32 ms·
How Technology Hijacks People’s Minds
- wslh 11y agoI was really interested in the article until I read: "I spent the last three years as Google’s Design Ethicist...". In the article he is focusing at the application level but the issue is at the form factor level. One simple example: if you give to a child a Simon game app based on the original Simon game [1] he/she will probably end up switching to YouTube and watching stupid videos but if you give him/her the "limited" form factor version of the game the child will have more fun. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon_(game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon_(game)
- nerdponx 11y agoLimited how?
- Jtsummers 11y agoI had to reread the OP a couple times but I finally got it. Give a child a smartphone with Simon, even opened to the app, and they'll wander off to YouTube or something else. Give a child the game Simon which only functions as the game, and they'll be enthralled.
- wslh 11y agoLimited because your mobile phone is a generic computer while Simon is a specific game.
- gukov 11y agoSimon the app will have to compete with other installed apps for attention. Simon the physical game, once in hands, is not as easily replaceable.
- whatsreal 11y agoI think that's another article. I would be interested in seeing someone think through different form factors for mobile computing that could go hand in hand with the application level ideas presented here.
- have_faith 11y agoTechnology doesn't hijack our minds, people do. It's an age old practice of blaming the tools. The logical next step might be to ask well then how do we fix people? (aka, society). Maximum freedom in society means maximum freedom to be manipulated by others. Perhaps ironically, the closer we get to solving world hunger and eradicating diseases and so on the closer we become to overpopulation and overcrowding our little planet that once seemed so large. Our ineptitude at cooperating with each other and our ability to manipulate each other so easily is probably the only thing stopping highly accelerated human progress, and thus our own demise. Absurdism looks more appealing every day.
- emodendroket 11y agoDid you read the article? The whole point is that there is a design intended to encourage "people" to act in ways they didn't really intend.
- have_faith 11y agoI read the article. The first line of my reply was in response to the title, the rest was in response to the rest of the article. Did you read my post?
- frogpelt 11y agoI have an overarching theory about people: their solutions create problems. e.g., According to some, Norman Borlaug saved a billion lives by developing semi-dwarf wheat. But according to some, semi-dwarf wheat is killing our guts and making us generally unhealthy.
- Jtsummers 11y agoKind of interesting idea about how our tools (generic) present us with limited menus, and effectively restrict our options. Facebook has expanded (barely) the options for basic responses to posts (no longer just like, but also a handful of emoticons to express laughter, anger, sadness, etc.). Not as full an option as when using the comment box, but for quick responses it allows for greater expressiveness. At least people don't have to "like" the tragic news of their friend's family deaths anymore. But then look at Allo, announced from Google yesterday, with its @google bot that will help people decide how to make basic, trivial responses to pictures posted to threads. (I'll try to find the link later, but the demo was with a graduation photo, and a few suggested responses like "You look great!" "Congratulations, so happy for you" or something similar). By pushing the job of coming up with options to tools, like the choice of restaurants and bars to Yelp, we narrow our worlds. We limit our expressiveness and creativity. I don't know that I have a point, just some thoughts.
- notduncansmith 11y agoGeorge Orwell felt similarly. https://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/intrel/orwell46.htm https://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/intrel/orwell46.htm
- Jtsummers 11y agoReally good essay, thanks for reminding me of that one. I believe it's been posted to HN before (I read it from a link here), but it may have been another comment suggesting it. But if thought corrupts language, language can also corrupt thought. (about 3/4 down)
- notduncansmith 11y agoI saw it here first as well. It's made a number of appearances: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=https:%2F%2Fwww.mtholyoke.edu%2Facad%2Fintrel%2Forwell46.htm&sort=byPopularity&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=https:%2F%2Fwww.mtholyoke.edu%...
- tacos 11y agoNovelty, not technology. The same cognitive behavior is exploited on restaurant menus.
- lilcarlyung 11y agoSooo... These are the things that I need to do to build a successful app?
- quadrangle 11y agoIf by "successful" you mean unethical, manipulative, and popular, yes. I happen to define success as providing actual positive value to the world because those are my aims. If your goal is to be an asshole but not get recognized as the source of the assholery, then you now know how to succeed at doing that.
- joslin01 11y agoYes, but if you don't align well-enough with a genuine human desire/need, your brand will slowly but surely rot away. See Buzzfeed.
- AlexandrB 11y agoSome of the design anti-patterns he's describing smell a lot like the broken window fallacy [1]. Sure, apps can get big on getting users addicted and "engaged", but there's no actual economic benefit being produced by such design - just tons of opportunity cost to users. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
- bognition 11y agoI'm not sure I follow why the fallacy applies. But for lots of smartphone apps there is an economic benefit. Making your app mildly addictive increases your weekly active users as well as the amount of time they spend in the app. These are two gold star metrics used by lots of VCs.
- AngrySkillzz 11y agoHe is implying there is no economic benefit to the users, not for the app in general but for engaging with particular bits of offensive design. If a user actually sat down and consciously decided whether or not to take a particular action, they likely would have gone the other way. See autoplaying videos. You probably didn't want to watch that next video, but if Google/Netflix gets their way you'll do it anyway for any number of psychological reasons. But that next video was not something you wanted, potentially it's value to you is zero or negative because of opportunity cost. That won't stop you from watching it though, if they can manipulate you and distract you from making that decision consciously.
- knowaveragejoe 11y agoThat's just the basic, innate value of increased activity time, too; not to mention other things like the more time people spend in the app the more likely they are to generate some other form of economic activity.
- bowlich 11y agoThe broken window fallacy isn't concerned with the local economic benefit for the app developer but the total economic benefit of society. A user who is addicted to an app may be using that app far past the actual utility they are deriving from it -- the app developer is encouraging them to mismanage their opportunity costs and in aggregate creates negative productivity across the total body of all users. It might be good for the VCs, but is it good for society?
- fsiefken 11y agoSnow Crash
- Dowwie 11y agoL. Bob Rife is behind all of it.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoWhen people are given a menu of choices, they rarely ask: “what’s not on the menu?” “why am I being given these options and not others?” “do I know the menu provider’s goals?” “is this menu empowering for my original need, or are the choices actually a distraction?” (e.g. an overwhelmingly array of toothpastes) It's so much more about politics (elections of all levels) rather than about technology!
- Aissen 11y agoIt's actually more about philosophy: free-will and the illusion of choice.
- imgabe 11y agoThe bit about choices reminds about the soda cup debacle from when Bloomberg proposed limiting the size of soda containers that some venues could sell. Everyone griped about how it limited their "freedom of choice", but nobody asked about why those particular sizes were the choices available in the first place. 7-11 and others decided that they could add a $0.05 more soda and charge $0.25 more and make more money. People would buy it because look, you get 50% more for only a quarter! Meanwhile the choice of buying less was never presented as an option.
- Jtsummers 11y agoAnd nevermind that most places have free refills on drinks anyways. So the total quantity of soda you consume isn't restricted unless it's take-away.
- aethos 11y agoThat's true, but I would assert that if you gave two people a small cup and big cup, the one with the larger would still drink more, even with free refills. More refills needed for the same amount if soda, more distance to walk, more time, etc.
- pessimizer 11y ago> Meanwhile the choice of buying less was never presented as an option. What do you mean here? There were always multiple sizes of soda. Bloomberg was the one who was introducing the restriction, requiring someone who wanted more than a particular size to buy it in two separate cups. I must be parsing this incorrectly.
- Nav_Panel 11y agoIn NYC, most soda drinkers are stopping by their corner bodega/deli and buying a bottle, then walking/taking the subway somewhere. I feel like in this particular case, the goal was to force soda manufacturers to sell 16oz bottles rather than 20oz bottles, thus reducing the amount most people consume in a single purchase. EDIT: I'm wrong, a reply below clarified the intent and also that bottles were exempt. Back when I drank soda regularly, I often felt like 20oz was a little bit too much. A 12oz can felt about right, but in NYC it's a lot less convenient because you must finish it immediately upon opening.
- AngrySkillzz 11y agoThis is what everyone means when they say "the medium is the message."
- danr4 11y agoI enjoyed the article. The most important takeaway for me was " now companies have a responsibility to reduce these effects by converting intermittent variable rewards into less addictive, more predictable ones with better design" I think most of the techniques listed actually cause pain for users, the same way addictions do. I think a lot of people are aware at some level that they are giving up to temptation and it makes them feel worse about themselves. On the contrary, when an app makes a prediction and nails it, I tend to appreciate it much more, and feel it helped me rather than lured me. My only gripe with predictability is it usually entails giving up a big portion of my privacy. In my idealist mind somewhere in the future, personal privacy will be a default state of mind for service providers. Total self privacy combined with life analytics (Lifelytics?) which empower streamlining ones routine is a dream I hope I witness come true.
- majewsky 11y agoExactly. I have wondered for a while why I find predictive AI services frightening and even disgusting. I realized that it is through apparent unpredictability of my actions that I perceive my own free will (or at least the illusion of it, depending on one's philosophy). If a computer can acurately predict my actions, it feels like my free will is taken away from me. And free will is one of the few things that truly sets us apart from mere automatons. (At least IMHO.)
- anchpop 11y agoIf your free will can be taken away by a machine predicting what you'll be interested in, you never really had it in the first place
- bikamonki 11y agoDoes anyone else feel the slot machine effect here on HN is the karma displayed on the top-right? After a submission or comment, is that number the first thing you check when you come back to the site?
- 6stringmerc 11y agoOften, yep. Sometimes watching it go down is quite a trip too. It's something an article I came across used as a conclusion while looking into how commenting communities can become friendly, turn into cliques, and then into "Join the Consensus or Die" cesspools: >Numerous comment sections and message boards and forums probably have ups and downs between Community, Clique, and Cesspool outside of this example — I know I’ve seen it on Ars Technica as well. It looks to me like a general extension of human social habits, like an evolutionary necessity where feeling part of a group is comforting. Experience makes me believe getting upvote currency is a pathway to the pleasure center of the brain. https://medium.com/@LongTimeLurker1stTimePoster/the-av-club-comment-section-community-clique-or-cesspool-f9c2e3295786#.ohili7t1w https://medium.com/@LongTimeLurker1stTimePoster/the-av-club-...
- bikamonki 11y agoYes, the "unlike-button" is the means to police the crowd and just have everyone behave on a consensual manner. Interesting enough, it only works on anonymous crowds b/c on social networks where you actually know the person, a downvote can actually have real-live consequences.
- philovivero 11y agoReddit almost stumbled upon the golden formula. They have a feature that shows a comment is "controversial" in that it's being up- and down-voted a lot. Those comments should be featured top and center.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoOnly looking for a change - which means somebody may have replied, and I'll want to be polite and check that out. I don't remember anything but the last 2 digits short-term.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tsunamifury 11y agoIt's called "railroading" and it's been around forever. The only new trick is to add more options that still railroad you in the same general direction. The problem is human minds are smarter than you think and they tend to disengage when they sense this and they strongly want to get off the rails. The user does this by quitting and/or deleting the service. Over time you realize it's best to give the user all their options and they are more likely to stay using your product.
- dredmorbius 11y agoI've certainly been railroaded out of specific retailers, away from specific products, and off of specific Internet / tech sites or concepts on account of this behavior. I draw attention to the negatives and expressly flag, block, or otherwise mark the antipattern. HN's increasing practice to deprecate anti-ad-blocking, clickbait, and the like is a positive counter-signal.
- lars 11y agoWow, I'm glad this was posted. I think the way we use technology today will be looked back on the same way we look back at naive cigarette smoking in the 1950s. Modern app design isn't about creating things that are good for the user, but about creating want in the user. This is a problem. For example, there are several studies showing that using Facebook in general makes people less happy. User happiness just happens to not be be necessary for Facebook to be a successful business. Go to a developer conference by one of the big tech companies, and speakers generally aren't talking about doing good things for the user. They'll use euphemisms like "increasing engagement". There's concepts like "permission priming", psychological tricks to get the user to do what you want. There's books written about how to maximize app addictiveness. It's stuff that mildly screws over the user, and it guides the product designs that affect the lives of billions of people. It's not good.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI think the more apt metaphor is lead in Roman pipes. They knew lead exposure made you crazy but they still used it in their pipes, on their plates - and it drove them mad. After the planet has warmed beyond a point of no return, after antibiotic resistant bacteria make routine surgery a life-or-death decision, after we have squandered away our resources and used what little we had left to wage futile wars, we will find ourselves looking back at these Bernaysian psychological tricks of mass consumerism...and I wonder if we will use the same excuse then as we do today: "But it was good for GDP!"
- reasonattlm 11y agoThe lead hypothesis for Roman decline is disputed. http://www.rsc.org/chemistryworld/2014/04/lead-pipes-polluted-roman-drinking-water http://www.rsc.org/chemistryworld/2014/04/lead-pipes-pollute... The demise of antibiotics is much overwrought. It won't happen, since researchers have basically solved the problem of cost-effectively finding an unlimited supply of new ones. https://www.edge.org/response-detail/26701 https://www.edge.org/response-detail/26701 In general people like seeing doom everywhere. To the extent this motivates some of them to do something about it, this is probably good. But it is very irritating when the doomsayers don't adjust their doomsaying based upon current scientific work.
- vicbrooker 11y agoI can't see a way for this style of design to be feasible that doesn't rely on a subscription-based business model. As long as users allow free + advertising generally be the way to for build a dominant tech company then I would assume anyone that tries to compete by not optimising for advertising (eg. reducing friction for users) will lose. Which is a damn shame. Based on my limited knowledge of the history of news media, theres a cycle between free + advertising and paid + high quality. Intuitively it should apply to other verticals too, and I hope that, in reality, it does.
- majewsky 11y agoFor many kinds of services it can work in parallel. For example, there are ad-supported mail providers like Google, while I consciously chose a subscription-based mail provider (posteo.de) whom I trust to act in my best interest. The only thing where this would not work so well is social networks, due to the network effect.
- forgottenpass 11y agoApparently google has an Ethicist. Ctrl-F: Ad Huh. Zero mentions of the thing that manipulates people by design. I guess I don't blame him, because even with a blind spot to ads it would seem Google still doesn't give two shits about his input. He explicitly calls out a problem YouTube feature, which he certainly would have voiced internally before externally. And he doesn't work at Google anymore. Google must want results from ethicists the way tobacco companies of old wanted results from in-house scientists.
- knowaveragejoe 11y agoHe mentions "thousands of other techniques" that exist, if you read the article. I'm sure advertising is a subset of those.
- eric_h 11y ago> Apparently google has an Ethicist. Well, had. From his bio snippet at the bottom: "Ex-Design Ethicist & Product Philosopher @ Google"
- nissimk 11y agoIt sounded to me like a euphemism for hanging out on the roof waiting for your non compete agreement term to run out.
- tremon 11y agoApparently google has an Ethicist. I'm not sure if I should rejoice that Google has one, or be worried that Google has just one.
- realitycheckxxx 11y agoFirst world problems. This post was really disgusting. "Oh, no, I have to look at pictures of bars...Manipulation!", "Oh, no, they are offering me to tag myself on a picture - systemic oppression and manipulation!" "Nooo... Fuck, now have to say 'You're welcome' " Fuck this author. A spoiled, rich cunt complaining that someone will auto-play a video after a countdown on his newest iPhone. ... In the meantime, slaves in Africa are digging material from the ground for $1 or less per day, so that he can get his iPhone. Slaves in Asia making his clothing or assembling his devices. Domestic, desperate part-time slaves delivering his food (Postmates) or driving him (Uber/Lyft).
- frank_jaeger 11y agoJust a small nitpick, all slaves make $0 per diem. It's sort of the main benefit of slavery.
- realitycheckxxx 11y agoNot true. Slaves are a cost to the owner, so they get food, accommodation, clothing, transportation paid for by the owner. In modern day, owner doesn't pay for you directly, but does it by giving you the money, so you get yourself all the things slaves used to get directly. You really are nitpicking and not seeing the bigger picture, because it's kinda uncomfortable.
- ifdefdebug 11y agoThe word "slave" is bound to the loss of freedom to walk away. You probably mean "exploitation". Don't use the word "slave" for that, because unfortunately there are still enough "real" slaves in the world who can't walk away. And don't bother to make the argument they can't walk away for economical reasons. It's still a whole different thing.
- zepto 11y agoI tend to agree with you about there being a distinction between unpaid and paid slavery, however I am not sure it's as useful or as clear a distinction as you imply. For example - one way in which slaves can be held captive is by having them work in a remote place where they don't have the resources to travel across the space between them and the rest of society - e.g. A camp in the desert, or jungle, or a plantation on an island. It is not clear why this kind of captivity is distinct from the captivity that arises when the barrier to cross is economic and social rather than physical. If people are being used as laborer a in a position where they cannot accumulate enough resources to leave, what difference does it make what kind of wall keeps them there?
- jonstokes 11y agoFirst thought: I gotta get off all of these apps. I always knew they were messing with me, and now I know how! Second thought: Our UX designer needs to read this ASAP... it's basically a "best practices" guide for making a social app that shows "traction".
- whatsreal 11y agoI had the same first thought, but I think it needs to be tempered somewhat. Some apps you can turn off notifications on. For example, Gmail on my phone I have turned off notifications for my work account, but not my personal account. I've also filtered what comes into my "Primary" inbox heavily so I only see emails that have some legitimate urgency on the phone. Everything else disappears into tabs and labels that I check when I want to. If Gmail didn't make that set of options available to me I would delete it off my phone. I have yet to receive such an important email that it would have had horrendous results to not know or reply immediately. I keep the limited set of emails I do see simply because I enjoy the convenience and politeness of being able to reply to my parents, wife, and friends from my phone.
- tlb 11y agoHow can one separate the inherent addictiveness of social approval (which we evolved to cope with) from the added addictiveness due to slot-machine rewards? (Discrete measures of approval, like a count of Likes, add their own variance in addition to the inherent variability of how much people liked something. That discretization is a property of the digital system, and adds the variance of a binomial distribution.) So when you say something IRL, you can gauge a lot of fine gradations of approval in the way people react. But online, where you get a small count of upvotes, the quantization adds variance and makes it more addictive. The added variance is most significant at small sample sizes. People whose submissions get hundreds of votes might find the process less addictive than people whose submissions get a handful of votes. Would HN be less addictive if the upvote process was more analog, somehow? Say, by adding up the duration people held down the mouse button for?
- petra 11y agoBtw, if we're talking about variance, reddit adds variance on top of the real comment scores, and they say it's to "fight spam". Maybe the real reason is addictiveness.
- knowaveragejoe 11y agoOne nitpick: maybe it's just the grocery stores near me, but the Pharmacies are almost always located near the front right by where you walk in. Milk is often in the back however.
- jff 11y agoMine has the pharmacy just inside the doors and a cooler right next to the checkout counters filled with milk. You do, however, have to walk past a big cooler full of delicious cheese and fresh sushi pretty much as soon as you enter the door :)
- kefka 11y agoMilk in the back or side makes sense though. The milk and dairy area is usually front-facing doors from the huge walk-in refrigerator. It wouldn't be smart to put a huge walk-in fridge in the center or front of the store, given the recurring shipments from cold storage trucks to fridge. ... However locally, our Kroger(s) has a small case that holds 15 gallons of milk, and a shelf of common bread up front and center.
- antognini 11y agoThere was an interesting episode on Planet Money a little while back about why milk is in the back of a supermarket. They had two people give very different explanations: Russ Roberts (an economist) argued that it was just simpler to maintain the cold chain with milk (and meat) in the back of the store since that's where trucks unload, and Michael Pollan (a food writer) argued that it was a behavioral economics trick to make people walk through the whole store. That said, I've also noticed that in many larger store they have a small case of frequently bought perishables at the front of the store. http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/07/23/334076398/episode-555-why-is-the-milk-in-the-back-of-the-store http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/07/23/334076398/episo...
- tunap 11y agoFormer merchandiser here. Staples are always furthest from entrance and then separated(ie: bread one back corner, milk opposite) to make most people walk the entire store to get what they need. And that 'convenience' case in the front... take a look at the expiration dates on the products in said case, that product needs to be sold faster than the stock in the back. Edit: PS: That economist, it's his job to rationalize the action monetarily. I/we/most people realize, if returns could be increeased, hamburger would be in a cooler next to the checkout.
- xufi 11y agoIt saddens me whenever I go out wit my friends and I try to have a conversation, that everyone is glued to their phones and can't have face-face conversation.
- jacquesm 11y agoFind different friends. Not everybody is like that.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoExactly. This is one of those things many people assume and it causes them problems. The assumption that people these days always stare into their phones. Some people do that, some do it a lot less, some barely, and some never. Reality offers more choice. Maybe OP should write a post on intersection of common assumptions with marketing tricks. There were a few embedded in here. Our assumptions get us just as often, though.
- ljk 11y agoEven sadder is when you see this happen to families, with the kids' eyes glued to the phone screen instead of interacting with their families
- xufi 11y agoYep. The typical American family dinner is the Digital Dinner if you can call it that
- majewsky 11y agoAre cellphone signal jammers available for purchase by common people?
- Kinnard 11y agoThe menu options metaphor applies so well to government. Especially given our current predicament.
- Mendenhall 11y agoThere are companies that have whole teams of "addiction specialists" that some video game companies hire to give talks to their producers. I know this from personal experience, they are literally trying to make you addicted and have that goal in mind.
- firebones 11y agoName names. Or at least LinkedIn titles!
- amelius 11y ago> That’s why I spent the last three years as Google’s Design Ethicist caring about how to design things in a way that defends a billion people’s minds from getting hijacked. Every time I see the doodle, I have the feeling I'm being hijacked. After playing with the doodle I often forget what I came to Google for. Just saying.
- cdnsteve 11y agoA brilliant article.
- lisper 11y agoThis is not just a problem at the consumer level. My entire career I have been told that I couldn't do X because it wasn't "industry standard" or "best practice" or some other code word for "not on the menu."
- stinkytaco 11y agoAs a manager it's an interesting balancing act. There are reasons things are done the way they are done and sometimes they are "because we've always done it that way" but more often it's because we've done it enough to understand something someone new to the company or industry doesn't. It's hard to know where to let go and where to draw the line. I try to provide an environment where new people can 1. Try an idea and watch them fall on their face because they didn't understand best practices. 2. Then try to encourage understanding of those best practices and how they can be improved and change slowly to minimize impact or unexpected consequences.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lisper 11y agoI applaud your willingness to let people try new things, but the way you describe it seems to assume that all new ideas are bound to fail. They aren't. Different is not necessarily better, but better is necessarily different.
- stinkytaco 11y agoMy point is that most new ideas do fail. People coming in don't realize that and it creates quite a bit of resentment. But people learn from mistakes and giving them the opportunity to fail is a good thing. After that they can take the time to learn why best practices are best practices. From that understanding we can talk new ideas. I've had so many employees come in convinced their idea was the best idea and then be frustrated and resentful that we wouldn't immediately start using it reciting the mantra that we do it "because it was always done that way".
- tdaltonc 11y ago> We need our smartphones, notifications screens and web browsers to be exoskeletons for our minds and interpersonal relationships that put our values, not our impulses, first. People’s time is valuable. And we should protect it with the same rigor as privacy and other digital rights. I think that the only way we can do this is for out technology to make our values impulsive.
- dTal 11y agoI don't know about the only way, but this is a stunningly thought-provoking comment.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoThe challenge is that there is no one set of "values" that we can agree on as a people.
- tdaltonc 11y agoThat's not such a big problem. I think we can get good an inferring values from behavior and using values in marketing. Then if you download an app that has positioned itself with certain values, the designer can reasonably assume that you hold those values.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoDisagree. People are terrible at aligning behaviors with stated "values." Economists look at this dissonance as "revealed preferences." While it may be the best thing we have to describe behavior, it's not well aligned with self-image - which is really what stated preferences aka "values" are. As a result, designing systems around revealed preferences might be advantageous in the short term - it conflicts with people's long term self concept. This ends up being a normative economics (< a rare thing any more) and philosophy question. Some people in the AI safety community have explored this idea of consolidating values, as the seed goals for artificial general intelligence - but it proved to be impossible.
- danvoell 11y agoWould it be possible to build an app interface which interacts with these apps yet works on behalf of the user? I might be willing to pay for something like this.
- tmaly 11y agoGreat post, the whole Yelp part really spoke to me as I have been working on my own side project to help me find better food dishes. I am trying to wrap my mind around this slot machine concept as I really do not want people using my project like this. Any suggestions on UI would be greatly welcome.
- kreutz 11y agoThis is not specific to technology and can essentially be traced back to capitalism for every industry. Businesses have nothing to gain by making product decisions around "will this help the customers well being". If it does not help them sell more, do more, make more it does not matter. All consumer facing companies apps, games, food, travel they are all gamified to grow the business regardless of whether there is a government agency to influence them. I'm all for making product and business decisions around these ideas but these psychological tricks have been applied to consumers for decades long before the Internet.
- excalibur 11y agoHe had me until the end. "People’s time is valuable." True "And we should protect it with the same rigor as privacy and other digital rights." LOLOLOLOL
- marxidad 11y agoAre you laughing because privacy and other digital rights aren't currently protected as rigorously as they should be?
- excalibur 11y agoThe notion that they're currently protected at all is a joke.
- majewsky 11y agoThere are a lot of people out there protecting digital rights and privacy right now. "Protecting" something is an entirely different thing as it being "protected" already.
- xg15 11y agoDepends who he means with "we". Being a Google Design Ethicist, you'd expect he means Google - which isn't exactly well-known for protecting privacy.
- astazangasta 11y agoIt's not "technology" that is hijacking people's minds, it's specific companies who are doing it. You don't blame the magician's hat for fooling you. The problem, as usual, is that technology is slave to the boring, insipid demands of capital to get us to click on ads and purchase more snow-pants.
- frogpelt 11y agotimewellspent.io contains a perfect example of indirectly hijacking our agency: the video play button. That little triangle has almost become impossible to resist. My two-year-old can spy it from across the room and he runs over and begs me to click it. What if we stopped using icons that have programmed our brains?
- ljk 11y agoisn't it better to use a universal icon for simple actions like this? e.g. pointing to wrist for the time, floppy disk icon for saving a file, etc
- frogpelt 11y agoI agree. It's better for design that compels certain actions. But its worse for helping users control their impulses. I personally feel the users should bear the overwhelming majority of responsibility for controlling their own impulses. But the author's own website contains design objects that encourage certain impulsive behaviors and I was pointing that out.
- tdaltonc 11y agoIf you're interested in learning more about these power and how to use them for good, consider joining us: https://www.reddit.com/r/behaviordesign https://www.reddit.com/r/behaviordesign https://www.reddit.com/r/habitdesign https://www.reddit.com/r/habitdesign
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ljk 11y agoVery eye-opening read. few random thoughts: > Hijack #7: Instant Interruption vs. “Respectful” Delivery... By contrast, Apple more respectfully lets userse toggle "Read Receipts" on or off Unfortunately iPhone has a new feature to reply to messages immediately even in the lock screen, looks like everyone is guilty of this > “now that you know I’ve seen the message, I feel even more obligated to respond.” always tried to purposefully not respond right away even when it said I read it already, but it does feel weird/rude
- floatboth 11y agoReplying from the lock screen is good though?? You reply from the lock screen, so you don't unlock the phone, so you don't start doing other things than replying?
- ljk 11y agooh yeah that feature is definitely very useful it just reminded me of what the author mentioned about replying
- jamesmiller5 11y agoSimilarly resonates with to another great article "The Slow Web" - http://jackcheng.com/the-slow-web http://jackcheng.com/the-slow-web .
- marknutter 11y agoInteresting read, but is the author being serious when they suggest that the FDA should be setting standards for how software UX is designed? I can't even begin to imagine how much of an unmitigated disaster that would be.
- alerting 11y agoNo need to worry -- FDA people are probably addicted to those software as well, if not worse
- gentleteblor 11y agoI wonder what impact this knowledge would have on the public's perception of Silicon Valley (and the tech industry in general) if it got very popular. The current thinking seems to be something akin to: Oil & Gas Industries bad, Tobacco Industry bad, Fast Food Industry Bad, Big Pharma bad. Startups Good! Silicon Valley Good. Tech will fix everything. But it's the same old game.
- bobwaycott 11y agoI spend most of my internet time on HN. It makes me wish HN tracked this and, each time I load the page, prompted me with a "Do you really want to spend the next n minutes here?"
- sah2ed 11y agoWell there's something close: the "noprocrast" [1] option in your profile. [1] Explained here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=814695 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=814695
- bobwaycott 11y agoOh, duh. I always forget those are there. :)
- hughw 11y ago/me furiously redesigning our app to be a slot machine....
- henrik_w 11y agoI just finished reading "Deep Work" by Cal Newport - great book. The central theme of the book is that you need distraction-free focus to do your best work (especially relevant for programmers I think). Social media goes against this - constantly checking HN, Twitter or FB breaks this focus. He basically recommends to quit altogether. A good start is to try and go a full day with checking any social media - it's harder than it sounds.
- mazuhl 11y agoSame here and I've just started reading "Hooked" by Nir Eyal which is kind if a counter/companion to "Deep Work". Following Newport's logic I am looking at optimising engagmement (for a paid/freemium app/SaaS website) as "help people stay in their flow state, make the interactions smooth and non-demanding, then get out of the way". Part of the book seems suggests that having tools is fine as long as the tool doesn't too much extra baggage or make to process of using it too much about itself (drawing you away from the goal/original focus).
- nnd 11y agoNothing new here. If anyone is interested to learn about these mechanisms in death there is a great book "Hooked" by Nir Eval. The real problem here are the users. If they keep unconsciously falling for the same tricks over and over again, rather than taking a stand and rejecting manipulative products, there is no incentive for product makers to create product which are _not_ manipulative. You can compare it to eating junk food, rather than choosing healthy options.
- flurpitude 11y agoAs with addictive drugs, the real problem doesn't wholly lie on either side. You can't blame the users entirely for the fact that people choose to supply a harmful product for profit, but neither can you wholly blame the suppliers for being tempted to do so when users lap it up. Regardless of the blame question, it will improve when (if) both sides change their behaviour, or when either side changes unilaterally and forces a change from the other side.
- nnd 11y agoAddictive drugs is a good comparison. The supply stills exists because it's profitable and because of suppliers who don't have any moral problems with providing the supply in the first place, for the sake of profit. I remember I watched a documentary on Mexican cartels, and their excuse is simply because they don't know any better. In the case of technology, it seems a sacrifice has to be made, to refrain from using said manipulative strategies, and thus losing profit. I still don't quite understand your point about consumers. Assuming that you have free will, it's your own choice to either use those products or not. You can't blame companies manipulating your behavior if you opted in in the first place.
- hypertexthero 11y agoA book on a similar theme from before the internet is [Ways of Seeing][1] by John Berger. The typography, set in bold throughout, doesn't do the text any favors, but the writing and information is good. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ways_of_Seeing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ways_of_Seeing
- thaw13579 11y agoThe article does a good job of showing examples, but strangely, it doesn't connect this in any way with the vast related research in psychology and economics. This makes me skeptical of the claims of expertise...
- siglesias 11y agoAnybody else struck by the irony of the glaring "Don't miss Tristan Harris's next story" dialog at the bottom of the article? Note the verbiage exploiting Fear of Missing Something Important.
- hughw 11y agoIronic, yes, and sad.
- sbierwagen 11y agoA note of slight relevant interest: fastmail.com's native client doesn't actually have a manual refresh button. You only get a notification for a new mail if the server pushes one to you.
- xg15 11y agoA manual refresh button apparently doesn't help, because now you stumble from the "constant interruptions" trap into the "slot machine" trap...
- grok2 11y agoI think this is not necessarily right -- the existing technology limits peoples choice and directs them to behave in a certain way sometimes, but it's not like people don't know they are being manipulated or that they are being provided limited choices, but they live with it what's available if what's available is satisfactory enough. But if it doesn't really satisfy them, people do go out of their way to get what they want...mostly. Atleast that's what I see from a data-point of 1.
- Animats 11y agoHm. Maybe we need a system for mail and messaging which puts most items into a bin to be read later. Once every N hours, it shows you the "later" items. (One real headache is the demise of third-party messaging clients. You can't write a Twitter client any more, or a Facebook client, or a WhatsApp client, or a Slack client. This is a big problem, because the vendor clients work for the man, not for you. With email, you're still in control, but not with the proprietary systems.)
- gruez 11y agoI imagine that this could be done on android by batching notifications for display at specified intervals. Not sure about iOS (without jailbreak) though.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoThis is classic game theory. You lose as a company if you don't build in these addictive features. So everyone does it because as he made clear, attention is the currency of business currently. All of these companies, and new companies would have to agree not to build these behaviors in. The idea of an FDA or bill of rights for technology is great in the holistic macro sense, but I think unrealistic as it is not aligned with the interests of companies. It's the same with any externalities, be it pollution or labor exploitation - things that have clear nexus with bad outcomes but struggle to gain traction around limiting because of overwhelming business interests.
- tim333 11y agoI agree a FDA for tech addictiveness probably won't happen. Now a Chrome extension to block much of it similar to adblock. That would be doable.
- firebones 11y agoShame beats it. See up-thread. Once people start seeing mindless staring at phones as the public health equivalent of smoking, things will improve.
- tim333 11y agoAs someone who spends much of the day staring at screens (more macbook than phone) I'm not sure that's going to happen in a hurry. I guess it's hard to distinguish the mindless staring from learning something useful. I can't even figure which category my own time reading the latest Trump craziness falls into though probably more the mindless category. (see also http://www.theonion.com/blogpost/admit-it-you-people-want-see-how-far-goes-dont-you-50895 http://www.theonion.com/blogpost/admit-it-you-people-want-se...)
- devy 11y agoTristan Harris, the OP of this medium post, listed a table of comparisons between what's today's engaging/addictive/time sink product characteristics vs. time well spent products he advocates on his main project site[1]. Of all the 11 points, two of them has the most profound sociological impact or inertia: * Success Metrics: measure success by net positive contributions rather than interactions * Business Model: use non-engagement based advertising rather than engagement advertising. I fully applaud Tristan's vision and mission but skeptical of how quickly companies, VCs and society can adopt it. [1]: http://timewellspent.io/ http://timewellspent.io/
- 1_2__3 11y agoI'd say it's worse, because now that we don't pay for things (ad support ftw?) the service providers have a much stronger incentive to keep you on the site than they do to make you happy. They've slowly but surely developed methods that do exactly that, leaving us all wondering why we spend so much time on sites/in apps that we don't actually enjoy. This isn't going to change.
- HemanHeartYou 11y agoMusic is what's wrong with youth these days. Why back in my day, yadda yadda yadda.
- JoeDaDude 11y agoI could not help but notice the block at the end that asked one to "Read Tristan's next blog" with a button to Follow him.
- johnchristopher 11y agotldr; : don't use social networks on your smartphone or you're going to miss out on real life.
- tard 11y agohow come this article only got 2 points[1] when someone submitted it here a day ago, but this time it's at the top of everything? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11726766 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11726766
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoBecause life isn't fair.
- hackaflocka 11y agoNothing "the government" can't solve!!!
- blabla_blublu 11y agoMy 2 cents on this(opinion) and how I am struggling to cope with tech usage in my life. I noticed that I spend a disproportionately high volume of time "consuming" than "creating". Recently I have been making efforts to create more. writing, drawing, painting. Something, anything so that the brain can spend some time coming up with new things instead of just reading/passively participating. Technology has empowered a lot of us to create more, but it has also played a huge part in 'consumption', since it is so easy to swipe up and get the next article and the next and the next. Not to forget passive reading where I just skim through without actually paying any kind of attention to detail.
- shostack 11y agoYeah, consumption vs. creation is a great way to sum it up. By and large I've cut WAY back on my video game playing (like, from several hours a week down to maybe a half hour of mobile gaming in bed at night) and tried to replace it with "healthier" activities like learning guitar and gardening. Oddly enough, I don't feel like I have any more free time in my life. I'm wondering if I've filled the gap with more consumption via Reddit/HN/reading books enough to make up for the difference. And that's the rub, because a lot of the stuff I read online or in books isn't garbage. HN has some interesting topics, my Reddit feed is lots of interesting stuff for the most part now, and I'm reading a great book on investing. Ultimately though those are still consumptive activities.
- greggman 11y agoI had a mildly negative reaction to this article which seems different from most people's reactions here Yelp example: I get that yelp is limiting my options but what did I do before yelp? Pretty much I just went to the 4 or 5 places I already knew instead of seeing if there was something new nearby. I tried hundreds of new places because of recommendations from Google Maps or Yelp that I likely would not have tried otherwise. Certainly not before I had this thing in my pocket that let me research at the moment of desire instead of having the plan ahead Similarly I look for meetups and have been to way more activities that I would have gone to in the past. On the slot machine idea: Before smartphones and apps I'd flip through a magazines and hope there'd be something interesting. Before digital TV back when channel surfing tuned into each channel immediately instead of taking 3-5 seconds I'd flip through channels hoping to discover an interesting program. When I buy a book I'm gambling it's going to catch me. When I go to a new restaurant I'm gambling it's going to be delicious (it often isn't) I guess I don't really see the difference between that and many of the things listed on that list. I also do uninstall apps. I've un-followed 90% of my connections to keep it my feed actually relevant to me. Sure I do spend too much time on (in my own opinion) on the net for various things. hopefully I can keep it under control. It got more scary for me toward the end where he seemed to be calling for government regulation. A digital "bill of rights". An FDA for Tech. No doubt he's assuming he'll be on the committees to decide what's best for everyone else.
- iamcasen 11y agoI think his point about Yelp was more that THEY CONTROL all those new choices you explored. Yelp becomes the gate keeper that restaurants and bars must appease in order to show up in their list that you are looking at.
- phantarch 11y agoThere's definitely positive value in the services and apps that you mention, otherwise people wouldn't begin using them initially. I think the key difference between the services and living life with "Pre-Internet" substitutes is that all of the services have been designed and engineered to elicit a certain usage. When you use something that was designed, there's a certain set of axioms governing that thing. You've got to buy into someone else's interpretation of value. If you're aware that the other person's interpretation is different from your own, then you'll be much more likely to have the self-control needed to interpret its value for yourself. The danger is that most people don't do that and as a result fall prey to their own assumptions based on what they were told is valuable. The trickle of pre-internet information doesn't compare to the firehose we have today. There's not one single solution and I agree that a governance of these ethical ideals will be tricky no matter what form it takes.
- cynoclast 11y agoI loved the part about the "friction required to enact choices" bit. Like how it's outstandingly easy to get a bank account, and how as a part of the law regarding privacy, they're required to provide a method for you to opt out of them selling your data, which involves them sending you a paper privacy notice, and to opt out you have to send them a written letter (no form is provided), to an address you have to write out yourself, and at your own cost. That always infuriated me. It should be as easy as signing up.
- majewsky 11y agoI think Germany has some legislation (or a court decision) that requires that customers be able to void their contracts over the same communication channel where the contract was initially created.
- Dowwie 11y agoMuch of this content is associated with the field of Behavior Economics. For instance, in Hack #1, the author is speaking of what academia has called "Choice Architecture". For more about that, you can freely access multiple studies published by Thaler and Sunstein.
- krosaen 11y agoRelated: http://darkpatterns.org http://darkpatterns.org
- imacomputer2 11y agoEstimated rewarding time is 12 minutes? Who reads that fast!
- galfarragem 11y agoI found it funny when the author also uses manipulative tricks: - he finishes the article with two links (one direct and one indirect) for the same website; - he (or the software) underestimates the time needed to read the article.
- Pulce 11y agoLikes was 666 wen I went to the page... that hijacks me.
- thesrcmustflow 11y ago> One major reason why is the #1 psychological ingredient in slot machines: intermittent variable rewards. I first came across this concept in a Hello Internet podcast, and it's amazing how much you see it in just about everything on the internet once you've heard of it.
- tomc1985 11y agoPerhaps we are in need of a cultural shift that emphasizes "doing it right" instead of "making all the money"
- Lxr 11y ago> But grocery stores want to maximize how much people buy, so they put the pharmacy and the milk at the back of the store. Early competitors of Google thought that accurate search results only served to drive users away from their site and search was therefore an unimportant part of an overall "Internet company". It would be interesting to see a grocery chain with the philosophy of "find what you want really fast" rather than "make it really difficult to find what you want so you spend longer here" - it could be very successful by the same analogy.
- mck- 11y agoHow Hacker News Hijacks your day...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bcoughlan 11y ago> What if your email client gave you empowering choices of ways to respond, instead of “what message do you want to type back?” Communicating directly via writing or talking is the only thing here that is not driven by limited choices. It reminds me of the koan about the expressiveness of the command line compared to point and click: http://catb.org/esr/writings/unix-koans/gui-programmer.html http://catb.org/esr/writings/unix-koans/gui-programmer.html One evening, Master Foo and Nubi attended a gathering of programmers who had met to learn from each other. One of the programmers asked Nubi to what school he and his master belonged. Upon being told they were followers of the Great Way of Unix, the programmer grew scornful. “The command-line tools of Unix are crude and backward,” he scoffed. “Modern, properly designed operating systems do everything through a graphical user interface.” Master Foo said nothing, but pointed at the moon. A nearby dog began to bark at the master's hand. “I don't understand you!” said the programmer. Master Foo remained silent, and pointed at an image of the Buddha. Then he pointed at a window. “What are you trying to tell me?” asked the programmer. Master Foo pointed at the programmer's head. Then he pointed at a rock. “Why can't you make yourself clear?” demanded the programmer. Master Foo frowned thoughtfully, tapped the programmer twice on the nose, and dropped him in a nearby trashcan. As the programmer was attempting to extricate himself from the garbage, the dog wandered over and piddled on him. At that moment, the programmer achieved enlightenment.
- dspoka 11y agoI love how on one side there is an engineer at google talking about how addictive technology is and then on the same day someone else at google releases an api to make mobile phones be even more clever slot machines... https://developers.google.com/awareness/?ref=producthunt https://developers.google.com/awareness/?ref=producthunt
- ca98am79 11y ago> Imagine a digital “bill of rights” outlining design standards that forced the products used by billions of people to support empowering ways for them to navigate toward their goals. This scares me
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kercker 11y agoThe author apparently has his own agenda, after seeing the time well spent link all over the article.
- ommunist 11y agoThis is another perspective on what Nick Carr noticed in his brilliant "The Shallows", and it is invaluable. I am glad Google is not entirely evil.
- urahara 10y agoHere is Tristan's post "How Technology Hijacks People’s Minds" in Russian (translated): https://wob.su/blog/ekonomika-vnimaniya-vzlom-umov/ https://wob.su/blog/ekonomika-vnimaniya-vzlom-umov/
- RonileC 10y agoInspiring!