20 ms·
Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing?
- twblalock 10y agoLast week's NYT article on free trade was pretty good: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/29/business/economy/more-wealth-more-jobs-but-not-for-everyone-what-fuels-the-backlash-on-trade.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/29/business/economy/more-weal... This is the bottom line on American manufacturing: > From 2000 to 2010, the United States lost some 5.6 million manufacturing jobs, by the government’s calculation. Only 13 percent of those job losses can be explained by trade, according to an analysis by the Center for Business and Economic Research at Ball State University in Indiana. The rest were casualties of automation or the result of tweaks to factory operations that enabled more production with less labor. > American factories produced more goods last year than ever, by many indications. Yet they did so while employing about 12.3 million workers — roughly the same number as in 2009, when production was roughly three-fourths what it is today. Most of the jobs that left are never coming back. They didn't go to Mexico or China; they simply disappeared because automation and productivity increases rendered them unnecessary. If the US sheltered its manufacturing sector from foreign competition, a small number of jobs might come back, but the increased cost of manufacturing things in the US would strongly incentivize companies to automate those jobs away as quickly as possible. Manufacturing has a powerful political resonance, both in terms of the imagery of hardworking middle-class factory workers and national pride, e.g. "Why don't we make things in this country anymore?" However, I suspect that most politicians who talk about a manufacturing revival understand that it won't really happen.
- Houshalter 10y agoBut there aren't a finite number of factories. If more factory work gets automated, then it will reduce the cost of building more factories and producing even more goods. Whereas service jobs seem more finite. There is only a finite demand for burgers or shelf stockers, unless you increase the population. I really don't understand how a mostly service based economy is sustainable. In any case, the service based jobs are just as vulnerable to automation. There are already a number of prototype burger making robots, for instance.
- moron4hire 10y agothere aren't a finite number of factories Please reconsider the absolutely absurdity of this statement.
- philipkglass 10y agoThere's a finite demand for manufactured goods too. If anything, the price elasticity for manufactured goods seems likely to be lesser than that for restaurant meals; I'd eat out more often if it cost less, but I'm not going to buy additional dishwashers or dining tables for my house no matter how cheap they get. I'm not going to buy light bulbs or printers faster than they need replacement due to failure. With laser printers and LED bulbs, that can be several years between purchases.
- akiselev 10y agoYou're correct that manufacturing too has a finite demand but it still has an order of magnitude more potential than the service industry. The vast majority of service jobs are extremely local or tied to a language/region/jurisdiction so those jobs have very little to export. Meanwhile, the vast majority of the world is not yet affluent enough to afford most luxury manufactured goods so as the population gets wealthier, the market for manufactured goods expands. As long as the developing world follows western consumerism, and by all vounts it looks like it is, there is a lot of room to grow. Developed countries who have centuries of industrialization behind them and a knowledge economy stand a much greater chance of capturing that newly generated wealth because of scale and experience. As long as higher labor and regulatory costs can be offset by automation, the manufacturing can be grown with the world while services can only really grow with the national population.
- philipkglass 10y agoI see a lot of growth potential for manufactured goods if you measure them in mass. I'm not sure there's great growth potential if you measure them in money. Every wave of industrial relocation so far has overtopped the previous one by lowering costs. China's steelmakers are exporting more tonnes of steel than US steelmakers did 50 years ago, but they're also commanding significantly less money per tonne. For that matter, if poor countries are going to get wealthier but buy manufactured goods from abroad, where is their new wealth coming from if not manufacturing or services?
- pavedwalden 10y ago>However, I suspect that most politicians who talk about a manufacturing revival understand that it won't really happen. The thought that maybe some of them don't understand that is what scares me the most.
- mywittyname 10y agoThe worst aspect of politicians is you can never differentiate between what they pay lip service to and what they truly believe.
- hrxn 10y agoSo, just like everyone else, basically...
- crdoconnor 10y agoThat study is bullshit. It's probably more the opposite - ~15% job losses caused by automation and 85% caused by trade policy. You only have to look at their opinions on "right to work" laws to see whose side they're batting for (not employees). Automation is simply being used as a scapegoat and a political justification for keeping trade policies that export jobs in place. >Manufacturing has a powerful political resonance, Manufacturing ecosystems take decades to fully destroy and decades to fully rebuild. The flow of goods on container ships can be halted overnight - which has happened before and will happen again. There's a country that begins with Z and a country that begins with V that enacted policies that deliberately sabotaged their local industrial and agricultural base and assumed they could always just import what they needed. Spoiler alert: it didn't end well for either of them.
- mywittyname 10y ago> That study is bullshit. It's probably more the opposite You need to back up statements like this. Contradicting actual evidence with figures pulled from your ass isn't going to fly here.
- nickpinkston 10y agoI figured they were just suckers for factory tours, or at least photos ops with the "working man". Also, a lot of the Left longs for the days of big factories and big union collective bargaining that could raise the wages a lot of people quickly. It's a great thing to point to with good economies of scale. Globalization has made this a mostly untenable strategy, but the longing remains.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agohttp://georgeosborneinahighvisjacket.tumblr.com/ http://georgeosborneinahighvisjacket.tumblr.com/
- hueving 10y agoManufacturing is a target because it's easy for people to see concrete results. They can point at something and say, "we made that", and it tends to generate some sense of pride. The same doesn't really apply for service industries or innovation in the service industries: "we produced consumer surplus by lowering transportation costs via automation" doesn't roll off the tongue as well. :) The same problem exists for creating software. Massive software projects tend to be unimpressive to people not familiar with the IT industry because they don't comprehend the scale or fundamental difficulties in computer science that were overcome to accomplish something. Compare airplanes and wifi on airplanes. Most people are impressed by an A380, but they couldn't give two shits about the incredible technology behind offering wifi 5 miles above the Atlantic ocean at 700MPH ground speed. They just trivialize it by saying, "yeah, it comes from that little radio".
- rfrank 10y agoManufacturing also provides jobs for both high and low skill workers. As such can be seen as more valuable to a community than say, a software company that only hires engineers and a CS center in a different state. Manufacturing was one of the best roads for a low skill worker to earn good money and move up the rung economically - something that only seems to be getting harder as time goes on.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoIt may seem to be getting harder, but in reality it's not. Rank based measures of mobility are stable. Since income inequality is up, absolute mobility has also increased. https://eml.berkeley.edu/~saez/chettyetalAERPP2014.pdf https://eml.berkeley.edu/~saez/chettyetalAERPP2014.pdf
- rfrank 10y ago"When compared to 24 middle-income and high income countries, the U.S. ranks 16th in the amount of inter-generational earnings mobility. The relatively low level of mobility in the U.S. may arise in part because low-income children in the U.S. tend to have less stable and lower-income families, less secure families, and parents who have less time to devote to their children." http://inequality.stanford.edu/sites/default/files/Pathways-SOTU-2016-Economic-Mobility-3.pdf http://inequality.stanford.edu/sites/default/files/Pathways-...
- blinkingled 10y agoMaybe because they're catering to a vote bank that was most affected by manufacturing / factory jobs that went overseas? And there's little else those voters could relate to other than someone bringing back the jobs that they know well. There's also the righting the wrong thing that's appealing to many. As TFA points out there is little chance of revival of American manufacturing. TFA makes a very good point that most of those who lost their factory jobs have moved to service industry and that's what the candidates should focus on making better.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- serge2k 10y ago> Manufacturing was, logistically speaking, easier to organize. There were lots of workers at each factory, and most knew one another. Service work is more dispersed and done in smaller crews. Workers living in the same city and employed by the same retail chain, for example, would likely know only a handful of their compatriots. Fostering a sense of trust and shared purpose under these conditions is difficult. Plus you can't just fire everyone and shut down the factory when they start talking union.
- superuser2 10y agoThis is a great article. The rage of the blue-collar masses is misplaced. It belongs with engineers, STEM people, operations research, Taylorist management. Globalism isn't the architect of their fate. We are. Want enough work to go around? Ban the last 100 years of agricultural development. That'll create all the jobs you could possibly want, real fast. Except then you'all find out that more work to go around is a wrong thing to want.
- prewett 10y agoThe rage may be misplaced, but the rage is still valid. There is basically skilled jobs and minimum wage jobs. You are saying "they're misinformed" but they are not actually incorrect. So what do you suggest we do instead of focusing on manufacturing jobs? (I would love to suggest something, unfortunately, I have zero ideas, and not sure where to get any ideas, frankly.)
- vacri 10y agoThis is my favourite counter to millenials complaining about how booomers had jobs handed to them on a platter. "What, you want an unfulfilling factory job doing the same mundane thing day in, day out, probably on your feet, and probably without climate control? And if you're a woman, explicitly get paid less for it?" The boomers may have had a higher employment rate, but they weren't design consultants and business analysts and so forth.
- douche 10y agoI've done both blue-collar, shitty industrial jobs and white-collar cushy programming jobs. If they both paid the same, I'd be very tempted to take the blue-collar job. There's something very fulfilling about working with your hands and producing something tangible. As bad as turning wrenches or pumping a grease gun can be, days of endless meetings with obtuse stakeholders or perpetual yak-shaving aren't any better.
- douche 10y agoOh, and overtime. Sweet, sweet overtime...
- helloworld 10y agoI wasn't aware of these facts: --[T]here can be no revival of American manufacturing, because there has been no collapse. Because of automation, there are far fewer jobs in factories. But the value of stuff made in America reached a record high in the first quarter of 2016, even after adjusting for inflation. --[T]here were 64,000 steelworkers in America last year, and 820,000 home health aides.... Soon, we will be living in the United States of Home Health Aides, yet the candidates keep talking about steelworkers. Given the opportunity, I think I'd vote for McKinsey, Bain, or BCG to manage the executive branch instead of our current Presidential candidates.
- drewrv 10y agoThat was basically Mitt Romney's whole pitch.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- serge2k 10y ago> I think I'd vote for McKinsey, Bain, or BCG to manage the executive branch instead of our current Presidential candidates Why not just give them whatever money they ask for and be done with it?
- Uhhrrr 10y agoThis is true for most companies that hire those consulting companies as well.
- Animats 10y agoHere's the US table of employment by category.[1] (I keep mentioning this table in discussions of employment.) 14% of the workforce makes all the stuff. That's manufacturing, mining, construction, and agriculture. 14%. US manufacturing employment peaked in 1979. Manufacturing output is at peak now. That 14% number was about 50% in 1950, and maybe 90% in 1900. That's how much things have changed. As for imports, China's government has decided that it is going to reduce its imports from the rest of the world. This is part of the "China 2025" program announced by Li Keqiang in 2015.[2] The US may have to reduce its imports from China to keep up. At most, though, this will add a few percent to manufacturing employment. [1] http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_table_201.htm http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_table_201.htm [2] http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/922394.shtml http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/922394.shtml
- chubs 10y agoBig factories can be retrofitted in times of world war to build tanks/guns/etc. It's seen as a national security thing.
- philipkglass 10y agoThis seems out of date. World War II is not going to be repeated. WW II could drag on as long as it did -- giving civilian-to-war conversions enough time to matter -- because there were no nuclear or precision guided weapons. If a no-holds-barred Total War breaks out between major world powers again, it's really hard to see how it would last long enough for factory conversions to be meaningful. And if it's just another big war of choice we're imagining in the future, like Americans fighting in Iraq or Vietnam, those haven't been bottlenecked by industrial capacity either.
- burfog 10y agoTwo more national security reasons: 1. There is the problem of depending on potential enemies (all others have potential to be enemies) for goods that are critical to the military and/or general economy. Suppliers can threaten to cut supplies. Note that this can happen even if actual shooting war is unlikely; the threat to cut supplies is a brutal negotiating tactic that can block us diplomatically. For example, if we depended on Russia, they could demand that we support the Syrian government. 2. Lots of physical things contain computer chips. He who builds them is in control. Remember when France gave the UK some secret codes to make Argentina's missiles (purchased from France) fail. It's not just military equipment. Consider your Ethernet card and/or motherboard chipset. It could include a hardware debugger with full memory access, controlled by magic packets. What happens when we can only get those from government-owned Chinese companies? What about modern computerized farm equipment that phones home for licensing? If that were foreign, could a foreign power disable our farm equipment at a key time, causing us to face food shortages?
- rjsw 10y agoI don't think the example in your second point is true. France did help the UK a lot but the Exocet missiles worked fine, one was even launched from the back of a truck.
- nickbauman 10y agoManufacturing has a history of high growth and employment. Services do not. Economically, service domination means an overall slow-growth economy. Even highly intellectual services do not come close to the historic growth / employment curve the nation enjoyed when it was dominated by manufacturing. Wealth distribution is also heavily-weighted toward to the top with services. Generally democracies fare better when wealth is more broadly-held.
- nickbauman 10y agoNot sure why this is being down-voted: it's pretty well established that service economies have limited potential to export or achieve economies of scale, and thus unable to benefit from expanding global trade.
- guyzero 10y agoThe plus side of service economies is that they're a lot harder to outsource - you can't open a Manilla call-center to handle a nursing home.
- brianwawok 10y agoYou can bring in h1b nurses for half pay.
- JBReefer 10y agoThat's not how that system works
- brianwawok 10y agoHave you been to a nursing home lately? I see a lot of nurses that are fresh in the country. Not sure if h1b or work visa or what. There is definitely some shady things going on around foreign nurses in nursing homes.
- 10y ago
- sriram_sun 10y agoThe votes that can turn the tide in this election are those in the rust belt. Manufacturing is the key word that gets their attention. I believe that's why. All other reasons are secondary. It was about the financial crisis in 2008 and Bain Capital in 2012 which ended up affecting manufacturing jobs.
- trhway 10y agoyep, politicians say what their voters like to hear (and do what their donors want to be done :). For example California politicians don't talk about manufacturing, instead they talk education, environment/climate change, security, minorities rights, some talk agriculture, etc... some even talk UFO/aliens (if you didn't read the official CA booklet listing candidates and their statements for this year race for the US Senate Barbara Boxer's seat you missed a lot of fun :)
- rayiner 10y agoThere is a lot more dignity of work in manufacturing. You're not servicing some old person who can afford to have a home health aid--you're making a product for people to buy (including other people like you).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- saturdaysaint 10y agoAs someone that works in manufacturing (on the ERP systems side), I assure you that the dignity non-unionized assembly line workers feel is about what you'd get from any highly repetitive $10 - $20 an hour job with scant pay raises. Having been around the assembly line, I'd definitely recommend someone try life as a barista or bartender or Costco employee before stepping foot in a factory.
- fspeech 10y agoIt is weird how people who never worked on an assembly line go on and on about the desirability of manufacturing jobs.
- pavlov 10y agoI can't understand. Helping a fellow human being who is too weak to care for herself is almost the definition of dignity to me. It may be dirty work, but there's nothing more important. In contrast, the manufacturing job turns you into a pre-programmed cog in a big machine that consumes substantial amounts of natural resources to produce something that will most likely end up in the junk heap in a couple of years. Where's the dignity in that?
- rayiner 10y agoDignity of work doesn't have anything to do with importance. It's about power relationships: vendors are in a different relationship with their customers than service workers are with the people they serve. In Manhattan, a nanny probably makes more than a journalist--but is there any comparison in which job is more dignified?
- mc32 10y agoBecause this is the work people who didn't go to college or uni can do and make a "middle class income" with a little vocational training (no real maths needed). Same as why the mittelstand is so important.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoBecause millions of people have been affected. This means votes. If you can promise some bullshit and they buy it, you got votes. Lots of them. Contrary to popular belief, politicians only care about their own enrichment and careers. They couldn't give one iota about the needs of the people. They want votes. They'll say anything they have to say to get them. They'll do anything they have to do to get them. And one in office they'll do nothing for the people who voted for them. This is true world wide and it isn't any different in the US.
- steven777400 10y agoThe memory is that these old factory/manufacturing jobs were high paying (middle class), secure, and accessible to people of low intellect, minimal education, and limited social grace. The proposed replacements "caregivers, retail workers and customer-service representatives" are significantly lower wage and also require more "EQ" that the working man of the prior generation didn't need. The voters these politicians are addressing are working from a memory of a time when "men were men", that worked hard in a physical way to produce a physical product; in the memory, these working men didn't think and didn't emote, they produced. Now, the voter says, men have been "feminized" by being forced out of a productive, provider role where a single income could support the family. Instead, they are placed into a role where they need to express concern, care, and use soft skills instead of physical strength. And when they want the same pay and security they had before, they are instead told to "learn to code" (or learn whatever, get an education). Which is easy for a coastal educated person to say, but to a line of family men who have not just eschewed education but actively resisted it, this is a tough pill to swallow.
- golergka 10y ago> actively resisted it Honest question. Is this a reality or a degrading stereotype?
- rfrank 10y agoDefinitely a stereotype.
- titanomachy 10y agoAccording to this poll [1], only 6% of Americans see college education as "not too important", and the rest see it as at least "fairly important". If there are people actively resisting education, they are a rather tiny minority. 1: http://www.gallup.com/poll/166490/americans-college-education-important.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/166490/americans-college-educatio...
- thesmallestcat 10y agoThe entire comment is an absurd stereotype, and about what you'd expect to find in this forum. Manufacturing jobs weren't (and aren't) filled with a bunch of meatheads coloring by numbers any more than are construction jobs.
- macspoofing 10y agoWhy are politicians so obsessed with farming and agriculture? The reasons for both are not dissimilar.
- andrewfong 10y agoIs there some dystopian novel where the majority of workers spend their time taking CAPTCHAs? I almost expect it to happen, as a way to keep the masses occupied in a way that's difficult to automate.
- hasenj 10y agoThat will either be automated, or those workers job would actually be doing that to train the AI that will solve the captcha.
- jfoutz 10y agoPoliticians are amateurs. I don't mean that in a pejorative way. Politicians are experts at politics, they can achieve consensus in seemingly impossible circumstances. If you pick a random politician, and ask them to design a transmission, or perform open heart surgery, they'd do as poorly as you or me. Yes, there are politicians from all walks of life, and you can probably find a surgeon politician. In general, the thing they're really good at is politics. It sucks because they're called on to provide solutions to deep problems, with only the skills of enthusiastic amateurs. Manufacturing solved a lot of problems. It's completely reasonable for an amateur to look at history for past solutions to current problems. For reference, the us congress has a panel of 700 or so experts in all sorts of fields to help write policy. This is in addition to each congresspersons's staff. There's something on the order of 2000 people available to write legislation. And about 10000 pieces of legislation written. So each potential law gets a few months of effort. It boils down to a congressperson (probably a lawyer), a few enthusiastic political scientists, and a few economists to shape national policy. It's not that they don't produce good work. They're smart hardworking people. A trillion dollar budget is probably as difficult to produce as a decent compiler. That's the kind of thing we'll see congress try to slap together right after the election. It's not much different than a team of undergrads trying to get their compiler to pass test cases. It's not inherently bad, it's that sometimes problems are really hard, and they should probably be handled by experts. We don't have a good way of collectively picking experts, so we pick amateurs and hope for the best.
- white-flame 10y agoContrast a politician with a juror. There's no real reason for a juror to focus on anything but the case at hand. They don't have a career as a juror to pursue, yet they're expected to learn about things relevant to the case. There's almost no personal incentives involved (which also happens to be heavily policed) besides scheduling. Now, a politician generally does things to further their political career. They don't research solutions, they're lobbied for them. They do research what they can say to get themselves [re-]elected. They make deals based on their their status and trajectory within their political party, maybe tempered by "the right thing" depending on how much they hold the concept of a public servant. Sure, there's some out there with passion for a particular problem, but that's not the common case behavior. I say term limits on everything. Eliminate career politicians. Huge bills are currently put together without one hand knowing what the other is doing, and in practice things like budget are fudged anyway to keep the machine mostly moving. If career politicians with no real-world knowledge of the represented issues can do this stuff, then a random scattering of people with greater expected slices of real-world experience and fewer expected strings attached can do the same.
- andreiw 10y agoAutomation? Oh is that how you see Foxconn employees? That would explain quite a bit... Most of light and heavy manufacturing is done somewhere else. Electronics. Housewares. Clothing. Tools. Equipment. Cars. Materials, both raw and those undergoing technological processing. High tech. A service economy? That's nice - but there are only so many prostitutes, bank clerks and Mickey D employees required, so what is everyone else going to do? Navel gaze? Fill jails? Starve? More importantly, what are you going to offer the rest of the world in exchange for all that stuff you can't make anymore? Democracy? Or just bomb them? At some point even bombs will be hard to make, due to lack of necessary facilities, equipment, materials, knowledge and experience. Just see how well "resurrecting" last century's space knowledge has worked out for NASA.
- bsder 10y ago> Automation? Oh is that how you see Foxconn employees? That would explain quite a bit... Even if you "resurrect" manufacturing, automation means less people. Quoting: http://www.bizjournals.com/pittsburgh/blog/innovation/2015/05/why-ati-spent-1-2b-on-its-brackenridge-facility.html http://www.bizjournals.com/pittsburgh/blog/innovation/2015/0... "Perhaps most surprising about the HRPF was the relative lack of employees on the floor of the massive facility. While ATI employs about 2,500 throughout western Pennsylvania and eastern Ohio, the technology and automation of the HRPF only requires seven operators and nine maintenance employees per shift, making the operation safer and more efficient, according to Deluca." That's not a recipe for a manufacturing job resurgence independently of whether you think that is good or bad.
- madengr 10y agoWow, cool facility. That is some automation.
- madengr 10y agoWhy can't I buy a toaster made in the USA, even if it is off a highly automated line? Because it's still cheaper to make in manually in China. Even if it's automated, it will still be cheaper to automate it in China.
- philipkglass 10y agoDoes this help? http://www.b4usa.com/tag/toaster/ http://www.b4usa.com/tag/toaster/ I've bought quite a few things made in the USA (or other countries with decent worker and environmental protections, like Italy, Germany, Japan...) that other people seem to usually get from China. Anecdotally, I've noticed that people who will talk about how Grandma's toaster or washing machine lasted forever and it's a shame you can't buy something like that today are not willing to budget for it like Grandma did. Grandma spent a lot of money on her appliances in 1950, whether you want to adjust by consumer price index or just look at (e.g.) the ratio of minimum wage to sticker price. Are you willing to spend thousands of dollars on a washing machine, to match relative buying power and prices from the middle of the 20th century? If so, you can still find appliances that are built like a tank, built by workers paid decent wages, built in factories that don't just dump all their trash into the nearest river. But if you want to buy a toaster that lasts a long time, is made in the USA, and costs only a little bit more than the Chinese toaster, yeah, I agree that is hard to find. There is good stuff still available at the high end. The low end has gone a lot lower.
- chiaro 10y agoYeah, on the other hand prices really have dropped much more than quality. I'm ten years strong on a toaster I picked up from Target for (and I can remember this, for some reason) $12.
- city41 10y agoDepends on the product. Some products could be automatically created in the US, then sold with "Made in the USA" on them, boosting their appeal.
- pipio21 10y agoInteresting that when I was living in China, I could not buy there things manufactured in China!! I had to go to US or Europe in order to buy them and them move again to China with it because most factories directly export what they manufacture. Automating something in the US or Europe is probably cheaper than in China because of the educated people there is much better prepared than in China. The huge difference is in basic commodities cost. China is so huge and dense(great basic markets) but with great fluvial communications(cheap transport), cheap energy from coal, and growing immensely. Most of the US is sparsely populated by comparison. The industry hubs are not as enormous as in China.
- brightball 10y agoBecause the numbers show that every dollar of manufacturing investment in an area produces $7.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoHow much do other types of investment produce?
- brightball 10y agoApparently I had my numbers wrong. Here's better info: http://www.nam.org/Newsroom/Top-20-Facts-About-Manufacturing/ http://www.nam.org/Newsroom/Top-20-Facts-About-Manufacturing... "For every $1.00 spent in manufacturing, another $1.81 is added to the economy. That is the highest multiplier effect of any economic sector. In addition, for every one worker in manufacturing, there are another four employees hired elsewhere. (Source: NAM calculations using IMPLAN.) - See more at: http://www.nam.org/Newsroom/Top-20-Facts-About-Manufacturing/#sthash.CCQopC41.dpuf" http://www.nam.org/Newsroom/Top-20-Facts-About-Manufacturing...
- williesleg 10y agoBecause without manufacturing you have nothing. Total loss of control for your product. Wal Mart crap everywhere.
- wott 10y agoManufacturing jobs are the only jobs who build base value, from which all the jobs derive. Service and retail will sooner or later collapse when there is nowhere to extract money from.
- SkyMarshal 10y agoAndy Grove spent the last decade or so of his life crusading about this. He framed the problem as, Silicon Valley invests a great deal in creating innovation, but outsources the scaling of it. Even though that may be in the short term best interests of the companies doing the outsourcing, both they and the country lose out on the economic growth, jobs, and crucial institutional knowledge that scaling innovations brings. And the knowledge transfer to other countries better enables them to continue building on the original innovation, developing their own capacity for original innovation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Grove#Preference_for_a_.22job-centric.22_American_economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Grove#Preference_for_a_...
- philipkglass 10y agoGood point. I don't think that every country in the world should be aiming to run an export-manufacturing trade surplus; that's mathematically guaranteed to end in tears. I do worry about institutional capability loss on the scale of companies, industries, and whole countries. Look how hard, over-budget, and over-schedule it has been to resume building nuclear reactors in the USA after the entire country took a decades-long break from new unit construction. There was too much knowledge lost from aging humans' heads before it could be passed on to the next generation on the job, and now it's very expensive to regenerate.
- jackcosgrove 10y agoExport mercantilism seems to result in the middle income trap. Even Japan never caught up. I would prefer not to have that kind of economy. Research and innovation yields the highest margins.
- theoh 10y agoManufacturing fetishism: http://www.johnkay.com/2016/08/29/the-economics-and-politics-of-manufacturing-fetishism/ http://www.johnkay.com/2016/08/29/the-economics-and-politics...
- brchr 10y agoHere, for instance, is a graph of manufacturing jobs per capita in the US: https://www.numer.al/us_bls_data/figures/manufacturing-employees-per-capita https://www.numer.al/us_bls_data/figures/manufacturing-emplo... It’s quite clear that manufacturing jobs have just been slowly and steadily disappearing over the past 70+ years. Viewed at this scale, the debate over the bump in the last 6 years seems totally silly. Moreover it’s hard to imagine a policy that would turn that kind of trend around.
- noobermin 10y agoIt is very easy to zoom out an fit a line but the step like changes at certain points are interesting. Averaging over the variations might throw away a lot of interesting information. But you are right about one thing, the curve has not dipped up appreciably in the last 30 years. All I see are steps, plateau's where the level is kept before the next drop. EDIT: can't do math or I keep thinking it's 2000's still.
- brchr 10y agoAgreed that it'd be interesting to try to figure out what explains those cycles and steps. Recessions in general? Would be interesting to see what correlated with those points in time.
- bzbarsky 10y agoAt least in the last 40 years of that graph, recessions seems to be it. A recession hits, some people get fired (sticky wages, etc, etc), the recovery comes and it's cheaper to automate stuff than hire people. Then things coast for a while. The cost of automation keeps falling, people keep getting relatively more expensive, but in good times generally you don't get people getting fired en masse because times are good and the employer is making a profit anyway. Then a recession comes, and the cycle repeats...
- anigbrowl 10y agoThey're not, but the demographic they need to appeal to is, and it's not clear how to sell people on capitalism in an age of diminishing labor requirements. Capitalism as we know it is almost over; there is no rational reason for people to starve while a tiny minority accumulates all the capital. History tells us that once enough people figure out that they've got no prospects they'll gang up on the elite, kill them, and attempt to redistribute the spoils. I'm not being hyperbolic, I expect western-style democracy to collapse within the next 10-20 years.
- yakult 10y ago>According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, there were 64,000 steelworkers in America last year, and 820,000 home health aides — more than double the population of Pittsburgh. Next year, there will be fewer steelworkers and still more home health aides, as baby boomers fade into old age. Soon, we will be living in the United States of Home Health Aides, yet the candidates keep talking about steelworkers. I'm picking up a sort of 'gamers are dead' vibe from all this. I wonder if the media considers Gamergate a sort of success story and template for future political discourse? The argument would be that the issues faced by outgroup demographic X are not real, because outgroup demographic X is dying anyway, and is being replaced by ingroup demographic Y, and is also full of misogynists and/or racists and/or basement dwellers and/or rednecks and/or Trump voters. As supporting evidence, I will note the author just casually slipped in there that steel workers are all white men while service workers are mostly women.
- IPbanned 10y agoI remember people half-joking that GamerGate was going to be the template for the 2016 election. I never would have imagined how right they would be.
- benderther0bot 10y agoAfter looking at Mr Appelbaums Linkedin entry I wondered why anyone would listen to his opinions about this as opposed to any one elses.
- intrasight 10y agoPoliticians like wearing hard-hats. Doing so at a software company looks weird - usually.
- ianai 10y agoWant more service jobs? Make sure people have money to pay for services. This feels like a strong basis for UBI
- sunstone 10y agoBecause employees of manufacturers have more power in the value chain than in most other jobs that employee high school graduates. This pushes up middle class wages without government intervention.
- bigger_cheese 10y agoI work at a steelworks in Australia. The economic conditions are not identical to America but a lot of the same pain exists. Australia also has worse Anti-dumping protections then the US. China is dumping steel (i.e selling below cost) into our market - see: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-09-28/china-trade-arrangements-questioned-over-steel-dumping/7884026 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-09-28/china-trade-arrangemen... The government deciding to build a submarine fleet 'in Australia' was a huge election issue. The local unions around here are campaigning on forcing state government to use 'local' steel as a condition of their tender process for infrastructure projects. I think they have a point somewhat, it is pretty absurd that they built a sports stadium about 2km up the road from our huge steel plant and imported all the Steel for it. I don't think there is an easy answer. Throwing the industry the odd submarine or two to supply material for isn't long term sustainable. However If it is enough to kick-start a ship building industry though who knows...
- wycx 10y agoAre any specialty steels (tool steels, etc.) made in Australia, or do we just make low carbon structural steel and a little alloy steel? When I call up steel suppliers and ask if they have any maraging steel, they just laugh at me.
- bigger_cheese 10y agoThe technical capability is there but my understanding is the sales volume is not present for speciality grades to be profitable. It is basically an economy of scale problem unless you make specialised grades in large amounts (thousands of Tonnes) it is not economical. The market for that volume is not there.
- onlibuton 10y agoAnd
- nylsaar 10y agoManufacturing jobs and service sector jobs are not mutually exclusive. Historical trends do not represent an evolving sophisticated economical stragety, but document economical needs met. The author suggests manufacturing jobs are irrelevant, but all jobs are relevant and necessary.
- douche 10y agoHaving a good source of manufacturing jobs can float an order of magnitude more service jobs in an area. Look at every decaying mill town across the northeast where the mills went under and vibrant local downtown economies folded up afterwards.
- blazespin 10y agoIt's because Germany and Japan is so successful with manufacturing. Donald is asking why the US cant compete with Germany and Japan.
- mywittyname 10y agoWe outproduce both Japan and Germany combined in manufacturing. Manufacturing is roughly 18% of GDP for each Japan and Germany, but only 12% of the USA. Germany GDP: ~$4 trillion. Japan GDP: ~$5 trillion. USA GDP: ~$17 trillion. 9 * 0.18 = 1.6 17 * 0.12 = 2.0 So, as usual, Mr. Trump's ignorance is causing him to ask the wrong questions.
- hrxn 10y agoYes, as the trade surplus so aptly shows. Oh, wait..
- mywittyname 10y agoThe USA could export everything it manufactures but still run a trade deficit because Americans spend too much money on French mobile games and Bollywood films. But your original argument was that the US doesn't compete with Germany or Japan in manufacturing, when the facts show they not only compete, America fucking decimates those countries in raw output.
- burfog 10y agoNow lets divide by people. For people, it's 208 million and 321 million. The USA is getting $6355/person from manufacturing. Germany+Japan is getting $7792/person from manufacturing. They beat us, earning an extra 22.6% per person from manufacturing.
- mywittyname 10y agoI just saw this. Manufacturing is a much smaller segment of USA economy though, so per-capita is a bad metric. Maybe it would be okay if you weighted it based on % of the economy, in which case the USA would be $6355 / 0.12 = $54,441 vs 7792 / 0.18 = $43,289. So, weighted GPD per capita, the USA comes out way ahead. And actually, the weighted GDP/cap in manufacturing for the USA is higher than the average GPD/cap of the economy overall, which is just $53,041.
- known 10y agoIncome for bottom 90% has declined http://www.oftwominds.com/photos2015/income-growth4-15.png http://www.oftwominds.com/photos2015/income-growth4-15.png
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoIn the 19th Century a lot of people were "physiocrats" - people for whom all progress had to relate somehow to the agricultural production of food. This was most stridently expressed in the denial of ( some ) patents to Cyrus McCormick for the combine harvester. Manufacturing ended that, especially "factory farming". So now, the logistics and communications revolutions are doing to manufacturing what manufacturing did to agriculture. It's the circle of life...
- rangibaby 10y agoManufacturing represents middle class jobs that have largely gone away thanks to globalization, outsourcing, and automation among other things. One of the reasons the Boomers were so rich compared to following generations was that it was easy to get one of those jobs with minimal education, a college degree was not a necessity to make a decent wage and buy a house, a car, etc.
- croon 10y ago> From an economic perspective, however, there can be no revival of American manufacturing, because there has been no collapse. Because of automation, there are far fewer jobs in factories. But the value of stuff made in America reached a record high in the first quarter of 2016, even after adjusting for inflation. The present moment, in other words, is the most productive in the nation’s history. Pay no attention to the top % - that reaps all that benefit of that automation, and widening the wealth disparity chasm - behind the curtain.
- jhoechtl 10y agoBecause manufacturing creates true value opposed to digital fiat goods.
- coldtea 10y ago>Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing? Because when the shit comes to shove and the global economy takes a nosedive or your previous friendly third world manufactures give you the finger, having a "service industry" is worth nothing, but being able to produce the actual shit your businesses design and sell/export, matters. Of course for the US this might be less so, because they can always force, by diplomacy or might, those developing world manufacturers to comply. Another question would be why are people like the author of the article not particularly hot for manufacturing? Because they are upper middle class pundits, have worked all their lives in the culture/media/academic etc industries, and could not care less for lost manufacturing jobs and other such stuff. That's how we get books about the world being flat, industry doesn't matter, it's all "information" and "creativity" now, from people that could not suffer a day without electricity (and the hard work that goes into producing it), or without their car, etc.
- pjc50 10y ago"Service industry" includes financial services, which have been hugely lucrative to the West. It's a globally integrated supply chain, and cannot be otherwise. There is no way countries are going back to a blast-furnace-to-car vertically integrated manufacturing world. It costs far too much and you couldn't even do it back when Ford tried it. He needed to import rubber, modern cars need to import chips. The only non-globalised manufacturing chain is defence, which is instead prohibitively expensive. Manufacturing is popular because it's percieved as a source of blue-collar jobs. Not only has that declined due to automation, but I think that one of the reasons for the decline in Western manufacturing in the first place was union-busting and labour relations issues. Part of the reason Germany has retained its manufacturing reputation is avoiding that failure mode.
- _pmf_ 10y ago> "Service industry" includes financial services, which have been hugely lucrative to the West. If you buy into the philosophy that it is something other than an elaborate global Ponzi scheme.
- 10y ago
- EGreg 10y agoThis is why: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-sector_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-sector_theory The Great Depression saw the "creative destruction" of farm labor. People migrated to cities and it took a long time for the economy to shift to manyfacturing. Manufacturing jobs disappeared more gradually, but are now gone due to automation and outsourcing. The only way they will come back is to robots. The next sector is IP, it's one of the USA's biggest exports -- movies, music, ideas, brands, etc. Designed in California, assembled in China. That's why the USA has such a strong IP lobby and negotiates international treaties and bullies guys like Kin Dotcom. What's left after that? Well, why do we all NEED jobs? Because currently wages is the primary mechanism of getting money to the masses. But demand for human labor is falling.
- DiffEq 10y agoManufacturing is a strategic asset. When/If war ever comes upon us again we will need such assets to preserve ourselves. We must not let hubris cause us to think we are above the ruin as other great peoples have suffered.
- 3minus1 10y agoAs other have pointed out, US manufacturing is at an all time high. It just doesn't require as many people these days.
- snowwrestler 10y agoThe holy grail for politicians is growth in jobs that pay well but don't require college degrees or a ton of specialized training. Manufacturing provided those jobs for decades. That's why they are obsessed with manufacturing. If someone could come up with another industry that does the same thing for unskilled workers, then politicians would back that just as hard. The sad part is that manufacturing itself no longer pays unskilled workers well. People blame China but it's arguable that automation and machines have taken more jobs. This is why free college for everyone in the U.S. is a good idea. Our economy is leveling up, and it's time to level up our education too.
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago>jobs that pay well but don't require college degrees or a ton of specialized training. This is my thinking as well because this demographic is most likely a swing voter. College educated white collar types most likely have a lifelong party affiliation and don't swing their vote, but this demographic often doesn't as they aren't typically political. Its easier to blame cheap manufacturing overseas than to admit that our own homegrown automation is to blame here. Everyone pretending automation isn't eating the world is something every politician and every party world-wide seems to have in common, at least or now. Lastly, there's a puritan ethic at work here. Manufacturing, as well as farming, is hard work that brings tangible and easy to understand results. Politicians can talk about those jobs and farmers with no controversy compared to praising a hedge fund manager or an investment group that created vast amounts of wealth and jobs. Its politically incorrect to praise the wealthier people in society, even though they're the ones responsible for much of the economy. Election season tends to bring out the myth that the economy is run by hard working men in overalls sweating to produce value, when its really run in swanky offices by people engaging in fairly technical disciples. One of the big problems with democracy or at least the demagogy needed to win an election is that you often can't talk about how things really work as its seen as too elitist, technical, or just confusing. So certain classes of people are seen a virtuous like teachers, farmers, or line workers and anything having to do with big business or finance is instantly vilified. So we have these elaborate lies and strange incentives (fight for manufacturing? why?) to make sure no one gets offended or feels inferior.
- markhahn 10y agoironically, manufacturing is an industrial-age metaphor: people still seem to imagine that it can or could drive the economy, that election-quantity people might be supported by manufacturing, and that location of manufacturing is negotiable. all arguably untrue. you can't brag about unicorns.
- brightball 10y agoFrom an earlier comment, but this is why: "For every $1.00 spent in manufacturing, another $1.81 is added to the economy. That is the highest multiplier effect of any economic sector. In addition, for every one worker in manufacturing, there are another four employees hired elsewhere. (Source: NAM calculations using IMPLAN.) - See more at: http://www.nam.org/Newsroom/Top-20-Facts-About-Manufacturing/#sthash.CCQopC41.dpuf" http://www.nam.org/Newsroom/Top-20-Facts-About-Manufacturing... http://www.nam.org/Newsroom/Top-20-Facts-About-Manufacturing/ http://www.nam.org/Newsroom/Top-20-Facts-About-Manufacturing...
- ComteDeLaFere 10y agoThat's interesting. Would it be correct to say that $1 spent on importing goods to the US would still generate the additional 81 cents of additional value in that country? And if that's the case, would we still get the 81 cents in additional value if, due to global competition, we were able to import those same goods at 50 cents? Or am I overthinking this?