22 ms·
HN comments are underrated
- dilemma 10y agoThe first and second paragraphs seem to contradict each other. Comments (and previously blogs, but not so much anymore) can have more insight than news articles because they're based on first hand experience. Journalists don't have that, and the organization they work for often has problematic incentives which they push onto the writer. HN comments are indeed very terse, to the point of being unfriendly. It bothered me at first but now I'm used to the style and sort of like it.
- scwoodal 10y agoI'm guessing the author tried to convey a stereotype about the comments in the first paragraph. Then tried to debunk that stereotype in the rest of the post. There definitely could of been a sentence or two to help transition between the two as it felt odd to me as well.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe post is dismissive of the value of the majority of the comments, it just thinks there are some that are worthwhile. It also suggests moving that content off of HN (or at least replicating it elsewhere).
- jdherg 10y ago> The first and second paragraphs seem to contradict each other. The assertions that "HN comments are terrible" and "I haven’t found a public internet forum with better technical commentary" don't seem contradictory to me if you allow the implication that all other (known-to-Dan) public internet forums have technical commentary that's at best also terrible.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoHN comments are full of naive political opinion, groupthink, and a tendency to blind optimism on all things technology or new. Often older ways have merit too. It's also probably the only place left on the net where, from comments, I'll find out rapidly, and bluntly with citations, when I'm wrong (and, yes I'm often wrong on the Internet!), usually learn something new on the topic, and sometimes talk with the guy who invented it. My ADHD brain loves the depth that side topics can get explored and being surrounded by people far cleverer than me. I wouldn't have it any other way.
- witty_username 10y ago> blind optimism on all things technology or new. Often older ways have merit too. I've seen plenty of "if it ain't broke don't fix it" in the comments and complaints about engineers always trying to use the newest technology.
- Semiapies 10y agoYes, using any tool or language that came out after the commenter started programming is "hipster". And you see a lot of xkcd 927 and "I can't help thinking effort would have been better spent on an existing project" when someone writes any program of any type where other examples exist.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoI only post a 927 when there are >6 different standards in the field, and there's no way a new one will catch on. As for the effort better spent posts, those are awful. Never post those. Instead post about how great emacs is compared to vim: you're more likely to spawn useful discussion.
- Semiapies 10y agoAnd if you post the xkcd link to a discussion about a piece of software and not a new standard for which many already exist, (and I see that post,) I will proudly downvote you no matter how many examples exist. Just be glad I don't have the magic ability to force anyone to use QED to program their next project in Fortran on a CTSS box.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoYeah, just don't post 927 on software: that's dumb. Note I said when a new one won't catch on, or is unlikely to do so, particularly of it doesn't have any significant benefits over what's already there.
- deleted 10y ago
- jrcii 10y agoEspecially mine. The wealth of technical knowledge available here is incredible, there's nothing else like it. Thanks guys!
- k__ 10y agoI follow many people on twitter who dislike HN. Reason for this is opinions here are alsmost entirely from white males with money.
- jessaustin 10y agoIf this were true, it would merit study. How can a forum that is open to all and used in mostly anonymous fashion, so effectively police the race of users? And how could other less open less anonymous activities hope to succeed in diversity?
- maxerickson 10y agoIt probably works like strong acid, destroying anything unfortunate enough to not be strong acid on contact.
- coldtea 10y ago>How can a forum that is open to all and used in mostly anonymous fashion, so effectively police the race of users? By being targeted at programmers and startup founders, that is, two predominantly white (ok, and asian) fields? It's not that HN does anything special, it's the actual world that does. Most programmers are middle class (so could afford university in the first place), most founders are upper middle class, and most of both groups are white. There are of course exceptions, but not enough to skew the majority. The most open and diverse "forum" in the world is YouTube -- you can find everybody there under a cat video or some such (which is also why it has the nastier comments, but that's life outside an echo bubble).
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoWith regards to the gender aspect, see any of the threads related to 'women in computing' and the horrible posts therein.
- tnones 10y agoOnly if you assume women cannot be successful in technology without needing a special interest group mooching off the entire enterprise. It's a vicious cycle based on a kafkatrap. If you don't agree that women are discriminated against in tech, you're discriminating against women. Culture committees, diversity consultants and women-only groups are set up to "address" this problem, yet all they do is create more division and alienation, holding up the most stereotypical fragile princess as representative for every woman on the planet. They keep throwing all sorts of accusations and aspersions on every single guy in the field, shriek and pearl clutch when they receive blowback, and have the gall to call this empathy, in a field where the average worker is an undersocialized and overworked code janitor. Whose preferred communication styles, hobbies and accomplishments are fair game to ignore or bulldoze over. Pointing this out gets you labeled as "horrible". Fine, then. Yet another word to add to the pile that has lost all meaning. Misogyny used to mean "hatred of women", now it just means "something a woman hates". Which appears to include the average mid-rung nerd.
- return0 10y agoHN comments need a vertical bar on the left side to indicate indent level. i find it hard to skim conversations in narrow screens.
- sidcool 10y agoAgree. But I am just happy that they added collapsible comments.
- tedmiston 10y ago> i find it hard to skim conversations in narrow screens. It's practically impossible to read comments nested more than one level deep on mobile and keep track of what level of nesting you're at. In contrast, Reddit handles this pretty well.
- shubhamjain 10y agoI prefer cynicism over unthoughtful, inconsequential comments that floods several discussion forums that I have come across. "Nice article", "Great write-up" and the next thing you know, you have created a place where people are only interested in submitting their articles and getting it upvoted rather than make meaningful contributions. People want to make good contributions here and that's something that differentiates HN from other news aggregators.
- willvarfar 10y agoSometimes really good articles don't have lots of comments. In these circumstances, I post an "excellent article!" comment just to give the author some feedback that someone somewhere actually read the article, and they really liked it! Humans writing articles appreciate that.
- shubhamjain 10y agoI am denying importance of compliments but they lose their lustre if the whole culture of forum is to "appear too nice"; it just gives an impression of everyone making comments for the sake of it. Besides that, the entire point of a forum doesn't bode well if there aren't any strong comments touching the subject, even if they are cynical or scornful. Take a look at OP's example of the "Should you leave a bad job?" thread [1]. The first comment is surely harsh and questions the entire thought process of hating a mundane job. Some people would disagree with it; some would not but I would be disappointed if the comment didn't exist. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7789014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7789014
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoIndeed. When my comments or articles hit the frontpage/top of the thread, I don't really care. What excites me is when I get a ton of responses from more experienced people. Because that gives me an opportunity to learn something.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago
- anton_tarasenko 10y agoWhen I worked with the HN post data, I noticed that some years ago HN users had correctly predicted the "Show HN" projects that later got funding. Those projects had more upvotes. The more recent data has no such connection. It seems that the influx of users reduced the quality of judgement. So one way to improve HN submissions and comments is to weight points by the user's tenure on HN. I also suspect that early comments dominate late comments by the time factor alone. The sorting algo gives a brief advantage to new comments, but old comments are more visible. A post on the front page gets 30+ comments in the first hour, and latecomers can only post into the void. To address that, long branches could be collapsed by default, leaving only 2-4 visible messages per branch.
- berntb 10y agoCool. And sad. But re old accounts: I've recently seen a few cases where old accounts with high karma dismissed Wikipedia -- without any references of their own. That is a "quality smell", if anything is. (One particularly shameless fellow just copied the primary link Wikipedia used -- and lied about the content. :-( ) EDIT: I wrote without any references of their own -- i.e. dismissed with hand waving. Wikipedia won't always be correct, but it has references and is whetted by quite a lot of people.
- 50CNT 10y agoMy dad likes to dismiss Wikipedia, and he used to be an admin. They may just know how the sausage is made. His rule of thumb is "If it isn't a major article there's probably errors". His favorite example is that of an article about an ancient persian poet, which says that there's only 2 of his poems known, and only 1 remains. Next to that line, there's a picture of the other poem. Eh, who knows.
- berntb 10y agoI didn't argue that Wikipedia always was correct (no source is that, I'd guess), just that it smelled really bad to dismiss it with just hand waving. It do have sources and have been whetted (for reasonably popular subjects.)
- libeclipse 10y agoAnother thing I've noticed about HN comments is that everything is hyped beyond what it deserves. For example, the recent DDoS attacks were just a bunch of skids with Mirai, but it was discussed as if it was the end of the internet. There's also the issue of self-censorship, where users will refrain from posting their opinion in case they get downvotes and negative karma. The things people post here are fascinating, but the comments, in my honest opinion, aren't.
- sotojuan 10y agoTo be fair those two things aren't HN specific. They seem to be human nature as they've happened in ever forum I've been part of.
- cjbprime 10y ago> For example, the recent DDoS attacks were just a bunch of skids with Mirai, but it was discussed as if it was the end of the internet. Couldn't it be both? What's your proposal for stopping DDoS from skids with Mirai?
- progman 10y ago> There's also the issue of self-censorship, where users will refrain from posting their opinion in case they get downvotes and negative karma. This is the price for shadow-banning which some blogs use to censor freedom of speech. The hosters may consider it super smart to silence unwelcome messengers. Actually they just expose their own intolerance. > The things people post here are fascinating, but the comments, in my honest opinion, aren't. Truth can be inconvenient and offending, causing downvotes. People often try to silence offenders as "hate speakers" these days just because of (justified) criticism. It is evidence of increasing intolerance.
- tedmiston 10y ago> For example, the recent DDoS attacks were just a bunch of skids with Mirai, but it was discussed as if it was the end of the internet. As far as I'm aware it was the biggest DDoS attack on DNS ever. Whatever the cause, the effect was massive. The potential to effectively blackout major parts of the Internet for more than several hours is pretty concerning to me.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoYou post a list of the best comments on HN without putting The Wisdom of Bane on the list? Seriously, how did The Wisdom of Bane not make it one here? That is one of the best comments on all of HN. For the uninitiated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8902739 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8902739
- nekopa 10y agoHeh, I prefer to refer to that whole comment as Bane's Rule. I have had many interesting discussions with IT managers face to face after having them read that, especially regarding the idea of having vendors show that their product beats out the current system. For programmers, I think one of the key takeaways from that comment is not the clever coding, but the direct tie into business results from the coding. Not just immediate business results, but also how the system was set up for growth and improvement easily too.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoIt's about some of core principles of software: Keep it simple, use the minimal code (if it's not there, it can't slow you down), see where speed problems are before optimizing, optimize before scaling up. It's common sense, but it's rare to actually follow it. Actually, I'm guilty of this myself. I was finishing last year's Advent of Code, and was given a problem which I tried to optimize, as I assumed the naive approach would be too slow. Then I realized I was trying to optimize Travelling Salesman, so I bit the bullet and went for the O(n!) solution. And it ran in less than a second. In interpreted scheme, no less. I felt kind of silly later.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThanks for the link. That was an amazing comment that should be required reading for all these people thinking about throwing datacenters at their problem of choice. It's actually about the same as the advice and methods used in the Beowulf clusters back when all this crap was starting. They did come up with creative ways to scale out while NUMA vendors (esp SGI) kept scaling further up. However, they also identified bottlenecks in their algorithms from transport all the way up to application layers. Active Messages vs TCP/IP, BLAS libraries, hand-tuned MPI, careful choice of interconnects, offloading I/O onto dedicated workstations w/ clustered filesystes... always improving efficiency of each component in the stack to get max ROI out of those expensive clusters. As bane notes, it seems that third part of doing HPC right was lost in translation to modern crowd. Not entirely sure why. Prior conversations indicated strong separation between HPC and business/cloud crowds in terms of knowledge sharing. Plus, there's marketing hype and VC money involved riding the waves of whatever is massively popular. Bigger IT budgets, too, if your proposal doesn't involve using one, mid-range Dell. I'm sure such things have more impact than the technical arguments in many places. ;)
- dancek 10y agoI think HN needs a way to easily find the top comments. There are absolute gems deep in discussion threads, but you'll need to spend a lot of time reading to find them. Hence, it's very nice of Dan Luu to list some of his favorites. The top root-level comment for each comment page is obviously easy to see, but good comments deeper in the comment tree are easily lost. Would be great if e.g. the top 5% voted comments on a page were highlighted in some way. Perhaps a workable solution would be to just follow the comments listing of smart people. Guess I'll at least try that.
- qb45 10y agoI swear there was a way to show top voted comments but I can't find it now.
- danieldk 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/bestcomments https://news.ycombinator.com/bestcomments
- DanBC 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/lists https://news.ycombinator.com/lists https://news.ycombinator.com/bestcomments https://news.ycombinator.com/bestcomments
- tptacek 10y agoThe problem with /bestcomments is that it's based on votes, and thus does not in fact track the best comments.
- tptacek 10y agoDan and Scott recently added a "favorites" feature that you can see if you click the timestamp for a comment. Saving a comment to your favorites publishes it in a list of favorites on your profile. I think they're not especially happy with how this feature is working out. But I also think they're very close to a version of the feature that would work quite well: * The "lists" page on the site should include a list of users that have "favorite" comments (at least until the site has so many users with favorites that the list is too long to make sense) with links to their "favorite" pages. This seems trivially easy, and would help bootstrap the feature. * There should be a master list, linked perhaps on the top of the page (maybe replacing the useless "comments" link) to a list of the most-favorited comments.
- bambax 10y ago> 1838 days ago Trivial improvement to HN: after more than 30 days, render time in number of years and months instead of just days.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cybertronic 10y agoEven better: actual time and date of submission
- latch 10y agoRemoving the vote count was a step back. You end up with highly positioned comments that are factually wrong and no way to weigh the corrections made in replies. If you saw that a comment had 20 votes, but a reply had 500, you'd have something to go by. If nothing else, they could show the relative score of a reply to its parent.
- crispyambulance 10y agoHow about just reading and evaluating what the damn words say instead of relying on a "score"?
- latch 10y agoBecause there are a lot of topics, even in my professional field, where I don't have the necessary foundation. Because sometimes a comment reaffirms or conflicts with my evaluation and it's useful to have a weight assigned to that. Because the world has enough people who make their own evaluation and refuse to change their opinion regardless of overwhelming evidence.
- coldtea 10y ago>Because there are a lot of topics, even in my professional field, that I simply don't have the necessary foundation. And what makes you think that the "majority vote" on them will be correct? Most often, it's the majority that doesn't have the necessary foundation.
- criddell 10y agoWell, if we had the vote counts, we could test your conjecture.
- coldtea 10y agoWe have them in other forums -- e.g. Reddit if I am not mistaken. Do they work that well there, or do they make the forums a competition for points and popular comments, in other words a popularity contest?
- renke1 10y agoI admit that I usually read the comments first and then go to article.
- sharpercoder 10y agoComing from a certain frame, context and worldview given to someone by his/her parents, many comments are not ill-intendend but come off as unhelpful or negative. A problem with moderation on the web is that for willing people it is hard to grasp why you have been given the mdoeration you got. An idea I'm toying with is to allow meta-comment reactions to comments. They would extend horizontally (as opposed to vertically for non-meta comments) and allow medium-to-high experienced users to provde meta-comments (feedback).
- humanrebar 10y ago> ...many comments are not ill-intendend but come off as unhelpful or negative. Unhelpful to whom? Pointing out bad examples as bad examples is helpful to the inexperienced; they may learn to avoid some pitfalls. People who publicly push back against popular bad schools of thought provide encouragement to others in the minority who might give up the fight out of fatigue instead of conceding on the merits.
- sharpercoder 10y agoI'm trying to point out that meta-comments (feedback) can help guide the discussion in the correct direction. It's generally unwanted to mix meta and non-meta discussion. So it may be practical to do allow for meta-commenting on comments, but display it horizontally. This would allow users to focus more and better on the matter at hand.
- jordanpg 10y agoThe bellwether of a bad but possibly technically interesting HN comment is one that begins with a humblebrag: "One time a Fortune 500 company hired me to re-write their entire web tier using Django" or "last year, for fun, I wrote a fully-functioning TLS implementation in node". Such nonsense (or at best, unneeded information) is intended to provide credentials so that the reader will take what follows more seriously. But ironically it only serves to erode confidence.
- GrinningFool 10y agoMore and more I'm trying to take those at face value - a statement that translates as: "I have opinions on this, but before I give them let me explain why I think I am qualified to do so. For most, perhaps it's a bit of both. And is that a bad thing? Is there something wrong with asserting your right to wield a technical opinion while also showing off a thing that you're proud of having done? On the other hand, if I had prefaced that opinion with the following , it would be been a bit over the top: I've been reading comments for years. Not just on HN, but all over the Internet. In fact, once I spent 60 hours in a week, just reading comments.
- blt 10y agoI think the culture of rejecting joke-only comments is significant. I love a good joke, but so does everybody else. Rewarding jokes would have a major effect on the signal/noise ratio.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoMaybe have a [jokular] tag and let readers flag a comment as such, then allow [jokular] comments to be hidden for the people who find them noisy. Edit: this comment deservers the [overengineering] tag...
- mortehu 10y agoSlashdot has something similar. Moderators' points have to be tagged with "Funny", "Interesting", etc, and users can choose how to weigh each type of point.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThat's a decent idea. The HN client could also have settings to turn them off entirely or just disable them for a specific thread with too much noise.
- AlexB138 10y agoAgreed. The quality-death of many forums I've been a part of came from the onset of users posting joke responses becoming the norm. One joke amid 100 comments can be funny. One quality comment amid 100 attempted jokes is banal and mind numbing.
- angry_octet 10y agoRegrettably it makes the comments read like the minutes from an accountancy standards institute. There is also a 'wikipedia editor' or 'stack overflow mod' effect, where because someone said jokes are bad a whole bunch of people jump on them to kill them dead. Dead! I'm reminded of a Robin Williams gag: German talk show host: Why do you think there is not so much comedy in Germany? Robin Williams: Did you ever think that you killed all the funny people?
- 10y ago
- internaut 10y agoIt's not complicated, just hard to digest. Anti-white racism. It's identical to the antisemitism of the far right in the 30s and 40s, except it is with whites.
- panic 10y agoThere's more to racism than just not liking someone's opinion.
- internaut 10y agoLet's not pretend we don't have a clue where this stuff is coming from. We know very well where it is coming from. It is straight out of one specific set of political doctrines.
- throwanem 10y agoDiscounting someone's opinion on the basis of skin color and economic circumstances rather than content, for example.
- panic 10y agoA person's background is what forms their perspective on the world. That background and perspective affects the content of their posts. You can't separate the two things so easily.
- c_c_c 10y ago
- amelius 10y agoI wish there was more research in moderation systems. I think it is a fascinating topic, because it can make or break an online forum. And perhaps it even has applications in political decision making.
- grzm 10y agoModeration systems and community guidelines on how to use them. (You likely implied that, I think making it explicit is important.)
- jacques_chester 10y ago> And perhaps it even has applications in political decision making. You might find Rules of Order useful to learn. Running an efficient meeting is a skill that is relatively simple to learn. With an organised way of passing around the sound wave lock and a common process for deciding what to discuss, what not to discuss and how to make decisions, stuff can get done pretty quickly.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI agree. I don't know of any such research but this article posted on HN was one of best summaries on the subject I've seen: http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/13/11387934/internet-moderator-history-youtube-facebook-reddit-censorship-free-speech http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/13/11387934/internet-moderato...
- oskarth 10y agoI often find my self searching through old HN comments for all kinds of things. Just off the top of my head I've searched for comments on: Redis, ZFS, Raft, SQS, ZMQ, message queue, RDS, connection pools, ECS in the last few days. I've learned quite a lot of things from reading comments by people with way more experience in these matters than I have. And that's probably less than half of my searches. A google search might give me some good stuff, and Stack Exchange too, but HN comments are indeed underrated.
- akkartik 10y agoIndeed. Searching on https://hn.algolia.com https://hn.algolia.com is an integral part of my workflow. When I read an article I often want to see: a) What did people say about it on HN? Because the comments there are often superior to the comments on the site itself. If there are multiple threads on it separated by years, it's often interesting to read them all and reflect on how opinions of reasonable people have drifted over time. b) Did I upvote any of the threads? (i.e. Have I read this before?) Did I, perchance, leave a comment? Often this process adds a few more favorites to my list (https://news.ycombinator.com/favorites?id=akkartik&comments=t https://news.ycombinator.com/favorites?id=akkartik&comments=...), which is also growing to be an integral part of my workflow.
- soufron 10y agoI feel the same. Most often, the comments are way more interesting than the links they're commenting. This led me to calm down on commenting all the time, coz I felt like I needed to try to make good quality comments in order to compare favorably to the rest of the discussion, and to contribute to the community. I wonder if others feel like this and decided to restrain on commenting?
- wfeui3 10y agoI lost faith in HN crowd when hyperloop started. California can not even replicate 40 years old TGV, but somehow it will build space-like technology for fraction of price. And than there are politics. Entire world should accept millions of refugees. But SF is different, and should not even host 400 homeless who arrive every year.
- novaleaf 10y ago"Not in my backyard"
- ghaff 10y agoBut it should build lots of housing for tech workers for whom life just isn't worth living if they have to be anywhere else on the planet.
- argonaut 10y agoYes, because otherwise they'll just take all the other housing, since tech workers are paid more.
- jomamaxx 10y agoI agree - the Musk delirium is strong with these ones. You have to take HN with a dose of salty optimism. The Valley depends on a little bit of irrational koolaid thinking.
- delluminatus 10y agoIt shouldn't be about faith. Every "crowd" has all kinds of people, and even the very smartest people aren't always right. By reading critically (and following up with research if necessary), you can decide what's right and what's wrong. In my experience, H.N. comments have a lot of wrong. But when the content is good, it can be truly great.
- wfeui3 10y ago"Faith" that HN comments is relevant source of information, sifting through hundreds of post to find one relevant is not worth it. I get better results from Twitter, Reddit...
- hellofunk 10y ago> comments are often gratuitously mean, and people will often defend gratuitously mean comments by claiming that it’s either impossible or inefficient to convey information without being mean. > Most of the negative things you hear about HN comments are true. I think it is interesting how the relatively anonymised nature of the internet has a similar effect on people of all stripes. HN readers, I believe, are among the more intelligent, or at least curious, in our species. The same is true of another popular internet forum, Stackoverflow. Yet there exists an air of negativity that is of much higher ubiquity than in "real" life where people are not anonymous. And this is true of most other internet forums as well where more of the general popular participates. I think it shows in a strange way that people just have a lot of negativity to vent, and the internet has made that really easy and without consequence to the rest of one's life, and that this remains true regardless of one's interests and general intelligence.
- GrinningFool 10y agoI've found my negative tendencies curbed quickly when I started using my real name, or accounts directly linked to my real name (such as this one). For me, it just forces an extra second of thought - whatever I type next affects people's perception of me as a person. At first this was just in the form of considering my reply more, but over time it shifted to occurring as a part of reaching my initial conclusions.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI use my main account as "nickpsecurity" for the same reason. I've posted as "Nick P" in security field for a long time. It's close to my real name. I do controversial posts and generate plenty of material that could be used for smears but tying it to my real identity does filter out some foolish, reckless or smearing comments I might otherwise make with zero accountability. So, I post everything here under that name or don't post it at all. The results have overall been positive with a very low amount of bad reactions in moderation or downvotes vs an aggressive throwaway I might create to write comments of dubious value.
- forgottenpass 10y ago
- kimshibal 10y agoI do feel React developers are like hardcore apple fan boy. The can't accept people criticism openly.
- grayrest 10y agoI've been using React as my primary platform for 3 years now and I'd be interested in novel React criticism. I believe the most important thing when developing software is managing state. The best cross-language technique I know for reducing state is to prefer functional approaches, lock down mutability wherever possible, and prefer persistent datastructures. These techniques cause problems for truly high performance code (HAMT-like datastructures have pointer contention at the head) but very little of the code I write is that performance sensitive. From the UI side, I believe the reactive programming model has won out and I'm unaware of any medium to large javascript frameworks that don't have some sort of change detection/propagation system. Polymer is the most dom manipulation oriented current gen framework I know about and it still makes substantial use of observables and bound properties. Put together, I currently believe that the virtual dom diffing approach on persistent datastructures is the best general purpose starting point for building a user interface. The biggest arguments against the approach I've heard are that it's memory inefficient since the entire output virtual DOM has to be retained for diffing and that the diffing process itself is less efficient than direct change propagation using observables. While both valid complaints, I have not found them useful complaints. For memory, the target market for the apps I've written has yet to include mobile devices that are memory constrained to the point that virtual DOM size is a significant factor and if they did, I'd be inclined to try something like incremental dom before abandoning the pattern. For performance, the combination persistent datastructures guiding the diff substantially reduces the amount of diffing overhead. I've been able to hit 60 fps on a randomly-update 10k DOM node stress test using Inferno and a custom HAMT implementation on a 2012 Macbook Air and ~25 fps on my 2nd generation Moto X. I consider this good enough but I can see how people who are more focused on mobile and in particular emerging mobile markets would have different opinions. My counter to these arguments is that I find the performance characteristics of the virtual DOM easy to reason about and performance being primarily driven by the output size has allowed me to take input datasets that I would not have even considered on observable systems. An example: I put together a calendar that was supposed to be a temporary prototype, wound up getting put into production (semi-predictably), and we had the events input grow to 9MB of gzipped JSON (two orders of magnitude more than I expected) before it got replaced. Load time was terrible but once it was up, latency for all actions was ~30ms. As for React itself, I find it acceptable. Its artificial event system made more sense when it was made but I think it's more overhead than value these days. I've never liked setState and never used it in a production app. The main reason to stick with it over a second-gen vdom library like Inferno is network effects. I tend to not use a lot of third party code so I expect to switch to an alternative vdom at some point in the not too distant future.
- yanjuk 10y agoA way to reduce disruptive comments might be to make one downvote cost one karma point. Down-voting should be for disruption, not ignorance. Ignorant comments are fine. Get them out there so they can be aired and corrected. Laymen get to know what they think. Experts get to know what laymen think. Occasionally there's a good idea. Talk is cheap and we should do more of it. The alternative is people being far more ignorant than they already are. But silently, in private, with more potential for harm.
- pjc50 10y agoSilent ignorance is fine. It's the loudly wrong people that are the problem. Wrong comments take more effort to rebut than they do to post; get enough of them and the SNR drops too low, because often the rebuttal is also "noise" - most people don't need a comment reminding them that global warming exists, for example.
- yanjuk 10y agoMy assumption is that commenting has the effect of reducing ignorance, even where ignorant comments are plentiful i.e. silent ignorance is more deadly than mostly-ignorant noise. This is because the very act of writing a comment, be it laden with misconceptions, causes its author to think, at least a little. Also reading different points of view helps people to identify common misconceptions and to make up their minds. (This doesn't include disruptive comments like fluff, complaining and gratuitous humour.)
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"My assumption is that commenting has the effect of reducing ignorance, even where ignorant comments are plentiful i.e. silent ignorance is more deadly than mostly-ignorant noise." What little, empirical evidence we have on these things shows the opposite: misinformation spreads more rapidly with less likelihood of being countered than accurate information. Facebook and others have done studies to show that. It would probably take a bit of time to go into the components of that but people (a) make spot judgments more than they do solid research; (b) prefer stuff compatible with their existing beliefs; (c) get those beliefs from biased sources; and (d) often attack people more as accountability goes down. This combo, which oversimplifies things but captures quite a bit, will create and reinforce echo chambers quite naturally if it's both easy to comment and vote. And we see it everywhere from HN to Reddit to political discussions about U.S. election. People presenting or voting in a balanced way giving disagreeing parties a chance are a tiny minority in overall discourse. Reputation and moderation systems should probably be designed with that as an assumption built-in.
- mooreds 10y agoI have often thought it's be great to do a "best comments of the week" email list the same way "Kernel Traffic" did for a number of years with Linux kernel development: http://www.kerneltraffic.org/kernel-traffic/archives.html http://www.kerneltraffic.org/kernel-traffic/archives.html Condensing comments down to the 5-10 gems would be very interesting. And, perhaps with the voting system, not that difficult.
- veddox 10y agoI like that idea! The only problem I see is that great comments are often embedded within an extensive discussion - how do you give readers of such a digest the necessary context without too much bloat?
- mooreds 10y agoI can think of two options: * Embed enough to give the reader context (maybe a link to the original article or quoting the parent or grandparent is enough) * Only include those comments that are stand-alone. It'd be quite a lot of work, but even if you highlighted 10% of the great comments, you'd provide a great service.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tedmiston 10y agoYC has something like this in the Monday Morning Macro newsletter [1] called "Top Posts on Hacker News". I think it's a combination of highly voted comments and ones referred by other users that found them insightful. Interestingly the links to comments don't seem to be published anywhere on the website, unlike everything else in the email. [1]: http://www.themacro.com/ http://www.themacro.com/
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cronjobber 10y ago> when people make comments that aren’t just reasonable sounding but are actually correct, those comments tend to get upvoted For a while, I found that on pages with lots of comments the most interesting ones were to be found at the top––and, buried between actual dross, at the bottom. That might have changed, I don't see it that much anymore. But that could be a side effect of something even less desirable. I think some people may have started flagging whole articles when the discussion has "too many" comments they dislike. I can't prove this, of course.
- zzzcpan 10y agoI have the opposite experience. I never found the most interesting comments at the top on popular posts. They usually just reflect a public opinion or come from "famous" HNers. I even reconsider my opinions, when my comments are upvoted too much. Because it means that public shares the same opinion and it is likely to be influenced by PR/marketing/politics.
- lorenzhs 10y agoThe comments on that "Lenovo is blocking Linux on some new laptops" story a while back were truly abysmal. I think that's the only time where I was really disappointed by HN comments. Now obviously (and as many of the more thoughtful commenters pointed out) this was just a case of missing support in the Linux kernel. There was no "secret deal" between Lenovo and Microsoft that the customer service rep on that forum revealed. Intel posted some patches to fix this a few days ago: http://marc.info/?l=linux-ide&m=147709610621480&w=2 http://marc.info/?l=linux-ide&m=147709610621480&w=2 The thread I question, with over 1000 points and 500 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12545878 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12545878
- qb45 10y agoThere was more to it than missing support in Linux. These SSDs have two modes of operation: AHCI (supported by any OS) and proprietary (requiring special drivers). Lenovo chose to hide the corresponding menu in UEFI setup and hacked the firmware to revert changes made through UEFI variables so that the SSD was permanently stuck in proprietary RAID mode, at that time supported only by Lenovo's modified Windows 10. Ultimately Lenovo said they did it because RAID mode performs better, but they only published this explanation after the outbreak of Internet drama.
- lorenzhs 10y agoI didn't argue that Lenovo did everything right - but there was no conspiracy. No secret deal with Microsoft. There were lazy decisions on Lenovo's side and missing driver support in Linux. But regardless of what the actual technical reasons where, when you look at that thread now, wouldn't you agree that many of the comments were sub-par and didn't meet the quality guidelines of HN?
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI'm around a quarter through that thread which I missed previously cuz this dude bought an Ubuntu Dell that lasted 8 years. So, the situation seems to be they intentionally changed BIOS setting to not allow alternatives to their proprietary image or something like that. A lock-in technique in an industry that's had one after another exposed going back over a decade. So, what is going on the thread posits. Let me go through the top-ranked comments. vanderZwan quotes a reference about companies that take away users' freedoms using proprietary extensions or changes that cripple or lock you into the product somehow. Biggest PC manufacturers do that when they can. Lenovo appears to. It fits. That subthread includes at least two good ones with the rest "blah." Next is paulintrognon sayings they locked the thread. DanBC countered that. Quality of this subthread & that original got upvoted is best evidence of your position so far. Then SamBam references a history of shady inclusions while some others show alternative products for Linux. Remember some upvote a shoddy, top-level comment if it contains useful information. Getting to your original point is deviate_X saying it doesn't have Linux drivers. dagaci points out Microsoft wouldn't block other MS products. Sounds good but subpoints win me over from a3n, the throwaway, and nowprovision. This is already probably the answer based on prior experience that showed up by 2nd top-level comment with some shoddy one-liners and such that are easy to skim since they likely greyed out quickly & rapid-fire, small responses are often flamewars. You might be thinking, "Hold on! You agreed with what?!" Microsoft's riches started with monopolistic partnerships with OEM's that preloaded what they wanted on the system with ways to knockout competition. This evolved into big manufacturers preloading garbage for competitive advantage plus controlling images. Sold it as convenience and recovery. I got bit by that with HP when I got my first computer that had a recovery CD but not a Windows install and license (wth!?). With Vista, Microsoft convinced manufacturers to help it trick the public about the value of a huge, bloated OS with hardware upgrades that generated revenues for the manufacturer. That one backlashed with resulting Windows 7 being awesome. Then, they tried to push Windows 8 on people with a discount then try forced moves to Windows 10. The commenters indicate this Lenovo scheme forces a move to recent Windows as a side effect of its operation. That's exactly what Microsoft, who controls Windows licensing at OEM level, wants along with their prior preference they executed in many ways with corrupt OEM's cooperating. So, that's my theory after just two high-level comments and skimming past some garbage ones in the sub-threads of the second one. Got to what I needed to know in minutes. Overall thread might be full of garbage comments with the eye rolling implications of that. However, if BIOS was changed & for an OEM image of latest Windows, then the voting scheme worked since I got to the likely scenario in just a minute or two. That's if those premises were true. If they're not, then the thread would be an example of something else entirely.
- franciscop 10y agoMy feeling is that a large enough part of Hacker News has been any time within the last 10 years actively contributing in Stack Overflow. From my own experience, I learned how to ask/answer technical questions and participate in a technical discussion there while trying not to keep it political, and I totally feel that has helped me to provide good comments in HN from time to time. So I would challenge the sentences: > And yet, I haven’t found a public internet forum with better technical commentary. I have, it's StackOverflow. Even though it is not a public internet forum properly, I've found there some awesome technical commentaries there and I think it might have helped HN a lot on that side.
- zyngaro 10y agoSo true. I often jump to the comments before I read the linked article. The comments a very often of better quality and more informed than the article it self. HN is unique in today's internet it's a great community and I hope it stays that way.
- angry_octet 10y agoI greatly miss Usenet newsgroups -- NNTP ones, not yahoo or google groups, or any of the pale http immitations. The best were usually moderated of course, but even unmoderated ones often had high signal to noise. I imagine how they might be now with rich text rendering, e.g. embedded TeX and images. Good newsreaders (MT-Newswatcher on MacOS springs to mind, but also fast console programs like tin) really helped. There were no 'likes' or 'vote' buttons. But there was the ability to whitelist or blacklist certain authors by adding them to a user's 'killfile', leading to the wonderfully pithy permanent downvote reply: <plonk>
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoPreach it ;-) Even the raging assholes had a more interesting command of invective, the food tasted better and the air was fresher ... well ... one out of three ain't bad ...
- DrScump 10y ago"I greatly miss Usenet newsgroups... but even unmoderated ones often had high signal to noise..." Me, too. My presence there began in 1987. Part of what helped its signal-to-noise ratio was that participants tended to be in industry or academia, resulting in both better-informed contributors and a sense of community. There was, of course, the odd flamewar here and troll there, but they were the exception, not the rule. Even passionate arguments were mostly civil (ah, comp.lang.c was quite a lively place as the ANSI standard was being discussed... even just the NOALIAS debate alone). Participants also cared about readability; good netizenship meant trimming text unrelated to the context you were discussing (interleaved posting, as Wiki calls it). As the AOL bridge and the top-posting mongrel horde of Outlook posters flooded in, there went the neighborhood... damn neighbor kids messing up our lawn!
- angry_octet 10y agoAnd now top posting is the norm in email! It's so anti-electronic to do it that way, as if we were exchanging _letters_. > Participants also cared about readability; good netizenship meant trimming text unrelated to the context you were discussing I get confusion these days if I use [snip], people think I am mutilating their email through spite or something.
- cyanbane 10y agoReading this article and thinking back on the users on HN that I do enjoy reading comments from I think that a neat feature may be the ability for a logged in user to "favorite/mark" specific authors. Those authors only get some particular character in front of their name (or a different color) so that they stand out more. I do agree with this post about seeing certain names and knowing that the signal ratio will be higher is nice. May just need a better way to discern those when scanning a comments section.
- egeozcan 10y agoOf course the top comment can sometimes be positive. For example when the article is about HN itself. On a more serious note, I guess most people in the tech crowd can make a 5-item list of why HN comments suck and that is exactly the power of HN comments.
- throw2016 10y agoI miss the deep expertise often on display on forums like slashdot in the past which is conspicious by its absence here. In many ways this is more of a professional board than a personal board. A lot of folks here are in the profession and don't seem to speak their mind, lest they lose career opportunities. This also seems to promote an affection of expertise and authoritative tone even on subjects commentators may not know much about. There is offhand dismissal of dissent as 'resistant to change' and a serious lack of scrutiny that often allows broken technologies and services to be hyped endlessly untill people come back months or years later to report deficiencies but by then the train has left the station. And any forum that promotes downvotes to signal dissent cannot by design promote diverse discussion and will naturally coalesce around a 'socially acceptable' consensus.
- jasonkostempski 10y ago"Some downsides of immutability" ...
- anythingbot 10y agoI would like to propose wikipedia edit history and comment deletion milestones for the hn comment system, and in addition, a comment redaction facility that works like redaction of classified documents.
- bashexporting 10y agoHN comments are moderated (not the moderators which are completely fine and, in my case, always clear of what was off-topic and in need of flagging, but the community that flags) by the hive-mind that is like any hive-mind against diversity. Of the dozens of accounts I had, some have reached karma levels of awe, and some were met with extreme flagging and disapproval. The most pleasant and interesting discussions are mostly in the technical, scientific themes. When it comes to diet, lifestyle issues, comments are overflooded with bunch of anecdotal claims, unscientific babbling and extreme boasting. I stay away from these threads after I've realized this was the case.
- ericolo 10y agoI come here for the content. Before I started frequently coming here, I used solely reddit. I didn't "get" HN at the time. But at some point it started growing on me, I started coming here more and more often, and right now it's my primary source of random information. I still reddit, but more for leisure and time wasting than anything else. I don't check comment much, thought. As a side effect, it had also changed my browsing customs; before it wasn't difficult for me to go down to the 10th page on reddit. Nowadays I'm barely past the 2nd page.
- acabal 10y agoThese criticisms, when phrased in the manner of the post ("HN is full of mean and rude people"), suggest by omission that there's some kind of internet forum Nirvana out there where everyone's nice all the time and nobody every says mean things or is rude. ("HN is full of mean and rude people [... unlike place X, which is always great all the time]") But the thing is, once a community reaches a mid-to-large size, certain kinds of people will always going to think it's full of jerks and trolls, and that its golden age has long passed--regardless of the community's age or actual composition. I run one of the largest online writing communities online, Scribophile. We've been around going on 9 years and I personally pride myself on the reputation we've earned as being a friendly and supportive community. By and large people seem to agree. And yet every now and then we still get people complaining that Scrib members are out to get them, that everyone is mean, that Scrib's golden age has passed. (I started hearing that same golden age comment about 6 months in, by the way). I think the truth is more like the faceless, voiceless, anonymous internet makes it really easy for people to both a) be jerks, and b) misinterpret harmless posts as people being jerks. I think this phenomenon happens in every mid-to-large sized community, ever. And I don't think it's really helpful to criticize any community of that size as having nothing but mean people, or trending towards meanness.
- zodiac 10y agoUh, did you read his second paragraph? > And yet, I haven’t found a public internet forum with better technical commentary.
- lstamour 10y agoI don't think they're mutually exclusive opinions. HN could be seen as mean or rude just as it can be technically correct -- and sometimes at the same time. The original post also acknowledges that there's been an effort to reduce negative comments in the past few years.
- zodiac 10y agoI read danluu's first two paragraphs as making the argument that "comments on HN are bad, but better than comments on any other online community", instead of as trying to distinguish between meanness and technical correctness.
- netsec_burn 10y agoThis article and its comments are surprisingly negative. I've long held the opinion that HN is the best aggregator out there, and the comments are top notch as well. Far better than Reddit, subreddits like /r/programming+sysadmin+netsec etc, /g/, Slashdot, and the list goes on.
- emblem21 10y agoHonestly, I come here just for the comments. I rarely read the articles unless a comment is excited about something arcane.
- tedmiston 10y agoI really think the author is onto something here. Recently I've been thinking about doing a couple blog posts that summarize the HN thread for a given article* in perhaps ~1500 words. I think of it like the approach that r/tabled uses for AMAs on Reddit (example: [1]). Would others find this interesting, or would you rather just read the comments yourself? A second idea is — a daily / weekly update of comments from all of the people you're interested in "following" on HN. You can do this very manually right now. I think it could be an interesting proof of concept. *When I say one article, I really mean the aggregate of recent links around that topic as discussions are often merged or commenters bring information from other sources into the commentary for whichever link takes off on that topic. Often that is the most original source, but not always. [1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/tabled/comments/4lh4t1/table_iama_i_am_david_belk_im_a_doctor_who_has/ https://www.reddit.com/r/tabled/comments/4lh4t1/table_iama_i...
- pavlov 10y agoI second Dan's advice of blogging more. I'm a very average HN commenter. I do put in effort in writing here, trying to be civil above all and sharing my experience where it could be of interest. But I'm not Alan Kay, I've never rewritten a distributed deep learning system in Haskell using a genetically optimized Paxos consensus protocol, and my entrepreneurial experience is a loose string of "don't do this" case studies at best... So my comments certainly won't make anyone's "Best of HN" list. Last week, after the news broke that Salesforce walked away from buying Twitter, I was about to write a HN comment about what Twitter could do. The text got long enough that I decided to expand it into a Medium post instead: https://medium.com/swlh/twitter-could-be-the-next-mozilla-e788e3bfd841#.x0gbzodo4 https://medium.com/swlh/twitter-could-be-the-next-mozilla-e7... To my surprise, the post has 28,000 views and 755 recommends so far. If I had written it as a HN comment, it would have got maybe 5-10 upvotes and perhaps spawned a short discussion thread about how unrealistic my idea was. (Please don't bother to criticize the content of the blog post in replies here -- I'm just using it as an example of blog vs. comment.) I love reading HN discussions... But maybe there could be a site that slots between the HN and Medium formats, and lets you expand your comment into a blog post with minimal friction? Call it "HN Long-Form" or whatever. Ideally it would interface with the HN comment system so that you could mark your comment with something like "Promote to long-form" after you've written it. That would create an editable post on the long-form site. You could then later expand your comment there, and publish it on the long-form comment aggregator site. (Maybe I should just build this myself and see if it feels right.)
- veddox 10y agoYes, I have sometimes thought too that some of my longer comments on HN could be expanded into a blog entry quite easily. Unfortunately, I don't have a blog to publish it on and I don't consider it worth the hassle getting one.
- david-given 10y agoI completely agree. In 2009 I got a brief 15 minutes of internet fame through a incredibly badly written essay about... a thing (not relevant here). Seven years later it's still one of the most popular pages on my website, although luckily it's been eclipsed by better content. If I spent half the time writing more blog content (aargh, my last entry was 2015) than I do here, I'd have a really nice corpus of work. Which people might read! I have seen a tool which allows a HN thread to be used as a comment on a external blog post --- it came up a few weeks back. I don't know if this worked by screen-scraping HN itself or whether there's an API, but either way it suggests that your idea would work.
- hogrammer 10y agoReally? Half of them are "I can't read it! It's paywalled". The other half is pointing out that it's a dupe. And the third half is people whining "NOT FAIR! I posted the same story and didn't get any sweet karma points."
- pavlov 10y agoOn second read, I'm not sure I agree with the first paragraphs of Dan's post at all. He seems to be saying that HN is terrible, but a handful of comments from star posters rise above the muck. I just don't think that's fair. Yes, the cliché is that HN is a place full of mean, entitled semi-autists who will criticize your site's CSS whitespace formatting when you ask for business feedback... And of course there's a grain of truth to that (persistent stereotypes usually don't come out of thin air), but it misses the mark on two dimensions. The first is that the criticism you get on HN is no worse than what other aspiring creative professionals suffer. I went to an art and design college, and the critique you'd get from students and even teachers was 99% of the time harsher than the HN style, yet no more guaranteed to be useful. Consider a first-time novelist who spent years on a book. One day it gets critiqued in a newspaper. The professional critic might find that the author has a clumsy style, poor research, paper-thin characters, and seems to lack the life experience to even write about the topic. What do you do after that kind of criticism? You suck it up and go back to work on the next novel. Making use of feedback is all about filtering and reducing multiple sources into something actionable. Nobody is right all the time. Your parents were wrong. Your teachers were wrong. Your peers were wrong. Your professors were wrong. Your boss was wrong. Your cofounders were wrong. Your investors were wrong. HN commenters were wrong. Still it's worth taking in all these inputs as much as you can. The other dimension of HN comments is that they can be surprisingly deep. When an arts or culture topic makes it to the front page, it seems like someone comes out of the woods with the perfect personal anecdote. Whether it's Mondrian, Messiaen or Modiano, there's always someone on HN who happens to have a passion for it. HN comments are underrated, but it's not just because of star power: it's everyone's contributions that make it consistently worthwhile for me.
- Mz 10y agoComment moved, per request.
- lucb1e 10y agoIs there any reason why you replied to a comment instead of responding to the article? Because as a sub it has little added value to the parent, but as a top level comment I would have liked to see it as the #1 comment. Edit: for the record, it moved to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12775905 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12775905
- sideproject 10y agoI absolutely love comments on HN and they are probably the main reason I read this site a lot. Some times, the posts themselves are quite self-explanatory from the title and I just go straight to the discussions. I created a little site called HackerNews Club http://hackernews.club http://hackernews.club Where you can easily search for user's submissions and comments. FYI, here's Dan's comments :) http://hackernews.club/luu#search/52e35e01f172df6d183c59633ce86089ad66cece http://hackernews.club/luu#search/52e35e01f172df6d183c59633c... And HN users ordered by the number of comments they have made. http://hackernews.club/#search/39a2159841122c713bf4324d6f9de7fbb98cfcd1 http://hackernews.club/#search/39a2159841122c713bf4324d6f9de...
- phs318u 10y agoSeconded. I too love HN comments. Overall, my perception is that HN has reasonably non-clickbaity articles with a good blend of tech and non-tech. The comments I find largely pertinent, overwhelmingly constructively critical, with FAR fewer trolls, flames and biased voting than any other public forum on the internet I've ever come across since the original Usenet days. In fact, it reminds me very much of good ol' Compuserve (there's nothing like having to pay REAL money for a subscription to curb bad behaviour).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wruza 10y agoTo be honest, I practically never read posts beyond titles. If there is no tldr in comments, post was not worth it anyway. It may seem funny, but it is a great mechanism to selectively widen knowledge without going into details everywhere.
- Mz 10y agoYet another human bemoaning the fact that when myriad humans randomly get together on the internet, some folks are clueless, some folks are not nice, some folks write poorly, etc. There are things that can be done to improve online discussion. But expecting everyone to be equally knowledgeable, savvy, etc is simply not a reasonable expectation.
- JoachimSchipper 10y agoWell, you can't have both that and "open", at least...
- spectrum1234 10y agoThis article and the (currently) highest rated comment with the Medium article is making me want to write more. I've always considered a simple blog where I just write short commentary on articles I've read that I feel are incorrect or incomplete. One thing that has held me back is knowing I'm not a brilliant writer. However am going to try and keep in mind the great blog post by Paul Graham that stresses to always write in short sentences. Good luck me!
- karussell 10y ago> HN comments are terrible. The truth is that more articles than comments are waste of time (as comments are often a lot shorter or simpler to grasp) so I have to disagree here: I often find myself reading the comments before clicking on the article to save me time. And I'm not the only one.
- Jaruzel 10y agoZero criticism here - I love danluu.com posts[1], but ... Who is he? And why does all of his posts get massively up-voted? Thanks in advance, from an ignorant chimp. :) -- [1] However, a little bit of CSS sprinkled on them wouldn't go amiss - even just 'max-width' would help a lot.
- JoachimSchipper 10y agoI upvote danluu.com because I consistently like the posts; at some point, the domain name becomes a marker of quality. Dan Luu has an about page and a LinkedIn page, but he's not a mega-celebrity or Chief Architect of Google or some such - he's mostly a guy with an uncommon-but-useful mix of backgrounds who writes well.
- lmm 10y ago> For the last couple years (ish?), the moderation regime has been really active in trying to get a good mix of stories on the front page and in tamping down on gratuitously mean comments. But there was a period of years where the moderation could be described as sparse, arbitrary, and capricious, and while there are fewer “bad” comments now, it doesn’t seem like good moderation actually generates more “good” comments. I agree that there was a major change in moderation 1-2 years ago. But I think it's worse rather than better. The moderation is more arbitrary and capricious now (in particular it's a lot more active during the hours when the US is awake), and there are a lot of positive-but-contentless fluff comments and even humour, both of which are inimical to what made HN great.
- z3t4 10y agoOne thing I dont like about HN is that I do not have time to read everything and explore each new technology. It's like throwing away good food when you're hungry.
- xcombelle 10y agoFrom my point of view, which is biased relatively to the HN target audience because I'm not so much interested in the startup things, reddit is overall superior to HN, either concerning the posts or the comment thread. concerning the technological news feed, my best source of content is definitely https://lobste.rs/ https://lobste.rs/