22 ms·
And yet not a single hard detail in the article as to why the headline might be true. For going on ten years we've seen the "iPhone killers" come and go, and th
by mikestew 10y ago
And yet not a single hard detail in the article as to why the headline might be true. For going on ten years we've seen the "iPhone killers" come and go, and this article does nothing to tell me why this time it will be different. Perhaps because it won't be.
Of what very few details the article outlines, they just go on about nifty hardware. Have we not learned by now that cool hardware still sucks when hamstrung by crappy software? (A Samsung logo popped in my head while writing that, don't know why.) Now, Google is no Samsung, but they're a long way from Apple or even Microsoft on the UX front.
(EDIT: the Pixel phones could be all that, but I wouldn't know it because I'm currently content with iPhones and have paid no attention to Pixel. Point is, this article does nothing to relieve my ignorance, which is why I clicked on the thing to begin with.)
- noobermin 10y agoProbably a case of the editor providing a clickbait headline. Remember, the title author and the article authors are often not the same person. PS Plus, it's Bloomberg. Not really expecting much in the way of technical details from them.
- mikestew 10y agoYa know, I don't know why I can't remember that. She writes an article with a working title "First Preview of Google Pixel Phone", subtitled "Light on Details, but Here's What We Know" and we end up with this instead.
- adamweld 10y ago>Now, Google is no Samsung, but they're a long way from Apple or even Microsoft on the UX front. Not sure I agree with this. I've been on android for a while, so I'm sure I'm biased, but stock AOSP Android is pretty much perfect for me. Very minimal and aesthetically beautiful, but still powerful and customizable.
- buckbova 10y agoTotally agree with this. Just got the moto g4 and for under $250. I have a really good looking color customized phone with stock android, that feels good in the hand, unlocked that I can take to any carrier. That is a killer.
- kogepathic 10y ago> I've been on android for a while, so I'm sure I'm biased, but stock AOSP Android is pretty much perfect for me. Very minimal and aesthetically beautiful, but still powerful and customizable. You can get AOSP on a lot of phones, you just have to be comfortable flashing a custom ROM. I don't understand why anyone would pay iPhone prices for an Android phone. Even if the hardware quality is similar (which it won't be, because Apple SoCs are at least a generation ahead of everyone else) Android app quality is much worse. I'm saying this as someone who has only ever used Android. I just can't see the justification to spending this much money on a phone Google will drop support for after 2 years, in addition to never fixing some issues that are present at launch (look up the Nexus 4 camera reset issue, which Google never fixed). I'm using a Xiaomi Redmi 2 I picked up new from AliExpress for $125 USD with free shipping to Europe, and I'm running Marshmallow via CM. Works perfectly, in fact most of the time it's better than $300-400 phones thanks to not being loaded to the gills with Google Apps crapware (seriously I have no use for Google Play Music, Books, News, etc) Edit: for people down voting this, could you explain why? I've left my opinion here and if you disagree with it, I'd love to hear why. I don't believe I've stated anything factually incorrect.
- noobermin 10y ago>(which it won't be, because Apple SoCs are at least a generation ahead of everyone else) Can anyone confirm if this is true? I thought the general advantage for i[a-zA-Z0-9]\+ is a well defined small N number of targets, which allow great optimization. Generally, the parts on apple things are a bit older than the competition but they pull off more (at least in user's eyes) compared with Android due to that optimization.
- kogepathic 10y ago
- wnevets 10y agoconsidering just how small the iphone global market share is, I'm not sure being an iphone killer is even a thing anymore.
- matwood 10y agoFlagship phones are where the big money is made. When people/companies talk of being an iPhone killer, that's what they mean.
- seanmccann 10y agoApple earns about 94% of the smartphone industry profit with just 14% of the market. It's a thing.
- wnevets 10y agoDifferent business models for different companies.
- hyperbovine 10y agoPretty sure most companies would aspire to the model where 94% of the rent accrues to you...
- wnevets 10y agonot when you can control 85% of the market and just want your software in front as many people as possible so you can sell them ads. Do you really think google cares that much about making profit on smartphone hardware?
- hyperbovine 10y agoThen why have they made this phone?
- wnevets 10y ago
- hesarenu 10y agoNow, Google is no Samsung, but they're a long way from Apple or even Microsoft on the UX front - I disagree. Material ui is an order better then iOS or metro ux. Coming from Android iOS on my iPad felt like a dated os in terms of ui and ux was not that good as well.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jusben1369 10y agoGiven that we all know headlines are made for clicking, I think it's pretty clear why this time is very different vs the previous 10 years: "He notes that the company is now managing inventory, building relationships with carriers, sourcing components, making supply chain deals and managing distribution. Google is even making accessories, including cases and cables." This article isn't about the technical approach, it's more about the business/go to market approach. That's _very_ different to how Google went to market prior. Is this going to materially impact the iPhone? I don't know. But it is different enough that it warrants some sort of "This is a new approach by Google to taking on the iPhone" headline.
- benologist 10y agoIsn't that what literally every android manufacturer has been doing since day 1? Google doing it "too" doesn't sound like a game changer.
- jusben1369 10y agoWell every other manufacturer has looked to Google (largely) for the sw and built the hw. It's this bundling together of the two that's being presented as unique and is different to every other Android manufacturer.
- threeseed 10y agoBut that's hypothetical. I'm not seeing any features that Google is uniquely placed to offer. And it's not like Android is so antithetical to third party modifications.
- MBCook 10y agoIt's different, but it doesn't mean it's an iPhone killer. MS started making their own hardware and it certainly helped push the market but the Sufarce never turned into the 'iPad killer' that tons of sites decided to declare it. It's a new Android phone, Google was heavily involved (more than the Nexus line). That's it. That's not bad, but it doesn't automatically make something an X killer.
- nindalf 10y agoTo be fair, the article links to the review of the camera by DXOMark [1], who rate it very highly. In my opinion, they're the most reliable reviewers of cameras out there so if they say its the best phone camera, then it is. [1] - https://www.dxomark.com/Mobiles/ https://www.dxomark.com/Mobiles/
- gnicholas 10y agoYes, though interestingly DXOMark seems not have reviewed the iPhone 7 Plus yet. Perhaps they're waiting for Portrait mode to be publicly released? Regardless, Google is on slightly shaky ground to claim that they have the best smartphone camera when a top contender hasn't been reviewed yet.
- ngrilly 10y agoDXOMark has already reviewed the iPhone 7, which has the same "main" wide-angle camera as the iPhone 7 Plus: https://www.dxomark.com/Mobiles/Apple-iPhone-7-camera-review-better-than-ever https://www.dxomark.com/Mobiles/Apple-iPhone-7-camera-review...
- jaxondu 10y agoThis number is used by most Android flagships when they launched. Surprised Google put it into their video ads, as it sure will not be the best when other flagship Nougat phones are launched.
- warfangle 10y agoAre other flagship nougat phones shipping before oct 21?
- sly010 10y agoYou probably haven't used a Google branded Android phone in the last 3-4 years. Project Fi + Nexus 5X + Stock Android is as good as it gets in integration and UX. The other day I lost my phone so I typed "where is my phone" into google. It showed me immediately. How many passwords do you have to type and licences to accept to do that on your Apple cloud? I agree the article doesn't explain it very well, but the bottom line is google is now controlling hardware, software, network and full online life (search, gmail, google play, calendar, map, etc) and they have the capacity to integrate it all. I recognize people are happy with their iPhones and they won't switch because of switching cost or fashion, but Google is creating some word class product here nonetheless.
- freddyc 10y ago> How many passwords do you have to type and licences to accept to do that on your Apple cloud? I made the switch to Nexus last year for work, but my wife is still a devoted iPhone user and recently upgraded to the 7. As I was setting it up for her I was shocked at how poor the UX was and the number of times the iPhone asked for a password (in some cases asking for the same password multiple times). Just a week earlier I had set-up a new Android device and I entered my Google login details once and that was it. The contrast was jarring.
- mattnewton 10y ago>How many passwords do you have to type and licences to accept to do that on your Apple cloud? No out-of-the-ordinary licenses, I just have to use the find-my app on iOS or my password + the iCloud.com website to locate any of my missing devices (including laptops), and make them play a sound. Apple's internet services are often behind, but I don't think this is a good example here - it just works, the UX is very discover-ably named "find my x", and it's reasonable to require a password for this. I think we need real competition as consumers. I know I don't want to see Apple's approach of the phone being the product and privacy as a feature being "killed". But I don't think they're in any danger yet.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bobajeff 10y agoHave never had an iPhone but I've exclusively used phones that have the stock Android experience (Moto G, Nexus 6). And to me nothing that Google has shown today is at a all threat to Apple (or Samsung for that matter). The only interesting thing in the whole presentation was the talk about AI which isn't really even anything that has to do with the hardware but the servers that it connects to. Maybe if they released a 4" phone or a standalone smartwatch they'd have something special. But two generic phones? Meh.
- gr3yh47 10y agoiPhones arent the one to beat though. Android has had a much larger market share since 2011 [0] 0: https://infographic.statista.com/normal/chartoftheday_4431_smartphone_operating_system_market_share_n.jpg https://infographic.statista.com/normal/chartoftheday_4431_s...
- fredgrott 10y agoand yet Samsung is out-selling Apple..talk about ignoring facts..
- bitmapbrother 10y ago>Now, Google is no Samsung, but they're a long way from Apple or even Microsoft on the UX front. I can tell you haven't really used any Google products in some time or if ever. And that bit about Microsoft and UX design - I couldn't tell if you were joking or not. You may want to add emoticons next time to make it more clear.
- amelius 10y ago> Now, Google is no Samsung, but they're a long way from Apple [...] on the UX front. Well, iTunes sucks, and it is pivotal in the Apple ecosystem.
- maherbeg 10y agoI don't think this is true at all. I haven't touched iTunes in a long time. With direct iCloud syncing and direct phone updates, you never have to go into iTunes for just about anything.
- kiwijamo 10y agoI've had a iPhone for three years and have been a MacBook owner for over ten years. I can't remember thr last time I used iTunes. It's just an app which some people use. It's hardly pivotal...
- erdevs 10y agoI've been a long-time Apple and iOS user. However, I can recognize that this is a big move by Google. > For going on ten years we've seen the "iPhone killers" come and go... The headlines says Google's first "real threat" to iPhone, not that this is an iPhone "killer". Let's not be hyperbolic. You don't need a lot of detail other than the fact that Google is designing, building and selling smartphones (and increasingly other devices) to recognize as legitimate the claim that this is merely a threat to iPhone. > Now, Google is no Samsung, but they're a long way from Apple or even Microsoft on the UX front. This seems biased. Everyone has their own tastes, but Google's software and UX have become pretty top notch across many of their product lines, imo. It's fine to state your personal preference or dislike of their design ethos but painting with such a broad and unequivocal brush is silly. This is not a universally shared sentiment. > And yet not a single hard detail in the article as to why the headline might be true. Again, you seem to be creating a strawman in taking about an "iPhone killer" claim. Certainly this represents some kind of threat. Other threats to Apple's iPhone have sprung up in the past, and some to great success. Google's new foray may or may not be successful in its own right over time and it may or may not impact the iPhone's success, but I bet Apple themselves view it as a competitive threat to monitor. > Point is, this article does nothing to relieve my ignorance, which is why I clicked on the thing to begin with. The tl;dr is that Google created a major new hw division that spans multiple devices including new smartphone lines and Google directly will carry the supply chain and inventory risk on their balance sheet. This is a major, major move financially and strategically and it's all that's necessary to back up the actual headline claim. On top of that, they provided some specifics on the phone offerings (eg two sizes, first phone to offer Android N, first phone with built in Google Assistant, the Pixel's design was unveiled (certainly a large part of Apple's phone unveilings, so why not count it for Google's?) including backside glass, lots of camera details (12MP, DXO Mark ratings, auto-stabilization for vid), free unlimited cloud storage, the fingerprint scanner+track pad, Daydream VR support, etc, etc). Not sure how you came away with such a stark view of the articles headline vs content.
- sbuk 10y ago"The headlines says Google's first "real threat" to iPhone, not that this is an iPhone "killer". Let's not be hyperbolic." I'd argue, based on Bloomberg's form, that "real threat" is verging on hyperbolic.
- erdevs 10y agoI've been a long-time Apple and iOS user. However, I can recognize that this is a big move by Google. > For going on ten years we've seen the "iPhone killers" come and go... The headlines says Google's first "real threat" to iPhone, not that this is an iPhone "killer". Let's not be hyperbolic. You don't need a lot of detail other than the fact that Google is designing, building and selling smartphones (and increasingly other devices) to recognize as legitimate the claim that this is merely a threat to iPhone. > Now, Google is no Samsung, but they're a long way from Apple or even Microsoft on the UX front. This seems biased. Everyone has their own tastes, but Google's software and UX have become pretty top notch across many of their product lines, imo. It's fine to state your personal preference or dislike of their design ethos but painting with such a broad and unequivocal brush is silly. This is not a universally shared sentiment. > And yet not a single hard detail in the article as to why the headline might be true. Again, you seem to be creating a strawman in taking about an "iPhone killer" claim. Certainly this represents some kind of threat. Other threats to Apple's iPhone have sprung up in the past, and some to great success. Google's new foray may or may not be successful in its own right over time and it may or may not impact the iPhone's success, but I bet Apple themselves view it as a competitive threat to monitor. > Point is, this article does nothing to relieve my ignorance, which is why I clicked on the thing to begin with. The tl;dr is that Google created a major new hw division that spans multiple devices including new smartphone lines and Google directly will carry the supply chain and inventory risk on their balance sheet. This is a major, major move financially and strategically and it's all that's necessary to back up the actual headline claim. On top of that, they provided some specifics on the phone offerings (eg two sizes, first phone to offer Android N, first phone with built in Google Assistant, the Pixel's design was unveiled (certainly a large part of Apple's phone unveilings, so why not count it for Google's?) including backside glass, lots of camera details (12MP, DXO Mark ratings, auto-stabilization for vid), free unlimited cloud storage, the fingerprint scanner+track pad, Daydream VR support, etc, etc). Not sure how you came away with such a stark view of the articles headline vs content.
- rezashirazian 10y agoI've been a happy iPhone user for a long time and of all the things all these so called iPhone killers have demonstrated none of them have ever touched on the one thing that would make me switch. 1 TB of storage. I run out of space on my phone all the time and would love nothing more than unlimited (or close to it) storage on the device. I honestly could care less about VR or home assistant.
- euxneks 10y agoI'm not sure what about the iPhone needs to be killed? As far as I know it's not got the majority market share? If they're talking about the ecosystem where iPhone is definitely making a killing, then they need to work on their software more than their hardware.
- MBCook 10y agoIt's the single best selling phone, but that's in part because Samsung has 12 options that compete with it so naturally no individual model has the same numbers. Probably more of a perception/mindshare thing.
- eagsalazar2 10y agoDude you are way off base. Try a Nexus 5x. Usability is at least competitive with MS and Apple (better IMO).
- hossbeast 10y agoGoogle has universally better UX than Apple. Have you used the enormity that is iTunes?
- redial 10y agoGoogle Plus.
- SwellJoe 10y agoEvery Android phone is an iPhone killer. Android owns ~80% of the market, to iPhone's ~18% [1]. Having many price points turns out to matter a lot; but, I think even people who are not price sensitive often prefer Android (I certainly do). I've loved every Nexus device I've owned...the pure Android experience is hard to beat, IMHO. 1: http://www.macrumors.com/2016/02/18/ios-android-market-share-q4-15-gartner/ http://www.macrumors.com/2016/02/18/ios-android-market-share...
- rcheu 10y agoI actually prefer modern Samsung variants of Android over Google (aside from the not-updating quickly thing). I really prefer S Planner over Google Calendar, and the Samsung Keyboard is superior to the Google Keyboard too (Samsung's runs much faster).
- pmontra 10y agoSamsung has hardware buttons which are extremely useful. They find the way to squeeze them on the bezel which other phones still have and they don't waste space on the screen. S Planner is good but I can't compare it to Google Calendar which I never used. Same for the keyboard. What I can say is that Samsung keyboard wins against SwiftKey and ties against Swype.
- jsight 10y agoYep, this doesn't meaningfully change the equation, except for making the Nexus-quality phones even more expensive. If you liked Android before, this will look great to you (though very expensive). If you didn't like it so much before, nothing has really changed with this specific device to change your mind. The article headline is just clickbait.