11 ms·
Tabby's star is dimming at an incredible rate
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI really like mysteries like this one. They defy simple explanations and force us to work harder to learn more about our world. Sort of like the bright spots on Ceres, which are still pretty awesome.
- okket 10y agoPlease correct the title, it is about a Tabby's star, not alien megastructures.
- sctb 10y agoThanks, we updated the title. We're happy to change it again if someone can suggest a better one.
- aarmenante 10y ago> In the meantime, we would remind you that it's very, very unlikely that this strange flickering star has anything to do with aliens (and is even more exciting if it doesn't - because, hello new space phenomena!). I think aliens would be a little bit more exciting... Might just be me though.
- zackya89 10y agothat headline though ?, online journalism at its worst, the chase for clicks, there really needs to be some solution to this problem journalism is dying and clickbait is where is at.
- sago 10y agoI think a big part of the answer is not to care. Or rather to just silently auto-discount. Imagine the 60s-90s and advertising just overwhelm with sexualised figures. We don't notice, because we just silently pass by. I don't see any way of turning back the tide of hyperbolic titles on articles. Better to just ignore them and move on. Buzzfeed headlines worked on me the first few times, now I know not to go there.
- kfrz 10y agoYeah, this is what I do to a tee. I just say "well, can't credit them as a reliable source of quality journalism." Then I move on and find some coherent research on what I need to know.
- digitalengineer 10y agoFB is working on this. If misleading title > lower ranking score.
- noiv 10y agoI hope one day title bashing turns into a global no-ads movement.
- nine_k 10y agoA global "we pay for the content" movement? Would be interesting.
- civilian 10y ago"Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence", and this is the weirdest star we've seen. Your claims of clickbait are out of line, because we really don't know and alien megastructures is a reasonable theory. And 'alien megastructures' isn't even the most ridiculous idea: https://www.reddit.com/r/KIC8462852/comments/4w7qfi/ben_montetjoshua_simon_paper/d65t063 https://www.reddit.com/r/KIC8462852/comments/4w7qfi/ben_mont...
- jimmytidey 10y agoThis is an amazing theory. What could possibly be more out there than alien life? Alien life in a gigantic spaceship accidentally coming between you and a star.
- echelon 10y agoWould it be "accidental" if they were traveling in a direct vector approaching us? Incredibly implausible idea for the sheer improbability, but fun to imagine nevertheless.
- erelde 10y agoI would think that by the time they actually move some meaningful distance, their sun would not be 'behind' them anymore, they'd still be moving toward ours, but as the whole thing is constantly moving, their sun would have moved relative to ours.
- api 10y agoWould it actually be a straight line? Going from e.g. Earth to Mars does not consist of aiming for Mars and firing your rockets. It consists of hitting a parabolic transfer orbit and then doing another burn to place yourself in Mars' orbit -- or just heading right in if you've got the heat shields and retropropulsion for that. Basically you do orbital mechanics like Wayne Gretzky: you don't go to where the planet is, but where it's going to be. Would interstellar flight be that different? Wouldn't you be executing a "transfer orbit" about the galactic center? Or is the effect of galactic-scale gravitational pull negligible there and you just end up basically going straight from A to B? Edit: turns out this came from an actual subreddit dedicated to this star! https://www.reddit.com/r/KIC8462852/ https://www.reddit.com/r/KIC8462852/ Subscribed!
- olympusmons 10y agoLets brainstorm. Perhaps one mathematical solution to the problem is to score pages based on the average time spent for each article. My hypothesis is that clickbait articles will score very low because the article will attract a lot of clicks from people who are not interested in the actual content but only the headline. In theory, you could do this by deploying a tracker across the web similar to a Google analytics that performs the measurement. But in practice, of course, this isn't possible. You might be able to approximate the score by building a browser extension that makes the measurement. A browser extension might also a good way to output results. It could, for instance, colour-code links (on mouseover) to help you spot click-bait before you click it!
- brownbat 10y agoThere's a plugin for Wikipedia where if you hover over a linked term, it will show the first paragraph from that article, usually all you need. We just need something like that for the web.
- olympusmons 10y agoI like your solution because it doesn't (necessarily) require a backend and would therefore be much simpler to implement. There are several libraries that extract article text reasonably well. I believe browser extensions are written mainly in HTML/JS/CSS. Would the following node library suffice? https://github.com/ageitgey/node-unfluff https://github.com/ageitgey/node-unfluff There's just the question of retrieval speed. I suspect simple HTML retrieval is an order of magnitude faster than normal page rendering due to ads, javascript, etc. So the client-only solution you've proposed might indeed be sufficient!
- kalleboo 10y agoI use QuickLook in Safari on OS X and iOS like that (OS X: triple-finger-tap to get a link preview, iOS: Force touch). It only gets ruined by those "subscribe!" full screen popups.
- j_m_b 10y agoCould an astronomer weigh in as to why the dimming effect isn't due to a 'rogue' blackhole entering orbit with the star and both blocking light and draining material from the star? I haven't seen that hypothesis dismissed yet.
- simcop2387 10y agoNot entirely sure why, but I suspect because they haven't been able to determine if there's any lensing going on of the star that you'd expect to see if something like that entered the system. But I do believe that they'd see higher energy (x-ray, gamma?) bursts if it was removing material from the star which would lead to a different kind of variability. We know roughly what that should look like because of other binary systems where one star is being consumed and I don't think I've seen anyone say this looks a bit like that. Though I'd love to have someone that's actually knowledgeable on the subject to weigh in and tell me how wrong I have this.
- antognini 10y agoThere wouldn't be any observed lensing because you have to be the right distance between the lens and the source for that to be observed. (For objects of comparable mass, the lens has to be roughly halfway in between the source and the observer) But if there were a black hole accreting matter from the host star, there would be an accretion disk which would be visible in X-ray. A black hole is also too small to explain the drop in brightness. That would require something planet-sized, but a black hole is only about the size of a city.
- jddjdbdbd3 10y agoSo it's flickering rapidly and slowly dimming. Perhaps it's because they are completing more of the dyson sphere.
- eudox 10y ago>What they saw was that, not only did the star's light output occasionally dip by 20 percent - the weird behaviour scientists first spotted last year - but over the course of the observations, its entire stellar flux actually dimmed. It would be interesting if this turned out to be like the OnOff star from A Deepness in the Sky.
- Symmetry 10y agoIt's not like this is right on our doorstep but I'd still be more comfortable if this was happening more than 1480 light years away.
- djcapelis 10y agoSo we could find out about it even later? :)
- lucb1e 10y agoWell whatever it is, we probably have 1000+ years to save ourselves right? If whatever caused it comes at us at 50% light speed, which sounds unlikely given how fast that already is, we'd still have 700 years. I'm pretty sure that if human's resources were suddenly all turned towards getting the hell out of here, we could certainly pull it off for a good part of the population in a few hundred years. Whether we'd eventually survive, after decades or centuries in space (before we manage to find and arrive at a new planet, if any), is something I'm less certain about, but I'd still estimate the odds to be fairly okay, especially with 1000+ years to prepare.
- jerf 10y ago"Well whatever it is, we probably have 1000+ years to save ourselves right?" No. That time has already passed. If we see signs that the star will go nova "in one year", we have one year, not 1481. The popular idea that we see "the past" in the sky is not really the best way to think about it. It is far more accurate to say that there is no such thing as "the" present, and what we see in the sky really is our present. The view that we're seeing "the past" is ironically perhaps less sophisticated than the more naive idea that it is simply our present we are seeing in the sky. (And at the moment, there aren't any other "presents" that we much care about.) The thing that really saves us is that even supernovas that far away can't really hurt us because of the inverse square law. A quick Google search shows one site estimating that a supernova would have to be 50 ly or closer or so: http://www.howitworksdaily.com/could-a-supernova-destroy-earth/ http://www.howitworksdaily.com/could-a-supernova-destroy-ear... Something would have to be beamed specifically at us, and the only natural phenomena I know that can do that are black holes and pulsars, neither of which seem to be what is at that star, and probably still wouldn't be powerful enough to hurt us at that distance.
- DiabloD3 10y agoWould plasma cosmology explain this?
- messe 10y agoNot in the slightest.
- sneezeplease 10y agoThe earth is flat and stationary and all stars are lights in the firmament. This is the truth.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- simcop2387 10y agoTwo reddit discussion that might be able to answer some questions we have here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Astronomy/comments/4waozn/new_paper_on_tabbys_star_no_known_or_proposed/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Astronomy/comments/4waozn/new_paper... https://www.reddit.com/r/KIC8462852/comments/4w7qfi/ben_montetjoshua_simon_paper/ https://www.reddit.com/r/KIC8462852/comments/4w7qfi/ben_mont... They also contain links to the resulting paper itself
- fjarlq 10y agoReddit user sigbjoernwilderness's idea is pretty wild... can it be easily ruled out? > Is this the last remaining explanation after Montet/Simon? > The dimming comes from the shadow of a spaceship traveling on an (almost) straight line from KIC8462852 to Earth. The slow continuous dimming results from the increase of the apparent size of the approaching ship while Earth/Kepler is in the penumbra. The irregular dips happen when Kepler accidentally passes the antumbra. A rough estimation by simple geometry would suggest that the alien spaceship is quite big (> 100 km diameter), significantly slower than light velocity (< 0.05 c) and has now almost reached its goal (< 2 ly away), arriving at Earth within the next 100 years after a journey of several 10,000 years. (cf. http://archimedes.soup.io/post/632873371/ http://archimedes.soup.io/post/632873371/) The c200 days of "rapid decreased flux" between Kepler-day 1100 and 1300 (first half of 2012) which Monet/Simon reported, followed by a series of large dips after day 1500, would suggest a course correction with the space ship now on its final homing trajectory. -- Comments? -- https://www.reddit.com/r/KIC8462852/comments/4w7qfi/ben_montetjoshua_simon_paper/d65t063 https://www.reddit.com/r/KIC8462852/comments/4w7qfi/ben_mont...
- imaginenore 10y agoHow can a ship 100 km in diameter cause any significant dimming of a star, which is 21,980,000 km in diameter? It would have to be pretty close to here and lined up just so perfectly. Why even assume it's a spaceship and not an asteroid or a rogue planet?
- civilian 10y ago
- mjevans 10y agoI don't recall the previous discussions, but without outright ruling out possibilities for things... * If it is some structure being built at/around the star, has anyone done the math on the rate of such a structure occluding the star from us to match the observed rate of change? * On a similar line of reasoning, what if the star were either being drained as a power source or caught in some kind of SG1 (that stargate TV series) level disaster? To be clear, I don't think that they're likely, but I'd rather they were eliminated for an obvious actual flaw instead of simply being unlikely.
- gp7 10y agoPretty cool that observed phenomena in space that can't yet be explained gets so much attention in the media. When you step back a bit and stop thinking about aliens
- jhbadger 10y agoReminds me of when quasars were first discovered and people thought they were part of some alien telegraph system.
- ianai 10y agoI find it funny that a clickbaity title like that bothers to tell people to "not get too excited" about the possibility of anything involving aliens. Further, you know what? I say this is something to be really fired up about. We've got a phenomenon here that matches nothing we can come up with theoretically. Live it up!
- singularity2001 10y agoSunspots, debris and/or a distant cloud are not completely ruled out: https://arxiv.org/abs/1608.01316 https://arxiv.org/abs/1608.01316 Wiki: The leading hypothesis, based on a lack of observed infrared light, is that of a swarm of cold, dusty comet fragments in a highly eccentric orbit.[12][13][14] Many small masses in "tight formation" orbiting the star have also been proposed.[9] The changes in brightness could be signs of activity associated with intelligent extraterrestrial life building a Dyson swarm.[9][15][16][17] The SETI Institute's initial radio reconnaissance of KIC 8462852, however, found no evidence of technology-related radio signals from the star. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KIC_8462852 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KIC_8462852
- CamperBob2 10y agoSafe to say that a civilization that can build a Dyson structure isn't using any 20th-century coherent modulation types that SETI could detect. SETI is only useful for catching civilizations in the ~100 Earth year-equivalent span between their development of wireless tech and information theory. There's nothing to listen to but white noise after that.
- Zardoz84 10y agoSETI have some dubious criteria like that an alien civilization would emit at Hydrogen resonance frequency because is a universal constant. Any HAM radio operator or telecommunication engineer know well how bad is trying to emit anything on Hydrogen band because is full of natural noise.
- kirykl 10y agoI understand the hydrogen line to be used tho because the noise is constant and any deviation or pattern could be easily identifiable
- machrider 10y agoThe problem with noise is that your signal has to be bigger than the noise in order to be intelligible. Preferably you'd find a channel with less noise, not more.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoBeing eaten from the inside out by a black hole?
- erdevs 10y agoGood ol' PV on Kinja (from the linked gizmodo article: http://gizmodo.com/the-so-called-alien-megastructure-just-got-even-more-my-1784883811 http://gizmodo.com/the-so-called-alien-megastructure-just-go...) has some interesting thoughts, as usual. > The biggest axe against it being an alien megastructure project is the fact its an F-type star. F-types only live a couple billion years, depending on mass. > But the drop in the radiant flux... a sustained drop. That could be something far more interesting. If you could do stellar engineering... you could draw the material off an F-type star while altering its core. You could reduce the mass to a G or K star, greatly increasing its lifespan... and gaining trillions upon trillions of tons of raw material with which to build an alien megastructure...
- Zardoz84 10y agoSpectral type isn't 1-1 correlate with the star estimated life. Depends on the star mass. Our Sun was one time a F type star.
- sitkack 10y agoQuestion for you Timex Eclair, can I use a star as the engine for my megaship? Pointing all the photons in direction?
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoLike this? http://www.popularmechanics.com/space/deep-space/a10885/the-shkadov-thruster-or-how-to-move-an-entire-solar-system-17000392/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/space/deep-space/a10885/the-... Of course if this was happening we'd see some unusual proper motion from KIC 8462852. Which we're not. (Did someone check?)
- ruste 10y agoThey're coming right for us!!! O_O
- monort 10y ago
- s_q_b 10y agoWe thought pulsars were alien transmissions for a while.
- pilif 10y agoAnyone else thinking of the beginning of the utterly excellent "Pandora's Star" by Peter F. Hamilton?
- boznz 10y agoA Bit at the scarier end of the possibility curve one hopes!
- wlievens 10y agoMorningLightMountain!
- pavel_lishin 10y agoYes, except I hated that series :)
- dave_sullivan 10y agoWhat would it look like if a super dense object like a neutron star or black hole were feeding off the star? We only "see" those dense objects when they expel the material they were pulling in from their accretion disk as relativistic jets, right? So if an object were just leeching mass from a star but not (yet) expelling the material, would it just look like a dimming star? This doesn't necessarily rule out aliens. It could be a post-singularity society of virtual aliens living in a quantum computer, leaching energy directly from the sun and periodically expelling waste material through relativistic jets. Of course.
- soheil 10y agoIn her TED talk [1] Tabby explains how comets could be an explanation for this phenomenon, she even says that it is consistent with their observations, but then she goes on to say "but it 'feels' a little contrived". Sorry what did I miss here? I thought we were discussing science and coming up with theories that support our evidence using data, how does feeling fit into this picture? Why would it be so unlikely that a big comet swarm happens to be between us and Tabby's star, a distance of 1500 light years! Comets seem like a pretty good explanation, I haven't heard an argument against them. [1] https://youtu.be/IyIAjUuxNKw?t=7m17s https://youtu.be/IyIAjUuxNKw?t=7m17s
- Retric 10y agoThousands of comets in just the right spot or tens of thousands of comets over a small area just for that star which seems contrived. If you can create a credible reason why there might be a swarm of comets like this say as remnants from a collision between a large body with just the right orbit* then that's just 1 event which is more plausible. *And I don't mean me saying it, actually create a model that would result in it based on you know math.
- throw_away_777 10y agoIt probably is comets, but why the comets are in the position they are in is not well described. Science is done by people, and it is often very challenging or impossible to rigorously quantify exactly how unlikely something is. This is especially true in observational science. Furthermore, in communicating results to the public it isn't necessarily helpful to speak with quantitative rigor because the audience doesn't care. If someone says this has a 1 in a 10000 chance of being due to aliens, the headlines will scream "Scientists say alien life could be found!"
- MichaelGG 10y agoA lot of evaluating a theory means making subjective judgements on the probability of things if there's not perfect priors established. Like debugging: You end up with things that could have a few ways of happening. Nothing seems to line up perfectly. Different team members can make arguments on what the most likely culprit is. If something doesn't feel right, then you perhaps lean towards another hypothesis.
- djrogers 10y agoMore accurately - it dimmed at an incredible rate ~1480 years ago and we are just now seeing the light from that event.
- sbierwagen 10y agoLink to paper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.01316v1.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.01316v1.pdf
- T-A 10y agoIt's obviously being eaten by black monoliths [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010:_Odyssey_Two https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010:_Odyssey_Two
- Apocryphon 10y agoPancreator deliver us, the suns fade.
- bni 10y agoMaybe its the On/Off star
- roberthahn 10y agoThe dimming is probably a dark matter nebula passing between it and us.
- theemathas 10y agoDark matter, by definition, does not interact with light. Therefore, it cannot cause the dimming.
- ceejayoz 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter > The name refers to the fact that it does not emit or interact with electromagnetic radiation, such as light, and is thus invisible to the entire electromagnetic spectrum.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoThere is an epistamological conundrum involved in astronomy. In this case even Jason Wright admits that theories involving alien-action are > a “perilous approach to science”—one > that could lead to an “alien in the > gaps” fallacy, and unfalsifiable > hypotheses. But on the other hand, if we always strain to find a non-alien answer to everything we are in danger of making them up and distoring our ideas of what can happen naturally.
- basicplus2 10y agohow about multiple nutating disks of debris who's centres are the star in question.
- amelius 10y agoCould it have been hit by a large planet that lost its orbit somehow (perhaps from another system)? (And out of interest, is this an event that has been recorded before?)
- sitkack 10y agoAre you saying we looking the edge end of an Accretion Disk[0] ? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accretion_disk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accretion_disk Two planets collide, forming a huge mess, that mess continues to collide with itself in a chain reaction. If the rings of saturn surrounded a star, what would that star look like when viewed edge on? Do the rings precess? What can we say about the size of the object in the ring and how will the ring structure evolve over time?
- T-A 10y agoI think this scale-correct image pretty much answers that: https://www.wwu.edu/skywise/solar/solar3.jpg https://www.wwu.edu/skywise/solar/solar3.jpg Tabby's star is a bit larger than the sun (1.4 solar masses) but you get the idea. You would need something much larger than Jupiter to visibly impact it.
- perseusprime11 10y agoWhen Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos start building their mega structures around Mars, some far away alien species will report a similar sighting about us.
- mchahn 10y ago> dimming at such an incredible rate that it can't solely be explained by any of the leading hypotheses So it must be aliens. That can explain anything.
- Pica_soO 10y agoCould a extreme deforming by a another gravity corpus in a elliptic orbit reduce the pressure necessary for fusion so much that the observed luminosity drop could be explained?