14 ms·
Four hundred miles with Tesla’s autopilot forced me to trust the machine
- j2bax 10y agoHow far out are we from truly autonomous personal vehicle travel? I want to set my route and play a game or work or sleep. I want the vehicle to automatically stop and charge when it needs to. If I'm feeling like it, I can get out and use the restroom. I would be so much more likely to make frequent cross country trips to visit family and so much less likely to ever book a flight unless I'm needing to cross water. I wonder how this would hit the airlines in the US.
- tobltobs 10y agoIn europe we have this already. It is called railway.
- adventured 10y agoWhich for most city to city travel will end up being dramatically less efficient and far more expensive than electric, autonomous cars that can go 400+ miles on a charge - unless you're only going from large metro to large metro over a particularly long distance. For travel within cities, autonomous electric vehicles will ultimately surpass rail travel. That will happen within several decades. The cost of car use and ownership will plunge. Software and constantly improving batteries will eat the expense out of the heart of the machines. What's the cost and usefulness to run high speed rail between two mid-sized Romanian cities that are 60km or 100km apart? Right, it's wildly impractical. Inexpensive, autonomous, electric vehicles however are the future and will be extremely practical for all purposes except very long distance travel between two major cities. No other scenario will justify spending the vast sums of money required to install and upkeep high speed railway - and that cost will only continue to climb with wages and security threats in Europe; meanwhile electric, autonomous vehicles will bring the cost of vehicles down dramatically over time.
- tobltobs 10y agoWhat about the already congested roads, missing parking places in (european) cities and lastly the expensive maintenance for roads?
- argonaut 10y agoWait what? You have it the other way around. Rail will still be dramatically more efficient and cheaper than electric autonomous cars. And inter-city subways will still be more efficient and cheaper than electric autonomous cars. They have higher density, use less space (as opposed to huge roads/highways everywhere), and pollute less.
- MagnumOpus 10y agoThere will be a combination. Autonomous cars replacing taxis and buses; light rail/MRT for the last 5 miles in dense city centres; heavy rail for rapid medium distance transit (100km < x < 400km); planes for long distance transit. If anyone thinks that there is the road capacity for a million self-driving cars to drop passengers during every morning rush hour in Mid/Downtown Manhattan or the City of London, they are deluded.
- vertex-four 10y ago> What's the cost and usefulness to run high speed rail between two mid-sized Romanian cities that are 60km or 100km apart? What's the cost of building from scratch and maintaining year-on-year a road along the same line, including vehicle and operating costs, before subsidies? That is - what would it actually cost you to drive a car if your taxes weren't paying for it? Hint - it differs for nearly every situation, and even the idea of high speed rail - 125mph or higher - is not necessarily useful in all situations. A decent commuter line with good bus links to every station is potentially more useful than a high-speed line which zips past dozens of towns.
- PeterisP 10y agoRailway cannot pick me up from where I are and cannot deliver me to where I want to be - it can cover the long distance parts, but I need another means of transportation to go to the railway station and from it.
- tobltobs 10y agoSeriously, we should find a solution for all those poor stranded railway passengers. Oh, wait, what are those tramway, buses, cabs, metro, rental cars, bikes and scooters are doing in front of the station. Hmmmm?
- lettergram 10y agoI'm guessing it would impact airlines minimally. I'm in California and my family is in Illinois. Even the best route, speeding the whole way, it takes me twenty hours. Hell, just to go to San Diego from San Francisco is 7 hours minimum (took me 12 last Friday). People fly to save time, and if youre going to a hub city (I.e. Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, Atlanta, etc.) It will likely be cheaper to fly as well, I just booked a flight from San Francisco to Chicago for $148 (driving would easily be $250).
- brianwawok 10y agoTo be fair not $250 in an electric car
- tlrobinson 10y agoProbably not if you factor in depreciation on an expensive self-driving electric car. Looks like SF to Chicago is at least 2000 miles. (Which also makes me wonder how you can do that trip in 20 hours. Speeding indeed :)
- j2bax 10y agoI can only assume as autonomous travel increases and incidents decrease, the speed limit would increase. Obviously battery technology still has a ways to go to be able to last more than a couple hundred miles running 100 MPH+
- falcolas 10y agoSpeed limits depend more on the road (banking in corners, surface conditions, imperfections) and the car (what happens to the vehicle if an accident does happen) than the drivers, so I wouldn't expect major increases in speed limits.
- true_religion 10y agoI doubt that or else you wouldn't see the same stretch, and grade of road get two different speed limits depending on what side of the state border that you are on. Additionally, on the intrastate highways, the speed limits are set by local districts so local districts who like making money will often change their speed limit for any highways that go near by them so they can speed trap people.
- simcop2387 10y agoThe tesla gets the easy parts down. Highway driving is largely uneventful straight travel. It's the rest of it that's hard, detecting stop signs and lights, pedestrians and all the other corner cases that make it significantly harder for the tail end of the problem. Google's press releases about their cars make it seem like it's a few years off but I'd actually expect it to be about a decade instead, more because of testing and regulatory changes that need to happen before we see them sold. A Tesla has the capability to do the worst of that long haul trip, but it has the charger problem right now that they're trying to get more of them out there for it.
- ForHackernews 10y agoGoogle's cars have logged a lot of miles, but only over a few miles of actual road in Northern California--road for which Google has extremely detailed maps already in place. It's going to be a long time before a Google car can just drive anywhere you tell it to.
- Gatsky 10y agoIt might happen significantly sooner if we start modifying roads and intersections to be more robo car friendly.
- duaneb 10y agoThat's gotta be a bigger project in terms of man power and money than anyone has invested in self driving cars already. We need more testing to even establish the problem areas and figure out how to actively solve them.
- agumonkey 10y agoGoogle has more data. CPUs, GPUs are more potent. Yes society might take SDV in account now, a parallel 'iot' road information system. One thing that is to worry, IIRC, is that gCar sensors are only good for that climate and fail rapidly under other conditions. Fog, rain, snow have no good technology for now.
- 10y ago
- ProAm 10y agoI'd estimate 8-12 years
- kyrra 10y agoThis was a good presentation by the Google team: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uj-rK8V-rik http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uj-rK8V-rik I believe they say in there that they got highway driving down really early on. They have been focusing on urban driving for the last few years.
- andrei_says_ 10y agoAccording to Chris Urmson, lead engineer at Google's driverless car project, less than 5 years. https://www.ted.com/talks/chris_urmson_how_a_driverless_car_sees_the_road?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/chris_urmson_how_a_driverless_car_...
- bbcbasic 10y agoI want a car to drive me to work, then drive out somewhere and find some free parking for the day (or circle the block all day) and then come back at the end of the day to pick me up.
- esmi 10y agoTechnically not a personal vehicle but it does meet all your other criteria. https://www.greyhound.com https://www.greyhound.com
- tim333 10y agoComing to Stockholm next year apparently http://www.volvocars.com/au/about/innovations/intellisafe/autopilot http://www.volvocars.com/au/about/innovations/intellisafe/au...
- chestervonwinch 10y agoJust curious - at one point, he is going 85 mph in a 75 zone, but the car is on autopilot. He mentioned he had the cruise set at 80. Who is liable for accidents in this situation?
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoThe driver, just as if they had set the cruise to 80 themselves.
- dragonwriter 10y agoIIRC, the driver is always liable for the vehicle being operated in an unsafe manner; if this is due to the vehicle systems being maintained in a condition that is unsafe, that's still the driver's responsibility. If the unsafe condition of the vehicle resulted from a manufacturer's defect, this, again IIRC, generally allows those who experience damages to seek compensation from the manufacturer, but doesn't necessarily relieve the driver of liability (legal liability for any particular harm isn't necessarily exclusive in one party.)
- DanFeldman 10y agoFor now, and at this level of automation (level 2) it is the drivers fault. When cars reach higher levels of automation (that generally means deciding more things like lane changes, target cruise speed, etc) it then becomes the car's fault and by extension the manufacturers.
- ctrlalt_g 10y agoIs that written, or just your opinion (professional or otherwise)?
- eru 10y agoThat's what eg Google is lobbying for.
- kalleboo 10y agoFor one, Volvo has decided to take responsibility for accidents that happen during Autopilot driving http://www.volvocars.com/intl/About/Our-Innovation-Brands/IntelliSafe/IntelliSafe-Autopilot/News/Volvo-Cars-responsible-for-the-actions-of-its-self-driving-cars http://www.volvocars.com/intl/About/Our-Innovation-Brands/In...
- fma 10y ago"The car had already seen a 60mph (100km/h) speed limit sign, so it set that as its target speed. " So...what about those signs where kids spray paint 35 to be 85. Will it zoom to 85?
- glibgil 10y agoThe speed of the zone is also in the maps database
- emptybits 10y agoSure, but putting aside pranks and vandals, the question remains what the AI does when there is a small (or large!) discrepancy between 1) physically-signed and 2) mapped/stored speed limits. I've driven roads where the GPS swore the speed limit was 20 clicks slower than the signed speed limit. It is not necessarily safer to drive significantly slower than the posted speed limit, since most traffic will be doing at least that and relative speed differences are a contributor to surprises/crashes/injuries on the road.
- droffel 10y agoSome combination of the speed of the cars around you, the speed limit gleaned from posted signs, the speed listed for the road in the GPS map, and the average speed of cars when traffic is within a density range[1] would work. The reason for using a density range, is that if the cars are too dense, there is likely traffic, and if they're not dense enough, you'll either have outliers skewing the data, or people driving faster than normal, due to the lack of other cars. [1] When you're using Google Maps, google crowdsources data on how fast traffic is moving, based on all devices using Maps in that viscinity. You can infer traffic density based on sampling the number of people in a given area providing data. I assume that this data would only get more granular as time goes on, as we add crowdsourced data from autonomous vehicles as well. https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2009/08/bright-side-of-sitting-in-traffic.html https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2009/08/bright-side-of-sitti...
- esmi 10y ago
- Animats 10y agoFrom the article: "Auto-steer had to wait for the freeway, where I toggled it on. Unfortunately, I toggled it right back off. The portion of I-45 near my home is undergoing a multi-year $6 billion rebuild, with a long stretch spanning several exits being destroyed, reconfigured, widened, and otherwise "improved." The result is a multi-mile segment of road that snakes back and forth across what will eventually be both sides of the finished project. For now, there's no consistent surfacing, no real lane markers, and nothing for the lane-keeping system to see." "Lane keeping was almost excellent. The car kept itself squarely planted in the middle of the lane without ping-ponging between the edges like some earlier systems did. The car would still sometimes "lunge" at exit ramps when lane markings would fall away to the right or left, though the behavior was never enough to make me grab the wheel and disengage." So Tesla just has lane keeping and smart cruise control, like everybody else. NHTSA Level 2. But they're way ahead in PR. Google can handle construction, changed lanes, and offramps, city streets, and follows navigation directions. They're NHTSA Level 3. Handoff from automation to human in emergency situations is still a big problem. Here's such a case. [1] Car with autopilot rear-ended stopped car on freeway. Why? The driver tapped the brake while approaching the stopped car. This disengaged the autopilot, including the emergency braking function, under the assumption the driver was now in charge. Tesla claims the driver should have understood that, as of firmware version 6.2, the auto-braking function was disabled by any manual braking. [1] http://arstechnica.com/cars/2016/05/another-driver-says-teslas-autopilot-failed-to-brake-tesla-says-otherwise/ http://arstechnica.com/cars/2016/05/another-driver-says-tesl...
- daveguy 10y agoHaving emergency braking turn off in the event of a manual brake tap is definitely a failure on Tesla's part. Emergency braking should not only not turn off it should brake harder (to the expected traction limit) and then, of course, engage abs if the traction limit is exceeded. Emergency braking should be on unless explicitly disabled (just like abs and traction control are auto on in cars that have them).
- beamatronic 10y ago>> Emergency braking should be on unless explicitly disabled I'm trying to think of a scenario outside of a mechanic's garage that emergency braking would ever be disabled. This should really be mandatory on all cars.
- dragontamer 10y agoGood article. It captures the wonder / awe of this without going full-tilt fanboy. It keeps in mind other competing technologies to help the audience stay aware of where the other competitors are.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kendallpark 10y agoThis is a major reason I'd love to own a Telsa (or car with similar features). Right now I have to avoid driving long distances at night because I have a hard time staying awake. While I would have no intention of taking a full-on nap while on autopilot, it would make sitting behind a wheel a lot safer during long hauls between cities.
- ars 10y agoNo, that would make it much LESS safe. Instead of now where you force yourself to be fully awake, instead you will allow yourself to semi-snooze, until you hit a situation the computer can't handle - and then you are in real trouble.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoA Tesla brings itself to a complete stop safely if you don't assume control when it required you to.
- ars 10y agoYou are assuming it's able to recognize that it needs to do that. And a complete stop on the freeway is not exactly safe.
- cstejerean 10y agoUnless you kick your feet into the brake pedal accidentally whole dozing off and it disengages emergency braking and you plow into an object at full speed while still asleep.
- developer2 10y agoThis is exactly why I wish these cars would be banned from being on the road at all in their current state. Some people are assuming it means you don't have to pay as much attention. In the hands of your average consumer, these cars are not safe. As an above average user of technology, I would not trust myself to remain in constant control of such a vehicle. I certainly don't trust the average or below average consumer to handle it! Most who claim they would remain attentive are not aware that they are making false claims, and this likely includes a lot of HN visitors. The better the cars get at remaining on autopilot, the more complacent drivers will become. A really good autopilot is training its users into trusting it to handle everything. If your average commute results in autopilot practically never kicking in, your brain will naturally - regardless of your intent - find something else to occupy your attention. Reading a book in your lap, checking the weather, grooming yourself in the mirror, or even just spacing out and daydreaming. Frankly I'm of the opinion that self-driving cars are something that will happen in 50+ years. When cities are built with "roads" that are actually tracks; tracks that are designed to handle only these cars and nothing else. I imagine we will not own such cars; they'll be more like subway/metro public transit systems, but with individual pods that hold a small number of people and with hundreds/thousands of small stations to embark/disembark from. These vehicles should not be allowed until there is no manual takeover. If the vehicle cannot operate at all times on autopilot, it should not be on the road.
- repler 10y agoWith the exception of changing lanes automatically, my Jeep Cherokee does all this stuff. It does, however, automatically adjust your speed to match the lane you're changing to. At the end of the day, it's all about sensors and software. I'm sure Tesla has better engineers than Fiat Chrysler but I'm also pretty sure it's off the shelf for them and they just bolt it into the car at this point. Good stuff, though. Can't wait to see full point A to point B navigation.
- extr 10y agoEveryone is giving examples of situations where they think an autonomous car will have trouble but many of them boil down to the same thing. Cars will not truly be able to drive as well as humans until they can model humans as other rational agents and interpret subtle environmental cues (like nonstandard signage). Maybe this still isn't strong AI, but it's pretty damn close. So in that regard "fully autonomous" cars are still a ways off, more like decades than years. But I've always thought the industry will still push forward quickly, the core tech is finally getting good enough that there is a strong incentive to just go in and brute force many of the little logic "defects" inherent in the current state of AI. If it can work really really well but only for 70% of weather/driving conditions that still has huge value.
- colejohnson66 10y ago4 way stop signs were really confusing for me when I first learned how to drive. It seems there's so many nuances about when you should go or not. Is there even an algorithm available to handle them?
- ktRolster 10y agoGood point, that's a tricky one, especially when you add in pedestrians and bicycles.
- extr 10y agoAccording to a NYT time article [1] they can already do that. I'm sure by this point they can model other vehicles behavior in common situations like this. But ktRolster brings up a good point, there are many situations where a glance is all that is used or needed to signal intent. In the article they mention that at four-way stops they do this by just inching forward and testing the waters, but obviously you don't want to inch forward into a pedestrian or bicycler. Makes me wonder if we might want to standardize the method of communicating intentions to pedestrians across all self-driving cars. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/02/technology/personaltech/google-says-its-not-the-driverless-cars-fault-its-other-drivers.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/02/technology/personaltech/go...
- 10y ago
- huuu 10y agoAfter watching this and a Volvo movie I wonder what happens when you touch the steering wheel when you are in autopilot mode. It's nice that you can check your mail or read a news paper in autopilot mode as advertised but doesn't this create the danger of touching the steering wheel, turning autopilot of, while still holding a newspaper in your hand? Also I can imagine people could fall asleep when the car is driving.
- kqr 10y agoWhat? Are they actually suggesting you can read the newspaper while driving, as long as you have auto-throttle, auto emergency braking and lane keeping on?
- huuu 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xYqtu39d3CU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xYqtu39d3CU In this Volvo movie the driver is opening a note book and making notes and also is watching a movie. Both Tesla and Volvo have auto pilot mode which still needs an alert driver. But they advertise it like autonomous driving. Edit: Volvo will launch Level 4 autonomous driving indeed. So they are a step ahead of Tesla. But it's confusing because they also call it auto pilot: http://www.volvocars.com/au/about/innovations/intellisafe/autopilot http://www.volvocars.com/au/about/innovations/intellisafe/au...
- mhandley 10y agoI was chatting with a friend who runs a haulage company recently. Some of their new trucks come with auto-braking features. He told me they had to have this disabled. The truck would be driving along in the slow lane on a motorway minding its own business, and suddenly a car would dive across the front of the truck from the fast lane, aiming for an exit. The truck would go to maximum auto-brake, trying to avoid a collision that wasn't going to happen, even though the car was crossing only a few feet in front. Not only dangerous for the manual truck behind, but it caused too much damaged cargo and corresponding insurance claims. Apparently car drivers do this all the time. Anyway, I thought it was interesting that the correct action here was to not auto-brake in some situations that were clearly dangerous.
- aedron 10y agoThe car should react to something closing up rapidly in front of it, which is not the case in that situation. Seems like just a poor implementation.
- amooiman 10y agoThis is how my Subaru behaves, and it feels right. The only false positive stopping I've encountered is someone coming from the opposite direction turning left across my path. And even then, it only happens when they're close enough that i they weren't moving, it would be a problem.
- thinkMOAR 10y agoStill waiting for the KnightRider feature where you can talk to your watch to have the car rescue you, i mean pick you up :)
- magoon 10y agoAuto-braking is mandatory in all cars by 2020.