16 ms·
“No, I'm the ex-CEO of Reddit because eventually there was too much bullshit.”
- vit05 10y agoI liked his other answer. https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/58zaho/the_accuracy_of_voat_regarding_reddit_srs_admins/d95aoft/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/58zaho/the_... It makes me wonder how big reddit could be internationally without major changes. Reddit has over 40% of their traffic from the USA, probably 99% of what is written is in English. The concept and the laws of free speech in America is different from other countries. I do not know if there is a long-term plan, with clearer and universal rules that could be easiest to moderated.
- bshimmin 10y agoI hardly know anything about Reddit and had no idea what "SRS" meant. I googled and found this page https://www.reddit.com/r/SRSsucks/comments/yxvu9/an_explanation_of_what_srs_is_and_why_they_are/ https://www.reddit.com/r/SRSsucks/comments/yxvu9/an_explanat... which left me feeling very content to leave the Reddit people to it. For all the complaints I see about the relative toxicity of HN and its comments, it seems vastly less insane than Reddit.
- unethical_ban 10y agoMy #1 advice for non-internet-addicts is to create a reddit account (no email address required!) and remove every subreddit from your defaults. Then, add back subs based on your interests. Maybe a default or two is acceptable, as some are better moderated than others. But non-defaults tend to have much friendlier, less insulting users. (adding entropy for my identity here) but the minecraft, sailing, and networking subs are good examples of midsize communities that are fun to be in. politics and the_donald and worldnews are examples of garbage. /r/politics really is in the pocket of Hillary Clinton. I say that as a non-Trump voter... the overt bias and suppression of anti-Clinton discussion is staggering.
- ythl 10y ago/r/politics used to be extremely anti-Clinton not too long ago... instead strongly favoring Sanders. But yeah, you'll never see a single pro-conservative story on /r/politics
- Yhippa 10y agoHow on earth did the polarity flip on that one? Amazing.
- mordocai 10y agoIt didn't really. Sanders lost the nomination and a large chunk of his supporters are supporting Clinton now as the "less bad" option.
- bbctol 10y agoAs the election approaches, many more ordinary people start paying attention to politics. In the year before an election, political forums are filled with die-hard supporters of candidates that inspire the most passion; now, the vast contingent of people who prefer Hillary have entered the discussion.
- MrZongle2 10y agoIt's almost as if there were a group of people who felt that the record needed correcting in /r/politics. So to speak. Mission accomplished, by the looks of it today.
- ufo 10y agoIt just means that the sub is more "anti-trump" than "pro-clinton" right now, even though the end result in both cases is similar.
- erics32 10y agoThrough the magic of money and super PACs http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/04/21/hillary-pac-spends-1-million-to-correct-commenters-on-reddit-and-facebook.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/04/21/hillary-pac...
- burkaman 10y agoA lot of Reddit users don't know what SRS is either. That's part of what makes it great, it's pretty easy to completely avoid the shitty parts.
- wlesieutre 10y agoThe problem with SRS wasn't that there were idiots off in their own private subreddit, it was that they took their opinions and vote-brigaded them across the rest of the site. You don't have to go to the shitty parts, the shitty parts come to you.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoNot if you unsub from the defaults, which are garbage.
- digi_owl 10y agoAnyone can link anything to SRS, and that in turn makes the SRS come to you...
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoBut outside of the garbage subs, people don't.
- ubernostrum 10y agoAs a moderator of a medium-sized (~170k subscribers, cyclically reaching 1M pageviews/day because of the topic matter) subreddit, I wish all the people who frequent the meta/drama subreddits would have a big meetup that gets hit by a meteor while they're all there. It's impossible to know what will trigger one of them to come invading, but when one does they all do. If KiA decides they don't like something, Ghazi will inevitably follow to counter them, then SRD will link it up and send their users charging in, SRS will start cherry-picking the worst of the invaders screaming at each other and then... Oh, and there's no good (as in, works consistently) tool I'm aware of to mass-nuke entire threads of comments as a moderator, so I've had plenty of exercises in deleting a couple hundred posts one by one.
- raverbashing 10y agoSRS = "Crap Reddit Says" (you can guess what the 1st word is substituting for)
- nicky0 10y agoShit
- vijayr 10y agoI don't disagree but there are lots of sub reddits without drama and toxicity. Opendata, datasets, babyelephantgifs etc etc. If you choose to ignore subs that have anything to do with politics, religion etc, Reddit can be quite enjoyable
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoThat's also true of 4chan. And the internet in general.
- DarkLinkXXXX 10y agoTrue, but /pol/lacks tend to ruin derail discussions outside of their space. This is not only true of 4chan, but a metaphor for the internet in general.
- qwertyuiop924 10y ago/pol/itical maniacs don't always have a way in: I've never seen that kind of nonsense on boards like /tg/, or /g/ for that matter (although I'm only on /g/ quite rarely: I have a kind of low bile tolerance for a 4chan user).
- VLM 10y agoHe means on HN (the internet as a whole) and so forth. You and I know that /DIY/ (what it sounds like) and /OUT/ (as in outdoors, camping and stuff) have nothing to do with /POL/ the venn diagram is a near perfect non-overlap. Also /hc/ and /s/ (both NSFW) are supposedly politics free. /DIY/ and /OUT/ are possibly the last refuge on the entire internet from marketing shills and paid reviews and all that kind of corruption near omnipresent on the internet.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoI haven't seen to many marketing shills on HN. Outside of the dedicated marketing shill startup threads, that is.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoWhat's the deal with SRS, for those of us who have got reddit blocked?
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoSome bits of reddit are dedicated to mocking or shaming other bits of reddit that are at the opposite end of the political spectrum. I read a book called Reality is Broken recently, and it talked about what people want from games, and it struck me that a lot of this behaviour fitted the description perfectly. They make social connections with other users, they feel like they're making a difference in the world, and every post has points attached to keep score.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoAh. Now it all makes sense...
- EpicEng 10y agoThe level of discourse on HN is a trove if intellectual splendor compared to reddit. I spend time on both, but I try not to comment on reddit because all you tend to get in response is know it all 20 year olds calling you an idiot. Here, even if/when I get into a disagreement, it's mostly fact based and not personal.
- DannyBee 10y agoYeah, it's kind of sad. the only forums i browse on reddit are things like "college football", etc, where it's not really a serious intellectual discussion. Even something like "hey, did i waterproof this shower correctly" on reddit turns into a massive crapfest. https://www.reddit.com/r/DIY/comments/58tl1w/did_i_mess_up_my_shower_install_by_not/ https://www.reddit.com/r/DIY/comments/58tl1w/did_i_mess_up_m... Though, staring at it days later, the top level comments ended up roughly okay. But until everyone mostly moved on, ... (IE if you stared at this thread 2 days ago, it would make you not have any desire to participate in an online forum ever)
- mancerayder 10y agoWhat kills me on sites like reddit are the 'quippy one-liners' in response to arguments. You might write something rationally-crafted, careful to support your conclusion, and someone will respond with a funny-to-them sarcastic sentence, intended to totally obliterate the argument. People fancy themselves cocky and clever enough that reason isn't necessary. A few rofl's in response is all you need (or Likes on another popular service). That's really why HN is the only place I comment.
- Semaphor 10y ago> For all the complaints I see about the relative toxicity of HN and its comments, it seems vastly less insane than Reddit. Well, of course. In the subs I subscribe to every once in a while an HN discussion gets linked because of the quality of the comments. The defaults on Reddit have a ton of SRS/SJWs vs. MensRights/Red Pillers. Also memes and general herd behavior. But there are also subs for pretty much every TV show and game out there. Frameworks and programming languages have subs devoted to them. In general many, many interests have their own subreddits. That's where you can often have intelligent discussions with mostly sensible people. And of course, let's not forget heavily moderated places like the shining star /r/AskHistorians What I mean to say is, you can't compare Reddit to HN, comparing HN to a specific subreddit would be more appropriate.
- detaro 10y agoEven in smaller subs, there often is a quite bad signal-noise ratio, with common posts repeated all the times, meme/joke comments, ... HN isn't perfect on the first point (especially political discussions get repeated over and over as well), but still better. That is something traditional forums often do a lot better, since a hot topic stays active for a long time instead of falling off and being replaced with a new one that discusses all the same points over again. Especially for common questions or product discussions, traditional boards tend to point people to search and existing topics instead of repeating them.
- flukus 10y agoSRS provides a great service of linking to some of the best comments and jokes on reddit. And they don't realize they're doing it.
- teach 10y agoI thought the link with added context[0] was better. (As originally seen on /r/bestof/) [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/58zaho/the_accuracy_of_voat_regarding_reddit_srs_admins/d95a7q2/?context=3 https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/58zaho/the_...
- arprocter 10y agoWhich is amusing, considering bestof is often accused of being an upvote brigade
- syntheticnature 10y agoHaving been involved in running various communities with an online component at various points, there's nothing in the post that surprises me. The biggest difference is just reddit's scale, which just makes things go worse faster.
- Scirra_Tom 10y agoSad how things went for Ellen Pao. The abuse she was subjected to was one of the worst I've seen and I bet there was plenty bleeding off into other aspects of her life other than her inbox. I genuinely felt bad for her, I wouldn't of been able to handle it at all. It was truly revolting and hateful.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoI understood the hate (although it probably wasn't all her fault by any stretch), and I still think that everybody went too far.
- Scirra_Tom 10y agoI fail to see any reason to hate her, what reasons are there?
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoAs I said, it wasn't her fault: She took much of the blame for many of Reddit's policies that users were unhappy about. Some of these policies were more-or-less good, like banning overtly hateful subreddits (fatpeoplehate, and so one), and some of them were really bad (omnipresent shadowbans, and totally ignoring the needs of mods, which had been loudly voiced, culminating in the AMA debacle, which caused the famous "Reddit Revolt", as the mods decided that they'd had enough). They probably weren't all her fault, but she took the blame. And if you already blame her, I can understand where the hatred might come from, justified or no.
- yuhong 10y agoThough it was not like that Ellen was particularly good in the first place anyway. The lawsuit against KP is pretty famous by now.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoI think the problem was more that she attempted things that didn't work quite as well as she thought they would, and the Internet Hate Machine - amplified by the presence of the CEO's additional X chromosome - spun things out of control faster than they could have been fixed, by pretty much anybody. There was plenty to dislike about Pao's actions as CEO (as well as the KP lawsuit), but I think the real lesson is that the Internet Hate Machine is very difficult to slow down or stop once it flies out of control. Every nuance or worthy consideration is drowned out by waves of rage at even the smallest worthy object of complaint.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoReddit is the new Usenet: It's good, it's bad, it's ugly. It all depends on where you look, and there is no single community, there's a fractal-like set of them.
- digi_owl 10y agoBig diff is that usenet was to a large extent decentralized and non-profit. Reddit on the other hand is very much centralized and for profit.
- qwertyuiop924 10y ago...Which is the problem: It's really hard to actually turn a profit on that model, much less to take responsibility for millions of users. The usenet approach was pretty much, "as long as it isn't illegal, do what you will: the local mods are the ones who make the rules." (yes, that wasn't the whole story, but close enough). Reddit's actually trying to clean up their community, and censor outright hatespeech. You may or may not think it's a good idea to do, but it's actually quite difficult.
- codezero 10y agoThe moderation of usenet was very much centralized: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backbone_cabal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backbone_cabal
- exolymph 10y ago> Reddit on the other hand is very much centralized and for profit. Although in a mind-bogglingly incompetent way. Their self-serve ad product is so far behind even Twitter's offering (which is inferior to Facebook and Google) that it's not even funny.
- deadbunny 10y agoYeah, these stories always make me remember that reddit really is a whole heaving mess not just the pretty niche subreddits I frequent (I unsubbed from the defaults years ago).
- 10y ago
- ninkendo 10y agoWhy are the SW devs who are supposed to write new features also in charge of managing complaints from mods? Wouldn't the solution here be to dedicate engineers to ship the features that are intended to decrease your support load? That's basic management 101: be an umbrella.
- SideburnsOfDoom 10y agoI think the role we're talking about is "Community manager" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_community_manager https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_community_manager This shouldn't fall to Software Engineers to do, it's an entirely different and far more people-centric skillset. Maybe you would have engineers providing support to community managers for tools and ad-hoc fixes "intended to decrease the support load" as you say, but as second-line assistance, not doing the main body of work. You would think that if anyone has the specialisation that comes at scale and could do this, reddit does.
- ninkendo 10y agoRight, it seems very odd that he cited that as the #1 reason they couldn't ship new features to decrease their support load: because their support load was too high. Why are the same people doing both?
- deadbunny 10y agoBecause Reddit makes very little money so devs get to joy of moderation as well as development would be my guess. I'm sure that worked back when reddit was a much smaller tech orientated site, not the beast it is today.
- moduspwnens14 10y agoIt might be just that Reddit is still fairly young and doesn't have a lot of employees. Maybe they want to add features like "showing number of unread comments since last visit" or "better ad management system." When you work at a small company, features like that can get sidelined for months to do something like "build algorithm for tying different users together as one entity to ensure bans aren't trivially worked around." With things like that happening, you can lose a lot of developer time on this kind of stuff without them even directly handling bans / policy decisions.
- api 10y agoI ran a small community many years ago. As soon as the personal attacks, threats, and other juvenile behavior started I took it down. Done. Reddit is a for profit media property, but banning subs where this stuff goes on is indeed the correct action. Nobody is ever under any obligation to support or sanction this kind of behavior with their money or time.
- Yhippa 10y ago> 11/ Sam Altman managed to convince Steve Huffman to come back, which was an amazing Hail Mary pass. The new administration is like, okay, FUCK ALL THIS and bans ALL the problematic subreddits. FUCK your free speech, this is why we can't have nice things. This is probably the right thing to do if you have investors to report to and you want a site that caters to the middle 50% of the population. I guess users will complain about their free speech rights being trampled. I have noticed that reddit seems to have less drama since Steve came back. I don't know if it's just being masked by the new algos though.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoIf it is, that's a good thing: if you want drama, just sub to the subs that have the drama. Anyways, reddit doesn't have to protect your free speech, and they never did. I'm just glad that they'll stop pretending that they will, which is what bothered me: state the rules on your door, and make sure that they're enforced.
- Scirra_Tom 10y agoSocially irresponsible to allow Subreddits such as "Fat People Hate" in my opinion. People have these views and they are free to express them, but creating a community dedicated to it normalises that behaviour and helps breed further hatred. Under 18 age group seems to be large on Reddit as well [1]. Allowing subreddits such as FPH is really unhealthy amongst the more impressionable. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/self/comments/1agz1o/ever_wonder_about_the_ages_of_redditors_some_data/ https://www.reddit.com/r/self/comments/1agz1o/ever_wonder_ab...
- DavidHm 10y agoTo play the devils advocate, where does this stop? Do you deny them any sort of public space where they can communicate with each other?
- Scirra_Tom 10y agoAre you comfortable denying the KKK a public place where they can communicate with each other? Where do you draw the line?
- jansenv 10y agoThis is entirely bullshit. This guy is still on the payroll and will say anything to calm the community down / discredit people who think something is up.
- yuhong 10y agoAs a side note, I have been thinking of Yishan-style CEOs for a while now. This is part of why I am thinking of changing anti-discrimination and wrongful termination laws. I suggest a compromise to only include certain kinds of jobs like manual labor under employment anti-discrimination laws, where workers are actually commodities that are measureable and interchangeable.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoTo keep the white men in power? Very effective.
- danso 10y agoIn the U.S., anti-discrimination laws sometimes differ among the states (and counties) when it comes to public and private jobs, particularly with respect to sexual orientation and sexual identity, and it's problematic. Good luck writing a law that attempts to define which jobs are "commodities", nevermind coming up with the legal justification for removing anti-discrimination law on non-commodity jobs.
- yuhong 10y agoYea, I know that might be hard. I think the Fair Labor Standards Act does something like that already though.
- EpicEng 10y agoYeah ok. Do you really believe that you're not a commodity as well. Hate to break it to you, but there are plenty of devs out there who can do the boring, mundane work that is most software development. You're not special.
- yuhong 10y agoYea, but this does not mean that it is as easily measurable as manual labor. Remember that performance reviews are often used in wrongful termination lawsuits. Why do you think there are "PIPs"?
- 10y ago
- my_ghola 10y ago> You know how the mods are always saying "you promised us this feature a year ago, and it's still not here!" You know why? Because the team was constantly drawn into having to police drama and blow-ups > when actually, the admins would just like y'all to shut up so they can write some features to make the site better Why did they have admins coding or coders admin'ing? Those should be different people.
- minimaxir 10y agoAdmins in this case is slang for Reddit employees.
- timjver 10y agoThe point still stands. Coders shouldn't have to deal with that.
- bmm6o 10y agoThat's the same thing that struck me. I think you end up in that position when you don't want to hire community administrators, you'd rather deputize your users. But until you build them the tools they need to do their jobs, you have to do it yourself. And if all you have is coders...
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoOh yeah! I forgot about that. That is a pretty big reason to hate her.
- Scirra_Tom 10y agoIf you take the position that the lawsuit was frivolous, hatred seems to be an extreme response. Reddit as a whole seems to struggle with recognising feminism as a legitimate social struggle and I cant help but feel that helped fuel the fire against Ellen.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoI didn't say it was reasonable, just that it was a big reason: not everybody agrees with you. >Reddit as a whole seems to struggle with recognising feminism I mean, I guess, but the phrase "reddit as a whole" doesn't make a whole lot of sense: Reddit isn't one community, it's a collection of disparate communities that really aren't all that connected to each other.
- jacalata 10y agoMeh, it's probably less diverse than any one state in the US. It's probably less diverse than most cities, and equally made up of disparate parts.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoBut it's more diverse than a single forum.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sctb 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12779252 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12779252 and marked it off-topic.
- pjc50 10y agoYou get the users you tolerate. > "The reddit admins (of the time; it's mostly a different group now) really did not like SRS. In attempting to force the admins to take their side, they would dox them, send bad shit to their family members, etc. It was really bad. Despite this, the admins never cracked but they really hated them." And somehow weren't banned for this? Futher down they say that they just want to make the site better, but 90% of that is just about building tools to stop (in order of importance) harrasment of users by other subreddits, fighting within a subreddit and (c) poor topic discipline. Eventually they learn from this: "11/ ... bans ALL the problematic subreddits. F* your free speech, this is why we can't have nice things. 12/ They've had peace so far, so I guess that was probably the right policy" I'm old enough to remember when people ran unmoderated newsgroups and open mail relays for free speech reasons. They either drowned in spam or were gradually blocked by so much of the rest of the internet that their position became untenable. If you build a system that doesn't deal with spam, it gets drowned in spam. If you build a system that doesn't deal with abuse, abuse becomes commonplace. If you don't secure your IoT devices you get journalists DDoSed by lightbulbs. It's the same kind of social responsibility. What makes this problem worse in the mid-20-teens is that there are hate groups organising off-board to cause these problems. See the discussion of VR harrasment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12777340 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12777340
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoWell, yeah. Some people handle freedom responsibly. Most... don't. If you really want freedom, 4chan, glorious 4chan! Enjoy your cesspit.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoIt's worth noting that 4chan is knee-deep in marketing shills and state-sponsored trolls these days. Any open community that attracts enough of a following becomes an object of interest to for those who want to accumulate money and power. Ever been on /pol/ these days? It's so much an echo chamber of sponsored trolls and shills I'm surprised any genuine conversation can happen there at all.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoBy the way, has anybody seen the rationalwiki page for Reddit? Some of it's accurate, and some of it is hilariously wrong: For example, they claimed the now infamous "Reddit Revolt" was due to /r/FPH being banned, which just goes to show how utterly out of touch they are.
- makomk 10y agoRationalWiki are part of the same social justice crowd as SRS, so that's not entirely surprising.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoReally? They seem to hate SRS just as much as we do...
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoI'm a bit confused that I just responded to another post of yours in this same discussion that seemed to indicate you didn't know what SRS was?
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoI read up on it. And I also read RationalWiki claiming that they hate SRS, which is enough information for this post.
- davidgerard 10y agoThis is literally false. Source: seven-year RationalWiki editor, RMF board member.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- iza 10y agoRationalWiki is almost as bad as Conservapedia. It's fine for debunking religion and pseudoscience but anything else is extremely biased.
- Goronmon 10y agoPeople who are caught doing bad things tend to lie about it (they are already people who are willing to break the rules, so lying isn't such a stretch). Man, tell me about it. I was a moderator for the Vault Network message boards back in the days when it was still around. It's hard to overstate how hard some people will work to make people they disagree with look bad. People would post super racists, hateful, gross comments and images to the board, get a ban, and then try to go on an alt account and complain about the moderator who banned them. The moderator would remove that post (discussing mod actions was against the rules) and then that person (and others) would use that as a reason that the mods were evil, biased people just trying to silence disagreement. They would go so far as sending personal messages to individual mods (both on and off the boards) who they assumed were responsible. The worst attacks somehow usually made it to a mod that wasn't involved, usually a woman. It really gave me an appreciation for how hateful and deplorable some people can get when they can remain anonymous.
- M_Grey 10y agoAt the end of the day, broken, obsessive people with no jobs and no lives will always be more committed to their activities than the functional people who monitor them. The only true solution is that a vast majority of people learn to recognize them online, and ignore/avoid them. Anything else will eventually be subverted or overrun.
- Bartweiss 10y agoThis is the best argument I've ever seen for hellbans. Yes, they're capricious and unfair and opaque, but troll-hours so outweigh mod-hours that it's worth considering any tool that helps create leverage for moderators.
- M_Grey 10y agoI couldn't agree more, and I'd just emphasize that no one likes hellbans, including the people who have to impose them. On and offline, we always seem engaged in some form of distasteful, yet necessary asymmetric conflict.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoThis is actually also a decent commentary on US political society right now. e.g. both sides accusing the same outlets of being biased, immediately going to radical / extremist points of view and advocating immediate, border-line violent action against them. Nothing that the overwhelming majority of reasonable human beings can look at and say, "yes, I really think this represents me right now, one or both of you make some valid points." edit: LMAO at the immediate downvoting that proved my point about not being able to have reasonable discussions in media anymore.
- bhaumik 10y ago> 6a/ Incidentally, as a result of my experiences running reddit, I have a lot more respect for police, governors, and presidents - anyone who has to uphold a fair system in the face of multiple opposing sides, all of whom want the system to favor them because they are convinced they are "right." This was particularly interesting. Massive communities like Reddit are a great testing ground for policies around free speech.
- blakecallens 10y agoJust because most of what yishan says is probably true, that doesn't mean he's not tactically omitting details. For instance, you can go to any of the right-leaning or conspiracy related subreddits and find posts where they show collusion between SRS and CTR. Evidence that is completely undeniable, like mods of SRS and r/politics also modding pro-Hillary or anti-Trump subreddits. When one side says CTR has totally taken over the site, and the other says they're not involved at all, the truth is probably somewhere in the middle.
- debacle 10y ago/r/undelete has traditionally been very much about free speech. Unfortunately due to the nature of the censorship on reddit, anyone who is for free speech also appears to be conservative, fringe, etc. There seems to be no concept of being anti-censorship in and of itself, from the vocal proponents of what reddit has become.
- grzm 10y ago> due to the nature of the censorship on reddit ... there seems to be no concept of being anti-censorship in and of itself I have spent very little time on reddit, so I'm unfamiliar with what form censorship takes there. That said, viewing Twitter and HN, I wonder if this doesn't have more to do with people pulling tangential topics into discussions. It takes effort to pare down an idea, separating it from others that may be logically related or associated with some bundled collection of ideas. Also, while two people may share a belief, they may not rank the belief equally among all of the others they hold. Alice and Bob may both think free speech is important, but it's really important to Alice. It's more likely that Alice will want to talk about it than Bob. So perhaps people who end up discussing free speech/anti-censorship issues also tend to share similar rankings of other shared values. That could explain why people discussing free speech tend tend to share other beliefs as well. They hold similar beliefs and similar belief rankings. I have nothing to back that up :) But it sounds reasonable. Anyone need a research topic? What do you think? Is there something more going on in reddit's case?
- makecheck 10y agoI can certainly understand wanting to pull the plug on some of the most egregious forums/users/behaviors and restore sanity as quickly as possible. On the other hand, it’s a good bet that most bans wouldn’t come with a lengthy letter explaining exactly what caused the ban so it might just reinforce the feeling of being suppressed unfairly. If the affected users actually are children (seems many of them are) then you’re not teaching anything by taking everything away with no explanation. As sad as this may be, in the modern age Reddit might be as much of an influence on a child as a teacher, day care or other major non-parent authority figure, and therefore what Reddit does “matters”. If Reddit’s primary response is to kill things, kids will feel unheard and disrespected and react strongly. If Reddit has a wide array of punishments and a very clear way to explain what a user did wrong, I think it would be a greater investment in the future of the forums.
- clifanatic 10y agoI'm sort of shocked he was that aware of what was going on. As a regular reddit user at that time, I wasn't even sure he knew what reddit's domain name was.
- depr 10y agoThe spin on this is just great. As others have said, new features have nothing to do with moderating. Note how the company did nothing wrong. It is not their fault they can't shield developers from user shitstorms. "Alexis was supposed to announce it [..] but somehow that did not happen". This is just casually glossed over. Somehow that did not happen? again, it is the communities' fault for assuming the CEO fired someone, when they could've easily been informed about who actually did it. "FUCK your free speech, this is why we can't have nice things." yeah, or this is why we can't have advertisers. If you want to have advertisers, you have to ban the subreddits that make the site look bad. https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/4ll9tc/it_looks_like_reddit_wants_to_become_a_profitable/ https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/4ll9tc/it_looks_li... Isn't it convenient how they could (in a series of moves) 1. Fire Victoria (for whatever reason) 2. Make the impopular CEO take the blame to get rid of her and 3. Hire a former founder as the new CEO (embraced by the community) 4. Who drops a "Reddit, we need to talk" and gets rid of the shittier subreddits
- losteverything 10y agoI love reddit because I connect with other co-workers in my 4000+ store chain. Get scoops on new stuff and share thoughts too. Very civil. What other sites exist that could do the same????
- nailer 10y ago> 4a/ As part of those culture wars, some people do things that step over the line. Like actual brigading. It's like when you have impassioned protests, and 1% of the protesters on both sides decide they are going to burn a store or car. This is applicable to nearly every online argument. You can find the media bias when sites chose to focus entirely on one side and ignore documented evidence of their own side engaging in the same behavior.
- Herodotus38 10y agoEvery once in a while I like to think about the evolution of sites like forums, slashdot, digg, Reddit, HN, etc... And what could be done to improve them, mainly from a technical rather than social aspect (such as the way voting works, how 'good' vs 'bad' comments are rewarded). Aside from r/theoryofreddit (which seems mostly focused on Reddit drama), are there other communities that discuss the creation and improvement of social networks?
- grzm 10y ago> mainly from a technical rather than social aspect (such as the way voting works, how 'good' vs 'bad' comments are rewarded) I'm interested in that as well, though I tend to think the tech needs to serve the social aspect. What kind of community you want determines what kind of features (technical aspect) you want. The features in turn influence the behavior of the users. Is that what you're getting at? Glancing at /r/theoryofreddit I think it is. Or is there something else?
- Herodotus38 10y agoTo clarify, I think I want to find a place where people discuss the pros/cons of implementing features, hopefully in an objective way. Here are some ideas I'm sure others have had before, but which I think would be interesting: Could one take the model of Reddit and make it real time? Basically a large chat room. There are of course huge problems that would have to be overcome, such as how to prevent spamming (so maybe a cool down period after each comment?), how to 'rank' up voted comments, and others I haven't thought about. The next step would be live voice, but I don't see a benefit with video. Now this next part is completely niaive and idealistic and I'm ignoring all the problems that will need to be solved but what if there were such an online anonymous community able to discuss and debate things in real time? In such a system perhaps the best 'ranked' idea (based on democratic vote, which may not be the best way...) is displayed in brighter it larger text, or lasts longer before disappearing. So, you see I would love to hear from people who may have tried this or could tell me "no, X doesn't work because then you get people taking advantage of Y".
- 10y ago