34 ms·
> Microsoft introduced a 28" desktop PC No. Microsoft introduced an entirely new kind of tool for digital artists. I'm not one myself, but the Surface Studio m
by throwanem 10y ago
> Microsoft introduced a 28" desktop PC
No. Microsoft introduced an entirely new kind of tool for digital artists. I'm not one myself, but the Surface Studio makes me wish I were. And the people I know who are, are over the moon about it. They can't wait to get their hands on one.
Yes, it's Microsoft that hit it out of the park, and made Apple look amazingly weak by comparison. Today's event wouldn't have been particularly impressive even on its own. By comparison with yesterday's, it's just embarrassing.
- andrewfong 10y agoThis. It's aimed at a very specific group of users and they love it -- e.g. https://www.penny-arcade.com/news/post/2016/10/26/the-surface-studio https://www.penny-arcade.com/news/post/2016/10/26/the-surfac...
- slantyyz 10y agoFor me, the most revealing piece of information from that Penny Arcade article was how much the 27" Cintiq costs ($2500). Makes the Surface Studio seem very affordable for what it offers.
- sosuke 10y agoThe bonus for the Cintiq is that the 12" one I bought over 8 years ago is still working great!
- mozumder 10y agoI use a Mac with an original 30" Cinema display, along with a giant Wacom tablet. The Surface Studio may seem impressive, but as far as workflow goes, the Mac with tablet setup really is perfection. I've never had the desire to look down on the tablet to draw, as the pointer always moves synchronously on screen. In fact, I feel my hand would get in the way of drawing.. Right now it seems like the Apple products are refined perfection, while Microsoft is still trying to figure out its place.
- j2bax 10y agoIn the last two years all of the artists at our studio (which does animation and interactive work) have switched to Cintiq's. We were really apprehensive to make the jump but they all seem extremely happy and some have even reported that pain they experienced after extensive tasks has gone away. I'd be really interested to see how they like the Surface Studio compared to a Cintiq.
- ahlatimer 10y agoDifferent strokes, I imagine. My fiancee is a graphic artist who had a wacom tablet and a cinema display as her setup for a long time, but she got the 27" Cintiq a few months ago and LOVES it. I had similar skepticism that it'd really be that big of a step up, especially given what she was spending on it, but she says it's noticeable improvement on her productivity.
- DigitalJack 10y agoWhether or not it improves her productivity, if she loves working with it, that's worth 100 productivity points. "The enjoyment of one's tools is an essential ingredient of successful work." --Donald Knuth It is worth spending the money, if you have it, to buy the tools you will enjoy working with.
- AJ007 10y agoI never used the Cintiq, but I've been using Wacom tablets for a good 15 years. I owned & used the Surface Pro 2 & 3, and the iPad Pro with pencil. Both have their place - pen on screen or pen off. Working with your pen on a screen, especially a smaller screen, means you lose a good chunk of your visible space. Overall opinion -- it is great for artists that two major companies have made a significant effort on getting the pen on display right.
- criddell 10y agoHow does the iPad Pro with the pencil compare to the Surface Pro? I played with the Surface Pro 4 and had a lot of issues with the palm rejection.
- Retric 10y agoI am basically convinced those are paid Adds. "Overwatch was fast and fun on medium settings. Civ VI is what I’ve played the most on the Studio and it looks and runs fantastic." "When I first saw the device months ago in that secret room at MS, they asked me what I thought. I said, “Well I have no idea if anyone else will want it, but you have made my dream computer.” Nothing about that is, I went out and paid my own money to buy this.
- mynameisvlad 10y agoSo you must've somehow missed the "Just to be clear, I don’t get paid to do any of this stuff but I enjoy doing it and I like to think I’m helping make the Surface better for artists." while reading the article, right?
- Retric 10y agoAdvertising is more than just paying actors to pretend to like something. News articles rephrasing press releases are often also adds. Video game reviews are usually not simply handing money to someone. That does not make them unbiased. People spreading Viral Videos are often unpaid paid, even if they are a critical part of a marketing campaign. Hand someone some free hardware and they don't think is this worth X, just is X cool.
- 1123581321 10y agoI suggest familiarizing yourself with the history of Gabe/PA and the Surface. Gabe initiated the relationship by writing a post out of the blue about its potential as a drawing tool, as well as complaining. In response, Microsoft invited him to a lab to try prototype Surface hardware/software and made a lot of changes based on his feedback. So, they've basically made a machine designed to be liked by him, and they continue to get his feedback to ensure that doesn't change. So, it's not surprising or questionable that his reviews are positive.
- Retric 10y ago
- rayiner 10y agoApple delivered meat and potatoes for ordinary users (albeit with a weird garnish), while Microsoft delivered a molecular gastronomy dessert that a tiny niche has any use for. I don't see how that is to Microsoft's credit, much less "embarrassing" to Apple.
- throwanem 10y agoWe agree, then, that Microsoft has just out-innovated Apple. When would you say is the last time that happened? Has it ever?
- mixedCase 10y agoThe Tablet PC. Prompt the usual "Apple did it best". Yes, but they did not innovate on the format.
- throwanem 10y agoWhen did Clarke and Kubrick work for Microsoft?
- oneeyedpigeon 10y agoThey did, just not in terms of the underlying concept. The sheer size and weight of the iPad was innovative. Doing away with a physical keyboard altogether was innovative. Using a capacitive touchscreen for a far more pleasant user experience was innovative. In short, many small innovations rather than one big one.
- wtetzner 10y agoWell, you could argue that Apple hasn't done a tablet PC. They've done a tablet-sized phone. Of course, where you draw the line between those is probably different for different people.
- icebraining 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Newton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Newton
- gnashville 10y ago> but the Surface Studio makes me wish I were Have you used Surface before? Asking because when I picked one up about a month ago, I had an awful time with it. Makes me think their announcement won't really do anything but look interesting. I could be missing something, though.
- therobot24 10y ago>> when I picked one up about a month ago, I had an awful time with it Did you get to play with it at a store or friends house, or actually take it home and use it for some time. Everyone i've met that has a surface (book, 3, 4, etc) loves it.
- Thriptic 10y agoWhat was your problem with it? I've had the pro 4 for about a month and have honestly loved it
- bilbo0s 10y agoI'm a digital artist myself. I'm a more goal based guy, so I use both Windows and Mac hardware and software. I know that I am probably the target market for both the Macbook Pro and the Surface Studio, but I have to say, I'm not impressed. And I'd argue that the only people who are would have to be Microsoft or Apple fans. Certainly not tech based artists. First, this is a business for me. And I suspect it's a business for anyone that Apple or Microsoft expects to sell this stuff to. And having to pay $3000 for outdated hardware is a tough pill to swallow. The hardware in the Macbook "Pro" is simply inexcusable. (REALLY???? 16GB RAM MAX!?!?!?) But the hardware in the Surface Studio is equally galling. They give you an NVidia what? 965 for $3000??? And the BEST I could even POSSIBLY get would be a 980??? And for that magnanimous gesture on their part I would be obliged to pay a MINIMUM of $4100??? For LAST GENERATION graphics cards???? On a machine purportedly about graphics???? (A 1080 would run both faster AND cooler using LESS power Microsoft. And at this point in time, for a business investment 64GB of RAM should really be offered by anyone NOT trying to screw you. What's the deal Microsoft???) I think to objective observers who were waiting for these presentations... both proved SEVERELY underwhelming considering the pent up expectations. I mean... OK... if you put a gun to my head, I'll probably buy the Surface Studio. But don't expect me to pretend that I don't know that both Microsoft and Apple are robbing me. Sorry for the rant.
- satysin 10y agoWhile I really like the look of the Surface Studio I was shocked at the GPU choice and the fact it comes with a hybrid drive. I mean I do think it is still a good machine even for the price but come on!
- meerita 10y agoDigital artists? I could program in that machine and be happy :). The only thing I would love is to have the Surface Studio but with OS X.
- stcredzero 10y agoNo. Microsoft introduced an entirely new kind of tool for digital artists. I'm not one myself, but the Surface Studio makes me wish I were. I'd bet that one could make a revolutionary stats program with the new form factor/interface possibility.
- Pokepokalypse 10y ago> a revolutionary stats program ... SURE! Except, of course, you're not going to be allowed to code it in Python, R, or Octave. Instead, it will be Microsoft(TM) Visual(TM) R#(TM) with the new NetDNA/DCOM/.NET/CloudyMcCloudface Framework (TM)!! (now, with 40% more Cortana!(TM))
- icebraining 10y agoWell, no, it's a regular desktop that runs any application, including those written in Python, R or Octave.
- voltagex_ 10y agoAnd it's even sillier when you consider that Microsoft's invested time/money in both Python [1] and R [2]. 1: https://github.com/Microsoft/PTVS https://github.com/Microsoft/PTVS 2: https://powerbi.microsoft.com/en-us/documentation/powerbi-desktop-r-visuals/ https://powerbi.microsoft.com/en-us/documentation/powerbi-de...
- recursive 10y agoPython runs fine on my surface. What are you talking about?
- thesimpsons1022 10y agoi think the biggest announcement yesterday was microsofts cheap vr.
- mhurron 10y ago> Microsoft introduced an entirely new kind of tool for digital artists Actually I believe they introduced a competitor to the Wacom Cintiq that comes in a variety of sizes and does not require you to use a desktop or Windows 10. Calling it 'an entirely new kind of tool' is really over stating it.
- billconan 10y agoI purchased surface pro 3 for drawing. so disappointed. I don't want to try again. if they are serious about art creation, they should only use wacom technology and nobody else.
- zoom6628 10y agoSome of you may remember when many many years ago Microsoft showed off an interactive coffee table. The Surface. And now finally with Studio they have brought to reality a device that will be nirvana for designers, factory planners, circuit designers and anybody else who can actually use an interactive surface (pun intended). Im a product manager for enterprise software and Im bubbling with ideas that such an eminently usable large screen touch device brings to the market. After decades of heaping scorn on MS for the stuff i had to work with that hasnt improved (talking about you Word, Powerpoint, Excel, Visual Studio) they have post-Balmer become an entirely different company and Im pleased about that. Competition is good for innovation and Studio is truly innovative in engineering and the things it makes possible.
- overgard 10y ago> Microsoft introduced an entirely new kind of tool for digital artists. Not really, you could buy a Wacom Cintiq since about forever. I'm glad they're giving wacom some competition though.
- cma 10y ago> Microsoft introduced an entirely new kind of tool for digital artists. It isn't an entirely new tool, it is an HDR, higher res, larger version of a Cintiq, with a built in slow PC with last-generation mobile graphics. The hinge and stuff was definitely an improved industrial design. Those screen improvements alone are probably enough for lots of professionals to switch from cintiq, even if they lose support for professional-tier desktop hardware, but what about the pen? As far as I can tell the pen doesn't even have tilt detection and from videos you have to use the dial/puck to simulate rotating or tilting the pen. In spite of that, it was definitely more innovative than anything Apple showed.