14 ms·
The Shame of Palo Alto: An Interview with Kate Downing on Affordable Housing
- jseliger 10y agoRelatedly: "More housing density keeps Seattle affordable for younger residents:" http://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/more-housing-density-keeps-seattle-affordable-for-younger-residents/ http://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/more-housing-density-kee.... Seattle is doing better than SF or NYC: http://www.vox.com/2015/12/23/10657690/seattle-housing-crisis http://www.vox.com/2015/12/23/10657690/seattle-housing-crisi... but still not good enough. Tokyo should be its example: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3c60.html http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3c....
- ryporter 10y agoI moved from Palo Alto to Seattle in 2014. One factor was cost of living (including taxes), but another was that Seattle had a large number of very nice, relative new high rise apartments. I had my pick of great apartments, while in Palo Alto such apartments simply don't exist. The housing problem in Palo Alto is not simply one of affordability. It's also a problem of desirability among those with the means to pay.
- hkmurakami 10y agoIt seems that we made a pact with the devil by positioning housing as an investment asset. By doing so, we've encouraged people to commit a very large fraction of their net worth into a rather illiquid asset, tying their financial fates to the future assessment of that asset. As a result, protecting the price and appreciation of this asset has come to overshadow the other crucial roles that housing plays in our society. If I bought shares in AAPL at $50 (now $100+) and someone comes along asking that AAPL let them buy some shares for say, $65, I'm obviously not going to be happy since the value of my investment is under threat. This is the kind of reaction we've unfortunately promoted for ourselves. It didn't have to be this way, as other countries have shown us. But now that we're here, it's hard to imagine a way to turn back time.
- vtange 10y agoIt's a double whammy when you also consider that property taxes are generally based on real estate value. City and local governments are dependent on that income and have little incentive to see real estate values (and thus tax) go down.
- hkmurakami 10y agoThat would depend on the price elasticity of the existing housing stock in response to each additional unit of housing that is supplied to the market. It's conceivable that the marginal decrease in tax revenue from the existing stock would be more than offset by the additional tax revenue from the one additional unit.
- maerF0x0 10y agoAlso governments get tax not on the value of a single property but the cumulative value of the properties (emphasis on the plurality) . If my 1M house gets replaced with 10x 250k units the government has 2.5x its tax base. See how affordability and solid tax base can coincide?
- Retric 10y agoLocal government costs also go up as population increases.
- mjmahone17 10y agoThe relationship is not usually linear, though. With density comes efficiency in services. Though some of that efficiency is eaten by the additional cost of doing the work.
- Retric 10y agoNot really teachers are linear with population size. An overpass is vastly more expensive than a stoplight and still cheaper than a subway system. So, yes for small changes to population size a city need not spend more an can simply degrade services slightly, but doubling population size quickly gets really expensive.
- ChuckMcM 10y ago"Downing and her husband, an attorney and programmer, respectively, say they simply could not afford to pay almost $150,000 per year for housing alone while starting a family in Palo Alto." It's interesting the difference a couple of miles make. $150,000 per year is $12,500 a month. The most expensive house for rent in East Palo Alto (3 miles away) is $6,000 (half that) and there are many choices under $4,000 per month. They could live in Gilroy and ride the train for free[1] for around $3,000 a month. They could do even better if they decided to rent an apartment or a townhouse instead of a detached single family home. Whining about not being able to afford to live in a neighborhood where multi-millionaires want to live is not very productive. Unlike San Francisco there are a lot of housing options up and down the peninsula, and since they work (or used to) in Palo Alto it is extremely close to the train station (so an easy "no drive") commute, which saves them even more because the City pays for their rail ticket and they don't have to buy gas. [1] https://www.cityofpaloalto.org/civicax/filebank/documents/40189 https://www.cityofpaloalto.org/civicax/filebank/documents/40...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mbreese 10y agoThe $150,000 number is the cost of the mortgage needed to buy a home the size of the one they rented in Palo Alto [1]. The breakdown was that they rented the home with another couple for $6200/mo. If they wanted to buy a similar home, it would cost ~ $2.7M, thus the $12.5k/mo mortgage. They were already renting a place in Palo Alto at ~ $3100/mo. Their problem was that they wanted to start a family and needed more space. Doing so in Palo Alto was prohibitively expensive. I don't think that she was whining about not being able to live in a neighborhood where multi-millionaire lived. It was about being able to establish roots anywhere in the Palo Alto area. It's all but impossible and it will become harder and harder to run a city where all of the labor force needs to be imported (police, teachers, city gov't, etc). I know this is already starting to become an issue with some departments at Stanford where it's very difficult to recruit/keep faculty and postdocs due to the cost of living in the immediate area. [1] https://shift.newco.co/letter-of-resignation-from-the-palo-alto-planning-and-transportation-commission-f7b6facd94f5 https://shift.newco.co/letter-of-resignation-from-the-palo-a...
- stretchwithme 10y agoNeither Hilliary nor Trump will stop feeding this monster.
- ermterm 10y agoAs much as I appreciate all these articles expounding the plethora of issues stemming from housing in the Bay Area, I can't help but feel thoroughly discouraged. It seems that despite an abundance of chatter, we'll never see any change. If things were going to be fundamentally different, any time soon, we'd see indications of that. Instead it's just articles. Articles, on articles, on articles.
- davidw 10y agoThe sfyimby people are quite active - they go to local meetings, get out the vote and otherwise engage with the political process.
- lindenksv1 10y agoDon't be discouraged! YIMBY groups are popping up all over the Bay Area working to make a difference in their cities. Join a group's mailing list and show up at your city council when they ask you to. Easy. Bring enough friends and we'll see real change. Live in Palo Alto: paloaltoforward.com Live in Menlo Park? www.imaginemenlo.com Mountain View? http://balancedmv.org/ http://balancedmv.org/ San Francisco? http://www.sfbarf.org/ http://www.sfbarf.org/ Some headlines: http://gizmodo.com/yimby-groups-are-organizing-across-the-us-to-make-citie-1771699132 http://gizmodo.com/yimby-groups-are-organizing-across-the-us... https://nextcity.org/daily/entry/who-are-yimby-first-meeting-boulder https://nextcity.org/daily/entry/who-are-yimby-first-meeting... http://www.forbes.com/sites/scottbeyer/2016/06/30/what-is-a-yimby/#6345d767b597 http://www.forbes.com/sites/scottbeyer/2016/06/30/what-is-a-...
- ryporter 10y agoI think that California will eventually be forced to change as more and more people migrate to states to like Washington. The data only goes through 2010, but the Tax Foundation has a nice table for net migrations from state to state. [1] Also, anecdotally, try call up a moving company and inquiring about a move from the Bay Area to Seattle. The typical response I received was, "Oh, no problem. We have a steady stream of trucks moving people up there." [1] http://interactive.taxfoundation.org/migration/ http://interactive.taxfoundation.org/migration/
- maerF0x0 10y agoSeems to be the same old story we've long known. Government interference in markets leads to distortions. Yet year after year we act surprised. And when it comes time to setting up a government, we vote for the person who promises to spend others' money on our pet project.
- jhanschoo 10y agoI'm tired of hearing the ideological position that government interference is absolutely bad. I live in a city-state where government housing and policies and strict zoning at once makes housing affordable for the middle and lower class insulated from fluctuating rents, and protects public spaces from overdevelopment in a land-scarce island.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoI'm curious to here more about how this policy works. I would be skeptical that the claim that a land-scarce island should be wary of overdevelopment-- I would think sprawl would be more dangerous (and density would be welcomed). In practice, strict zoning tends to create sprawl-- when density is outlawed, the displaced people need to live somewhere... and thus the footprint of cities grows wider and wider.
- jhanschoo 10y agoSorry for the late response. The city in question is Singapore. The homeless population is extremely tiny in Singapore, but the homeless choose to live in public spaces and parks near urban centers due to the proximity of services. When I say zoning, very little space is zoned as low-density in Singapore. Where there are buildings, they are almost high-density. However, the government owns a large proportion of the land, and this preserves and protects common pool resources like parks from being developed on.
- xapata 10y agoYou're right in one sense -- all government (in)actions should be considered, not an "interference" per se, but a choice made with at least some understanding of the consequences on society. As for the problem of interfering with the market... One issue is that a well-functioning market depends on the idea that price captures all information. This is central to the idea of the "invisible hand" guiding individuals to arrive at the correct level of supply to optimally satisfy demand. When government actions set prices, the market participants no longer receive the correct information. In turn, the market will arrive either at too much supply (and waste) or too little supply (and unsatisfied demand). In the case of housing, the government usually takes action to set prices for some homes lower than what market forces would arrive at. Therefore, the market will under-supply and some folks who want housing will not have it. The answer is to either allow prices to move without intervention or for the government to subsidize the supply of housing.
- vadym909 10y agoI'm surprised that none of the YCs startups have tried to solve this problem. People really want 'affordable housing' and YC's motto to its startups is to 'make something people want'- so what gives?
- tachyonbeam 10y agoHousing is not just an app... I'd like to see someone mass produce stackable prefabricated units out of pieces and assemble them into multi-floor apartment buildings, increasing the number of aparments on offer very fast and driving costs down. Unfortunately, I think the problem here comes down to regulations. It's hard to acquire land. Much of the bay area has laws preventing you from building new housing much higher than a few floors. The property taxes are very high, which also makes it difficult to offer low cost housing. My general impresion is that the bay area does not want to grow... Or at least, much of the existing homeowners, the NIMBY crowd, don't want it to grow. They want tech people to get out and for things to go back to how they were in the 1980s, while maintaining the price of their own homes as high as possible.
- geekbeast 10y agoLike this? http://www.abc10.com/news/local/sacramento/modular-apartments-stacking-up-in-sacramento/205520901 http://www.abc10.com/news/local/sacramento/modular-apartment...
- tachyonbeam 10y agoYes, like that, except I think you could make the process even more efficient. Make the modular units more "plug-n-play". Maybe even make them replaceable, so if an apartment is old and damaged, a new unit can relatively easily be swapped into its place and the old one recycled.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoHousing prices depend on availability, and housing density is controlled by regulation. No amount of innovation can fix a zoning problem.
- fhrui 10y agoI found these whining hypocritical and snobbish. I can't afford a house in Palo Alto even if I work there. I don't complain about it just like I don't complain about not being able to purchase a luxury car. I don't expect the people who CAN afford these things to just lower the price and give them to me. Many cities near Palo Alto have houses at a reasonable price, East Palo Alto, East Menlo Park, Mountain View, Redwood City, just to name a few. Why doesn't the author want to raise her kids there? BECAUSE SHE DOESN"T WANT HER KIDS TO GO TO SCHOOL WITH THE AVERAGE JOE! She wants her kids to go to a school where Joe Millionaires send their kids, while only paying the price of an average Joe. How could that be possible? Her mentality is the same as that of the people she's accusing of not making a change. She just makes less money and she's loud.
- ScottBurson 10y agoYour theory doesn't explain why she's moving to Santa Cruz -- the schools are nothing special there.
- lindenksv1 10y agoWe're moving to Santa Cruz because we wanted to live in a walkable area. If you travel up and down the peninsula, any house near the walkable downtown area is going to be $2M+. Yeah, sure, you can buy for less and have to travel by car absolutely everywhere. But why spend $1.5 to live in a dead cul de sac when you can spend the same money to live in a lively walkable area near the beach? If you're going to hang an albatross around your neck, you better think it's awesome. We're sick of driving everywhere and we want our kids to be able to go bike around the neighborhood safely.
- ScottBurson 10y agoYou're preaching to the choir :-) I lived in Santa Cruz for 13 years, and I would love to go back -- except that commuting to Sunnyvale would be hell.
- geekbeast 10y agoRedwood City has a lot of nice houses near the downtown for under $2M
- will_brown 10y agoWhile it is fine to call out the City Council, I am surprised there wasn't an acknowledgment that the City Council is a reflection of the will of the people in the City. If it were really an issue to the community they would elect new Council persons. Since the majority of the stakeholders on this issue likely can't vote to change the Council because they don't live in the City, I would recommend a boycott. One thing the transit workers could do is organize to the extent they don't buy anything within the city limits. No gas, no food/lunch, no shopping, no entertainment, etc... Once you get local business behind a political issue the rest typically fall in line or they may find themselves ostracized within their own community.
- lindenksv1 10y agoThe problem with the "will of the people" is outlined here pretty well: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/08/10/why-cities-need-to-care-more-about-works-in-them-not-just-who-lives-in-them/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/08/10/why-c... A small minority of NIMBY homeowners can capture and control a city council fairly easily. When you are well off (and are retired or independently wealthy and don't work...) and you're in a town of 65,000, that really means there are maybe at most 1000 people actually going to City Council and paying any attention to it. That means that if you've lived there for 30 years, you know all of them and your networks are very deep. So, a small minority who has time and resources can effect a lot. And meanwhile young people, working people, people with young kids, people working 2-3 jobs, etc they're not paying attention, they don't have those deep networks, and frankly they only show up to vote in presidential elections. Plus, people who like how things are going, don't really dig into this stuff and have no reason to think anything is wrong. If you think Palo Alto "is on fire" and "going to hell in a hand basket" because you have to drive by a new apartment building, then you show up to council and you show up to vote. But if you have no issue with new buildings, you've got no reason to show up and you're far less concerned with voting. So, problem #1 is that people who are most affected are not paying attention or do not know that they should be paying attention. Problem #2 is as outlined in the article above. When every city council is captured by existing homeowners, no town decides to add housing. Every town prefers to add jobs that bring in tax revenues but thinks they have little to gain from allowing more housing, because of the attendant infrastructure costs (like new schools). And so collectively, they make choices that drive up the cost of housing, drive people away from jobs centers, create homelessness, and which contribute to income inequality as people spend more and more money on housing because of an artificial constraint on housing supply. Added together, this stuff hurts our economy and it's killing off the middle class.
- youngButEager 10y agoThe east coast of the USA was settled first, recall. What did they do back east to 'solve' this problem of "we're running out of space"? They increased the density of occupants per unit of land -- they built UPWARD. That will have to happen here too. It's already happened in LA. There will always be crybabies like this attorney during the growing pains of a popular 'destination city.' For now, think of turning the Peninsula into tall buildings, concrete and asphalt. Think how the picturesque drive up highway 280 to San Francisco from the South Bay will be affected. Everyone wants the nature. Not the tall buildings, concrete and asphalt. Crybabies need to do precisely what this gal chose -- LEAVE. There's the door. That's how markets work -- when the price of a good or service is too high, demand drops. Well, she's a living example of a smidgen of demand disappearing. People who don't like markets should move to Venezuela or North Korea or Cuba.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoWhat you're missing here is that the market delivers rent to the holders of a natural resource (land) far in excess to its marginal product-- which is to say economic rent. Landowners in the Bay Area are rentiers, and unless we enact policy to reverse this, we'll never have a competitive market in housing.
- lindenksv1 10y agoThere is no free market in housing. Supply is very tightly constrained by the city via a system of very stringent zoning (3 stories max most of the city, only 3% of the city is even zone for multifamily housing) and taxes. What you see happening in the Bay Area isn't the result of the laws of supply and demand, it's the result of the laws passed by city councils. There's no developer in the world who wouldn't love to build more housing in one of the most booming places in the country. They're not not doing it because it doesn't make financial sense or because there's no demand there. They're not doing it because the housing market in the Bay Area has been regulated to death.
- youngButEager 10y agoIt does not matter, the 'supply being constrained' point. Let's say that Palo Alto allows high-density housing. Will that solve the housing supply issue? No. You missed the point about the east coast having been settled first in the USA. And the point about LA. Both of those regions allow high density housing. Would Palo Alto housing drop in price? NO. The only way to solve Palo Alto's housing problem is -- MAKE IT NO LONGER A DESTINATION. Turn it into a non-destination locale, like -- say -- Stockton. Or Vallejo. Or Compton. Or Watts. Or Detroit. The desire to live in 'destination cities' like back east, or LA, or Palo Alto is UNQUENCHABLE. It doesn't matter how much supply there is -- IT'S A DESTINATION. People shun Stockton -- at least compared to Palo Alto. Stockton has cheap housing. Many fewer people want to live there. If Palo Alto could suddenly pop up a few skyscrapers of apartments and condos, that supply would be taken up quickly. The same is true for San Francisco. The desire to live in a destination city is like the desire to date a hot young gal. Unquenchable. If one hot young gal moved to Man Jose, the sausage fest of the South Bay, and ran a short TV ad, "I'm ready for dates and I won't be picky, just be nice" guys would come from outside San Jose to get access to that 'destination.' Stockton is a plain, unattractive object of desire. Palo Alto is a gorgeous, extremely attractive object of desire. Adding more housing to beautiful Palo Alto will increase the number of eligible suitors dramatically -- and the added supply will not save this crybaby lawyer at all. >"There is no free market in housing." Not true. Go visit large geographic areas that are not 'destination cities' like Stockton; Modesto; Vallejo. The entire state of Wyoming has a total population of only 564,000 people. Wyoming has an extremely free market in housing. And there are free markets in housing in Destination Cities too. The City leadership is smart enough to know that a 'Destination City' has an unquenchable demand and faces a choice of: - median home price of $2,700,000 with current population - median home price of $2,700,000 with (current population + all those new arrivals who will quickly buy any new housing) City leadership knows that adding supply will NOT lower housing prices. It will just make Palo Alto more crowded and grouchy.
- davidw 10y agoRelevant: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/collective-land-ownership-in-palo-alto.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/col... http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/laissez-faire-in-tokyo.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/lai... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/08/10/why-cities-need-to-care-more-about-works-in-them-not-just-who-lives-in-them/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/08/10/why-c... http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/04/business/how-anti-growth-sentiment-reflected-in-zoning-laws-thwarts-equality.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/04/business/how-anti-growth-s... http://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2016-07-27/zoning-has-had-a-good-100-years-and-that-s-plenty http://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2016-07-27/zoning-has... Get involved: http://sfyimby.com http://sfyimby.com http://www.strongtowns.org http://www.strongtowns.org
- Animats 10y agoPalo Alto has the problem that people don't leave. It used to be a college town. University Avenue had four bookstores. But then people stopped moving away. About a decade ago, Palo Alto did a survey of residents to find out how long they intended to live where they were. Most said they intended to live there for the rest of their life. This implies Palo Alto becoming a retirement community. University Avenue now has zero bookstores.
- kleiba 10y agoBookstores are certainly disappearing in other cities as well due to economic pressure from online vendors and ebook readers.
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoNot just Palo Alto but California-wide....Prop 13 makes dying of old age in the home you raised your children in the cheapest option. Literally anywhere else people move to, even a downsize, will result in higher property taxes Related to this is the shabby conditions of many homes...the aged can't afford to renovate, but they also can't afford to move. They die in a tear-down
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ben_jones 10y agoIs living in the Bay Area a privilege or a right?
- ctulek 10y agoThat is the core of this discussion I believe. Bay Area is really hot as a place to live and many real estate investors are very much aware of that. I can assure you that most of the new housing put there just becomes a big target for the investors. I believe most of new housing won't be available to low income families but immediately go to the real estate hunters. Right now, there is a huge global market hungry to invest to Bay Area. In that respect, I support the housing is limited, instead we should push more public transportation, we should push more on new hot zones for commercial zones, outside of the current ones. This is the best way to balance housing and traffic.
- lindenksv1 10y agoIt's not a privilege or a right. But it's a smart policy that will make us all richer, healthier, and more environmentally friendly. You can read more here: https://medium.com/b-copy-com-longform-content/why-can-t-those-people-move-to-be7f70e8ff91#.b5l2b7f3p https://medium.com/b-copy-com-longform-content/why-can-t-tho...
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoWe'll kill the golden goose and eventually companies will leave. They can't afford to pay workers 3x the competitive rate just to support housing costs.
- bluthru 10y agoThe person who cleans your office's bathrooms shouldn't be burdened with a long commute.
- jurassic 10y agoI get depressed every time I think about the Bay Area housing situation. As half of an early-30s professional couple looking at our baby clock and anxious to start a family, I don't see how I can possibly provide a middle-class lifestyle for children while staying here. The choices are to join the bleeding edge of gentrification by moving into a slum like East Palo Alto or commit to severely degraded quality of life that comes with a megacommute. I don't mind leaving and I probably will, but I do resent it when people act like two highly-educated and gainfully employed young people wanting to live where they work is some kind of unreasonable millennial self-entitlement.
- lisper 10y agoWanting to live where you work is not "unreasonable millennial self-entitlement", but wanting to live in PA is. PA is one of the best places on earth. That makes it a scarce commodity. A lot more people want to live there than can possibly live there without fundamentally changing what makes it a nice place to live in the first place. If everyone who wanted to live in PA did it wouldn't be PA any more, it would be Westwood.
- davidw 10y agoIf some of the area were more like this: https://goo.gl/maps/h6VUZB7hVZs https://goo.gl/maps/h6VUZB7hVZs Wouldn't it still be a pretty desirable place to live because of access to so many things, high paying jobs, a great climate, etc....?
- ScottBurson 10y agoKim-Mai Cutler's excellent and thorough analysis from a couple of years ago [0] is still broadly relevant, though I think there have been some changes -- the whole Google bus thing blew over, I guess, and Mountain View's city council got largely replaced, the new council being more housing-friendly. But there's still a lot in here that's applicable. ETA: Oh, and here's a great piece on Henry George [1]. [0] https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ [1] https://techcrunch.com/2016/01/29/nothing-like-this-has-ever-happened-before/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/01/29/nothing-like-this-has-ever...
- _ph_ 10y agoWe see the same problem here in Europe, maybe to a less extreme extend. We have a few economy hotspots with rapidly raising real estate prices. One fundamental problem is, that those people, who could change things have litte interest in changes. Homeowners like to see their property value rising and for cities life is easier without a growing population. If one says: let free markets take care of that, the problem is exactly that there are no free markets. A free market would mean, that anyone owning a piece of land could build there without limitations. But zoning laws and building size regulations prevent exactly that. As a consequence, building permits have exploded in value like taxi concessions once did. They are no longer tied to the economy of building/owning a cab, but of a limited market. Munich is one of the most expensive cities in Germany, but it is closely surrounded by farmland. The housing problem could be solved easily, if more of it were allowed for building. But as this happens only at a very small speed, land value can multiplay up to 100x when a building permit is issued. This multiplier shows how skewed the market is.
- narrator 10y agoNo owner of an oil company wants to live next to a refinery. No owner of an auto plant wants to live next to the plant. In the Industrial era, owners wanted to live far away from where the work was done because it was ugly and polluted. This created the suburban pattern and cheap housing close to work for workers. This is basically Oakland. Rich Tech entrepreneurs, executives, highly paid programmers, and VCs want to live close to the tech "factory" and they want it to be a nice place. They don't care where everyone else who works there lives, just as long as they don't screw up their nice neighborhood with excess traffic, pollution and density. It's as simple as that. All this stuff about economic policy and zoning laws and the general decline of western civilization is a whole lot of overanalyzing, IMHO.
- whack 10y agoI used to live in Silicon Valley for many years. Devil's advocate: Why should Palo Alto provide affordable housing? People who want affordable housing can find it in Menlo Park, East-PA, Mountain View, all of which are just minutes away from Palo Alto. The reason why people don't want to live there, is because they want to live in a neighborhood that's as exclusive/upscale as Palo Alto. And yet, if Palo Alto gave in to demands for Affordable Housing, it would lose that very upscale/exclusivity that people are seeking in the first place. I've always argued that San Francisco needs more affordable housing, because it's not just a neighborhood, it's a city. Anyone who lives outside of SF has to expend considerable effort in getting to SF, hence why the city has a duty to provide affordable housing within the city. However, this argument doesn't apply to Palo Alto. It might be a city, logistically speaking, but given its small size and extremely close proximity to other "cities" around it, it's really more of a neighborhood than a city. And I don't see the evil in having some neighborhoods within a metro area that are more upscale/exclusive than others.
- khuey 10y agoNone of those places are affordable anymore, with the possible exception of parts of East Palo Alto (and even that pool is drying up fast). The problem with your logic is that just about every city on the peninsula has decided it can be the "exclusive/upscale" neighborhood in the region. And the ones that aren't on board with that can't possibly make enough of a dent in the regional jobs/housing imbalance on their own to matter. Thus people commuting to Palo Alto from Gilroy and Tracey.