8 ms·
Thousands of adoptees thought they were US citizens but learned they are not
- erkose 10y agoThis is just wrong. He entered the country legally. The Adoption Citizenship Act seems like the right way to handle this.
- rdtsc 10y agoIt isn't, not without an amendment it seems. These people were too old to qualify. The reason the law was that way is to prevent loopholes like someone adopting a 30 year old person and then using this law to naturalize them.
- erkose 10y agoIf he was entitled to citizenship at the time of his adoption, and his adoptive parents failed to file the paperwork, then he should be entitled to citizenship regardless of his age. There are certainly many ways to abuse the system, but I prefer to err on the side of good faith.
- rdtsc 10y ago> but I prefer to err on the side of good faith. Usually though good faith and bureaucracy don't mix. It is dangerous to have faith in bureaucracy. In a way that is what the parents did, how the girl at the end said her parent just believed common sense would prevail and even if there is a missing paper here and there, someone sitting across the desk will understand and fix the error eventually.
- ap3 10y agoNo reason not to pass the adoption citizenship act.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIf they become citizens, they can vote. They might be likely as a whole to vote for or against things that bother certain groups in Congress. That by itself will be a reason for those parties to prevent them from being citizens. We see the same thing with the islanders. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CesHr99ezWE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CesHr99ezWE
- toomanybeersies 10y agoHow many people would become citizens under this law though? I doubt it would be a significant amount in terms of voting in or out certain politicians.
- stcredzero 10y agoThat's simply putting political gamesmanship over humanity, in the most inhumane way imaginable!
- drdeadringer 10y agoSounds like a perfect job for Congress. More at 11, here on Fox.
- linkregister 10y agoI disagree with using "Congress" as a euphemism for the political party one is in opposition to. Clearly a majority of Americans believe in their own senators and representatives. It's the "other guys" who are bad. Call a spade a spade.
- drdeadringer 10y agoI was using the word "Congress" as I intended, which was to refer to Congress as a whole.
- ivanca 10y agoAmericans killed all the natives, then they killed all the Mexicans in California (ok "expulsed" some). And now everyone must believe they are the good ones and kicking Latinos is the right thing. You know what, fuck you, prove you are different than ISIS, prove you are rightfully the world police .
- letsdotnet 10y ago>Americans killed all the natives, then they killed all the Mexicans in California That's long time ago. The mind set and cultures were different back then. If you want to use history as some sort of mockery or prove a point. Every countries/citizens in the world can be blamed for something.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoWhat? It's not even accurate. All as a substitute for some?
- letsdotnet 10y agoWhat are you talking about?
- protomyth 10y agoI'm pretty sure all the natives weren't killed as I talked to my father today which constitutes proof of the falsity of the statement.
- thrden 10y agoActually the treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo extended citizenship to the formerly Mexican citizens of California at the end of the Mexican-American war, 90% accepted this offer. Legally the United States considered individuals of Mexican heritage, "white". America certainly has a difficult history, however it is incredibly misleading to say that they killed all the Mexicans in California. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Guadalupe_Hidalgo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Guadalupe_Hidalgo
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoI want to help this guy but I have to ask....how did the parents just "forget" to get his citizenship complete????
- taspeotis 10y ago“There wasn’t a lot of education to adoptive parents in the earlier time about naturalizing their children or even what papers to keep, said Kessel, whose organization is helping push for bills in the House and Senate.
- DanBC 10y agoImmigration is complex enough that there are lawyers who specialise in immigration law. Most people can't afford immigration lawyers. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11972135 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11972135
- Flimm 10y agoSome of these people had US passports. US passports! If I had a US passport it would not cross my mind that I was not a US citizen and that I needed to do even more paperwork.
- nylsaar 10y agoJustin Ki Hong just needs run for president. Problem solved.
- rdtsc 10y agoI thought an executive decision is all it's needed but apparently not. Interestingly, there is a special law to expedite naturalization for those who "made an extraordinary contribution to the national security of the United States or to the conduct of United States intelligence activities". But even there it's a 5 person per year maximum. https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/USCODE-2011-title8/html/USCODE-2011-title8-chap12-subchapIII-partII-sec1427.htm https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/USCODE-2011-title8/html/USCODE... Congress can change the laws obviously, wonder what the turnaround there could be.
- khuey 10y agoThat provision is presumably for "this guy told us where to find Bin Laden/Edward Snowden/Satoshi Nakamoto" level activities.
- rdtsc 10y agoI was wondering why they need a quick citizenship and why a green card wouldn't be sufficient. Guessing could be in case of defectors maybe their original country would revoke their citizenship or at least their passport. So they might be left for years in kind of a limbo.
- rcthompson 10y agoThat sounds like a law written decades ago as a lure for high-value defectors from the USSR during the Cold War.
- jacquesm 10y agoMore likely: those brought over from Nazi Germany to help with rocketry.
- drinchev 10y agoI know a girl that had to leave the U.S. >24< years after her parents brought her there ( she was a baby ). The story ( as far as I can remember ) is that a family of Germans moved to the U.S. with their 1 year old child. 24 years later the child graduated university and ... needs to apply for a green card or permanent VISA. US government refused, so she had to come back to Germany. I've never understood why U.S. is so protective in terms of citizenship. In most of the EU countries you get naturalized ( receive citizenship ) if you spend certain amount of time in the country and pass a test ( Germany I think it's 7 yrs ).
- nickff 10y agoThe USA does have similar rules, but there are some restrictions based on what you can prove, and your status upon entry.
- 8611m 10y agoWhat are these rules that you refer to? I know a lot of people who could benefit from such rules having come to the United States legally and spending 10 years and has to leave because their visas were expiring.
- nickff 10y agoI am not too familiar with the details, but the government website is informative, as is the Wikipedia article.[1][2] [1] https://www.uscis.gov/us-citizenship/citizenship-through-naturalization/continuous-residence-and-physical-presence-requirements-naturalization https://www.uscis.gov/us-citizenship/citizenship-through-nat... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalization#.C2.A0United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalization#.C2.A0United_St...
- justinlardinois 10y agoIn the US you can begin the naturalization process after five years of permanent residency. A green card is what establishes permanent residency. (I don't think we have permanent visas, but I could be wrong.) I can only speculate how your friend was allowed to live in this country that long without ever obtaining permanent residency, but regardless, it's an example of the system failing, and that's a really terrible thing to happen to someone.
- jzwinck 10y agoThe more bizarre part is how the various federal agencies do not coordinate. For example, the "fear they will be unable to collect Social Security benefits they have paid into." This means these people are paying taxes to the IRS who collects SS money from them yet they are "not eligible" to work in the US. This is "impossible" but the tax man doesn't ask questions when people send him money. I think if someone has paid, say, 20% of their total lifetime earnings, with a minimum of $50K over ten years, in taxes to the US government, and they have not committed any crime, they should be given citizenship. This gives the USG ten years to find anyone they'd rather not have in the country, and let them leave before they contribute more than their fair share to a country that rejects them.
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoI like the idea, but it firstly makes "purchasing citizenship" a thing (as if it is not already) and it has an underlying principle that is more useful - if you spend ten years openly in a country and are not a criminal, then you get to stay, which is a much better principle.
- puranjay 10y agoThe problem with that is that it penalizes legal residents waiting for their citizenship My brother has been in the US for nearly 20 years. Started out as a grad student, then as a H1-B. Took him more than 10 years just to get a green card, then 5 years more to be eligible for citizenship. All this while, he must have paid several hundred thousand dollars in taxes (6+ figure income over 15 years) Why should another immigrant get the same benefits as him faster than he could by paying even less in taxes?
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoThe most curious instance I've heard of this was a man who came in as a young child and joined the Army (perfectly legal for non-citizens). While in the service he was an MP and then took a job as a police officer after finishing his service. The problem came that without citizenship he couldn't legally work as a LEO and all of his arrests were technically invalid. As an MP, though, he was working under the exclusive authority of the executive and no such conflict was present.
- lisper 10y agoWhat was most shocking to me was that some of these kids managed to get U.S. passports without being citizens. How does that happen? I'm a first generation immigrant. My parents were naturalized when I was 10. AFAIK that means that I automatically acquired their naturalization. But I do not have a naturalization certificate of my own, and I don't have a copy of my parents certificate. I do hold a U.S. passport, but that is apparently not ironclad proof of citizenship. I'm frankly not sure what I would do if Trump gets elected and the brown shirts show up no my doorstep to haul my ass back to Germany because my passport is invalid. Ironically, my situation is a little less tenuous because I am the biological child of naturalized immigrants rather than the adopted child of natural-born citizens. Like so many things about this story, that seems so wrong.
- epicureanideal 10y agoReally? Trump and the brown shirts? Do we need to compare everybody to Hitler? I read an article recently that says he's more of an American version of Italy's Berlusconi, and that seems more reasonable to me.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoI know the inexorable pull of Godwins Law, but this is a reasonable fear - Trump is standing at the top of a slippery slope, Berlusconi is further down the same slope, and the history of the 20th C shows where the slope goes. Putting up warning signs, even contentious ones, at the top of the slope is reasonable. (I read the same article and it is worth noting that a decade ago, every Italian I spoke to began conversations with "I am sorry about Berlusconi ...") I am not advocating ignoring all discussion of issues raised by Trump or (trumping?!) all his issues with the Nazi card, but it is a part of his background and appeal and should be calmly assessed along with other issues of protectionism, labor rights and more.
- panic 10y agoThis Wednesday he literally promised to create a "deportation force". The comparison isn't too far off.
- pash 10y agoThe legal history of the concept of citizenship in the United States is remarkably circuitous. The original text of the constitution referred only to citizens of individual states, never to citizens of the United States. Consequently, federal law and jurisprudence lacked any conception of national citizenship until the decision of Dred Scott v. Sanford in 1856, in which Chief Justice Roger B. Taney created the concept from whole cloth for the purpose of declaring Scott, a slave, not to be an American citizen and therefore not entitled to petition a federal court. The precedent held until the constitutional amendments of Reconstruction rectified it, explicitly introducing the concept of national citizenship into the constitution as a side effect. There has remained a great deal of ambiguity about who is entitled to American citizenship by birth. Although the constitution as amended grants certain rights only to national citizens, the amendments that made national citizenship a part of the constitution failed to describe comprehensively who is entitled to citizenship. As a consequence, the question of who is and who is not a citizen, rather than being been decided on constitutional grounds, has been left to Congress. The odd result is that ordinary federal law, not the constitution itself, decides who is entitled to many fundamental constitutional rights and protections, including the basic rights to live in the United States and vote in national elections. An interesting series of changes to the federal laws governing national citizenship occurred in the years after World War II. Because thousands of American soldiers and sailors were for the first time being permanently stationed abroad, there arose the question of whether their children born abroad had a right to citizenship. Federal law had previously granted citizenship to all children of American citizens, but during this period the laws were re-written to exclude the illegitimate children of military men with foreign women from citizenship in most cases. Today the law deciding the citizenship of children born abroad to a single American parent is a tangle of considerations of the marital status of the parents, when the child first visits American territory, how long he or she stays, etc. I've sometimes wondered what the world might have been like in another several generations if those exclusions hadn't been made; by that time, due to the wonders of sexual reproduction, it's likely that tens or hundreds of millions of people outside the United States would be able to find an American in their ancestry, and therefore to claim American citizenship. Eventually, almost everyone would be an American. What would the world be like if everyone were entitled to vote in American elections (and obligated to pay American taxes)?