?
- reasonattlm 10y agoPaper: http://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(16)31664-6 http://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(16)31664-6 Caveats: 1) Doing anything to the aging of cells in culture has next to nothing to do with what goes on inside aging tissues, or where it does that is heavily dependent on the details. The article doesn't tell you enough to decide, so you should look at the paper. 2) Doing anything that attenuates the effects of an accelerated aging phenotype, actually usually a DNA repair disorder, almost always has nothing to do with aging as it happens in normal individuals. You can hit mice with hammers, and then evaluate the effects of a hammer-blocking cage, but that doesn't tell you anything about aging - and for exactly the same reasons. This is generally true except when it is isn't, and that depends on the fine details. Again, go look at the paper. 3) The interesting experiment is the one in which pluripotency-inducing factors are upregulated in a normal mouse, but temporarily. This is the thing that people have looked at in the past and said, well, turning on widespread transformation of somatic cells into pluripotent stem cells sounds like a really bad idea. Cancer seems the likely outcome, and that has in fact been demonstrated in a couple of studies in mice, but there is also the point that your central nervous system rather relies upon maintaining the fine structure it has established in many cases, such as data stored in the brain. Running in and randomly reprogramming any CNS cells that take up the vector or the pluripotency signals seems like a bad idea on the face of it. So on the whole it is fascinating that a good outcome was produced in the normal mice, analogous to the sort of thing that has been produced via stem cell transplants and telomerase gene therapies. But I'd still want to see what happens to the mice over the long term after that, and would expect cancer.
- EdSharkey 10y agoBetween the theory that cybernetically augmented humans will become the "hard AI" of science fiction and signs that a cure for aging is nearly here, I would feel a lot more comfortable if we all started having a public debate about the limits we will set on metahumans. A cybernetically augmented human might gain an intelligence completely alien (and hostile) to us non-augments. And an immortal-except-for-catestrophic-accidents could amass an unseemly amount of wealth and control over non-immortals over their long lives - moreso than the elites of today could dream of. My concern about those that metahumans will hold such disproportionate power and they'll quickly get bored. Idle hands are the devil's playthings after all, and they could really make life difficult for the rest of us. I want to see what a many-hundreds of years healthy life will be like and live many lives, but I do not want to have implants or devices that warp my mind/memory. I want to stay human, just minus the frailties. I'm hoping that these evolving new technologies sort neatly into two buckets: those that enhance but still retain the essential (limited) human experience, and those that seek to obliterate and replace the human experience (so that I know which ones to avoid.)
- SilverPaladin 10y agoNext thing you know, we will be getting email spam to buy Yamanaka Factor.. look 30 years younger just take this pill!
- jgord 10y agoIts very noisy to read these 'blip' articles, rather like following the stock ticker blow by blow ... Its wonderful that we see these interesting reports every week, but as a non-specialist you never how it will impact human longevity, and when. What I'd like to read is a well considered "state-of-longevity-science" report - by someone not Aubrey DeGray (give the man a medal) but equally cognizant, perhaps more conservative - that actually explains and weighs the torrent of advancements as they happen and gives them some context. What is the likely impact of crispr, of rosveratrol, of telomere-foo, of gene-therapy, of blood cleansing, of stem-cells on logevity in 10 / 20 years ? Where and why should we rationally allocate research money ? What is likely to benefit Alzheimers patients in the 5 year term ? Its the kind of state of play you need updated on a monthly basis, due to the pace of progress. Does such a report already exist ?
- reasonattlm 10y agoI could put one together. Or you could read the last few years of posts at Fight Aging! and get the gist. But I'm pretty pro-SENS so it might not agree with your preferences. The short answer to your question is that the impact of everything viable that is not SENS is probably going to be about the same as exercise or calorie restriction in your life span if you are in the middle of life now. Which is to say +10 years if you pick the right things, and the people building those things do a good job. That would be, say, the combination of a couple of successes in things building upon mTOR or stem cell or telomerase therapies or etc. Not resveratrol, not 99% of the other pharmaceuticals, not 99% of the possible gene therapies, and not 99% of what people are trying to sell you.
- HaveCourage 10y agoSummary of pro death arguments re: longevity progress Fairness Only rich people will get it. (no tech has ever done this.) Better to give money to the poor than science. (family,city,state,nation, has proven local investment beats foreign.) Bad for society Dead people make more room for new, other people. (consider going first.) Run out of resources (live people discover/extract/renew better than dead or nonexistant) Overpopulation (colonize the seas, solar system, or have a war.) Stop having kids Worse wars (nukes are more dangerous than having your first 220 year old person in 2136) Dictators never die (they die all the time and rarely of age) Bad for individual You'll get bored. (your memory isn't that good, or your boredom isn't age related) You'll have to watch your loved ones die. (so you prefer they watch you?) You'll live forever in a terrible state. (longevity requires robustness.) Against gods will (not if he disallows suicide, then it is required.) More people make more progress faster. I'm glad my parents didn't decide the world would be prettier or work better without me in it. Einstein, Bell, Tesla, Da Vinci etc, still alive and productive would be nice. You're literally asking for others to die out of your fear. The burden should be higher. Have courage. If living longer sucks, we'll know 100 years from now, and decide then. First 220 year old in 2136 unless you know how to make one faster than 1 year per year? And that's if you added 120 years to a 100 year old person starting TODAY. Man up, save your family, save yourself. Disclaimer: I'm half way done with a book on this topic. Mail me if you're interested. Scivive on the most popular email service. P.S. Curing aging isn't immortality. You die at 600 on average by accident, and if the parade of imaginary horribles comes true, even earlier.
- djsumdog 10y agoFor you Sci-Fi fans out there, I highly recommend Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars trilogy. In his fictional world, humans do discover how to extend longevity and it goes into many of the social issues that arise (who gets treatments? The rich? The poor? How do we deal with over population?).
- AstralStorm 10y agoDealing with overpopulation is best done the Elon Musk way - go to space, it is empty. A trip to Mars of three months in a lifetime of few hundred could be considered an interesting interlude.
- feelix 10y agoOriginal submission: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13189220 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13189220
- feelix 10y agoWhat I don't understand, is that with ageing billionaires everywhere, why isn't anti-aging the most funded thing in the world? Or is it?
- AstralStorm 10y agoThey perceive the field as moving too slow to reap the benefits.
- biuffwbiubi 10y agoWhat we need right now is more babies and young people and less old people. Babies make everyone around them happy. Old people are racist and suffocatingly repetitive. They never have any new ideas and spend all their time in the past. They're the brakes on progress. Life is all about novelty. Let's have new people in this world.
- known 10y agoMETFORMIN also does the same http://qz.com/431663/scientists-want-to-treat-aging-like-a-disease-and-they-already-have-drugs-for-it/ http://qz.com/431663/scientists-want-to-treat-aging-like-a-d... and http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21704788-fight-cheat-death-hotting-up-adding-ages http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21704788-fight-cheat-...
- AstralStorm 10y agoCurrently probably the most impressive treatment, yes. But it is not patented, so no company can go out and make a killing off it ;-) Much better than the second best, statins.
- jmount 10y agoIt is what the rich want to hear, so there is money in saying it.
- dandare 10y agoThe consequences of longer lifespan to social order are unimaginable. Even increase by dozen of years may result in wars and chaos, especially if the treatment will not be available to everyone. From where I stand it seems that relatively little resources are spent on the research of consequences of longer lifespan compared with the discussions we have about friendly/enemy AI, machines replacing jobs, universal income and other social order changing themes. While I am not saying scientists will stumble upon immortality tomorrow, a serious increase in lifespan may happen relatively soon.
- ekianjo 10y ago> While I am not saying scientists will stumble upon immortality tomorrow, a serious increase in lifespan may happen relatively soon. We have been hearing that for a while though, when do you think "soon" will be ?
- Jaruzel 10y agoI echo this. We're already over-populated on this planet as it is. Yes there's still a lot of available land, but there are reasons we're not using it either to live on, or to farm - too hostile, too wet, too hot/cold, and the cost of terrafirming those areas is prohibitive. Unless we manage to escape this rock, and find a nice Earth 2.0 out there, extending lifespans is pointless. It's driven by pure selfishness, and if ever comes to fruition, will create a subdivide of people who can afford to live longer and healthier and those that can't; Homo-Richus vs. Homo-Poorus.
- aaron-lebo 10y agoEscaping this rock is no relief either. What happens when there's a Muskovite Empire on Mars and all the rich people move there to let the poor die on an old planet stripped of resources to make that possible? Transfers of wealth like that are already happening - let's not make it interplanetary. Humanity has changed so much in the last few generations and we are still catching up. Maybe we don't understand the consequences. We definitely have to figure out it soon because we'll either never make it to another planet or we'll just bring it all with us.
- amalrik_maia 10y agowhat amazing time to be alive :)
- zizzles 10y agoEvery life extension discussion derails into debates about foreverness; and therein lies the problem: humans of all backgrounds (even today) are dropping dead of health problems at 60 years of age. Thus, foreverness is science-fiction with our current understanding. Baby-steps first perhaps? Regardless, many agree foreverness is not possible - and if it was - I would not want it.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoIt's a red herring anyway. The valid question is, would you prefer to remain alive today? You're free to answer in the negative at any time, but it would be nice not to have the decision taken from you by mere biochemistry.
- ilaksh 10y agoThe valid question is actually would you prefer to be healthier today. Aging affects everyone's health (perhaps after a certain age) whether they currently realize they have some acute condition (such as cancer or imminent death) or not.
- smcguinness 10y agoThere shouldn't even be a debate between people who approve of reversing aging and those who do not. Whoever doesn't approve... when the treatment will finally be available... just don't use it! I'll use my freedom of decision and my money to extend my life, thank you! If you want to die, go ahead.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sdfjkl 10y agoRelated reading: Misspent Youth and the Commonwealth Saga by Peter F. Hamilton. A series of sci-fi books where "rejuvenation" technology plays a significant role, its impact on society and human risk taking.
- kickpush1 10y agoClicks on interesting hackernews post > prepares self for opposing negative comment > aaand first comment.
- ilaksh 10y agoSee also http://www.sens.org/research/publications?research_themes_tid=253 http://www.sens.org/research/publications?research_themes_ti...
- Pica_soO 10y agoWhat actually happened to the lady who did this telomere prolonging experiment on her self?