25 ms·
The Anti-Helicopter Parent’s Plea: Let Kids Play
- dzdt 10y agoI am surprised this guy's homeowners insurance hasn't dropped him. A few years ago I had to switch companies or be dropped for having a trampoline -- with a full net -- in my fenced backyard. Insurance companies hate anything with any risk, especially of injury to outside visitors.
- grecy 10y ago> A few years ago I had to switch companies or be dropped for having a trampoline -- with a full net -- in my fenced backyard Seriously? Wow, as a non-American I find that outrageous. I wonder when they'll threaten to drop people for having coke in their fridge or water in their bathtub. After all, those things kill people every day! They're extremely dangerous.
- ascendantlogic 10y agoInsurance isn't about helping people cover expenses, it's about collecting as much premium as possible while paying out as little as possible.
- lando2319 10y agonowadays commercials of Insurance companies actually tout that they pay the settlements. It would be like me, a Developer, touting that I actually finish apps, I don't just take the money.
- Ntrails 10y agoTaken to it's logical conclusion you can argue that every business is going to try and cut every possible cost and service to maximise profit. Insurance is not about helping people cover expenses though, it is about pooling risk for the benefit of the group. This does mean that if you are a stunt helicopter pilot then other people in a low risk pool may tell you that they don't want you in it anymore. America has a whole bunch of weirdness around insurance law etc. so I can't really speak much as I'm foreign - but there are good reasons that insurers don't cover Skiing on default travel insurance for example - and it isn't to screw the consumer.
- grecy 10y ago> it is about pooling risk for the benefit of the group. AND making obscene profit for the insurance company. I wish we had more things like this that were non-profit. An insurance non-profit could charge the same premiums as a company does today, then whatever "profit" they have left at the end of the year after expenses they just refund back to all customers as a percentage of their premiums. Everyone would pay way less, all the employees still get paid the same, and we'd still have the benefit of pooling the risk.
- Ntrails 10y agoI'd love to see more on the obscene profit side of this. Honestly - I've done some work on pricing, reserving, etc in insurance and spoken to practicing GI actuaries - the margins are just not that large. Are you specifically pointing to US medical insurers (I cannot comment at all on that tbh beyond the fact that the whole system is problematic)?
- sliverstorm 10y agoIn fairness, it's my understanding trampolines are really honestly fairly hazardous, despite their pedestrian appearance & our fond memories. More than 1 million people went to emergency departments for trampoline-related injuries between 2002 and 2011, with nearly 300,000 of those injuries involving broken bones approximately 900,000 consumer trampolines sold each year Doing some extremely crude correlation- For every ten trampolines sold a year, one person will visit the ER that year, and for every thirty trampolines sold, one person will break a bone. Yeah, I can see why insurance doesn't like them. They aren't saying you can't have one, they just don't want to cover them. http://theweek.com/articles/472062/dangers-owning-home-trampoline-by-numbers http://theweek.com/articles/472062/dangers-owning-home-tramp... http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/04/29/trampoline-injuries-fractures-broken-bones_n_5227768.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/04/29/trampoline-injuries...
- fsloth 10y agoWhat? That sounds crazy to a non-US person. Are you saying that if someone came to visit and hurt themselves on the trampoline they would charge your insurance for it?
- jwhitlark 10y agoThey could sue you, and it would fall through to your insurance.
- matthewmcg 10y agoNo, an injured guest could sue you and your insurance company would be required under the policy to defend you and pay any bodily injury against you.
- moonbug 10y agoI guess you live some place with free-at-the-point-of-use healthcare.
- vonmoltke 10y agoInsurance settlements in personal injury cases go well beyond just medical bills.
- 1123581321 10y agoAbsolutely. I just opened my home policy online and I have $300,000 coverage for Personal Liability in addition to coverage of home, property, etc. The description for the Personal Liability insurance says: "If a claim is made or a suit is brought against an insured for damages because of bodily injury or property damage caused by an occurrence to which this coverage applies, we will: * Pay up to our limit of liability for the damages for which the insured is legally liable. Damages include prejudgment interest awarded against the insured; and * Provide a defense at our expense by counsel of our choice, even if the suit is groundless, false or fraudulent. We may investigate and settle any claim or suit that we decide is appropriate. Our duty to settle or defend ends when the amount we pay for damages resulting from the occurrence equals our limit of liability." Some people also take out a personal umbrella policy which covers personal liability beyond home or auto. For example, a former employer's daughter and a friend were in an auto accident. The parents of the friend sued my boss for personal injury on her behalf, and my boss had to pay about two million dollars. Her auto policy probably covered $100-500k of that, and the rest was covered by the umbrella policy.
- M_Grey 10y agoInsurance companies want nothing to do with attractive nuisances; they'd much prefer you live in a padded cell, drawing a paycheck and paying your bills. In short, they are scum.
- pilom 10y agoA successful entrepreneur who had sold businesses could theoretically just self insure. If you have paid off your house, you don't technically need home insurance (though this guy would be silly not to have it).
- Icedcool 10y agoThis is awesome. I think this is much needed for boys and children today.
- M_Grey 10y agoThe degree to which people in this country, in this time feel entitled to impose their neurotic crap on other people's kids, is disgusting. Ironically, it's one of the of the few reasons to, "Think of kids".
- mc32 10y agoI think it's the opposite. People used to raise children more communally. People knew each others children and would scold them if they misbehaved while out in the street etc. Nowadays, people are fearful to give misbehaving children feedback for fear of the parent getting aggressively offended.
- M_Grey 10y agoThere's an element of that, but it exists in combination with the air of hysteria and constant panic influencing the decisions of police and other public officials. It becomes a crime to leave a child unattended for minuscule periods, that kind of thing. It's an odd combination of extreme societal neglect, punctuated with equally extreme hysteria.
- mc32 10y agoYes, very true. It's unfortunate. It seems people have moved away from being normally concerned an offering a helping hand to becoming parenting vigilantes. I think the fear instilled by "stranger danger" and litigiousness has had a big influence in how people behave toward other people's children. Since they can only interact from a distance, it's now through official channels where there is no leeway, common sense judgement. It's all black or white.
- yanjuk 10y ago'Helicopter parenting' is misleading: it's not the degree of parental involvement and oversight that's the problem, it's the degree of unwelcome interference. True, if I'm going to err I'd rather err on the side of benign neglect. Yet blaming 'overprotective' parents is unfair. It only takes phone call or two and children can be temporarily removed by social services. The mere prospect of which is a major heartache.
- veidr 10y agoLet's be clear: this is an issue only in the world's sole superidiocracy. (I share your concern, because my children and I are citizens.) There are (many) other problems in other countries, but not that specific problem.
- tarr11 10y agoThe American Academy of Pediatrics advises against children using trampolines unsupervised due to high rated of injury. https://www.aap.org/en-us/about-the-aap/aap-press-room/pages/AAP-Advises-Against-Recreational-Trampoline-Use.aspx?nfstatus=401&nftoken=00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000000&nfstatusdescription=ERROR:+No+local+token https://www.aap.org/en-us/about-the-aap/aap-press-room/pages...
- chrissnell 10y agoThere's a lot of activities that the AAP recommends against and we did almost every one of them as a kid. I'm eternally grateful to my parents that I enjoyed an amazing childhood full of trampolines, dangerously unstable and high tree forts, homemade fireworks, driveway skateramps, pocketknives (and plenty of sliced fingers), and all of the other cool shit that parents don't let their kids do anymore.
- logfromblammo 10y agoThe only blade-related injury I have ever seen was actually caused by a hatchet, while splitting small-diameter firewood for a campfire. Some topical antibiotic ointment and butterfly bandages took care of it for the four days it took us to reach the pick-up point. She didn't have permission to use the hatchet unsupervised, and was not following the family-approved safe-use technique. Needless to say, she was not allowed to do anything fun for the rest of the trip. It made a nice scar, though. People can ask her how she got it, and she can say, "oh, that's from a hatchet, a four day journey away from the nearest hospital." My most interesting scar is from the underside of the dashboard on a Honda Civic while installing an aftermarket stereo, and you can barely even see it. I have never seen a pocketknife injury, though. Nor any from archery equipment, or firearms. I'd probably be most worried about barbed treble-fishhooks and swimming in warm freshwater lakes and rivers. Not really because of drowning, so much as slips and falls from mud or algae-coated rocks, or infectious parasites in the water. My spouse, on the other hand, never got to do anything fun as a kid, and freaks out about everything even remotely dangerous, like my sharp, pointy tweezers. The only people more unreasonably intolerant of minute risks work for the TSA. Trampolines, though. Those things are deathtraps. I'd rather have a swimming pool drained of water and refilled with rattlesnakes in my back yard. Also, no [American] football.
- keeran 10y agoKinda amusing that it looks like the girl in flight is about to slam hard!
- EA 10y agoI'm pretty sure she is jumping from the railing on the porch of the house and will land well onto the trampoline.
- modoc 10y agoI agree with this 100%! I grew up free to explore the woods, build forts, climb trees, jump off rocks, swim unsupervised, ride mt. bikes down steep hills, drive dirt bikes from age 10 on, drive snowmobiles, carry a pocket knife, whittle, etc... Yes, I cut myself on occasion, even broke a couple bones, but it was completely worth it and helped me grow up to be self sufficient, self confident, and know my limits, strengths, and weaknesses. I really do feel badly for most of the kids today, who are so hampered and restrained. Don't let you kid fall into a bonfire, but DO let them burn themselves on the stove (after you tell them - that is hot). Inform but let them learn from their own mistakes. There's nothing wrong with a few cuts, bruises, scrapes, burns, etc...
- throwawayReply 10y agoThat's very literally survivor bias. How many kids swam unsupervised, jumped off rocks and rode down steep hills and didn't return home? They're not here to tell the tale about how it "worked fine for them". I'm not saying that things haven't gone too far the other way, but anecdotes about how things were fine aren't good data.
- goodJobWalrus 10y ago> That's very literally survivor bias. How many kids swam unsupervised, jumped off rocks and rode down steep hills and didn't return home? According to this guy, very few: https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/freedom-learn/201404/risky-play-why-children-love-it-and-need-it https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/freedom-learn/201404/ri... > From an evolutionary perspective, the obvious question about risky play is this: Why does it exist? It can cause injury (though serious injury is rare) and even (very rarely) death, so why hasn’t natural selection weeded it out? The fact that it hasn’t been weeded out is evidence that the benefits must outweigh the risks. What are the benefits? Laboratory studies with animals give us some clues.
- sliverstorm 10y agoWhile I don't disagree with his premise, that gives almost no data, and seems like a weak argument. Why hasn't war been weeded out? It must not really be all that risky.
- bwooceli 10y agoMy wife and I are not "helicopter parents", but that doesn't mean we don't believe in healthy boundaries. Mike talked about wanting to believe that his kids would respect his trust, well part of that respect can also be earned in demonstrating that you do, in fact, "know better" about some things by virtue of your age/experience/wisdom. As a parent I don't use my "wisdom" as an excuse to prevent them from learning things for themselves, but in the case of playing on the roof for example, I would put a limit. C'mmon man, don't kill your kids for an ideal.
- Prefinem 10y agoHaving fallen off a roof before, I feel like going straight to the 'kill your kids' is a little extreme. I would guess that most falls that result in death are from either a higher than average roof height or onto ground harder than dirt. Also, how will a child learn about the dangers of heights if they never fall and hurt themselves? You can teach them, and that might work for some, but some children have / need to learn the hard way and that's okay.
- sliverstorm 10y agoThey can certainly have fun & play, and learn about falling, without falling off a roof. The same way they can learn about the hazards of sharp things without playing on a table saw.
- DannyBee 10y agoJust to point out (because hey, why not :P) Table saws are a bad example in some cases. My saw stop will stop the blade in <5 milliseconds of contact. It equates to basically scratching your finger or better (blades move at 3000-3600rpm, so it calculates out to about 1/4 revolution of the blade, max.) As far as i'm aware, they've literally never had a brake activation failure. It's pretty much the safest thing in my shop. Of all the things i'd never let kids play with in the shop, it'd probably be chisels. Which is ironic, because people think they are a good way to introduce kids to woodworking, when they are probably the sharpest and least safe thing due to how sharp and easy to cause severe injury.
- herbps10 10y ago“What are the chances of falling off the roof?” he argued vociferously when we tried previously to hash it out. Have I ever known anyone who has fallen off a roof? Anyway, he said, it’s not as if he doesn’t give his kids any limits: They are not allowed to play ball or tag up there." Yes, but most kids are not allowed or encouraged to play on their roofs. If they were, the rate of injury would likely be much higher.
- barry-cotter 10y ago> Yes, but most kids are not allowed or encouraged to play on their roofs. If they were, the rate of injury would likely be much higher. I used to play on the roof of our shed. I have no idea what I did up there but I think it was mostly being deliberately up high. I dangled and jumped many times and jumped at least once before deciding that kind of hurt and deciding not to do it again. You overestimate the stupidity of children who are familiar with the concept of consequences. I also had my thumbnails fall off multiple times after hitting them with hammers and burned off the skin on my little finger once on a stovetop seeing exactly what these burns were that were so scary. I never even broke a bone and I have less than five wounds that should have received stitches. I had a boring, safe childhood.
- wonder_er 10y agoSame. I spent lots of time on the roof of our house. I'd jump off into the snow, sometimes, or sometimes just onto the dirt. Loved it. I hope my kids get a similar experience.
- duderific 10y agoSounds like your roof was not all that high. In the article I think they said the roof was 25 feet, which would very severely injure you (at least) if you fell off.
- durandal1 10y agoAs a kid, me and my friends would climb any roof we could. Of course adults would chase us down if they saw us, but we would just do it again when they were gone. This was rural Sweden in the 80s. You don't want to raise conformist children, you want to raise rebels.
- SunTzu55 10y agoWhat was that old Dennis Leary monologue about how all kids' toys in the 1950s were actually a Darwinian means of weeding out the weak and stupid before they could reproduce?
- chrissnell 10y agoThis is my ethos. I have two young boys--one 4 year-old and one 18 months--and this is how they are growing up. My four year old was riding without training wheels by two and on skate ramps by three [1]. My wife was initially against it but through my stubborn insistence, she's come around. As I mentioned in another comment, my sister and I grew up doing all sorts of dangerous shit and I will forever be grateful to my parents for not raising pansies. We build a rickety tree fort high in a tree and threw balls of mud and rocks at each other and the other neighborhood kids who played with us. We rode our bikes across major streets, we made homemade fireworks, and we had a trampoline in the neighbors' yard and a skate ramp in the driveway. It was an amazing childhood and it's exactly what I want for my boys. When we moved out here to small-town Kansas from the Seattle area, we spent time looking for the right street and we found it. Packs of kids roam unsupervised and there are few backyard fences. It's perfect. I hope that "playborhood" does become a thing again because there's no better way, IMHO, to raise kids. [1] https://www.instagram.com/p/BHNBJqmhM5T/?taken-by=christopherjsnell&hl=en https://www.instagram.com/p/BHNBJqmhM5T/?taken-by=christophe...
- Icedcool 10y agoGood for you!
- llimllib 10y agoWhere did you find a bike that fit a two year old? I have a balance bike for my kid but he can't stand over it yet
- chrissnell 10y agoThe bike in the Instagram video is a Diamondback Mini Viper. He got a balance bike (the Strider) for his second birthday and like your son, he also had a tough time standing over it. But, he grew and was able to get up on it pretty quickly. First, we practiced locomotion and later, coasting with his feet up on the stays behind the seat. Once he was flying around on that bike, we switched to the pedal bike. We had the same problem--he wasn't quite tall enough--but he grew again and could straddle it, sort of. The actual transition from balance bike to pedal bike went really quickly. Main thing they have to learn is the coaster brake. Good luck.
- rayiner 10y agoThe sad thing is that, unlike many other areas, parenting in the U.S. is getting worse, not better. Millennials are leading the way in increasing acceptance of LGBT individuals, legalizing drugs, etc., but most of the millennial parents I know are absolutely nuts. They make my own "overprotective asian mother" seem like a proponent of "free-range kids."
- saosebastiao 10y agoI can't speak for everywhere, but at least in Seattle, most of the helicopter parents I see and know are not millenials but genX. I'm on the upper edge of what is called a millennial, and almost everybody I know that is younger than me is very intentionally hands off.
- pnathan 10y agoCurious, do you have kids & if so, are you doing the hands off thing? I live in Seattle (within city limits) and would love to chat with someone about how the hands-off/free-range thing is working in practice within this city.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoI don't see any evidence that free play is increasing as new parents are coming on line. Things look even more structured and over protected than ever.
- sulam 10y agoWait, do you want to let children be, or intervene in their lives? Or is it that you only want to intervene when your sensibilities are offended?
- Diederich 10y agoI'll post this as a top-level comment because I think it's a relevant reply to a number of other comments. In response to, for example, this line from goodJobWalrus: > I mean people get arrested for letting their kids go to the park or play in their own backyards, for god's sake. Honest question: what is the objective, per-child risk of that happening? I don't have data for that handy, but I would be shocked if it was anything except exceedingly low, on the order of getting killed in a commercial aircraft crash. My wife and I frequently struggle with the this vague fear of people turning us in to social services, because we've read a number of articles about that happening to families who were raising their kids in a way that was completely normal a couple of decades ago. But even with all of the general societal paranoia we are saddled with, I'm almost certain that we are still statistically safe from such over-reach.
- rootusrootus 10y agoAs with everything else I hear on the Internet, I remind myself that it wouldn't be talked about if it were not newsworthy.
- orthecreedence 10y agoEhh, I disagree. Hysteria and FUD can take on lives of their own, living inside the minds of people who let them in even a little. Just because a number of people are upset by something (or believe they should be upset by something) doesn't actually mean it's worth being upset about. The news/media takes these small concerns and blows them out of proportion to sell ad space, which compounds the hysteria. Example: terrorism. It's a nice trigger word in the USA, but how many people are killed by terrorism vs car crashes or unhealthy habits? Yes, terrorism should be reported on, but it's certainly not as important to anyone's everyday life as not eating shit food and texting like an asshole while driving. Kids just don't get kidnapped or molested by strangers enough to be statistically significant. Kids are almost always molested by relatives, in a private setting. Kidnapping by stranger is even more rare. Sure, it can happen. Just like a comet could hit Earth. Should we sit around worrying about it, while our children re doomed to have us constantly looking over their shoulders until they're 18 and have no sense of self-purpose?
- easyfrag 10y agoI have 2 kids and have consciously tried to avoid the helicopter-parent mindset and let them play on their own. But now as they approach adolescence I find myself more interested in how they spend their free time. Not so much hovering but making sure they are busy, gentle encouraging team sports & activities as an alternative to just "hanging out." I believe the audience here skews younger but for those of you that have raised kids to adulthood, any advice? And for you more recent adolescents, how did you experience parenting at that age? When I look back it seems to me that the smartphone has changed everything.
- cortesoft 10y agoWhy do you want them to do something besides "just hanging out?" What is wrong with just hanging out?
- mschuster91 10y agoBecause the simple act of "hanging out" on the streets might earn them an arrest for "loitering" or whatever, which in turn greatly diminishes employment when you got a record full of arrests. As a German, it was absolutely normal for me to be outside on a public place and drink beers! From what I see on parenting-related HN posts, in US drinking beers in public is illegal in most places, and minimum age for a f..ing beer is 21. I didn't spend all my youth drinking beer though, but just hanging out with friends at a park was daytime activity after school until I was 18 and had a driver's license - we ended up with driving around town, spending all money we had on gas, and generally having fun. Also, it was perfectly acceptable to grab a phone, drum up your friends for a spontaneous LAN party and basically spend the entire day with gaming and watching 240p porn downloaded via eMule. My sister is a bit younger than me, and even then I saw the great difference in available time after school between her and me. Thanks to the G8 reform (instead of 9 years highschool after 4y basic school, they shrunk it down to 8y in Bavaria) not only the school days were longer, but the amount of homework and learning were massively higher. If all your time gets eaten up by school, when are kids supposed to play or take part in outside-of-school activities like politics, sports, music, ...?
- ewhanley 10y ago
- javiramos 10y agoI like this blog of a couple that has been traveling the world for many years: http://www.bumfuzzle.com/ http://www.bumfuzzle.com/ They had kids a few years ago and they strongly advocate giving kids freedom to play, explore etc. Not advocating for anything but just wanted to share an example of one of the ends of the spectrum...
- EA 10y agoI like to think of myself as more of a VTOL parent instead of a Helicopter parent.
- Fricken 10y agoI my city in we had a little Robert Moses in the parks and rec department who designed amazing, unique and challenging playgrounds in every new neighbourhood that went up in the late 70s and early 80s during a time of rapid growth for the city. From 6-12 I lived in my local playground during the summers, it was a full time job, I wanted to be a stuntman when grew up. Those playgrounds have since all been replaced by the common kit playgrounds that are so crippled by draconian safety regulations that they aren't any fun at all for any developmentally normal kid over the age of 6. But weirdly, next to where my old playground used to be, they've put in a fancy new skatepark. Among other concrete forms it features an 11 foot high quarterpipe kids are encouraged to drop in on while standing on a little board with wheels under it. The ambulance pays a visit every other day during the summers. Thank heaven for universal health care. Nature finds a way, sometimes.
- Spooky23 10y agoThat phenomenon is ADA related as well. You need to provide ground accessible equipment, "sensory" activities for specific age ranges at specific heights, limited slope ramps and other features now. Our local parks department actually has a court-mandated compliance officer because they were sued a few years ago for having a non-compliant playground. Having connecting ramps and bridges reduces some of that burden, which is one of the reasons why many playgrounds consist of a sprawling elevated ramp system with a few slides, wheels and other random crap. The skatepark is ironically easier to build, until someone manages to win a lawsuit, despite the obvious safety hazards.
- l3m0ndr0p 10y agoNice to be rich! Imagine this setup in a poor / middle class neighborhood. The cops & city/town would shut them down ASAP. The article is correct about one thing, letting children play freely. I've done this growing up in Queens NY, late 70s->80s. Funny thing. I wasn't allowed to cross the street until a certain age, I think around 8 years old. I used to ride my bike, play tag, hide &seek etc... down the block, where there were other children. We'd run in backyards (if they didn't have a too high of a fence). Then when I was a little older 12+, I'd ride further down other streets & avenues.. Eventually I'd go places further, Green Acres Mall, Bayside and even ride my bike to Roosevelt Field Mall. Early 80s....
- mafribe 10y agoThe article makes a testable statement: "Think about your own 10 best memories of childhood, and chances are most of them involve free play outdoors [...] How many of them took place with a grown-up around?" Yup, that is correct for me. And I was a bookish, introverted child. Still unsupervised exploration of forrests, abandoned factories, houses under construction, rivers, caves, tunnels ... was awesome.
- eric_h 10y agoSame here. I think my favorite unsupervised childhood memory was the time when (I was about ~10 years old) the day after a big rainstorm, that turned a nearby creek into more or less a river, we took a couple of inflatable rafts and went for a little boat ride. We ended up miles and miles away from any of our parents' houses and once it started to get dark, we hopped out of the stream, went and knocked on some random person's door and asked to use the phone. Our parents weren't thrilled at having to pick us up, but we had a great time.
- DavidAdams 10y agoI did this exact same thing as a teenager when our creek turned into a torrent, but because I had thoroughly explored the forest as a free-range kid, I knew where the creek would take us, so we arranged to have someone meet us at a faraway bridge with a car.
- eric_h 10y agoOurs was more spur of the moment and done without our parent's permission. We spent hours on the boats, and none of us had traced this particular creek that far (and the water was moving at a nice clip).
- int_19h 10y agoSame thing here, and I was one of those kids who got regularly taunted by playmates for being a bookworm. I recall we were also pretty cavalier about getting messy - dirty water, actual dirt, clay, even animal poop. I wonder whether exposure to all that stuff has any benefits for the immune system later.
- nether 10y agoWould it be better to take these kids back inside to teach them to code? Honest question. I've seen viewpoints for both more and less screen time vociferously defended on HN, see: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12250500 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12250500.
- madamelic 10y agoI think this is really great but there is a difference between "boy-ish behavior" and bullying. Just hand-waving away bullying as "boys will be boys" is reckless and irresponsible. If a boy wants to shove around someone else, fine. But if your son starts beating up and harassing children, maybe it is time for a talk with him.
- ksenzee 10y agoI'm absolutely a free-range parent. My kids have the same freedom I had in the 80s to play outside with friends and roam the neighborhood and walk to the store. But come on, man. If I had wandered out on the roof at the age of 5, my parents would have read me the Riot Act and boarded up the window. Giving your kids a normal childhood doesn't mean throwing all caution to the winds.
- redleggedfrog 10y agoI am a parent of 2 teenage boys (16 and 18) and this is similar to the philosophy under which they were raised. Contrary to what people are saying in the posts, it is not difficult to raise your children this way, nor more dangerous. The worst injuries either boy has sustained have all been at organized activities. The benefits, and I can't overemphasize this, outweigh whatever the hazards. The problem isn't the kids of course, but parents, who are extremely overprotective of their children. I blame our media, which focuses on the violence and dangers in our society to make money while ignoring we're living in literally the safest time in history. They've scared the parents into thinking the world is too dangerous for their children. It's the kids who suffer. They don't get the learn autonomy, or how to use their imagination, or how to set their own boundaries. And most of all, how to productively manage boredom. I see how they're doing that these days - they've got their noses in phones.
- _mhr_ 10y agoFor me at least, I know that if I didn't have my nose in my phone, I would have my nose in a book instead. Either way, I manage boredom through reading.
- scaryspooky 10y agoAs an anecdote, in 2006 I was in grad school and helped a friend with her summer camp for nerdy teens. I still remember the brother and sister (16ish years old) who were deathly afraid to be outside at dusk during the summer because of the West Nile Virus, which at that point was a concern but nothing DEET couldn't prevent. They'd read about it in the newpaper, I think. I don't think it's the parents who are solely at fault for the safety paranoia.
- mordocai 10y agoWhile it definitely looks like Mike doesn't discriminate against girls(since several were present in the story and pictures) I find the focus on boys less than ideal. "Tomboys" exist, and even girls who tend more to the "traditional" female gender roles like to play outside and be rambunctious. To me, he should be focusing on all kids not a particular gender. Edit: I also think encouraging kids to segregate less by gender might help with our other discrimination/segregation issues as well but that's pure conjecture.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- w4 10y ago> I find the focus on boys less than ideal...To me, he should be focusing on all kids not a particular gender. He has sons, not daughters, so he's focussing on what's best for his sons. I wouldn't be surprised if his approach might change if he ever has a daughter, but he doesn't have any obligation to worry about what's best for other people's kids.
- mordocai 10y agoRight, and in my opinion part of what would be best for his sons is for them to be playing with girls as well as boys. Therefore, in my opinion Mike shouldn't be marketing this specifically for boys.
- w4 10y ago> in my opinion part of what would be best for his sons is for them to be playing with girls as well as boys Except they are - right in your comment you say: > it definitely looks like Mike doesn't discriminate against girls(since several were present in the story and pictures)
- georgeecollins 10y agoMy nine year old is very anxious to be far from an adult (more than 20 feet) in public places, even very safe ones like residential streets, parks and grocery stores. Why? Because other "helpful" adults come up to him and ask him if he is OK. Does he know where his parents are? Once a small group of adults gathered around him when my wife was getting the car from down the street. Concerned adults see other concerned adults and they gather like a flock, producing great anxiety in my child. Now he is very nervous to be far from a parent in any public place.
- dougmccune 10y agoThis rings incredibly true for me. I'm certainly the type of parent that lets my kids wander farther than normal (by today's ridiculous standard of normal anyway, which means within 5 feet) and I see constant looks of concern from all sorts of adults. My 4 year old is perfectly capable of being a half block ahead of me as we walk down the street and doesn't need an adult stopping him to check in. My last walk through the airport with two kids, both always well within eyesight, resulted in multiple concerned adults stopping in their tracks, ready to leap into action. If a kid is clearly lost, crying, or distressed then please, by all means try to help. But if a kid is confidently walking without a parent within 5 feet don't jump to the conclusion that something's wrong.
- georgeecollins 10y agoMy nine year old is very anxious to be far from an adult (more than 20 feet) in public places, even very safe ones like residential streets, parks and grocery stores. Why? Because other "helpful" adults come up to him and ask him if he is OK. Does he know where his parents are? Once a small group of adults gathered around him when my wife was getting the car from down the street. Concerned adults see other concerned adults and they gather like a flock, producing great anxiety in my child. Now he is very nervous to be far from a parent in any public place.
- gedy 10y agoThey call this "helicopter parenting" - but it's not at all, it's that both parents usually work, people have less kids, and the fear of lawsuits.
- overcast 10y agoI can't imagine growing up, and not spending my summers building forts, trekking through the woods, jumping off ramps with bikes, and beating up my body on a skateboard. Sounds like a horrible childhood these kids have to deal with.
- baldfat 10y agoFORMER Residence Director at a college: US Law helps with this. I would get dozens of phone calls about how little Johnny or Little Jenny are doing. They wanted the numbers I would then tell them it violated US Law for me to tell them, unless in some circumstances. They never asked what those circumstances were, which were they your dependent :) The sad thing is the helicoptered kids don't know how to make decisions for themselves and so they go to town because they never got to learn self-discipline or consequences to making the lazy choice. Teach your kids self-discipline and learn the consequences and rewards for their decisions. To many parents try to take away the consequences or shorten them.
- aiiane 10y agoI'm sure there are some interesting points in the article but I can't get past the sexist overtones in this piece.
- nkrisc 10y agoI am convinced there are benefits to letting your children roam and learn about the world on their own (within reasonable limits, of course). I grew up in Chicago in the 90s and once I was old enough to understand the seriousness of being careful around traffic and crossing the street safely I was allowed to walk to the home of friends who lived a few blocks away on my own. I learned how to navigate the city: oh my usual route is blocked by construction, I have to find a different way. By the time I was 12 I was taking the El home from school, a consequence of my decision to participate in after-school Jazz band. But that's the thing, it was my choice. If I wanted to be in the band, then I'd have to take the train as my parents couldn't pick me up at that time. By the time I got to college, it was painfully clear which of my fellow students in the dorms had never had to do anything for themselves before. They were very nearly incapable of caring for themselves, be it their living spaces or navigating life in a new city.
- monkmartinez 10y agoWould you let your child roam about Chicago these days?
- teen 10y agoI think most of the major cities were actually worse when we were children
- monkmartinez 10y agoSeriously? I don't have the words... especially for Chicago. http://heyjackass.com/ http://heyjackass.com/ <- This is a serious website BTW
- tirant 10y agoWell, there's been clearly a decline: http://heyjackass.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/yearly_homicide_trend.png http://heyjackass.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/yearly_homi...
- 10y ago
- WillPostForFood 10y agoAre people reading the whole article (which is great) - but i was horrified by the last sentence, which as a parent I found crushing. * I saw the animation in the boys’ slender bodies: the power of making the grown-up world momentarily bend around them. I held Kieran’s hand tightly and decided never to play there again.
- davidw 10y agoSpeaking of kids and playing, here's something I'd love to see: my kids are stuck on this 'Animal Jam' computer game, and while I try and be a good parent and set limits and stuff, I've also thought a technical solution might be fun: "The Great Firewall of Games". It would act like the Chinese thing: rather than simply deny access, it progressively degrades the experience so that the user puts the blame on the game itself, rather than whoever is denying the access.
- Crespyl 10y agoThat seems technically over-complicated and personally dishonest... Why not simply set a hard time limit, and optionally enforce it with existing parental control software? Surely you don't need to deface a product to manipulate children when you could simply say "no, you've had enough, go (play outside/read a book/help your sister set the table)" and deny access to the game? I'd feel terrible if someone grew up thinking the games (or movies, or books) I'd made were low quality/broken just because someone was intentionally degrading the experience for them.
- davidw 10y agoEh, the hard limits get tiresome after a while. Sometimes parents need some other things in their arsenal, as long as they don't become a crutch. Little secret for the non parents: parenting is not always about complete and total honesty. Sorry to burst your bubble.
- jdbernard 10y agoSorry. I have to disagree. Vehemently. I'm a parent of three. I don't always tell my children everything, because they are not always capable of handling everything, but I am always honest with them. We're not perfect, but we try very hard never to manipulate our children. Hard limits get tiresome, sure. Explaining yourself in terms they can understand gets very tiresome. Little secret: parenting gets tiring. There is no silver bullet. Sorry to burst your bubble.
- 10y ago
- callmeed 10y agoOnly tangentially related, but I think this is part of the draw/success of Stranger Things on Netflix. Gen-Xers like me (who are now parents) get nostalgic about the days we could freely roam town on our bikes. Well after dark. Without a helmet. And explore without supervision. (Yes, I know helmets save lives). I'm very much an anti-helicopter parent similar to the article. I wonder if deep down most parents know its better–but for whatever reason (peer pressure, media, etc.) they hover.
- duderific 10y agoMy wife is a hover-er. I am always battling with her to try and give our 2-year-old son a little more space. Unfortunately, he fell down a few stairs when he was 18 months or so (scraped up a bit but otherwise ok) and now she won't let him walk down stairs without holding his hand. Sigh.
- callmeed 10y agolol my wife is the same. We should start a club.
- ideonexus 10y agoThere's a big problem here: Parents are judged poorly no matter how they oversee their children. You watch over your children and make sure they're safe and supported? You're a helicopter parent. Took your eyes off your child for five seconds and he jumped into a cage with a gorrilla at the zoo? You're a horrible neglectful mother. Spoke to the principal of your kid's school concerning a bully or about putting some padding over the concrete at the playground? You're creating a "safe space" for your child and raising them to be a sissy. Being a parent is a no-win scenario in the eyes of public perception. People always talk about "back in my day" when things were tougher and how that made them resilient. Well, back in those days, kids got impaled on steering wheels sitting in their parents laps while they drove, got skull fractures from falling on playground concrete or teeth knocked out from see-saws, or they committed suicide because school administrators saw bullying as a natural means of letting kids establish a pecking-order. Following science-informed safety measures is too often dismissed as coddling our children. I'm all for letting kids roam and giving them responsibilities. But there's a rational, measured way to provide for such freedom and responsibility. Because if anything bad happens to your child while giving them such freedom, you will face the wrath of social media. I watch time and again as the same people complaining about sissification of our children are also the first to rage against the parents when the news reports on a child coming into any kind of harm. If people would empathize with parents instead of leaping to judgement of them, the world would be a better place.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- irrational 10y agoHmm, reading your post makes me wonder if the problem is people not having enough children. What I mean is, back in "the day" people were too busy trying to keep up with their own kids to worry about what other people were doing with their kids. But now that people have few or no kids they have plenty of time to tell other people how they are doing it wrong. I sometimes wonder if so much of the partisanship, outrage over seemingly little things, rude comments on discussion boards etc. is just people having too much time on their hands. Were people happier back when they had to struggle each day to survive? Anyway, I need to get back to commenting on what the Kardashians are doing today.
- smallnamespace 10y agoPerhaps helicopter (extreme risk-averse) parenting is a rational reaction to the recent trend of having many fewer children much later in life. For most of human evolutionary history, women had their first child in their teens. That means even if your child died, you would have many more chances to reproduce. The average age of first child is now closer to 25. If a 10-year-old kid dies from an accident, the mother may have a lot of difficulty conceiving and bringing another child to term. This might also explain why the author thinks moms are more likely to helicopter parent -- men's reproductive ability declines with age much more slowly than women.
- duderific 10y ago> The average age of first child is now closer to 25. Probably closer to 35 among the women talked about in the article (wealthy Silicon Valley types), so the effect is even more amplified.
- ThomPete 10y agoRaising a kid is a project not a concept. The second you understand that your whole approach to parenting changes drastically and you can finally start thinking about it rationally allowing your kids to build their own life with the support of their parents.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- clarkevans 10y agoI think the freedom to play and experiment is a good thing. Talking to your children about "risks" so -they- learn risk analysis is a very good thing. However, from the article, Mike Lanza sounds a bit of a male chauvinist. I don't like the tone of males vs females and his anecdotes. At young ages, especially before puberty, there isn't that much of a gap between girl and boy athletic capabilities. There is a huge gap in parental and society expectations and norms.
- zzzeek 10y agoBy all means, lets normalize bullying again as healthy male behavior. And normalize all their miserable victims as the losers they obviously are. Where have I heard this recently ?
- Steuard 10y agoI went into this article expecting to cheer it on: I'm grateful for everyone who's pushing back against our modern insistence on overprotective parenting, all too often backed by the brute force of law. But barely a page into it (by the end of paragraph 6, and heavily reinforced in paragraph 7), I'm already barreled over by what looks like some seriously intense sexism. Maybe the article misrepresents him, but Mike Lanza appears to place the blame for overprotective parenting primarily on moms ("mom philosophy", he calls it, though the article's author tries to shelter him by generalizing the term) dominating "passive dads". He describes the fun and freedom that he advocates as "masculine experiences". While the article does mention and show some girls, most of the quotes from Lanza are about boys and what they need. (The article even politely specifies that "his focus is on boys", without comment.) I'm not okay with any of that. I could express that as anger on behalf of my wife (who doesn't buy into overprotective parenting any more than I do) or on behalf of my daughter (who was begging me just this week to lift her into a tree again and again). But honestly I'd be just as annoyed if they weren't in my life. It ought to be obvious in this day and age that "I blame moms!" is an embarrassing (and harmful) way to ground an argument. Calling for revival of the term "sissy" and normalizing bullying as "normal, boyish aggression" in paragraph 9 was just one step too much for me. Sorry: I'm out. There are plenty of people advocating similar "free range kids" philosophies who aren't also assholes.
- clarkevans 10y agoI also had a visceral response to this article. As Mike Lanza is explaining his childhood experience to the journalist (Melanie Thernstrom), she quotes him: Since they didn’t want to “stoop all the way to girls,” he says, giving me a smile.
- grotsnot 10y agoTo be fair, the guy is in his 50s. 40someodd years ago was a different world and he's just describing the attitudes of the time. Boys played with boys and girls played with girls. I interpreted as Lanza merely walking us through the thought process boys from the 70s had, not as saying it's an attitude boys today should have. It's easy to picture that smile as indicating self-awareness of the outdatedness of the attitude.
- mighty_atomic_c 10y agoVery interesting article. I'm an example by-product of the opposite extreme. My parents kept me from my neighbors, other kids in school and other people in church (I can count on one hand the number of guests that came over to hang out with me throughout my childhood). I also had no access to TV, the internet, the library, etc. I was isolated to such an extreme that the only thing I think I really developed was an active imagination. I guess my parents were a little more extreme than typical "helicopter" parents, but also unable to afford any structured activities for me, so I was closely watched and kept indoors all the time. By my teenage years, the home-schooling program my parents were putting me through was so isolating and so obviously worthless on its own that I started to spiral into depression and contemplated suicide. By that point, I was convinced that I was wasting away mentally and physically such that when I would attempt to enter the adult world, that I would fall on my face and simply never be able to "catch up" with my peers who had two decades of normal development. Things did get orders of magnitude better when I was in college the next year and working multiple jobs. I managed to move out somewhere after I turned 18 with nice roommates and cheap rent. I think I managed to close most of the mental/social/physical gap that I had perceived in my teenage years, but I would be lying if I said that I was a completely normal 25-year old. I have the strangest deficiencies that crop up now and again in my life, and I have a strong suspicion that kids who come from "helicopter" households will share these problems (such as difficulty reading people's emotions, difficulty in executive function, strange worries, low self-esteem). So when I consider the possibility of having kids, I really like the idea of letting them socialize with other people, explore, and solve problems on their own without my constant interference. That's much better than my experience of growing up, with only fantasies of being outside and doing stuff. But if that's culturally unacceptable, then there will be a generation or two of people like me, who struggle daily with the little things I never had a chance to deal with growing up.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- balabaster 10y agoLove this guy. Am this guy. Want to be this guy's friend. Want my kids to be friends with this guy's kids. I wish there were more people like this because just like him, I am an outlier where I live. My kids don't want supervision, and I don't want to constantly supervise them. I will offer them endless amounts of advice if they want/need it, feed them, clothe them, keep a roof over their heads, love them, but I want my kids to be kids and spend time discovering themselves. I fully approve of his parenting style and tactics. I am with him. Kudos, truly!
- duderific 10y agoAll except playing on the roof. That's just silly.
- balabaster 10y agoI never fell off the roof... or the 80 ft trees we used to climb. That's not to say that the likelihood of that being zero, however, of the approximately 50 people in my circle of friends that did those things, I only have recollection of 1 falling out of a tree and breaking an arm. I once trod on a nail and had it go through my foot... compared to the countless numbers of sprained wrists, ankles, broken ankles, legs and arms occurring in organized sports. I realize the fallacy of statistics, but anecdotally, 1 broken arm from falling out of a tree in a pool of approximately 50 test subjects vs. more than a dozen in a test pool of similar size for organized sports. I realize that not allowing your kids to do anything is much safer, but at a much greater cost to their happiness.
- morgante 10y agoOne thing which really frustrates and surprises me is that techology should be helping to free children, not constraining them. Parents universally have cell phones and many kids do as well these days. These should be a huge enabler for freedom—if something happens while you're roaming or home alone, you can easily call a parent. It seems unequivocally safer to leave children alone today than it was 20-30 years ago. This isn't even including the fact that crime rates are substantially lower today. It's really hard to find any empirical justification for the tide of over-protective parenting.
- losteverything 10y agoWhen I was told that Skittles were not sold in the high school vending machines any longer and that a bottle of vanilla in your children's bedroom was another sign I knew Parenting was just like my career -if I didn't keep up on the latest I would fall behind. Parenting is like version control and awareness.
- wott 10y agoI don't know what treatment the photographer applied to his pictures. They look fake to me: the lighting is weird, the colours are weird. (I don't mean that they are are fake, not at all, I just mean that they look so).
- duderific 10y agoAgree, it looks like they used some sharpening filter that makes everything look eerily hyper-real.
- peterwwillis 10y agoOther societies without helicopter parenting (read: most of them) don't have a wealth of maimed and dead kids. Instead, parents are involved with their child's development and they teach them to keep themselves safe - though their societies are not unoften more safe than the USA, anyway. We could do things like reduce the incidence of gun and car related injuries and fatailities and provide more opportunities to encourage parents playing with their children outdoors. Or we could create more protective laws and further cushion the playgrounds we essentially "walk" our kids in, and more organized sports leagues for children where the parents act like an unruly mob. This whole article is so insanely closed in view and experience that it's not worth reading unless you're an upper middle class white American in the suburbs. Talk about first world problems.
- int_19h 10y agoAlan Dean Foster had a great book "Sentenced to Prism", one of the premises of which is a society that evolved from such a helicopter mindset, to the point where all adults wouldn't leave home without a protective body enclosing suit, containing various amenities, and guaranteeing safety from most accidents, even highly unlikely ones. One of the main takeaways of that story was that this mindset breeds complacency. If nothing bad ever happened to you that you didn't have to deal with the hard way, you start to believe that you're invulnerable; and thus, more likely to wade into dangerous situations without fully realizing just how dangerous they are.
- gjolund 10y agoWhy is this on HN?
- araneae 10y agoLibertarian Silicon Valley entrepreneur man tells you how best to raise your child, of course it's on HN.
- euske 10y agoThis sounds a good idea. But one of the highest reader-rated comments of the article is intriguing to me: Anna - Pittsburgh 11 hours ago ... But, this whole article just oozed misogyny. The casual dismissal of mothers and the harsh declaration that the female sex and their worrying is ruining today's young men is, in a word, offensive. Worrying about boys growing up to be sissies--- who even says that anymore outside the men's rights movement? It sounds to me that this guy wants to create a world for his boys where girls are not allowed or, at best, are merely tolerated. Which sort of reminds me of Silicon Valley, actually.
- aaron695 10y agoI think they are more a troll than anything else. He never called anyone a sissy. > was putting my son at risk of turning into what used to be called a sissy He was specifically making a commentary how the word is no longer used. Taking the article as an entirety, it was written by a woman and ends with > I held Kieran’s hand tightly and decided never to play there again. But I think the writer as a female knew the story she was telling. It added to the tale told.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- goldfishcaura 10y agoCould not agree more. That's why my wife's preschool is play-based: http://www.petitefrance.xyz http://www.petitefrance.xyz Sure, there is academic stuff and learning. And as a licensed preschool, we have full-time supervision. But the helicopter parent as a concept is absent in French upbringing. Instead, my wife focuses on building kids inner-confidence through play and social interactions.
- goldfishcaura 10y agomy wife's response: http://ahedgehoginthefog.weebly.com/hedgehogs-adventures/-feature-the-anti-helicopter-parents-plea-let-kids-play http://ahedgehoginthefog.weebly.com/hedgehogs-adventures/-fe...