19 ms·
Massachusetts to tax ride-hailing apps, give the money to taxis
- rev_bird 10y agoThis is a pretty surreal move: >The law says the money will help taxi businesses to adopt "new technologies and advanced service, safety and operational capabilities" and to support workforce development... [Larry Meister, manager of the Boston area's Independent Taxi Operator's Association] said the money could go toward improving a smartphone app his association has started using, or to other big needs. I'm not an anti-regulation guy most of the time, but this doesn't even seem like regulation -- they're literally giving money to a fading industry because they are incapable of keeping up. I don't want to see cab drivers turn into homeless drifters, but this just seems wrong. Making a more efficient competitor pay to help taxi companies make their service better? The whole reason these companies exist is because taxi companies have been utter garbage for years and got the government to elbow out competitors. Am I missing something? Surely the burden for "do things better and buy nicer equipment" falls on the taxi companies, not the other organizations that are embarrassing them.
- AndyNemmity 10y agoCab drivers don't become homeless drifters, they become your next lyft pick up. And the quality of service of Lyft and Uber have gone down the more and more cab drivers become drivers. It's starting to not feel like much of differentiation.
- emodendroket 10y ago> Cab drivers don't become homeless drifters, they become your next lyft pick up. Yeah, at significantly lower wages.
- AndyNemmity 10y agoHow much lower? Has anyone done an analysis of the difference in pay, given any requirements to pay the cab company, pay for a gold star, etc. Does a standard cabbie make significantly more than a standard lyft driver? Cabs are certainly far more rundown generally when I take them than lyft vehicles. People seem "better off" driving lyft, but it may not be their main source of employment. So it would be cool to see a real breakdown done.
- emodendroket 10y agoUber did an analysis that they claimed showed Uber pay was better, but they didn't take into account or share data about costs the driver is stuck with in Uber that they wouldn't be in a cab: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/01/22/uber-drivers-pay-study_n_6527470.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/01/22/uber-drivers-pay-st...
- RyJones 10y agoYes. I got a nice lecture from a cab driver who was moonlighting driving Lyft about how I was destroying taxis using Lyft. Yes, I am, the faster the better. To hell with taxis.
- civilian 10y agoI don't think that's the case? My worst drivers are usually people who just don't have experience driving. They drive slow, they don't know the city, or they get confused other ways. Or they're just timid and don't know how to take a right on red. I'd much prefer a cabbie who's in an Uber. But I'm also someone who judiciously gives people lower stars. The rating system works for us! People just need to be willing to give 1-stars and file reports.
- tao_oat 10y agoThey become your next lyft pick up (with drastically decreased wages).
- taneq 10y agoThe right thing for the government to do would be to either deliver on their promise of an artificially scarce market (which they made when they instituted the taxi medallion system) by cracking down on unlicensed operators, or to buy the licenses back off the licensed taxis and then abolish the system and free up the market. What they're currently doing is like if a shopping mall charged resident shops a hefty fee, but allowed hawkers to set up next door for free, allowing them to sell the same goods for far less.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoHmm: - an industry wants to operate as cartel, - but it can't police defectors charging market prices, - so it gets the government to enforce the cartel, - and calls this "regulation" even though it gouges, rather than protects the public. And somehow it is unfair if this gets undermined by events? To take your mall-and-hawkers example, what exactly is wrong with that situation? In practice it doesn't happen very often because no one is going to give the hawkers space for free. But if the mall rents were high because the builder bribed the council to keep competition far away, well that's their own fault.
- rhino369 10y agoThat's not how taxi medallions came into existence. Cities began to regulate taxis. They set prices, made safety regulations, made it so taxis couldn't refuse service. In exchange taxis were licensed to ensure the prices the city set supported a fleet of taxis. It's hilarious that Uber a billion dollar corporation portrays a bunch of Muslim or African immigrants as rich fat cats. Just lol
- emodendroket 10y agoWhat can you say? They've got good PR folks and well-connected political hires.
- rayiner 10y agoWhat's particularly fantastic is that they can maintain this PR shtick in the face of the fact that the thing that makes uber possible--surge pricing--is exactly the kind of "gouging" government-regulated rates we're designed to prevent. "Oh, it's raining? Well that's going to cost extra!"
- acidburnNSA 10y agoI mostly agree with you, and I would have wholeheartedly agreed with you 2 weeks ago, but I just read a book ("Listen, Liberal" by Thomas Frank) that makes some interesting points about how liberals have shifted from representing working people to representing professionals, and to worshiping innovation. While free trade and disruptive technology is good for the professional class, it inherently increases inequality. Frank argues that after the liberal shift, "everyone" now agrees to these pro-business, pro-Wall Street policies, but we don't have to allow rapid disruption freely. We could do what Massachusetts is doing. We could have tariffs and bring manufacturing back. Policy can prevent the inevitable. I learned about the book while vigorously researching Trump's rise to popularity during the primaries. I personally can't wait for self-driving cars, etc., but I think someone needs to be thinking of the swaths of working people who are afraid of losing their jobs. I know lots of working people. Many of them don't want to go back to school or get technical training. Many of them don't want to start the next big company. They just want to work their job and go hang out with their family. What do we tell the taxi and truck drivers when Uber shows up with self-drivers, etc.? I'm new to this line of thinking myself and I know there are lots of counterarguments. I just find it worth a ponder.
- AndyNemmity 10y agoSounds like a pop style rewrite of what Noam Chomsky has been saying for eternity. Except less well cited, and accurate as Chomsky's work is. An excerpt if anyone is interested like I was, http://harpers.org/blog/2016/02/nor-a-lender-be/ http://harpers.org/blog/2016/02/nor-a-lender-be/
- maverick_iceman 10y agoHmm, if liberals are so pro-business then why Bernie has so many fans?
- toomuchtodo 10y agoBecause he's a democratic socialist? I love tech as much as the next person, but disrupting wide swaths of the country's working populace and drastically increasing income inequality and increasing unemployment in an unsustainable manner, due to the leverage tech provides, and we step in with laws to override the marketplace. A government exists for all its citizens, after all. No man is an island.
- 0xFFC 10y ago> I don't want to see cab drivers turn into homeless drifters This is wrong. This is exactly how they want you to think. Cab drivers are not going to become homeless or jobless, they will work(drive) for a new companies(I agree if market is healthy enough, which is not).But they frame the issue kind of like "losing job" and "becoming homeless" just because they don't want to change. (I said cab drivers because it is what we talk. Other sectors are the same) P.S. when it comes to education and health and natural environment, I am 100% pro regulation and government interference(kind of like I am firm communist in those three categories). But other than those three I am 100% percent for free market, and I believe invisible hand will get the job done.
- dsacco 10y agoIt doesn't make sense to say, "Except for [subset of policy a], I am 100% in favor of [policy a], but for [subset of policy a] I am 100% in favor of [policy b]." That's like saying, "Except for my student loans, I am 100% debt free." It muddles your point. Just a nit.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 10y agoIt makes sense to me. Try something more like "I don't think people should get into debt, except for student loans". They support policy A for some markets, and policy B for other markets. That's not muddled.
- dsacco 10y agoThis is exactly my point. There is no reason to use an arbitrary percentage. More to the point, if you're "100% for something, except for [whatever]", you're simply not 100% for that thing. Why even use a percentage at that point, let alone 100%? It's just involving numbers with no purpose.
- 10y ago
- ben_jones 10y agoThe counter point I think is that if the persistence of a fading industry is in the public interest, then it is within the government's rights to give tax payer money to them. The only corollary I can immediately draw is the Detroit auto industry in 2008/2009 which was kept alive by bailouts despite the fact that it was not able to compete in the global market. I don't know if added competition by taxi companies is in the public interest, but it might be.
- tomp 10y agoIt definitely is in public iterest. You can't haul Uber when your phone's dead or your bank won't give you a credit card.
- dpeterson 10y agoI know most people hate Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged here but that is literally what happened in the book. Roark Steel was made to give "green steel" to the unprofitable competitors to keep them in business.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoAh, you're confusing Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged. Roark is an architect in Fountainhead. What you have in mind is Rearden Steel giving money to Associated Steel of Orren Boyle. But I agree, the current situation is eerily similar.
- xg15 10y agoI'd agree with you on any other case. But it seems to me a big part of Uber's "innovation" was circumventing the taxi regulations - which were protecting the taxi business, yes, but also giving protection to customers and individual drivers. With that I can kinda understand there is an interest to keep taxis alive.
- emodendroket 10y agoUber and Lyft supported the bill because they got a bunch of other stuff they wanted; it seems weird to me that all the sudden I'm seeing a bunch of stories downplaying what seems to be a rather pertinent fact here.
- mirekrusin 10y agoBy the time they are going to "improve their app" uber is going to be running self driving cars.
- empath75 10y agoThis is one reason why we need basic income, to protect people who get 'innovated' out of work through no real fault of their own. So we don't have to subsidize failing businesses just to protect workers. This is not something that's just going to go away if we bury our heads in the sand.
- empath75 10y agoThis is one reason why we need basic income, to protect people who get 'innovated' out of work through no real fault of their own. So we don't have to subsidize failing businesses just to protect workers. This is not something that's just going to go away if we bury our heads in the sand.
- sebastianconcpt 10y agoTotally agree. The only part I think you are missing is the part in which one stops being accepting on regulation because always ends in some form of distortion to what's best. Taxi drivers need to become one of the providers of these new services and things wil go well
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThere aren't enough of them. And regulation limits the number, solely so they can profit more. No way is the taxi industry going to 'go well' with a little more automation. Well, not for the public anyway.
- sebastianconcpt 10y agoReading your commend made me thing that state regulations is like parents not letting kids solve its own problems.
- shiven 10y agoIt's the same darn argument as was used against the automobile when it started replacing horse drawn carriages (buggies) as the dominant mode of transport. "Oh, but think of the poor buggy horsewhip-makers! They will be deprived of their livelihood." Guess what? They adapted to the new reality and here we are, rehashing the age old argument for populist/crony politics. Change is always hard, sometimes unforgivingly so, but in the end, you adapt and survive or you perish (however that is defined). As a bleeding heart liberal humanist, I feel for the poor folks who will be put out of their current livelihood. But the societal answer to that cannot be the continuation of the status quo. If we, as a society, feel the need to help people in such situations, we need to find them alternatives that enable them to transition into the brave/merciless new world, rather than keep their current job on the socially funded ventilator, just because. Most importantly, I'd rather support the decentralization of taxi companies, i.e. turn them into car rental companies for free-agent drivers who then use them to pick up fares using uber/lyft/whatever. The taxi system is a bloody mess and some real competition will help clean out the systematic cruft that has accumulated over time. So yes, take money from uber/lyft, but NOT to support the rent-collecting taxi company owners. Better yet, use the money to give short-term loans to people who'd rather buy a car to drive as a ride-share cab.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoActually some of those buggy-whip makes just died of starvation. Folks used to fight hard against mechanization (the word Sabotage is said to originate when workers in Japan hurled their wooden shoes called 'Sabo' into the looms to break them) because their fate was starvation and death.
- randallsquared 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabotage#Etymology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabotage#Etymology
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThanks! The final definition in that article, "In Japanese, the verb saboru (サボる) means to skip school or loaf on the job." may be closer to the real origin.
- fsloth 10y agoWhile this does sound odd to say the least - the government regulates everything. I see no reason why they should not be able to regulate the speed of technical innovation. For instance, if government had regulated financial innovation more vigorously 2008 might have gone differently. What's sensible in the long term is a different thing of course. And, there is the strong history where regulations supports too much entrenched industries.
- rayiner 10y agoIt's not so simple. Taxis were granted a monopoly in order to serve as an extension of cities' public transit. In return, they lost the autonomy of a normal business. They can't set their own rates. The government sets rates. They aren't allowed to use surge pricing to match supply and demand. Indeed, in many cases they're not allowed to use a GPS-based method to compute the fare, which increases the difficulty of implementing an app. This level of intrusion into a private sector business would be inconceivable today, post-Reagan. But taxi regulations were implemented at a time when this sort of thing was standard practice. So you've got all these people who invested into these businesses with these regulations on the explicit promise the government would protect them from competition. Taxis are upset about having to compete because the whole deal was they would not have to, in return for regulated rates. But heavy regulation destroyed any possibility of innovation in the taxi industry. So you have to let ride sharing operate to move forward. But what do you just reneg on the promise to taxis? I don't think taxing ride-sharing is an ideal solution. I'd prefer the state to just buy out the monopolies using general tax dollars. But it's not totally out on left field if you keep in mind the state isn't free to draw on a blank slate here.
- rev_bird 10y agoI wasn't expecting to start understanding the other side on this one, I have to admit. But this is a compelling argument -- that maintaining the taxi companies is like trying to maintain city buses, except companies built the infrastructure.
- CyberDildonics 10y ago> I don't want to see cab drivers turn into homeless drifters, but this just seems wrong. They could always drive for Uber
- quickben 10y agoWell, things should be equal. Why should a taxi service have to perform a regular vehicle inspection and a an uber driver be exempt from it? Either make the Uber driver go through regular inspections or cancel the regulation for the cabbies.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoNone of which has anything to do with this tax. This is directly using taxation to hand one business a market advantage over another business.
- quickben 10y agoWell plenty of things don't make sense at a first glance but it's all connected. For example, and I'm going offtopic here, but in USA they have lobbying, which is basically legalized bribe. Then people wonder why they chose to do the taxation weirdness from the article. Somebody probably got paid to shave % off Uber income, and I'd bet it won't stop here too. When the system if flawed from the bottom up, you really can't be wondering why some parts of it are illogical. Especially when money are allowed to directly and openly influence people in power.
- brightball 10y agoMaking Uber drivers abide by the same standards would make sense. This is using government authority to take money from one business and give it to another.
- rspeer 10y agoI think this legislation is a tacit admission that those standards don't make sense. If the taxi regulations had any benefit, then there would be something better about taking a taxi than taking an Uber. But in the real world (especially in Massachusetts) taxis completely suck. From the user experience point of view, Uber has done a great job of regulating itself. So the government has decided not to make things worse by putting the regulations on Uber. The taxi owners complain that this is unfair. The government says "you're right, have some money."
- xyzzy4 10y agoAs a lifelong resident of Massachusetts, color me unsurprised. This is a tangent but I've also spent some time in India, and a $1.50 Uber ride there would be about $10 in Massachusetts. That has to do with other factors though such as PPP, birth rates and age demographics, immigration policies, number of skilled vs unskilled workers, etc.
- robbiep 10y agoAnd by the big mac index, the cost of living in India is 50% less (at a minimum) than in the US. Direct price comparisons between countries are useless
- xyzzy4 10y agoIt's not useless. If something is too expensive in one place (5x-10x in Massachusetts compared to India) then it's evidence of some serious problems. My own theory is that the immigration policies of the US prevent enough unskilled workers from filling the roads with lots of Uber drivers.
- mahyarm 10y agoHow much is the average GDP per captia in india? Rent? Food? How much is the average low-skill worker make in india vs mass? Is it also 5-10x less?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- yazaddaruvala 10y ago> then it's evidence of some serious problems. There is still currently a human in the car. Human's wage's are hopefully in proportion to the cost of living. Are you suggesting we actively force Uber drivers to compete for unlivable wages? You must really like the idea of self driving cars :)
- qq66 10y agoI think that this makes sense in concept if not in implementation. Taxi medallions were sold and traded under a certain set of laws which defined their value. The government decided to change those laws, so "buying out" the medallions at some fair price, paid for by the beneficiaries of the change in law, makes sense.
- taneq 10y agoExactly. The issue isn't the taxi companies' competitiveness, the issue is that the government is allowing Uber et al. to offer a taxi service without having to follow the same rules imposed on taxi driers.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoThe medallion owners were making an investment. Every investment carries a risk. If they were profiting from their investments then they were not going to share those with anyone else. Why then should others share their losses?
- tomdell 10y agoImagine you want to open a restaurant. You know that it will be successful - you've done your research, whatever, yadda yadda. The government charges you a hefty initial tax to open your restaurant - it's a steep cost, but you expect that you'll be able to pay it off, because you know your place is going to do well. Seriously, you've paid attention to history - these kinds of things - the way you're doing it, anyway - always do well. Time passes, and your restaurant does do really well. You get a few negative reviews, though - some people think the place smells funny, some customers don't like hearing you (the head chef) screaming at the cooks in the kitchen. A couple years later, a competitor restaurant opens across the street. Similar price level, cuisine, prestige - all that. The only thing is, the government doesn't level the same tax against the competitor that you had to pay. In fact, that tax isn't being applied to them at all, because, even though you know and everyone else knows they're really basically a restaurant - despite that, because all the customers there order the food through an app, the place is legally classified as something else. The competitor's head chef and owner has paid attention to what you did poorly - he makes sure his place smells good (he spends a lot of money on this), and he's careful to keep his speaking voice down while chastising his chefs. He starts to get good business, and as word spreads, you start to lose business. Things aren't looking good for you. You're not really sure you're going to be able to stay open for long enough for that heavy tax you paid to be worth it.
- intopieces 10y agoThe weird thing is they don't even have a solid plan for what to do with the money. Or a plan at all, it seems. The least they could do is create some kind of MassTrans App that shows a user options for navigating the state (uber/lyft/cabs/transit/greyhound etc). Otherwise it seems like collection for the sake of it.
- AndyNemmity 10y agoI've never seen a successful government app, certainly there must be one. Does anyone know of a reasonably useful government app? It's hard enough for normal tech to create useful apps, let alone the over expensive bogged down government.
- raziel414 10y agoI can provide an example. I live in Seattle, and use "One Bus Away" everyday. It provides a map showing of all the public bus stops, and real time estimates for bus arrivals at each stop.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoOne Bus Away was developed by University of Washington students, not government bureaucrats.
- yazaddaruvala 10y agoHow do you believe University of Washington students know the location of each bus in the Metro Seattle area, in "real time"? Also, to play devil's advocate, isn't UW technically government funded, at least subsidized for "in state" students?
- staticfish 10y agoSimple. they pushed and pushed until they could get wheel arch counters installed on the buses.
- xname2 10y agoIt should be totally opposite: 1) uber drivers are in lower income than taxis drivers 2) uber economy is new and innovative, while taxi is old and dying
- spriggan3 10y agoor better 3) uber is a taxi company and should follow the same laws and regulations as other taxi companies. Which would of course destroy uber's business model which is based on dodging the law, sorry, "disruption".
- xname2 10y agouber is not a taxi company
- spriggan3 10y agoMy bad, uber is running illegal taxi operations in a lot of countries, that's why its illegal taxi service was shut down in many countries and cities around the world.
- AndyNemmity 10y agoJust googled Taxi Service. Uber is the third listing under Yellow Cab, and Discount Cab. Looking at Uber's SEO, they have a lot of listings like "Request taxi cabs from your phone with uberTAXI" on their home page in the source. 52 entries. Strange for a company that isn't a taxi company to advertise their taxis.
- Dylan16807 10y agoWanting to show up when you search for taxi doesn't tell you if it's a taxi. Like a cable company showing up when you search DSL, it's not strange at all. UberTAXI gets you non-uber taxi cars, more or less. That's not their main service, and doesn't tell you whether their main service is a taxi service.
- cloudjacker 10y agoDuring periods of extremely high surge pricing, I take regulated taxis instead. At first I think, 'wow I love competition its such a good thing this alternative service was around' but then I try to pay the cab driver, here is the experience in 2016: - The meter system is broken - The cab driver presses buttons frantically on a black box before resorting to hitting it in hopes that it responds to external stimuli - The cab driver is unsure how to process credit cards (or even cash) in the event this black box does not start responding "Uhhh, ahhhhh, this stupid thing" - If black box does begin responding, then lets advance to the credit card processing part, which also doesn't work - FUTURISTIC WORLD CITIES in the US have taxis with screens in them so the rider can do the credit card processing on their own, except this doesn't work either "your screen isn't responding..."
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> The cab driver is unsure how to process credit cards Or, quite frequently, the cab driver doesn't want to process credit cards and are you sure you don't have cash?
- Azkar 10y agoIf the taxi even shows up at all...
- scottmf 10y agoOr you hail one and they don't want to go where you're going. It amazes me how consistently poor the service is from old-style taxis across the world. Is there a worse industry for consumers?
- maverick_iceman 10y agoNot to mention the blatant racism of many taxi drivers.
- chillacy 10y agoAlso in Las Vegas, where taxis reign supreme, you get the pleasure of being blasted with ads on giant screens.
- brownbat 10y agoThere are two competing narratives about ride-hailing apps success: 1) They are profitable because they are finding loopholes in relevant legislation, or, 2) they are profitable because they are injecting competition and new ideas into a stagnating industry dominated by government-protected monopolies (or oligopolies). Your opinion of the law will likely depend on which narrative you find more persuasive.
- darawk 10y agoThey are pretty clearly profitable for both of those reasons. They are not at all mutually exclusive.
- paulcole 10y agoAre they profitable though?
- hueving 10y agoIn the US, yes. They were using that to fund expansion into China/India.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoUber is, I don't know about Lyft. Does anyone here knows about Lyft's profitability?
- tim333 10y agoLyft is losing a fortune. >According to Bloomberg, the ridesharing startup took a net loss of $127 million in the first half of [2015], off less than $47 million in revenue.
- manarth 10y ago$0.19 a ride in the USA (not including “interest, taxes, and equity-based compensation for employees").[1] Although it's possible that after interest, taxes etc, that they're not even profitable in the US yet. [1] https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/uber-says-profitable-us-much-151211910.html https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/uber-says-profitable-us-mu...
- maverick_iceman 10y agoBy this logic, Facebook should be taxed to give money to Myspace.
- chuymax 10y agoGoogle should be taxed to give money to Yahoo.
- MicroBerto 10y agoSounds like time for some politicians to get voted out of office. Voters may not care about certain things, but they definitely care about their transportation.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoWorking class folks care more about their jobs than Uber's profits (rightfully so).
- yazaddaruvala 10y agoThere are more working class folks, who this disadvantages than advantages. I'm sure the people of Mass who use Uber, would look at this as an extra tax put onto them. And Uber will cost more. For example, when regulation (which was needed) around driver verification came out: I remember a very clear message on the Uber app about why the price of each ride went up $1.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI would absolutely love for someone to leak Uber's user demographic data. I find it hard to believe it's working class people regularly using it, and not just upper middle class professionals and above primarily (except on nights out to the bar; in that case I could see the demo skewed).
- yazaddaruvala 10y agoMy bad, I should have tried to clarify. It seems we have different definitions of the working class. I'm an upper middle class professional, but I consider myself in the "working class". Otherwise, I'm not sure why I waste 40-60 hours every week on other people's problems :P
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI consider working class the chunk of middle class constantly shrinking, joining the lower class. Tech workers are a minority.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- yohoho22 10y ago> The 5-cent fee will be collected through the end of 2021. Then the taxi subsidy will disappear and the 20 cents will be split by localities and the state for five years. The whole fee will go away at the end of 2026.
- randyrand 10y agoah the old 'temporary tax' we hear time to time. I remember some story about a few WWII temporary taxes that are still taxing today.
- jdminhbg 10y agoPennsylvanians still pay a "temporary" 18% tax on alcohol instituted to pay for damage caused by the Johnstown Flood. ... in 1936. http://www.post-gazette.com/opinion/editorials/2016/03/27/Truth-in-pricing-Remove-a-hidden-tax-from-the-liquor-monopoly/stories/201603230036 http://www.post-gazette.com/opinion/editorials/2016/03/27/Tr...
- staticfish 10y agoThe toll charges for a trip across the Golden Gate Bridge were instituted to pay for the segment not subsided by the citizens on each bank of the San Francisco Bay.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoIf only the buggy whip industry had been so good at bending government to its will.
- a_c 10y agoIf this logic make sense, perhaps AirBnB need to be taxed to support hotel industry, Iphone should pay to nokia and internet should be taxed to landline
- giaour 10y agoLandlines all have a fee that subsidizes service in rural areas. Hotels have to pay hotel taxes in addition to property taxes, which are often earmarked.
- briandear 10y agoI have some properties that I AirBnB in France and we pay the hotel taxes just like the hotels. So that argument that AirBnB properties don't have to pay hotel tax isn't true. And the tax isn't even that much. If a hotel is on such a tight margin that €0.80-€2.10 per occupant per day is a hardship, then they have bigger problems. We also get to pay property tax, habitation tax as well as income tax. Yet here in France the hotel business still lobbies against AirBnB.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoNot to say, real doctors need to be taxed to support homeopaths, power plants taxed to support oil lamp manufacturers etc. etc.
- known 10y ago"If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." --Reagan
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ricw 10y agoThis is unbelievable. Never have I used a more corrupt and unfriendly taxi service as the one in Boston / Cambridge. And they are supposed to be subsidised?! I have 1) been driven round crazy detours to up my cost 2) been forced to drive a detour because the card machine was broken and they only accepted cash 3) been turned down because my destination wasn't far enough 4) been shouted at because I was watching the free tv in the cab In short, they suck. Badly. Thinking about it, I can't remember a positive experience. In contrast I've hardly had a negative experience with lyft/uber and mostly had very positive or positive experiences. What's the best way of contacting this senator?!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jacobolus 10y agoI lived in Cambridge for about 6 years from ~2004–2011. Nothing but positive experiences with Boston-area cabs. The drivers were uniformly friendly and competent, and had no trouble with the ridiculously convoluted MA street layouts. When I was carrying suitcases or moving boxes of books around, they were patient and helpful with loading/unloading. When I left my wallet one time, the driver called me as soon as he found it and promptly returned it. Maybe you just got unlucky? Or maybe things have deteriorated since other transportation started undercutting them? Yay for anecdotal evidence, right?
- staticfish 10y agoI'm not disputing your experiences for one second, but mine closely match OP's in Boston, and just about every other large city in the US.* *With the exception of London. Maybe having to study The Knowledge has something to do with it..
- benjiweber 10y agoThe "card machine is broken" line is consistently used by most London cabbies. They're being forced into accepting card kicking and screaming by regulations towards the end of the year https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/media/press-releases/2016/february/card-payments-to-be-accepted-in-every-black-cab https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/media/press-releases/2016/februa...
- losteverything 10y agoCouldn't a "medallion cab" franchise that licenses tools (technology) to existing city cab drivers be created? So cabbies in Massachusetts can spend the tax money on their own uber via a franchise. The franchise can be repeated all over for the "old industry" - In every big city. So a user could choose their "Dominoes" app and they would be getting a legacy cab, not uber-lyft. And the customer would support existing men and women whose jobs are threatened. And like dominoes pizza, behind the scenes is a local owner (or local group of cabbies) that has to follow their own rules. A cabbie could be hailed with 4 fingers and a thumb up or via two thumb touch. Have cake and eat it too.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ilostmykeys 10y agoWhen Uber switches to a fleet of self-driving cars (with lower paid drivers, since they'll just sit and watch 98% of the time), this tax would be absolutely nothing short of taxing innovation to save an inefficient business model. Wow. I thought Capitalism was evil. Now I don't know what to think.
- Jach 10y ago"The only thing worse than being exploited by capitalism is not being exploited by capitalism." --Joan Violet Robinson
- madgar 10y agoCome on, you must know that nobody on HN gives a shit about anyone who didn't go to college. Here, the uneducated are meant to be tools of those who are educated and should be happy to be tools.
- dang 10y agoThat's far from true, and please don't diss the community as a rhetorical device. Doing so is a cheap shot and a reliable marker of a low-quality comment. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12329348 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12329348 and marked it off-topic. p.s. I noticed you also did that at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12329714 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12329714. Please make your points by expressing them directly. HN is a lot of different people; nearly all the generalizations are false, and since you're commenting here you're as much a part of the community as anyone else is. That's a good thing.
- halis 10y agoThey don't even pretend to care about every day consumers anymore.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- thesumofall 10y agoI believe they have a point. The traditional taxi industry _can_ be rescued. Living in Germany I use myTaxi which is basically providing the same interface as Uber but connects you with professional taxis that are regulated, insured, and being paid proper wages. There is simply no difference in convenience (even the opposite: you can book taxis in advance) and the driving experience itself is typically by far better than any Uber I've ever taken in the US (inexperienced drivers, often old cars,...) So I would argue that the tax could help achieve a similar scenario in MA if invested properly and if Uber is forced to raise prices by bringing them to uphold professional standards. I was long enough in MA to know that regular taxis have a long way to go but there is hope
- briandear 10y agoDefine a 'proper' wage please? I don't know what that means apparently. I would think it would be a wage at which the supply curve and the demand curve meet for your particular skill. However if seems that you're implying that people ought to get paid more than the demand curve for their services would support, which is why I ask the question because that would be absurd. That would mean that someone else would have to subsidize this person by paying a higher price which would reduce demand for the product. Only the market can raise wages in any real way.
- thesumofall 10y agoI define a proper wage as such that for jobs that society deems necessary (e.g., taxi drivers) people are able to live a life above the poverty line. The textbook definition of supply and demand is a bit too simplistic here. Uber has artificially increased supply to starve of competition and to create network effects for the sake of them, they lowered prices by creating externalities that others have to pay for, and they lured (sometimes barely educated drivers) into a job that paid less and less over time.
- GarrisonPrime 10y agoSociety deems things necessary based on what people want, what can be provided to them, and at what price it can be provided. If society isn't willing to pay taxi drivers enough for them live above the poverty line, then society doesn't really want taxi drivers that much, does it?
- akulbe 10y agoIf the taxi cab companies can't make it on their own, they should go out of business. As a self-employed person, I shouldn't expect someone else to bail me out by their efforts. If I can't make it on my own steam, I close up shop. When this happens, it's unfortunate, and unpleasant, but it's a simple fact of doing business. Our parents and grandparents would balk and roll in their graves at the thought of this idea that someone else should shoulder the burden of bailing you out. What ever happened to the idea of (in the case of business hardship or failure) picking yourself up, dusting yourself off and starting OVER??
- wutbrodo 10y ago> Our parents and grandparents would balk and roll in their graves at the thought of this idea that someone else should shoulder the burden of bailing you out. That's definitely not true. People have been kicking and screaming (and regulating) against being obsoleted by technology since literally the beginning of industrialization, and even earlier if you broaden that to "obsoleted by a change in market conditions". The only difference between that and asking for a bailout is that the bailout happens later in the process.
- akulbe 10y agoIndustrialization didn't end up with a net loss of jobs. It ended up with a change and retooling of jobs. This hasn't changed with the advance of technology. We just have to figure out the how, and where, and what of this change. You know... be resilient, like we are as humanity. That's not to say it's going to be easy, and I'm not trying to over-simplify things. It will be HARD, but it is POSSIBLE. One of the things I'm advocating for is to try and figure out the challenge yourself rather than ask for a bailout. Personally, I don't think that is unreasonable. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Information is plentiful for us. Probably not nearly as much for previous generations.
- wutbrodo 10y agoI don't disagree with anything you're saying, except for the claim that our parents' and grandparents' generation took the obsolescence of job categories with noble foresight. They were pretty much just as in love with bailouts and protectionism as we are (if not more).
- aerodog 10y agomassholes
- joshmn 10y agoI'm all for taxing the rich to help the poor but not like this.
- lpolovets 10y agoObviously the logic is mystifying, but the math behind this is baffling as well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_the_United_States#Boston https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_the_United_States#... says there are 1825 cabs in Boston. Boston is 10% of Massachusetts' population, so let's say there are 18k cabs in the state. http://www.reuters.com/article/us-massachusetts-uber-idUSKCN10U1ST http://www.reuters.com/article/us-massachusetts-uber-idUSKCN... says 5 cents/ride-hailing app will go toward taxis, and Uber+Lyft do 2.5m rider per month. So, the tax will produce 2.5m rides/mo * 12 months * 5 cents/ride = $1.5m/year. That works out to... drum roll... $83 per taxicab per year. How is this supposed to help taxi drivers with anything? Maybe as ride-sharing increases, this becomes $200 or $400 per cab per year, but that's still a small sum. I imagine a few hundred dollars is a small consolation when you lose 50% or 90% of your business.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wutbrodo 10y ago> there are 1825 cabs in Boston. Boston is 10% of Massachusetts' population, so let's say there are 18k cabs in the state. The number would likely be way lower than this (it doesn't make too much sense to extrapolate linearly from the densest urban population), but your point still stands even you double or triple the $/driver. That's pretty weird...
- lpolovets 10y agoThat's a good point. After Googling some more, it seems like MA has about 8300 "taxi drivers and chauffeurs" (http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes533041.htm http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes533041.htm), so the $83 should probably be doubled or tripled.
- manarth 10y ago> "the tax will produce…$1.5m/year" If that's $83 per taxi-driver, then I agree: handing that $83 to the driver will not have a significant effect. So rather than use the tax to directly subsidise taxi-drivers income, what if it's used to invest in taxi infrastructure? Or perhaps invest in things that level the playing field, providing equivalents to some of Lyft/Uber's tools? Research or software into the most profitable time to work (to equalise with surge-pricing). A ride-hailing app that's open to all taxi companies. A training system that lowers the cost of entry into the market.
- kasajian 10y agoThis is so weird. I'm not sure it's legal.
- contemporary2u 10y agoFood for thought: I am working on AI robot that will ultimately replace human programmers/coders/software engineers. It will make human programmers obsolete. What will most of you do? Will you go back to school to get a new degree/profession? Open a coffee shop perhaps? or apply for peace corps? It is coming.. just remember that eventually anyone could be the next "taxi cab" driver with his or her job going away to automation. Our society will have no choice but to adopt in more ways than one.
- GarrisonPrime 10y agoThat doesn't mean we should forcibly grind all progress to a halt just to avoid hurting feelings or avoid having to go through the uncomfortable process of change. I, for one, am glad we as a society decided to leg go of our reliance on horse-and-buggy transportation technology.
- trengrj 10y agoI'm in Sydney Australia and we have a one dollar fee for each Uber to bribe off taxi medallion owners. It feels completely wrong and Uber makes the fee separate on your card I think in protest.
- mbreedlove 10y agoI hope they label the charge "Taxi Bribe".
- punnerud 10y agoThis is genial! This way we don't need the complains from "the old taxies" and can gradually reduce the tax when ride-hailing apps are established. This way we gradually remove the old ones :)
- nomercy400 10y agoIsn't this unfair competition? Government meddeling with free market? Also, does anybody know if taxi medallions expire?
- chappi42 10y agoAs long as taxi drivers have higher salaries and are better protected this is a good move. I very much salute the innovations uber enabled. Only there should be a law which guarantees a decent minimum salary for uber riders. No good to allow an income-race-to-the-bottom for drivers.
- GarrisonPrime 10y agoThere is a law that guarantees a decent minimum salary for uber drivers. It's called the law of self interest. If uber doesn't pay their drivers enough, the drivers leave and find other work. The fact that they stay is proof that they're being paid enough. If you disagree, then I suggest your idea of what kind of pay would be "enough" is highly arbitrary and biased.
- IkmoIkmo 10y agoI fully understand one may tax a new successful industry, and then use the proceeds for individual citizens who lose jobs and need some support, training and job programs to help them back on their feet. But this is ridiculous. The notion an uncompetitive industry, which is fading because ordinary people can and do choose a better product or service, gets money to stay alive with its shittier product, just makes no sense. It doesn't achieve what we want, and there are good alternatives.
- jbmorgado 10y agoI would understand if the state imposed this tax in order for this money to provide some social security to the drivers of Uber/Lift/etc. But taking this money away from them and giving them to the taxi lobby sounds almost like state imposed robbery.
- sunshiney 10y agoSo Wix should be taxed with the proceeds given to developers it has has taken low-fruit from?
- aji95 10y agoFunny video :Dhttps://youtu.be/4C1cg2o-nHE https://youtu.be/4C1cg2o-nHE
- jwallaceparker 10y agoYou and a friend are stranded on an island. You both spend all your working hours catching fish by hand in order to eat. You use some leisure time to build a fishing rod, which enables just one of you to catch enough fish to feed you both. It would be foolish to destroy the fishing rod to preserve both your jobs as fishermen. One of you would fish and the other would do something else, like build shelter and cut firewood. It's just the two of you, so you don't literally exchange in barter, but an implicit exchange takes place when you share the fish, shelter and firewood. You both enjoy a better standard of living thanks to the productivity increase created by the fishing rod. A modern economy is much more complex but the same fundamental principle applies. The ride-hailing apps make taxi drivers more productive by helping them connect with customers faster. Now it takes fewer taxi drivers to satisfy the demands of customers. This frees up the labor time of the remaining taxi drivers to produce additional goods or services. There is certainly temporary pain endured by workers who are displaced by the innovation. But it is folly to subsidize work that is no longer in demand.
- gkya 10y agoThe number of professions don't go up, and will certainly diminish in the future. Switching professions as a young person without a dependent family is not all that hard. But as a family father/mother, it's not always possible to spend the time to switch professions. Today most of the jobs have qualification, experience and age requirements. > There is certainly temporary pain endured by workers who are displaced by the innovation. But it is folly to subsidize work that is no longer in demand. That should not mean the transition could not be smoothened, though. Let me comment on your example. In todays economy things are sold, not shared. So I need to have something to give in return for the fish that the fisherman (the guy with the fishing rod) gives me. I can dive for scallops. But another guy comes with a scallop-collecting machine and the fisherman does not need my scallops anymore, as he can buy from him cheaper. So I start guarding their stocks for them in return for fish and scallops to eat. But then they invent an automated system for defence of their stock, so my labour is unnecessary now. I need to eat, so I start farming, and as I can't live on herbs merely, I trade some of my crop for fish and scallops. But one day they start importing it from another island for cheaper, and stop buying from me. I can't support my farm year-round just on my crops, so I switch to herding a flock of sheep, and trade meat for fish, scallops, and herbs. But someone comes and builds a modern meat production plant, and I can't sell cheaper than him, so I'm out of business. Given I can't live on my herds' meat only, I need to move on. And while the island slowly thrives with newcomers as the services are increasing and life is becoming easier, the amount of my opportunities diminish. Finally I start up a little market where I sell stuff that I import and/or buy from local providers in order to earn the money to buy fish, scallops, herbs, meat and other stuff. But comes a big coop and drives me out of business. I resort to taxi driving in order to survive, but apps and ridesharing replace my business. I go around seeking a job, in factories, coops, fishmongers, etc., and I find a job as a cashier in the local coop. But an automatic cash largely diminishes necessity of a cashier, so, I'm moved to the big depot of the coop. There, automation, growingly replaces the need for human labor, and as I'm rather inexperienced, I'm laid off. Because they don't want me to become a hobo and pose 'em a threat, some institution gives me 'unemployment money', so that I can survive. I don't want to survive, I want to live, but I lost the chance to become a white-collar while I was trying to catch on, I didn't have the time to focus on one thing and become a professional. So I sort of live as a dependent of the social welfare system, barely surviving, without human dignity. Furthermore, I'm excluded from some parts of community by social code, and am informally a second-class citizen, as I live off the taxes of others. A family is merely a dream for me, as I don't have the money to support it. And should I already have a family, my kids and my partner are at least frustrated at me as I'm a dysfunctional member of the family, though it's also possible that I'm excluded. Here, a more realistic allegory.
- m1sta_ 10y agoThe tax collected should be forced to go directly to buyback of taxi licenses.
- fastball 10y agoOr performing background checks of drivers.
- meira 10y agoAs a transition solution, this is genius!
- meira 10y agoAs a transition solution, this is genius!
- douche 10y agoTaxachusetts strikes again. Rather than let a shitty industry that already enjoyed monopoly protections, fail and be replaced with something more efficient, let's prop them up with a misguided subsidy/tax scheme.
- finid 10y agoThe state wants to play Robin Hood. Hey! Why don't they give the money to me. I can use it. Next they will want to take money from the likes of Facebook and give it to struggling newspapers.
- nathan_f77 10y agoI hope they're also taxing car manufacturers and giving it to horse owners.
- owly 10y agoThe 5¢ should be allocated to public transportation to keep late night bus service. This is pure corruption.
- mrerrormessage 10y agoI haven't read all the comments in this thread, but I'm surprised at the outrage over a one-nickel tax. This seems like a fairly simple, straightforward rule. Is anyone going to decide not to Lyft/Uber over 5 cents? I don't think so. Let's also not forget that these ride hailing services are MASSIVELY subsidizing the cost of rides in order to attract drivers/users. That hurts business for taxis. In my mind, this is a sort of protection that ensures taxis stay in business as another, publicly regulated option. What happens in other areas of Uber/Lyft kill all the taxis and then decide doing business isn't profitable and leave (or all their drivers leave I've subsidies end)? This might seem like a farfetched scenario, but remember that Uber is still sitting in a large cash reserves. What will change when they need to turn a profit every quarter? If they have established a monopoly (even locally), they can charge users as much as they want. If they've established a monopsony on drivers, they can lower wages. In my opinion, subsidizing a long-standing industry from a monopolistic competitor with gobs of money to throw at the market looks like a good move.
- z3t4 10y agoHow do the app taxi buisness work? Are drivers employed by the app-maker or are drivers registered for VAT?
- appleflaxen 10y agoWhen obsolete industries / models / methods become replaced by something better, the best thing that can happen at a macro level is to have them phased out as smoothly as possible. If that smoothness can also be fast, then you will maximize your economic productivity as well. So this decision is exactly the opposite of what you want... you are going to prolong the inevitable with a market-distorting subsidy. It would be much better to tax Uber and require the funds go to taxi cab retraining scholarships, so that people who couldn't make a living driving a cab anymore have another option. Better yet: send them to customer service school, so that they can work as an Uber driver if they wish to do so.
- chmaynard 10y ago> "They've been breaking the law," said Larry Meister of the Independent Taxi Operators Association. If so, then the duty of government is to enforce the law (presumably with fines or prosecution). Imposing a new tax is another matter. It's amusing that a Republican governor supports a new tax of any kind.
- tiatia 10y agoThey should tax cars and give the money to horse carriages
- alanz1223 10y agothis move seems like a desperate attempt to revitalize a dying dream... Taxis are dead, ride sharing killed it. End of story. Typewriter manufacturers werent given subsidies when the computer f*cked them over, were they?
- 40something 10y agoMassachusetts is literally run by tyrants. No one cared when the attorney general trampled over the constitution by banning the sale of built to compliant "assault" weapons and now this. The disarmed populace has to just take it. The rulers know best.
- bawana 10y agoThe capitalist model, the concept of 'disruption', Adam Smith's precepts work well when they allow individuals to control their choices, their fate, their destiny. When the transactions exceed human scale - when they become so big, so far reaching, so expensive that the participants are powerless to make changes, then capitalism fails. It fails because the 'losers' suffer even if they try to adapt. They cannot compete because the the 'winning side' is so new with fewer legacy costs. The losers necessarily must die and become assimilated by the winning strategy. And the winners who skirt the regulations will close shop and disappear at the first sign of trouble. I disagree with the concept of entitlement-taking money from the winner and giving it to the loser. But the winner MUST abide by the same rules as the loser. If the ride sharing industry has the advantage of venture capital startup money and newer (less costly to maintain) infrastructure, then their benefits to drivers should be GREATER than what the taxi industry provides, not less. The 20 cent tax should go entirely to the health care and insurance of the drivers of the ride sharing industry's drivers. Not the welfare recipients we call 'politicians'. That HALF of this tax goes to people who are ALREADY living off of money made by people who actually work really bothers me. I would really like to see silicon valley startups that offer a new and better forms of local government. I would like to see our political system get improved by disruption. I really believe politicians are vastly overpaid for the non-service they provide.
- tbihl 10y ago>I would really like to see silicon valley startups that offer a new and better forms of local government. I would like to see our political system get improved by disruption. I really believe politicians are vastly overpaid for the non-service they provide. There was an idyllic notion in the heads of some of the founders of the US that the many towns could be thousands of little laboratories, each testing their own ideas and then, as a wider community of towns, naturally coalescing around the ideas that worked best. The problem, as I see it, is that they don't have the agility and flexibility of a laboratory or startup. In modern times (in the US), towns act as franchises rather than labs, with the exceptions of large cities and a few other special places. For example, I think most people can instinctively feel the unpleasantness of a place with large chain retailers and restaurants lining the sides of a 6 lane, 40MPH road with openings and stop lights everywhere. Nonetheless, they're everywhere in the US. Places without these awful (and horrendously expensive) development patterns are the exception. The reason is because the US government pushes development decisions. They do it not by saying 'thou shalt construct car sewers,' but through more subtle means. Since 1934, it has been artificially expensive to build multi-use buildings with dwellings over a shop because you can't get an FHA-compliant mortgage and the accompanying subsidies. We push common road engineering standards, which works great for highways, but then towns build highway-compliant roads in town to get federal grants. Then each state has its own set of policies that create perverse incentives in curious ways. Actually, in CA the state government did effectively mandate car sewers for decades by deciding that car idling and congestion were environmental impacts that had to be mitigated (with more highway-spec supersized roads.) Anyway, all this is to say: give local governments a little credit. Certainly some of them are bad, and this article shows a particularly disheartening variant, but in a lot of cases it's an issue of asking mere mortals to prevail over the huge obstructions built by other governing bodies.
- sevenless 10y agoAll hail the glorious US free market...
- ruffrey 10y agoWhat prevents taxi drivers from taking Lyft and Uber shifts? Are there some kinds of restrictions on official taxi drivers? Do they need to keep a certain number of hours? Do taxi drivers have benefits?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tremendo 10y agoKodak and Polaroid should have thought of that. Get governments to tax digital photography, cameras and memory cards, in order to save their business and all those jobs they provided (as opposed those newly created, because pfft!). Never mind any benefit to the paying public.
- chillingeffect 10y agoSerious question here: how come taxi organizations haven't leveraged uber/lyft tech by now? Seems most kinks, tech and laws are figured out now. Why not upgrade using capital since the returns are obvious!?
- taxicabjesus 10y ago> Serious question here: how come taxi organizations haven't leveraged uber/lyft tech by now? They have, but only the largest taxi companies have the financial resources to do it well, especially in an environment of collapsing revenue. There are off-the-shelf apps for taxi companies, but these aren't very polished. Large transportation companies have existing dispatching systems to work with their existing contracts (Medicaid transportation, etc), and they can't just 'start over' with a new dispatching system very quickly. The company that I used to drive for bought the software company that provided its Electronic Taxi Dispatch v1.0 [1] phone app, and spent a couple million upgrading it to v1.1, where the passenger is given instantaneous feedback just like duper's app. It took several months to work out most the bugs - I frequently filed reports with the developers. [1] http://www.taxiwars.org/p/electronic-taxi-dispatch-v1.html http://www.taxiwars.org/p/electronic-taxi-dispatch-v1.html They were going to replace all the in-cab computers with tablets, to better interface with their new app, but I don't know if they've done that yet... Discount Cab's apps: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.treeline.gfc.discount_cab https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.treeline.g... https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/total-transit-prev.-discount/id499063019 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/total-transit-prev.-discount... VIP Taxi's apps: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/vip-taxi/id1076304288?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/vip-taxi/id1076304288?mt=8 https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.vip.taxi https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.vip.taxi
- mungoid 10y agoI haven't read all 400-some comments, but in the several pages worth i read I haven't seen a single person mention looking out for their own welfare and keeping their future in their own hands. Just because a line of work has been around for decades doesnt mean it is always going to be a safe bet. I've worked hard for the past 10 years to get to my middling-middle class income. Enough with my wife's to support our family. I could just be content with that and staying right here for the rest of my life, never wanting to do any more with myself, but I know things will change and i want to be prepared for it. Maybe it's the brain wiring of a software developer, but I refuse to become complacent with where I am at. I already know I wouldn't last another 10 years if I don't regularly adapt, learn new technologies, stay current. I think in a way, this isn't too much different than the housing bubble. Too many people thinking that everything is just going to keep going its steady pace forever and if anything bad does happen, someone will come to the rescue. I want to position myself so I don't need that rescuing.
- ChartsNGraffs 10y agoBro, you're a hero. Change is the only constant and you're wise to prepare for it. I wish you and your family the best.
- ovatsug25 10y agoInteresting excerpt that makes me support the move: The 5-cent fee will be collected through the end of 2021. Then the taxi subsidy will disappear and the 20 cents will be split by localities and the state for five years. The whole fee will go away at the end of 2026. They know they're fucked. The question remains: will they be able to use this temporary subsidy so they can become more "sovereign individuals" in the future?
- astrostl 10y agoLots of jokes about horse-drawn carriages in here. Would note that, in order to legalize casinos in the STL area, they were required to give money to a dump of a horse track which would have otherwise sped (no pun intended) toward an even earlier grave.
- samuraibum 10y agoThis is why people should avoid paying taxes. Taxation is theft and your hard earned money will always be wasted anyway.