9 ms·
How I turned “Street Sharks” into an online social experiment
- coldcode 10y agoTruth is such a slippery concept. How easy it was to create by a school kid, and how organically it grew over time despite being entirely made up. Imagine how much better people with professional tools and desire can generate much more harmful information than fake Henry Winkler appearances.
- rspeer 10y agoA while back, I forget who, but someone tracked down some false facts that were supported by circular references in Wikipedia. Wikipedia doesn't allow you to cite Wikipedia, of course, but the trickster added an unsupported, false fact to Wikipedia, which was quoted by someone's blog, which was quoted in an article by a "science" "journalist", and then the trickster updated the Wikipedia page to reference that article. I think it's important to take note that this can happen instead of dismissing it as childish pranks. We should apply the "security mindset" to our sources of information, not just to our computation.
- kanyethegreat 10y agoGood point. However, he does touch on the fact that since the information was so trivial, not many people cared to vet its validity. Hopefully, people would be more critical of "harmful" information. "We form rough consensuses based on vast amounts of conflicting data, but who really has the power to verify any of it? This is especially true when the stakes are low. A lot of people will put effort into dispelling rumors that the Moon landing was fake or that Hitler is still alive, sure, but who cares enough about something as meaningless and easy to ignore as Street Sharks to make sure all the information about it online is totally accurate?"
- fennecfoxen 10y agoThis seems like an interesting article. However, the large advertisement on the screen covering the entire viewport with no 'close' button makes reading it a real challenge.
- pinum 10y agoYou need a better ad blocker.
- mangeletti 10y agoI can't help but read this like: Let me show you how dangerous sidewalks are by telling you the story about the time I went for a walk while swinging a spiked bat at every passer by. It was great fun, but it demonstrates why sidewalks are dangerous.
- gilrain 10y agoAnd considering the respectable sources have since corrected his misinformation, tack on a: "That neighborhood is now better policed, but still, you never know!"
- knodi123 10y agoHow many articles have had the premise "You can't trust wikipedia, because it's full of lies! Why, just look at this handful of lies I've put on there!"
- incongruity 10y agoBut that's not what this is, really. It points out the greater danger of the propagation of those lies. It's entirely reasonable to assume others might similarly lie and this article demonstrates how such lies can propagate through the internet in certain cases.
- sp332 10y agoSo, you lied, but it's someone else's fault? After all, what kind of person would intentionally sow lies about Street Sharks across the internet? Well, not a good one.
- Balgair 10y agoMeh. I see this more as god-tier trolling. We have no way to easily tell if this piece is a total lie or a long delayed admission of truth. I'm certainly not ever going to research this to determine if it is valid. And that is what makes the troll god-tier. The nugget of truth he alludes to is then instantly suspect for everything now. Though I may forget that the internet of made up of dogs impersonating people from time to time, upon reflection I will remember the Street Sharks guy and be brought back to the 'center'; that everything on the net is a lie. The commentary on epistemology and nihilism aside, this guy is a god-tier troll. Soberly, I'll never trust a thing on here again.
- jessaustin 10y agoGrandparent probably doesn't consider trolls to be "good people". Of course, with the wisdom of experience one finds that trolling is just another form of rhetoric, neither "good" nor "bad". Good people will troll us to the truth at least as often as bad people will troll us to butthurt.
- sp332 10y agoLiars, not trolls. I mean I guess there's overlap but it's the lying I'm calling out. The author seems continually surprised and concerned that people would believe lies about history, but that's not new or surprising or even interesting. In fact that's why we each have a responsibility to tell the truth.
- jessaustin 10y agoEveryone who communicates, lies. One who doesn't expect that, won't be able to make much sense of the world. It's not useful to draw bright lines around the category of "lies". It would be pretty awful to lie to your boyfriend about whether you had an STD, or to your kid about the existence of imaginary holiday characters. Making up shit about some forgotten TV show just ain't the same thing. The best trolling may not be precisely lying, but it's certainly more about assuming alternate versions of reality than it is about e.g. just being rude.
- projectramo 10y agoI know this is pitched as an experiment about the internet, but I think it is an even more telling experiment about the malleability of human memory.
- MollyR 10y agoI'm still wondering if its really the malleability of human memory or our need to fit in / social pressure to conform ?
- eric_h 10y agoOr, indeed, if the latter affects the former.
- munificent 10y agoA little from column A and a little from column B. I have young kids and it's fascinating watching them talk about half-remembered stuff from the past. They'll start off not really remembering much and taking guesses. Then the other takes that guess as gospel and repeats it back. Now the first has more confident. Soon they are both fully convinced of a whole pile of fabrications. It made me realize how much of our memory is socially constructed.
- MollyR 10y agoNot sure I understand. Isn't memory of experience different than our believing it ? Or is it something like there isn't "truth" in our memory ?
- toss1 10y agoExcellent question, and the answer is that human memory is generally highly fallible, malleable, and unreliable. We all have the naive impression that memory is somehow like a video recording and we can just access it to find out what happened. Indeed, we all have some very vivid and probably quite accurate memories about some exceptional events, or can recall exactly what page and what part of the page we read some specific item. There area also examples of amazing memory stunts and records, and even memory contests and championships. But we cannot assume that just because we have some very good memories, memory is generally good, indeed, it is mostly pretty bad, especially compared to any kind of recording system. This is supported by several areas of research demonstrating how easy it is to plant fake memories, reshape memories, and get people to be completely convinced that they are describing are exact and real. One area of research is eyewitness testimony, which has pretty much been the standard in courts since courts existed, yet when eyewitness accounts are compared, they almost always come up with a variety of contradictions. There's also been research into the phenomena of "found" or "recovered" memories often used to convict accused child abusers. Again, it turns out that suggestion and guidance on the part of the investigator can create things our or whole cloth, so it must be very carefully guarded against. There's also several other research areas in which this is relevant, but the outcome is pretty consistent -- human memory is generally pretty bad (sorry I haven't got the time to track down the references). I've found that it's best to just treat memory as merely a good hint about what might have happened (or where I might have left that tool or the keys), and then look for actual evidence of what really happened.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoIn my opinion, this prank is very intricate and took a lot of effort while not actually proving the point that "history is meaningless on the internet" because the subject matter - the Street Sharks - are/were essentially forgotten by history itself. Sometimes things just naturally slide away and nobody cares. It's like, "What year did the black Power Ranger turn good?" or "What was the top selling Rock band in the years 1975-1983?" and then making up an answer because, well, it's not really pertinent stuff. There are much better cons online, I like to think...edit...even if this is some kind of meta-joke where it turns out all the fake parts are being faked...sigh...
- fearandclothing 10y agoWell, if the author's intent was some sort of meta-joke about hot "everyone reports on everyone else’s reporting," it seems to be working, as other sources are reporting on it: http://screencrush.com/street-sharks-hoax/ http://screencrush.com/street-sharks-hoax/ http://www.vox.com/2016/5/27/11788884/street-sharks-hoax http://www.vox.com/2016/5/27/11788884/street-sharks-hoax http://www.avclub.com/article/read-utterly-fraudulent-alternate-history-street-s-237396 http://www.avclub.com/article/read-utterly-fraudulent-altern... http://gawker.com/everything-i-ever-thought-i-knew-about-street-sharks-wa-1778991889 http://gawker.com/everything-i-ever-thought-i-knew-about-str...
- justinlardinois 10y ago> "What year did the black Power Ranger turn good?" Was the black power ranger ever bad? I recall the green ranger going bad, then later returning, reformed, as the white ranger. Or was mixing up the colors intentional to further your point?
- 6stringmerc 10y agoHonestly I don't really remember and was just trying to throw out a subjective memory example. Black, Green, whatever. If it helped make my point I can say it was unintentional!
- Klinky 10y ago
- dsugarman 10y agothink about how much worse it was before the internet
- vessenes 10y agoTo those who are questioning how much truth the 'confession' has in it, you are definitely getting in the spirit of things. The confession is sort of a buzzfeed-ish version of Umberto Eco's Foucault's Pendulum, and he digs in, at length musing on lies and truth and how they mush together in ways that are very hard to untangle. At any rate, if you liked the essay, I recommend the book.
- imron 10y agoBack in the early days of the IMDB, and before they got strict with verification, my brother uploaded information and credits for his high school movie assignments, which I had 'acted' in. A Google search for my real name still returns my IMDB actors page as one of the top links.
- ipsin 10y agoI honestly don't understand the animosity towards the author. I consider this sort of mischief to be a healthy thing. If you are exposed to true facts constantly, all facts are true, in the same way that a TSA X-ray tech who sees ten thousand not-bombs might miss the one actual bomb. I think of lies and disinformation as good for a mental agility, and an adjunct of storytelling. Is there no space for the trickster in our lives?
- joe_the_user 10y agoPranks and studying how unsourced information spreads is fine, the "history is meaningless on the internet" claim is probably what people are reacting to. A lot of mystics use the argument, "because you can be fool here, truth itself does not exist" and sometimes that can be fairly harmful.
- mangeletti 10y agoIf you're referring to my comment and the tree under that, there isn't any animosity whatsoever, just a lack of respect for the notion that the author's own mischief is somehow a sign of how the Internet isn't capable of representing truths, which is absurd.
- andrewflnr 10y agoI think Rox->Roxie is a pretty plausible confusion even without "malicious" interference, so I'm not sure those parts prove anything.
- bendmorris 10y agoThe actual Rox was a human, though, not a female Street Shark as the author described her and people are claiming to remember her. Edit: to be fair, I'm trusting the author's current account, I never watched Street Sharks myself. I could be the victim of some epic meta trolling.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Aelinsaar 10y agoMore like, "I used lies about a cartoon to convince some people online that history is meaningless on the internet." Nothing was proved, and I wonder how long that deception lasted. Edit: Title has since been changed.
- koolba 10y agoThis is a jawesome playbook of how "facts 2.0" get created.
- JackFr 10y agoI don't think it's the internet's fault. In 1941 a couple of friends made a few phone calls to newspaper sports desks and concocted a college football team: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/16/sports/ncaafootball/the-41-season-at-plainfield-teachers-college-when-every-play-was-a-fake.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/16/sports/ncaafootball/the-41...
- ZenoArrow 10y agoYes, was certainly possible to dupe people in this way before the Internet. This Wikipedia page contains some relevant examples: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fictitious_entry https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fictitious_entry As a side note, it'd be funny if one of the stories on that page turned out to be made up.
- CapitalistCartr 10y agoIn Tampa we have an annual celebration each year, in the style of New Orlean's Mardi Gras, of the notorious pirate José Gaspar capturing the city more than a century ago. Of course its all made-up nonsense. None of it ever happened. We still have a great party for it.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoThe National Baseball Hall of Fame is located in Cooperstown, NY, a tiny village in the middle of nowhere. Cooperstown was chosen because a man named Abner Doubleday invented baseball in Cooperstown in 1839. A baseball field, Doubleday Field, stands on the exact location where baseball was invented. Of course, that is a totally made up story. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doubleday_myth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doubleday_myth
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rz2k 10y agoIn 1910, a delegation of Abyssinian royals was given an official tour of the HMS Dreadnought[1]. The delegation was comprised of Virginia Woolf with a glued on beard, Horace de Vere Cole, and other members of the Bloomsbury Group. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dreadnought_hoax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dreadnought_hoax
- ikeboy 10y agohttp://www.dailydot.com/entertainment/wikipedia-hoax-yuri-gadyukin-nitrate-movie/ http://www.dailydot.com/entertainment/wikipedia-hoax-yuri-ga... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9724350 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9724350
- tuna-piano 10y agoFor those blaming the guy, and not the system / sites. If Obama used the fake fact in a speech of his, would you blame his researchers or the guy who originally made up the lie? I think the point is that authorities on information have a responsibility to ensure the information is accurate.
- iamgopal 10y agoHow deep you go for checking the fact ? Ultimately you always need to depends on someone/something else.
- FussyZeus 10y agoNone of this is the author's fault. The initial lie was meant as harmless fun, the fact that so many (largely highly regarded) media properties went and spewed it out as fact later on is the real problem. I mean how many times a week do we hear about Old Big Media retweeting nonsense or publishing Onion articles? News sources these days are so programmed to chase every story that there's no room for fact checking and they all look like incredible idiots. It's amazing to me that anyone takes Old Media seriously anymore.
- passivepinetree 10y agoWhat news sources do you use? What is New Media?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoDoesn't matter. Pretty much everyone knows most of media publishing is bullshit. After N+1th comment thread debunking a news article I'd thought at least everyone on HN understands that implicitly now. But quite many people agree and then immediately forget about it when the next story hits. On-line news publishers don't care about accuracy or truth. Period.
- FussyZeus 10y agoI wouldn't say there's a singular answer to that question, it's a combination of multiple sources and social media driven sources. None of them are particularly good, and none of them are infallible even slightly, it's about checking. Plus a good old fashioned bullshit filter.
- MollyR 10y agoA little scary what this implies about groups of people with axes to grind on places like wikipedia.
- fullshark 10y agoIt's why the wikipages on hot button issues that special interests care passionately about (Scientology, Abortion, etc) are so heavily moderated.
- MollyR 10y agoBut who moderates the moderators ? In this article, the author mentioned he became an editor for street sharks to help him spread his lies.
- kolapuriya 10y agoThe fact that people have blindly accepted them as false is subtlety proving his point about history on the internet. the fact that you do not understand that people simply do not care about street sharks does not make his premise intelligent or thought provoking.
- syphilis2 10y agoIt's interesting that in this case the misinformation can readily be proven false. What method is there to identify incorrect information when no primary source exists? How much trusted information can never be verified?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoWhat surprised me the most was people willing to go along with a lie. Human memory is a pretty faulty and malleable thing, but this level of confusion as was cited at one point in the article? I think it requires someone to be either consciously lying or have utter disregard to the value of what they're saying. It's one thing to repeat a lie because you didn't know the information wasn't true (though I'd consider providing confidence estimates on information you repeat as a basic human decency); it's something else entirely to repackage the lie and sell it as something you vouch for personally. These people are bullshit amplifiers.
- sp332 10y agoInformation that's mostly true with a few lies thrown in is very hard to verify. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap_street https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap_street
- TeMPOraL 10y agoFair enough, but posting that you have a movie that never existed recorded on tape because you presumably liked it so much - that's a completely different thing. That people are willing to do this - for what? Internet points? - saddens me deeply.
- conradfr 10y agoThat's great. I love how myths can still be created and spread in this Internet age. Another example : around 2005 someone made a playlist for himself of some Mars Volta b-sides and called it "A Missing Chromosome" [1]. Somehow it spread on P2P networks, was even listed on Wikipedia in the band's discography section with a back story etc. I still have it in my collection under that name with the art etc and don't see the need to correct it. A forum I'm in maintains a list of some fake things they put in Wikipedia. It's harder to do these days but some are still there and we joke that some parts may have found their way in some student school work. 1. http://forum.thecomatorium.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=105589 http://forum.thecomatorium.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=105...
- fixermark 10y agoConsider the Slender Man story, which was concocted more-or-less whole-cloth on Somethingawful.com's fora. Two young people stabbed a third ostensibly to sacrifice her to this character, and one of the editors of somethingawful.com posted an article [http://www.somethingawful.com/news/slenderman-not-real/ http://www.somethingawful.com/news/slenderman-not-real/] reminding people that the story was 100% fabrication.
- nkrisc 10y agoWhat I think is most interesting is the people who all claim to "remember" these lies. Are they knowingly claiming to remember something they never saw to appear more knowledgeable or is their memory shaped by these lies they read? The latter is scarier.
- bitwize 10y agoThis reminds me of the time some fangirl invented an entire season of Inspector Gadget with her fan character in a prominent role as a love interest for Gadget -- and tried to pass it off as if it really happened, replete with faked screenshots of Gadget and her invention. The IG fan community actually took the bait for a while before she was outed.
- EGreg 10y agoI have done something less malicious, but right around the same time. When I was in NYU's grad math program, the Wikipedia just getting going. It had a lot of articles, but not on every topic. I was studying Analysis and decided to start the article on the Hessian Matrix. Yes, I started that article and it's been fun to watch it grow over the years. Most sections I have added are still there, as well as some phrases such as "more can be said from the point of view of Morse Theory". It really set the direction of the subsequent topics and edits. One section in particular, there, was completely made up by me. It was ACTUALLY TRUE, but it was never (to my knowledge) stated anywhere. No one had really made a treatment of the matter. Namely: Hessians of vector valued functions. I said they were tensors of rank 3. There was a discussion in the talk page about it. Some people were confused and argued for a bit but since was true, the community kept it, thinking that being a true math concept it must have a source somewhere. Now it has been expanded and an actual analysis of how it can be a tensor of rank 3 has been worked out. Now this may have led to citations that will lead to research on Hessians of vector valued functions acting as tensors. All because I wrote it there. It wasn't false, like the Colbert's lie that "Elephant population of Africa has tripled in the last six months." But it was an experiment to see what an unsourced original statement would lead to on a fairly mainstream article.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- superJimmy64 10y ago"I’m living in an ontological nightmare of my own making. It’s jawsome!" Had me in tears. Also, I completely forgot about that show until coming across this so thanks for bring back some history!
- smaili 10y agoIMHO I think it was the fact that the show was so obscure and lacked enough popularity to actually motivate people to bother validating it. If it was a much more popular show, say The Big Bang Theory, there would be enough knowledgable people to catch the falsities.
- cloudjacker 10y agoI was hoping this would reference the Berenstain Bears thing. I thought that was stupid because someone was obviously introducing a psychological impression when creating the theory.
- Endy 10y agoOne word applies: JAWSOME!!!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Dove 10y agoThere was an article a couple days ago about why everyone believes Columbus proved the world was round[1], even though that isn't true[2]: The real myth of the medieval flat earth begins first in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries and has two principal sources. Probably the most influential of these was the American author Washington Irving who in his fictional biography of Columbus claimed that Columbus had to fight against the Church’s belief that the world was flat in order to get permission and backing for his voyage, a complete fabrication. I see an interesting parallel between the two cases. When you're the most influential person talking about something (or the only person at all...), people who later want to learn about the subject treat you as the best available authority, even if you're a bad one. Information is copied from authorities and self-reinforcing over time, much like genes in a population. What that means is when there's a bottleneck in the number of people talking about a topic, you can see a founder effect[3]. [1]https://thonyc.wordpress.com/2016/05/25/repeat-after-me-they-knew-it-was-round-damn-it/ https://thonyc.wordpress.com/2016/05/25/repeat-after-me-they... [2]That Columbus proved it, that is, not that the world is round. [3]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Founder_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Founder_effect
- vidarh 10y agoOf the many sources to demonstrate that it was well known that the Earth was round, I like Dante the best: His Divine Comedy explicitly described the world as spherical, described how that meant different parts had day and night at different times, described how the stars would be different, etc.. It's not a very early source - there are many earlier ones -, but his level of detail shows that it was well understood what it meant and that the idea could be published in a work dealing with religion without controversy in the middle of Europe.
- Namrog84 10y agoWhat if this article was the social experiment. Did anyone verify any of the claims that he had even actually lied. Maybe he is fabricating a story about fabrication? I know I didn't verify. But don't fall into his sneaky trap again(or perhaps the first time).
- drivingmenuts 10y agoIt's going to be a much bigger problem in the future. I looked at the descriptions for the three shows. Frankly, nothing seemed out-of-line because I didn't watch toy-oriented cartoons in the 90s and that subject matter falls into a genre I just don't care about. Truthfully, I suspect that those synopses pretty much describe all 90s cartoons. For that matter, your entire article could be a social experiment, but the subject matter of Street Sharks is so far off the spectrum of things I care about that it's the first time I've ever even heard of them. But, it does illustrate how easy it is to slip things in like that. Do it enough times with lots of small things and sooner or later, you have enough evidence for something larger and so on and so forth. Still don't care about Street Sharks, though. And please, for the love of <deity>, don't show this to Michael Bay.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- justinlardinois 10y agoReminds me of the tale of Slow Blind Driveway, which if I recall correctly was the longest running hoax ever on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:List_of_hoaxes_on_Wikipedia/Slow_Blind_Driveway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:List_of_hoaxes_on_Wi... And of the fingerboxes meme on 4chan.
- fapjacks 10y agoI have done very similar stuff to Wikipedia for almost ten years now. It is astonishingly easy to make specious claims in backwater articles that no one cares about. It is pretty insane what happens to the articles afterwards. For example, on one article, someone else has made a couple of edits adding even more lies to my completely invented claims! Another "subtle vandal" (as I call myself)! I never expected that. And when someone else edits your false information for clarity, or whatever, it's as good as gold. One trick I use to encourage that is to make minor grammatical or spelling errors. If a human doesn't lumber by to edit (and then seal into fact) my bullshit information, usually an automated bot will eventually do the same thing. It's very important not to make your information sound too trite or wild. Most Wikipedia editors take everything with a big grain of salt the last few years.
- owly 10y agoNo one has mentioned the 2016 Election and the fabrication of stories from the front runners of both parties. History and memory are not being erased, just overwritten with new "facts".
- madebysquares 10y agoThe idea that lies and misinformation can spread quickly and widely on the internet is proven almost daily. If you've ever seen a onion or any other satirical website post a story and then get shared liked, commented on, restated and then its like wait did none of you 60-70 ppl realize the article was fake?