13 ms·
In Newly Created Life-Form, a Major Mystery
- meursault334 10y agoArticle summary and Article http://www.cba.mit.edu/docs/papers/16.04.minimal.pdf http://www.cba.mit.edu/docs/papers/16.04.minimal.pdf edit: appears to be the full article (scroll down past summary)
- kens 10y agoI encourage people to read the one-page summary and at least the section headings in the full article. To answer a few question that have come up: How did they synthesize the genome? By creating short sequences of DNA and joining them together step by step to make larger sequences. They chemically synthesized short DNA sequences and assembled them into 1.4 thousand base pair (kbp) fragments. Five fragments were assembled into 7 kbp cassettes, which were assembled in yeast to generate 1/8 chunks of the genome, and these chunks were assembled in yeast to create the full genome. (See figure 2.) To try out deletions, they could replace a 1/8 chunk, rather than synthesizing the whole genome. Why can't they delete all the non-essential genes? Bacterial have a lot of redundant genes, where two different genes provide the same essential function. Just like redundant disks, you can remove one, but not all of them. And you'll get different of minimal genomes depending on which gene you keep. One interesting thing is that because the growth medium provides almost all the necessary nutrients, they could remove a lot of the metabolic genes, but needed to keep a lot of genes to transport molecules across the cell membrane. You can imagine a minimal cell constructed the opposite way. The article doesn't mention that in their first synthetic bacterium (2010), they encoded text (actually HTML!) in the DNA to provide a secret watermark. See http://www.righto.com/2010/06/using-arc-to-decode-venters-secret-dna.html http://www.righto.com/2010/06/using-arc-to-decode-venters-se...
- daemonk 10y agoI wonder how they removed the genes? I am not an expert in microbiology. I work with mainly eukaryotes, but I am guessing intergenic distances are not a huge factor here? What about spatial arrangement of the genes? Did they generally leave that alone? Genes are not independent functional modules. Their placement and arrangement on the genome matters. Did they only mess with coding features (genes)? Or did they also mess with other genomic features? Or do such things just not matter with bacteria?
- maxerickson 10y agoIf I understand correctly, they built the technology to synthesize arbitrary genomes. So they remove genes by omitting them from the synthesis.
- chubot 10y agoThe article says they tried the additive/synthesis approach first, which didn't work. And then they tried the subtractive approach, starting with M. Mycoides. And in that case they were left with a lot of "unexplained" genes. But he reminds us that the subtractive process entirely depends on the starting cell. I would like to hear more about the difference between additive and subtractive methods -- it wasn't entirely clear from the article.
- maxerickson 10y agoYes, for the design of the genome. As far as I can tell, they synthesized the molecule. A line from the paper...: We used whole-genome design and complete chemical synthesis to minimize I did fret for a second over what meaning of "remove" daemonk was using (from the design? From the instantiation of the genome?) but decided I at least wasn't posting misinformation.
- jhoechtl 10y agoThis reads to me as: They took a working system and did parts away until the system failed (or did stgh "odd" towards failure). Then they were looking at the pieces they took away and guessed what functionality these pieces have.
- alextheparrot 10y agoAdditive method: Synthesize genomes with the genes you expect to be necessary, pretty much an optimization problem on the number of genes where you continually try to remove genes that were in previous iterations. Subtraction method: After reading a bit of the paper, they utilized Tn5, which causes a DNA sequence to be arbitrarily inserted into the DNA (Random locations). This randomly disrupts genes, causing them to likely not function correctly. Here's the logic: If all genes were necessary we would expect no cells to live that had mutations. If no genes were necessary we would expect all cells to have mutations at about an equal rate relative to the space they occupy. (Assuming no bias by the Tn5, but that's a nuance) What they instead found was that some cells grew, but there were certain genes that were not mutated, meaning that they are likely necessary. They also classified a few things like studying the growth of the cell (Slow growing, but still viable was classified as "quasi-essential") and implanting their minimal genome in another species, which failed giving evidence that a subset of genes that are sufficient for survival are not necessarily sufficient in all cells.
- sevenless 10y agoI find it fascinating we still don't really know how life works. I have a hunch we are going to find the large scale 3D structure of the chromosome is a big deal, and these genes regulate it. There aren't many good tools to study chromosome structure and it's quite possible there's a whole layer of information we've missed so far.
- daveguy 10y agoThere is a significant branch of microbiology that studies the 3D structure of chromosomes. Epigenetics is the study of how gene expression (rather than composition) affects a phenotype. There is a strong influence of structure, telomeres, centromeres, and expression modifiers that work at a physical level. It will certainly be a major component of functional life. It took decades after genetics were established for the scientific community to accept epigenetics as a valid influence and avenue of study (due to both a lack of methods to accurately study these aspects of an organism and scientific inertia). edit: pedantics.
- dekhn 10y agothat's not biochemistry- it's structural biology. Biochemistry focuses almost entirely on reducible components in isolation.
- MOARDONGZPLZ 10y ago>it's quite possible there's a whole layer of information we've missed so far Can you expand on this comment? What would such a layer look like? Have we missed layers before and then found them?
- sevenless 10y agoThe whole story of molecular biology has been discovering layers of control and information: DNA, genes, gene regulation, RNA, RNA splicing, protein structure and regulation, protein interactions, micro-RNAs... and it's usually been limited by the tools that scientists could bring to bear. Possibly there's another control layer in charge of the long range structure of the chromosome. Being wet, squishy and fragile, it's hard to study.
- sixQuarks 10y agoI'm afraid it's not the individual genes themselves that are important to life, but a specific combination of those genes. Further complicating the problem is that we have no idea how many genes comprise an "essential group". Is it a combination of 2 genes? 3, 5, 10? When you're talking about 175 unknown genes, the combination of all of these is a huge number. It's like finding a needle in a haystack the size of the solar system. I don't think this brute force approach is going to work, we need a different way to figure this out, but I'm confident that once figured out, it will seem simple looking back on it.
- smaili 10y ago> I don't think this brute force approach is going to work, we need a different way to figure this out, but I'm confident that once figured out, it will seem simple looking back on it. Why not? Couldn't we use machines to automate this and analyze the results?
- JimmyM 10y agoI think it might take a while. http://coolconversion.com/math/factorial/What-is-the-number-of-zeros-on-the-end-of_175_factorial http://coolconversion.com/math/factorial/What-is-the-number-...
- sixQuarks 10y agoWhen you're talking about 175 different genes, there are far more combinations of genes than there are atoms in the universe. Perhaps a quantum computer can tackle this kind of problem, but nothing we have today can brute-force the solution.
- alister 10y agoThey got it down to 473 genes, but let's say that minimal life is some 20 of those genes. A brute force approach would require trying 10^34 combinations[1]. And that's already with the simplifying assumption that 20 genes is the minimal set rather than 19 or 106 or some other subset. [1] http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=473+choose+20 http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=473+choose+20
- davnn 10y agoTL;DR: Venter and his collaborators originally set out to design a stripped-down genome based on what scientists knew about biology. ... With the right tools finally in hand, the researchers designed a set of genetic blueprints for their minimal cell and then tried to build them. Yet “not one design worked," ... So the team took a different and more labor-intensive tack, replacing the design approach with trial and error. They disrupted M. mycoides’ genes, determining which were essential for the bacteria to survive. ... Venter is careful to avoid calling syn3.0 a universal minimal cell. If he had done the same set of experiments with a different microbe, he points out, he would have ended up with a different set of genes. ... In fact, there’s no single set of genes that all living things need in order to exist. ... They found that not a single gene is shared across all of life. “There are different ways to have a core set of instructions,” ... Venter’s minimal cell is a product not just of its environment, but of the entirety of the history of life on Earth. ... He and others are trying to make more basic life-forms that are representative of these earlier stages of evolution. ... Some scientists say that this type of bottom-up approach is necessary in order to truly understand life’s essence. “If we are ever to understand even the simplest living organism, we have to be able to design and synthesize one from scratch,” ... “We are still far from this goal.” As @sixQuarks has already written, finding the minimal amount of genes when there are 175 unknown ones and you don't know anything about their dependencies and relationships seems to be pretty much impossible. > In fact, there’s no single set of genes that all living things need in order to exist. ... They found that not a single gene is shared across all of life. That's the most interesting point to me, I deeply believed that organisms share the same basic set of genes.
- Retric 10y agoNot all life has DNA.
- davnn 10y agoDo you know an article about that? Did not find anything about a life form without DNA, except http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/12/101202-nasa-announcement-arsenic-life-mono-lake-science-space/ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/12/101202-nasa-.... The definition of life itself is not really obvious to me either, some sources count viruses as life other don't.
- LionessLover 10y agoThe actual study can be accessed for free on "The Pirate-Bay of Science publications" Sci-Hub: http://science.sciencemag.org.sci-hub.cc/content/351/6280/aad6253 http://science.sciencemag.org.sci-hub.cc/content/351/6280/aa... About Sci-Hub: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sci-Hub https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sci-Hub
- coldcode 10y agoIf I were a biology/biochem/genetics/etc type of student today this is exactly what I would love to work on. Perhaps someday we will actually understand how life works. That's both exciting and incredibly scary.
- XorNot 10y agoIt does involve loving a lot of really mundane and slow work though. Bioscience is a lot more fun to read about then do, because our tools still really really suck (but grad students are plentiful).
- pluma 10y agoI don't know. The definition of "life" seems so arbitrary and nebulous. It seems really more like we're trying to attribute properties based on a wishful interpretation of emergent behaviour that ultimately boils down to extremely convoluted chemical reactions. Trying to produce genuinely novel and distinct biological lifeforms sounds cool enough on its own though.
- sevenless 10y agoYes, the boundary between life and non-life is not sharp, but to claim it follows that life is hard to define would be the continuum fallacy (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuum_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuum_fallacy) Manufacturing a living cell from purely chemical ingredients is a concrete enough goal. And almost certainly it lies far, far off in the future.
- phieromnimon 10y agoSo it's like a unikernel of life?
- IncRnd 10y agoIt's closer to a microkernel.
- kazinator 10y agoThat's like forking someone's program, but not understanding two thirds of the code. (What's the big deal? It happens!) If you take someone's 4000-5000 line program and whittle it down to 473 lines which are still somehow useful, "newly created" doesn't apply in full honesty, let alone if you don't know what a third of those lines do.
- fnovd 10y agoIn this analogy, they're not looking for the code to "work". They simply want it to compile.
- majkinetor 10y agoThat is wrong analogy. Compiling the code doesn't mean it will run.
- oldmanjay 10y agoMaybe life is written in Haskell
- entropicmind 10y agoThey do want it to work, they just want it to be the MVP.
- darawk 10y agoThis is great. This is the proper engineering approach to understanding life. Whittle it down to the minimal reproducing test-case, and poke it with a stick until you understand what all the parts do. This is just excellent science. It seems like it should be very easy to get these unknown genes to reveal their function now. Very exciting times.
- no_flags 10y agoInteresting work, but it reminds me of the famous "Could a biologist fix a radio?" paper [1]. The paper imagines biologists trying to determine what parts of a radio are essential using a similar trial and error technique. As you can imagine, this technique would lead to many erroneous conclusions, especially when paired with the "publish or perish" and "gold rush" mentalities so prevalent in academia. It makes you wonder if we are trying to understand biological systems with a fundamentally wrong approach. [1] https://www.cmu.edu/biolphys/deserno/pdf/can_a_biologist_fix_a_radio.pdf https://www.cmu.edu/biolphys/deserno/pdf/can_a_biologist_fix...
- roadnottaken 10y ago> It makes you wonder if we are trying to understand biological systems with a fundamentally wrong approach. Got a better idea?
- no_flags 10y agoThe last couple pages of the aforementioned paper give some thoughts on that. The author suggests an approach more like engineering that is focused on formalized mathematical descriptions of biological systems.
- scott_s 10y agoThe submitted article talks about attempts to design a minimal set of genes, but they kept failing. The difficulty with your comment is it sounds like you're dismissing the work; I'm sure they are aware of that paper and its lessons. They tried working in that direction and failed.
- entee 10y agoThis criticism of the way biologists/geneticists/biochemists approach problems is I think quite misguided and misunderstands both limitation of testing things you can't manipulate with your bare hands, and how subtractive (take stuff out, see what happens) methods fit into the larger process of biological inquiry. First, when you can't manipulate things directly, it becomes more difficult to tweak systems slightly to learn how they work. This is especially true if you start with something made from things you don't understand, and for which you may not even have a complete catalog. The radio paper raises some issues and acknowledges these challenges, but then sort of glosses over them, saying, "it's complicated, but that's just because we don't understand and don't use the right language." Second, biologists don't just use subtractive methods, they try to use additive approaches to complement and test the hypotheses that come out of "it's broken when I take this bit out." Biochemists also try to reproduce complex behaviors by mixing only the purified components of the system in question. Biochemists and biophysicists also often measure very precisely physical and chemical properties to mathematically define the behavior of biological components. The point is biology is hard, and we barely know anything about it. We have to start with simple experiments that point us to what's important and then progressively do better defined experiments to figure out how it works in detail. The next step here is: now that we know what proteins are important, let's figure out how they work exactly. We couldn't have gotten there before trying to knock out as many parts as possible. TL;DR: this isn't the wrong approach, it's the right one, and given the limitations of the system, realistically the only one we have at this stage. It's also only the first step, now we get to try other approaches on what we've learned.
- drabiega 10y agoMy take-away: Work like this is somewhat akin to attempting to determine the specification of Intercal through reverse engineering given a working program and a compiler.
- dekhn 10y agoOne of the things that originally attracted me to biology was the idea that it was like reverse engineering a computer system with no manual. After a while that got old.
- otto_ortega 10y ago"The function of 79 genes is a complete mystery.'We don't know what they provide or why they are essential for life — maybe they are doing something more subtle, something obviously not appreciated yet in biology' " It is the activation key God puts on each living being... Ain't gonna work without it. =P
- wahsd 10y agoThey should have called it Pandors's Box
- misiti3780 10y agoHas anyone else here read Nick Lane's new book - The Vital Question - I just finished it and this article really seems like a continuation of some of his theories he talks about. I found about the book from HN, and have since bought every single other book by him, almost done with Life Ascending now, which is also amazing
- kens 10y agoYes. I read The Vital Question after hearing about it on HN a few weeks ago and found it very interesting (although less so nearer the end, as it seemed to get more speculative). To oversimplify, mitochondria are the key to understanding life and eukaryotes. (I should study electron transport more closely.)
- haberman 10y agoHow much information is 473 genes? How many bytes does this represent, in a compact but "raw" encoding? What about if you compressed it with gzip? Also what are the raw/compressed sizes for a human genome? I have wondered this for a long time but never seem to find a concrete answer.
- gberger 10y agoFrom [1], "Mycoplasma genitalium: it has only about 480 genes in its genome of 580 070 nucleotide pairs." So in average, each gene is 1200 nucleotide pairs. A nucleotide is one of [A,T,C,G]. So that means it encodes 2 bits of information. 473 * 1200 * 2 = 1 135 200 bits, or 141.9 kilobyte. Of course, this is coming from a software developer using numbers from Google, so I might be wildly wrong. [1] "Molecular biology of the cell" by Bruce Alberts
- haberman 10y agoThat's a great start at least! Posting something that is wildly wrong is the best way to get someone who knows more to interject with corrected information, so hopefully someone with expertise can confirm or deny.
- gberger 10y agoCunningham's Law
- pYQAJ6Zm 10y ago141.9 kB! In the future, I expect there will be a demoscene of biosynthetics.
- amphitoky 10y agothe cellular genome size of RGD3.0, the organism with a 473 genome, is 531kbp according to the paper. this means that the genome encompasses ~531,000 nucleotides (base-pairs). for reference, the human genome encompasses approximately 3.3-billion base-pairs. you can download the human genome from here http://hgdownload.soe.ucsc.edu/goldenPath/hg38/bigZips/hg38.2bit http://hgdownload.soe.ucsc.edu/goldenPath/hg38/bigZips/hg38.... (it is recommended to use ftp, see: http://hgdownload.soe.ucsc.edu/goldenPath/hg38/bigZips/ http://hgdownload.soe.ucsc.edu/goldenPath/hg38/bigZips/). it is an ~800mb download. if it takes 800 mb to store 3.3 billion bases, i would assume it takes (531k / 3.3b) * 800 mb = 0.141 mb to store this genome.
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoForgive my complete ignorance, but how do they even count genes? Given a very long string of base pairs, how is it possible to know where one gene ends and the next one begins? Do genes overlap?
- ceejayoz 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Start_codon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Start_codon and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_codon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_codon
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- warrenpj 10y agoI think this is a great question. I was vague on this as well but I found this site after a quick search [1] A gene is a code for making a specific protein. Each gene is a sequence of three-letter "words" called "codons". There are special "start" and "stop" codons which mark the beginning and end of a gene. [1] http://genetics.thetech.org/about-genetics/how-do-genes-work http://genetics.thetech.org/about-genetics/how-do-genes-work
- pazimzadeh 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene_prediction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene_prediction is usually done by searching for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_reading_frame https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_reading_frame
- callesgg 10y agoIf the cell had a log it would be filled to the brink with warnings and errors :) Thinking if it like: Just remove files from the OS until it wont start :)
- peter303 10y agoFour months old news. I will Dr Venter in Aspen Saturday.
- k26dr 10y agoAnybody else find it suspicious that 2 quanta magazine stories were the top two stories on HN today?
- rgtk 10y agoThat should be us.