16 ms·
Termination of YouTube Service on 2012 BRAVIA TVs
- niftich 10y agoAs far as failure modes go, so far so good -- the 'smart' TV will still work, it'll just have one less app. Eventually, as more and more apps raise their minimum requirements (either by necessity or just because), the older hardware will no longer cut it; but the TV will keep working as a display. The problem will come when the smart TV's OS itself is no longer getting patches. --- Are there any details on what Google changed?
- qq66 10y agoThe "Smart TV" is like those "all-in-one desktop PCs" -- unless you really prioritize the appearance of the thing, like in an architect's office where clients are visiting, etc. -- it almost never makes sense. The display stays good for a decade and the compute is often obsolete in 12 months -- it makes no sense to bundle them. I have a overheating iMac whose compute I wish I could switch out.
- rconti 10y agoThe difference is, you sacrifice almost nothing (save a few dollars) to have the Smart TV gubbins inside. The TV still works great as a display -- in fact, my new Smart TV has more inputs and other such non-Smart-TV features than my old Dumb TV did. Also, I call BS on being obsolete in 12 months. My mom wanted to buy a 20" iMac back in ~2009, and I was hesitant to go along with it, as I felt the same way as you did. Then I realized computers last longer and longer these days, and are approaching display level lifespan. She's still using that iMac today, and it works great. And guess what, I bought a 5k 27" iMac to replace my 10 year old Mac Pro (which has a high-end-for-its-time 24" Dell 2407WFP connected to it). The reality is, by the time the computer was too old to be particularly useful, a 1080p 24" display was old hat as well. I don't disagree it makes the disposable culture a bit worse; I'm not particularly likely to try to repair the iMac after a couple of years (which is one reason I sprung for an extended warranty on it which I typically avoid like the plague), but it's not so bad as you suggest. And, of course, the machine can still be used as an external display (or output to another display if it's the display that fails instead of the computer). Perhaps your strongest argument should be that Smart TVs may accelerate the decline of standalone streamers. If that comes to pass, TVs may come to look a bit more like the all-in-one computer world. But for now I'll enjoy my 4k streaming on my Smart TV apps, and replace those functions with standalone devices that do it better, as they come on the market. They're not there yet, though, and I'm not about to throw out all of my other devices and replace them just because I bought a new TV.
- jimjimjim 10y agoYet another reason why the internet of things will be truly appalling.
- Pengwin 10y agoIt seems like a dream come true when you're in the business of people buying new iterations of the same thing, Which seems to be all SoCs and embedded systems providers these days.
- ghaff 10y agoI get why the TV manufacturers don't like the concept but TVs should really be dumb displays. Using something like a ChromeCast to get content to the TV makes so much more sense than embedding "intelligence" in a display. It's the same mismatch of lifecycles that you get with entertainment (and navigation) electronics in cars.
- simplexion 10y agoI agree with this. There was a time where smart TVs were useful but it is dying out. The other big issue with Smart TVs is they try to put the lowest powered SoC in that they can and tiny amounts of RAM. They should all just be monitors now. The cost of a Chromecast, Raspberry Pi, or Apple TV is so low that it makes Smart TVs redundant. I actually don't understand why these manufacturers haven't moved to making their own versions of casting/streaming devices. I remember when I bought my Bravia a long time ago it didn't come with WiFi but you could buy their wireless USB device for AUD$80 (they blocked all others). Why don't they do that but instead a Chromecast like device (without blocking out 3rd parties)?
- dogma1138 10y ago>They should all just be monitors now. The cost of a Chromecast, Raspberry Pi, or Apple TV is so low that it makes Smart TVs redundant. I actually don't understand why these manufacturers haven't moved to making their own versions of casting/streaming devices. The vast majority of TV viewers do not use and do not even understand how to use these devices. Chromecast/Firestick is at least somewhat usable to the masses, some of the other streamers are more complicated but do you really expect some random person to buy and build a RasPi streaming set top box? The TV makers can't take out features because people would not buy that TV, people want features, and these features are what the guy at the store can sell TV's by. And for Samsung/Sony and the likes to get into the streamer business it's pointless, and it would not change the issue it would just move it to another component albit considerably cheaper one. Streaming devices also need to be constantly updated, many of them need to be updated more often than the TV their SoC's get obsolete just as fast if not faster and YouTube can make changes tomorrow that would make the current version of Chromecast incompatible as well. If you are an Advanced user you don't care for all that crap, my best TV still by far is now what a 7-8 year old Toshiba 42" with a 10 bit panel which was actually made in Germany, dumb as you can get (it can show images, play MP3, maybe some MPEG) it has a PCMCIA slot which I used to hack into it and the image quality is still better than virtually every TV out there that doesn't cost 1500 GBP. But I can use it because I'm an "advanced" user I run my own streaming and transcoding server and have a media center PC. But for some one who wants a no hassle turn on TV and get netflix this isn't really an option, even Chromecast isn't very ideal quality isn't that great and it can lag pretty badly on congested networks. The more expensive streamers give you quality that matches the TV native app but they also tend to cost considerably more than the cheap sticks, unless you buy the Android unbranded chinese SoC sticks.
- dcw303 10y agothere are trade offs all the way along the convenience spectrum. If you're reading HN, you're probably not in the target market for youtube apps embedded in smart tvs. But these customers do exist. I imagine the main selling point is they don't have to connect or configure any external set top box or media pc, and they don't have to install or maintain the app. If you don't have the skills (or the time) to do so, this may be appealing. The polar opposite would be a Linux expert running their own media center - absolute control but at the cost of said time and skills.
- niftich 10y agoI am skeptical of smart TVs and smart fridges and the like, but I like having an embedded Netflix/Youtube app because it's not harming me any -- provided the UI is snappy, the UX is good, the TV isn't spying on my pixels -cough- Vizio -cough-, and it doesn't go away like it did here. I know these are generous assumptions, but if it saves me from having to Bring My Own Streaming Stick and I have no particular brand loyalty and/or ecosystem investment like AppleTV, Amazon, Google Play Store, PlayStation Store, then fine. It's only harmful when it doesn't work as intended, of when my 'smart' TV is so obsolete that it's no longer functional as a 'dumb' TV. The problem is every TV manufacturer suddenly pulled a Windows 10 and thought to themselves: "Everyone already has our products in their homes, why don't we try to monetize this further? Otherwise we'll never beat Google and Apple!" So they're all trying to build 'platforms' and 'ecosystems' and the like, which is terrible value for the person who doesn't want to re-buy the same DRM'ed movie on four different platforms. Luckily, more and more of these homegrown smart TV platforms are dying out in favor of Android/Google TV (whatever they keep renaming it to), Roku's licensed software, and Sony's PlayStation ecosystem.
- justinlardinois 10y ago> I like having an embedded Netflix/Youtube app because it's not harming me any -- provided the UI is snappy, the UX is good People have been putting up with digital cable's crappy on demand menus for a decade, so I imagine they'll tolerate the chunkiness that smart TV apps usually have.
- 10y ago
- Animats 10y agoWhat, it can't decode HTML5 video? What does YouTube need that the device doesn't have?
- phantomathkg 10y agoMost likely because the browsers on older generation of smart TVs does not have the capability to work with MSE/EME.
- 0x0 10y agoIs there a chance to get a full refund and return a device in general when something like this happens? Some countries have pretty hefty consumer protection laws
- giarc 10y agoAs an owner of a Sony Bravia "smart TV" I'm not surprised to see this. I tried using the features but they were very slow and never seemed to work properly. It was hard enough to keep it connected to my wifi with the $80 wifi dongle I bought. My new Apple TV is so worth the money.
- niftich 10y agoPotentially related: Youtube updated their TOS [1][2] and posted additional documents that developers need to adhere to [3][4]. These take effect February 10, 2017, but were posted in advance on August 11, 2016. HN submission: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12409825 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12409825 [1] https://youtube-eng.blogspot.com/2016/08/an-updated-terms-of-service-and-new.html https://youtube-eng.blogspot.com/2016/08/an-updated-terms-of... [2] https://developers.google.com/youtube/terms/api-services-terms-of-service https://developers.google.com/youtube/terms/api-services-ter... [3] https://developers.google.com/youtube/terms/developer-policies https://developers.google.com/youtube/terms/developer-polici... [4] https://developers.google.com/youtube/terms/required-minimum-functionality https://developers.google.com/youtube/terms/required-minimum...
- wmf 10y agoFor everyone saying "just use Chromecast", note that Vizio now sells that: https://www.vizio.com/m-series https://www.vizio.com/m-series It's flaky, but I don't know if it's more or less flaky than smart TVs.
- azurelogic 10y agoI have one of the affected TVs and I don't think that I have ever used the YouTube app on it. This is primarily because it has always been hooked up to something smarter: a computer, game console, or Apple TV. The interfaces on smart TVs of that era were abysmal. Now that all of the modern boxes and TVs have voice search and everything, I can't imagine there are too many people who are extremely heartbroken over this. Especially when you look at the price of a Roku or FireStick.
- jwatte 10y agoInternet of bricks!
- mikeryan 10y agoI have a company that has built a lot of smart tv apps. I can say that the Sony TVs have consistently been the least performing of the bunch. We don't support most 2012 TVs anymore and that's on more solid TVs like Samsung and LG. This is a pretty natural evolution it's hugely painful to support legacy TVs right now and 2012 is about where they're becoming too old and underpowered.
- scurvy 10y agoI realize it's quite fashionable to bash "smart TV's" in this thread, but I've got a Sony 2016 Bravia and love it. It runs Android TV and has the usual stuff via Android app store (Netflix, Plex, etc). It has built-in chromecast support, too. Everything is nice and responsive; no complaints. The HDMI CEC supports works well, so I can do everything from 1 remote.
- rspeer 10y agoBut will you still love it in 2020? Home electronics used to last longer than this.
- voltagex_ 10y agoThe first TV I remember at my parents' place was thrown out after twenty years. The first TV I bought for my place (admittedly for $999AUD) was thrown out after 5 years - ironically because I wanted a "smart" feature, HDMI CEC. I'm now using a second hand Sony TV that just barely supports the HDMI CEC features I need - enough for it to be driven by a Raspberry Pi, at least. Our electronics don't last as long but we ask a lot more of them.
- scurvy 10y agoConsidering that it replaced a TV from 2005, I'd wager yes. 4K will probably be the last big consumer TV tech push until we get cybernetic implants for eyes. You can't see a difference from 4K to 8K at under 100" screen sizes.
- 4ad 10y ago> Everything is nice and responsive; no complaints. My parents-in-law have the same TV. The UI is the most frustrating UI I ever had to use. Please give me back the dumb 1-level-deep dumb UI. Apart from how hard is to actually do anything (because the Android crap just gets in the way), everything is so slow and takes forever. There's so much lag in everything. So much time until the damn app that I need starts. So much time until the damn thing boots. With the previous TV, it took less than half a second to change inputs. Everything was smooth and responsive. Now it takes about 10 seconds, and it's 10 very, very frustrating seconds. Plus, the worst of all, audio and video are not synchronised on this TV. How can it have such a basic problem, I can't explain. By turning image processing and all that crap off (as much as possible), A/V sync has gotten better, but it's still noticeable to me, and, very, very, very annoying. So I split A/V signal, and route the digital audio through a box that delays it as much as the TV delays the image, so I can get them in sync. But depending on the load on the TV, the delay is not constant. It changes during the movie. It's the most frustrating piece of equipment I ever laid hands on.
- forgottenacc56 10y agoTV software is so deeply ordinary. It's a massive missed opportunity, but TV manufacturers just don't "get" software.
- faragon 10y ago"The symptoms being experienced are not a failure of the TV, but are as a result of specification changes made by YouTube that exceed the capability of the TV’s hardware." Which changes? YouTube still streams H.264, and I can not believe that those TVs can not run properly the glue-code scripting, e.g. doing a check of "if old TV, then, use less fancy things". So as others comment here, it looks like an excuse.
- timcederman 10y agoLikely software to support ads that they didn't want to write code for.
- acd 10y agoRichard stallman started the GNU project because he was not allowed to modify closed source printer drivers. https://www.talisman.org/~erlkonig/misc/free-as-in-freedom-r-stallmans-crusade.pdf https://www.talisman.org/~erlkonig/misc/free-as-in-freedom-r... It would be better for the environment if consumer devices had open source so end users can fix software issues. Reason being end users care about their devices longer than device manufacturers do. In the meantime a Chromecast dongle will fix the TVs. Imagine your future TV booting Debian/Ubuntu from an open boot loader via standard micro SD-card.
- sleepychu 10y agoYeah I can imagine it being exactly like every linux machine I've ever used (stable but vulnerable or needing some techno-fu to persuade it to boot back up again after I ran apt-get upgrade and it didn't quite do what it meant to for my hardware).
- Freak_NL 10y agoIt would be nice, but in the end you gain more flexibility by building a HTPC with the hardware you want and treat the TV as a dumb screen that can receive input from HDMI, DVB-T and DVB-C.
- acd 10y agoTrue thanks, a htpc would be more long lived.
- cletus 10y agoTo me "smart TV" means "we're going to interrupt you randomly to tell you the privacy policy or the T&Cs on something you never use have changed". The best thing you can do for your TV is not connect it to the Internet. Get a Roku box or similar for all your streaming needs.
- douche 10y agoSigh. I kind of miss the old, heavy, dumb-as-rocks TV I grew up with. It turned on instantly. Switching channels was instantaneous - none of this five second Comcast delay - although you did have to get up and punch the physical buttons on the cable tuner[1]. I don't think it even had coaxial input; I remember there were two leads[2] that were held on with a couple screws, so if the picture got snowy, you'd jiggle the wires around to get a better connection. edit: footnotes [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/95/Push_button_cable_box.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/95/Push_but... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin-lead https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin-lead
- torrent-of-ions 10y agoI really don't understand how TVs are so bad. You can spend thousands of pounds on one and the interface will be incredibly slow, buggy and take ages to change channels. A £5 raspberry pi is capable of running a faster interface and my old DVB-t cards for PCs were able to switch muxes almost instantly. What is so difficult about putting this capability inside a television?
- 9point6 10y agoBecause it's rare for hardware manufacturers to be good at software and also that those hardware manufacturers don't want to spend to license something better that 95% of their customers wouldn't really care about. To be fair in the current situation, it's not worth buying a TV for it's smart capabilities because they'll rapidly fall out of date. It makes more sense to buy something like the Nvidia Shield which can be swapped out without replacing the panel should it be needed
- c3833174 10y agoEven a cheap external digital tuner has a more features and a more usable interface than (dumb) TVs with builtin tuner. Samsung TV (2010): takes longer than a CRT to "warm up", remote died within 4years Sony TV (2008): half the screen gets covered by program info popup for some seconds every time some decoding error happens, remote died within 4years Telefunken TV (early 90's) + external tuner: original remote still works, screen turns on automatically when decoder is turned on and it also has built-in DVR and tetris