14 ms·
Electric cars are no longer held back by crappy, expensive batteries
- pcr0 11y agoI'm all for electric vehicles, but there are a few things that have bothered me about its mass adoption. Right now, electrics comprise a tiny part of the automobile market share. Yet Tesla is already running into supply issues, particularly with lithium as there are only 3 companies in the world that do industrial-scale lithium mining, that too in a handful of mines around the world. Secondly, I suppose we're currently in the honeymoon period for electrics. But what will happen 5-8 years down the line, when all the early mainstream adopters of electrics will have to replace their batteries? Is it feasible to recycle all those batteries?
- victorlew 11y agoYes. You can think of all those batteries as high quality lithium ore.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- microcolonel 11y agoI wonder how slate got the idea that they're not "expensive". Maybe the prices have been manipulated independently of supply.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoBattery costs are five years ahead of the predicted price curve: http://cleantechnica.com/2015/03/26/ev-battery-costs-already-probably-cheaper-than-2020-projections/ http://cleantechnica.com/2015/03/26/ev-battery-costs-already... GM says li-ion pack costs for its Bolt are ~$145/kWh, predicting $100/kWh by 2021: http://www.hybridcars.com/gm-ev-battery-cells-down-to-145kwh-and-still-falling/ http://www.hybridcars.com/gm-ev-battery-cells-down-to-145kwh... Tesla confirms its costs are below $190/kWh: https://forums.teslamotors.com/forum/forums/battery-cost-below-190kwh-says-tesla https://forums.teslamotors.com/forum/forums/battery-cost-bel... Batteries are following the same price curve of solar panels, and are about to get stupid cheap. EDIT: If Tesla is able to drive down battery costs to below $100/kWh, I assure you, EVs won't be the biggest success story; you'll be able to turn every wind and solar generator into dispatchable generation cheaper than coal, nuclear, and natural gas. We'll be off fossil fuels in ~10-15 years.
- colanderman 11y agoNitpick: the unit you mean is kWh, not kW, which is a different, though related, unit of merit for batteries. (kWh measures capacity; kW measures output.)
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThanks for the correction! Comment updated!
- owengriffiths 11y agoI think there's a bit of confusion about Pack prices vs Cell prices. The $145 is cell only, which is one of the reasons it is so much lower. There don't seem to be consistent pack-pack price comparisons.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI agree there is a disparity between the Bolt's cell-only cost vs Tesla's cost all-in on a pack. Regardless, the cost is below $200/kWh, and it appears that the cost decreases will continue.
- dredmorbius 11y agoThis is a real problem and a real concern. An EV essentially is a car with a very expensive fuel tank (the battery), made out of specific materials and properties. While it is efficient in energy use and can make use of fungible electricity, lithium is rare, limited to specific areas of concentration, and can (as any material) only be partially recycled. There's lithium elsewhere on Earth, or more precisely, in seawater, but processing seawater for minerals (uranium is another which might be extracted) is expensive in the sense of requiring a lot of energy (arguably the ultimate definition of cost is energy requirements). At US rates of auto ownership scaled to the world and future populations, known lithium reserves would quickly be exhausted -- a few decades, if that. With recycling, yes, some of that would be re-used, but even at 90% material recoverability (and references I have suggest 30% is far more common), you'll lose ~50% of your original material in 7 generations. (The formula: remaining material = (portion recoverable)^generations. So: 0.47 ~= 0.9^7.) Other options include other forms of energy storage (including possibly synfuels), other battery components, or we all just start walking a lot more.
- 8note 11y agoThere's someone in Halifax researching Sodium Batteries, which would be a fair bit easier to find than lithium, though less effective.
- Animats 11y agoSodium batteries have been around since the 1960s.[1] They're a high-temperature battery, 90°C and upwards. Ford built some experimental vans with sodium-sulfur batteries in 1991. Two of them caught fire. That technology was abandoned for mobile applications. There's still interest in this for stationary energy storage on power-grid scale. But not for mobile. Sodium catches fire if exposed to air. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium%E2%80%93sulfur_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium%E2%80%93sulfur_battery
- lhl 11y agoSodium-ion batteries aren't necessarily the dead end you might think. Faradion has been working on portable batteries w/ decent energy density (~150 Wh/kg), excellent charge-discharge performance (93% capacity after 1000 cycles) and competitive costs: http://www.faradion.co.uk/about/news/2015/05/489/ http://www.faradion.co.uk/about/news/2015/05/489/ Recent formulations for sodium rechargeable batteries are room-temperature and non-flammable: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4525335/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4525335/ Here's a a short article progress being made getting Na-ion batteries into an 18650 form-factor (their current prototype has an energy density of about 90 Wh/kg): https://news.cnrs.fr/articles/a-battery-revolution-in-motion https://news.cnrs.fr/articles/a-battery-revolution-in-motion While energy density is lower than Li-ion, there's probably a good argument for longevity, safety, and material costs.
- ebbv 11y ago> Right now, electrics comprise a tiny part of the automobile market share. Yet Tesla is already running into supply issues, particularly with lithium as there are only 3 companies in the world that do industrial-scale lithium mining, that too in a handful of mines around the world. Why would any consumer have to care at all about this? If it really becomes a problem the price of EVs will go up and then people won't buy them. You're letting details you needn't worry about influence your possible purchase now? That makes no sense. Do you worry about how Ford is going to source their parts when they run into supply chain issues (which they do)? Do you worry about any other company's supply chain issues? You are repeating anti-EV FUD. > I suppose we're currently in the honeymoon period for electrics. But what will happen 5-8 years down the line, when all the early mainstream adopters of electrics will have to replace their batteries? Is it feasible to recycle all those batteries? A) All manufacturers have buyback/replacement programs in place that they have to uphold with the customer. Again, you needn't worry about the details as a consumer beyond that. B) If you really insist on worrying about the details, look at some actual historic data instead of FUD; the price of EV batteries has been dropping dramatically over the last 10 years. All real signs (the fact that manufacturers keep opening new plants and increasing capacity, and that there is no real shortage of Lithium in the world despite the "3 companies" baloney) point to them continuing to drop. The only REAL reason to consider not buying an EV right now is the dramatic pace at which they are improving. But to me that just points to leasing instead of buying one.
- gnicholas 11y agoConsumers should absolutely consider whether we are on a sustainable growth curve. How common will electric charging stations be if it turns out that EVs can't rise above 10% of the total car market? If hydrogen-powered cars all of a sudden became the norm, EV drivers will be much less well-served than if EV sales continue to scale (as most EV purchasers probably assume they will).
- ebbv 11y ago> How common will electric charging stations be if it turns out that EVs can't rise above 10% of the total car market? One of the beauties of EVs is you don't need charging stations. I leased a Nissan LEAF 2 years ago, and it almost only gets charged at home. You can't really know whether EVs are going to take over or not, it depends on too many factors. If our government gets bamboozled with Hydrogen the way they did with Ethanol, then yeah Hydrogen cars could become more popular than EVs. But I would argue that even in that world, EVs are the better choice. They are lower maintenance and like I said, you don't need refueling stations. Your car refuels while it's parked in your garage.
- jseliger 11y agoBut what will happen 5-8 years down the line, when all the early mainstream adopters of electrics will have to replace their batteries? Is it feasible to recycle all those batteries? I quoted this below, but yes: http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2016/05/09/3775606/used-second-life-electric-car-batteries/ http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2016/05/09/3775606/used-sec.... Furthermore, lots of research is going into electric battery recycling. I've worked on EV-battery-related grant applications that also demonstrate promise. I can't say more about them, but I'm optimistic. At the moment, lithium commodity prices remain oddly low if most people expect reserves to run out (if you (in the plural you sense) expect reserves to run out, there's a fortune to be made!). See also http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/Is-There-Enough-Lithium-to-Maintain-the-Growth-of-the-Lithium-Ion-Battery-M http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/Is-There-Enough-....
- scythe 11y agoSupply issues are normal when demand rises suddenly. They aren't necessarily indicative of the long-term productive capacity of the Earth. Websites go back and forth on this, but truly scientific analyses of "will we run out of X" are few and far between. But there's just no point in looking for a new quarry if the demand isn't there. You think it will be, but technology is capricious -- someone could invent a new gizmo that renders your investment worthless, so market forces generally don't support dragging a bunch of resources around until there's no other option. There are ten pounds of lithium in a car battery. It's about as common as copper. That's hardly the end of the world. http://gas2.org/2008/10/13/lithium-counterpoint-no-shortage-for-electric-cars/ http://gas2.org/2008/10/13/lithium-counterpoint-no-shortage-...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- agumonkey 10y agoWild bet: Musk is planning on spatial extraction to provide itself lithium.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoIn case you missed this a few years back (not musk, but his peers): http://www.planetaryresources.com/ http://www.planetaryresources.com/
- agumonkey 10y agoI did not.
- codingdave 10y agoMineral extraction of non-renewable resources is a funny thing - when demand moves up, eventually supplies will drop, and prices rise. Then people either find a way to extract energy from a different mineral, or build better technology to remove it from rock, and prices go back down. The drop in oil and gas prices over the last few years being a perfect example of this, as it is due to new drilling techniques. When the current lull in oil prices ends, electricity will take its place. And we will start the same cycle for batteries that we have lived through over the past 100 years with oil -- either technology will bring out more lithium, or research will move us to use a different fuel source.
- devy 10y ago> particularly with lithium as there are only 3 companies in the world that do industrial-scale lithium mining, that too in a handful of mines around the world. It appears that there are more than 3 lithium mining companies[1]. Care to provide your source to prove otherwise? [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_as_an_investment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_as_an_investment
- dragontamer 10y ago> Is it feasible to recycle all those batteries? Why recycle when you can give them a second life? https://www.technologyreview.com/s/538541/nissan-gm-give-ev-batteries-a-second-life/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/538541/nissan-gm-give-ev-... No recycling involved. Just use the batteries as they are as cheap power storage.
- dghughes 11y agoForget the batteries look at the cost of replacing aluminum quarter panel which is welded on. For the Model S it's supposedly $15,000+ just for the part then fixed at a Tesla approved bodyshop. That's nuts! I did the math and for comparison on a $3 million Enzo Ferrari a hood (couldn't find a quarter panel) unpainted and used is about $10,000. http://www.ferrparts.com/en/usd/diagrams/front-hood-and-opening-device-23f01bca-50c3-48e2-ae63-e4ebfc5a08db http://www.ferrparts.com/en/usd/diagrams/front-hood-and-open... I like electric but I can't own a car that will cost so much to repair. A $15,000 bill not including labor on a $70,000 vehicle 20% of the total vehicle cost is not worth it.
- greglindahl 11y agoI'm not sure what this complaint has to do with electric cars in general -- sure, expensive cars are expensive. Your Tesla number is definitely incorrect; I rear-ended someone in traffic and fixing the front-end was $10k of parts and $10k of labor. Not a surprising amount given what the car costs. I suspect a Chevy Bolt will cost about the same to repair as other Chevy cars with a similar price.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> I rear-ended someone in traffic Emergency braking safety system didn't kick in?
- greglindahl 11y agoI have an early car, without the necessary sensors.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- StavrosK 11y agoNot to mention that even my 2014 Mercedes A class doesn't have that, for some reason.
- omellet 11y agoNow they'll just be held back by lack of a widespread charging infrastructure.
- Animats 11y agoThe next big problem is the lack of a unified charging infrastructure. Yes, you can buy a trunk full of adapters.[1] Teslas use their own plug, for which there are a CHAdeMO adapter, a J1772 adapter, and adapters for standard 120VAC and 240VAC outlets. A full set of adapters is about $700. [2] The Chevy Bolt uses Combo Cord, which supports J1772 and CCS. Looking around Silicon Valley, almost all charging points have J1772. Some are free, some require payment, and some require membership in a charging plan. Higher power stations are mostly CHAdeMO. There's a big retail markup on electricity. $0.59/KWh at some stations. And there are payment "plans", which look like cellular phone plans. Tesla's "Supercharger" is supposedly unlimited once you've paid your $2500, but apparently if you use ones near your residence, they send you nag messages saying it's really for travelers. [1] https://www.evseadapters.com/ https://www.evseadapters.com/ [2] http://shop.teslamotors.com/collections/model-s-charging-adapters http://shop.teslamotors.com/collections/model-s-charging-ada...
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Tesla's "Supercharger" is supposedly unlimited once you've paid your $2500, but apparently if you use ones near your residence, they send you nag messages saying it's really for travelers. Because its meant only for travelers. Its for unlimited cross country travel, not as your local free filling station.
- NotSammyHagar 11y agoYes, but you don't need chademo. Your car comes with 120 and 220v, plus j1172, plus you don't need an adapter for superchargers. So $0 additional cost. Plus it comes with the wall charger. So you might live in a place with Chademo, but its only useful if it exists, and there is no high power charger. So the extra set would $450, but you actually need $0 extra - and it fits in the corner of the trunk. I've owned a tesla since 2012, and I don't have chademo. I've spent exactly $0 extra on the plugs you suggest. I have been from seattle to portland, eastern washington, Vancouver BC, Whistler, Banff. Just using regular j1772 and superchargers.
- KKKKkkkk1 11y agoI've been shopping for a used car in the Bay Area, and it looks like used electrics are even easier to buy (and harder to sell) than former rentals. That's not a good signal.
- Coincoin 11y agoLike any 1.0 product. The technology evolves so rapidly it loses 90% of its value in a few years. It reminds me my first digital camera, 2000$ and 3 years later you could get better for 500$.
- hliyan 11y agoI own a 2014 Nissan Leaf. Except for the battery and motor, almost every technology in the car is what you'd find in a regular vehicle. Any obsolescence can be dealt with by a battery upgrade (motors are a century old technology, I doubt that'll improve much in 5-10 years).
- vonklaus 11y agoahhh gotcha, so just the internal energy source and the part that locomotes it. Nothing too important then, eh? edit: yes, it was a joke. However, not for nothing, this is still a bizarre comment indicating that only the highy technical nuances in the car are nuances and that it should be trivial to swap them out. The battery is tied to the drive train each having a highly specialized and proprietary function. The power train uses a "centuries old technology" a synchronous electric motor. I am just jokingly pointing out that all cars use technology for motors grounded in history. Leaving aside considerable differences in size, weight, calibration, horespower or interconnection as well as subtle differences converting the imperial system into metric, sure, I guess you could argue motors are a commodity. As for the battery, the leaf's is great. Slated to hold 70-80% of its charge for around a decade. However, again, this was a limited production run-rate and can't really be decoupled from the drive-train without a significant degree of knoweldge and tooling making it highly unlikely someone would do this for any other reason than to learn a massive amount and have a really cool project. The battery is a 24kWh supercell constructed out of 192 subsells with a cooling stack and whatever battery chemistry they are using[0]. So yeah, I was having a playful joke here. I don't think anyone was arguing that EVs are overtly complicated due to the new radio & blue tooth technology they have to interface with the stereosystem...it's all about the powertrain/motor & energy source interface. jeez... [0] Googled it, fairly standard: lithium ion manganese oxide batteries, like the kind grandma used to bake.
- ktRolster 11y agoAccording to the article, we are now held back by expensive, non-crappy batteries. But the price is dropping, and eventually will be affordable.
- vonklaus 11y agoobviously Tesla is the front runner for spearheading the insudtry by virtually every metric & subsector (except maybe price). Look, I love Tesla and have been bullish on the company for a pretty long time, so I am biased, but why can't other car companies have quality cars and aesthetics. * Fisker Karma: The car looked super sleek, was super sexy and from an engineering standpoint it was a heap of shit. * Chevy Volt: Was an ICE car that had the worst of both worlds. Not particularly attractive. * Rimac Concept One: Ok this car was fucking brilliant but it was like $1M USD. * Prius: Pretty decent as far as hybrids go. Aesthetics are lacking what many might consider: the ability to not look like a cross between a golf cart and a mobility scooter. * Chevey Bolt: Seems to have pretty amazing specs. Aesthetics are sub-par for sure. Yes, Tesla's thing was making a compelling electric car, however other manufacturers seem to be doing alright in actually making the car. They just need to bend the metal in a way that doesn't look fucking horrible and Tesla will have a bit harder of a time of it. Edit: Here is a quick album I made. Nearly every car looks the same: http://imgur.com/a/HEsyf http://imgur.com/a/HEsyf edit 2: Here[t] you can see Tesla's offerings. The roadster is omitted. However, of the 4 cars, they made: roadster and the models s,3,x,y* you would be hard pressed to confuse them for any of the cars in the above album. However, those in that album are very close to one another aesthetically. [t]http://st.motortrend.com/uploads/sites/5/2016/05/2017-Tesla-Model-3-2016-Tesla-Model-X-Tesla-Model-S-charging-stations.jpg http://st.motortrend.com/uploads/sites/5/2016/05/2017-Tesla-... * they haven't made y yet....
- jejones3141 11y agoAs time goes on, CAFE standards tighten, etc., aren't cars converging on whatever turns out to be the aerodynamically optimal shape?
- megablast 11y agoThey look like every other car to me, I have no idea what you are talking about.
- techbubble 11y agoOne more for the list -- I got a Mercedes B250e three months ago and have been quite happy with it. It has a Tesla drive train [0] and although the official range is 83 miles per charge, I consistently get around 105. Bonus -- the CarPlay integration is really well-done. [0] http://www.plugincars.com/mercedes-b-class-e-cell http://www.plugincars.com/mercedes-b-class-e-cell
- mtgx 11y ago> There is no Moore’s law for battery storage—the power of batteries doesn’t magically double every two years. > Put another away, the battery pack in the 2017 Volt will cost less than 10 percent more than the one in the 2012 Volt. But it will be more than four times more powerful. Intel wishes its chips still quadrupled in performance every 5 years. > We’re moving toward a world where more and more cars will either run primarily on gasoline but with an assist from powerful batteries or primarily on powerful batteries but with an assist from gasoline. He's saying that in article talking about how cheap batteries have become and how in a few years they'll be $100/KWh? Within 10 years all EVs will have 100-150 KWh batteries. That's 400-600 mile ranges. The only place where you'll see "hybrids" is some niches where batteries alone couldn't possibly make sense, but I have a hard time coming up with ideas for vehicles where batteries alone wouldn't be enough in 15 years and they're smaller than say a train or an airplane. Even buses should do just fine with a 200KWh battery for a 16-18h work-day. > Earlier this week, Bloomberg New Energy Finance released a report arguing that by 2040, 35 percent of annual vehicles sales will be electric. It will be at least twice as much by 2030. By 2025 few will want a car that isn't an EV, and the car makers will have no choice but to start competing in EVs as their primary cars.
- kalleboo 11y ago> But it will be more than four times more powerful It's also more than twice as heavy
- Freestyler_3 11y agoI just find it funny, that they think that moore's law means that chips magically improve, that it is not dependant on the hard work of people.
- intrasight 11y agoAnd if we go the Hydrogen route, then batteries definitely won't be what holds it back. But certainly other factors will.
- sunstone 11y agoInteresting article but the timelines seem way to conservative to me. For example if batteries continue to improve over the next four years as they have over the past four years, according to the article then in 2020 the batteries will weight 1500 lbs, travel 1142 miles on a charge and cost about $10k. (Or a 500 mile battery for $5k) And the cost of electricity will be, at today's rates, $1 per "e-gallon" Who wouldn't want that? Project this to 2040 and the numbers become just ridiculous but the article suggests just 35% market share by then. I don't think so. By 2025 the market will almost certainly be strongly in the favor of electrics.
- kfk 11y agoFuel engine are improving too and oil price doesn't seem to want to go down any time soon. I'd say we have an interesting 10 years ahead. Electric is probably going to win, but time estimates are very hard to do. Don't forget that replacing a car fleet is expensive and takes years. A modern car can easily last 15-20 years, so even if we started replacing fuel with electric today (which we are not), replacing the whole car fleet would require 15-20 years. I don't see the 35% so far fetched in 2025...
- gambiting 11y agoAnd don't forget that there are millions of people who have a car right now, but who wouldn't have a place to charge an electric car. People living in apartments, terraced houses, especially in the UK it's very common to see rows upon rows of houses, none of them with their own driveway.
- garrettheaver 11y agoI know what you're getting at but I don't think the above comparison is entirely fair. Those houses don't have petrol pumps outside them either
- gambiting 11y agoYes, but I go to a petrol station once a month, takes me 10 minutes to fill up and the whole tank lasts me for the whole month. With electric cars there are two ways out of this, either build enough electric charging points that you can charge while you are at work, or make every single car supercharger-compatible. I personally don't think the first option is likely, I don't see why my work(or any other) would have literally every single parking spot wired for charging(there's over 1000 parking spots at our office), and as for the second option, even 30 minute charging is excessive, it's fine o long journeys so you can go an have a coffee and stretch your legs, but if you want to quickly "fill up" after work 30 minutes is not acceptable. That's why I said that for majority of people charging at home is ideal - but a lot of people don't have private place to charge at home.
- calgoo 11y agoWhat about making the battery packs "hot swappable". You pull into the station, the current pack is unloaded and a new one is loaded. I It can also have interesting effects on the battery upgrade you need to do every X amount of years. The packs could be owned by the gas station chain, so you can stop at any of their establishments and get a new one refiled. These battery pack charging stations could then also be used as power offloading for local power generation.
- vertex-four 11y agoTesla designed that, built one, then dropped it last year as nobody was using it. It could be more useful in vehicles which don't charge as fast, perhaps?
- ZeKK14 11y agoThe french car maker Renault tried this : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renault_Fluence_Z.E https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renault_Fluence_Z.E. (<- the point is in the link) It didn't work.
- avar 10y agoJust escape the .: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renault_Fluence_Z%2EE%2E https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renault_Fluence_Z%2EE%2E
- Tempest1981 10y agoSounds like it wasn't profitable, at least in 2013: "The company's financial difficulties were caused by the high investment required to develop the charging and swapping infrastructure, about US$850 million in private capital, and a market penetration significantly lower than originally predicted..."
- dagw 11y agoThere have been many demos of hot swappable battery packs. However as long as every car maker has their own battery packs and swapping methods it means you'll need a half dozen different swapping stations at each location making the whole concept very financially inefficient.
- contingencies 10y agoThe reality here in second-tier Chinese cities is that most people already get around, if not always then at least often, by electric vehicle. They've either never had cars, have bought cars but have problems parking them or getting anywhere due to traffic (many cities were not designed for cars, and now have millions of them clogging every available space on and off the road network), or just jump on the back of black-market 'taxi' e-bikes to zip about. E-bikes already carry a large proportion of people in Chinese urban environments. There is no way that e-bikes, subways and buses combined are not the dominant people-movers in the country, today. While I did see some e-bikes in Japan, they were nowhere near as numerous. China is leading the way. Typical Chinese e-bike cost new is USD$500 or less. Battery replacement (good for 1 year or so) is currently about USD$150 or less. They do get stolen a lot, unfortunately.
- jeromeflipo 10y agoI went last month for a road trip in Cuba, where most of the bikes seem to be AVA1000. This electric scooter is everywhere: http://cubanclassics.blogspot.fr/2015/02/2014-unison-international-ava-1000.html http://cubanclassics.blogspot.fr/2015/02/2014-unison-interna.... It was quite an shock for me to go back to Paris and realize how much my neighborhood is polluted by toxic fumes and deafening engine back-fire.
- devy 10y agoTrue statement. Having been visiting China annually for the past 10 years and seeing the transportation transition from mopeds to E-bikes first hand, I can attest to that. And the price has really been going down significantly because of the mass production and economy of scale (exports are a major contribution). Typically e-bikes with traditional car batteries are starting at around 2000 RMB. Some newer ones with Li-ion batteries are priced slightly higher. However, e-bikes are seeing a decline and/or full ban in top-tier Chinese cities due to new traffic regulations and new road design. It is still the predominant transportation tool in 2nd-tier and small cities where public transportation is scarce and downtown areas are smaller.
- contingencies 10y ago