54 ms·
Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him
- gamechangr 10y agoFlag - duplicate - you may want to delete this. There are about 10 threads on this in the last two hours. Some have 300 comments. Take a look - one #28 is still on the front page now with almost 500 comments.
- iaw 10y agoThere's a vocal contingent of alt-right Donald Trump supporters that think this is a big deal.
- legodt 10y agoIn the future, please wind down the usage of soft euphemisms like "alt right" and instead refer to the group by its proper name- neo-nazis.
- MustardTiger 10y agoDon't go lumping us in with the alt-right. We're not even right wing.
- dracht 10y agoCan we start referring to social justice warriors/feminists as Marxists too, or should we only vilify groups you don't agree with?
- andybak 10y agoIs 'Marxist' simply a term of abuse now? When I did Sociology is was perfectly respectable school of thought that was studied and discussed.
- vidarh 10y agoIf applied to social justice warriors or feminists who actually are Marxists, then sure. Personally I don't think you'll find nearly many Marxists there as you'll find self-processed nazis amongst the "alt-right".
- Programmatic 10y agoIn a venn diagram of neo-nazi's and alt-right, I'm sure there would be plenty of overlap, if not neo-nazi's being a subset of the alt-right. But to categorize the entirety of alt-right as neo-nazis is itself not useful, as you can then not have a conversation about the actual viewpoints of the alt-right. I'm really disappointed in the quality of the discourse on both sides this election cycle. Straw men abound.
- legodt 10y agoWhat? The alt right us built os racism, misogyny, and white nationalism. This isn't some sweeping generalization like "all Trump voters are Nazis" or something like that, the alt right is built on fascist, neo-nazi ideals.
- Programmatic 10y agoI'll admit that I was apparently ignorant on the topic and had a misunderstanding of the ideals of the alt-right. After reading for a while, I have come to a similar conclusion given the idea(l)s of NPI, Spencer, and so on. As with anything label-related, it's hard to determine who wears what label for what reasons and what elements of the label are made up by outsiders attempting to discredit the wearers of the label. But it is currently difficult to come to a conclusion other than yours given the facts I've been able to find. As a small aside, I still hold a small amount of hope given the history of inaccuracy in the media's portrayals of 4chan. Hopefully this is similarly overblown and hysterical...
- gamechangr 10y agoI think it's a big deal and I wouldn't be in the "alt-right" for sure. Having a CEO of a social media site impersonate users and censor comments calls into question the credibility of the their whole brand. That's not a partisan perspective??? How would you feel if Paul Graham of HN changed your comment to "I am strong supporter of the alt-right?" ...you wouldn't like that. Opposing opinions are fine - using admin priledges to put words to literally put words in users mouths is madness? I already made a comment elsewhere - but I'm surprised they haven't let him go. If reddit were a real company, they wouldn't tolerate that. I wonder what would happen if a middle manager started tampering with user comments - he would be gone.
- vidarh 10y agoAs someone firmly left wing (by European standards), I agree. It may very well be that there are "alt-right" people blowing it out of proportion, but that doesn't mean it's not a big deal.
- celticninja 10y agoIt's not a big deal because it's reddit, a semi anonymous Internet board. It's not like he was editing legal statements.
- zamalek 10y ago> It's not like he was editing legal statements. That is not the case.[1] [1]: http://thehill.com/policy/national-security/296680-house-panel-probes-web-rumor-on-clinton-emails http://thehill.com/policy/national-security/296680-house-pan...
- vidarh 10y agoIt's a big deal because he was making it seem like users had made statements they haven't made. Maybe these specific instances doesn't matter so much, but the fact he did it, and did it without leaving a visible sign it was edited creates an issue of trust. We now feel less safe that Reddit admins haven't done this in the past too, in cases where it matters more.
- fit2rule 10y agoIts definitely a big deal. Censorship of this issue is seriously bad news: Either we expose the pedophile rings in our governments, or we are subject to their will - and abuse of power - at every point. So, yeah. This is a huge breach of trust, and I hope that this story gets out there so that people can be informed while deciding whether to contribute to the reddit empire.
- crimsonalucard 10y agoIt is a big deal, but it's not like it's anything new in modern society. Graphic images of war have been censored since Vietnam. So in other words, the mainstream media has been doing it for decades, how is reddit suppose to be better then the media?
- gamechangr 10y agoIt wasn't just "censored". He used his admin privileges to CHANGE users comments. Like if you made your last statement and then Paul Graham changed it to read "It's a huge deal, it's never happened before"...so that became YOUR USER COMMENT
- celticninja 10y agoIt's reddit for fucks sake, he didn't change a legal record. You are giving reddit comments too much credit for being a source of information.
- ManlyBread 10y agoCan you give me access to your account so I can change what you wrote to whatever I like? It's just a HN comment after all, not a legal record.
- visarga 10y agoForums censor their comments as a standard practice against trolling. But on the other hand, reddit is fully open and such attempts are easily found out by comparing older version to current version. So, people were saying "fuck /u/spez" (CEO's username), and he edited that.
- smokeyj 10y agoI haven't seen this.. It definitely changes how I look at Reddit.
- verroq 10y agoNo that one's disappeared. This is the only thread left.
- nostrademons 10y agoIt's at the top of page 2. The heated discussion triggered the flamewar detector, which kicks in when an article generates a lot of comments in a short period of time.
- RyanZAG 10y agoThere doesn't seem to be any flamewar though, looks like decent discussion. Should the flamewar detector not be turned off when no flamewar is present?
- duncanawoods 10y agoYeah, I think its a bit of sly trick from HN admins - they get to plausibly deny suppressing hot button topics because their intervention is to white-list discussion instead of having to be up front and make the tough decision to black-list them. When a negative story about YC emerges and generates a lot of comments so it gets pushed off the front-page and they just say "shame but its just automatic flamewar detector, <shrug>". I'm sure they think they are clever but it just erodes trust over the long term.
- RyanZAG 10y agoAh right, that makes a lot of sense. I was probably just being naive there. Probably best to discuss YC related topics on different forums.
- sctb 10y agoThe reason we didn't turn off the flamewar detector, and how that relates to moderation of YC-related stories, is explained here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13027515 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13027515 and further here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13028145 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13028145. Trust me, there's no room for feeling clever in this job.
- dragontamer 10y agoAs a moderator to one forum, I commonly edit the poster's posts if they are especially rowdy or otherwise rude to everybody else. But its not a "prank", like what the Reddit CEO did. I make sure everybody knows that I made the edit (signing my name on the edit, using the poster's privileges), just as a warning that yes... as moderator I do have complete control over the conversation. Its a threat that I make to keep rowdy members in check. But it only works because everyone trusts me (ie: I never "impersonate" the poster, no one ever "impersonates" my edits either). I know that if I "cross the line", then people will no longer trust me as the moderator of discussion. The position of moderator is to serve the forum, not to dictate the direction of every conversation. The issue here is that Reddit's CEO is in charge of a community, and that community is losing faith in the leader because of his abuse of his power. ------------ From one perspective, I understand that moderators have surprisingly few options. Mods can delete posts, and maybe edit them (if they're careful and only edit in extreme circumstances). But... that's about it. Otherwise, there's not really much power mods have. Banning doesn't really work. Everybody knows how to proxy up and reregister accounts to rejoin a forum. Warnings don't really count, a lot of posters don't care about them. The threat of an edit war however? Well... that's basically the moderator's best tool. But it needs to be more carefully used than what the Reddit CEO did here.
- wheelerwj 10y agoNo, there are a dozen issues with this but losing Faith in reddit's leadership isn't one of them. That happened a long time ago.
- dragontamer 10y agoIf you already don't trust Reddit, then there's nothing lost by this event.
- yuhong 10y agoStackExchange has a good system for doing things like this.
- greenyoda 10y agoHere's the original discussion (currently 477 points, 444 comments): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13027031 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13027031
- vowelless 10y agoFlagged off the front page. ..
- Figs 10y agoActually, it was the anti-flamewar filter that pushed it off, as dang explained later in the thread.
- johansch 10y ago"It set off the overheated discussion detector (a.k.a. flamewar detector), which lowers the rank of a thread. We do turn that penalty off for particularly substantive discussions—which, though this may surprise you, I'm not sure this one is. Not every Reddit drama shitshow is uniform in its excellence." "Edit: ok, we've reduced the penalty" Apparently not enough to get it visible to the front page again, though.
- dang 10y agoOf course it was. The story was on the front page for over 5 hours, including 4 hours after we reduced the penalty. No moderator has touched it since. HN's software causes stories to fall off the front page after a while. If you didn't happen to see a story while it was there, that doesn't make it "apparently" suppressed.
- johansch 10y agoWhy "of course"? Did you set it specifically so that it would be on the FP? It certainly wasn't within an hour of you writing that comment. (I'm in Europe, so I was checking the frontpage many times while you guys were asleep.) Eventually it did make it, that was quite a lot of hours later, and it only lasted for a handful of hours. Edit: it strikes me now that there is a need for an hourly HN frontpage archive. Does this exist?
- edblarney 10y agoIf he did this without indicating that he did so, then I'd argue that this is a very deep breach of trust, irrespective of the nature of the comments. He could have deleted them, or flagged some 'bad words' and indicated so. This is an issue of integrity, so it's one of those 'fireable offences' type things. I have no idea who this guy is, and certainly, many 'big corp' CEO's get away with much worse ... but it's definitely a problem. Anyhow. Not good.
- bambax 10y ago> much works Much worse?
- naner 10y agoPretty dumb move, he may end up resigning over this. Also there's no reason a CEO should have this level of access.
- edblarney 10y agoIt's odd because Reddit is basically about 'voices' so this is in a way a 'core issue'. That said - it's 'by young people for young people' - and the CEO is pretty young it seems. If I were the board - I'd cut the kid some slack, make him apologize, put some process/measures in place, 'be better' and move on. My hunch is the guy was just emotional about it, and had a lapse of judgement. People make mistakes. If this were a bank, or a 'real' news site, or if the guy had serious issues with reality, I'd sack him, but for this ... no. Learning lesson. Oddly - if it were their last CEO - that ex-VC ... I'd probably sack her, she should have known better ... she's super educated, been on a lot of boards, a lot of exposure to companies, CEO's, a lot more experience/maturity, I'd kind of expect a much higher standard. Then again, I'm being totally speculative about all of this.
- sooheon 10y agoHe's in his 30s, it's a bit disingenuous to call him 'kid'. Being young has nothing to do with this lapse of judgement.
- Theizestooke 10y agoIf this means the alt-right leaves, great.
- sergiotapia 10y agoHigh-level moderators openly discussing being paid by CTR (Correct The Record - a Hillary Clinton organization): https://i.sli.mg/eZXD0R.png https://i.sli.mg/eZXD0R.png This is really funny, the undoing of Reddit - and for what?
- naner 10y agoAm I missing something obvious? The comment in the red box looks like sarcasm.
- cr1895 10y agoNo, it's painfully, obviously sarcasm.
- sanswork 10y agoYou do realise that comment is making fun of people like yourself right? When people call you a shill all day your humour tend to include jokes about being a shill to mess with the idiots calling everyone that disagrees with them a shill.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- scrollaway 10y agoYou've been on HN for nearly 5 years and commented enough to gather over 8000 karma, yet you can't detect such blatant sarcasm? How?
- sergiotapia 10y agoNot sarcasm buddy: https://i.sli.mg/ntY8HY.png https://i.sli.mg/ntY8HY.png
- scrollaway 10y agoYou are unbelievable. Get out of your bubble would you? "They paid foreigners because they didn't believe Americans deserved jobs." You would have to believe some serious conspiracy theory crap to not read that as sarcasm.
- zyb09 10y agoSo this was about the banning of PizzaGate subreddit, and its understandable that a Reddit-Mob can be a scary thing, and needs to be dealt with somehow. But it feels Reddits moderation practices have become increasingly shady over the last couple years, and spez editing comments directly just shows how seemingly lax they are with their powers. You don't really have to be a conspiracy nut to see that places like /r/politics during the election had some very questionable moderation.
- ManlyBread 10y ago/r/worldnews is even worse, they outright censor everything that is not in line with the political affiliations of the moderators.
- debt 10y agoReddit has been on my shitlist since the Ellen pao situation. How anyone uses that site after how the Reddit community treated her is beyond me.
- Axsuul 10y agoThe politics of Reddit don't really touch most subreddits. Most people are there to talk about their interests and passions.
- vesche 10y ago(read: porn)
- Chris2048 10y agoWhat about how Ellen Pao treated Reddit? She threw the first punch.
- tnones 10y agoAre you sure you know what happened? Because all I saw was Pao being lauded as a hero for standing up to supposed misogyny, when the community was upset about how they fired a female community coordinator on top of bringing in other harsh censorship tools like quarantining. It was classic fact-free "women in tech" non-sense. Equality means if you mess up at the top, you take responsibility. What women-in-tech advocates want is all the prestige with none of the flak.
- stefantalpalaru 10y ago> the Ellen pao situation You forgot this part, haven't you? http://nypost.com/2015/03/18/users-lash-out-at-reddit-boss-for-deleting-posts-on-hubbys-lawsuit/ http://nypost.com/2015/03/18/users-lash-out-at-reddit-boss-f...
- EJTH 10y agoEh. Not exactly the personality fit for running a comminity site such as reddit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uSVqoW1rz6w&feature=youtu.be&t=835 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uSVqoW1rz6w&feature=youtu.be... Pretty obnoxious person to be honest.
- rounce 10y agoRight at home then, eh?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vvdcect 10y agoA little bit of backstory from r/outoftheloop on this issue : To explain what's happened to anyone not wanting to dig through the threads, Spez, the CEO of Reddit, has admitted to editing some comments on The_Donald. Specifically, he changed mentions of his name in insults to the usernames of The_Donald moderators. According to his comment, he did this for about an hour before stopping. His comment states that he was very stressed over dealing with the removal of r/pizzagate and being called a pedophile for it, resulting in him going out of line and making edits to comments. He also says that he won't do it again, and that the community management team is angry with him. The Reddit admins have had a strained relationship with the moderators and users of The_Donald, for multiple reasons. For a lot of users there, this validates some beliefs about the admin's treatment towards them, specifically that they make an active effort to censor their content. Other users on the site feel like this sets a dangerous precedent, as it demonstrates the admins can and have edited comments without disclosure. Further users feel like, while Spez made a mistake, he was unfairly treated and harassed by TheDonald and his response was an understandable outburst. Now, people around the site are wondering what the repercussions of this will be. Some question if Spez will be removed from his position over this. Some wonder if the admins will come forward and admit they've edited comments in the past. Others wonder if a significant population from The_Donald will migrate to Voat, a Reddit alternative.
- Fluid_Mechanics 10y agoI genuinely don't understand why that subreddit hasn't been suspended.
- CmdrSprinkles 10y agoThe same reason youtube and twitch (and youtubers and streamers) seem to have so much difficulty with moderating chat Yes, getting rid of the hate and the stupid is something the owners of the site (and the content creators) want. It gives them a horrible reputation (and can impact business, as Twitter discovered). But that is still their userbase, and getting rid of the userbase drastically decreases their value. So it is a balancing act. And the trump subreddit would be a disaster to remove as everyone would REALLY get on them for being "too political"
- Jerry2 10y agoOne of the reddit employees/admins leaked Slack conversations... it's all over Twitter now. https://twitter.com/Cernovich/status/801680245631766528 https://twitter.com/Cernovich/status/801680245631766528
- mhomde 10y agoAww, that sucks :( Huffman always seemed like a measured and fair individual. I appreciated the way he communicated with the community when he took back the reins. The act itself seems petty, the larger issue is the breach of perceived trust ... The_Donald finally made the frog boil over. Don't wrestle with pigs, they like it and you get dirty. I do however have a hard time seeing a better replacement for spez so I hope him and reddit learned a lesson and put some measures in place to ensure this doesn't happen again. Everyone is allowed one major fuck up in my book as long as it isn't systemic, they admit it, and don't repeat it. This seems to be another sign of reddit isn't quite mature enough both when it comes to leadership and technology to handle the scale of popularity they've grown to. They have all my respect but the league they're operating in provides a new set of unique challenges. From a technical standpoint, it would be interesting if posts and comments could be signed so tampering wasn't possible and prevent even the temptation of doing so. Hard nut to crack in a user-friendly way though when everything is server-side.
- SticksAndBreaks 10y agoIntroducing- the Insult Blockchain- so in 10.000 Generations your ancestors know you called that guy a maggot
- chaostheory 10y agoI'm not on any side. I'm just a bystander. See this and other incidents reminds of the time users got fed up with Digg and left for reddit. We'll see what happens with Voat in the coming months.
- novia 10y agoFrom what I've seen, voat is already an alt-right haven.
- 650REDHAIR 10y agoVoat is an awful place where fatpeoplehate, 4chan, and the racist-Right have set up camp. No thanks.
- theWatcher37 10y agoOnly because they were the first to get purged. Any substantial migration from Reddit would drown out those voices pretty quick. Just look at their vote counts compared to practically any medium sized subreddit
- CmdrSprinkles 10y agoSomewhat off topic and not condoning the editing of comments (I probably will condone the closing of boards once I know more) but: What the hell is a pizzagate? I saw it mentioned a few times while reading the mess that is the reddit detectiving for Assange but never saw a clear description. And now it is apparently a pro-Trump thing too? What was the logic behind calling him a pedophile for that?
- jonathankoren 10y agoPizzagate is about Hillary Clinton and John Podesta running a pedophile ring out of a Washington DC pizza parlor. Yup. No word on if John Podesta is also conducting satanic ceremonies as well. Seriously. I can't even say that without snickering. Makes you miss the days when Hillary Clinton was just decorating the White House Christmas Tree with crack pipes doesn't it?[0] [0] http://libertynews.com/2015/06/flashback-flotus-hillarys-x-rated-white-house-christmas-tree/ http://libertynews.com/2015/06/flashback-flotus-hillarys-x-r...
- suby 10y agoThe thing about the satanic ritial claim is that it makes sense if you view it as a method of discrediting the victim / story. If someone is molested and the perpetrators also conduct a whacky satanic ritual during the act, the victim is going to have a hell of a hard time being believed if they come forth. Hell, we see it in this thread with people dismissing the whole thing based on that alone. Don't get me wrong, I think the evidence for it is a stretch, but there is some objectively weird stuff in the emails that do not make sense if taken literally.
- toss1941 10y agoPerfectly reasonable view of things if you ask me. I remember watching this thing spawn in real time during the release of Podesta's emails. There were 4 things IMHO that made this into a big deal for the_donald: 1) #SpiritCooking, 2) the "Pizza Related Map", 3) Bill Clinton's alleged trips to "pedo island without the secret service", and 4) Some have interpreted Joe Biden's interaction with children as creepy. Then, people started looking at old emails in a whole new light and realized there appeared to be coded messages involving children in them. That's kind of where I stopped tracking personally because the signal to noise ratio is pretty low.
- Lazare 10y agoWhat an amazing multi-level clusterfuck. You either need to ban /r/TheDonald, or just accept it for what it is, hold your nose, and walk away. I believe that I'd choose the former, but if I had the power to do so I might feel differently. But this is the worst possible thing. It makes Spez look horrible, it undermines trust in the site and the admins, it confirms all the nutty things the alt-right believes about Reddit, etc. It makes actually dealing with any of the underlying issues much harder; anything that the admins do which is or might look anti-The_Donald can now be spun as "another example of their bias". And since we've already got such a glaring example of that bias, the claim is now plausible in a way it wasn't before. Should have just quietly banned the sub and moved on. Or not banned it and ignored it. Anything but this.
- taurath 10y agoThis is psychological gamesmanship. I punch you, you punch back, I win. I punch you, you don't punch back, I win. The only way for me to lose is if you punch back with such force that I can't punch again. Open and inclusive only works when there is an underlying good will or mutual benefit.
- jpgvm 10y agoThe sad part is he could have punched hard enough that they couldn't punch back, and it probably wouldn't have stirred up that much of a fuss. Simply mass ban instead of find and replace. Could go one step further and just ban the entire subreddit and move on with his life.
- taurath 10y agoRight, and they pulled the punch in order to appear fair and impartial. You cannot be fair and impartial against people trying to destroy you or take over - something many internet communities and media establishments need to learn.
- taurath 10y agoRight, and they pulled the punch in order to appear fair and impartial. You cannot be fair and impartial against people trying to destroy you or take over - something many internet communities and media establishments need to learn.
- beedogs 10y agoThey should've nuked The_Donald six months ago. They should still nuke it now.
- ianamartin 10y agoHuh. Color me surprised. A social media website with a shit-for-brains business model has a CEO who, well, isn't the sharpest knife in the drawer. Look reddit was never a source of real truth. It likes to think it is because every teenager and lonely 50-something wants to feel important. Fine. Whatever. There isn't a big story here. The Lord of the Flies wanked off on Piggy's dead body. Anyone who expected otherwise is probably daft enough to reheat pizza in the oven instead of in a skillet with no oil because that's what makes the bottom so crispy and the top so melty. In other words, you're all mostly heathens and idiots about this. If you want control of your content, host it yourself. Not on someone else's dime. Especially not an idiotic dime like reddit's that calls dimes gold. Do I think this is a huge and massive breach of trust for reddit users? Yes. Yes I do. Do I think it matters and that the people who are surprised by this basically have shit for brains? Yes. Yes I do. Does this actually matter? No. It's just one more social media thing that will go away because the leadership fucked it up. That's all. Our work is done here. We don't need to do this anymore.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoI wonder how many of the hateful comments posted in that subreddit were actually written by the admins.
- andybak 10y agoI think I can answer that one for you - very very few.
- olh 10y agoWashington Post linked to a reddit thread with comments bashing the CEO. The CEO did not like the world seeing him bashed by his own community and decided to impersonate the users to make them seem attacking the moderators of /r/The_Donald. Reddit's TOS: > You are solely responsible for the information associated with Your Account and anything that happens related to Your Account. The CEO crossed the line because he thought he could get away from any liability for doing it.
- allemagne 10y agoReddit has long enjoyed a level of perceived subversiveness that helped it seem cool. It almost paradoxically seems that reddit has become too edgy for the mainstream by housing /r/The_Donald, and now way more Big Brother than subversive after this. If it has to embrace one philosophy going forward, it's going to get a lot more sanitized and will lose a lot of its original allure. From the fact that those slack logs were leaked, and from reading their contents, there's some significant internal turmoil among Reddit admins that this has only enflamed further. They REALLY want to ban /r/The_Donald. They are extremely frustrated with spez. Then if /u/spez resigns, the biggest advocate (ironically enough) for not banning /r/The_Donald will not be in the way anymore. Recognizing this, it's possible that spez stays on for the wild ride of banning T_D and then leaves it to the next CEO to run the new reddit husk. I'm not sure how reddit ever worked, however. Maybe it'll survive this just fine.
- beedogs 10y agoIf reddit actually needs T_D in order to generate revenue, it's probably better off if it doesn't survive once they finally ban it.
- diggan 10y agoI'm curious, why do you find it good that a subreddit like r/the_donald gets banned?
- Daishiman 10y agoWhat would be particularly bad about banning it?
- rokosbasilisk 10y agoit will just evolve stronger. when 4chan banned gamergate it bleed over into twitter and reddit, and parts of it become the donald. The new alt-right is much stronger and diverse than people think due their filter bubble, and thats why this will become far worse no matter what anyone does.
- andybak 10y agoI'm slowly coming to the conclusion that reality is actually a simulation but unfortunately one that has been hacked by /b/
- raverbashing 10y agoLook up "analogy" in the dictionary Oh I see you're just trolling
- rfrank 10y agoThe fact that you made an analogy doesn't make it meaningful or relevant. Oh I see you're just stupid.
- sctb 10y ago> Oh I see you're just stupid. You can't do this to other users here, please stop. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13029430 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13029430 and marked it off-topic. Edit: we've moved it back and detached the thread further up.
- rfrank 10y agoI'll respond in tone to people who accuse me of trolling all day. Why was the comment I replied to not flagged as well? "Look up analogy in the dictionary u troll" provided a lot of constructive commentary to the thread? Your bias is showing.
- sctb 10y agoI didn't notice the parent, sorry (see edit). However, the responsibility you have for commenting within the guidelines is independent of what you're replying to. We don't have permission to make bad threads even worse.
- yladiz 10y agoTwo definitions I found: - a thing that is comparable to something else in significant respects: works of art were seen as an analogy for works of nature. - a process of arguing from similarity in known respects to similarity in other respects. I don't really understand your analogy because I was not saying there should be no limit, like you implied I did, I simply asked for the limit to be defined.
- TorKlingberg 10y agoI think it has become impossible to run a social site without any central moderation today. You will attract a certain group of people, and they will act more and more horribly and brazenly (generally harassing third parties) until you just have to delete something. Then they will accuse you of censorship, and the rest of the community will side with them, not you. The harassment will turn on you. Eventually you will snap, and then you are in a world of trouble. It doesn't matter how much free speech cred you have built up over the years. It happened to the founders of Reddit, Twitter and even 4chan. Of course I am painting site admins as too innocent here. Ultimately they brought it on themselves by letting the community norms fall off a cliff. Back in 2000-2010 being the rough underbelly of the internet was fun, but that period is definitely over.
- sagansucker 10y agoAll that's needed is to ban "meta mob" type content. Shit like SRS, kotakuinaction, subredditdrama, hell even /r/cringe, etc. That shit is toxic and frankly destroyed reddit.
- theWatcher37 10y agoExcept those subs exist for a very real and tangible reason. When the Orlando shootings happened /r/news censored it for almost that entire day deleting threads and banning people. These alt subs only caught traction when the mains started pulling shady stuff
- SwellJoe 10y agoThat's hilarious. I've always found spez to be a genuinely good guy, on every front. I don't find this "disturbing" or whatever other thing people want this to be. People were being dicks to someone who's never done anything but try to make reddit a nice place for as many people as possible; he lost his cool for a minute and made a funny hack (a very specific hack, that required someone to have said "fuck /u/spez" to be changed, and the only effect was to change the target of the pointless insult). He rolled it back and fessed up an hour later. Big deal. The reddit I want to see is the reddit Steve wants to build. It's doubly hilarious that the people getting so riled up are the same people who rant about "PC culture" and people being too sensitive. If ya get your knickers in a bunch about this, I think you have revoked your right to call anyone "too sensitive" ever again.
- philh 10y ago> It's doubly hilarious that the people getting so riled up are the same people who rant about "PC culture" and people being too sensitive. What are you basing this on? This happened on /r/The_Donald, and that sub tends to have people who dislike PC culture. So it's likely true that the groups you're talking about have a lot of overlap, as an accident of population samples. I do not rant about PC culture or people being too sensitive, and I think spez massively fucked up here. A lot of the commenters on this thread think the same, more strongly than me. Do you just casually assume that those commenters rant about PC culture and people being too sensitive? I also think that getting annoyed when you can't say what you want to say is a large factor in disliking PC culture; and getting annoyed when admins edit other people's comments seems entirely consistent with this. They want to be able to express themselves in a certain way, and stealth-editing their comments is the exact opposite of that.
- SwellJoe 10y ago"What are you basing this on? This happened on /r/The_Donald, and that sub tends to have people who dislike PC culture. So it's likely true that the groups you're talking about have a lot of overlap, as an accident of population samples." Sometimes, I generalize as a tool for understanding large groups of people. Generalization is a useful tool; it isn't always right, but the preponderance of folks on The_Donald have, as a big part of their identity, being "anti-PC". And, the preponderance of folks getting really riled up about this are people who are participants on The_Donald subreddit. So, sure, I probably swept up some innocent folks in my generalization. It happens sometimes. Luckily, I hold no political power, no power to censor anyone, and no power to cause anyone harm with my generalizations. All I can do is make fun of people on the Internet. "I also think that getting annoyed when you can't say what you want to say is a large factor in disliking PC culture" More accurately, it would be "getting annoyed when you can say what you want to say, but other people are allowed to say you're an asshole for saying it", because no argument about being politically correct ever involved police knocking down your door for being an asshole on the Internet (unless "being an asshole" also includes "making actionable threats to someone's health", which might bring a police response). Free speech is a thing, and it applies to people making racist/sexist/homophobic comments, and the people who reply angrily to those racist/sexist/homophobic comments.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Fej 10y agoAm I the only one who isn't really concerned with this? spez was engaging in a bit of the Internet pastime... trolling. It wasn't some conspiracy to control information on reddit, he was just having fun. Dastardly fun, yes, but fairly innocent, all things considered.
- tezza 10y agoThe head guy with God Mode needed a much thicker skin. Running around like a headless chicken is the opposite of what was required. Future people with God Mode should avoid repeating the same mistakes. But that depends on what the God mode wielders perceive the mistakes were, either: 1) Losing composure and making secret edits 2) Getting caught doing it Can trust be restored ? Open question.
- nstart 10y agoSigh. Why did spez do this? His entire credibility lost to a bunch of people who made my head hurt when I read their material. I popped over to voat and caught up. I was genuinely thinking there'd be some kind of vague link of emails and a few jumps in assumptions, but it's full on "here's a picture. Here's another picture. Look. They have the same shape in them. They are connected. Also, here's the person in this picture. That means they are connected to the earlier connection" type conspiracy stuff. And then there's full on accusations firing away about who's an FBI agent attempting to silence them. The fact that u/spez did not just laugh at the ridiculousness of it all and instead chose to take it on this way, I'm trying to imagine what kind of abuse he's had to deal with today. :( .
- Shivetya 10y agoSo basically Reddit has now been proven to have comments that may or may not be what the user intended. That alone should hopefully lead Reddit code changes that prevent anyone but the author of a post from modifying a post without very obvious indicators if permitted at all. As it stands now, reddit is pretty much imparts no trust and nothing read there would have any trust associated with it. depending on context I wonder what the legal exposure could be. could they trace a modified post that suggested something illegal?
- ben_jones 10y agoIs the CEO of Reddit technical or non-technical? I'd be most shocked if this meant Reddit had user-content-editing tools for its employees, rather then one rogue employee going into the database(s) and changing data there. I strongly get the feeling that tools were created at Reddit to allow them to do this, suggesting that sometime ago employees at Reddit thought "wouldn't it be great if we could change what users actually said"... Don't get me wrong I feel no protectionism for a lot of the scumbags on boards like Reddit, but I would find an extreme amount of hypocrisy in "the front page of the internet" actively manipulating its content in such a way.
- _1 10y agoHe's the founder of the site .. highly technical. He had to modify the database directly and tinkered with the "edited" flag or "modified" timestamp so the comment would not show it had been edited.
- theWatcher37 10y agoThis is a huge part of this I don't see most here discussing. The CEO didn't just edit the comments, he did so in a way that did not reveal the comment had ever been edited.
- johansch 10y agoOptions: 1. He directly manipulated the production db (seems like they use Cassandra). Definitely doable for someone with a deep technical background, even if they spent 99% of the the past couple of years working "via other people", rather than writing the code themselves. I could easily imagine him getting database access privileges as a part of the "catching up what's happened since I left" process. 2. Reddit has built easy-to-use, e.g. web based in-house tools for editing comments - without leaving any trace of the fact that they were edited. I guess there also a third option; that he fudged the truth (err, lied) when confessing: that he asked some developer to do the work for him: presumably while laughing and thinking they were hilarious, and then took the blame for when it was time to confess.) I think he needs to resign. Such a dumb, irresponsible action. I don't think someone that impulsive and immature should be the the CEO of Reddit. And since he's 33 rather than 23, it's not very likely he'll much more mature within a few years.
- asderty123 10y agoI am going off topic a bit...but dear brothers and sisters I sincerely wish you investigate this further there is a heaven and a hell. people says this thing is creepy relating to the pizzagate but its demonic and these guys do this its getting to the point where they are practicing it openly. The media as well as the majority information sources don't tell you about this please investigate for yourself. To all who don't believe in Jesus Repent for the kingdom of God is at hand.
- sctb 10y agoWe've banned this account for posting only ideological comments. That's not what this site is for. We've happy to unban accounts if you email hn@ycombinator.com and we believe you'll comment within the guidelines in the future.
- typon 10y agoReddit should have banned that sub a long time ago. Its nothing but a bunch of toxic neo Nazis being given a huge platform for free
- clydethefrog 10y agoBut look at all that growth in user activity! Investors love it.
- whataboutpizza 10y agoI'd start with the news networks that broadcast Trump 24/7 for a year
- dbg31415 10y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/Cernovich/status/801680245631766528 https://mobile.twitter.com/Cernovich/status/8016802456317665... - deplorable how all these people at Reddit are calling for censorship. If you ignore The Donald people, they implode. Don't respond to them and that's the ball gane. All Spez it is doing is pouring gasoline on the fire. Immature tone at the top doesn't help things right now. Spez needs to go.
- andybak 10y agoThe fact that this was part of a particularly crazy episode on /r/The_Donald/ should surely at least be taking into account before sentencing is determined. "Whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster. And if you gaze long enough into an abyss, the abyss will gaze back into you" - Friedrich Nietzsche, Beyond Good and Evil, Aphorism 146
- 650REDHAIR 10y agoThe_Donald sub has ruined Reddit for me. I can't go into any remotely-political post without a bunch of weird alt-Right commentary that's been upvoted through the roof with poster's comment history filled with r/The_Donald shit. Who cares if these people go to Voat or back to 4chan...
- diyorgasms 10y agoFight back against the white supremacists and neo-Nazis and racists and write nationalists, both in real life and online. You think they're ruining a website? They took control of the USA. The might take control of France. I can't imagine how tired you'll be of them after they've run the world into the ground.
- giarc 10y agoThe problem is that in a post yesterday about the same topic, there seemed to be a lot pizzagate supporters here in HN.
- whataboutpizza 10y agoEcho chambers are boring
- basch 10y agoit would be a shame to visit a community that challenged your worldview. you really want to only read things that confirm your beliefs? i actively try and read mostly things I disagree with to see if they can change my mind.
- Yhippa 10y agoI see a lot of handwringing about this but what are people really going to do about this? Go to Voat or 4chan? Even if people claim they feel they can no longer trust reddit they aren't going to leave. If anything this just gave reddit a huge amount of free publicity.
- marcoperaza 10y agoLots of people are complaining about r/The_Donald in this thread, wishing that it would be banned. The casual attitude with which people are advocating censorship of Trump supporters is troubling. They claim that it's polluting the rest of the site. It's not a default subscription, so it's not on the front page. It's at most a handful of the posts on any page of r/all, which by the way, almost no one browses according to Reddit admins themselves. Yes, the moderators of The_Donald ban opposing viewpoints, just like moderators in other partisan subreddits do. It is advertised as a 24/7 Trump rally, and that's what it is. They claim that the subreddit is racist, sexist, homophobic, etc. If you took a moment to even read it, you'd find post after post expressing the OPPOSITE sentiment, advocating for equality for all regardless of race, sex, and orientation. The problem is that the definition that the left is using of "racism" has been broadened to include basically anything they don't agree with.
- randomname2 10y agoLeaks from the reddit admin slack channel show the motivations behind this: http://archive.is/ZmULb http://archive.is/ZmULb Apparently a long history of harrassment from the subreddit in question finally made /u/spez retaliate. The leaks further show the admin team is planning to deal with the subreddit in a more definitive way.
- imode 10y agothere are many sides to this. for one, the CEO should be thinking "oh shit what did I do", because he's now responsible for every event on reddit. good job, I can't wait to see what happens, if anything. for two, it really shows how violent people are towards those with differing political opinions. note, I'm not referring to /r/The_Donald, I'm referring to everybody who thinks that /r/The_Donald should be shown the door with no other reason than "I don't agree with their views". you're shouting at someone to shut up because you don't like what they're saying instead of arguing. note, I don't like the folks there either very much, but they are people, with opinions, and they founded a place to share them, and it just so happens that they're pretty loud and easily spotted. have some decency. stop calling for a total ban or witch hunts on the people you don't like, because you look exactly like them to the outsider. and outsiders are all over. develop some common decency. your fellow man isn't as terrible as you think he is. polarization will only cause more problems. spez, the CEO of reddit, can't make this conclusion, which is kind of funny. if you can't do this, then can your users? can the users who're friends of the users? do you understand how this represents your community? clearly not. I'll be sitting back and watching the outcome. at the most, it's social commentary. at the least, it's cheap entertainment.