17 ms·
Investing Returns on the S&P500
- HorizonXP 10y agoIt's funny that this is so non-intuitive. My wife continues to try to "time the market" despite me telling her that it's pointless over such a long time horizon. Maybe this will help convince her.
- nicholas73 10y agoThis only showed that in the historical periods, one was virtually guaranteed to come out ahead over long periods. It does not disprove timing the market, though I think it can be shown why it's extremely difficult.
- purplelobster 10y agoThat's because most people (perhaps subconsciously) view the market as zero sum. What goes up must come down.
- VLM 10y agoNegative sum, all that fun hardware and hard workers live off trading commissions. Something to think about is the market originally existed to raise capital for massive industrial projects like transcontinental railroads and Ma Bell and steel mills and factories in general. That's methodically been destroyed and soon will be as economically relevant as selling farm tractors is today. True its diversified out into providing capital to set up financialization schemes, holding companies, stuff like that. But in the very long run I'm not seeing a purpose in having a stock market. That would tend to make it go away. Take America 2016 and just turn all the dials up to 20 and call predictions for 2036. The last industrial employer closed years ago so no need to raise money for factories full of workers. The last privately funded construction project was built long ago and all construction not just sports stadiums and corporate HQs are completely government funded, no need for stock market funds if all the money comes from taxpayers. Income inequality has accelerated to the point of there no longer being a consumer economy, no need to finance consumerism like retail stores or car loans by selling stock. That also means no advertising because there's almost no value left to extract once all the blood has been squeezed from the stone, which in a country where no one can afford medical care, higher ed, or housing means they don't need to sell stock because they've crashed and no longer exist for all practical purposes. Of course this sounds all rather negative but theres plenty of good news. I'll continue to front money to my local farmers for my vegetable CSA and my occasionally "half a cow" purchase... although none of that requires stocks. Now that software has eaten the world and no computers cost more than a $5 Raspberry Pi, I can work a startup at my local makerspace with practically no money and certainly no need to raise money by selling stock, capitalist industrialism was so 19th century, I don't need to sell $25K of stock to buy a Sun SunOS minicomputer to serve DNS in a world of cloud computing and $5 raspberry pis. There's no need to invest 401K funds because everyone except the hyper wealthy is dirt poor, so no financial market demand. Yes yes the interval from 1850 to 2000 or so was an era of needing massive investment to build industrial infrastructure. And we need great piles of cash in say 2050 to build... what? Nothing, would be my guess. So the marketplace to raise great piles of cash will go away, more or less. The future being unevenly distributed, you should be able to find a country today thats de-industrialized (or never industrialized to begin with) and has wide enough income inequality that the population has mostly gone back to barter (probably computer / smart phone assisted agent bartering, but no currency anyway). One where most of the population works non traditional jobs, more like subsistence farmers or subsistence economy in general. How about subsistence farming in Columbia, how healthy is the fraction of the Columbian stock market that focuses on or works closely with subsistence farmers? Oh there isn't one? Oh. Well that's the future of the NYSE given recent trends.
- rileymat2 10y agoI do not disagree with your premise, but they are using a log scale. Over time, the returns are still vastly different, even if the graph looks compact for long horizons.
- lintiness 10y agotiming the market can be done any number of ways -- productively. we're short term beasts not programmed to be patient (schiller pe, deviations from averages, down x%).
- Spooky23 10y agoHow do her portfolio results compare to yours?
- twblalock 10y agoBuy her a copy of David Swensen's book for individual investors, "Unconventional Success." Anyone who still believes in market timing after reading that just can't be helped.
- vanderfluge 10y agoI'd be curious to see results for other countries, the graph of "Chance of Losing in the Stock Market" in particular. In the case of Japan, it appears that if you'd still have significant losses if you invested 25-30 years ago: https://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=%5En225+Interactive#{"range":"max","allowChartStacking":true} https://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=%5En225+Interactive#{"ra...
- stevenmays 10y agoIf you're in Japan you can still invest in the US stock market... and should to diversify. I invest in international markets even though I am in the U.S.
- soVeryTired 10y agoJust to point out to people who may not be aware, this leaves you open to currency risk. The FTSE 100 dropped 3% in GBP terms last week, but maybe 10% in USD terms. This cuts both ways of course: you can make money on favourable currency moves. But it's an important risk to be aware of before buying assets in a foreign currency.
- UK-AL 10y agoYou want this though. For example if you was English and invested all in uk investments you would have dropped massively USD terms. If you spread your investments in many different currencies in pound terms you would have actually gained from this crisis. Diversification also applies to currency
- dharma1 10y agoI moved my all of my UK pension to non-UK bonds (mainly US) one day before the referendum result. It was a mission and a half using my pension fund's online system, truly awful UX, I almost gave up. I don't normally change the holdings or attempt active investing, but it just seemed like a very asymmetric bet - nearly 50/50 polls, very large potential downside if not diversifying outside the UK/sterling.
- chollida1 10y agoCool, this is very similar to what I had people do at one point as part of the interview process. Give them a bunch of historical data - find me the longest period that we would be flat/negative - find the best time to invest - find the optimal portfolio off stocks to hold over a given period. I think I've said this before but I see too many people who think that they need to have a huge public repository of code to show off in an interview. If you want to be a programmer at a hedge fund just having some very shallow analysis like the above would get a programmer to the top of the resume pile. Now if you want to be a quant the bar is obviously much higher:)
- mailshanx 10y agoI'm interested in walking the quant path. Just how high is the bar? And would there be an equivalent project that would put a prospective quant to the top of the resume pile?
- chollida1 10y agoI've attached two pdf's on what you should expect. The latter was the take home an old company used to give quants as a test. If you can answer the questions on teh practicum then you probably have enough math skills to start as a quant. https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0B1iikX5PwNx4d2dKQ3FTSWVRSDA&usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0B1iikX5PwNx4d2dKQ3FT...
- mailshanx 10y agoThanks, that is very valuable.
- aorth 10y agoJust in case anyone else doesn't know what a "quant" is: quantitative analyst. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantitative_analyst https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantitative_analyst
- cloudjacker 10y agoif you enjoyed that too bad you'll never do any of it on the job
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- yread 10y agoWould be more interesting to compare it against a realistic return from a savings account instead of saying "if the index is worth the same after 20 years then you haven't lost anything". You would have almost 25% more even in a 1.1% savings account.
- arbitrage 10y agoI haven't seen a 1.1% savings account in the better part of a decade. Perhaps that's not useful to theorize about in the modern economic wonderland we've created.
- iamjdg 10y agoIf you live in Canada https://www.highinterestsavings.ca/chart/ https://www.highinterestsavings.ca/chart/
- kapkapkap 10y agohttps://www.ally.com/bank/online-savings-account/ https://www.ally.com/bank/online-savings-account/
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- _yosefk 10y agoIf you look at it that way, it's also hard to theorize about stocks in that modern economic wonderland "we" (they?) have created. There could be, for instance, a large wave of defaults on the plentiful debt created by low interest rates, which is probably bad for stock prices, or else the trend of rising P/E ratios due to a lack of safer ways to get a return on an investment could keep inflating stock prices.
- ericd 10y agohttps://www.gsbank.com/en.html https://www.gsbank.com/en.html https://www.synchronybank.com/banking/home https://www.synchronybank.com/banking/home 1.05%, but close enough.
- minimaxir 10y agovia this /r/dataisbeautiful post, with added commentary from the author: https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/4q9iwa/40_years_of_investing_returns_in_the_sp500_with/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/4q9iwa/40_...
- ozten 10y agoDoes the stock data used suffer from Surviver bias? That is a free download of historical data that lacks failing, delisted companies of the past.
- chollida1 10y agoThis is a good question. The S&P 500 kind of dodges this question by its very nature. The S&P 500 constantly changes the stocks it holds. So if a stock falls out of favor, say Sears, its dropped from the index. It's also important to Note that comparing the S&P 500 from 100 years ago to today is very naive as the methodology for what it holds has changed significantly over the years. Comparing the returns of the S&P 500 from 1900 to now is kind of like comparing the statistics of a baseball player from 1900 and now in isolation and using that as the sole determination of which player was better. http://www.joshuakennon.com/sp-500s-dirty-little-secret/ http://www.joshuakennon.com/sp-500s-dirty-little-secret/
- ianai 10y agoIt's also only one statistic (as used). You would find differences for what years were loses 10/15/25 years down in different markets. For instance, Japan.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mrb 10y agoYes sometimes companies are delisted from the S&P500, but if you invest in an S&P500 index fund, then your investment is also automatically adjusted to remove that company. Which makes me think: with index funds becoming more and more popular, should we see bigger and bigger crashes of stocks when they are removed from an index?
- dforrestwilson 10y agoPotentially yes, but some hedge funds play the index dynamic by trading into or out of stocks before/after they are added.
- jakozaur 10y agoI don't think it is fair to say that next 100 years will be same as last 100 years: 1. GDP growth is not as high as it used to be anywhere in developed world: http://www.oecd.org/std/productivity-stats/oecd-compendium-of-productivity-indicators-22252126.htm http://www.oecd.org/std/productivity-stats/oecd-compendium-o... 2. USA is superpower at the peak. Plenty of other stock market economies hasn't been so successful. E.g. Argentina used to be one of the richest country in the world. Investing in history is easy, e.g. you can also say about Apple stock that it will always recover based on past data, but plenty of other companies hasn't. 3. Most of the 100 years we have inflation: http://inflationdata.com/Inflation/Inflation_Rate/Long_Term_Inflation.asp http://inflationdata.com/Inflation/Inflation_Rate/Long_Term_... Right now interests rate are close to zero, which is rare. Long term trends may change if we continue to operate in those climate. Edit: Inflation was factored in the graphs. Sorry I was wrong about that.
- stevenmays 10y ago> So at Year 1, we take every point on the S&P500 curve, look at every point on the S&P500 that's one year ahead, add in dividends and subtract inflation, and record all points as a relative gain or loss for Year 1. Point #3 is wrong.
- Retric 10y agoWhile inflation was adjusted for it was not accurately adjusted for as it ignored taxes. If your returns are 10% and inflation is 10% you get taxed on that 10% and lose money. PS: Now if this is for 401k accounts or something that's another story.
- sks 10y agoYou dont get taxed until you sell. The performance shown here is for a buy and hold strategy.
- Retric 10y agoDividends are also taxed, so even reinvesting has a cost. Granted, IRA/401k etc exist and in years with 0-3% it's not that big a deal, but over 20 years it's often a significant cost.
- thomaslieven 10y agoi've made simmiliar visulations in backtest app which shows returns on cash invested > https://itunes.apple.com/cz/app/backtest-stock-asset-portfolio/id1064281237?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/cz/app/backtest-stock-asset-portfol...
- maxxxxx 10y agoLooking at the discussions here I find it interesting that even in something as number driven as the stock market everybody argues about the meaning and the validity of the numbers. There really is no clear picture. But somehow the regular guy is supposed to navigate his way through this jungle of conflicting, confusing or meaningless numbers. And considering the long time frames most people don't have much opportunity for leaning from mistakes and doing better. Once you realize that your strategy doesn't work you have already wasted many, many years and lots of money.
- notadoc 10y agoThat is basically the argument for managed pensions, fiduciary managed retirement accounts, etc
- stevenmays 10y agoMost people have a financial adviser, but for the industrious I recommend: http://jlcollinsnh.com/stock-series/ http://jlcollinsnh.com/stock-series/ And for the lazy, this is a good resource: https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Lazy_portfolios https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Lazy_portfolios
- nathantotten 10y agoI doubt most people have a financial adviser. What percent of people even have savings more than a single paycheck?
- ryandrake 10y agoWhat? Most* people (at least in the USA) don't even own a single stock, let alone have a financial adviser. *(Actually, looks like it depends on your source: 48%[1] or 52%[2], so let's say "about half of people") 1: http://money.cnn.com/2015/04/10/investing/investing-52-percent-americans-have-no-money-in-stocks/ http://money.cnn.com/2015/04/10/investing/investing-52-perce... 2: http://www.gallup.com/poll/190883/half-americans-own-stocks-matching-record-low.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/190883/half-americans-own-stocks-...
- dforrestwilson 10y ago
- chrismealy 10y agoThe stock market isn't some immutable thing. It's the product of economic and social forces, the share of income given to capital and labor, international politics, etc. Basically stocks are a convenience for rentiers that the little people are allowed to access. There's no reason to expect the social forces that underly market returns will deliver the same returns in the future.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted, I agree. One hundred and a bit years of human history is a small sample size. Capitalism and the explosion of the human population has unleashed explosive and rapidly transforming forces, there's no reason to assume that those forces will continue to exhibit the same characteristics 40 or 50 years from now.
- tim333 10y ago>There's no reason to expect the social forces that underly market returns will deliver the same returns in the future. Except human nature is the same, economics is the same.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoExcept that people didn't live under a capitalist economic system with stock exchanges, shares, and private property for the 10000 years of settled urban existence before the 18th century, so, yeah -- apparently "economics is the same" isn't true.
- cesarbs 10y agoI suggest you read A Splendid Exchange. Although humanity didn't have the exact same economic system as today's, it's a mistake to think there weren't complex systems in place in the past.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoI never said anything of the sort that there were not complex systems in place. Precisely because I can see that I can say that the system we have now is not inevitable, immutable, or eternal.
- pbreit 10y agoI am not a financial advisor and this is not financial advice! Robinhood seems like an OK way to keep a free portfolio of ETFs approximating a Vanguard all-in-one fund. My super-unscientific portfolio is loosely based on Vanguard's LifeStrategy Growth & Moderate Growth funds with a sliver of MGK that seemed to both boost returns and moderate declines. A $5k portfolio would be 6 MGK (10%), 19 VTI (40%), 23 VXUS (20%), 12 BND (20%), 9 BNDX (10%). From what I can tell, you can hold this portfolio in Robinhood for free. Shouldn't need to re-balance more than once per year or so. https://personal.vanguard.com/us/funds/snapshot?FundIntExt=INT&FundId=0914 https://personal.vanguard.com/us/funds/snapshot?FundIntExt=I... https://personal.vanguard.com/us/funds/snapshot?FundIntExt=INT&FundId=0122 https://personal.vanguard.com/us/funds/snapshot?FundIntExt=I... Pay off your credit cards and max out your 401k/IRA first.
- artursapek 10y agoI really don't understand the appeal of Robinhood... if you're going to hold stocks for years you really shouldn't be skimping on an $8 commission. Get a proper broker with a reputation.
- smpetrey 10y agoWell for one, it's about disruption and change. The creators are more than familiar with brokerage, and it shouldn't be a shocker that most brokers do not operate trades, it's mostly electronic.[1] If you're going to hold stocks for years, why not skimp on an $8 commission? If you make a purchase of 100 shares of $FB, it could save you at least $800 for that sale. So the real question is, why not? [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JwpQpFqzoAE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JwpQpFqzoAE
- jdmichal 10y ago> If you make a purchase of 100 shares of $FB, it could save you at least $800 for that sale. That's not how commissions work. They are per order, not per share.
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kmm 10y agoI like the animation. You can see crises percolate backwards in time
- javiramos 10y agoI have followed http://www.crossingwallstreet.com/ http://www.crossingwallstreet.com/ for years. I have traded the portfolio he lists and I've done pretty well. His focus is in the long-term...
- thro1237 10y agoIs it possible to do it for dollar cost averaging? That is what happens if one didn't invest in a lumpsum but invested $1000 every month -- how does the returns look like for different time periods?
- aeling 10y agoIt's discussed near the bottom of the writeup, but the author suggests somebody else may be better suited to do it: What about Dollar Cost Averaging (DCA) instead of Lump Sum Investing (LSI)? This one is going to be a little more difficult. I've included the original code and it's open-source, so if you want to play with the numbers, you can try to do this yourself. However, there are a couple points I'd like to keep in mind: •You're working with a "cash multiplier" as the main result. You'd be trading in a unitless scale for a scale with units since you'll need to specify a base value. Perhaps the act of buying a single share of SP500 per year might help with keeping the scale nondimensional? •There's inflation data in there, but at some point you're going to have to account for that if you're using dollars as a scale. How does one compare investing a dollar in 1902 vs. 2002? •DCA will probably cause some scaling issues. You'll need to accurately tune your algorithm to reflect an equivalent investment under the LSI algorithm I provide. My prediction is that DCA will "thin out" the plot and bring a lot more values closer to the average. This makes investing a bit safer, but at the cost of slower gains.
- prattmic 10y agoIt is only over 10 years, but Vanguard has a short analysis of Dollar Cost Averaging at https://pressroom.vanguard.com/nonindexed/7.23.2012_Dollar-cost_Averaging.pdf https://pressroom.vanguard.com/nonindexed/7.23.2012_Dollar-c...
- pilom 10y agoThe gist of their analysis was "since the market always goes up eventually, investing all up front will give you higher average returns but significantly higher variability"
- eevilspock 10y agoWhat of opportunity cost? That should be factored in just as inflation is. > After 20 years, you're almost guaranteed to sell high. Not if you factor in opportunity cost. If I invest $100K and after 20 years I sell at $110K, which works out to a 0.5% APR, I wouldn't consider that selling high.
- plg 10y agoan oft-neglected nugget of info that has great bearing on a buy-and-hold approach, esp with mutual funds: FEES Fees can kill your returns There are many low-fee or no-fee options
- mercutio2 10y agoTo the best of my knowledge, there are no available to the general public truly no-fee options for having someone else buy a variety of stocks for you. ETFs internalize fees, so many people are not aware of them, but their fees are generally comparable to the equivalent index fund's fees.
- Jabbles 10y ago"Buy and Hold" applied to the S&P500 actually means "sell when an individual company loses enough market cap, buy one that has gained enough".
- tbrooks 10y agoWarren Buffett bet $1mm that S&P500 will outperform a hedge fund over a 10 year period.[1] That's good enough for me, I'll follow the oracle. [1] http://longbets.org/362/ http://longbets.org/362/
- comboy 10y agoThis bet ends in less than 2 years. Does anybody know what would be the result if it would end now? edit: I guess it depends on the detailed terms that they haven't disclosed, but educated guesses are fine
- OscarCunningham 10y agoI seem to remember that as of Berkshire Hathaway's annual shareholder meeting in April, Buffett was winning by a long way.
- evanpw 10y agoBuffett is winning 66% to 22%: http://www.cnbc.com/2016/02/16/warren-buffett-slips-but-still-winning-epic-hedge-fund-bet.html http://www.cnbc.com/2016/02/16/warren-buffett-slips-but-stil....
- phonon 10y ago65.67% vs. 21.87% returns so far (net after fees) http://fortune.com/2016/05/11/warren-buffett-hedge-fund-bet/ http://fortune.com/2016/05/11/warren-buffett-hedge-fund-bet/ Almost impossible for Warren to lose at this point.
- comboy 10y agoWhoa, thanks. I would have definitely taken the losing side of the bet.
- infinite8s 10y agoHis bet is on returns net of fees. There are some theories that any alpha generated by a fund is eventually just captured in the fee structure.
- pilom 10y agoIf you want to run your own analysis about what retirement might look like for you, I recommend the extremely powerful http://cfiresim.com/ http://cfiresim.com/
- hellofunk 10y agoWow that site's UI needs some work. Just the wordings are confusing with no explanation.
- ryandrake 10y agoFunny how his time horizon stretches out to 150 years, where the vast majority of people don't live past 100, and have probably, what 25-35 or so years of investing time in their lives? The insanely long term is a simplified look at the stock market as some money-multiplication machine, but I don't think it is really that to most people. Given a normal person's time horizon, the difference between "did I start investing in 2007 or in 2009" is significant.
- dceddia 10y agoA little further down it shows graphs of a "typical investing timeline" from around age 20 to age 60. It still looks pretty solid.
- ryandrake 10y agoAhh, you're right. My comment is directly addressed in the article--that's what I get for skimming it. My only nit then would be that I don't know too many people in their 20s putting money into the stock market. Most people that age are spending every dollar they make on rent and their student loans. You're probably not in the position to "invest" until you have a professional job, well into your thirties.
- lmickh 10y agoTypical federal student debt payment is ~$300/mon assuming 6% interest, 10 year repayment, and >$30k of debt. With less than $35k income, that payment drops. You have to make some really poor decisions about where you live to be spending every dollar on rent and student loans assuming you have a job that does not pay minimum wage. Making investing a priority can be hard, but it is far from impossible at that age. Even a small amount early on will far out weigh a much larger amount invested later. It is important to communicate that instead of telling people they probably can't do it.
- iaskwhy 10y agoI'm usally more worried about having a long term investment, say for 30 years and on the 25th year another 2008 takes place, I might not have 20 years to wait by then.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- enoch_r 10y agoBy defining the probability distribution as the historical distribution of one-year returns, you're severely warping the possibility space. Imagine two experiments: Experiment A: you flip a coin 1000 times. You estimate the probability that the coin flips heads, and use this to estimate the odds of flipping 10 heads in a row. Experiment B: you flip a coin 10 times. You repeat that experiment 100 times. You use the results of that experiment to estimate the odds of flipping 100 heads in a row (by looking at how many times it occurred, and dividing by 100). Assuming reasonable results and a fair coin, you'll conclude from experiment A that the probability of a heads flip is around 50%, and that the odds of getting 10 heads in a row are (1/2)^10. In experiment B, ~90% of the time you'll conclude that it's impossible to flip 10 heads in a row, and ~10% of the time (in the cases where you did flip 10 heads in a row at least once) you'll overestimate the likelihood of doing it again by a factor of 10 (at 1%, instead of the true value, <0.1%). So when you only look at annual returns, you're effectively looking at an aggregate of 365 daily returns (or 365*6.5 hourly returns).
- known 10y agoJust find out how to do insider trading without getting caught. This is even better :) "Give me control of a nation's money supply, and I care not who makes its laws." --Rothschild, 1744
- jrockway 10y agoJust buy a baseball bat and threaten to hit people if they don't give you their money. Way better returns than the stock market. Of course, you won't be able to enjoy that money in prison.
- tim333 10y agoIf you want to know the returns for the next 7 years, GMO has quite a good track record, based on ratios being mean reverting http://www.gurufocus.com/news/349958/how-to-play-gmos-latest-7year-asset-class-forecast http://www.gurufocus.com/news/349958/how-to-play-gmos-latest...
- ianai 10y agoThe take-away I got from this is: unless you have 30 years, forget the s&p 500 market.
- pfarnsworth 10y agoTry this on stock markets like the Nikkei, and I think you'll find completely different results.
- Apes 10y agoI definitely am interested in seeing this for different stock markets, and the global stock market.
- sp527 10y agoThis is not very interesting. Anyone who has attempted even a cursory inspection of market returns understands this rationale. The more interesting problem is to attempt to train an investment curve based on some normalized metric for market value, which would be superior to both the lump-sum and DCA strats. What he's not showing you is that gyrations in the market have a tremendous impact on the long-run return outlook and this is extremely detrimental to the lump-sum strategy in particular. DCA is slightly better but still not perfect. You therefore want to pool cash over certain periods of time and invest more, relatively speaking, during periods when the market is trending lower. This is a tough model to construct because there are certain subjective features (how to normalize market value properly) and more complicated variables you have to account for like a negative ROI on holding cash. All that said, I actually built a model fitting this description a while back and it works swimmingly.
- dap 10y agoThe NYTimes has a great visualization of S&P 500 returns for money invested any year between 1920 and 2009 and withdrawn between 1921 and 2010: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2011/01/02/business/20110102-metrics-graphic.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2011/01/02/business/20110...
- loeg 10y agoI saw that visualization back in 2011 and I think it's actually a pretty poor one. It uses shades of red for what are objectively not bad outcomes (return greater than inflation is red, real return between 3 and 7% is pink). IMO that's misleading. It would be helpful if it compared against the same visualization for other straightforward market investments, like bonds, or savings accounts / CDs. Those asset classes would be red (or pink for long-term bonds, perhaps) across the board. Stocks look great in comparison. But picking a slightly more reasonable color scale would help.
- squeaky-clean 10y ago> It uses shades of red for what are objectively not bad outcomes (return greater than inflation is red, real return between 3 and 7% is pink). IMO that's misleading. Not sure if I'm reading it wrong, but the key shows <=0% as red, 0-3% as pink, 3-7% as biege.
- loeg 10y ago3-7% looks more pink than beige to me, but I'm a little red-green colorblind, so what do I know. IMO it would make more sense to show 0-3% real return — strictly above inflation — as beige and 3-7% real return as a shade of green.
- secondhandvape 10y agoExcellent visual, I would love to see this updated for 2016. You can see that there are quite a few vertical slices where you will always result in a positive return. It's just a matter of how long you are willing to hold your money, and for what kind of return. That's why I'm attracted to index funds for investing. How do people feel about investing in the SP500 right now? I'm not too bullish considering the current peak and the US political future. https://www.google.com/finance?q=INDEXSP:.INX https://www.google.com/finance?q=INDEXSP:.INX
- socrates1998 10y agoThere are a lot of issues with this data. 1) Last 100 years has ZERO chance to be the same as the next 100 years. 2) The SP 500 adds and subtracts companies as they grow, fold and go bankrupt. So the only way this would be maybe work is if you invested in the ETF. 3) Macro-economic events are notoriously hard to predict and anticipate, and your returns are very much tied to how you time your entry point. If you invested in the beginning of 2008, you would have a 33% return, same for a 2001 entry. In the beginning of 2009, around 100%. Or a mid 2013 entry would get you a 17% return for three years, around 5% a year. And if you invested in mid 2014, you haven't seen ANY return, 0%. The point is that entry points are insanely important. Getting 33% return for 15 years is horrible, especially given the opportunity costs. This is the problem that you get when Warren Buffet fools you into "buy and hold". Yes, it has worked for him, but he is an insanely great investor. You can't replicate his returns. You can't even sniff his returns. So what's the answer? I don't know, do what you want with your money, just don't listen to anyone who thinks they know the answer.
- zymhan 10y agoThe entire point of the article is that you should invest long term, and that long term will always pay off over a long enough time frame.
- edanm 10y agoI totally disagree with your points. "2) The SP 500 adds and subtracts companies as they grow, fold and go bankrupt. So the only way this would be maybe work is if you invested in the ETF." First of all, it's not the ETF, it's an ETF. And this isn't exactly news - this is the basic method of investing always recommended (alternatively, an index fund, which is similar). "3) Macro-economic events are notoriously hard to predict and anticipate, and your returns are very much tied to how you time your entry point. If you invested in the beginning of 2008, you would have a 33% return, same for a 2001 entry. In the beginning of 2009, around 100%." Well, yes, but this is kind of the point of the article. It shows what is the chance of coming out ahead out of any 20 year period in the last 100 years. "This is the problem that you get when Warren Buffet fools you into "buy and hold". Yes, it has worked for him, but he is an insanely great investor. You can't replicate his returns. You can't even sniff his returns." Warren Buffet doesn't "buy and hold", but he recommends it for most people exactly because it's relatively easy, and gives you very good returns.
- rando18423 10y agoLots of talk in here concerning superpowers falling, and not much about how it's way more favorable for companies to use debt financing in a low interest rate environment... Lol developers should stick to developing
- Evolved 10y agoWho do you think created HFT (High Frequency Trading) systems? Surely bankers stick to banking but hire developers to give them that competitive edge. The odds are that software engineers would have come up with the idea of and implementation of, a working high frequency trading system before bankers would have despite banking probably not being a software engineer's specialty.
- rando18423 10y agoI think market makers used technology to do exactly what they've always done at increasingly higher speeds. History also shows you're wrong, for hundreds of years market makers have sought an edge by trying to get information faster and faster. Hell, it used to be carrier pigeons that gave them the edge. There's really not much new here...
- AceJohnny2 10y ago> for hundreds of years market makers have sought an edge by trying to get information faster and faster. And then it spurred the telegraph, and then the telephone, and then... :)
- the_watcher 10y agoI wouldn't say this is surprising. If you can extend your horizon, you can weather downturns that reduce your asset value, buy while demand is low, and simply wait for the cycle to reverse. Real estate shows the same pattern. The problem is that not everyone has the means to simply extend their horizon.
- edpichler 10y agoI am a holder and, as a small stock market investor, this study is gold to me. As a holder, the worst years are the first decade, after that, the interests become explosives. The difficulty to be a holder is to spend less on the present to get return in a future. Human being is definitely not good on this.
- tunesmith 10y agoThe other reason none of these returns are realistic for an average person: 1) People don't get a lump sum at the beginning of their investment history 2) Ah, but you say, dollar-cost-averaging. The problem there is that people get more money to invest when times are good, and less when times are bad. 3) As a result, even when buying in responsibly, people are buying more when the market is high, and less when the market is low. It distorts performance. Plus, betting on having average-or-better performance is a risky bet. Don't count on more than 2.5% / year lifetime.
- vm 10y agoA lot of companies offer retirement plans where a % of income is invested monthly, a la dollar cost averaging (e.g. 401k plans). It's really easy to set up and let ride on autopilot.
- greedo 10y agoBut that still skews the dollars invested. At age 22 (college grad) you might make $50K. You put in 6% and get a 3% match, for $4500 into your retirement fund. Fast forward to age 50, when you're making 200K (this is 28 years from now, so inflation and pay raises bump you very high), you're putting in the same %, but that equates to $18K/year. So even with dollar cost averaging, the majority of your money is invested in a small, 10 year time window when you are at peak earnings.
- cryoshon 10y agoAhem, good comment, but: At age 22, you make 25k and get 0% matching, and can afford 0 to put into your still-hypothetical retirement fund. At age 50, if you're the median person, you make 50k. And you need that money to put your kid through college.
- dismal2 10y agois your planet accepting applications?
- dredmorbius 10y ago
- nradov 10y agoThis is a silly analysis in that it ignores investment costs. You can't invest in the S&P 500. You have to either buy an index mutual fund, or buy the individual component stocks. Either way the investment costs will significantly cut into long term returns, even with a fund like VFINX.
- Inufu 10y agoThe expense ratio for VFINX is 0.16%, compared to average yearly returns of 6%. Over 30 years, that's the difference between 5.74x and 5.48x your starting capital. Noticeable, but insignificant compared to the taxes you'll pay.
- twblalock 10y agoIt can be even cheaper than that. If you buy VOO, the ETF equivalent of VFINX (Vanguard's ETFs hold the same portfolio as their corresponding funds), the expense ratio will be only 0.05%. If you buy this ETF through Vanguard, you will not pay any commissions. It's very close to being free, and definitely the cheapest way to invest in the S&P 500.
- tempestn 10y agoOne important thing to note is that although the far right end appears to narrow, that is not because returns become more certain over very long time ranges, but rather simply due to lack of samples over those very long periods. What's more indicative of reality is the relatively constant vertical distribution, in a log scale, across any time range up to about 90 years, when the lack of data starts to play a significant role. So, in relative terms, uncertainty remains fairly constant over time. In absolute terms it actually increases. In a sense risk still does decrease over long time horizons, as the chance of earning over any given amount does increase with time; contrary to common belief though, the distribution of possible returns (another possible definition of risk) actually increases with time - or remains roughly constant on a log scale, as mentioned. (You can find a great many opinions surrounding this by googling "time diversification".)
- bllguo 10y agoVery cool project, but - and I mean no offense by this - these views are taught in basic finance! There are similar graphs in standard finance texts. So it surprises me that so many people here seem to be caught off guard. I look forward to seeing where the project will be heading next. In fact it is inspiring me to do similar analyses.
- nullc 10y agoThese graphs with inflation adjusted returns need a cash line, to show that in inflation adjusted terms cash is not some magical safe option that doesn't go under 1.0.
- rrecuero 10y agoI really like the write up & simplicity of the explanations. Obviously, choosing Vanguard Index funds and avoiding timing the market it is a great financial advice. One piece that I always find missing is that in my opinion, money is not worth the same as you age. From my point of view, money in your 20s, 30s have 3x or 4x more value than when you are 50. You can go skydiving, scuba diving... When you are 60 your options to enjoy that money are much more limited. I think that should be factor in financial decisions that it is often overlooked
- styli 10y agoany chance you can show us some of the source code? curious to know how to build these type of graphs.
- meric 10y agoThis is great analysis. Keeping in mind there's more motivation to do this kind of analysis during euphoria phase of the stock market than during capitulation phase of the stock market like in 2009 or 2010, I think this shows investing in the long term will cancel out losses in the short term.
- chae 10y agoAs somewhat alluded to in the article, some of the graphs here extrapolate historical data and assume it to be a good predictor of the future. Without an understanding about the deep nuances of economics - for which someone else can supply good or bad reasons why this or that might happen - there is no reason why the future should necessarily rely on anecdotal evidence.
- Halaoo 10y agoNow if only the next 100 years will be the same as the last 100 years! Even though it's a totally different world.
- FuNe 10y ago<fun-at-parties-mode: on> Ehm it's a bit of a long shot to assume next 100 years will be more or less business as usual. Having said that and after a quick look around the climate frontier, economy and international affairs I'd probably buy (if I had money to burn) defence industries stock. <fun-at-parties-mode: off>
- Jackmc1047 10y agoIt would be great to see the long term results as compared to buying less risky assets, like treasuries. It's not a question of whether the market's returns are positive over the long run, but whether they are positive enough to justify the additional risk.