33 ms·
I'm really amazed by all the supporters on here. When I first heard about Soylent, I thought it was a terrible terrible idea. I mean, there's so much to food. I
by djsumdog 10y ago
I'm really amazed by all the supporters on here. When I first heard about Soylent, I thought it was a terrible terrible idea. I mean, there's so much to food. It's not just eating it, it's all the flavours and ingredients and cooking with friends and loved ones and parties and such. I'm guessing most people on here use it as a supplement + regular food, but when I saw it originally, it seemed like it was intended to be someone's only source of food.
I think I'll just stick to Quest bars when I'm too busy to eat right. :-P
- kinkdr 10y ago> there's so much to food. It's not just eating it, it's all the flavours and ingredients and cooking with friends and loved ones and parties and such Food is like sex. There are times for long love making session, times for a orgies in a well equipped dungeon, but there are also timea for a quick masturbation. You can think soylent as the last.
- themodelplumber 10y ago> I think I'll just stick to Quest bars Oooh, protein bar talk! Lately I'm liking EAS Myoplex 30 Chocolate Peanut Butter and NuGo Dark Mint Chocolate Chip. For when I'm uh..."too busy"...
- nether 10y agoRhinehart asserted from the start that Soylent was meant to replace shitty meals like the Big Mac consumed at your desk alone. There was and still is a lot of misunderstanding about this. One of his interviews took place at some LA hipster fried chicken place. He's not antifood or antisocial.
- eridius 10y agoReally? When Soylent was first announced, I'm pretty sure I read something where Rhinehart was positioning Soylent as the primary source of meals, with the occasional real meal thrown in as a luxury.
- rgbrenner 10y agoHe asserted this from the start??? Here's the Tilt crowdfunding page: https://wayback.archive.org/web/20141012152640/https://crowdtilt.soylent.me/soylent-free-your-body https://wayback.archive.org/web/20141012152640/https://crowd... Note, it's titled "Soylent Free Your Body". Here are some phrases in the short post: "What if you never had to worry about food again?" "Soylent frees you from the time and money spent shopping, cooking and cleaning, puts you in excellent health, and vastly reduces your environmental impact by eliminating much of the waste and harm coming from agriculture, livestock, and food-related trash." Packages available: $255 One month supply of Soylent We'll ship enough soylent to fully replace one month's worth of meals This is after he went on a 30 day experiment titled "How I Stopped Eating Food" http://robrhinehart.com/?p=298 http://robrhinehart.com/?p=298
- batbomb 10y agoDon't forget: "Soylent™ was developed from a need for a simpler food source." "No need to shop for individual ingredients or plan ahead" (I think this one was Mealsquares) "You’ve got more important things to do than worry about food." "Enjoy a 26 hour day" I wrote a parody post based on the marketing on the web page and my own personal outrage with the claims: https://medium.com/@__1/on-food-and-not-cooking-4c9fba0d2d20 https://medium.com/@__1/on-food-and-not-cooking-4c9fba0d2d20 I still believe my note is true: Note: Neither Soylent nor Mealsquares make any public claims that I could find, beneficial or otherwise, about using their product for the complete nutrition of women, especially those expecting or nursing, children, teenagers, the elderly, or people with medical conditions, including malnutrition. I think it’s probably optimized for healthy males, aged 20–40-ish, or in the words of Soylent: “All Adults”, but I don’t have a B.S. in Electrical Engineering like Rob, so I probably shouldn’t comment. Please proceed at your own risk just in case.
- batbomb 10y agohttps://vimeo.com/107941191 https://vimeo.com/107941191
- enneff 10y agoBelieve it or not, some people are just not really into food. Just like some people are not into music or sports.
- phowat 10y agoI'm really not into food. I force myself to eat. If it wasn't for me trying to bulk up I'd eat just one meal a day and be fine. I force myself to eat 2800 to 3000 calories per day and it's a HUGE pain in the ass. Since I first heard about Soylent I wished they'd start selling Here in Brazil. This report doesn't change that.
- Daishiman 10y agoTo be honest, Brazilian food is IMO some of the most bland and least interesting in the continent, so it wouldn't be suprising. A lot of people think they don't like fish because they've never tasted fresh fish.
- virmundi 10y agoI appreciate your position. I agree there is more to good than mere nutrition. There is also a segment on HN that likes the idea of hacking biology, especially their own. They seem good more as fuel for an engine than something to be enjoyed.
- esotericsean 10y agoI don't really care about food. If I didn't have to eat anymore, that would be amazing! I tried Soylent and it was disgusting, though. Couldn't stomach it.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoHonest question: Why not just make yourself a bowl of lentils? Definitely more nutritious than this stuff and very easy to make it bulk/reheat.
- Karunamon 10y agoMore nutritious? Uh... no. I have no idea why you'd think that. The nutrition facts[1] on the powder show that you can basically live on the stuff and receive 100% of your micro and macro nutrients. Which is the whole point. [1]: https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0421/5993/t/4/assets/Complete-Soylent-Nutrition-Facts.pdf https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0421/5993/t/4/assets/Compl...
- greglindahl 10y agoUh, you realize that nutrient absorption means that you can't just eat the molecules that you need and stay healthy? That's why products in the same space as Soylent, like Ensure, have a lot of research involved.
- Karunamon 10y agoGiven the amount of people that are consuming large amounts of this stuff and reporting their progress, I'd have expected any serious nutrient deficiencies to have been reported quite a while ago.
- greglindahl 10y agoI'd suggest that you read research on the topic instead of having expectations. Some things only affect some people. Other things take a long time to develop.
- fusiongyro 10y agoI absolutely love food and I'd say a significant amount of my hobby budget goes into food and cooking supplies. I was an early Soylent supporter because my wife and I were curious about it and thought it might be inexpensive and sensible to replace our lunch meals with it. If we both worked through lunch, hilariously, we could have had an extra hour to spend cooking dinner. Not every meal of my day needs to be a fine dining experience. Also, my wife was pregnant, and having a lot of random food aversions. The idea of something you could just sort of mindlessly drink was appealing to her. She tried it once and really hated it. I tried it twice and also really hated it. So it didn't stick for us, but I liked the idea of it. I brought it to the place I was working at the time and one of the engineers there really took to it, ate all the rest of it over the course of a few weeks. Different strokes.
- otuutti 10y agoIf you stopped solely based on taste you should just try a couple similar products, eg. ambronite might fit the bill pretty spot on.
- Matachines 10y agoEvery time Soylent is on HN people say this. Why don't people understand? It's so simple: Soylent is for meals you don't care about but need. It's not a) the ONLY food you can eat or b) supposed to replace all meals. I order a box of Soylent bottles every few weeks—they come in handy while working or for a quick breakfast or if I have little time and am hungry. I also cook meals with my girlfriend a few times a week and go out to dinner every weekend. Both things can exist at the same time. It's just a nutritious drink you can drink at any time if you need to. If you want to make it most of our meals, sure go ahead. But no one says you must.
- ng12 10y ago> Soylent is for meals you don't care about but need This is the problem. That concept is completely foreign to a lot of people (me included). The combination of my body's needs and the way I was raised lead me to view each meal as an opportunity to be enjoyed, never a chore. Something I observed in the weightlifting community: there are people who need to worry about dieting (cutting) and people who worry about eating enough (bulking). Serious weightlifters go through cycles of both but most people struggle more with one side or another. Bulking isn't a struggle for me -- I can clear 5,000 kcal/day without a sweat. I've trained myself to eat pretty healthy but I'd always prefer steak and eggs for breakfast. On the other hand, a friend of mine complains about all the pizza he has to eat to meet his targets. Soylent makes a lot of sense for him (quick calories) but I'll never understand that feeling of "ugh, I need to eat, guess I'll have a Soylent".
- greatjones 10y ago> but I'll never understand that feeling of "ugh, I need to eat, guess I'll have a Soylent". It sounds like you have either more free time or a more a steady work schedule then their target user.
- cko 10y agoI have all the free time in the world and I have that "ugh do I really need to eat again?" I find it hard to hit 2500 calories daily to not lose weight.
- labster 10y agoNot all people taste food the same way. Some people don't have a strong sense of taste, so eating Soylent all/some of the time is just not a big deal to them. Just the same as how some people are tone deaf, so music is not important to them. Or colorblind people can't tell the difference between red and green, so stoplights aren't a big deal to them. Wait a minute... But really I think a lot of the Soylent hate comes from the fact that people assume their own senses are the best judge, when really we only have a sample size of one. It doesn't even have to be a lack of sense acuity as I said above, but just personal taste. People come in all different types, and that's cool.
- duaneb 10y agoI'm anorexic. This shit is amazing.
- greglindahl 10y agoThere are a lot of products, like Ensure, which have a much longer researched track record than Soylent. It's more than sticking a few things into a powder.
- kazagistar 10y agoAs far as I can tell, Ensure is just sugary chocolate milk with vitamin pills, ie it has horrible macro-nutrient balance. Its not like these companies do their own research anyways; its an application of the same nutritional studies everyone else has access too.
- greglindahl 10y agoAnd I see no evidence that Soylent paid any attention to basic things, like what you need to also eat in order to absorb the necessary nutrients. While Ensure has more sugar that I'd like, at least it's not totally ignorant.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>And I see no evidence that Soylent paid any attention to basic things, like what you need to also eat in order to absorb the necessary nutrients. Care to elaborate? What exactly do you mean by "what you need to also eat in order to absorb the necessary nutrients"?
- webscaleizfun 10y agoDifferent food items will have different absorption rates for the nutrients they contain when passing through your stomach, upper & lower intestine. For example, an apple may contain a small amount of iron absorbed at a rate of 20%, while a steak may contain significantly more, with an absorption rate of 80%. These absorption rates can also vary widely from person to person, based on the flora in your gut, the drugs you ingest, your diet, and also certain DNA (eg. most East Asians never developed specific lactose related digestive abilities [1]) and ancestry can significantly alter this too. For example, my grandfather had issues with high iron absorption, thus he would regularly donate blood to get rid of the excess iron in his bloodstream. Neither I nor my immediate family share that issue, but he made dietary choices based in part on avoiding iron rich food (like the iron enriched cookies I used to eat, mmm). TL;DR: Your body & the food you eat are very complex things to understand, and we understand the tiniest sliver about it. Highly processed food likely misses important nutrients you need. 1 - https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/condition/lactose-intolerance#statistics https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/condition/lactose-intolerance#statis...
- Itsdijital 10y agoI did a DIY soylent diet for ~6 months last year. I had maybe 1 regular meal every 2 weeks during that time. Honestly, it fucking kicked ass. I'll list some of the pros and cons Pro - Easy to make - Portable - Little mess/no cleaning - More time to do other stuff - Most insane regular shits. 2pm everyday, sit, shit, 2x wipe, done in 30 seconds. Every shit was exactly the same. - Never any indigestion, gas, diarrhea, sick feeling - Never felt hungry. Like I would go weeks without feeling that sensation - Felt really good overall - Skin disease cleared up for the first time in over a decade - Perfect control over calories and macro composition - Cheap(ish), $7 a day. Cons - Bland/bad taste and texture - Gets old fast (like "Ugghh, not this again") - Must drink lots of water with it. (really only a con because I had to carry a water bottle too, but water is good for you) - Takes a while to drink, at least for me. - Piss is neon yellow (from vitamin B, not really a con, just odd) - People are kind of freaked out by it - Doesn't store well in liquid form, so must be made each time before drinking or at least daily. - Needs some time to sit (~30 min) after making or else it has a really bitter taste. - First 2 weeks were brutal. Felt all manner of sick and uneasy from it. My body felt all out of wack. Intense headaches too. Others had warned of this so I pushed on. I was about to give up but on day 13 I woke up feeling great and it was smooth sailing from then on out. Guess it was my body adjusting? I had a really shit diet before that. Right now I am still drinking them but way less, maybe 6 a week down from 21 a week. Regular food is just so good. But I plan to go back to it in the near future.
- LordHumungous 10y agoArmies have mutinied over bad food and here you are voluntarily subsisting on gruel. The 21st century is weird.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- JauntyHatAngle 10y agoWell yeah, armies didn't really have much else to entertain them back in the day. We have enough other stuff in our lives to look forward to that we can sacrifice one part of it. Not that anyone should if they don't want to, just saying I can understand it.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoI love the Soylent concept. I did it for a good amount of last year (before getting a job with free food). My only complaints: * Too expensive * Too inconvenient (It leaves a residue on everything, and mixing a pitcherful consistently was a chore)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- warfangle 10y agoI'm still curious why the soylent thing has hit it off in the HN crowd and not, say, Slimfast. Which is basically the same thing but with more production hardening. Maybe fragile masculinity? IDK.
- carrja99 10y agoHa this is on my mind every single time someone brings up Soylent. Seriously, it's a joke. Some kid makes a knock off slimfast meal supplement and HN is all "Goddamn genius is disrupting meals. This is the future man!" This would make a great Black Mirror episode.
- doublevea 10y agoDid you even compare the nutrition facts before writing this hilariously condescending post?
- aaron-lebo 10y agoI wouldn't attribute it to some kind of nefarious gender issue. It's as simple as marketing, which does matter. Slimfast in it's name implies a diet drink, not food replacement. Most people would never even consider them in the same arena and that's due to simple marketing by the very companies that produce them.
- mysterypie 10y agoYes, I can see that in the case of Soylent vs Slimfast, customer choice is driven by what marketing says is the intended use. But don't be too quick to dismiss masculinity or coolness factors in product selection. Diet Coke and Coke Zero are essentially the same thing made by the same company (the latter having a slightly different "flavor profile"). Coke Zero exists because some men or many men will not order a Diet Coke: it's sissy or uncool. Coke Zero was introduced solely for that reason.
- martin_bech 10y ago
- thaumaturgy 10y agoThere's a niche that Soylent has been really helpful in, that pretty much everyone seems to have ignored so far (including Soylent-the-company, who I sent an email to regarding this and received back a form letter response that hadn't had all of its fields filled in). Backpacking, hiking, search and rescue, hunting, anything outdoors. I carry an unopened package of Soylent powder in my SAR pack and I've been glad I have it several times. Take a Nalgene, fill it up to about 300 ml with powder, add water, shake vigorously, and now you have enough fuel to ease fatigue for several hours. It's lightweight and convenient and easy. Cleanup is simple. Now when I'm peak-bagging my default is just to carry some Soylent with me. The only time I carry my mess kit anymore is if I'm going out with the intention of a morning, afternoon, or evening meal ritual being a planned part of the trip. Like, "let's hike out to Phoenix Lake and have a nice hot dinner at sunset." Otherwise, Soylent. I've been gradually becoming a disciple of the ultralight over the last couple of years and food weight is challenging to whittle down. The alternatives, freeze-dried anything, are mostly disgusting and still require carrying a stove, fuel, and require cleanup. Soylent has reduced my pack weight and size by quite a bit, and (for the most part) I'm getting better nutrition overall because I can just chug it in small doses throughout the day. It also means I'm less likely to develop a fatigue-related injury. It's gotten some attention from other folks on my SAR team and my longtime hiking partner has started giving it a try too. It doesn't seem to be something that's really caught on in the outdoor industry yet. I really wish Soylent would sell small, lightweight packages of the powder that were pre-sized to mix with about .8 liters of water and then get it into places like REI, but I guess that's not something they're very interested in.
- enraged_camel 10y agoI tried the powder when backpacking like you described when I went on a camping trip last year. The problem is that you need to rinse the Nalgene bottle thoroughly after consuming the Soylent (which means you have to carry excess water, or find a water source relatively quickly). Otherwise it stinks like hell. I found Soylent 2.0 and Coffiest work a lot better, since their bottles are disposable. Just put it in your trash bag and you're good.
- skookum 10y agoHow do you deal with the Nalgene getting funky once you're >1 days into a trip, or does the Soylent rinse out cleanly enough for it to not be a concern? I used to use Accelerade for a significant proportion of my calories when backpacking - mainly because I have trouble getting down enough solid food when I'm on the go - but switched to Accel gels because the drink mix would leave the bottle pretty nasty after the first day. > The alternatives, freeze-dried anything, are mostly disgusting and still require carrying a stove, fuel, and require cleanup I've found Mountain House to be decently close to tasting like real food and requires no cleanup other than wiping the spoon. A Snow Peak LiteMax with a 750ml titanium pot weigh next to nothing, but there is still the fuel canister. I find the MoHo tasty enough that I'll eat it at home or work on occasion if I really don't want to spend any time on a meal.
- nurettin 10y agoTraditional social eating is deeply embedded into the culture I was brought up in. However, that doesn't stop me from experimenting with food that requires no preparation, no ordering, no waiting when I am in a hurry to accomplish a life goal. That said, of course I would never support "soylent" anything if it is making people energy/immune system/vitamin deficient no matter how many classic dystopian novels it names its food after.
- kaishiro 10y agoI'm equally amazed how every Soylent article that passes through HN has people that seem to be genuinely offended that some people enjoy Soylent/the idea of Soylent and don't want their lives to revolve around "the beauty of food and social blah blah". It's wild.
- akvadrako 10y agoMaybe they are shills for the food industry? I don't get it either - why are they even reading a Soylent article.
- amarka 10y agoMaybe they're not shills, just folks trying to expose themselves to new ideas and possibly caught out by some that upturn their current views. Sometimes they might not understand, so they reach out and converse with others: "I don't understand why anyone would X, because Y has always worked for me." What's so wrong with that conversation and assume they're shills?
- chadcmulligan 10y agoyes I agree, the lack of bulk would be one of the many worries I'd have about eating this regularly (if you know what I mean). Is it really that hard to go and pick up some groceries? This would probably keep you alive for a while, but is it really worth it? even prisoners get better food.
- miend 10y ago> It's not just eating it, it's all the flavours and ingredients and cooking with friends and loved ones and parties and such. One possible angle for explanation is that if you're already missing these things, there's only upside. Additionally, it seems most who use soylent don't use it to replace all meals, but only some where time savings is the primary consideration. Anecdotally, I searched for bars that would do the same thing some years ago, because I had no patience for cooking anything, no friends or family to enjoy it with, and always something more interesting to use my time for. That's still largely true today. Cooking anything more than a very simple meal is a big indulgence, and will leave me questioning why I spent all the time I did preparing it. When cooking these days, usually I will prepare a few days' worth of food at a time, sacrificing time in the short-term for savings later without feeling pressured to eat something quick and unhealthy (and potentially expensive). Soylent -- the idea, not necessarily any particular product -- seems very attractive in this case.
- Latty 10y agoI love food. Too much, I'm very overweight because of it. My initial reaction was the same - why the hell would I want to take calories and not taste something great? It sounded like madness. Then I tried Huel (Soylent equivalent made in the UK), and I get it. The best way I can describe it is that food had become like music for me. Rather than just sitting down and listening to music, I have some music on all the time, in the background. I constantly wanted to be tasting something, eating. I found that by using Huel, I changed that habit. I can prepare it in a minute and drink it quickly, and it stops me feeling hungry. I can limit my calorie intake perfectly without having to think about tracking it, and it means I can avoid thinking about food at all. Then, on occasion, when I go out with friends or whatever, I can have a real meal and really enjoy the tastes. It's like only listening to music when I go out to a concert and that's all I'm doing. It's not for everyone, for sure, but there are definitely real cases for it. I'm sure on the other end of the spectrum, there are people that just don't care about food and this helps them remember to eat the right amount. Assuming that your relationship with food is the same as everyone else's is your mistake.
- M_Grey 10y agoThere are two broad types of Soylent fans... the ones who would normally eat dog shit otherwise, and those who struggle with obesity or anorexia. The former case just doesn't know better, and the latter case is ill and wants an easy solution to a complex problem. Neither group reacts well to reality or criticism of their pet slurry.