29 ms·
With Windows 10, Microsoft Disregards User Choice and Privacy
- helloworld 10y agoMaybe this can be read as a cautionary tale about how easy it is to convince yourself to cut ethical corners when money is involved. In an honest moment, I suspect that many Microsoft executives would acknowledge that the behavior described here is morally dubious. Yet they've allowed it to happen. This reminds me that it's a daily challenge to avoid temptation and do the right thing. I hope that at least a few people in Redmond are thinking the same thing.
- shmerl 10y ago> The Way Forward is to ditch Windows. You can't seriously expect MS to respect user choice and privacy.
- 0xmohit 10y agoSome highlights: Microsoft installed an app in users’ system trays advertising the free upgrade to Windows 10. Not satisfied, the company eventually made Windows 10 a recommended update so users receiving critical security updates were now also downloading an entirely new operating system onto their machines without their knowledge. This is essentially equivalent to saying: You've been running whatever version of Windows, but we'll trick you into installing Windows 10. Specifically, when prompted with a Windows 10 update, if the user chose to decline it by hitting the ‘X’ in the upper right hand corner, Microsoft interpreted that as consent to download Windows 10. The previous trick didn't work on all of you, so we'll go on to change the default behavior of our dialog boxes in order to trick you into installing Windows 10. By default, Windows 10 sends an unprecedented amount of usage data back to Microsoft, and the company claims most of it is to “personalize” the software by feeding it to the OS assistant called Cortana. And while users can opt-out of some of these settings, it is not a guarantee that your computer will stop talking to Microsoft’s servers. This probably explains it all. -- Microsoft appears to have learnt a lot from LinkedIn [0]. [0] https://twitter.com/darylginn/status/590664399041519617 https://twitter.com/darylginn/status/590664399041519617
- makomk 10y agoI think this slightly understates just how sleazy Microsoft were about it, if anything. Before the dialog that interpreted closing it with the X in the corner as agreement to install Windows 10, they rolled out a similar-looking dialog where that was the only way to avoid install Windows 10 - clicking on any of the buttons in the dialog would cause it to be installed.
- wangchow 10y agoOver the past year I've noticed a lot of things mysteriously getting installed, things moving around, etc. I don't mind automatic updates so long as there's a separation from the new features and bug fixes. There should be a base core of apps that are necessary and a set of opt-in add-on features. It's time to move to Linux on laptop/desktop/tablet I think. While I love my surface pro 3 and the Windows 10 experience is overall a good one, I don't like them changing undisclosed stuff on me.
- tracker1 10y agoOn the flip side, I run Ubuntu on my htpc, and have for several years now... there have been a couple times where the updates broke audio, and the fix took on average 2 days, though I can imagine some people having worse experiences... Getting an MCE remote (arguably the most common PC remote type) working with Kodi (formerly xbmc and very popular full screen media player) took some cumbersome steps. On average one app breaks every 6 months or so after updating. By comparison, omitting the privacy issues, MS has a much better track record with updates.
- fdgdasfadsf 10y agoBoth are subpar (and osx or whatever Apple call their offering is no better). I've been stuck in an update hell with windows where security updates simply would not install the only solution I could find was a full re-install. I've been in a similar situation with Ubuntu and was able to fix it - but only because I understood it - otherwise I would have had to do a re-install. The key with Ubuntu updates is to stick to LTS versions and to do a clean re-install (keeping /home as a separate partition makes this painless). Both have rubbish audio systems. Windows breaks on my laptop every few suspend resumes (fixed by restart). Ubuntu every few months (fixed by restart). At this point I'm disappointed by every system I use.
- whatareyoureal 10y agoShould have just branded it Windows 7 SP2. But I guess everyone expects MS to support multiple branches of code forever. These discussions always avoid talking about the merits of data-driven design and always assume malicious intent.
- 0xmohit 10y agoNot sure what else has changed, but the changes in personalization (including Cortana) and telemetry changes warrant that it be called a new version. With LinkedIn in it's arsenal, Microsoft now wants to surpass Google in the amount of user information that can be collected.
- sjm-lbm 10y agoIf I buy a computer and/or pay Microsoft money, I think it's reasonable for me to expect my computer to do what I'd like it to do (and only what I'd like it to do). The problem isn't data-driven design, it's how the data is being collected. I'd be annoyed if my home builder occasionally came through my house while I was gone in an attempt to analyze how I was arranging furniture and using my space. They could, undoubtedly, use that data to better their future work - but I'd still feel violated.
- Grishnakh 10y ago>I'd be annoyed if my home builder occasionally came through my house while I was gone in an attempt to analyze how I was arranging furniture and using my space. They could, undoubtedly, use that data to better their future work - but I'd still feel violated. Too bad. If you sign a contract with your builder allowing him to do this, or you sign a contract allowing him to change your agreement and force new terms on you whenever he wants, then you brought this on yourself. Worse yet, if you willingly buy from a builder who is infamous for a decades-long history of horrible customer service and shoddy house designs and construction, I have zero sympathy for you. Customers have a responsibility to research their purchases beforehand, and avoid patronizing vendors with poor reputations.
- 10y ago
- JamesBaxter 10y agoI certainly agree that Microsoft have been very underhanded in some of their approaches. What really grinds my gears though is the lack of interest people have in maintaining their tools. If your computer is central to running your business you should be informed about upcoming updates as computer downtime is a threat to your business.
- cptskippy 10y agoBy default, Windows 10 sends an unprecedented amount of usage data back to Microsoft... location data, text input, voice input, touch input, webpages you visit, and telemetry data regarding your general usage of your computer, including which programs you run and for how long. Unprecedented for Microsoft or everyone? This is inline with what Google collects on Android. ...the fact remains that many users would much prefer to opt out of these features in exchange for maintaining their privacy. Which they can do at any time, the initial setup permits opting out of almost all of this. A significant issue is the telemetry data the company receives. While Microsoft insists that it aggregates and anonymizes this data, it hasn’t explained just how it does so. Microsoft also won’t say how long this data is retained, instead providing only general timeframes. Microsoft has been doing this since Windows XP as do Apple, Google, and Amazon for their respective OSes. Microsoft has tried to explain this lack of choice by saying that Windows Update won’t function properly on copies of the operating system with telemetry reporting turned to its lowest level. This is interesting because Windows 10 won't let you disable telemetry data entirely which upsets people. But most people probably want updates and the data necessary to determine which updates you've got installed on your computer are considered telemetry data by Microsoft and that information is essential in order to determine which updates are applicable or available. So does the minimum setting in Windows 10 collect more telemetry data than is necessary for Windows Update to function or not? But this is a false choice that is entirely of Microsoft’s own creation. There’s no good reason why the types of data Microsoft collects at each telemetry level couldn’t be adjusted so that even at the lowest level of telemetry collection, users could still benefit from Windows Update and secure their machines from vulnerabilities, without having to send back things like app usage data or unique IDs like an IMEI number. Did Microsoft actually say that the lowest level of telemetry data collection includes that information? That sounds like an assumption. And if this wasn’t bad enough, Microsoft’s questionable upgrade tactics of bundling Windows 10 into various levels of security updates have also managed to lower users’ trust in the necessity of security updates. Sadly, this has led some people to forego security updates entirely, meaning that there are users whose machines are at risk of being attacked. Right or wrong, this is what Apple, Google, and Amazon currently. Sure it's nice to be able to look at each and every update to scrutinize what's going in but very few people do that. If you've every looked at the updates in earlier versions of Windows they're usually just KB numbers that you have to copy/paste into a browser to see what they actually fix.
- joering2 10y agoMicrosoft paid $10k [1] to one single count of this deceiving practice and decided to settle not to pursue further. Me and my young children see Transvaginal Mesh Implants class action lawsuit invitation few times a day for probably a year now on multitude of national TV stations. When will some tech-literate lawyer start gathering evidence to file a class action lawsuit over what MS just did?? [1] http://www.theverge.com/2016/6/27/12046738/microsoft-pays-10k-over-windows-10-auto-update http://www.theverge.com/2016/6/27/12046738/microsoft-pays-10...
- tobias3 10y agoThe EULA you agree to during Windows 10 installation prohibits class action lawsuits, but Windows 7 should be fair game...
- a3n 10y agoIs it really an End User License Agreement when Microsoft worked hard to circumvent your desire not to have Windows 10 in the first place. I would think that the change to the red close this box X would be somewhere in exhibit A to F in any class action.
- jessaustin 10y agoI support some computers that auto-updated to 10, and everyone with access to them swears they never hit "OK" in the week leading up to that auto-update. Did the EULA just flash up on the screen at 2 AM?
- tobias3 10y agoI guess it reboots to Windows 10, but keeps the old installation in "C:\Windows.old". If you then do not agree to the EULA in the Windows 10 setup wizard it rolls back to your old Windows installation. Definitely a dark pattern, because most users may feel that going back is not possible.
- jessaustin 10y ago
- jakebasile 10y agoI upgraded willingly so the deceptive upgrade practices, while deplorable, didn't really affect me. What does affect me is that Microsoft refuses to let me control my computer. - If you turn off Windows Defender Real Time Protection it explicitly tells you "You can turn this off, but if it's off for a while we'll turn it back on". It turns itself on upon next reboot, it seems. - You can't turn off Windows Update. It will always end up downloading new updates. - Once an update is scheduled for a restart you can only delay a few times and it will then force the restart. - You can't remove worthless apps like Microsoft Groove and OneDrive integration. - They are continuing to try to weasel the Windows Store into my life by buying up or forcing exclusives (games), with all the drawbacks of UWP. Microsoft, I promise I know what I'm doing and the risks and benefits of each action I want to perform. I own my hardware, I'd like to control the software I licensed. I am well aware of other OS options and I use Linux & OS X often, but neither can compare to the gaming library available on Windows which is my primary use case for my desktop.
- dimino 10y agoYour last few points are annoying for sure, but the first 3 are the result of 20+ years of Microsoft's poor reputation for security due to its prominence and numerous flaws. I completely sympathize with Microsoft's plight here, and while you might not be among those who are constantly infected, the number of people who do end up having problems is so high that they're willing to lose you as a cost of keeping the other folks safe. We're all safer for this, too, because fewer infected computers on the Internet means fewer proxies for spam and other malignant behavior.
- jakebasile 10y agoI completely understand why this is the default behavior, but there should be an "I'm not a normie" switch somewhere that allows me to control my experience. The Pro edition was originally that way, but as I understand it this is no longer the case and is similarly controlling.
- oz 10y ago
- native 10y agoNot shocking. I'm writing this out of my Ubuntu partition and I'm running Windows 10, forced down my throat to begin with, and it just does what it wants when it wants to. I've had times when I've gone for a break and my laptop has rebooted and installing some updates I wasn't even aware of. And I'm running Windows out of sheer necessity for the time being because I need Illustrator, Photoshop, etc.. But Microsoft has really never cared for the user, more like you'll get what we give you and like it.
- wlesieutre 10y agoI was thinking of dual booting and relegating Windows to gaming, have you had any trouble with your setup? Especially with Windows updates messing up the boot settings or wiping partitions that they shouldn't? Seems particularly risky now that MS is pushing out regular "major updates" like the anniversary update, which get handled like a system reinstall.
- native 10y agoI haven't had any issues at all. The only minor inconvenience I have is needing to hit Esc immediately when my laptop is booting up so I can change what I want to boot into, the default being Windows. Now I'm running all this from an HP laptop that came with UEFI and not BIOS so I had to jump through a few hoops before it worked out.
- kaybe 10y agoThe only issue I had so far was that Mint wouldn't boot because Windows didn't actually shut down as instructed but went into default quick-boot mode, which made the Windows partition unmountable, which by default causes the Mint boot to fail. No other problems so far. I had some issues with UEFI during install as well, but it worked out somehow. Also, it seems that you can still feed the Windows 10 installer a Windows 7 key. I wanted Windows 7 initially, but the computer wouldn't have it.
- pritambaral 10y agoDid you set the Windows partition to automount in `/etc/fstab` in Mint? That would make Mint think that that mount is part of the system, and since the system isn't entirely available, the boot cannot proceed. I suggest you add `nofail` to the mount options, and `nobootwait` on older that Ubuntu-16.04-derived Mint (doesn't run systemd) and `x-systemd.device-timeout=1` on Ubuntu-16.04+-derived Mint (should run systemd)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jalami 10y agoI dual boot on my PC, Ubuntu and Windows. I'm writing this from my Arch laptop. I only drop into Windows if I want to play a Windows-only game, but thankfully that's happening less and less. I've stopped buying games for Windows entirely so I won't have this problem in the future. When I installed Windows10, I did the hour long dance of trying to find all the places where I could turn off tracking, even temporarily. Then I ran this[0] which does a pretty good job in a magic black box kind of way. It's a patch job, I don't recommend using Windows10 as a daily driver or putting too much faith into any gui setting or external patch. Also updates are important. Software developers know maintaining multiple old versions and backporting fixes is more art than science and even with the best intentions is prone to incompleteness. Update your software. If you find you can't because upstream is consistently invasive/lacking/gross, chose a different project or you know... fork. [0]: https://github.com/10se1ucgo/DisableWinTracking https://github.com/10se1ucgo/DisableWinTracking
- milankragujevic 10y agoBecause of their (Microsoft's) bullshit with Windows 10 I had to switch my family to Ubuntu and myself to OS X. Bye bye Microsoft, you won't have any more of mine or my family's data...
- S_A_P 10y agoFramed this way, I cant believe there is no class action lawsuit. I remember my mother in law said she was being asked to upgrade from 8.1. She said she didn't want to. I actually willingly installed win 10, and was across the country. She then called me one day and said "windows 10 installed anyway and I clicked the X to get out of it". At the time I just chalked it up to user error, but thanks MS, now I owe my mother in law an apology.
- jalami 10y agoIANAL, but it looks like when you agree to the Microsoft TOS you waive your right to bring a Class Action suit against Microsoft >Class action lawsuits, class-wide arbitrations, private attorney-general actions, and any other proceeding where someone acts in a representative capacity aren’t allowed. Nor is combining individual proceedings without the consent of all parties. I believe that's why companies are taking MS to small claims for $10,000 despite losing way more than that in downtime. [0]https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/servicesagreement/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/servicesagreement/
- ominous 10y agoIf you read this, you agree to give me 2L of blood every 88 hours, as well as a lock of your firstborn's hair. I agreed to nothing.
- jalami 10y agoSCOTUS seems to disagree with you[0][1]. I try to read or at least skim what I agree to. Some companies have an opt-out of their binding arbitration (eg. Ting), which I try to make use of, but most don't allow you to opt out of the class action waiver. If you don't like the terms, email them and tell the company why you won't sign up. I rarely get a response, but someone on their staff knows there's at least some push back. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT%26T_Mobility_LLC_v._Concepcion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT%26T_Mobility_LLC_v._Concepc... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DIRECTV,_Inc._v._Imburgia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DIRECTV,_Inc._v._Imburgia
- 10y ago
- dman 10y agoI have lost work on Windows 10 because it doesnt seem possible to not have it restart after an update. This behavior being a default from the Windows "Professional Edition" boggles my mind.
- jefe_ 10y agoThe automatic update restarts are the worst. Followed guide here and have not come into work with a restarted computer since (used Method 3): http://www.redmondpie.com/disable-turn-off-automatic-updates-in-windows-10-heres-how/ http://www.redmondpie.com/disable-turn-off-automatic-updates...
- dman 10y agoThanks - just enabled this and will see how things go.
- hendersoon 10y agoOption 1 on that link stops updates from running on their own, but once you update you are forced to reboot. Also I had problems with that solution causing stalling forever on "Installing updates 0%". Option 2 is for hiding specific updates, like broken drivers. Doesn't really apply. Option 3 again will stop updates from installing in the first place, but will not stop reboots once they're installed. Windows 10 completely ignores the "No auto-restart with logged on users" policy from that same group. The only way I have found to stop my computer from rebooting after installing an update is #2 in the link below. This works, 100%. https://superuser.com/questions/973009/conclusively-stop-wake-timers-from-waking-windows-10-desktop/973029#973029 https://superuser.com/questions/973009/conclusively-stop-wak...
- quantos 10y agoThis is the reason why i moved to linux. The path this "new" microsoft have choosen, if they continue to do this, they will certainly lose their market share on PCs in near future and I hope when users will start caring about their rights and privacy, they will move to other OSes.
- mitm2mitm 10y agoLet's be real, "they" won't. A select few might change to a mac, maybe a chromebook, and that's it. Developers are a case apart.
- specialp 10y agoChromeOS is just as bad with spying as Windows 10 (or worse considering how much other information Google has to tie to you. Apple is well on their way to making their upcoming OS similar as well. We live in a world now where most people are conditioned NOT to pay for software, and don't mind being "the product" for free services. For those that do mind being data mined there are fewer and fewer options every day.
- mitm2mitm 10y agoNo shit. I was just trying to avoid the year of the linux desktop meme, since I gave up on that already, while also doubting that "they" are going to ditch Windows.
- nol13 10y agoAnd I'm just one small developer, but I won't be investing my time in .NET and hosting on Azure.
- beamatronic 10y agoI have one remaining Windows 7 license that I would like to set up on a new machine. Is there no way to keep it untainted forever by Windows 10?
- SixSigma 10y agoMine haven't done the update, although they have done the download
- nly 10y agoInstall Never10
- tdicola 10y agoThey aren't doing the free upgrade to 10 offer anymore so you're probably fine. I've been running a 7 instance in a VM for a long time and never had a problem with it upgrading to 10.
- tunap 10y agoProbably not fine... Do not assume that the "Free" expiration stops them from loading 10 in all but name & fugly menu on your back-end through 40+ supposed updates & patches. The telemetry is what they are after, the telemetry is what they will go to almost any length to collect and telemetry is all you are good for... at the moment.
- superkuh 10y agoInstall a neutered pirate version instead of using your license.
- cwyers 10y agoLet me be clear to you. If you do not want to put in the "investment and effort to run just so that I can control my computer" required to actually do the job of administering your PC correctly, but still want all the safety features built into consumer Windows turned off for your benefit anyway, STAY OFF THE SAME INTERENET AS ME. You're the electronic equivelent of someone who refuses to vaccinate their kids but still wants them to go to public schools with my kid. You're going to get us all killed. I hope the ideological purity that comes from letting five different branches of the Russian mob have your telemetry data instead of Microsoft is worth it.
- stevenhuang 10y agoYou have a very... unique view on security.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dang 10y agoPlease don't comment like this here. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12306616 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12306616 and marked it off-topic.
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoAfter the crap associated with the Anniversary Update, I decided to stop threatening to move to Linux every time Microsoft made a consumer-hostile move and just do it, in order to see how feasible the shift would be. Fedora has been fine so far, sans a few hardware-specific issues I've run into. The laptop is certainly better optimized for Windows, which is not surprising. I'm trying to document all of the problems I've run into along the way and the steps to remedy them, in case they are of value to anyone else. The Arch Linux wiki has been great for this sort of thing, even without using Arch.
- anonbanker 10y agoCongratulations on the switch. Ubuntu might be slightly superior to Fedora (you'll outgrow it eventually), but again, congratulations on finally doing so. If you get a whim to tinker, try a KDE-based distribution; it'll feel the most like windows, just with more options to tweak.
- graycat 10y agoGb abbreviates gigabit or gigabyte? What does GB abbreviate? ===================== In update: PLEASE stop down voting me for my simple, nice, courteous reminder to the person who wrote the post I replied to. I was NOT, NOT, NOT, NOT ignorant of the meanings of Gb versus GB and was NOT, NOT, NOT, NOT asking for a tutorial on the difference. I am not an ignorant newby on HN knowing too little to be posting here. Just what I did wrong is beyond all obvious criteria. These attacks are personal, based on my user name and some earlier posts of mine? I did NOTHING, NOTHING, NOTHING wrong. Instead, I was suggesting that maybe the post I responded to was not using Gb versus GB correctly -- MAYBE. I was trying to be subtle and suggesting that the person just review the meanings of Gb versus GB. I DO know very, very well the correct, accepted meanings the two abbreviations. So, for trying to be nice, I get attacked? What kind of hostility is that? MOD, please get involved and correct this. Right, I'm a newby? I've published several peer-revewed papers of original research in computer science and artificial intelligence and taught computer science in graduate school at Ohio State University. I DO know quite a lot of computing. Early in my career I designed and wrote the software that scheduled the fleet at FedEx and literally saved the company -- pleased the BoD and enabled crucial financing. My Ph.D. dissertation in engineering was in software. For one of my contributions in artificial intelligence at the IBM Watson lab, I received an award from IBM. For some other research I did at IBM, I reinvented k-D trees -- a few years earlier, and k-D trees would have been mine. MOD: I've done NOTHING, NOTHING, NOTHING wrong, but I've been severely attacked. The attacks look personal, by paid propagandists attacking me for some old post on some topic the propagandists are paid to fight about. MOD: Please straighten out these attacks.
- yomly 10y agoSome people have connections with download limits. I.e. You can only download 4 gigabytes of data before having your connection throttled or being charged. Some people also tether to mobile internet, which very definitely has download limits. Case in point, I was working on the road a lot this Summer and was using my 4G hotspot. Automatic downloads can very rapidly eat your download limit up whereas browsing and email is unlikely to do so.
- 10y ago
- ap22213 10y agoDoes anyone know what MS does with this data? Is it just for ads?
- overgryphon 10y agoIt's for quality and personalization, not for ads. This is Terry Myerson's blog explanation of data usage. https://blogs.windows.com/windowsexperience/2015/09/28/privacy-and-windows-10/ https://blogs.windows.com/windowsexperience/2015/09/28/priva...
- hendersoon 10y agoThat assumes you believe Microsoft, that they are not deliberately lying to their customers. Not plausible? Microsoft claimed Skype has end-to-end encryption, too. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/12/newly-published-nsa-documents-show-agency-could-grab-all-skype-traffic/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/12/newly-published-n... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/11/microsoft-nsa-collaboration-user-data https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/11/microsoft-nsa-...
- mark_l_watson 10y agoI think that Microsoft could fix this fairly easily: make an easy opt out for Cortana and telemetry, offer more control over security options. I totally sympathize with Microsoft for wanting everyone to be on Windows 10, with continuous updates (security and otherwise). Better for them and long term probably better for users. I don't use OS X anymore but when I did, I liked always being at the latest update. Except for my iPad, I use Ubuntu Linux laptops and like keeping every device up to date. Pardon a tangent, but: society as a whole really needs a "going to the moon" level global project to harden computing devices. As an end user of technology I am willing to keep my devices up to date and I try to be understanding of Apple, Microsft, and Ubuntu (and other Linud distros).
- mitm2mitm 10y agoI wouldn't mind paying twice the price of Windows 10 Pro if I could select what I want installed and the OS respected that. No telemetry, no Cortana, no Windows Stores apps if I need to have a MS account. No missclick-based features (you click yes and suddenly your local account is now an online account). Since I'm stuck with this crap forever (Adobe, Office, games, etc) at least let me pay you not spy on me and install your crapware. And let ME control MY PC.
- M4v3R 10y agoYou do know that both Adobe apps and Office apps are natively available for Mac? Games are still a problem though, but you can dual-boot just for games.
- mitm2mitm 10y agoPersonally, I can't stand OSX. Since running things on Wine or VM end it up being too much of a hassle, Windows is my only option. I did that for a couple of years though.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoI bought a really cheap Windows machine a year ago, curious about Windows 10 (I have Linux on it now). I bought it directly from Microsoft's store, and as a 'signature edition', it had no 3rd party crapware installed.
- joesmo 10y ago"But it’s a shame that Microsoft made users choose between having privacy and security." Great article, but this part is simply wrong. Microsoft chose to remove both. You now have an operating system without security that is known to steal data and install things on its own (malware). How can EFF say this OS is more secure when Microsoft can and does access any data on the system at any time without asking for permissions? When even the permissions dialogs are fake? To classify this as anything but malware would be willful stupidity at this point. It's not that the OS has less security, now it has none. In fact, users running Windows 10 might want to question whether they even own their machines anymore. Physical possession aside, when one no longer controls the software or data on a machine can one be said to own said machine? Can one be held responsible for what it does? What if Microsoft decides to download child porn on everyone's machine? Considering what they've done in the last year, I wouldn't put it past them.
- joonoro 10y agoThe saddest part about it for me is that Windows 10 made some of my friends cynical regarding privacy. If you asked them before they would have at least acknowledged the value of privacy, but now it's just "Why not upgrade to Windows 10? Everything you use is already data-mining you." They see all the bad news about privacy in Windows 10 and I guess that's the only way you can rationalize using it.
- topranks 10y agoYou make me feel bad about it but I find myself saying this kind of thing now. It didn't start with Windows 10 tbh.
- finid 10y agoFolks, Microsoft blatantly disregarding user choice and privacy is not news. What else do you expect from a company that ships at least one backdoor in every software they've ever made? If you understand the true nature of Bill Gates and Steve Ballmer, this should never come as a surprise. It's going to take several generations for the culture to change, that is, if ever...
- maglavaitss 10y agoI guess people shouldn't be speaking while debating if <INSERT-CURRENT-YEAR> is the year of the Linux desktop or not. The choices in life are usually (and i emphasize usually) simple, and this case is no exception. You either discard your privacy and maybe your security and go Windows, or you discard your usability (for some) and go Linux. Or go Mac, FreeBSD, hell, even BeOS or Hurd or whatever floats your boat. But seeing people still bitching about how they can't go over Windows "because I have to play games" well ... it hurts. It really hurts. We should know better.
- jakebasile 10y agoGaming is my passion, my hobby, and by far my largest expense save mandatory things such as my mortgage. I don't understand why this means that I cannot say that Windows 10 is upsetting to me unless I give up a huge part of my identity. It is an unfortunate situation from which there is little recourse for people like me.
- maglavaitss 10y agoI'm not saying people shouldn't play games, hell, I'm a gamer myself. But we have to compromise in life, and when I fire up my Windows VM, I understand all the implications that come out of it: I might get malware, I might get my personal information sent to various sites, my OS might be upgraded to NewWinOs or downgraded to OldCrappyOs automatically and so on. And this is freaking unfortunate for everybody involved, except the big companies like Microsoft, Google, FB, Apple, etc.
- ionised 10y agoThe solution is two separate machines. One Linux machine for all personal computing and dev work, and a Windows machine with Steam on it, and anything else game-related.
- josteink 10y agoAnd to think that before this, people were angry at Microsoft for not providing updates to new versions of Windows free of charge, and free of hastle. Damned if they do. Damned if they don't. But now at least, they'll have a much smaller install base for ancient versions of Windows, so my guess is that even with all this bad PR, it's going to pay off.
- l3m0ndr0p 10y agoBased on my opinion, the reason MS is doing this is to implement "Implied Consent." The information MS is collecting is being used by MS and also by the US Government. MS hands this information over, or at least has it readily available. There's no other purpose for this information to be sent back to a company, other than to build a profile of the user which can be used for anything and everything.
- randiantech 10y agoHonest question here: Why tech community is so hard with Windows mandatory updates, and kind of flexible with other companies? Maybe its just me, but the ratio of posts and articles blaming Microsoft for this practice seems to be disproportional. I mean, my Mac asked me 875 times about accepting something about iTunes. No matter how many times i click on decline, it keeps appearing there all the time. Same thing with Chrome: It got silently updated (just figured it with last update that brought Material Design to the interface). If avoiding updates to a system is kind of a user right, then it would be fair to have an option to stop updates in cloud based systems as well (IE: My email service).
- mitm2mitm 10y agoIMO it does not matter what other people are doing. I'm paying for this software so I want control (over my own hardware). Mobile is a lost cause but I literally can't afford to fight my desktop OS. It must work and be reliable. Maybe I would accept forced security updates if they allowed live updates. Having to restart your computer is awful. But that's not even the worse problem. It reset settings, install things you removed, services you don't want, remove features you had before for no reason. Not to mention drivers and all the update problems people are reporting. If there's a chance to break, I must be able to choose when I want to upgrade. I'm willing to pay more for not having to worry about telemetry, MS account and all that bs.
- kminehart 10y agoRight? That's something about Windows that I hate; having to restart for an update. Microsoft, with it's endless supply of money, is somehow completely incapable of live OS updates? Hell, Linux has live updates; I don't even have to restart to update my kernel! I would expect Microsoft to somehow take this existing technology, cater it to their system and call it a brand new feature like they did with the resizable command prompt. "Look at this revolutionary thing we're doing in Windows 10!" Obviously I'm generalizing or assuming that they would be able to do it; I know nothing of how Windows works. It could be impossible without completely rewriting the entire thing. It's just my ultimate pet peeve about Windows.
- Aldo_MX 10y agoI had to install Windows 8.1 from scratch recently, for the first time in my life I had to review update-per-update what the f%$k did they do, it is depressing that too many updates had something to do with Windows 10 or an increase in telemetry... - KB2976978 - KB3035583 - KB3058168 - KB3068708 - KB3080149 - KB3123862 - KB3173040
- hendersoon 10y agoWin7, 8, and 8.1 updates are moving to cumulative patches next month. Assuming you still patch at all, you will be unable to avoid installing the telemetry on older MS operating systems too. I assume that like Win10, there will be ways to hack around and disable the telemetry there. But you can't avoid installing it in the first place for long.
- Unbeliever69 10y agoLong since stopped using Windows... http://s2.quickmeme.com/img/29/295931841857280419b1d9f99759e4731d0e1f4d16426d9a5d97c7b0713a111e.jpg http://s2.quickmeme.com/img/29/295931841857280419b1d9f99759e...
- noblethrasher 10y agoI hate to say it, but a lot of this stuff was advocated by Butler Lampson (one of heroes)[1]. Basically, he advocated for having at least two computers (which could be virtual machines) labeled “red” and “green”. The red machine is promiscuous, and accepts inputs from anything; whereas the green machine only accepts inputs from “accountable” sources (n.b. this means it wouldn’t accept input from the red machine). Crucially, he says that the green machine, which might have access to sensitive information such as your financial records, would ”require professional management”. The user might be able to make course grain adjustments to qualify what it means to be an accountable source, but in this scheme, the system’s integrity is only assured by allowing the professional administrator to preempt the user. I don’t like it (Win 8 will probably be the last version I use), but since it’s Butler, I have to at least consider that he might be right. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJw2SZPjAfA&feature=youtu.be&t=2123 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJw2SZPjAfA&feature=youtu.be...
- ape4 10y agoMicrosoft let us turn off all the telemetry, Cortina, etc. Please. I don't want to hate you.
- laktak 10y agoPrivacy issues aside, I can't actually trust Windows 10. It shut down twice on me while I was working (to install a mandatory security patch). This OS treats its users like kids who wouldn't know better.
- supernovae 10y agoIf you're a computer "Enthusiast" most of the time you know what's coming (sites like winbeta and neowin post the news) or you would have known how to set the restart time, accept/reject the action center notifications or gracefully finished work to reboot because rebooting in windows only takes about 5 seconds these days.
- puddintane 10y agoI wonder if these moves will push more and more users to go down the pirating path of the Enterprise edition.
- scrupulusalbion 10y agoHonestly, having two computers has been the only way I can sanely function at work. We have to use Windows for at least one application. My solution has been to setup a second desktop (these are small towers), install Linux on it, and remote into the Windows from the Linux machine. Oddly enough, I can actually play some video games on the Windows machine through that remote session. We replace computers two to three times per year; I get to pick from generally four-year old computers. I assume that a second computer is not an option for most at work.
- ryuuchin 10y agoJust for the record if you disabled the Windows 10 update properly[1] I'm pretty sure it would never bother you and you could never accidentally install it. I'm not saying I approve of what Microsoft did with the W10 upgrade but if you were technically competent to change a few registry/group policy options it was never a problem for you. [1] https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/kb/3080351 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/kb/3080351
- bitmapbrother 10y agoSomewhat related - How to turn off Cortana http://www.zdnet.com/article/windows-10-tip-turn-off-cortana-completely/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/windows-10-tip-turn-off-cortana...
- Artlav 10y agoThe saddest part is that no one cares and no one does anything. No protests, no rotten tomatoes into MS manager faces, no uproars or boycotts, not even pathetic stuff like lawsuits. At best a few educated people complain on the internet or brag about moving to Linux. All this does is the evaporative cooling that hardens the cold death grip of a blind company whose moral compass doesn't even point north around the necks of the common folk that notice nothing and wonder why it's getting harder to breath every other year. And no, i'm not smart enough to come up with a solution either...
- oolongCat 10y agoI recently had to install windows 10 on one of my computers. I remember getting to a menu which asked me if I wanted to install the recommended way vs customizing, selected custom and the number of options that could seriously undermine my privacy were insane, a special ID to help 3rd parties (ms certified partners or something they called it) WHAT THE HELL!! Microsoft seriously sucks. Yes I know, the options to turn these things off are there, but the fact that 90% of the people who use ms windows are not even aware of these options is insane. And couple that with the soul sucking updates,Jesus Christ windows 10 is just a big no no. As for the updates, you should seriously consider disabling the windows update service using the admin privileges. Especially if you are using a rate limited internet connection or hate having to wait 10-15 mins for your computer to shutdown or startup.
- gsmethells 10y agoThey are trying to fix their fragmented OS version pie chart problem like it was a fragged up Win 95 hard drive. Feels about as fun, too.
- Snesker 10y agoHacker News: shills and the bluepills who eat their shit.
- Bitedge 10y agoPersonally I will never by windows anything again. Unix all the way.
- altern8 10y agoThe reality is that no one is going to adbandon Windows, no matter what Microsoft do. Windows 8 is proof of that.
- hlfcoding 10y agoI clicked for a deep dive. Not what I expected.