12 ms·
The American Dream Is Alive in Finland
- robert_foss 10y agoThe American dream mantra as it is currently being regurgitated in America is little more than a cheap slogan at best and calculated lie at worst. What it is said to represent are qualities like social mobility in which America ranks amongst the very worst of the other 48 developed nations.
- chrischen 10y agoYea but if you are coming from a developing or third world country it is not a lie.
- ori_b 10y agoIt might be worth striving for more than "America: It's better than a tin pot dictatorship"
- adventured 10y agoHow about: America: one of the highest median household disposable incomes on earth. 25% higher than Norway, 30% higher than Germany and 50% higher than Sweden. America: owner of 45% of all global private wealth. America: half the unemployment rate of the EU and Eurozone. America: a higher median income than Finland, with half the unemployment rate. Finland I'll note has been in a soft-depression for nearly a decade, with net negative growth over that time. Their economy is a disaster. America: median house two to three times larger than what's typical in Scandinavia, at a much lower median cost as well. America: drastically lower household debt to income ratio than Sweden, Denmark, Finland, Netherlands. America: where more people have moved up and out of the middle class, than have moved down out of it, for 40 years running. So much so, that it's contracting the middle class, and the majority of those people are moving upwards. America: nearly twice the GDP per capita of the Eurozone. America: adding an economy the size of Germany in the time - eight years - that Europe's economy has had zero growth. America: household poverty line nearly twice as high as the EU and Eurozone. A line so high, that 70% of all UK households would fall short of the US household poverty line (per the guardian).
- jazzyk 10y ago>America: one of the highest median household disposable incomes on earth. 25% higher than Norway, 30% higher than Germany and 50% higher than Sweden. Careful here... You need to subtract: - cost of health care (even if you are a W-2 employee, you still have to pay, typically 30% of the cost, self-employed people may end up $25K/year for a family of 4) - cost of higher education - $250K/child for private college, $!20K/child state college - additional taxes, like real-estate, excise taxes - hidden taxes: telecom, airport/FAA (sometimes half of the price of the ticket), etc. - absurd real-estate prices (on the coasts) While the US is probably still ahead, the difference is not as big as you stated.
- adventured 10y ago> cost of higher education - $250K/child for private college, $!20K/child state college US households have better balance sheets than most highly developed European nations. So that's obviously not making the impact that people would like to claim it is. The median student loan for all people with student loans, is a mere $13,000. > cost of health care I agree, that's why the US has such low taxes on the middle class compared to most of Europe. However, the median US household has $15,000 more in disposable income than for example Sweden. That's a dramatic sum, that can easily cover health insurance - and in fact enables the US to be the vast consumer engine that it is. Simultaneously the median household net worth is higher in the US than Sweden or Germany. As a significant counter point, a vast number of Americans are receiving compensation at their jobs in the way of health insurance coverage. That isn't counted at all in the US disposable income numbers and it's an extremely large number financially. > additional taxes, like real-estate, excise taxes That's a rather ridiculous inclusion. Most of Europe is overflowing with similar taxes, including very high VAT taxes. > hidden taxes: telecom, airport/FAA (sometimes half of the price of the ticket) Those referenced costs are comically trivial compared to the extreme disposable income gap in question between the US and most European nations. > absurd real-estate prices (on the coasts That's a pretty narrow example. Real estate costs are not absurd along most of the US coast in fact. South Carolina, Oregon, Georgia, Florida, Maine, Virginia, North Carolina, half of California, most of Washington - all of those are perfectly reasonable for the most part (most of Florida for example is not absurdly priced). Unlike in Europe, you can possess an extremely high standard of living in the majority of the country by just avoiding half a dozen cities. Want to move to Boise Idaho? You can have a household disposable income higher than Sweden, with real estate costs 25% that of Sweden. In Europe, you can't just choose to move to Portugal, much less Czech, much less Bulgaria, and expect to have an income as high as in Germany or Sweden, in order to take advantage of lower cost real estate.
- jomamaxx 10y agoFalse. 'Social Mobility' cannot be compared between USA and small Euro nations. 'Social Mobility' within Denmark, a country smaller than Los Angeles, is pretty good. What if you compared 'Social Mobility' across the EU. Do you think that poor people in Croatia, Sicily and Greece are 'mobilizing' up past the Swedish middle class? No. Also - America has large ethnic groups. America is really 5 nations: Europeans, Asians, Latinos, Blacks, and 'everyone else'. By almost every measure, America is different for these people, it's tough to compare. I'm not saying it's right, rather alluding to what it is. Finally - I would say having lived in the US and Europe - that there is without a doubt more opportunity in America than in Europe overall. No question about that. The elite in most European nations come from pretty good families. They go to the top schools and have their careers guaranteed. Anyone in America can be successful. Obviously, that's not a pragmatic statement, as poor kids from the ghetto often have no appreciation of this and simply don't work towards great outcomes - but this is the reality. Anyhow - the gini coefficient for 'all of Europe' I suggest is definitely lower than the US, and this is because it's nary impossible for poor Spaniards/Greeks/Sicilians to rise to higher than the European upper middle class.
- jomamaxx 10y ago"as poor kids from the ghetto often have no appreciation of this and simply don't work towards great outcomes" FYI I'm not blaming them, rather indicating that for whatever reason, opportunity is not grasped.
- aleksei 10y ago> Anyone in America can be successful. As can anyone in Europe, no? EDIT: must have read too fast, above point stands.
- dilann 10y agoUS is more like Russia by the gini. Multi-nationality is not unique to the US.
- adventured 10y agoAnd the reason the gini is a bad joke: the median US standard of living is four to five times that of Russia.
- jandrewrogers 10y agoSocial mobility measures based on income (PPP) percentiles are misleading because they don't account for the hugely different income variances between countries. In countries with low income variances like Denmark, a small change in your absolute income will be deemed "socially mobile" whereas a much larger increase absolute income in countries with high income variances like the US will be deemed as not "socially mobile" even when it is vastly better for the average individual in absolute income terms. Individuals don't care about their ability to change their percentile, they care about their ability to change their total income. I think most individuals would prefer a "non-mobile" $60k increase in income versus a "mobile" $40k increase in income. You can't spend percentiles.
- voodoomagicman 10y agoThis is a good point, but I think individuals care a lot more about their percentile than you would expect - their benchmark for whether their income is 'a lot' or 'a little' is how much they see the people around them making.
- Trombone12 10y agoOf course, you can't have very much social mobility in high income variance countries anyway if you want to preserve those precious income inequalities.
- lumberjack 10y ago>Individuals don't care about their ability to change their percentile, they care about their ability to change their total income. I think most individuals would prefer a "non-mobile" $60k increase in income versus a "mobile" $40k increase in income. You can't spend percentiles. I highly dispute this. Take it as a completely different world view but I think if people were given a choice: 1 >a nominal income of $100k for you and a nominal income of $200k for all your neighbours 2 >a nominal income of $75k for you and a nominal income of $60k for all your neighbours A lot of people would opt for choice 2. I myself am not sure whether I'd go for 1 or 2.
- sanoli 10y ago
- mc32 10y agoHmmm. I think if the dream were killed, then there would be nothing for people to lodge a complaint against. Nothing to look forward to and so people might grow comfortable in their poverty, for example. Imagine, there is no dream. You get what you have. There is no chance for anyone who has not achieved. Don't even try, there is no chance. I think we'd be worse off with that mindset. I imagine Russia, Venezuela, etc. feel a bit like this. You're there to eek out a living with little chance of thinking things could change for you.
- jolux 10y agoWhat makes you think that it's not already like that for certain classes? Income mobility is historically low. Also why would people grow comfortable in their poverty? What exactly does that mean? That they've made peace with the fact that they have to choose between being dead or being broke? As long as there is poverty there will always be complaints.
- mc32 10y agoGo to a poor country. See how people go about the days. It's as if there is a "place" and people "know" their place. If you don't believe in having a stationary "place" you seek more, you tell your progeny there is more, if only they try. Go, don't be like your father or mother, go make something of yourself.
- jolux 10y agoJust because you don't believe in a stationary place doesn't mean you don't have one. Plenty of people may believe in the American Dream but that doesn't mean it's real. Plus even if you don't believe in upward mobility it still doesn't mean you're happy where you are. Shitty conditions are shitty conditions regardless of whether or not you think you can get out of them if that's even possible.
- drabiega 10y agoI've seen plenty of this mindset in America already and honestly they're not wrong.
- jomamaxx 10y ago60% personal income taxes after big payroll tax and 20% VAT? I don't think so.
- jakub_h 10y agoMaybe it's also about what it buys you? Also, https://www.nordisketax.net/main.asp?url=files/suo/eng/i07.asp https://www.nordisketax.net/main.asp?url=files/suo/eng/i07.a... claims it's at worst 31.75%, not 60%, and that's not even the average. Plus if you're rich, not all or even most of your wealth comes from personal income anyway, so there's that. And ~20% VAT or equivalent seems quite common over the developed world.
- jomamaxx 10y ago32% national, 22% municipal and 8% social security = 62%. 20% payroll tax. 24% VAT. That it is 'common' does not mean it is fair. If a company has $100K allocated to pay you, $20K goes to payroll tax. Of $80K remaining, you take home 40% of that, which is $32K. Suppose 2/3 of your take home goes towards consumer goods meaning that you're paying an additional $5K on VAT ~= $25K direct take home. So for $100K salary, you get $25K. And that's before property tax, wealth tax, inheritance taxes, and massive taxation hidden into other things such as fuel etc.. It's too much by any stretch.
- ptaipale 10y agoThe national tax percentage is 32 % (actually 31.75 %) only for the amount that exceeds the "high earner" threshold, i.e. you pay it for the part that you earn in excess of 72,300 € per year. (That income puts you in top 4 % of earners in Finland.) The municipal tax varies between 16.50 % (Kauniainen) and 22.50 % (Savonlinna). The church tax varies between 1 and 2 %.
- clarry 10y agoAnd you don't have to be in church.
- 10y ago
- SixSigma 10y agoI have long argued for a non means-tested welfare state that is not a safety net but a foundation on which to build your life. Here in the UK there is much resentment to people who receive benefits. I have been someone who lived on benefits because I could, not because I needed to. I spent that time learning new skills and overall have been a net contributor. But I also know people who have no intention of personal improvement who plan to spend their entire lives on handouts. I look at the US and see a system that seems designed to breed crime, poverty and prostitution. Don't trick yourself into thinking the Nordic model is the greatest though. I spent 6 months there in Finland and predict a lot of social pain in the next decade. Growing unemployment will put strain on the social services. Multinationals have been allowed in which means profits sucked abroad via Wal-mart, Lidl and a host of others. The brain drain to other parts of the EU will also grow, if the students I met fulfil their ambitions.
- jomamaxx 10y ago"I look at the US and see a system that seems designed to breed crime, poverty and prostitution." While at the same time producing the highest GDP per captia in the world, the most number of people with college education, and leadership in probably 80% of global industries? The US doesn't 'breed' anything - communities 'breed' themselves. I suggest the US could do a little better with the social safety net, and possibly some basic healthcare guarantees, but having 60% taxes, 30% payroll tax and 20% VAT meaning the average worker putting 75% of their income directly towards government spending is not going to work either. The 'Nordic Model' can only work in small countries, with small, tight ethnic groups and cultural foundations. Nordic Countries almost all have Monarchies, State Churches (Sweden gives 1% of it's tax revenues to their Christian State Church - could you imagine that in the US?). I'm not saying 'faith' is an important factor, rather pointing out the relatively cohesive social identity. And yes, you are right: UK and Germany are sucking up talent like vacuums.
- Retric 10y agoWell ignoring: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal)_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nomi... United Nations (2014)[6] lists US as 12th, which is not bad. But, has been falling for a while. Norway for example seems to be ahead by ~30% despite a huge safety net. Of course by PPP we seem to be stuck at ~25: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_IMF_ranked_countries_by_GDP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_IMF_ranked_countries_b...
- wingcommander 10y agoThat the nordic societies are nice, is of course without question. But the U.S is a different animal. If you want to live a complacent life, squeeze out a few children, work 9-5 for the rest of your life, without taking any risks, the nordics are a great choice. If you want to create something extraordinary, take huge risks, maximize your potential, tap into unprecedented resources in the form of engineering know-how, scientific capital, venture capital etc, then you are without question better of in the U.S. There is a reason why the Googles/IBMs/Facebooks/Bell Labs/MIT's/Skunk Works/DARPAs/NASAs of the world are ALL American. Technological and scientific dominance does not go hand-in-hand with a dull society where 99 % are just complacent.
- Mendenhall 10y agoThe american dream seems to have changed more towards taking from others to give to ones self. I notice a difference in "safety nets" now compared to say end of ww1. Very different times, and it affects many things.
- joshkpeterson 10y ago"Safety nets" is an unfortunate term. It's pejorative in an American sort of way because it implies that you screwed up. We should instead think of these things as a platform that everyone deserves, and everyone gets.
- chris_va 10y agoDon't conflate political rhetoric with quality of life. Quality of life has never been higher for any social class, even with unfortunate income inequality.
- gr3yh47 10y ago>Quality of life has never been higher for any social class even if this were true (source?) it doesnt matter when there is a steady move toward lower social class on average for the overwhelming majority of Americans
- fleitz 10y agoYes, the middle class IS shrinking, but the amazing thing is people are leaving to the upper classes at a 2:1 ratio. > The study shows that as the number of middle-class Americans fell (from 61 percent of the population to 51 percent of the population), the percentage of Americans who are upper income surged from 14 percent of the population to 20 percent of the population. http://www.cnbc.com/id/48754974 http://www.cnbc.com/id/48754974 71% of Americans are middle class or better, amazing. Most of those in the lower classes are those who decided not to get any skills.
- hrehhf 10y ago
- sremani 10y agoWhy so must fascination about a homogeneous society that has population of City of Houston? I will not take some of these articles of Scandinavian fetish any seriously any more.
- sotojuan 10y agoI've always wondered how the people that live there feel about the constant "I wish we were like them!".
- madeaccountnow 10y agoDon't really know how to feel. It's kinda like it's disingenuous hype. Sure most of all these "omg look at Finland" facts are mostly true, but they come at a cost. It's a pain in the ass to have a business or a high salary here. Everything is expensive and you could end up paying 60% taxes of your salary, after the employer pays taxes on your salary. The bureaucracy can get ridiculous too, it's like they don't want to have businesses here. The system works with a small population but I don't think it could ever scale. Basically, if you're ok with being nothing more then middleclass, it's a great place to live, but the ambitious people who really bring in the money and pay the majority of taxes aren't living nearly as good as they could elsewhere. I keep looking at the salaries of US jobs with my title and I'd make so much more money there, and have more left after all the taxes. Then again I had a free education and the healthcare is pretty much free and decent. Maybe it's one of those "grass is greener etc." type deals.
- clarry 10y agoWell, as someone whose life in .fi hasn't been so terribly great so far, I find the hype a bit irritating. Everything is so amazing, except for those for whom it isn't. Opportunities certainly aren't equal. "The Nordic approach of basic universal social policies—that allow everyone to fulfill their potential, allow everyone to work, allow true equality of opportunity" is just bull. And just like a lot of other European countries now, we have a bad unemployment problem (and the statistics lie; they coerce people into various programmes that result in them not showing up as unemployed, even though they don't have an actual job). There are signs that suggest the social "safety web" won't hold up; government budget is really tight and cuts are made here and there. Benefits are not increased as cost of living gets higher. I don't know what the statistics say, but there are lots of alcoholics. And again not sure what the statistics say today, but afaik .fi has ranked pretty poorly with regard to cases of depression and suicide. Maybe all is not so well? And then there's this touchy wtf-worthy subject of the generation that boomed after war retiring. Supposedly there aren't enough of us to fill their positions so we need immigrants. Meanwhile, as I said, unemployment is pretty sickening.
- amsilprotag 10y agoMalcolm Gladwell's Revisionist History podcast is doing a three-part series critiquing the state of American education and its effect on social mobility. The first part (released last week) gives a personal perspective of a child who passes on an opportunity for social advancement to instead provide family support. As far as I understand it, the next parts are looking at the incentives that that shape college budgets. Part 1: http://revisionisthistory.com/episodes/04-carlos-doesnt-remember http://revisionisthistory.com/episodes/04-carlos-doesnt-reme...
- Nokinside 10y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/nordicmasterrace https://www.reddit.com/r/nordicmasterrace
- jug5 10y agoOnly people in America or third world countries think America is great anymore. The rest of the first world would only live there as a last resort.
- dharma1 10y agoFinn here (though lived the past 12 years in the UK). In my experience, the one thing that by far works best to enable social mobility, and that I think Nordic and some central European countries have done quite well, is free, high quality education - from primary school to university. Especially as we move further and further to knowledge based economic growth, this is crucial, not just for social mobility, but well being and success of whole countries. Market forces are great at optimising some things, some not so great. Things that require long term focus - basic research, education, environmental issues - are best handled, and paid for by governments.
- nickff 10y agoThere is a great deal of information (in studies and research) that shows post-secondary schooling is a good investment for the individual, but that does not mean that increasing the average amount of schooling is good for the country. A number of people are now making the argument that greater 'educational' achievement is mostly just signalling status, intelligence, socialization, and work ethic, not actually teaching people anything useful. If this view is correct, increasing the amount of education that the average citizen receives is just wasting their time (as most people do not enjoy their time in class), at great expense to them and the average taxpayer.[1] [1] http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2014/02/why_the_college.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2014/02/why_the_college.... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_(economics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_(economics)
- drabiega 10y ago> If this view is correct, increasing the amount of education that the average citizen receives is just wasting their time (as most people do not enjoy their time in class), at great expense to them and the average taxpayer.[1] Even accepting your first premise, this does not follow. Even if degrees are 100% signalling and 0% actual education, it's still the right choice for the individual because that signalling has value. The alternative is that people who have the positive qualities that are signaled but not the money for the degree cannot get the jobs which require those characteristics and have good pay.
- bggy00 10y agothere's a summary/excerpts here: https://www.contentcreamery.com/articles/what-s-so-special-about-finland https://www.contentcreamery.com/articles/what-s-so-special-a...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Joof 10y agoSo many people talk about it in sheer numbers, but you know what sounds nice? Having time off to spend with your kids (as a man!), more balanced relationships and not worrying about healthcare if you get laid-off.
- kaid 10y agofreedom is hard earned, neither generously provided, nor enforced. a universally dictated form of "freedom" is a degeneration.
- drjesusphd 10y agoExactly, which is why the Finns are diligent in maintaining a good standard of living for their worst off. They work hard to hold their government accountable to the people. Or did you have something else in mind? Such as taking credit for the sacrifices of generations past?
- kaid 10y agomy perspective is on the opposite side of modern european social liberal standards. individuals should only hold themselves accountable. the effort to establishing universal well-being assumes political enforcement and coercion. it's a process of ceding individual sovereignty to a political entity.