32 ms·
How the Sugar Industry Shifted Blame to Fat
- aws_ls 10y agopure gold comment by Eduard Fischer (in Reader's pick section): "Last week while traveling in the US, I witnessed a mother place a cola soft drink in front of a young child. The girl began to sip on the drink, the volume of which I estimated to be about twice the size of the girl’s head. I was tempted to make a remark, but remembered that I was in a foreign country where the citizens are famously well armed and roughly half the folks eligible to vote have lost their minds..."
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoWe're going to need another Surgeon General's warning, it seems.
- amist 10y agoWhat about the fat industry? Didn't they have enough money to pay for scientists to shift the blame to sugar?
- timewarrior 10y agoFat based foods are pricier vs sugar based. Given limited household budget for food, margins tend to be lower on Fat based products. And you can eat a lot more sugar based food vs fat based food on per food weight basis.
- sosuke 10y agoI believe there isn't a fat industry, can you imagine manufacturing fat? Paid for by the Fat for America Industry.
- ThomPete 10y agoThere actually are fat factories I know of one in New Jersie, whether it's an industry I don't know.
- knodi123 10y agoI guess the closest is the National Association of Margarine Manufacturers (http://www.iheartbutterytaste.com/ http://www.iheartbutterytaste.com/).
- logfromblammo 10y agoWhat? Where do you think soybean, corn, Canola/rapeseed, peanut, cottonseed, sunflower, safflower, olive, coconut, and palm oils come from? Animal fats are rather expensive in comparison, but I can also buy pork lard, beef suet, and butter rather easily. The problem there might just be fragmentation. Growers of cane and beets (and sorghum, too, I guess) have basically just one major homogenized end product: refined sucrose. There are a few related products, like molasses, brown sugar, and confectioners' sugar, and the stuff like bagasse, that tends not to be seen by consumers, but refined sucrose is the moneymaker. Corn growers can also side with the sugar lobby thanks to corn syrup and high-fructose corn syrup. There's definitely an industry ($800M/year?), but it isn't one that has a great common marketing association around, to collect dues and pitch catchy slogans that play well on television and radio. The soy and Canola/rapeseed growers might come together to promote B20 biodiesel, though, while simultaneously bashing palm oil plantations. I can't currently imagine anyone trying to convince me to eat more fats and oils in my diet, at the expense of sugars. Low-carb is still largely seen as an irresponsible, unhealthy, fad diet in the mainstream.
- hx87 10y agoThey're not as powerful as the sugar lobby, but they did manage to get out recommendations that unfairly demonized saturated fats and promoted unsaturated fats.
- ConceptJunkie 10y agoProbably not without the corn subsidies that make sugar so cheap.
- neolefty 10y agoIs there a "fat industry"? Sugar production is very industrialized, just a few companies with a strong lobby. Fat is much more diverse. Sure, there are a few giant soybean oil producers, but it's not their only product, and individual companies don't dominate their market.
- anon1385 10y agoThe pork industry for one. see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bacon_mania https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bacon_mania and http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-10-06/bacon-why-americas-favorite-food-mania-happened http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-10-06/bacon-why-...
- LordHumungous 10y agoThere are definitely meat and dairy industries.
- Noseshine 10y agoBut they are happy to remove the fat and sell you fat-free and/or low-fat versions of their products - just see American supermarket shelves (not nearly as much of that here in German, although even here the low-fat versions are more numerous and more prominently placed). This is hard with sugar-free sugar... :)
- hx87 10y agoWhich is why the average American store shelf is full of painfully lean pork and nonfat Greek yogurt (Seriously, WTF?).
- ginko 10y agoGuess they were busy destroying the reputation of lard.
- alecco 10y agoThe dairy industry is backing all these sugar bad, and implicit or explicit fat good. In particular discrediting valid research warning on saturated fats. Against the American Heart Association and the American College of Cardiology, and even NHS.
- fastoptimizer 10y agoWhen in fact nothing can be blamed but our overconsumption of almost everything but vegetables and fruits. I eat about 70% from my calories in carbs (some are refined), but it's just 2500kcal calories per day. I'm pretty sure the fact that average US citizen eats 3500kcal daily has more to do with anything than what particular ingredient one eats. edit: some irrational unscientific and anegdotal statements require me to remove myself from discussion. thanks.. for the downvotes, I'm outta here boys! :wink:
- kentor 10y agoThen the question is why do they eat 3500kcal? The hypothesis is that sugar does not make people feel full whereas fat does, so they eat more. A calorie is not a calorie.
- fastoptimizer 10y ago> The hypothesis is that sugar does not make people feel full whereas fat does, so they eat more. They still eat about 1500kcal of fat and protein - of which I eat about half the amount. If you were really talking about feeling full, nothing makes you feel more full than a belly and guts filled with lovely starch/fiber from fruits and vegetables, which an average US eats little if not any.
- mobiuscog 10y agoDepends on the person. I can eat stupid amounts of fruit and vegetables... Low-carb is the only way I can not feel hungry. Of course, the general population does like their carbs to be the refined type.
- hx87 10y agoI can easily get full from starchy/fibrous foods, but then I feel hungry again 1 hour later. Fat/protein rich foods, in contrast, keep me full for 4-8 hours.
- GordonS 10y agoYes, they make you feel full... until your blood glucose level drops 1-3 hours later, then you feel very hungry again. By contrast, if I eat a fat and protein based meal, there is no blood sugar drop to instigate a 'fake' hunger signal, so I don't begin to feel hungry for 4-7 hours or so.
- jbb555 10y agoThere seems to be increasing evidence that high blood sugar over a long period of time is very bad for you. That insulin response keeps this under control mostly... but that it was probably never meant to be active all day, every day. So eating lots of sugar (and carbs in general) at every meal is probably long term, not the best thing you can do.
- muzster 10y agoRIP: British Scientist John Yudkin - The man who tried to warn us about the perils of sugar.. Source(s) : http://www.telegraph.co.uk/lifestyle/wellbeing/diet/10634081/John-Yudkin-the-man-who-tried-to-warn-us-about-sugar.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/lifestyle/wellbeing/diet/10634081... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Yudkin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Yudkin Edit: Lest we not forget his arch-enemy Ancel Keys
- agumonkey 10y agoA story every scientist should now. For its own sake.
- infodroid 10y agoAnother good discussion of Yudkin's work and how it was received: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/apr/07/the-sugar-conspiracy-robert-lustig-john-yudkin/ https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/apr/07/the-sugar-co...
- gtrubetskoy 10y agoAlong with Robert Atkins. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Atkins_(nutritionist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Atkins_(nutritionist)
- djsumdog 10y agoIf you ask people to this day, they'll say Atkins died of his own diet. That was actually a total lie run by Harpers magazine. They corrected the mistake in the following edition, but the damage had been done. Although there is little evidence to support it, the running conspiracy theory is that PR people in various arms of the food industry paid for that article. Edit: Adkins died because he slipped on a piece of ice during a snow storm and cracked his skull.
- merpnderp 10y agoTo be completely fair, he slipped on the ice likely as a complication from heart disease. His doctors swear that his arteries and heart were the healthiest they'd seen for someone that age except for the infected portion.
- jamroom 10y agoThis quote from the article is a great one: "It was a very smart thing the sugar industry did because review papers, especially if you get them published in a very prominent journal, tend to shape the overall scientific discussion" Has the acceptance policy for prominent journals improved that we're sure this is not happening now? I have suspicions that this is likely still happening more frequently then we might expect (i.e. pharmaceutical trials, etc.).
- digi_owl 10y agoThe basic issue is that reviews are just looking for glaring problems in the presentation. To really test an article one has to replicate the experiment from the ground up. And these days thats damn hard and expensive to do.
- oxryly1 10y agoFor the typical reviewer, replication is probably downright impossible. http://www.nature.com/news/1-500-scientists-lift-the-lid-on-reproducibility-1.19970 http://www.nature.com/news/1-500-scientists-lift-the-lid-on-...
- ilaksh 10y agoThe real issue is the reliance on authority rather than actual evaluation of the merits of the papers by everyone.
- bbctol 10y agoAs indicated in the article, journals at the time often didn't require scientists to disclose their sources of funding, whereas they're now extremely strict about full financial disclosure. You can still get published in a prominent journal with a tricky source of funding, but it will be a matter of public record, and your results will (in theory) be more heavily scrutinized.
- timewarrior 10y agoIt took almost 50 years to starting to debunk health issues created by Sugar. It took decades to accept the health issues created by Lead and Asbestos. Sometime I wonder if chemicals from bottled water, radiation from Cellular/Wifi/Bluetooth pose health risks and we will find it out decades later.
- oxryly1 10y agoTrue. And until then if you resist such things you're labelled as a crank, luddite, anti-science, etc. etc.
- timewarrior 10y agoCompletely agreed. I have been avoiding using anti-bacterial soaps for years, because something didn't add up. I am perfectly happy washing my hands with water before meal. Sometimes if I feel that my hands are really greasy/dirty I would use a natural ingredient based soap. I have friends who would chide me for that. And now FDA bans sale of many anti-bacterial soaps: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/03/science/fda-bans-sale-of-many-antibacterial-soaps-saying-risks-outweigh-benefits.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/03/science/fda-bans-sale-of-m... I just went to gym and someone who used the treadmill just before me doused the treadmill with 10-12 pieces of anti-bacterial wipes. The treadmill was wet when I started and was giving out fumes for almost 10 minutes while I was running. I am wondering what is worse for me: potentially germs from a reasonably healthy and hygienic person vs vast array of chemicals from this cheap anti-bacterial wipe.
- MichaelGG 10y ago"didn't add up" is a very different reason than the FDA reasoning. Indeed, it's not that anti bacterial is directly bad, but the second order effects of weakened immunity and "superbugs". It's not being correct if you act suspicious about everything, then something has a negative effect you weren't aware of.
- timewarrior 10y ago
- redwards510 10y agoThe documentary "Fed Up" is about sugar and was the first time I was made aware there is no daily RDA % for sugar on nutrition labels. They just have the grams. They lobbied very hard to make it that way, because having "4700%" for a daily RDA wouldn't look very good!
- hammock 10y agoThe WHO recommends a 50g daily limit of sugar (the FDA's RDA for total carbs is 300g). A single 16oz Coke will put you over the limit. Even as someone who eats relatively clean, it's hard for me to stay under 50g over the course of an entire day.
- derptron 10y agoStep 1 - Don't drink regular Coke.
- MrMullen 10y agoTrue, but there is carb count and percentages on labels and it is not hard to figure out that something that is 4700% your daily limit for carbs is not something you should be eating.
- mhurron 10y ago> it is not hard to figure out that something that is 4700% your daily limit for carbs is not something you should be eating. You are probably getting more sugar from things you don't think should be full of sugar than you think. US tastes have skewed to sweet so far that sugar is stuffed in everything.
- vertex-four 10y agoEven in the UK, when I stopped eating candy for a while, it turned out that I found a lot of "ready-to-eat" food overly sugary.
- wccrawford 10y ago
- jly 10y agoI think after the last few years of these kinds of things coming out, the takeaway is pretty simple: be fairly sceptical of 'advice' coming out of large governing bodies and instead just be sensible. Don't eat too much food. Limit processed foods. Eat lots of fruit and vegetables. Eat a large variety of foods. Be active. These rudimentary guidelines are clearly difficult for a lot of people to follow, but I think it's pretty easy to avoid negative diet effects by just doing what most people intuitively know as the right thing, even if we consume some of all types of food. It seems to me this is more about self-control and effort level than any scientific knowledge, at this point.
- ajsbae 10y agoAs someone who has a fairly limited and simple diet, what are some of the effects of not eating a large variety of foods?
- yodsanklai 10y ago> be fairly sceptical of 'advice' coming out of large governing bodies and instead just be sensible. I agree with the latter part, but what's wrong with health institutions recommendations? they look pretty sensible to me. I'm much more skeptical of advice from 'health gurus' that seem to have increasing influence.
- Dylan16807 10y agoThe massive gulf in healthiness between fruit and fruit juice is not intuitive at all. The most important question by far is how to eat less, and the answer is very complex.
- abainbridge 10y agoYeah. But humans haven't had fresh fruit available all year round until recently. Similarly, there was never a wide range of foods available. I'm not sure we've got enough evidence to say that changing our diet to include lots of fruit and a wide variety of foods is safe. The encouragement to do this is coming from large governing bodies. I'm off to eat nothing but turnips for a year and get scurvy :-)
- graham1776 10y agoMy wife and I rewatch the obligatory Lustig lecture about once a month to re-anger ourselves at sugar. Nothing motivates like a bit of biochemistry mixed in with political intrigue. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM
- acconrad 10y agoThe problem is Lustig is on the far end of the spectrum on anti-sugar. No added sugars? Sure, I buy that. Labelling fructose as a poison simply because it is directly metabolized in the liver is stretch. I'm not going to worry that my kids are eating berries because of their fructose content.
- yotamoron 10y agoClearly you didn't fully understand what lustig is saying. Its not the fact that fructose is metabolized in the liver that is problematic - its the effects of the process that are horrible and poisonouos.
- cconroy 10y agoRegardless, people coming away with the conclusion that fructose is bad for you is bananas ;) Also it is not clear that he is for/against eating lots of fruits and starchy veges of which humans thrive on. Lots of evidence for this too!
- jacobolus 10y agoFructose is bad for you. A couple pieces of fruit every day is generally fine, because fruits are packed with fiber, but if you e.g. drink 3 glasses of fruit juice per day, that’s terrible for you. Even eating fruits isn’t the best though. Modern fruits are bred to be as large and sweet as possible.
- cconroy 10y ago
- aswanson 10y agoThe documents show that a trade group called the Sugar Research Foundation, known today as the Sugar Association, paid three Harvard scientists the equivalent of about $50,000 in today’s dollars to publish a 1967 review of sugar, fat and heart research. The studies used in the review were handpicked by the sugar group, and the article, which was published in the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine, minimized the link between sugar and heart health and cast aspersions on the role of saturated fat. The Harvard scientists and the sugar executives with whom they collaborated are no longer alive. Good thing there is no collusion between big industry and paid off scientists like Willie Soon to direct the narrative around things these days.</sarcasm>
- balabaster 10y agoYou forgot your sarcasm tag, most people will miss it ;)
- aswanson 10y agoDone, thanks.
- brianwawok 10y agoYour post now fails wc3 validation.
- stepanhruda 10y agoSo much wealth lost so 3 people can get $50k...
- tomjen3 10y agoI am honestly mostly scared by how cheaply those scientists were brought. I mean 50 grand?
- WillPostForFood 10y agoNot even, the number is ~7,000, but the article is using inflation adjusted dollars to make the number sound bigger. It is also unclear whether they got that amount each, or in total.
- sliverstorm 10y agoYou realize the absolute number is virtually meaningless? Inflation adjusted is the best number, with the caveat that your inflation index needs to be good.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoNot sure how it is better for the article to never include the actual, factual, payment amount. If you have an agenda to minimize the number you only print the original, if you have an agenda to maximize, you only print the inflation adjusted. It would be better for the article to include both. Because what happens is people start throwing around the 50k number without the "inflation adjusted" like in the parent comment.
- r_smart 10y agoNo, the inflation adjusted value allows a person reading it to compare it to the buying power of the time they live in to understand how much money it actually was. Having a monetary figure expressed in a time other than as an analog to the present reduces the usefulness of the figure.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoI'll take facts over context, but would be happy with both. I'm fully capable of figuring out the inflation adjusted number, but now we don't actually know what they were paid. I also guarantee you they we will see secondary reporting of this article, and the 50k number will be in it, and the inflation adjusted/today's dollars piece will get lost.
- smokeyj 10y ago> One of the scientists who was paid by the sugar industry was D. Mark Hegsted, who went on to become the head of nutrition at the United States Department of Agriculture, where in 1977 he helped draft the forerunner to the federal government’s dietary guidelines. This is why I'm cynical.
- gist 10y agoThis was a great documentary on the subject, I saw it on Netflix I don't know if it's there anymore though: https://vimeo.com/122387548 https://vimeo.com/122387548 http://sugarcoateddoc.com/ http://sugarcoateddoc.com/
- balabaster 10y agoand this folks is why I have trust issues... Scientists paid off by industry to make people look the other way, who then become head of some Governmental departments and agencies advising the world on whatever it was they were paid off for or have a conflict of interest in and the door keeps revolving... It's a wonder we believe anything at all after the amount of lies and propaganda we're fed only to find out it's false... or are they lying now? Now we're being fed information that it's the sugar industry at fault and not the fat industry, while we have fad diets that are high fat, low carb, low sugar, because carbs and sugar are bad and fat isn't bad at all allegedly. Who is making the money from the increased fat sales and decreased sugar sales? Is it because sugar is cutting into their bottom line too much and fat is in cheap supply? Why do we continue to believe the shit that pours out of the mouths of big agriculture and the nutrition agencies as if they haven't been feeding us bullshit for the past 50 years in aid of increasing profit. They don't give a shit about the consumer, they give a shit about whatever fuels the greatest growth in profits. So this is why I have issue believing anything that any of them have to say about anything because it's all underhanded subterfuge and manipulation, with no end in sight.
- DougWebb 10y agoAs far as the actual food sales, most of the money winds up in the same small set of hands regardless of which fad is currently popular. They'll resist trends that switch from high-margin to low-margin foods, but only until they've figured out how to alter the low-margin food to make it high-margin. The secondary money-grab is from the food-fad industry. All of the books, all of the websites, all of the memberships, all churning out recipes and advice and misinformation, depends on constant change in what's considered "good". Without constant change, their markets would dry up to a trickle. It's just like the fashion industry; if we all decided to wear the same SciFi-like jumpsuits all of the time because it's really the best thing to wear, the fashion industry would be destroyed. So instead we have a constant rotation of the fashion trends. (At least the fashion industry isn't killing us, though.)
- balabaster 10y agoThe longer I live, the more I value the lessons I learned from my Grandparents: - Don't listen to the shit you hear in the media, it's all self serving. Do your own research, that way it serves your need, not anyone elses. - Stay out of the centre aisles at the grocery store. Buy simple ingredients. Make it yourself. If you can't grow it yourself or kill it, you probably shouldn't be eating it. - Do the research, buy it once, buy it right. Quality will always beat quantity in the long run. Buy something you can repair yourself over something replaceable. > if we all decided to wear the same SciFi-like jumpsuits all of the time because it's really the best thing to wear, the fashion industry would be destroyed A few of us got stuck at a moment in time and never really updated... a decent pair of hard wearing jeans and an endless supply of decent t-shirts that last more than a few months of continuous wear and a decent pair of solid, dependable boots. You may be able to tell that the fashion industry doesn't make a whole ton of money out of me. Don't care, lol.
- balabaster 10y agoFollow the money and you will find the motive for what you're being told. There is a reason you're being told what you are and don't believe that it's for your own good. These industries and agencies don't care about what's good for you, they are self serving and only care about what's good for them. You're just the vessel supplying the cash they're after.
- e40 10y agoFollow the money and you will find the motive for what you're being told. That is definitely true, but way beyond the scope of almost everyone that is targeted by the things that should be questioned.
- balabaster 10y ago> way beyond the scope of almost everyone that is targeted by the things that should be questioned and this is both why the lobbyists are successful and shouldn't be trusted
- open_book 10y agoI wonder that sometimes about seat belt laws and stop smoking campaigns. Is it the insurance companies that lobbied for and promote these ideas, or is it some altruistic group that actually cares about my well being instead of profits?
- tlb 10y agoSeat belts and many other automotive safety improvements were driven by insurance companies. That's a fortunate case of incentives being aligned. It's surprising that health insurers aren't more vocal about sugar. Diabetes and obesity are expensive for them.
- balabaster 10y agoFollow the money, I'll bet you dollars to donuts there's a reason for it... like executives having conflicting interests that result in either direct or indirect financial stakes in or hidden kickbacks from the sugar industry. Companies of these sizes have departments that are aware of the entire picture and everything is scripted, choreographed and quite deliberate - except when it serves their purpose to play dumb: "Hey DOJ, <sheepishly> we're real sorry, but we weren't aware of this massive conflict of interest that we made billions off! Please, take this $50m (from our $958m profit) as our mea culpa and divide it up between to 284 million people it affected as our way of saying sorry, we fucked up."
- cloudjacker 10y agoWell that escalated quickly Only saw the documentaries a few months ago. I'm glad this awareness has pushed for deeper more reputable investigation.
- ianamartin 10y agoOf course this happened. Duh. It's still happening today. I'm not saying where because I don't know where. But if you do the simple math about how many people are working as scientists, it's not hard to figure out that there are companies who could benefit from positive scientific findings--no matter how wrong--and realize that some of what we're reading in original research was paid for and not really true. I wish people would keep that in mind when they get all worshippy about science being self-correcting and a great system. It's not a particularly great system if you are looking, for example, for certainty. If you want absolute certainty, a good dose of syllogist reasoning will serve you better than any inductive method. The problem is that syllogistic methods break down very quickly in real world applications because you have to find ways of classifying all the objects that may or may not fall into your category of "all", "some", or "none". The scientific method is not a bad method, but it's not great. And it's weak in ways like this. It is not even close to the best method. But it's the only one we've found that's generally applicable to the human endeavor. That's all it is. Better at being more general. I wish we'd get over ourselves and be honest about that.
- balabaster 10y agoIt doesn't help when most of the information you hear regarding nutrition has been to underwrite the profits of multi-billion dollar corporations that are only out for one thing: Your money... and they don't care what means they have to use to get it. For instance buying exclusive access to resources that you had free access to for pennies on the dollar so that you don't have access to it any more and then selling it to you for gross profits... and I don't mean that in a taxation sense of the word gross. I mean that it's quite literally disgusting. I'm looking at you Nestle, but realistically, you're just one example of the systemic corruption and propaganda that is pervasive across the entire nutrition market.
- Kenji 10y agoThe less political the subject, the better the science about it. That's why I love maths. Nobody bribes a set of mathematicians to incorrectly claim the Collatz Conjecture has been proven.
- ggregoire 10y agoThere is almost everyday a topic about sugar/carbs/fat on the frontpage.
- yotamoron 10y agoThe bitter truth about sugar: https://youtu.be/dBnniua6-oM https://youtu.be/dBnniua6-oM
- degenerate 10y agoCTRL+F to see if anyone posted it, and sad to see it so far down. This is the #1 video to show anyone that thinks sugar is fine. It's literally, at a biological level in high doses, poison to our bodies. Watch the vid. It will open your eyes. Too bad the food industry fabricated their lies decades before we had the internet to share information like this. The damage is done and will take decades to undo.
- dxbydt 10y agoHoney is a strange alternative to sugar. For the past 2 decades, I have used honey as the sole sweetener, though the rest of the family continues to patronize sugar :( The trouble with honey is that it's seriously pricey, and the community is a something of a cult - you have to know a lot of the terminology, otherwise you'll walk out with sugar-water. I take an empty 1 gallon jar to the honey store in Sac, and pay $100 to fill her up. I have experimented a lot with the cocktail over the years. Generally, avoid anything"American" ie. sweet light colored honey. Go for the raw unfiltered darkest thickest broth you can find. They have gigantic jars of various colors, so I sample from the darkest ones. Then add a few grams of propolis and a few scoops of nectar and a few combs. Top it off with manuka and part with $100. Lasts 3 months. It tastes weird and too thick and gooey, but it's an amazing product. All the debris floating around on it is supposedly packed with enzymes etc.
- jmcgough 10y agoThere isn't a significant health benefit to using honey over refined sugars. Sugar is sugar.
- caw 10y agoSugar is sugar, but honey is interesting in the flavors and aromas it can provide outside of your standard white sugar. Just to add if anyone is interested in honey as a sweetener - What dxbydt was saying with honey being ~$8/lb is a good price for identifiable flower honey. Wholesale is roughly $4-5/lb, depending on varietal. There's a significant range in flavors and aromas depending on what type of flower produced the bulk of the honey. Don't need to avoid anything on colors, it's primarily based on what type of flower is used to produce the honey. Try a sampler, most apiaries/honey specialty shops will sell you a small container of each varietal they have. Avoid heat treated honeys, heating the honey to have it pass through a filter will get rid of a lot of the aroma. You'll see a lot of "raw, unfiltered" at specialty shops. If you're interested, you can ferment meads with a minimum of ~1.5 pounds per gallon, depending on how strong you want the resulting beverage.
- hx87 10y ago1 gallon of honey lasts you three months? I have a 12 oz jar that has lasted me almost a year, and I use honey closely to exclusively.
- LordHumungous 10y agoOn the other hand, I think the low carb/keto people have taken the pendulum too far in the other direction. A lot of research seems to suggest that a plant based diet heavy on whole fruits, vegetables, grains, and nuts is healthier than one consisting of animal fats and protein. It makes sense when you look at the diets of the healthiest people on Earth. Just because excess processed sugar is bad for you doe not mean all carbs are unhealthy.
- martinko 10y agoLow carb and keto is consistent with a vergatable, plant and especially nut diet. > Whole fruits What are whole fruits and why do you feel fruits of any kind are healthy? The levels of sugars in them are unnatural - neither oranges nor apples have historically been as sweet as they are now.
- gohrt 10y agoWhole fruits are pieces of fruit from a tree, that you bit into, as opposed to fruits that have been chemically mechanically/processed to extract some molecules (sugar) and discard others (especially the pulp/fiber) Modern meat is also unnnatural, engineered by the agriculture industry.
- dualogy 10y ago> Modern meat is also unnnatural, engineered by the agriculture industry. Doesn't matter, because we digest and absorb plant matter only extremely inefficiently compared to all true herbivores and animal omnivores --- no matter how much more palatable we engineered/bred those plants to be; and we digest meat nearly as efficiently as any of the truest carnivores in the wild --- again, no matter how far removed by now our agricultural breeds are from their original ancestor stoneage species.
- jcsvyu789jh 10y ago> Modern meat is also unnnatural, engineered by the agriculture industry. Aren't you conflating "natural" with safe/nutritious/good for you? Or am I misreading your comment. (It seems to strongly indicate you believe that "unnatural" things are bad for you.)
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoThis bad advice may have directly contributed to the deaths of millions of people.
- nnain 10y agoWhat if this backlash against Sugar is as extreme as the initial marketing? What if 50 years on, people come back to say, "the generation that endlessly promoted tasteless food and took away the sweetness". Is there a proper study on the effect of eating a sweet chocolate everytime you feel like it, to some kind of happiness? Everyone just sees to be treating this as a magical wand... while still irrationally giving in to a lot of other hyped up food.
- tux1968 10y agoPossible but unlikely. For one, you can get lots of tasty food by reintroducing more dietary fat. One of the main culprits for the over reliance on sugar for tastiness in the first place was the focus on reducing fat intake.
- hx87 10y agoIn my experience, tasteless food and sweet food are positively, not negatively correlated. The blandest food (lowfat yogurt) is often the sweetest while the tastiest food (ribeye steak) has no sweetness at all.=.
- sridca 10y agoAye, exactly my thinking. The French woman who lived the longest (122) has reportedly eaten a kilogram of chocolate every week. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeanne_Calment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeanne_Calment Personally, I don't subscribe to any of these dietary fads (including 'cutting sugar'). Just eat less, and you'll do fine.
- tlb 10y agoThe sugar industry was also the main driver of the African slave trade. When you have strong selection bias against morally principled people joining an industry (as there must have been in, say, 1850) it's hard for an industry to ever recover a moral compass.
- r_smart 10y agoMaybe you have a lot of information that I don't (I'm hardly an expert here), but describing it as the main driver seems like a stretch. In the Caribbean, I can see your statement being true. But in the US, as I understand it, it was more general agriculture / cotton. And so far as I know, a huge proportion of slaves were sold into the Middle East, and I assume they didn't have a huge sugar trade there.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- adrianggg 10y agoI rarely say anything is black and white in this world but sugar is in my opinion. Without any doubt in my mind. Recently in the last 3 months I gave up sugar, hard core, it's hard but the benefits are out of this world. I was healthy and active. I ate healthy, or so I thought. Boy was I wrong and mis informed. I had heard theories so I decided to check them out. I went all out to avoid sugar for a couple of weeks just to see. It was amazing. I have lost 20 pounds that I didn't think was possible, I think better, I sleep better and I eat way less. I have way more energy, like I drank 5 cups of coffee all the time. I don't fade in the afternoon. Those of you looking for a way to get more energy and focus at work, especially those working long hours in startups. I encourage you to go all out to reduce sugar intake to as little as possible. Of course eat whole fruits those are ok. Best thing I have ever done in my life. There's a saying "those on high sugar diets don't know what it feels like to be sugar free." It feels amazing. Try it. At least once in your life. You won't go back . sorry that was long :-)
- tiglionabbit 10y agoI weaned myself off sugar once too. It was hard. It took about two weeks before the intense cravings subsided, and then everything tasted sweeter. I was getting a sugar high from eating carrots. It was awesome. Later, though, I started working at tech companies that had catered food, so I didn't control my diet anymore. It's funny how much better I feel when I can choose my own diet. I think I'll make a point of avoiding sugary foods again.
- kmonsen 10y agoSo what did you actually eat? It seems like sugar is everywhere these days.
- hx87 10y agoI wonder if this has anything to do with my observation that it's ridiculously hard to find whole fat yogurt, especially whole fat Greek yogurt (!), in most grocery stores in the Boston area. Only specialist and high-end stores such as Whole Foods keep them in stock, whereas the proles get stuck with the sweetened, low-fat versions that contain up to 30 grams of sugar per serving.
- M_Grey 10y agoBoston area? Oh, I may be about to make you very happy then, especially if you like real Greek yogurt. Sophia's Greek Pantry in Belmont makes the best yogurt I've had outside of Greece. You have to enjoy a good, tangy yogurt, and it will ruin you for all other yogurts. It's best (IMO) with a little bit of good honey drizzled on top. I mean, this stuff is so thick that you can hardly shake it off the spoon, no sugar, and not too much fat; just a nice protein gel as the yogurt gods intended.
- foobarian 10y agoCounter-anecdata: I am able to find plain, whole milk yogurt pretty much at any grocery store I visit out in the Natick area (Natick + adjacent towns). Occasionally they are sold out but it's rare. I certainly don't think it is ridiculously hard.
- hx87 10y agoMaybe my observation has another plausible explanation: everyone is buying the whole fat yogurt, so they're constantly sold out! If true, brings up another question though...why do Shaw's and Stop & Shop keep stocking items that don't sell?
- NOSHSHNACKERS 10y agowal-mart has it..
- canjobear 10y agoTrader Joe's has it.
- 10y ago
- ScottBurson 10y agoThis is the kind of thing I think of when people here on HN try to convince me that glyphosate is safe. When so much money is at stake, corporations naturally try to influence the science, and unfortunately, there are plenty of poorly-paid and/or dubiously-ethical scientists in the world who will take their money. Under such circumstances I think we have to be massively skeptical of any result that aligns with the business interests in question. When public health is at stake, the burden of proof should fall very heavily on those claiming their product is safe.
- henrik_w 10y agoI thought the book "Why We Get Fat" by Gary Taubes was a pretty interesting read in the sugar vs fat debate. https://www.amazon.com/Why-We-Get-Fat-About/dp/0307474259 https://www.amazon.com/Why-We-Get-Fat-About/dp/0307474259
- partycoder 10y agoFirst of all, there is no daily recommended value on sugar because that value is 0. Then, a can of regular Coca-Cola (and most sodas) has about 38g of sugar. 38g doesn't sound like a lot, but would you take a cup of coffee with 8 teaspoons of sugar? That's what 38g is, 8 teaspoons, for a single can. Many kids drink multiple cans a day, with sugary cereals, pancakes with syrup, snacks, and adding all that up they end up consuming over 100g and end up severe obesity and diabetes.
- aiyodev 10y agoThe scientific consensus is that weight gain is caused by saturated fat. Anybody who disagrees with the consensus is anti-science and a fat-denier. Any scientists who disagree with the consensus must have being paid off by Big Fat. Even Crisco agrees that their products are the cause of Global Fattening and is working on alternatives to oil. Companies that produce saturated fat products should have to buy Fat Credits and fat skeptics should be thrown in prison! But what about all the actual scientific evidence that a low-carbohydrate high-saturated fat diet results in weight loss? Well, I never said that weight gain causes weight gain or a Global Fattening. What I said was it causes "Body Change". Body Change means eating saturated fat will make you become deathly skinny or morbidly obese or grow a tail or get cancer or contract herpes or go blind or a million other medical problems. Basically, if something is wrong with your body, it's because of Body Change. Child falls off jungle gym and breaks its leg: Body Change. Man dies of heart attack in China: Body Change. Conjoined twins: Body Change. Down's Syndrome: Body Change. Hot flashes: Body Change. Wet dream: Body Change. Body change hides under your bed at night waiting to murder you with saturated fats. Some people say that Body Change is idiotic and unscientific! I guess they believe bodies never change. What morons! /s
- mary_fortran 10y agoThe biggest problem with our health, however, is still Obesity. Just as the fat were mislead by being made to believe that "low fat == healthy" these people will be similarly think "low carb == healthy" and proceed to get obese on low-carb foods. Face it, if you're a healthy weight, by body-fat percentage, you don't have to worry about fructose vs glucose or fat vs carbs. Americans need to put their forks down. We need to start holding the overweight and the fat accountable for their expensive lifestyle choices.
- acuozzo 10y ago> We need to start holding the overweight and the fat accountable for their expensive lifestyle choices. Accountable to whom? Here's a suggestion: Mind your own business. Don't concern yourself with things that don't concern you.
- ythl 10y ago> We need to start holding the overweight and the fat accountable for their expensive lifestyle choices. Ha, that's a good one. The answer you'll get is that nobody is responsible for their expensive lifestyle choices, and everyone is a victim of the system. People are fat? Not their fault; they live in food and exercise deserts and/or are trapped in the poverty cycle where they can only afford garbage calories. What, they are middle class? Genetic, then. Their parents are fat and it takes an overwhelming amount of effort to break the cycle. The only solution is to change the system, not people. Which, unfortunately, can have adverse effects on healthy weighted people that like the current system.
- rhino369 10y agoWeight should probably be taken into account for insurance premiums. But you shouldn't single them out as the only unhealthy people in the world. Drinkers, drug users, smokers have huge impacts. People who engage in anal sex transmit a hugely disproportionate amount of STDs. Non-obese people who eat unhealthy are also a problem. "They cost us money" is often just an excuse to discriminate or control other people's lives.
- thedaemon 10y agoIt's cheaper to eat unhealthy than healthy foods in America. Only the rich or upper middle class can afford healthy food.
- deisner 10y agoThis is the definition of chutzpah: "The [sugar] association also questioned the motives behind the new paper. “Most concerning is the growing use of headline-baiting articles to trump quality scientific research,” the organization said. “We’re disappointed to see a journal of JAMA’s stature being drawn into this trend.” Yes, the dubious ethics and research quality at issue here are clearly JAMA's, and not the lobbyists' who, by their own admission, paid scientists to publish a journal article to exonerate their own industry.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoThis makes me remember the late Dr. Atkins of the "Atkins Diet" who was pretty much the laughing stock of dietitians then and now. Yet people that tried the diet have found life-long positive health impacts. I'm one of these people. I would also like to put some blame on so-called dietitians, who up until very, very recently would have warned you against a low carb diet. Every dietician I talk to is so absolutely sure about what they recommend and believe.
- alecco 10y agoFalse dichotomy. Both sugar and saturated fats are bad. Processed foods in particular. Atkins died fat and with a heart problem. An extremist but not a scientist.
- Cozumel 10y agoCan anyone recommend a 'healthy' alternative to sugar? Primarily for sweetening Coffee.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoNope :D But truth be told, I only drink black coffee. Now. I used to put lots of sugar and cream in coffee. I simply started cutting back slowly. I got rid of the cream first, and when it got to the point I was wanting less than 1 package of sugar in a McDonald's large coffee, I just stopped using it, though I could have cut down a little more. For the first week or two, the coffee seemed a bit bitter, but in the years following, it has been just fine. And much easier to order.
- asavadatti 10y agoAgave or Honey although they do impart some taste to the coffee
- terio 10y agoI wouldn't recommend any of these either. They are rich in fructose.
- zizzles 10y agoObesity as the end all be all measure of health is flawed and out-dated. The real damage is being done silently, ie. cell damage, DNA damage, telomere shortening, endocrine disruption. Visual cues may or may not be there.
- kenjackson 10y agoFrom the article I can't tell if the sugar industry hid or falsified data. There are at least two ways you can look at this. Imagine if the sugar industry thinks they are getting a bad rap about heart disease, and want to get researchers to study the link and show that they aren't to blame. Conversely, maybe they knew there was a link and were paying researchers to downplay it (or worse). I feel like this article just points out that the sugar industry funded research, but it never points to actual misinformation that resulted from it -- or did I miss it?
- truth_sentinell 10y agoThis teaches among many lessons, one in particular: We can't take anything for granted. A lot of people use research studies in arguments as it was the absolute truth. The papers can be wrong, or even true but for a narrower sample, or even worst, faked.
- grexe 10y agosee also the really well done movie "That Sugar Film" (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3892434/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3892434/) where exactly this connection is laid out in the first part.
- sethammons 10y agoIt is available on Amazon Prime last I checked. I've recommended it many times over to friends.
- bonoboTP 10y agoThe lecture "Sugar: The Bitter Truth" by Robert H. Lustig explains some details about the harmful effects of sugar: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM
- smnplk 10y agoyou sir are my hero.
- stevenwiles 10y agoplease avoid making comments like this. you do not contribute to the discussion and you embarrass yourself.
- kahrkunne 10y agoplease avoid making comments like this. you do not contribute to the discussion and you embarrass yourself
- sctb 10y agoWe detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12481745 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12481745 and marked it off-topic.
- Question1101 10y agoSo food with sugar but also a decent amount of fiber is fine? Like vegetables, certain fruit and whole grain bread? What should the fiber:sugar ratio be? Broccoli has 1.7g sugar and 2.6 fiber per 100g. Bananas have 12g sugar and 2.6g of fiber. I guess you should avoid food that goes below 1:1?
- seizethecheese 10y agoGlycemic index/load help a lot to answer these questions.
- Ericson2314 10y agoI'm American and sugar doesn't taste good; I must be very lucky.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoLet's not forget how WW2 propaganda shifted blame to sugar. Where the fictional notion of a "sugar high" was invented to connote an illicit character that will get your children that much closer to the reefer madness. All to manipulate the public into conserving sugar needed for the war effort.
- thedaemon 10y agoA sugar high is not fictional. I do in fact get a sugar high. Just ask my co-workers. I sometimes use a threat of eating a candy bar, which will make me hyper before I crash.
- caub 10y agohow to fat industry shifted blame to sugar in return
- dennisgorelik 10y agoSugar industry is guilty in that case, but let's not put all blame on them. It is the whole society that wanted to believe that mass consumption of sugar is OK.
- ievahanordah 10y agoOh wow this is a real shock. Who could have ever imagined this was actually what was going on the whole time. They totally got me here.
- nice1 10y agoThe corruption of science is much more subtle these days. This is an enlightening read: https://wattsupwiththat.com/2010/10/16/hal-lewis-my-resignation-from-the-american-physical-society/ https://wattsupwiththat.com/2010/10/16/hal-lewis-my-resignat...
- newscracker 10y agoI watched this documentary titled "That sugar film" [1] a year or so ago. It was quite an eye opener. Although I knew processed foods had a lot of sugar (like we expect sodas and colas to have), what was shocking was the amount of sugar added even in foods where you would never think of sugar as an ingredient. Of course, this varies across different geographies and cultures, but if people consuming processed foods spend some time reading the ingredients in whatever they buy and learn more about them and the proportions, it could help in bringing some changes (I realize this is a rather simplified view). We also need more education and awareness to be spread around to effect a change in people's habits. [1]: http://thatsugarfilm.com/ http://thatsugarfilm.com/
- nice1 10y agoThe corruption of science is much more subtle these days. This is an enlightening read: https://wattsupwiththat.com/2010/10/16/hal-lewis-my-resignation-from-the-american-physical-society/ https://wattsupwiththat.com/2010/10/16/hal-lewis-my-resignat...