23 ms·
Time to Dump Time Zones
- grzm 10y agogrr... "A century and a half ago, time zones didn’t exist." Sure. How old are the concepts of noon? Midnight? The transition to railroad time and time zones wasn't from a single time zone to many, but from incredibly local time zones (what time is noon in this town?) to fewer. Likely a lack of imagination or caffeination on my part, but it's hard for me to imagine what it would be like to have shops open at, say 22:00. And we still need to take into account differences across the world for coordinating with people. It's not like we're going to change our diurnal habits just because it's, say, 14:00 across the world at the same time. Wow. This is one of the most caustic comments I've left on HN. Someone back me off of the ledge. Off to read the Cato Institute commentary linked to in the article. (And you kids! Get off my lawn!)
- bryanrasmussen 10y agoit does seem that if time zones didn't exist someone would have to invent them, just to make remote work feasible if nothing else.
- grzm 10y agoReading the Cato Institute commentary "Changing Times"[0] didn't help me. I do think Daylight Savings Time should be gotten rid of. As for removing time zones, I remain unconvinced. Still holding out for someone with a compelling argument. After all, 1 is simpler than 39, right? [0]: https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/changing-times https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/changing-times
- diggernet 10y agoSpot on. The author speaks of "the messy affair" of changing to have 4 different times in the US, seemingly oblivious to the fact that we were changing away from having a unique time in every town. It is beyond me how having 4 time zones is supposed to be messier than that. He describes his 1883 newspaper quote as an example of how difficult and unpopular the change was, but I read it as describing how simple it was becoming to know what time it was in another city (except Chicago). Simply put, the author's fantasy of eliminating time zones is ignorant of history, and silly and unworkable for reasons many other commenters have already covered. I wouldn't mind losing DST, though.
- facorreia 10y agoI think the article makes a valid point but it can't get past Americanisms like "noon" or "4 p.m." If people were to adapt UTC, those would be 12:00 and 16:00 respectively. And that just reinforces the main point, that the numbers are largely arbitrary -- but descriptions like "after mid-day" (p.m.) aren't.
- grzm 10y agoAmericanisms like "noon" or "4 p.m." Huh. I had never thought of these as Americanisms (though being from the States I might say that, right?) I've lived abroad in a country that uses a 24-hour clock for more official uses, and 12-hour clocks for more informal, spoken uses, including the use of the concept of "noon". Given my small sample size, I looked at Wikipedia to see how time is referenced in other countries. I was surprised to see that the first five countries I looked at all have mixed usage of 24-hour and 12-hour (except for Thailand, which has a 6-hour clock). Both the 12-hour and 24-hour notations are used in the United Kingdom. The 12-hour notation is still widely used in ordinary life, written communication and displays, and continues to be used in spoken language. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_notation_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_notation_in_the_... Turkey uses the 24-hour clock system. In informal speech, however, the 12-hour clock is more commonly used. When speaking in the 12-hour system, the words such as "sabah" (morning), "akşam" (evening) or "gece" (night) are generally used before telling the time to clarify whether it is a.m. or p.m. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_notation_in_Turkey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_notation_in_Turk... In Thailand, official time is indicated in 24-hour clock system; however, a six-hour clock system is also used, especially in spoken language. It divides the day into four six-hour periods, with additional words added to make the night-morning-afternoon-evening distinction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_notation_in_Thailand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_notation_in_Thai... In spoken Swedish however, the 12-hour clock is much more common. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_notation_in_Sweden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_notation_in_Swed... In common spoken language, times are given in 12-hour clock, and those between 1 and 11 are assumed to be post meridiem, past noon, if not otherwise noted. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_notation_in_Spain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Date_and_time_notation_in_Spai... I haven't done an exhaustive search through the rest, but this does strongly suggest that these are not only Americanisms. If I'm missing something, or misinterpreting what you're saying (which wouldn't be the first time :) please let me know and clarify. As for the numbers being arbitrary, I agree. There is a utility to the choice of 24 hours in a day. That doesn't get around the behavior of humans, where our own biology follows the sun. We'll for the most part be awake when the sun is up, likely be active in community during the middle of the day, at home in the morning and evening. In a global world, we need some way to coordinate with people living at different longitudes, especially for synchronous tasks. Is there a significant difference between needing to know that working hours is from 9:00 and 17:00 in London and from 4:00 and 12:00 in New York, and looking up the time difference between London and New York is 5 hours? Six of one, half-dozen of the other, seems to me. We'll still need some way general convention locally as well. It'd be interesting to see what the business hours are (at a per-business level, perhaps) in relation to the time zone and nearness to time zone borders, and see if there are any trends for businesses compensating based on what the time zone is for the majority of the local population. There'd still need to be some convention for locales. With a limited number of time zones, that decision and coordination is taken care of. Maybe I'm approaching this wrong, but so far what I've read hasn't convinced me that getting rid of time zones does anything more than shift the issue elsewhere. Given that it makes sense to some people, I'm open to hearing more. While I might not agree with some opinions, I generally want to be able to understand how people come to them. Thanks for reading!
- grzm 10y agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12882318 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12882318
- frik 10y agoTime to dump summer vs normal time. Switching twice a year, and every other country choose a different date or doesn't switch... It's time to stop switching between summer and normal time.
- khattam 10y agoLast time I read something so retarded, it was in the NYT... oh wait.
- drallison 10y agoTime zones and, worse, leap seconds interfere and needlessly complicate recorded time--the ability to compare two times and compute the time interval between them. Anyone who has tried to geophysical data from diverse locations and organizations knows how difficult that is. Now would be a good time to adopt this change since the way standard units (mass, length, time, etc.) are being redefined.
- grzm 10y agoThere's more to time zones than just recorded time. We still need a way to coordinate synchronous human action around the globe. People are still going to wake, work, and sleep roughly with the sun. Time zones are one way of accomplishing this. What do you propose as an alternative? As an aside, please don't conflate the issues of leap seconds (or leap days, or daylight savings time) with time zones. They're at least three distinct topics. Interesting, yes, but distinct from time zones. I agree that management of temporal data across the globe is a challenging process. That's why some domains agree to operate in UTC all the time. And some of our common tooling (JavaScript in the browser comes immediately to mind) doesn't do a very good job in providing good methods for handing time zones. I think the answer to that is to improve our tooling. While removing time zones might make this recorded time issue go away, it seems problematic that we'd make a societal change to compensate for computer deficiencies. What do you think? In particular, how would society work without time zones? What do you see as the trade offs?
- grzm 10y agoDupes: 5 comments, 6 hours ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12885299 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12885299 3 comments, 22 hours ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12882318 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12882318
- mjevans 10y agoAs this version of the thread seems to have more points I'll comment here. I completely agree with everyone using UTC for numeric time numbering. I DISAGREE, with remapping 'noon', 'midnight', 'morning', etc. All of the relative descriptions for when in the local solar day a thing is should be approximate local references. An example: 'lunch' and 'noon' would still be the time in the middle of the local solar day that people get a meal. (Somewhere around 11AM to 2PM in current local times)
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoRegarding UTC: when I've tried (as a European) to coordinate online meetings with Americans (working in tech companies) using times given in UTC, it's gone wrong about 50% of the time. Usually caused by people confusing UTC and British Summer Time (UTC+1).
- mjevans 10y agoSadly, that's because they think UTC == GMT (which does have DST). UTC would be the time that computer software operates in and then feeds humans 'human time'. You also can't use 'Zulu' from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_military_time_zones https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_military_time_zones either, for that same confusion. The problem, like with driving, is that humans are communicating the time to humans, instead of the 'smartest' humans having programmed computers how to convey time for the rest of the humans.
- CalRobert 10y agoGMT doesn't exactly have BST; rather, many places that observe GMT in the winter observe BST (which is defined as GMT +1 hour) in the summer. Google is not the arbiter of all things, but a good clue is that Googling "current time GMT" in the summer will give you the time in Britain as though DST didn't exist.
- a_plastic_bag 10y agoGMT doesn't change throughout the year. Birtain uses GMT during winter and BST(UTC+1) during summer though. https://www.timeanddate.com/time/gmt-utc-time.html https://www.timeanddate.com/time/gmt-utc-time.html
- Spooky23 10y agoInteresting thought experiment, but what problem does it solve?
- grzm 10y agomod: Can you please combine the three threads?
- adamnemecek 10y agoWhat will Jon Skeet do now?
- abcd_f 10y agoLooks paywalled to me.
- darawk 10y agoHmm...this is an interesting idea. However, the core of the argument seems to be this: > “The economy — that’s all of us — would receive a permanent ‘harmonization dividend’ ”— the efficiency benefits that come from a unified time zone. But this editorial is pretty light on actually supporting that. The basic argument seems to be that it reduces 'translation costs'. But..does it? What about the benefits of being able to refer to times without having to localize them? If my friend on the other side of the country says "I woke up at 9 this morning", I have a pretty good idea of what that means. If we used this new system, i'd have to mentally translate. In terms of scheduling things, it would get easier in some ways and likely harder in others. If say, I want to schedule a conference call at 3, yes, 3 is the same time for everyone, but i'd still have to do some mental sanity checks to ensure that that time is reasonable for everyone who might be participating. Overall, is there really an efficiency gain to be had here? I'm not taking the firm position that there isn't, btw. Just a bit skeptical and curious to hear a better argument in its favor if anyone has got one.
- artpepper 10y agoThe real inefficiencies stem from daylight savings, and the fact that (in some places) time zones change for political reasons.
- minznerjosh 10y agoThis hits the nail on the head. Abandoning time zones would only make sense if there were no more need for time translation. But you'd still need to translate for the sake of biological clocks, and without time zones it would become more challenging to communicate that translation. I would be in favor of doing away with DST and also eschewing AM/PM in favor of a 24-hour clock. I'm surprised this article didn't mention that.
- snvzz 10y ago> This hits the nail on the head. Abandoning time zones would only make sense if there were no more need for time translation. But you'd still need to translate for the sake of biological clocks, and without time zones it would become more challenging to communicate that translation. I argue it'd avoid mistakes, such as the assumption it's dark at the other clock's 18h because it is here.
- Longhanks 10y ago> Don't have an account? Sign up here! No thanks.
- edblarney 10y agoThe article is upside down. "Perhaps you’re asking why the Greenwich meridian gets to define earth time. " It doesn't. Everybody gets to have their own, proper time. In comparing times, we +/- based on an arbitrary spot, and that's it. Time zones are a great solution to a problem. People want their time in local terms. Everyone waking up and going to bed at different times is an utterly ridiculous concept. FYI - if you want to use UTC - you're free to do that today. To those suggesting we should use UTC: walk down the street and look at regular people. 'Other time zones' are irrelevant to them - utterly. There are very few people who need to deal with other time zones. It might be remotely possible to put an entire nation on one time - i.e. put America on 'Mountain Time' - it might be possible to convince New Yorkers and Californians that they are getting up earlier/later etc.. But even that wouldn't be very useful in the end.
- Aloha 10y agoTime zones are an arbitrary construct anyhow - what makes 0800 morning and 1900 evening other than our understanding of that time means. They are all entirely human constructs. In business - abolishing time zones is a great idea - but in personal life.. maybe not so much - as a linked article pointed out - humans don't normally publish waking hours.
- dexterdog 10y agoSo is time.
- mjevans 10y agoThe numbers are already arbitrary. Even within the US, where the east and west are 'only' three hours apart there are many who believe that only their timezone matters. For conveying when in time something happened or will happen, using UTC properly is good. There is one singular number that can make sense to everyone. For all other things people perform a lookup, either in their mind or in some utility (paper or program) already. Times for accounting (arbitrary numbers that presently have local offsets) could benefit from having the offset, and the need for specifying /what/ that offset is, removed. There is no reason we //need// 9am to mean 'morning', we can use morning for that. Any 'time' that isn't a hard number is a loose social reference for local meanings.
- ericzawo 10y agoA crazy thing my brother and I noticed this morning that the last clock we have to manually change ourselves is our watches. Yes, even the oven had a built in DST time change.
- rcarmo 10y agoI'd be happy with doing away with Daylight Savings Time.
- M_Grey 10y ago^This. Lets tackle the thing that's definitely a good idea, and much easier to manage before shooting for the metaphorical moon.
- mjevans 10y agoI want to shoot for the moon; because if you actually try you can sometimes accomplish great things.
- M_Grey 10y agoEven Wernher von Braun aimed a little lower first...
- jamesrom 10y agoWhy is it definitely a good idea?
- M_Grey 10y agohttp://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2015/03/time-to-kill-daylight-saving/387175/ http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2015/03/time-to-... Honestly though, just Googling, "Daylight savings bad" yields a wealth of result at this time of year.
- zwily 10y agoI'd be happier making DST permanent :)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- matjaz2k 10y agoWait until we go interplanetary. :) Then also "let's talk in 5 mins" won't work anymore.
- kryptiskt 10y agoSo you want to abolish time zones (https://qntm.org/abolish https://qntm.org/abolish)
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoThat is the best narrative I have read regarding time zones. Thanks!
- Sir_Substance 10y agoBeat me to it!
- cyberferret 10y agoThe argument here though, is convenience rather than timezones. To reference the premise in the article: What if Uncle Steve in Melbourne is a baker or a night security guard? Then 4:25am would absolutely be a fine time to call him. All these machinations to find a mutually convenient time. Heck, I have trouble finding a mutually convenient time to arrange a sit down chat with my wife, and we both live (and work) in the same house in the same time zone. Meetings almost always means at least one party has to compromise their existing schedule and suffer some level of inconvenience.
- barnacs 10y agoIf I want to talk to Uncle Steve, I don't really care what time it is either here or there, or what it signifies. All I care about is whether we can communicate synchronously at the time or not. If he doesn't want to be disturbed for whatever reason, he can mute/turn off his phone and I can send him an asynchronous message. Problem solved.
- uryga 10y agoIf you care about his availability, I'd say his local time is a pretty good predictor :) I used to like the idea of asynchronous messaging and thought it was the future of telephony/voip. But honestly, async is pretty annoying, because you have to wait ;). I guess what I'm trying to say is, synchronous things are easier for us. It's pretty gard for me to keep track of all the async text conversations I've got going on Facebook. Async is useful for some things, but it makes talking feel like work. I guess CPS-based humans would be more suited for a networked world...
- bbcbasic 10y agoSounds good to me. If the farmers want daylight savings then simply go to work at a different time, UTC.
- goodcanadian 10y agoFarmers don't give a good goddamn about daylight savings; I wish this myth would die. Source: I grew up on a farm in a farming area.
- bbcbasic 10y agoOk I looked on Wikipedia and I stand corrected. In-fact farmers opposed DST.
- bbcbasic 10y agoSounds great to me. If the farmers want daylight savings then simply go to work at a different time, UTC.
- bbcbasic 10y agoSounds good to me. If the farmers want daylight savings then simply go to work at a different time, UTC.
- olliej 10y agoSomeone wrote an article a while back about why this is a stupid idea -- mostly things like "if I want to call so and so in Australia I would now need to find out what time of day in Australia is the time I consider to be evening" Computers already work in terms of utc (assuming correct code ;) ) -- this article is mostly "I know what time I'm in, why should I have to consider other people?" If we were to get rid of anything it should be DST as we aren't agrarian and there's no evidence that the modern "save power" claims are remotely accurate. But then again it's a politically cheap thing for politicians to change it "help the environment" and helping the environment is always good, right? :-/
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pfarnsworth 10y agoGetting rid of Daylight Savings makes complete sense, and it's something we should really pursue. Getting rid of Time Zones is ridiculous. People know that 6am roughly is morning, and 6pm is roughly the evening. When you're dealing with someone internationally, you know not to call them at midnight their time because there's a high probability they may be sleeping. Having time roughly follow a standard around the world makes absolute sense because we're human.
- pixie_ 10y agoWe need permanent daylight savings time. Yesterday sunset was around 6pm in LA. Today it will be at 5pm. At least I had a little bit of daylight after work, now it's just depressing.
- twic 10y agoWe need midday to be roughly the average of when the sun is at its highest across the year. I think that corresponds to permanent standard time. If that leaves people working later in the day than they'd like, then we also need different working hours in the winter.
- raldi 10y agoWithout Standard Time, it would have been dark out until 7:40am today here in SF. That's really tough on people (or children) who have to be at work/school by 9 or even 8. By mid-December, sunrise wouldn't be until almost 8:30. In Seattle, it would be dark outside until 9am. Losing an hour of sleep in the spring is rough, but I'd rather do that (and get an extra hour in the fall) than have to get ready in the dark all winter.
- macspoofing 10y ago>That's really tough on people (or children) who have to be at work/school by 9 or even 8 In what way? People (and kids) survive wars and famines I'm sure we can handle a little bit of darkness. But if you really really can't, there's no reason why in winter, school couldn't start an hour later. Probably a good idea regardless.
- glook 10y agoI remember https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatch_Internet_Time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatch_Internet_Time - I loved the concept. Maybe if we switched to beats we wouldn't have an association for 'noon.'
- taeric 10y agoThis should be required reading for anyone thinking time zones are a bad idea: https://qntm.org/abolish https://qntm.org/abolish
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gwbas1c 10y agoOk, pretty much every comment here is about why time zones are important. I agree! But one thing to ponder: Just like telling time in 24-hour mode is useful, perhaps it will be useful to have some clocks display UTC? Perhaps it'll be useful to talk about international events in UTC? Perhaps instead of abolishing time zones, we just use UTC as a convention when talking about events that happen across time zones?
- jlgaddis 10y agoFor over 20 years, I've kept a clock near my computer desk that shows time in both my local time zone as well as UTC. I started doing it because I was pretty active in ham radio. I'm not now (and haven't been for many, many years) but I still use UTC several times a week. It's very handy when dealing with people/events/servers/etc. in different/multiple time zones. (Then again, I use 24 hour time everywhere so maybe I'm just weird.)
- ebalit 10y ago24h time is the normal setting in France (and I think in most of Europe). Not that weird ;)
- ebalit 10y agoI also think that it's the right solution. The important thing is to disambiguate the timezone (UTC, CET, GMT, etc) and get rid of ambiguous time as much as possible. I think it's similar to currencies. In a local shop, the currency is often implied. But on Internet, prices without currency is ambiguous and should be avoided.
- grzm 10y ago"use UTC as a convention when talking about events that happen across time zones" For coordination of events across time zones, perhaps. Would you really want to read international events happening in UTC in the news? In the local time I can put the event in context: is it evening? morning? Middle of the night? If it were UTC, I'd have to either look that up and do some mental math (or maybe the reading device, if I were using one, would do that for me?) or the author would have to provide it for me, which would be extra work on the author. I keep coming back to, what problem does abolishing time zones really solve?
- danso 10y agoDumping time zones might be painful, but in the long run it'd probably be the right thing to do. First, it'd make learning about time as a programmer much easier because you'd inherently know that it's a bit complicated and why epoch time and UTC is a thing instead of storing values like "Sunday 4PM". But more future facing...what are we going to do when we have colonies on the moon and Mars? Things are going to spiral fast if we don't stick to uniform time while we're still mono-planet. As an example, NASA's Mars photos API provide an option to sort by Martian sol instead of earth date: https://api.nasa.gov/api.html#MarsPhotos https://api.nasa.gov/api.html#MarsPhotos
- leppr 10y ago>First, it'd make learning about time as a programmer much easier Ok let's change how everybody thinks about time so that programmers have an easier time! >But more future facing...what are we going to do when we have colonies on the moon and Mars? IMO this is probably only until then that it'll start to make sense, since we may be living in buried/heavily radiation shielded habitats without any sunlight, there wouldn't be anything preventing the whole planet from having a synchronized, artificial, day/night schedule.
- danso 10y agoI don't see programmers being a special profession. Time affects us all, and it's a complex thing that's worth spending time contemplating, and I really don't think the math is hard, if there is even much math. Though admittedly, I do enjoy such clusterfucks as this: http://www.salon.com/2013/06/28/alec_baldwin_deletes_twitter_account_after_meltdown/ http://www.salon.com/2013/06/28/alec_baldwin_deletes_twitter...
- artpepper 10y agoThis is basically a form of Utopian thinking, that we should adopt a convention because it's "logical" rather than one that meets human needs. > People forget how recent is the development of our whole ungainly apparatus. A century and a half ago, time zones didn’t exist. That's true, but not because everyone was living on GMT. Time zones are somewhat arbitrary, but aligning everyone to a single time zone is even more arbitrary.
- namank 10y agoSo 2pm Earth Time for me in North America means afternoon but it means night for Asia? This might make sense if Earth's communication with extraterrestrial localities significantly outweighed communication across Earth. But it doesn't. So, no. But upvote to the OP for posting an interesting idea. :)
- nealmydataorg 10y agoIt will be difficult for all the countries to agree to dump time zones. If they agree then adjustment of computer systems will bring time similar to Y2K effect.
- cyberferret 10y agoLiving in a place that doesn't have the concept of daylight saving time, I positively hate the dance that we have to do twice a year with our interstate and overseas brethren to arrange meetings etc. Having been a commercial pilot, I also appreciate the concept of 'Zulu time' where EVERYONE is on the same page as to when an aircraft will depart or reach a particular waypoint. No need to wonder if it is during morning, noon or evening, if a crew member said they would be at a particular location at 0421, we all knew how many minutes ahead or behind we were, no matter where we are in the world. After all, everyone who cares about that reference is already awake and working at that time. Currently, I work with a widely distributed remote team across the world. Yes, arranging meetings is hard in order to ensure that it fits with working schedules and awake times, but at the end of the day, I usually also clarify the meeting times in UTC times, just to ensure that everyone can double check in their local timezones. This means using only one fixed datum for checking rather than figuring out if the remote timezone & daylight saving, and trying to work back to your local timezone accordingly. For instance, I am in Australia and you are in the US, you have to figure out the subset timezone each is in before working out. I have no idea what zone Kalamazoo is in off the top of my head, and I bet you have no clue what timezone Darwin is in?!? In our web apps, we always set our servers to the default UTC timezone, and try and use humanised time displays all over the app (i.e. "Updated 34 minutes ago") or use local browser timezones to display actual time. This way, it doesn't matter if someone in the Ukraine or in Alaska enters a record, it is always "x minutes from a fixed datum" no matter what your local time is, and it seems to make more sense to the users.
- emilburzo 10y agoI've recently discovered the 'Meeting planner' from timeanddate.com http://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/meeting.html http://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/meeting.html Initially, I was just using it to double-check that my calculations are correct. But it's so much faster to use it for planning, by just adding everyone's location/timezone and see what works. And of course include the full link in the calendar event/email for a final check.
- nealmydataorg 10y agoIt will be difficult for the countries to agree to dump time zones. If they agree then adjustment of computer systems will need effort similar to Y2K effect.
- brianwawok 10y agoI vote for infinite time zones. Each town picks their own timezone based on solar noon. We have tech to map for us when traveling. Bringin 1900 back.
- ced 10y agoPeople on the West Coast would start their work week on Sunday around 11PM, and finish it on Monday at 8 AM. Then they would agree to a Wednesday morning meeting, and miss each other by a day.
- barnacs 10y agoI'd go even further and divide every human settlement into multiple districts with schedules shifting gradually between them. Like, in one "district" of the city most people would be sleeping, it would be quiet and somewhat dead, while at the same time a few "districts" over in the same city businesses would be open, including banks, offices and other stuff on extremely strict schedules currently. Yet in another district it would be leisure time, where most people would be doing whatever they do between sleep and work. The point is, you could always find the appropriate district for whatever you want to do, be it business, leisure, sleep or anything. Also, with digital timekeeping devices (watches, calendars, digital presentation of business hours, etc) schedules could all be dynamic. Instead of "2016-11-09 16:00" you could schedule things like "3 days and 2 hours from now" and all devices would dynamically keep track of how much time is left until the event.
- emodendroket 10y agoSounds like a completely unworkable mess.
- barnacs 10y agoWhy do you think so? I believe it would work better than the current system. We could utilize roads, vehicles, parking space, other infrastructure, as well as manpower more evenly. Rush hours are a weird concept and painful for pretty much everyone every day - waiting in traffic or lines is not much of a joy. The fact that 9-5 workers all work at the same time means that any one worker doesn't have much chance to take advantage of what other businesses have to offer. Like, if you work exactly at the same time banks and government offices are open, when do you even run your errands? And why do we assume that from say 10pm to 6am everyone just wants to keep quiet and rest? Fck that noisy pub down the road, let's just shut it down already! To put it another way, since we currently have no practical control over the passage of time, it would make sense to separate activities spatially instead.
- emodendroket 10y agoWell, for one thing, a great many people commute to their jobs. For another, I doubt the zones would be far enough apart in hyper-local time for this to actually help congestion at all. That's before we account for headaches of the time changing six times as you drive to the grocery store.
- mixedCase 10y agoArchived version: https://archive.fo/oZVQ2 https://archive.fo/oZVQ2
- amelius 10y agoThe article is a little short-sighted. What time will we use when we start colonizing other planets? Those planets may not even have a 24-hour day. And to make matters worse, relativity tells us that a global clock doesn't even exist (look up simultaneity).
- droithomme 10y agoUTC+8 has the largest population by far: http://artscience.cyberclip.com/world-population-by-time-zone http://artscience.cyberclip.com/world-population-by-time-zon... Therefore that is what everyone should use rather than Greenwich time as it would provide the least disruption.
- powvans 10y agoI've spent the last several years developing applications that have calendaring at the core, where users collaborate across timezones, and where proper timezone handling is expected. Just try to explain to everyday people just how hard the problem is, the technical in and out, the practical miracle that it all works in almost all the cases, that all the error prone complexity can be eliminated by acknowledging that it's the same time everywhere all the time. They will not understand and they will not care. They will most likely consider you crazy. Like Don Quixote tilting at windmills. We implement technical solutions to hard problems in order to simplify daily life for the 99.9% of people who do not care about things like timezones. Not withstanding the elimination of DST, this article is asking for the opposite. Furthermore, behind the scenes we already deal with time in the agreed upon standard. If your dates are not stored in UTC in your database, you are doing it wrong. If your API and client software do not deal in dates in UTC, you are doing it wrong. If your dates are not localized when displayed to end users, you probably have very unhappy users.
- taeric 10y agoOddly, when working with calendar events, I found UTC to be unhelpful. In particular, consider the case of seeing an alarm for Friday at noon. If I happen to be traveling across the country this week, I don't want to remake my alarm. This is more problematic for recurring events. If I set a weekly meeting at 11, I do not want it to move just because daylight savings time.
- mkj 10y agoIn my experience it's better to store local time (where the event physically happens) with a named timezone. That way when daylight saving laws change with 3 weeks notice you can adjust without shifting events (cough Outlook). UTC can be calculated easily if needed.
- grzm 10y agoI can see how this could work for recording timestamps as they happen, or for events that have already happened. In this case, you still need to keep around the tables of time zone changes if you ever want to compare two timestamps. How do you handle future timestamps when time zone data changes? Update all future timestamps? Keep a separate timestamp recording the timestamp at which the future timestamp was last updated? Storing timestamps at UTC solves this at the expense of knowing how to view the timestamp at a specific time zone.
- taylodl 10y agoHow about we start with ending daylight saving time and see how that goes, hmmm?
- Mz 10y agoPrior to railroads, local time was determined by making it Noon when the sun was directly overhead. Time zones became necessary when railways spread in order to be able to catch your train. Airplanes use Zulu Time because they can fly fast enough to make it a confusing mess to do anything else. This is the same problem the railways had, but the next order of magnitude up. We already have and use Zulu Time for airplanes. There is no compelling argument here for making that universal. Local time zones still make sense in terms of setting schedules for local services, jobs, etc. The fact that I can talk to people all over the world isn't a compelling reason to move to a singular Earth Time.
- pipio21 10y ago"Time" has always been linked to sun or moon or the stars. In English you say o'clock because it is the time of a mechanical clock, it was normal and way more precise to use the sun for a long time in history so 12 was the time the sun was the highest(Zenith). Astronomers used the moon and stars for calculating time with extreme precision, and they continue doing that. This always gives you local time at the point of the observer. The man that writes the article probably lives without contact to the environment,in a city,goes to work to a building without the light of the sun but for those of us that do not, knowing when the sun is going to be the highest, the rising and setting of the sun is a great idea. With GPS enabled clocks, like Apple watch and future smartwatches, every person could carry in his clock the real local time, the political local time zone time,and UTC. No need for globalist trying to force us into doing that. In America and specially New York it looks like the only important thing in life are first money, then the economy. Instead of money and economy being in service of the world, in those places the world has to serve the economy and money.
- 131hn 10y agoHaving all clocks of the world in sync will be a bless, but there remain a gap in time information, so people will add location offset by themselves (we mostly use time to describe life in our timezone) "yes it's 4 am, and i'm in paris". That location offset will be nothing but current timezones, with an inverted logic. I know we are all on different schedule and rythm, but 7am is a good time for breakfast, everywhere, 12h30 feels fine for lunch, kids go to bed by 8pm, and we should sleep at 2am. I guess timezone make life easier for 80% of the world ( i dont think it's 99% anymore)
- paulddraper 10y agoAgreed. Baby steps: get rid of daylight saving time.
- mckoss 10y agoI don't think people could easily adjust to having the date and day of the week change every day at, say 2pm (for those on PST).
- upofadown 10y agoIf you have UTC and solar time available, you don't need zone time anymore. If you need to coordinate with other people you use UTC. If you want to do things at a particular time of day you use solar time. If you decide to go to work at, say, an hour after sunrise you get all the advantages of DST, anywhere in the world, without any of the disadvantages. The reason DST sucks is because of the way time zones force all time to be an even number of hours (yes, I know there are exceptions, but the principle still holds).
- uryga 10y agoTo be honest I'm surprised at how simple this UTC/Local solution is. I feel like we reinvent absolute/relative in many different areas, and act really surprised each time... That concept is so universal, it's beautiful.
- mxfh 10y agoMy argument as well, keep local time in sync with solar events, mean solar time for practicality. School should start relative to sunrise. Work depending on preference, relative to sunrise/noon/sunset/timezone or utc. All other events that need cross metro region syncs, trains, planes and tv schedules should stick with time zones. I kept a sunrise calendar sheet in the kitchen to be able to bike at sunlight home and to work, it's really all up to flexibility of your workplace and not about DST and "more" daylight. In the Northern hemisphere this is mostly relevant for the months around winter solstice, since otherwise there is enough daylight. I just see no reason to send kids to school in the dark. http://www.aasmnet.org/articles.aspx?id=5176 http://www.aasmnet.org/articles.aspx?id=5176
- chx 10y ago> No more wondering what time it is in Peoria or Petropavlovsk. Sure, I know it's 10am in Petra and so what? Is my partner in the tourist business dead asleep or just stirring? If you detach these numbers from the life of people then you need to find some other way to remember their cycle.
- shmerl 10y agoI don't mind ditching DST. It's a mess. Not sure why it's still in use.
- piotrjurkiewicz 10y agoIn my country (Poland) there was such an initiative, but was turned down by officials. Their explanation was that "EU law does not allow that" (a single state to ditch DST).
- return0 10y agoThis will be useful when we've colonized a few planets. Until then, hell no.
- ajmurmann 10y agoI have huge issues with DST and how we measure time in general (24hours, 60 minutes, 60 seconds?! Who the f* came up with these crazy ass numbers?!). But what bugs me much more is the insane calendar. 12 Months with arbitrary numbers of days. That's just crazy. In the very least we could make it so that January to May have 31 days and the remaining months get 30. ideally we would switch to the positivist calendar. That would make everything date related trivial, easy to remember and calculate.
- AckSyn 10y agohttp://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2011/11/15/3364432.htm http://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2011/11/15/3364432.ht... > Our 24-hour day comes from the ancient Egyptians who divided day-time into 10 hours they measured with devices such as shadow clocks, and added a twilight hour at the beginning and another one at the end of the day-time, says Lomb. "Night-time was divided in 12 hours, based on the observations of stars and https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/experts-time-division-days-hours-minutes/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/experts-time-divi... If you had such huge issues, google was a quick fix for them.
- ajmurmann 10y agoAre you kidding me? I know it comes from the ancient Egyptians. That's not a fix, that's an explanation and it's an explanation that makes it even worse. It's the equivalent of a conversation that goes like this: A: Why do you guys have these weird variable names in your code that you touch every day? B: Well, the company was started in the 70s by a bunch of Egyptians who named their variables in Egyptian. A: But they are all gone now, right and nobody here speaks Egyptian anymore? B: Yeah. A: Why did you never rename it? This stuff makes it really hard to ramp up. B: *shrug* Only that this happened 2000+ years ago! Plenty of time to refactor that shit. It's even worse if you look at the purposefully broken month names. September to December are named "7th" to "10th". However, some arrogant pricks decided to inject their own names as months in between and couldn't even bother fixing the months whose names they now broke. And nobody bothered in the meantime to go back and fix it. It's 2000 years later and instead of fixing it we coerced most of mankind into using this obviously broken piece of crap. EDIT: Formatting
- taf2 10y agoI wish this was about day light savings and the random changing of the time zone. I can live with the different time zones and I think they are even kind of nice, but day light savings changing the current time, is terrible. You could argue it had cost real money (think azure going offline) and think of all the countless other hours people have spent dealing with the change.
- brongondwana 10y agoCome back to me when you've managed to convince the USA to adopt metric, which is significantly more of a no-brainer than throwing away timezones.
- remoteme 10y agoWe should use local relative times based on sunrise. "I start work at 3 past". Meaning he or she starts work at 3 hours after sunrise.
- bbcbasic 10y agoVery hard to coordinate with other people. If someone is 200km East they'll have a slightly different Sunrise time and you need to take that into account when arranging a phone call for instance.
- foxylad 10y agoWe run a global booking service. Fixed timezones are simple to accommodate, but abolishing daylight savings would save me hours of scribbling clock faces. The issue is that when someone books a given time across a DST change, you need to adjust the unix timestamp in the right direction. And in my experience, your first guess at the direction is always wrong - even if you know your first guess is always wrong. Still, I guess that making a few developer's lives easier is less important than saving several lives a year due to reduced pedestrian deaths.
- nxc18 10y agoScheduling a recurring meeting of busy people (think college students with busy schedules) across continents, cultures and countries is hard enough without timezones and arbitrary changes in daylight savings time. For example, Dubai doesn't have DST - it never changes relative to the others. Kosovo and Croatia change a week before the U.S. changes. Then the U.S. changes but Dubai doesn't. For about 6 weeks out of the year, scheduling is confusing chaos, and a workable schedule under one time configuration very likely doesn't work for the others, keeping in mind that a midday meeting in the U.S. is pushing on midnight in Dubai and family time in central Europe. The whole situation is a disaster, and while manageable, certainly takes a lot of effort, planning, and luck to get right.
- apaprocki 10y agoMaybe I'm the contrarian. I don't mind timezones at all. The thing that throws us for a loop is changing the timezone either temporarily due to some custom (Daylight Savings, Ramadan, elections, etc.) or permanently with little notice (populist tendencies in governments). I maintain timezone infrastructure and what I'd rather see is an international treaty that all changes to country timezones require some standard period of notice. Even 90 days would be better than what we have now. Getting international politicians to care about timezones seems like a losing proposition before even starting, so I was imagining a "hack" to an existing treaty. The best one I could think of was an amendment to the International Maritime Organization (IMO). Perhaps if governments were made aware that screwing with, say, DST 3 days before it is about to go into effect would violate some treaty, they would shy away from that behavior. I know that's something the IATA could get behind.
- the_watcher 10y agoNo, you aren't contrarian. Remove timezones, and it still doesn't help me sort out if it's morning in Italy yet, or if business hours have started. In fact, it's more difficult, since I'd then have to figure out what Italian business hours are.
- stouset 10y agoYou still have to figure out what Italian business hours are in the current system. Do they show up to work at 9? 8? 10? I don't know, do you?
- aomega08 10y agoMost schools and public offices open at 8 am. Factories and offices usually run business from 9 to 18, but YMMV ;)
- the_watcher 10y agoI know that Italian business hours do not start at 18:00:00. That's absolutely not a fair example.
- 10y ago
- reflexive 10y agoThe advantage of daylight savings is I can set my schedule to wake up at the same time each day, while maximizing my daylight hours and never getting up before dawn. Without the shift for daylight savings, the sunrise time in San Francisco varies from 5:47a at the summer solstice, to 8:25a just after winter solstice. If I set my schedule to get up at 8:25a every day, I'd miss a significant amount of morning sunlight. The beauty of daylight savings is it shifts the sunrise time to be earlier in winter, so instead of 8:25a the sun rises at 7:25a. Thus I can set my schedule to get up at 7:25a and get an extra hour of sunlight every day. (Technically the latest sunrise time is just before shifting from daylight to standard, 7:39a on November 5 - the point is we reduce the range of variation from 2hrs 38min to 1hr 38min)
- parthdesai 10y agoAnd yet by the time i leave my work at 5:30-6 pm, it is pitch dark. I personally would prefer having some daylight after work.
- reflexive 10y agoIn that case, your ideal daylight savings would move the clock forward in the fall and backward in the spring, so that sunset remains close to the same time year round.
- cheiVia0 10y agoNo, just get up earlier and leave work earlier.
- reflexive 10y agoThis is true if your only goal is to maximize the amount of daylight you have after work - taken to its logical conclusion, you would just go to work in the middle of the night and get off in the morning. However, if you add the constraint that you never want to go to bed before sunset, you will improve by adjusting the clock so sunset is at a relatively constant time.
- irascible 10y agoGlobal, linear, synchronized utc time for computers, and local noon when sun hits zenith, for humans.. would be my preference.
- leroy_masochist 10y agoMeh. The military has been trying to run everything on Zulu time for years and it hasn't gotten a lot of traction because everyone seems to hate it. (Speaking from experience on the ground side, I know it is a bit more commonplace and accepted in the aviation community). At least as far as the US is concerned, if we're going to change a major standard of measurement, let's focus on going over to the metric system.
- egypturnash 10y agookay so let's substitute one completely arbitrary time measurement (Greenwich Mean Time, which is basically "solar time outside an observatory in Greenwich, England") for an intricate set of time zones that is, admittedly, confusing, but also has some vague relationship to "solar time in the area covered by the time zone" it'll be great almost everyone on the entire planet will have to get used to workday hours being different numbers, and we'll still have to do timezone calculations when we want to try and make realtime contact with someone in what was formerly another time zone it'll be super awesome oh hell let's just all switch to Swatch Internet Time while we're at it, throw out all the analog clocks. (I mean yeah, fuck daylight savings time anyway, but sure let's throw out the baby along with the bathwater and make life marginally easier for people who regularly schedule intercontinental phone calls. They're the only people whose opinion matters evidently.)
- bitwize 10y agoTime zones I'm okay with. But DST needs to GTFO.
- peterwwillis 10y agoHas anyone else noticed that dialing a phone number to call or text someone is like using their IP address to send them an e-mail?
- cushychicken 10y agoChina has one time zone. People outside of Beijing and the eastern Chinese seaboard don't experience sunrise until as late as 10 AM in some places. I don't find that terribly sensible, frankly. It might make scheduling communication easier, but I agree with a lot of the other comments pointing out that 9 AM actually means something to people as far as time of day goes.
- vidoc 10y agoVery interesting article, I've wondered about a universal time several times, tons of pros and cons sure, but it's cool to think that people are thinking about such disrupting alternatives. Reminds me this cool episode of 99% invisible[1] where they talk about calendar design, in particular, Kodak company used a 28-day/13 month design calendar until the 70s and it turns out it was beloved by teams who were doing a lot of forecasts. 1: http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-calendar/ http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-calendar/ When I see how tough it is to move to the metric system in the US, I'm not quiet sure we'll ever see such a change any time soon tho!
- PapaSlug 10y agoYes this was my favourite episode!
- ChicagoDave 10y agoHaving worked on computers for 30 years and seeing a recent uptick in globalization of system usage, getting rid of time zones would be a fucking awesome change to localization nightmares with data. DO IT!!!
- gdw2 10y agoI would imagine for many places, a normal 'day' would actually be split across two dates. That would be confusing!
- henrikschroder 10y agoYes, it would be extremely confusing! Let's say you have a coffee shop in Hawaii. You are closed Sundays. You are of course closed in the middle of the "day" on Sunday, because it's nighttime where you are. Which daylight period are you closed? The period that starts on Saturday but continues into Sunday, or the period that starts on Sunday and continues into Monday? What do you write on the door of your coffee shop? Having a single timezone is such a stupid idea, and yet someone brings it up again and again and again and again.
- m1sta_ 10y agoA single, open, calendar interface for all people would solve this. I cannot see that happening though.
- jameshart 10y agoThis proposal focuses on timezones as names for hours and completely glosses over what the relationship is between timezones and days. Does Monday November 7th 2016 run from 00:00 UTC - 23:59 UTC? Do people in Sydney start work at 21:00 UTC on Sunday and come home at 17:00 UTC on Monday? Or do different places around the world have different times when they flip the calendar over? (in which case you've just recreated timezones by another name). You don't get to get rid of the international dateline, either, because when every country chooses which two daylight-periods a week to use as their local weekend, even if everybody aligns them with their closest neighbors to the east and west right the way round the world, someone's going to find themselves having to make a choice between matching their western neighbor or their eastern one, because they disagree by a day.
- jeroen94704 10y agoExcellent point. Getting rid of timezones would mean most people would have to switch to a different _date_ at some random point (determined by their longitude) during the day. Very impractical.
- jwfxpr 10y agoThe United States still uses Imperial measurements and Fahrenheit, and the NYT publishes an article arguing for an unnecessary, human-unfriendly re-standardisation of time zone(s)...? Mmhmmm. The whole world's gonna take THAT idea seriously.
- glandium 10y agoI agree with the sentiment in many of the threads that this is an awful idea, OTOH, there is some level of condusion with time zones in the US: I don't live in the US, but the few times I went there, it took me a while to figure the whole "8|7c" thing for TV programs, where, AIUI, east and west coast get to have programs at the same local time (8), but obviously not the same absolute time, and states in the middle get to have programs at the same absolute time as the east coast, but earlier in their day (7). Or did I get it wrong, and the whole thing is even more confusing?
- jeffwilcox 10y agoEven more confusing on the TV show timing now thanks to Internet streaming. Westworld on HBO may technically broadcast at 10pm Eastern, and on HBO west it is broadcast at 10pm Pacific, but then it's also available on HBO Go and HBO Now to stream at 10pm Eastern.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoNo, just no. You still need to keep track of local times relative to the Sun because that's important. And time zones are the best way to do that. We could improve our usage of time zones, but abandoning time zones is just a silly idea.
- henrikschroder 10y agoThis is stupid. This is obligatory reading: https://qntm.org/abolish https://qntm.org/abolish
- syrrim 10y agoLets review the arguments: - Time hasn't always had zones, so why not get rid of those too? - Nazi germany, communist china, and north korea all do it, so clearly this is a policy befitting the modern world. Presumably alongside mass censorship and death camps.
- petre 10y agoFirst get rid of leap seconds.
- contingencies 10y agoThe author James Gleick wrote The Information which was recently recommended to me but I found a bit slow-going and obtuse. It didn't really resonate with me coming from a comp-sci pragmatist background, though some here may enjoy it. As far as TZ's go, IMHO one of the biggest issues is the TZ database which itself lacks support for i18n and many modern pragmatic concerns. I once made a proposal to modernize it but it fell on deaf ears... it is, understandably, fairly conservatively maintained.
- saretired 10y agoThis editorial seems to assume that clocks were more or less synchronous prior to the introduction of time zones -- this is completely false. Time zones were introduced (at the behest of the railroads in the U.S.) because communities had their own local mean time, and often those communities were not distant from one another. In other words, there were an indeterminate number of time zones worldwide. The current time zone map, for all of its peculiarities, is hardly difficult for people to grasp: it gets light in the early hours, etc. China has a single time zone for the entire country--perhaps the author expects a Maoist ``harmonization dividend'' worldwide but speaking to Chinese friends over the years I'm not convinced that such a happy dividend ever materialized there.
- laurieg 10y agoI think less reliance on clock time would be a good thing for the modern world, but I don't think getting rid of time zones would achieve that. It's amazing how much of modern life is unnecessarily affected by the time on the clock. When daylight savings time rolls round in the UK you can make 60 million people change their schedule by an hour, and even miss an hour of sleep while doing so! Who would have thought the humble clock had such control over people? In the modern world of plenty, why is it so incredibly rare to meet someone who goes to bed when they're tired and wakes up when they're not?
- mememachine 10y agoTime zones make cross-geographical communication far easier. This is important in the age of the internet.
- ryanbertrand 10y agoIt would reduce a lot of code in Date libraries :)
- guilt 10y agoI think the first thing to dump is the daylight savings time concept. Then rebase the timezones based on UTC. It won't help when you have a polar winter or a midnight summer - but at least it will remove unnecessary conversions.
- nullc 10y agoWe can't even manage to agree to get rid of the nearly pointless and _highly_ disruptive leap second...
- endymi0n 10y agoPublic Service Announcement: https://qntm.org/abolish https://qntm.org/abolish (So you want to abolish Time Zones...)
- stretchwithme 10y agoI've been thinking this for years, as dealing with time has been a chore in software development. But I think it would make life simpler for those with the resources to deal with time zones and harder for those with less resources. You wouldn't want a change made in medicine that made life easier for doctors but harder for patients, would you? I'm mean, which is trained to deal with complexity and is well paid to do it? And which is often overwhelmed with what's happening to them? Of course, software is going to make time easier and easier to deal, so perhaps it doesn't matter if we change how we deal with it or not. Not in the long run anyway. Software may get so good at dealing with time that we each can deal with it exactly how we want to and the software we used to share information will seamlessly deal with all the translation back and forth.
- Lazare 10y agoI remember when I thought the same thing. Then I spent a couple hours thinking about it, and realized what a terrible idea it was. In my day to day life, I often need to talk to fellow tech people (engineers, support, etc.) in my own time zone, but also in places such as Sydney (2 hours behind me) or California (20 hours behind me). As a society, we've agreed that tech people like that are generally working 9-5, give or take, and we have a universally agreed mapping of locations to adjustments to local time (aka, time zones). This means that I can look at a clock and realize "oh, it's only 10am, I shouldn't expect a reply to my email to that guy in Sydney yet". Even if I'm dealing with a place I'm not really familiar with, I can look up the timezone, or just google "time in Berlin", and I now can translate appropriately. But what if we abolished that mapping (aka, timezones)? Presumably every location would just continue on about their life as before. Sydneysiders with desk jobs would stop working 9-5 AEST, and would start working 19-3 UTC; New Yorkers in similar roles would be working 4-12 UTC. Sounds odd, but it would quickly start to seem normal. Problem: We just abolished the mapping tables that let me adjust for local time. It was trivial to work out that my Sydney colleague was probably out to lunch at 12:45 AEST, but how am I meant to know if he'll be out to lunch at at 22:45 UTC? The only way to make this work is to have or create some form of mapping that tells me the adjustments to make to bring Sydney schedules in line with my own schedule. Eg, "I go to lunch at 00:30 UTC, and Sydney is about 2 hours behind me, so they'll be at lunch now". Because without that table, I simply have no clue what (or rather when) people in Sydney are doing. But that table is just another word for time zones, the thing we abolished. Even better: While there are work arounds, most of them are very difficult to computerize. For example, I could check the corporate website of the guy I'm trying to call, and see if they have office hours (in UTC), and then try an work out when they'll be at lunch, but my calendar app wouldn't be able to do that. It needs a formal, agreed upon table of adjustments. Which would be time zones, whatever we want to call them. TL;DR: This is an idea that makes a lot of sense to people who only have to deal with people who are geographically close to them. If you're actually dealing with people around the world, time zones are not an inconvenience, they're critical.
- taejo 10y agoIf you're only dealing with people geographically close to you, you might as well all agree on a convenient local timezone, with features like not changing the date in the middle of the work day.
- sschueller 10y agoSwatch tried to do that a 'very' long time ago: https://www.swatch.com/en/internet-time/ https://www.swatch.com/en/internet-time/
- captainmuon 10y agoAnother radical idea, we could do the opposite: Use local astronomical time everywhere. One reason unified time zones were introduced were train timetables. I haven't used one directly in quite a while, instead I've used websites, apps and public displays. They could all accommodate for the fact that different train stations had slightly different times. Unified time is also important for TV show airing times. But scheduled TV is getting less and less important compared to video on demand. (Also if you really wanted to, future set-top boxes could modify the text of announced times on-the-fly. Text-to-speach has become pretty good :-)) I believe this would also encourage places to adjust their opening hours relative to sunlight, which would probably be healthier and better for the environment in the long run.
- tancybertitan 10y agoStop upvoting stupid posts. Time zones is a perfectly sound way of calculating the current time on anywhere on the planet. We should just try to improve it by removing skewed concepts like daylight saving and non uniform time zones. Saying that we need to get rid of the concept of time zones is saying we need to get rid of the metric system.
- vacri 10y agoGiven how difficult it's been to get the US and the UK to adopt something as simple as a sane measurement for distance, it's weird that so many people think that it's even vaguely possible to get them to change measurements for something as complex as timekeeping...
- mcs_ 10y agoif the problem are the financial operations let them have a Time Zone. Consideration, if you plan something at 8 am, who/what makes that possible? probably a clock! so: 1) reset the time, 2) start having business related time zone 3) start having speed related time operations my clock tells me when i have to speed up or slow down to accomplish a task. There are a lot of applications that can contribute to a better life: Speed Clock for Uber! Speed Clock for development Speed Clock for ... I mean, who cares about 2016 AC at this point? You can always have a coca cola party with gifts in some moment in the "year" if you want. (Note: this idea is absurd and will never works)
- benjaminmhaley 10y agoActually we need local and universal time. Say you have a meeting with remote participants. You want to know that it's at 9am UTC. With only that everyone knows when to meet. You also want to know that it's at 4am local time. That way you know that you will be asleep. Universal time is useful for communicating. Local time is good for understanding whether people are likely working, eating, or sleeping.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoThe vote is in: I like the idea and my wife hates it :-) I agree that using Earth Time would harmonize business and personal relations around the world. I work remotely, and time zone calculations for scheduling meetings, etc. are a small inconvenience, but why have any inconvenience at all?
- smokedoutraider 10y agoSo time would only make sense if you're in England. As most things coming from the nytimes lately, this is another pathetic joke. Now dropping daylight savings, that does make a lot of sense.
- btbuildem 10y agoNix the DST, but keep the timezones. Maybe clean them up a bit (standard 24 or smth).
- daveheq 10y agoThis is idiotic; it would actually have the same problem but worse: translating time to where the sun is relative to Earth. It's called false simplification; it looks easier on the surface but is actually more difficult for the person, just for some blog writer's own convenience.
- mvindahl 10y agoThere should be a single, unified time across the globe. It would greatly simplify matters. I propose something like Friday around five-ish in the afternoon.
- knz 10y agoThere is - it's called UTC+0000!
- joquarky 10y agoI agree with getting rid of the DST switch. But getting everyone to use UTC is messy. If you're going to overhaul the system, why not base time on the longitude where the sun is at the meridian (noon)? Of course, you'd have to use degrees with decimals to avoid confusion over minutes and seconds. And even then, it might be better to use a term other than degrees to avoid confusion with the weather.
- OOPMan 10y agoI don't mind timezones, but DST is the devil. And I don't even live in a country that has it.
- MistahKoala 10y agoWhat if there were two sets of time? The 'local' timezone, as we know it, and a universal timezone - like Swatch attempted to create with Beats way back (in the last century?).
- srtjstjsj 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coordinated_Universal_Time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coordinated_Universal_Time
- norea-armozel 10y agoThis is definitely not an issue I think that can be solved by merely doing away with time zones. Time zones at least in the US were part of coordinating arrival and departure times for the railroad which was a big problem when two towns that were mere miles apart were on two different times (sometimes by an hour). I think the real problem is that every governing body involved with time measures seems to think theirs is the best. UTC is awesome but by itself it's not enough to synchronize with local habits which are dictated by solar time (even when considering the most extreme ranges of time zones). At the heart of the matter is how do you fix time zones such that governments respect solar time over their own desired time frame fork human activity? Honestly, I have no solution beyond a fierce beating of the average legislator/bureaucrat. Because honestly timezones should be in 15 degree slices around the Earth since that approximates well with the shape of it. Mind you, for people living near or at the poles is going to be a mess for them regardless of how you settle it but the majority of humans a simple 15 degree slice of the Earth gets the time zone problem as close to a solution as possible. But the odds of any major government (or even local government) adopting this is nil. So I just pray no one actually tries to reform the existing timezones otherwise we'd might get something worse.
- neves 10y agoWill it be easier than to make America use the metric system?
- paulvs 10y ago> New York (with its longitudinal companions) will be the place where people breakfast at noon, where the sun reaches its zenith around 4 p.m., and where people start dinner close to midnight. He must mean latitudinal companions..
- runeks 10y agoWe already have a universal time zone, UTC. Anyone is free to use it and some do, mostly in software. Why do we need to "dump" anything? Just use UTC for coordinating time globally, and local time zones for local coordination.
- wst_ 10y agoCould anyone, please, explain to me why 12:00 the noon is 12PM? Why PM? I come from Europe so it may be not so obvious to me. My reasoning is, assuming 12h clock, we have 12:00 twice a day. Once in the morning and once at night. So it would be only natural to say 12PM at midnight, not at noon. Since we already are dividing day for two halves, why not use exactly the same division for AM/PM? And yet, in the morning we (or actually you guys) are saying 11AM but 12PM.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- detaro 10y agoI think the best explanation is that AM means "before noon" and PM means "after noon" (ante meridiem/post meridiem), and it works better this way for all minutes after the hour: 12:01 PM is after noon, 12:01 AM is before noon (of the day it occurs on). Exactly noon and exactly midnight then are edge cases that don't make much sense, but they probably would be either way. Language probably used noon/midnight for a long time, only in newer times people started to write numbers for those as well.
- atomicUpdate 10y agoThe AM/PM lines are drawn at midnight and noon exactly. So from 00:00 to 11:59 it's AM, then from 12:00 to 23:59 it's PM. With your logic, The AM/PM lines would be drawn at 01:00 and 13:00. I think most people would find that counterintuitive, since each day draws the line at 00:00, but it would still be PM for another hour after that.