13 ms·
To Compete Better, States Are Trying to Curb Noncompete Pacts
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agouh... isn't the whole point of "States" because a larger controlling body is a bad thing, and many groups want to make deals in their own ways? so then a Company WANTS to make deals their own way "Noncompete Pact" deals, and now you're telling them they can't do that... and you think by driving away these companies by not letting them do what they want, that you will somehow compete better? for what? the 50th spot on the economic rankings list? idiots.
- pyre 10y agoSo your argument is that to achieve economic growth one just needs to pass a law that says "companies can do anything and everything that they like, no restrictions?"
- ProAm 10y agoI thought it was illegal to prevent someone from earning a living?
- mcv 10y agoIt should be, but apparently it isn't in all states.
- gnopgnip 10y agoIn most states the agreement must be reasonable, and there is a lot of variation in how that is interpreted.
- kiba 10y agoIf you're a felon, then you're essentially prevented from earning a living.
- sokoloff 10y agoHow so? They're prohibited from possessing firearms, so they're not suited for armed security, but there's nothing structural preventing them from earning a living. Plenty of companies will hire felons, just not all of them.
- astrodust 10y agoIn practice "plenty" translates to "almost none" and those that do tend to abuse their employees since there's very few repercussions. Simply being unemployed for an extended period of time is enough to exclude you from many jobs. Being a felon and having done jail time excludes you even more severely.
- tracker1 10y ago"I was operating a sole-proprietorship business from 1998 to 2012."
- astrodust 10y agoThat can work for a case of simple unemployment if you can make it sound plausible, but if you can't come up with a single client reference from that period of time you could be pooched. This is also complicated by the fact that you may have no option to admit that you're a felon and served time since they may have your police report on their desk. We're living in an era where having nothing more than an arrest record, even if no charges were ever filed, is grounds for suspicion. It doesn't even matter if you were someone walking their dog and rounded up by the police in some kind of illegal kettling, you have a record.
- driverdan 10y agoFelon here. I haven't had trouble finding work. I have highly desirable skills though so I recognize it's much harder for others.
- st3v3r 10y agoSure, but that's not another entity doing it, that's due to your own actions.
- praxulus 10y agoIf you voluntarily enter into a contract in which you agree not to do a certain kind of work later in exchange for compensation now, it's perfectly legal for the other party to enforce that contract (unless it was in the form of a non-compete and you live in e.g. California.) This is a matter of labor standards, not individual liberty.
- pyre 10y agoIt's hard to argue that a competitive salary for work done is "payment" for not doing something later on. If they are paying an above average salary for the job, it might be arguable.
- alkonaut 10y agoIt's possible to sign a contract with unreasonable terms, but such a contract may or may not be enforacable. If you happen to live somewhere where a contract can have a noncompete for 6 or 12 months without compensation, and it also happens to be enforcable there, only then do you need to worry about this. A noncompete without compensation likely isn't enforcable in many places (Although it may be in some or most of the states of the US).
- tdicola 10y agoI've been fortunate enough to have an employer with no non-compete, but in the past with my first job out of college I just signed everything and was under one for a year after leaving. My thought process now is that a non-compete is just another thing to negotiate during the hiring process. I'm happy to sign one but I will absolutely require that I'm compensated at least for a year of salary, benefits, etc. while under the non-compete. It's only fair that if you're asking me not to work for a year that I can actually sustain myself and my family. Employers are just coasting off the fact that people will sign these things and ask for nothing in return--once people realize it's negotiable (even if you just plain walk from that job opportunity to something else) employers will have a much tougher time with them IMHO.
- aetherson 10y agoYeah, so it would in a lot of ways be ideal if people could reasonably read, understand, and negotiate the contracts they sign, and then be reasonably bound by those contracts. So each person could say something like, "Sure, I'll sign a non-compete. For an extra $15,000 per year." And then the company could decide if that's worth it to them. In practice, people just sign what's in front of them, and indeed even if they want to read and understand everything, they can't without a fair amount of training -- and the existence of lots of other people who will just sign what's in front them means that it's hard to negotiate based on what you're signing even if you do read and understand it. (Digression: I bought a house. The amount of paperwork that I signed without reading was probably around 100 pages. This is a crazy way to live.) This feels like a problem that is getting amenable to a technological solution. It's pretty easy to imagine a digital assistant that could understand common contract phrasing and even do things like say to a person, "This offer includes a non-compete clause. Based on your demographics and the position, signing a non-compete clause will cost you approximately $X per year. Would you like to negotiate for +$X per year? Y/N" The problem, it seems to me, would be to get buy-in to the idea that such digital assistants should exist and that companies would have to accommodate such assistants.
- CaptSpify 10y agoI signed mine with my new hire paperwork. I had just flown across the country to take the job. Am I supposed to say no when my family had just spent a ton of money to move? Shady when companies do this, IMO
- rdl 10y agoI've been thinking of a mutual defense society for startups in Washington who in good faith hire someone and the employee is then threatened by Amazon or Microsoft, as a former employer, on non compete grounds. I suspect if you were willing to completely go to war over a hire, you could ultimately get noncompetes invalidated. The problem is the chilling effect on marginal hires -- it usually isn't worth going all the way on hiring someone when you have other options, and even when it is, it makes sense to settle and move on (for both sides). (From what I've heard, Amazon is particularly egregious in enforcing noncompetes. I believe they are an unconscionable and unconstitutional restraint on individual liberty, and believe the federal courts would agree, as well as the court of public opinion.)
- aetherson 10y agoWhat is your basis for believing that federal courts would agree?
- st3v3r 10y agoThey generally take a dim view of a company trying to prevent someone from earning a living.
- tacostakohashi 10y agoPerhaps the main thing such a society could do is maintain a website with data about employers that have non-compete clauses in their employment contracts, and the extent to which they try to enforce them (like Chilling Effects, but for employers). If prospective hires for such companies knew that they would be seen as damaged goods on the employment market as a result of working for a certain company, it would influence their choice of employers, especially in the common scenario of having a few offers to choose between and not having much else to separate them with.
- jessriedel 10y agoAgreed. It's always a shame that the response to purported market failures is either (1) attempt to regulate directly or (2) do nothing, rather than (3) attempt to fix market failure through narrow means.
- mancerayder 10y agoIn New York State, the company has to demonstrate damage to it in order to win a lawsuit, and non competes are usually tied to some sort of previous granting of something, like stock options which can be lost. In practice judges rarely enforce them more than a year although the contracts stipulate longer periods. Now, the above is just my understanding, I'm not a lawyer and new to this awful world of non competes. Just the threat of a lawsuit can steer behavior since defense against one can be costly.
- x0x0 10y agoa mere threat of a threat (counsel at new company saying yes his noncompete covers us) lost me a job offer in nyc
- ghaff 10y agoI worked for a small company for a number of years. We wouldn't even look at anyone who had a non-compete that could even conceivably have triggered legal action.
- chollida1 10y agoIt's nice for some anonymous internet person to say "Non compete clause? just don't sign them" but if you are ever lucky enough to get high up in a company this often just sometimes isn't an option. So if you do have to sign one then the below is the advice I've been given by the employment lawyer's I've spoken to over the years. 1) make sure it says you are compensated for the time you can't work. ie if it says you cant' work for a competitor for a year then you should be getting a salary for the same duration. Some companies will try to give you a signing bonus and include language that the signing bonus is consideration for you waiving this compensation. I mean it's nice to get $50,000 in stock vested over 3 years just for signing, but it won't feel that way if your former employer also views this as compensation for you not working for a year. I've had 3 or 4 employment lawyers go over this with me, both as an employee and as an employer and they've all repeated this, if the company doesn't' pay your salary during the non compete period then you just cant' sign it. Now they also stressed that this means the non compete is probably not enforceable but that won't be much consolation if they drag you to court. 2) Be very clear as to what "salary" means. So if you are a Google engineer and you have a salary of say $125,000 and then a bonus of say $100,000 worth of restricted shares vesting over 3 years and maybe a signing bonus of $50,000 worth of shares vesting over 3 years, you might brag that you just got paid $275,000, but the company will probably argue that they only need to pay you the pro rated amount of your salary over the waiting period. Finance especially gets burned by this, as small salary and huge bonuses are how many hedge funds compensate their key employees, also known as the "you eat what you kill" compensation package. 3) Be very wary of telling your former employer of where you are going to work. There just is no real upside to it. I've also been told not to hire former employee's in the first year you leave for a competitor. It's one thing for a company to loose you, but if you leave and take an entire team with you then even though you've probably done nothing wrong, it own't be very comforting when you are out of pocket $10,000's of dollars in lawyer fees and stress. As always, IANAL, I've just happen to work in the most incestuous industry around, finance, and I've seen and heard too many horror stories of people leaving for another firm and bringing their team with them and then being in court for years.
- morgante 10y agoI think the key point isn't not to automatically sign or not sign non-competes. It's to realize they are a negotiable item (just like salary, stock, vacation, severance, etc.) and to ask for appropriate compensation in return for signing it. This can include a guarantee of salary during the time of its application. You can also narrow the conditions under which they're invoked or the scope of what's considered competition.
- jt2190 10y ago*** MASSACHUSETTS TECHIES: THIS IS ABOUT YOU *** * Read the article * Contact your State Representative [1] and urge them to support the bill [2] [1] https://malegislature.gov/People/Search https://malegislature.gov/People/Search [2] I think this is the bill text: https://malegislature.gov/Bills/189/House/H4434 https://malegislature.gov/Bills/189/House/H4434
- etjossem 10y agoWhen an employer sends you their boilerplate agreement and you see "Employee will not work for a competing business", you're not looking at the only employment agreement they've ever signed. You're looking at the version most favorable to them. Strike out the "for 2 years following employment" and replace it with something reasonable like "while employed by the Company." It's customary to ask for a ridiculous clause like this up front, because no candidate will walk away over the mere sight of it. They get one free chance to screw you over, just like when you were talking about salary and they asked what you made at your last job. But you have to do your part; politely bounce it back. You are a professional and this is a negotiation. No one will begrudge you putting a reasonable counteroffer on the table.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoWhy would I want to work somewhere that I notice has just taken a free chance to screw me over?
- etjossem 10y agoBecause the opportunism of the company's legal department (or laziness of them using RocketLawyer boilerplate) doesn't correlate one bit with whether you'd want to work as an engineer there. Other signals matter way more.
- nsxwolf 10y agoThat's getting to emotional. The definition of "screwing you" is you taking their first offer, no matter what it is. Both sides should be trying to get as much as they can in a negotiation.
- st3v3r 10y agoNo, this is actually screwing you. Preventing you from working for any amount of time after you've left their employ is actively trying to screw you.
- 10y ago
- angersock 10y agoI'm curious if there has ever been a case where an employee going into competition with their former employer has been a net negative for society at large. Most of the tech we enjoy today probably would've been prematurely killed if the creators were under modern non-compete and NDA paperwork.
- zerohp 10y agoIt's hard to imagine that we would be even close to where we are now if non-compete agreements, that are common in other states, had existed in California in the 1950's and 1960's. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traitorous_eight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traitorous_eight
- pinewurst 10y agoCertainly Shockley would've used them and sued if he could.
- shawnz 10y agoI imagine the harm would come from it becoming commonplace, not from any one employee doing it.
- anonymousDan 10y agoWait, so in some states you can be prevented from working in your field, and the company doesn't even have to compensate you? That's insane! Why would you agree to that?
- ryandrake 10y agoBecause you have one job offer, are almost out of money, and like having food to eat this month? Most employment agreements I've seen are "agree or GTFO". Sure there are some HNers here who have successfully negotiated this or that out of their agreements, but the option is not available to everyone.
- st3v3r 10y ago"Why would you agree to that?" Wrong question. The proper question is, "Why is that allowed?"
- forgetsusername 10y ago>Wrong question. The proper question is, "Why is that allowed?" Because people should be able to put whatever ridiculous terms they want into a contract. It's up to you to agree in the first place, and in the second, a court to determine if the term is enforceable. There are a few valid reasons for a non-compete, after all.
- st3v3r 10y ago"Because people should be able to put whatever ridiculous terms they want into a contract" No, they shouldn't. "There are a few valid reasons for a non-compete, after all." No, there aren't.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>No, they shouldn't. No, you're right. Someone like, say, you, should get to decide, preemptively, what a contract between two parties should or should not be allowed to include. Because you know better than the parties actually doing the negotiation, right? Why should we trust that the relevant parties know what's in their own interests? >No, there aren't. Yes, there are.
- TempleOS 10y agoTempleOS is God's official temple. Once my space alaien contact has been announced to the World, the whole world will know and I will have 400 million customers. God says... highlight Lysenko widgeon's widest Shenandoah Hammett's Gaea transmigration's sweep's obdurately mistletoe grit's haggles Suez Abner's microwave Czechoslovakian's professionalism unions calabash's Gilchrist infirmary's leashes Felipe yielded narcissist modifiable Bluebeard's denominated withdrawing scrunching pearled
- DannyBee 10y agoThe old boogeyman that used to get trotted out by companies was the "they'll steal trade secrets and run away to other companies". With the federal defense of trade secrets act now a thing, can someone tell me exactly what purpose at all non-competes still have that makes any sense? (If it's "we spend time and money training people or signing bonuses or whatever", great, make them pay back the money if they leave too quickly)
- morgante 10y agoNon-competes can make sense in client-facing roles. You don't want to pay a lot of money for someone to come in, develop relationships with clients, and then walk out the door with all their clients when someone else offers more money. It makes some sense to have non-competes for sales, lawyers, and similar positions.
- DannyBee 10y agoErrr, that's not a non-compete. That is a "no-solicitation-of-clients" agreement, and that is common in the legal industry, for example. There is no reason, as a lawyer, i should not be able to go to a competing firm just because they compete with you for the same client base. Full stop. If you want me to not solicit your clients, that's fine. But again, that's not "non-competition", it's "non-solicitation". So while i don't disagree with you, that isn't what these agreements cover :P
- morgante 10y agoYou're right. Non-solicitation agreements and non-compete agreements serve slightly different and overlapping purposes. Technically, non-solicitation agreements only prevent solicitation. So they can bar me from hopping to a competitor and calling up all my old clients to bring them over. They don't prevent me from joining a competitor, having all my old clients find out, and having them then decide to join me. Thus, a non-compete is often simply a stronger form of non-solicitation. That's also why you sometimes see non-compete agreements which apply to a geographic area. They're also often regulated in tandem. AFAIK, both are unenforceable in California. For what it's worth, I think the harms done by non-competes far outweigh this limited argument. But you can't argue that there isn't an argument.
- morgante 10y agoIt seems particularly egregious that non-competes apply even in the case of layoffs or firing. It's one thing to keep employees from running off to a competitor for a slightly higher salary. It's unconscionable to fire someone and then prevent them from finding a new job in their field. That's egregious.
- harry8 10y agoYou can fire someone to go to their competitor for a lower salary, eg off-shoring. That's just fine. Surely it has to work both ways. You must be able to quit to go to a higher salary unencumbered or it's just pure regulatory capture by employers to screw employees.
- st3v3r 10y agoYou're under the impression that employers want things to be fair.
- zekevermillion 10y agoThe article is seriously misinformed. It seems to imply that noncompetes can restrict employees from working in their field. That is not the case in New York. Post-employment restrictions are only enforceable to the extent they protect a "legitimate business interest" of the former employer. That interest does not extend to preventing former employees from practicing their trade. Employers use noncompetes abusively all the time. The problem is not the state of noncompete law. The problem is the nature of the legal system.
- DerekL 10y agoHow is it misinformed? So New York is different. The article clearly says that the legality of noncompetes varies from state to state, and it doesn't mention New York State at all.
- zekevermillion 10y agoIt is misinformed in that it misstates the law in most US jurisdictions, including the one in which it is published.
- harry8 10y agoIt's really simple. If you want to enforce a non-compete you have to pay* the employee gardening leave for its duration. Enforcing a non-compete when you've laid someone off is utterly indefensible and anyone who does this deserves to go bankrupt fast. Usually when forced to pay employers discover ruining an employees career isn't actually worth anything much to them and don't enforce. But if it's free it's a great lesson to current employees - we'll go after you if you want to leave so no you're not getting a raise. *pay the maximum of the employees salary including any bonuses vs market rate, where the market rate calculation has to be defended by the employer in court and can be retrospectively re-applied. With the usual obvious basis of "the employee had offers for $x" etc.
- roflchoppa 10y agoYeah when I was working retail, there was a cat that i met that needed some help, (he was known by all the managers). I offered to help him on his project, to which my mangers found out, and were talking about firing me over it. I had no idea that that would violate my NonCompete clause that i signed to when hired, being that it was not related to retail AT all, and there were no transferable skills that I learned. Luckily my lead saved my ass, and told the managers "theres no way he knew that."
- bbcbasic 10y ago> there was a cat that Sounds like an Alice in Wonderland story.
- OliverJones 10y agoIf you live in MA, please write to your state legislator and ask her or him to move on this. We need noncompete reform here. This bill isn't perfect. But, as a child I know might say, "EMC isn't the king of me." https://malegislature.gov/People/Search https://malegislature.gov/People/Search Thanks.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shermozle 10y agoIn Australia it's quite simple. If you want an enforceable non-compete, you have to pay the person their salary for the duration. I'm personally quite happy to sit on the beach on full pay for a year or two if you guys think it's important!
- NetTechM 10y agoI'd be on board with this idea. Australia seems to have a very worker supportive law system though.
- bbcbasic 10y agoGardening leave I think it's called.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- randomacct44 10y agoGot any references for this? I'm in Australia and have never heard this, nor have I seen such clauses in any non-competes that I've signed.
- Animats 10y agoNone of those states will catch up with California. The other states are proposing weak limits on noncompetes - limited by industry, limited to "unreasonable" terms, etc. California also doesn't let employers claim rights in work you do on your own time. Both of those rights fuel California's startup culture.
- jbpetersen 10y agoGot details on employers not being allowed to claim rights on work done during free time? I heard from a Google employee that their contract prevented them from working independently on personal projects.
- arkem 10y agoHere's the California statute: http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=lab&group=02001-03000&file=2870-2872 http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=lab&gr... It says that IP assignment clauses that cover non-competing work done on the employee's own time with their own equipment are not allowed. How it works at Google is that you sign an IP assignment clause that says effectively "All the intellectual property that you create is the property of Google except where prohibited by law" and then they attach a copy of that law to the contract. After that you can work on personal projects but if you don't like uncertainty Google has a process that will affirm that Google has no claim to your side project. The process has you describe the project and affirm you worked on it on your own time and then if Google agrees that it doesn't compete with them they'll let you know that they're ok with it.
- NDizzle 10y agoI have worked part time at several different places while keeping a full time thing going. (which doesn't pay much, but I choose my own adventure) Each one has tried to make me sign paperwork involving them getting first right of refusal on things I make. I have refused to sign those documents, three times now, twice for one company, with no real recourse from their side. HR put on a show but I didn't take the bait. Make a stand when it comes to things like that. I own my spare time, nobody else.
- ckdarby 10y agoPaywall. Why Does HN allow this stuff to be submitted?
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoMy favorite is when the company you work for is purchased and the new owners come in and lay people off, then those who are left get 3 days to sign a non-compete. I begrudgingly signed because I had nothing else lined up at the time.
- sitkack 10y agoI don't understand the companies that are going under, lay off employees and then still except the non-compete to be binding. I would at least expect where the company initiated the departure that the non-competes are no longer binding. That, and that I get a small stipend for the duration of the non-compete.
- gwbas1c 10y agoI think requiring a high portion of a former salary during a non-compete is fine. Otherwise, it's just not fair to enforce.
- pc86 10y agoBy "states" they mean Massachusetts. In many states they are all but entirely unenforceable (CA) or only enforceable under very specific circumstances (PA).
- CyberDildonics 10y agoI had a non compete clause crossed out of a contract once. I was told they didn't usually change contracts, but they did. I was also told 'it isn't usually enforced, there are plenty of people that have taken jobs at <only competition in the city>'. I said 'then it shouldn't be in there'. Everything worked out for me but people need to remember a few things: 1. A contract is a negotiation/conversation/two way agreement. It is never a take or leave it offer in my experience. 2. Get the contract EARLY. Companies try to build momentum and act like a contract is a formality. Then they hand you something that takes away as much power from you as possible. They have lawyers, bargaining power, choice, time, experience, and a global view of salary that you might not. There is a huge imbalance of information. 3. If it is worth signing, it is probably worth having a lawyer take a look at it. A lawyer might bill at $250/hr. It might take 30-45 minutes to look through a contract and that can be a very worthwhile investment. 4. And of course, take the contract seriously. Don't sign something thinking the scenarios where it comes into play are too rare for you to care.
- st3v3r 10y ago"1. A contract is a negotiation/conversation/two way agreement. It is never a take or leave it offer in my experience." In your experience. In many others, it is. Especially if they're in an area with not a lot of tech employers. Just because you find it easy to negotiate doesn't mean everyone does, and that doesn't mean that those who can't should be screwed over because of it.
- CyberDildonics 10y agoNothing I said contradicts what you've said.
- st3v3r 10y agoNo, this is a complete cop out. You're saying, "I can do it, so there's no problem." Yet, most people aren't in the position to do it, so there is a problem.
- nfriedly 10y agoI have a friend who was "reminded" by his first employer that he had signed a non-compete after he changed jobs to a second (competing) employer. He ended up finding a third job at a company in a somewhat different field. This was in Ohio where non-compets are enforceable, and the courts likely would have sided with the first employer if it had gotten to that point. I don't think he ever realized what he had signed until he was "reminded" of it.