14 ms·
Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker
- wslh 10y ago> Sneakers ridiculously featured a universal key that can break all crypto... If Cory Doctorow had done his homework he would know that Leonard Adleman (the 'A' in RSA) worked in that part: https://www.usc.edu/dept/molecular-science/fm-sneakers.htm https://www.usc.edu/dept/molecular-science/fm-sneakers.htm
- throwaway7767 10y agoYeah, that dig is unfair. Sneakers didn't have a universal key that broke all crypto. They had a device that could break a certain kind of crypto that happened to be used by the US (in the movie, the Russians state that it doesn't affect their encryption). I always assumed the original script called it a DES cracker but the studio people dumbed it down. But sneakers is unique among hacker movies in that it needs very little retconning to make sense from a technical perspective.
- partycoder 10y agoOr the CSI hacker (2 people typing on the same keyboard to hack faster, or creating a hack on visual basic interface (technically possible, but sounds really odd))
- VikingCoder 10y agoFor those who haven't seen it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8qgehH3kEQ&t=13s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8qgehH3kEQ&t=13s In case you need to do it yourself: http://hackertyper.net/ http://hackertyper.net/
- hacker_9 10y agoand this [1]! Both still make me laugh after the 100th time. I'd love to have been in the room when the writers actually thought these scenes up. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkDD03yeLnU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkDD03yeLnU
- curiousgal 10y agoThe Youtube comments are surprisingly hilarious!
- booleandilemma 10y agoI'm tempted to tell people that's how pair programming works.
- minimaxir 10y agoThose memes are the exact thing the article argues against.
- partycoder 10y agoWow, such haters. Downvoted my comment. Better invite a second guy to downvote faster!
- _nato_ 10y agoDavid Mamet once lamented that the computer has taken over the horse, in films. Where once the hero would jump onto their ride to go fight justice, now we have her pulling out the keyboard.
- VikingCoder 10y ago"injustice"
- MichaelApproved 10y ago"for justice" also works.
- cr0sh 10y ago..."for great justice" works best. ;)
- randallsquared 10y agoMaybe it depends on the film. ;)
- vacri 10y agoMamet should probably have watched more than just Westerns.
- qbrass 10y agoMamet should add a little film-noir to the mix. "Case was twenty-four. At twenty-two, he'd been a cowboy, a rustler, one of the best in the Sprawl. He'd been trained by the best, by McCoy Pauley and Bobby Quine, legends in the biz. He'd operated on an almost permanent adrenaline high, a byproduct of youth and proficiency, jacked into a custom cyberspace deck that projected his disembodied consciousness into the consensual hallucination that was the matrix."
- serg_chernata 10y agoI'm a huge fan. What I would like to add is that in my experience the show has also helped the general public better understand some common practices and dangers. In particular the episode where Darlene drops a bunch of infected USB sticks in the police station parking lot. It's nice for people to understand that some mysterious hacker doesn't specifically need to target them as an individual. They're not safe just because they're not very popular or active online.
- danso 10y agoI love his narration of the password cracking, such as how his psychiatrist's password is "Dylan_2791" -- her favorite singer and her birthyear backwards. To me, that feels like what the average person would consider "good" obfuscation, because they can't imagine how fast a brute force attack works inside a narrow space. Or how he tracks his psychiatrist's lover's identity by checking her (the psychiatrist) Instgram checkins, faking a reason to borrow the man's phone, then phishes his security questions and brute forces the password in minutes ("He's too old to have a complicated password, it had to be a combination of these things").
- ZenoArrow 10y agoI'd say 'temporarily killed'. After the rise of quantum computing and AI in the public consciousness, I'd expect we'd see a return of the hacker-as-magician archetype.
- jerf 10y agoThe attempts to explain quantum computing are often as crap as any other attempt to explain anything "quantum", but in practice, it doesn't really change what computing looks like for most people. It means a certain class of problems can be solved more efficiently, and some problems may be solved that previously could not be, but it's not that significant to one not versed in the field. By contrast, if we ever did get true human-level AI... uh... are quite sure that "magician" wouldn't be appropriate at that point...? It's not entirely dissimilar to "demon summoner", though there probably won't be actual pentagrams involved. Although you never know; just as my UNIX system has an awful lot of "demons" in it it would only take one AI researcher with a hacker sense of humor to program in an last-ditch emergency "containment via drawing a pentagram" routine in the base OS for the successful AIs....
- ZenoArrow 10y ago> "The attempts to explain quantum computing are often as crap as any other attempt to explain anything "quantum", but in practice, it doesn't really change what computing looks like for most people. It means a certain class of problems can be solved more efficiently, and some problems may be solved that previously could not be, but it's not that significant to one not versed in the field." Quantum computing is likely to have a large impact on crypto (making the crypto we rely on now easier to break). A large part of the Hollywood hacker is someone who breaks into systems with relative ease. >"By contrast, if we ever did get true human-level AI... uh... are quite sure that "magician" wouldn't be appropriate at that point...? It's not entirely dissimilar to "demon summoner", though there probably won't be actual pentagrams involved. Although you never know; just as my UNIX system has an awful lot of "demons" in it it would only take one AI researcher with a hacker sense of humor to program in an last-ditch emergency "containment via drawing a pentagram" routine in the base OS for the successful AIs...." Again, the angle I was going for was more about the power of hackers. The type of opinions people had when they denied Mitnick his phone call from jail because they thought he could launch nuclear missiles. We're only starting to see the widespread impacts of AI. Wait until the impacts on day to day life are undeniable. At that point, people who can control AI will be seen as a little beyond the ordinary.
- senior_james 10y agoMr. Robot may be technically correct, but I couldn't get past a few episodes of the first season. Comically bad/cliche companies that are polluting the earth, killing innocent people, and robbing the poor. A closeted gay, masochist antagonist and a smug, patronizing protagonist that regularly demeans the people around him and feels they are less intelligent than himself. This was all in the first few episodes. I assume the characters and plots have changed since the first season, but not by much. I felt like the writers were ignored in high school and used the show as a way to passive-aggressively get back at their perceived enemies.
- yarou 10y agoRami Malek really kills it in the first season IMO. Especially the opiate withdrawal scene. Also minor nit - I'm pretty sure Tyrell's wife is aware of his escapades. But you're missing the point about it...Tyrell and his wife are concerned solely with power.
- RUG3Y 10y agoI'm fairly certain that he's not meant to be a closeted gay man, but a psychopath who will pretend to be gay and sleep with someone he isn't interested in, in order to get what he wants.
- cheald 10y agoI think this is right. The Willicks are the embodiment of the maxim that "everything is about sex, except sex, which is about power." They are both the most sexually prolific characters in the show, and at the same time, the characters least motivated by sex. It's entirely about power for them.
- teekert 10y agoYeah it's cliché but if you call it Evil Corp you kind of imply that that is what it should be. I can appreciate that.
- qwertyuiop924 10y ago
- phantom_oracle 10y agoThe dramatic "typing frantically" is what bothers technical people. Smart coders design elegant solutions that don't require frantic typing (and the same would apply to elegant hack-scripts). Seeing an online gamer crank at WASD is more in-line with "hack faster by typing more".
- wlesieutre 10y ago> The dramatic "typing frantically" is what bothers technical people. Also the "GUI interface in Visual Basic."
- RUG3Y 10y agohaha I remember the reference but I can't remember what show it was from...CSI?
- wlesieutre 10y agoYeah, one of the CSIs, couldn't tell you which. It was to track the killer's IP.
- sirtastic 10y agoI don't know about this. Co-workers and myself can run console commands so quick that for moments at a time (esp with console text scrolling, deploying, etc) it looks like we're hacking. I've heard more than one sales/project manager who's hovering mention it looks like Hollywood hacking. The part that looks like BS in Hollywood hacking to me is the green "matrix" text.
- cr0sh 10y agoI'm anything but fast at my typing, etc. I've never been that way, but I've also experienced the "soul crush" of taking down a production system because I was doing things too fast, not paying attention, and then BAM - bye-bye production DB - so since that time I take a more cautious, think-before-hitting-return attitude (it was the early 90s, I was 18, blah-blah - we eventually got things back to normal, and somehow I kept my job). That said, I once worked with a guy who could type, switch windows, desktops, etc - at what seemed like lightning speed. I mean, when he was at it and "in the groove" - his screen, fingers, etc - were a blur of frantic activity. In some ways, it even reminded me of "hollywood hacking". He was expert at what he did, though - more often than not, his solutions and designs were spot on, and even these "quick fixes" or whatever - would work right first time out the gate.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoMake no mistake though: to the public, we're still wizards. But would you really want it any other way? Let's face it: we will forever be viewed as either wizards, or plumbers.
- neilsimp1 10y agoIronically, I think the majority of people would have a lot of difficulty doing even the simplest plumbing jobs.
- qwertyuiop924 10y ago...but they're still looked down upon. Isn't this analogy great?
- dsacco 10y agoI don't think it's fair that plumbers aren't well-respected as a profession, but you act as though it's inconsistent that people would look down on something they cannot currently do. I'm extremely confident that if you trained me, I would be an exceptionally good plumber. I am extremely unconfident that if you trained me, I would be an exceptionally good neurosurgeon. I'll extend that - I am confident that the majority of adults could be trained to become competent plumbers. I am not at all confident that the majority of adults could be trained to become competent neurosurgeons. Some people react to the reality of vastly different education, patience, effort and talent requirements in job occupations by being condescending. That's not fun for anyone, but it also doesn't make sense to be smug about that reaction as though those people are being condescending towards a skill they fundamentally couldn't learn how to do even with great effort, time and intelligence. They are being condescending towards a skill that is very low in terms of the percentile required to do it competently.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoIt's not inconsistent, or even necessarily wrong. But it is funny.
- ocschwar 10y agoI'm a huge fan of the hacker angle, but I really deplore their use of the Mad Genius trope. In real life, when people are as tormented by schizophrenia and PTSD as Mr. Robot is, their talents are of no use and of no threat to anyone. We're surrounded by such people in every city, and the only threat they pose is to themselves.
- bitwize 10y agoYeah, but a series about the TempleOS guy wouldn't make for such compelling television
- larsiusprime 10y agoI kind of want a TV producer to see this comment and go "challenge accepted."
- cmurf 10y ago[God/OS/user's imagination] has the voice of the MCP in Tron.
- zaphar 10y agoSadly if current reality shows are any indication it probably would make for compelling television. But I wouldn't wish that on the TempleOS author in any fashion.
- RUG3Y 10y agoIf the truth were embellished I bet Terry would make a good basis for an interesting fictional character.
- yarou 10y agoHave you actually seen any of Terry's streams? They're actually quite instructive about topics like OS design. Barring the occasional rants against "CIA ni*".
- 10y ago
- qwertyuiop924 10y ago>Sneakers ridiculously featured a universal key that can break all crypto That's not ridiculous at all: go back and re-watch the film. If the MacGuffin did what the film said it did, it would effectively act as a universal key.
- wslh 10y agoAnd they were assessed by a top cryptographer: Leonard Adleman (the "A" in RSA) https://www.usc.edu/dept/molecular-science/fm-sneakers.htm https://www.usc.edu/dept/molecular-science/fm-sneakers.htm
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoI knew it was one of them. For some reason I thought it was Rivest and not Adleman.
- svachalek 10y agoYeah I was wondering if I remembered it wrong. I thought what they figured out was an efficient algorithm for factoring primes, which is effectively a universal key. AFAIK Shor's algorithm is pretty much just that, and handicapped solely by the lack of a [known] sufficiently-sized quantum computer to run it on.
- logfromblammo 10y agoIt was a combination of an algorithmic improvement and ASIC hardware, to attack and recover encryption keys from vulnerable schemes in minutes, rather than billions of years. The algorithm might have also required a hardware instruction not typically provided by commercially available chips. As a MacGuffin, it is still entirely plausible. But the actual use of any such magic box would never be visually exciting enough for Hollywood. "Ok, so I ssh in to the box, feed it the hash, let it run for 450 hours, and then we get the result and spend Satoshi's Bitcoins into accounts we control." "Does anything blow up?" "No." "Blinky lights at FBI headquarters?" "No." "Car chases?" "No." "Break in to a secured building?" "No." "So who's going to watch this movie?" "How about we just get some laser pointers and some cats while we wait?"
- dsugarman 10y ago“I’ve been in this game 27 years. Not once have I come across an animated singing virus.” Maybe not, but you're damn right I've rickrolled hackers trying to access our servers and steal user data.
- stormbrew 10y agoAlso: http://observer.com/2016/02/this-online-museum-lets-you-download-computer-virus-art-from-the-80s-and-90s/ http://observer.com/2016/02/this-online-museum-lets-you-down...
- the8472 10y agoCryptolocker UIs come close dancing and singing virus. And some keygens (or malware pretending to be a keygen) have pretty whimsical designs with music and animation.
- digi_owl 10y agoC64 cracker intros, anyone? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFqBkSJOYOQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFqBkSJOYOQ
- bitwize 10y agoThe "animated singing virus" was probably Leonardo Da Vinci, which was based on the real-world panic surrounding the "Michelangelo" virus in 1992. Michelangelo displayed on the infected machine's screen a still image of the artist Michelangelo's Sistine Chapel fresco, much like the fictional Leonardo virus displayed a solarized Vitruvian Man. Some viruses of the era (early 90s) did feature animation, such as making the on-screen text slowly disappear or "rain down" the display like the Matrix intro.
- Scuds 10y agoThe Michelangelo virus in 'Hackers' sang "Row-Row-Row Your Boat"
- Tactic 10y ago
- Neliquat 10y agoThis would be true if the average viewer watched Mr Robot. Pretty much only geeks tend to. So just more preaching to the choir. Sure its a step forward, but not a paridigm shift by far.
- seattlefreeze 10y agoMy mother, a "non-geek", actually referred me to the show.
- burkaman 10y agoIt was nominated for six Emmys and won two. I don't know who votes for and watches the Emmys, but I don't think it's geeks.
- minimaxir 10y agoAn interesting example of the change of perception in hacker culture is the difference in the video games Watch Dogs (released 2014) and Watch Dogs 2 (released last month). Watch Dogs 1 features a cyberpunk, grindark Chicago where an unlikeable hacker fights against Big Brother government survellience. Watch Dogs 2 takes place in sunny San Francisco, and features younger hackers having to infiltrate places such as not-Google and not-SpaceX to fight back against corporate data collection (yes, big data is the villain!). The second game also features more real life technologies, companies (not-Google, not-SpaceX) and ripped-from-the-headlines sidequests, including one where the main hacking group leaks a Ubisoft video game trailer... As a whole, the game was much better received. Although, Watch Dogs 2 has Hacker Vision, which lets you see people and objects through walls. The game makes no attempt to justify how that works.
- logfromblammo 10y agoI'd just go with Batman magic from The Dark Knight. Hacked microphones and speakers already on the other side of the wall produce a short range ultrasound sonar image.
- minimaxir 10y agoGranted, both games have magic cellphones that can hack anything with the push of a button, but atleast that makes sense in the game's universe.
- talmand 10y agoMany games from UbiSoft do this. At first each game tried to justify the existence of such an ability, these days they don't even try. In Far Cry 4, if you see them mark them with the camera; if you don't see them, inject a magical leaf drug that marks them. In other games just make your eyeballs glow and you see more than you could possibly know.
- minimaxir 10y agoAssassin's Creed was the first and atleast attempted to justify it in universe. As essentially hereditary magic.
- xrd 10y agoI'm very sad that Swordfish was never mentioned in this article. My developer friends all have a soft spot for the ridiculous world created in that film.
- masondixon 10y agoThis is the absolute worst show. The terminal screenshots seemed more legit than normal though.
- cmdrfred 10y agoWhat killed it for me is the "We have to teach her to hack in 24 hours!" bit. She had to run a script and bounce a network interface. If that's hacking I'm Captain Crunch.
- sushid 10y agoYes! That was possibly the stupidest part. Why teach her how to manually write the commands when she can just run a script? And the whole wiping her fingerprint part was extremely stupid.
- bernardovitch 10y agoGPS to send private emails?
- mixmastamyk 10y agoCan't happen soon enough. I just watched the last season of Arrow on Netflix, and while I like the actress that plays the computer chick I want to punch someone in the face at least once an episode over the absurd lines she has to read.
- minimaxir 10y agoArrow Seasons 3 and 4 are examples where hacking inconsistencies are the least of their problems.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoNot completely false but off-topic.
- bitwize 10y agoHackers killed the Hollywood hacker. (Hackers as in people, not Hackers the film.) Dominic Sena, in his director's commentary for Swordfish, stated that the people who were likely to complain about the inaccuracy of the hacking shown in his movie were nerds who ultimately didn't matter. In this era where the internet response can make or break a film or TV show, the nerds do matter and directors go the extra mile to please them. This started before Mr. Robot. Think Tron: Legacy.
- macspoofing 10y agoIt's not even a nerd thing. I found that I enjoyed technical jargon even when I didn't understand the meaning behind all the words. I doubt every viewer understands everything Big Bang Theory physicists say, but it's still fun! It does seem to enhance the experience plus it has the side benefit of buying good will from the experts in the relevant field.
- smnplk 10y agoI never understood what people find funny in Big bang theory show. Can you still laugh at the jokes if there is no laugh track https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AY0Zkthn8Og https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AY0Zkthn8Og ? :) I like IT crowd much better.
- beedogs 10y agoAgreed. BBT is a terrible show with mostly cringe-worthy humour.
- veridies 10y agoFirst of all, while BBT may sweeten the track, it is still filmed in front of an audience; people really do laugh at the jokes. It doesn't work at all in part because the actors pause to let the laughter subside, and if you watch without that, it just feels bizarre. Second of all, the show's humor isn't entirely verbal. The overbroad stereotypes and exaggerated reactions are part of a joke, and a lot of that requires a familiarity with (and appreciation of) both the specific characters and the archetypes they're playing on. Of course some people just won't find the show funny, and that's fine. But a lot of very experienced, talented people put a lot of work into that show; it would be unfortunate to dismiss it entirely. (And for the record, I personally don't find the show funny in the least bit.)
- drawnwren 10y agoI'd argue that Mr. Robot just perpetuates the Hollywood Hacker stereotype. Sure, the logistics of hacking have moved closer to the truth, but it was unable to escape the moralistic 'greater good' story arc of most hacker movies. It seems like, given the distribution of breakins and news articles about discovered hacks, there are very few morally motivated hackers and when those hackers do surface - their hacks take the form of much broader less targeted attacks than those of the show. i.e. It's a lot more of grab Xtb of data and then find the weak passwords than everyone has weak passwords.
- drvdevd 10y agoYes. The story arc matters more than technical detail. And the moral tropes are boring. I've come to realize that I actually care less about the technical inaccuracies than I do about a good plot. I don't expect the general public to know a lot about hacking, and I don't care that much. Sometimes it can contribute to the plot (e.g.: prison SCADA systems being easy to break), but often it isn't that important, if it's not too ham-handed. I care more about a good story. So yeah, the story arc matters, the dialogue matters (the conversations, the attitudes of the characters) -- all the basic elements of a good film/tv show/movie matter first. Which is why I stopped watching Mr. Robot at the beginning of season 2. I just didn't care about the characters or story any more. Maybe it gets better? Personally, if you're looking for a good story, involving technology and morality, I can't recommend West World enough. There's some "hacking" involved and the show over all is genius. Just my $.02. [edit] I'll add that the article does bring up the point of the societal harms technically "dumb" plots can cause -- making computing/hacking seem like magic for example. This is an interesting point, but I still think this is less important than a good plot. The potential social benefits of good writing outweigh everything else, if you ask me.
- slg 10y agoI am surprised you found something in the characters and development arcs of Westworld that you didn't see in Mr. Robot. Westworld is almost entirely plot based with little care or regard for character motivations or development while Mr. Robot spends a lot more time on that type of thing.
- strictnein 10y agoThe new Bourne movie didn't get the message, unfortunately. Some of the worst hacking nonsense ever.
- amag 10y agoOT, but WOW! What a tedious movie! By making everything instant (because people will get bored if there's ever a change of pace?) they manage to make it super-boring. The thing that made the previous Bourne movies appealing was that there were some slow moments between the action.
- strictnein 10y ago"We've found a phone in the room Bourne is in! Hack it and then hack the laptop next to it!" > typey type type typey type click type "Done." edit: typo
- mikeevans 10y ago>"Use SQL to corrupt the databases" Groan.
- mdc2161 10y ago> Use SQL to corrupt their databases! Use alphabet to write this comment!
- mhomde 10y agoLegendary hacker Hacky McHacky typed swiftly on the IBM M Model keyboard with the fingers attached to his hands. He hated laptop keyboards, they made his eyes flash like thumbdrives. The Model M is a designation for a group of computer keyboards manufactured by IBM starting in 1984, and later by Lexmark, Unicomp and MaxiSwitch. The keyboard's many variations have their own distinct characteristics, with the vast majority having a buckling-spring key design and swappable keycaps. Hacky's nostalgic reverie about IBM keyboards was suddenly interrupted when a voice spoke, chillingly close, coming from the other side of the server hall. "Drop that keyboard McHacky" it said menacingly.
- dghughes 10y agoI'm not a fan of the character's narrative ramblings it seems conspiracy theories and paranoid rants are far too common these days. Suspension of disbelief is one thing but when characters who are experts have to explain to each other what they should already know to me a real groaner in TV and movies. One character on Mr. Robot at the security company didn't know what a rootkit was, really?
- pswilson14 10y agoHe did, but the audience doesn't. Every show and movie that deals with this kind of stuff does it.
- icebraining 10y agoI think that's the point. It stands out and harms the suspension of disbelief. Maybe we should bring the intertitles back.
- celticninja 10y agoIt's a large security company, filled with middle managers, I find that entirely plausible. I'm a junior developer in a large organisation and some of the PMs that I work under don't understand the tech we use.
- btreesOfSpring 10y agoYou're comment reminds me of that Anomaly comic about the manger and the pie chart[0]. [0] http://img-9gag-fun.9cache.com/photo/277232_700b.jpg http://img-9gag-fun.9cache.com/photo/277232_700b.jpg
- komali2 10y agoIt's exposition. It kind of sucks because we'd like to suspend our disbelief and pretend we're entering a "real" world when we watch a movie, but movies and books are doing more than just "showing scenes from the life of ___," they're telling a story to an audience. An audience needs to be told sometimes what a rootkit is, or that this character has a history of x or y, because the audience didn't grow up with the characters and experience all their shared experiences, or sit in university with them and learn rootkits alongside them.
- mhd 10y agoI've just binged through the faux-bitcoin series "Startup", and didn't see a lot of progress there. Random computers (including a PowerMac G4), keyboard mashing, bad & dark visuals, assuming that everyone in IT is also a "hacker" and the usual bad jargon ("He's using bots! They're in the wifi!") and awkward mistakes (main character has "proficient in Linus" on her CV).
- samstave 10y agolink to series please?
- quicklyfrozen 10y agoPerhaps it's this one: http://www.crackle.com/startup http://www.crackle.com/startup
- florinutz 10y agoyes hello
- shmerl 10y ago"Hollywood hackers" differ. Cyberpunk genre can be quite good, so I don't think it needs "killing" necessarily or even can be killed. It's not that creators don't know about real hacking. Some may be don't, but others can be quite aware of it. But as in various science fiction genres, things don't necessarily always correspond to real ones.
- grumblestumble 10y agoWhatever gains Mr. Robot made in "killing" (i'd say updating, but anyway) the Hollywood "hacker" trope, they lost twice over with their shoddy portrayal of mental illness.
- user5994461 10y agoPlease. The guy depicted in the movie has nothing from a Hacker. He's just a dude suffering from schizophrenia. Hackers, for starters, are playing in the autism-asperger spectrum. They're utterly opposite and incompatible psychological traits.
- dsacco 10y agoNot only are you generalizing about an entire hobby/profession and its overlap with a particular mental disorder, you didn't even diagnose the main character of Mr. Robot correctly. He has dissociative identity disorder, not schizophrenia. The two are similar in some respects but vastly different for the most part.
- elorant 10y agoThe real problem with Mr. Robot is how it's perceived by noobs who think that using SQLMap or whatnot would give them the ability to hack into any site in a jiffie. Popularizing specialized themes is a double edged case. At one hand it makes the general public understand our work and also the dangers modern technology carries. From the other hand it makes hacking seem cool and easy which is far from true.
- RUG3Y 10y agoI like the social engineering aspect. In that regard, the show is interesting. They make hacking much more about human security than software and hardware. And when you think about things that way, the world is a scary place.
- spydum 10y agoNot sure what you get exposed to on a daily basis, but this is pretty much factual. The amount of SQL injection is astounding.
- anigbrowl 10y agoWhen hackers hack in Mr. Robot, they talk about it in ways that actual hackers talk about hacking. Mr Robot exists as it does because there are now enough people familiar with computers and the relevant concepts to constitute an audience, rather than due to any sudden insight on the part of screenwriters (of which I am one). We know, and have always known, that there's a distinct hacker subculture with its own linguistic tropes, ethos, etc. etc. and that there's been a big gap between reality and how it's portrayed in movies. We also know (or learn the hard way) that there's a big gap between including enough detail for verisimilitude that will satisfy people who are competent in a particular field, and what the general public wants to watch - which is why you'll continue to see shallow or outright stupid portrayals of hacking in the entertainment industry's output. Why? Primarily [1] because the mass of people are just not interested in any given field that requires nerd-level commitment to understand. The larger the budget required for the film, the larger and more general the audience has to be, and the more accuracy and authenticity will be sacrificed in favor of spectacle and symbolism, which is the most reliable method for getting people to fork over their money in the first place. Take a recent example from a different context - Jurassic World. The 'plot': capitalists and scientists employ DNA technology to produce a bigger, smarter, more aggressive dinosaur than has ever existed in nature; said dinosaur escapes from confinement and menaces everyone in the vicinity, especially the attractive hero, anti-heroine, and small children that are introduced early in the story. It's basically Frankenstein only with dinosaurs. Spoiler alert, the attractive proxy for the family unit survives and the bad dinosaur is defeated, though not before killing off the most ethically deficient characters by eating them like ham sandwiches. Now, any biologists worth their salt would cringe at many scenes (if they watch such nonsense at all). Any genetic scientists had to suffer through yet another scene of an annoying smartass mumbling a few meaningless phrases about 'advanced gene splicing' while screens in the background display animations of double helixes and molecules. I think they might have mentioned CRISPR, I'm not sure and have no intention of watching it again to check. Would Jurassic World have been better if it was more like Primer or Mr Robot, with in-depth discussions of structural factors and real-world constraints, and a hard-science approach that admitted of 1 (one) speculative assumption, from which the rest of the plot flowed organically? Sure,,,if you wanted to make Gattaca - Herpetology Edition. But though gattaca is one of my all-time favorite sci-fi films, neither it nor Primer will ever appeal to a mass audience and so films like that will never have the most recognizable actors or the most astonishing visual spectacles or the same sort of short-term existential anxieties that would result from having to run or your life from a creature the size of an apartment building. People go to Big Movies to allay their quotidian existential anxieties (about which they often feel helpless) by seeing them safely reflected [2] in contexts that are outside normal human experience. How far outside is primarily inversely proportional to the budget and corresponding box-office performance requirements, while being secondarily proportional to the depth of the underlying existential anxiety. Hacking in films has simply been a proxy for magic, in line with Clarke's observation that any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic. Magic serves an important dramatic function as the source of the unknowable solution to the Intractable Problem with which the story's characters are presented.Thus, magic and its various proxies (specialist bodies of knowledge, from hacking to legal procedure to medical knowledge) is not a black hole which encapsulates the ignorance of the writer (although many inferior or lazy writers abuse it for that purpose) but a singularity which offers the possibility of escape from the otherwise-inexorable logic of the story world; it symbolizes the hope of a future discoverable solution to an otherwise insoluble problem. A few examples from popular films may illuminate this. In Star Wars the insoluble problem is a spaceship that can blow up an entire planet. The magical device is The Force, a limited but still useful psychokinetic ability. In the Alien films the insoluble problem is an ambulatory disease; the magic device is an artificially intelligent android that can approach the alien closely enough to observe a weakness of some kind (but which has to be temporarily decommissioned first, like Dumbo losing the magic feather). In the Terminator films, the insoluble problem is nuclear conflagration as the crystallization of war in general; the magical device is industrial capitalism's promise of reducing economic inequality (represented by the vast technological superiority of the Terminators themselves). To wrap up, Mr Robot hasn't killed the Hollywood hacker at all; it has just crushed his dreams and forced him into getting a day job, which is the function that television shows perform relative to movies. You'll still see hackers in movies, but strictly as lip service to a real and increasingly less aspirational employment demographic. This might seem like an odd conclusion to draw, but it's worth bearing in mind that that serial television dramas are general occupational comedies (I'm using the term 'comedy' in the technical sense of everything basically going back to normal at the end of the episode, even if the subject matter isn't funny at all). Consider cop shows; they follow a nice steady formula with an initial outrage, a bit of detective work, an uncomfortable moral confrontation, a setback, and finally a little bit of legal procedure. On the other hand if you watch a movie about cops, they almost invariably take place at the beginnings or ends of the lead characters' careers, and the Best Person in the movie almost invariably has to die. 1. there are other reasons but I don't want to turn this into an essay on screenwriting. 2. A few films address this dichotomy as their subject matter, albeit indirectly. All films have a political dimension insofar as the choice of subject matter and its portrayal reflect some aspect of their originating policy which the creators aim to praise or criticize, but relatively few dramatize the critical process itself; invariably, the subtext of such films is that critical awareness forces us to choose sides in an ongoing moral conflict; or put another way, moral agency comes at the price of other kinds. Generally in these films the lead has to either die or give up the old life completely in an anti-hero pattern.
- jrnichols 10y agoAdult Me, who has not seen the show yet, is hoping that it's as awesome as Max Headroom was to Kid Me. As a younger human, I greatly enjoyed the hacking/computer stuff scenes in that show. It was one of the things that made me more curious about tinkering with things.
- biztos 10y agoHaving seen much but not all of it, I think it's top-notch TV drama with excellent writing and acting both. But I think the computers, however well realized, are just the backdrop. It's really about questions of identity, morality, and sanity. Much of the hacking is hacking the self, often through drugs and/or psychological manipulation.
- wityak 10y agoMaybe, but they're still squeezing every ounce of the hoodie-wearing hacker trope.
- solidr53 10y ago/r/itsaunixsystem
- scandox 10y agoMaybe I'm missing something but one of the core technical conceits driving the first few episodes is that an IP address found inside a "dat" file is compelling evidence that the person with that IP address was guilty of something. Of having an IP address that somebody typed into a file? I didn't get that. As I say perhaps I misunderstood. I actually believe it would be possible to build a coherent and effective story around technical ideas but it would require a writer of great skill, who just happened to have a very technical background. The way it would work is that the plot would be driven by a technical obstacle/issue. Instead of focusing on the details of the technical issue, the key would be to elucidate the conceptual background to it. Obviously, this has to be done in a way that respects character and which eschews heavy-handed exposition. Which is hard. It would have to be a much slower burn in terms of action. I think you'd have a single hack maybe taking an entire season :) I think though this approach has been successfully used in Film and TV when representing politics. They manage to show how big issues break down into specific pragmatic issues and then how those pragmatic issues in turn feedback.
- 0xcde4c3db 10y ago> Maybe I'm missing something but one of the core technical conceits driving the first few episodes is that an IP address found inside a "dat" file is compelling evidence that the person with that IP address was guilty of something. Of having an IP address that somebody typed into a file? I didn't get that. As I say perhaps I misunderstood. It's been a while, but as I understood it, the "dat file" was (ostensibly) part of a professional forensic dump of a filesystem on a compromised server, and the IP was buried somewhere in the malware itself as the address from which commands were accepted.
- Renevith 10y agoDisappointed that nobody has mentioned Blackhat yet. Although it was a terrible movie overall, the computer hacking parts were astoundingly accurate. When the character needs to elude a police escort that can track his ankle bracelet with their smartphone, he tricks them into letting him have the phone for a sec and surreptitiously drops the update frequency in the tracking app to 24 hours. When he needs to hack into the NSA, he uses insider knowledge of an employee's name/email and their boss's name/email to write a plausible spearphishing email with a 0-day PDF attachment. I think there is also some good command-line activity on screen, though it's been long enough that I don't remember.
- mhomde 10y agoLuckily they listened to Kevin Poulsen that was technical adviser :) It's very unfortunate that the movie was otherwise so poor. Michael Mann is one of my long time favorites. A hacking movie with the mood and grittyness he's famous for could and should have been awesome. Not sure exactly where they were wrong, I think I found bot the plot uninsteresting as well as the characters. Also Hollywood tendency of casting jocks and models as hackers :/
- Renevith 10y agoYeah, I also struggled to figure out how it went wrong. Mann of course is a strong director, and the actors are (otherwise) quite good as well. Try Hemsworth in Rush, or Wei Tang in Lust, Caution if you want to see either of them really shine. Though as you mentioned they weren't quite cast to type. And in Wei's case acting in a second language probably doesn't help. Still the whole thing really underperformed.
- tomelders 10y agoIf I ever directed a movie with a hacking scnene, it would be half an hournof someone just staring a a screen before copy pasting something from stack overflow.
- maxt 10y agoThis is as glamorous as it gets I think. Throw in repeated yelling at the screen and many WTF moments and we have hacking to a tee
- herbst 10y agoI agree that Mr Robot was above standard. But already in the first episode in the first few minutes he talks bullshit about Tor :/
- up_so_floating 10y agoI couldn't get past the second episode, or whenever the lead character met the idiosyncratic band of misfit hackers. These individuals seemed extremely cliche and unlike any hackers I have ever met in real life. The terminal input might have been valid, but the people doing the typing seemed out of place.
- thewhitetulip 10y agoI am seeing a series of changes in our world that I am happy about, this is one such change. The establishment is getting challenged and in a good constructive way.
- yolololol 10y agoman, so useless. Of course we've seen the difference between "hackers" in Holliwood movies and Mr.Robot, thats precisely why this TV serie worked in the first place. Of course future movies will have to up their acting if they want to compare, WTF. Next article "usb 2.0 killed usb 1.0"?
- maxt 10y agoThere's an interesting article on how the movie Wargames[1] influenced the public consciousness surrounding hacking. Another movie similar to Mr Robot is Algorithm which I'm surprised nobody has mentioned: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6qpudAhYhpc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6qpudAhYhpc [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/21/movies/wargames-and-cybersecuritys-debt-to-a-hollywood-hack.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/21/movies/wargames-and-cybers... What annoyed me about Mr Robot is the stereotype / trope of a hoodied punk teen wielding their talent with a computer which has been done to death already in other movies (I class Mr Robot as an extended movie with episodes). Hackers can be anybody infact, and it doesn't help that the hoodied punk stereotype is perpetuated. Think Stallman, Zimmermann, & Eric Raymond, not Zero Cool or Neo.
- digi_owl 10y agoI wrote Mr. Robot off the moment i watched the first preview. Psycologically troubled, hooded protagonist that blackmails a guy about a pedo exchange running out of the back room of a restaurant. No matter how accurate the computing may be, that just got too ham fisted for my tastes. As for Hackers the movie, i wonder if one best treat it similar to Streets of Fire[1]. a fable that happens to be set to New York. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streets_of_Fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streets_of_Fire