20 ms·
Nest Reminds Customers That Ownership Isn't What It Used to Be
- barney54 11y agoAs the owner of a nest thermometer, a couple nest cams, and a nest fire alarm I sure hope that nest reverses their policy on the Revolv hub. I have been pretty happy with my nest products so far, but this makes me seriously reconsider buying any more.
- losteric 11y agoI was considering upgrading to a nest smart home, but this has shown they don't care about customers. They have lost my trust and gained animosity... I won't give them a penny and I will discourage anyone from buying their products.
- smrtinsert 11y agoThe joy of free markets. Sometimes they work!
- darkclarity 11y agoJust stick with basic thermostats and controls. Using these over-engineered devices will be a nuisance if you decide to sell your property or temporarily hand over control to someone else. Never mind the problems with cloud based vendor lock-in.
- the_unknown 11y agoI "own" a Nest Protect alarm. I liked it and was planning on outfitting the rest of the house with them during renovations this summer. I will not be buying any more Nest products/services now. The risk is too high to have them in my home.
- shitlord 11y agoReplace them with Z-Wave or Zigbee products instead. There are a lot of hubs out there which don't require cloud connectivity or a monthly connection.
- andrewpe 11y agoI would stay away from anything Zigbee. It has become a complex mess
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoINSTEON does a solid job. Their protocol is proprietary, but the devices aren't cloud dependent. You can either use a cloud hub device, or just a serial adapter to a PC or third party controller. They have no ability to take away my Insteon thermostat's functionality, or mine data from it. Because all translation of it's communication protocol goes through my computer, and is interpreted by open source software.
- gmac 11y agoI got given one for Christmas. It appears to work as advertised. But it also slightly spooks me that it is an Internet-connected black box with a microphone, and the kind of thing that under the UK's proposed Investigatory Powers Bill the government could probably insist be hacked to spy on me. (The microphone is used as part of the self-test routine, to check the thing is sounding properly).
- hrrsn 11y agoWe bought a Dropcam, which worked great until they decided they no longer wanted our non-US credit card. Replaced with Ubiquiti UVC cameras. What a waste.
- beambot 11y agoWell... they just told you: You don't really own those devices. You're paying upfront for a lease that lasts until they decide to deprecate the service. Yay, IoT!
- drauh 11y agoNext up: cars!
- jellicle 11y ago"What do you mean my four-year-old car has been end-of-lifed?"
- logicallee 11y ago>"What do you mean my eighteen-month-old car has been end-of-lifed?" FTFY
- ehudla 11y ago- Where's my car?! - Discontinued. It drove itself back to us last night.
- rasz_pl 11y agoReminds me of a short scifi story I read in the ~1992, cant remember the title of the novel or the book it was published in :( Deep space mission is send to a distant solar system where signals of civilisation have been discovered. As they approach the planet all the signs, radio waves, artificial lights, etc progressively disappear. Meanwhile on the planet we are introduced to the civilization that solved all of the world problems by providing everyone with a job, all thanks to invention of a timed catalyst able to disintegrate any matter after coded period. Every item on the planet is programmed to turn into dust when expired. Clothes one year, car 3 years etc, perfect planned obsolescence on a global scale. Unfortunately there is an accident at one of the catalyst producing plants at the time deep space mission approaches. Giant spill creates chain reaction eating everything on its way. Narrator goes back to the space mission, now landing on a barren planet, with astronauts embarking and looking around confused at the sight of an empty world.
- caseysoftware 11y agoI think they'd have major legal issues to shutting off people's thermostats. Losing control over heat and cooling could be a major health and safety risk. That said, I wouldn't be surprised if nest cams were on the chopping block.. despite how many parents use them for monitoring infants.
- gwright 11y agoDo they really stop working without network connectivity? I just assumed that they would "fail-safe" into a local/manual mode, but am I mistaken?
- chippy 11y agoYou are reconsidering. And you admit that you are heavily personally invested in the brand. What will it take for you to not buy any of them any more? We like to protect our investments. These investments are in time, money, effort and psychological face. We would rather wait and see if our investment still is worth something after all we put into it. Brands, if we have invested in them sufficiently, are able to get away with much more than other companies because the consumers who have invested so much are unwilling to lose their investment.
- a3n 11y ago>customers who reasonably expected that the promised "lifetime" of updates would enable the hardware they paid for to actually work, That would be the functional lifetime of the device. "All these on this list are dead." Promise fulfilled.
- cmdrfred 11y agoI was going to buy a nest, but now I'll just rig myself something up with a Raspberry Pi. Lower cost and I know it will still work in a few years.
- jmaygarden 11y agoBe careful doing that. A smart thermostat isn't exactly trivial, and doing it wrong can be bad.
- Gratsby 11y ago> A smart thermostat isn't exactly trivial, and doing it wrong can be bad. That's sarcasm, right? I automated my HVAC in the '90s and even then there were a ton of roadmaps to follow by people who had done it before. It was an afternoon project using something similar to these: https://www.sparkfun.com/products/245 https://www.sparkfun.com/products/245
- click170 11y agoAs Nest demonstrated time and again. Their thermostats had a defect at one point (not sure if it was ever actually fixed) where if your heating or cooling system caused a surge in your wiring, your nest would get stuck with both heating and cooling at full blast, or something equally silly. The Nest thermostat was certainly not designed to fail safely or sanely.
- hueving 11y agoif temperature > max(desired_range): activate_ac() deactivate_heat() elif temperature < min(desired_range): deactivate_ac() activate_heat() else: deactivate_heat() deactivate_ac()
- ryandrake 11y agoCode review #1: You're going to want to add debounce logic, or you're going to be erratically turning on and off your heat and ac when the temperature is exactly equal to the ends of desired_range.
- 13of40 11y agoI didn't catch it in the article, but I assume they're turning them off because they have a back end service that's going to do nothing but cost them money if they continue to run it. Does anyone know if that's the case?
- tobyjsullivan 11y agoThis whole saga serves less as a warning to customers and more as a warning to businesses. Be careful about acquiring other companies - liabilities come in many forms. It may have seemed like a great deal when Nest bought Revolv - after all, we know acquihires are usually based on the fact that the acquired company was going under anyways. Pay a minimal amount for a failing company and get some great engineers. But it sounds like they didn't anticipate the brand problem they would ultimately face for ending support for a product that was inevitably going to disappear in either case. Something early messaging (say, at the time of the acquisition) could have helped soften. Nest didn't build this product - Revolv did. And they banked their company on its success and lost. Nest might be alive and healthy but it doesn't seem right to say they somehow acted dishonestly just because they picked up the pieces of a failed company but didn't want to prop up a product which nobody wanted.
- studentrob 11y ago> it doesn't seem right to say they somehow acted dishonestly just because they picked up the pieces of a failed company but didn't want to prop up a product which nobody wanted. Agree with all of your comment except except this part. Had Nest acquired the company after Revolv independently announced it would discontinue its product, then customers wouldn't have reason to be unhappy with Nest. M&A is risky and research is important. This case seems like a catch 22 for Nest. Acquire the assets early and inherit the legacy product burden. Don't do that, and risk losing access to the same assets. I'm sure they did their research. What is not known at this point is the cost of keeping up the systems that enable Revolv's product. Were they more open about that, I might be more sympathetic. As it is I'm not sure what could be done to right this other than give Revolv customers a refund.
- abraae 11y agoThis is the key point indeed. Some of us probably have a mental image of a large ec2 instance plugged into an Oracle RDS instance, nicely monitored, disaster recovery plan tested and ready, chugging away just fine. Maybe a few $10Ks per year to keep it running. Why would they piss their customers off just to save a few thousand bucks? But in reality, maybe the back end is a teetering pile of doggy do, running on old bare metal machines in a couple of racks, backups not trusted 100%, lots of humans involved in keeping it running and answering customer support inquiries - so more like many $100Ks per year (indeed some companies would be able to spend $1Ms). In this case it would be crazy to try and keep it running, since there is no new business coming from it. Likely the truth is somewhere in between. Some transparency here from Nest would be a PR win.
- gerbilly 11y ago> Lifetime support Silly consumer, not _your_ lifetime, the lifetime of the product. BTW, we just declared your 300$ gadget end of life. kthxbai...
- astebbin 11y agoFrom The Verge, "Nest says it may offer 'compensation' to Revolv users for disabling smart home hub:" http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/5/11374358/nest-revolv-smart-home-hub-disable-user-compensation http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/5/11374358/nest-revolv-smart-...
- decwakeboarder 11y agoProbably would have been a good idea to sell the bridge before burning it.
- studentrob 11y agoNow we know they will give back something but are not sure how much. The Nest/Revolv situation is reminiscent of when Netflix raised prices in 2011 [1]. It was a great product, and despite being the industry leader, customers disappeared overnight. Then Netflix made the correction and recovered strong as ever. In that moment Netflix was touch and go and needed money. Fortunately for consumers, they survived. [1] http://www.cnet.com/news/netflixs-lost-year-the-inside-story-of-the-price-hike-train-wreck/ http://www.cnet.com/news/netflixs-lost-year-the-inside-story...
- chris11 11y agoNetflix just hiked their prices up 60%. That's definitely high. But Nest bricked hardware that customers have already paid for. I have less sympathy for Nest here.
- studentrob 11y agoI'm talking about the price hike years ago when Netflix was still building steam. These days Netflix is more widely used and they have more money in the bank. Nest today is still building steam and could be hurt by negative PR.
- throwaway_xx9 11y agostudentrob: > Netflix was still building steam. Netflix's stock price went down, but they already had a huge streaming business and were not distressingly low on cash. In fact, raising prices generated record revenue. So your comments don't make any sense to me. However, if you had said, "Hollywood could rape Netflix any time they wanted on licensing fees," then that is actually true and the reason Netflix is a sketchy investment, and why they are creating their own content.
- unclebucknasty 11y agoThe fact that software drives everything now means that we never quite own the product we initially purchased. I remember thinking this a year or two ago when Samsung dropped from my Smart TV an app for a streaming service that I used quite a bit. While this Nest situation is an extreme case, we're now always one update away from products being altered in ways that make them very different from what we originally purchased.
- sumoboy 11y agoRoku 4 remote has a dedicated Pandora button, that didn't last long. I'm sure a few TV's had Pandora as a feature.
- profmonocle 11y agoAt least many of these IoT devices still work if their Internet service goes away. An unsupported smart TV still works as a dumb display for a more modern streaming stick. An unsupported smart fridge still keeps food cold. my smart scale can still weigh me even if it can't upload the reading. I'm not sure if a Nest thermostat can work offline indefinitely, but I sure hope it can. The question is, what will most consumers do when they discover their smart device is no longer smart simply because it's "old"? Considering the lifespan of the dumb versions of these products, I'm guessing the owner's definition of "old" will differ from the manufacturer's. Not many consumers would consider a 15 year-old refrigerator to be old, but it's hard to believe Samsung will still be maintaining the software on their 2016 smart fridges in 2031. Will most people say "well, that was nice while it lasted" and keep using it as a dumb device, or will they be so used to the smart features that they'll go out and get the latest, supported model - deciding that a thermostat or a bathroom scale is now something that needs to be replaced regularly like a phone or a PC?
- unclebucknasty 11y ago>Considering the lifespan of the dumb versions of these products And what's ironic about that is that in theory the lifespan of the product should be longer, given that that it can theoretically be "enhanced" OTA vs in a pure hardware situation. But, of course, there's no financial incentive. We may start seeing more paid software upgrades for new features.
- awinter-py 11y agoIf you excavate any square yard of ocean you'll find a bunch of sharks' teeth in the sediment. They're like tree rings for ocean paleoclimatology. They're 'high tech' (in the sense that an apex predator uses them), effective and constantly being replaced. Now do the same thing with a landfill and you'll find generations of silicon doodads in the strata. My point: we shouldn't be too surprised when things are disposable. Sharks' teeth aren't useful after they fall out. Companies can't be supporting ten generations of gadgets.
- ralmidani 11y agoWhat makes Nest's actions deplorable is not just that they don't want to support and maintain the product; they are also deliberately destroying pieces of hardware purchased and owned by customers.
- awinter-py 11y agonest is doing the world a favor. we need to learn the lesson of closed hardware sooner rather than later.
- voltagex_ 11y agoThe only people talking about this are people who already know the risks.
- studentrob 11y agoI agree we need to learn the lesson, but am not convinced Nest's actions are overall beneficial. Learning a hard lesson isn't the only way to learn a lesson. We need more tech companies who can lead with positive messages about openness
- capote 11y agoDon't these pieces of hardware rely on their service being provided? Their service is what they want to shut down, after all; this can't have started from a desire to brick hardware devices.
- zik 11y agoSurely this is illegal? If a Nest tech turned up at your door and when let in to do "service" he took a hammer to the device destroying it, people would be suing left and right for property damage. Surely this is just the same?
- StephenConnell 11y agoAre they actually damaging the devices or are they just turning off the remote servers that the devices rely on?
- bobbles 11y agoWhat's the difference between damaging the device and making it no longer able to perform the function it was designed and sold as?
- awinter-py 11y agoPhysical destruction. The nest is affixed to a wall via quick-release bolts so that if it's mounted too high to reach, you can remote-eject it. Properly reprogrammed, the incendiary charge on the quick-release can act as an autodestruct. Beyond vaporizing the device, in some cases it's taking out a chunk of wall or the family pet.
- anexprogrammer 11y agoDoes it matter? The effect is the same, and it's a choice not that the company is insolvent so cannot continue.
- gherkin0 11y agoThe devices were sold with the implicit promise that the servers operated by the manufacturer would remain in service, so I don't think there's much of a real distinction between bricking a device by shutting down servers vs. hitting it with a hammer. That said, they probably tried to weasel themselves out of any obligation via the EULA.
- victorhooi 11y ago
- capote 11y agoI feel like this is all a bit dramatic. It's not too big a deal to deactivate something that isn't supported anymore. Can't security issues arise from unsupported hardware/software after all? There must be some reason. Also, nobody's walking into anyone's house... these comparisons are so over the top. Even if it is unfair (and I see the point, it is somewhat irritating) can we stop with the rampant and out of control use of slippery slope arguments? I feel like that's all I read anymore—slippery slopes happening everywhere with everything. Also, why has nobody asked or investigated as to why they want to brick hardware intentionally? Let's figure that out before we go crazy about this.
- davorb 11y agoI understand that you feel that way, but do me a favour. Go back and look at some of the stuff RMS wrote 10-15 years ago, and then tell me to stop with the slippery slopes. What they are talking about is a pretty big deal, it's a huge deal. What we're going through now is a quiet redefinition of the concept of ownership of property, and that is quite frankly something that we should be having a public and very open debate about. And we need to have it now; in a few years it will be too late.
- petra 11y agoIt's not new. Just look at printers, keurig, routers and wifi sharing, who controls your car computer,windows 10 shenanigans, iPhone software updates, etc, etc.
- capote 11y agoAll these things you mentioned are fine. Cars aren't crashing by being disabled remotely, Windows 10 is decent, I have no issues with my iPhone, I have Keurig coffee at work every now and then and haven't gotten sick or died. Some platforms are open and some are closed. Some are being remotely disabled by their manufacturer (have we bothered to find out why nest is doing this?) and we simply can stop buying products from them.
- tremon 11y ago
- nkrisc 11y agoTime to buy a new car because Google no longer wants to support yours. The wonders the future holds.
- smrtinsert 11y agoYou're thinking Apple. Android 2.x still has 2 or 3 percent of users just fine.
- thejosh 11y agoAh yeah, Google never ditches or turns off products.
- ekianjo 11y agoSadly the NEXUS line was supposed to be an answer to that, until they decided "oh, we are going to drop long term support for older NEXUS devices actually". What a bunch of retards.
- throwaway049 11y agoI don't really expect a phone to be supported beyond 2 years because that's the standard contract length, although I do think it's wasteful and I've had my phone longer than that. My basic heating system control unit is about a decade old and I'm sticking with it.
- ekianjo 11y agoRecent phones (i.e. less than 5 years or so) still work pretty well even with the latest OS updates, there is really no reason to make them obsolete apart from the laziness on the part of Google / manufacturers. Even Apple has been supporting the original iPhone for much longer than 2 years. Buying a new phone every 2 years is not just a waste, it's expensive. You pay for it with your contract. I live SIM-free and i go for the cheapest providers without buying a new phone that often. Works fine and I have yet to see any application that's not running fast enough. The only missing piece of the lack of OS updates.
- tomc1985 11y agoIt is amazing that so many are so desperate for shiny new tech that they're willing to put up with this kind of stuff. I used to consider myself an early-adopter, but its clear they're being played for fools...
- acidburnNSA 11y ago> In an ideal world, Hub owners would be free to point their devices at a different central server, run by a third-party competitor or a trusted friend, or even run such a server on their own. They would likewise be free to collaborate on improved software that would unlock the potential of the Hub hardware or purchase such software from a competitor to Nest. This ideal world exists, and it is glorious. I somewhat recently set up a Raspberry Pi 2 with https://home-assistant.io https://home-assistant.io and a cheap z-wave USB stick. The interface is through a webpage (not an app), and I access it remotely using a OpenVPN server on my router. It's interfacing with door sensors, motion sensors, wall switches, cameras, my stereo, HUE lights, etc. It can email me or send me SMS for notifications. When I wake up and walk past a motion sensor, the lights come on in a dim scene. When I come home and open the door, the lights turn on. I have tons of rules and it's super fun. Totally self-hosted, and the main server is completely open-source (written in Python3). I haven't set it up with a thermostat but lots of other people have.
- balloob 11y agoAuthor here. Thanks for the shout out. As AcidBurnNSA said, Home Assistant is free, fully open-source and fully community driven - no company involved. We have over 240 components and platforms to include a wide range of products and services: https://home-assistant.io/components/ https://home-assistant.io/components/ If you're attending OpenIoT Summit in San Diego, I'll be speaking tomorrow about Home Assistant 1:35pm - 2:25pm in Harbor Ballroom F: http://openiotelc2016.sched.org/event/6DBd/automating-your-home-with-home-assistant-pythons-answer-to-the-internet-of-things-paulus-schoutsen-appfolio http://openiotelc2016.sched.org/event/6DBd/automating-your-h...
- el_benhameen 11y agoMan, I work about a block from there and would've registered in a heartbeat had I known about the conference. The talk sounds fantastic. Any idea if they sell day-of tickets? I don't see them anywhere but figured I may as well ask.
- 11y ago
- mwsherman 11y agoSimilar to another commenter’s note about Raspberry Pi, this seems like an argument that an well-supported, and ideally open, OS is the way to go for devices. Android comes to mind, even iOS would be unlikely to leave customers in a lurch.
- PeCaN 11y agoYeah, if only there was a well-supported open-source OS that is generally regarded as reasonably secure and has been ported to pretty much everything under the sun. It would be nice if it ran the GNU userland for easy development and had a fast and portable kernel.
- eclipxe 11y agoGNU/Windows
- ceejayoz 11y agoYou joke, but... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Subsystem_for_Linux https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Subsystem_for_Linux
- ekianjo 11y agoYeah, that kind of OS is unheard of. :)
- plorg 11y agoSince the Revolv products themselves already run such an OS it might just be a matter of popping a root shell, curling a dropbear, and killing the update daemon.
- diskcat 11y agoThis is why I tell everybody who talks about internet of things that I like my devices like I like my women: small and dumb.
- exabrial 11y agoOk, I was thinking about buying a Nest, definitely avoiding it like the plague now! My home is a long term investment!
- fiatjaf 11y agoMore eletronic devices, more broken devices. More smart devices, more devices infected by viruses. More IoT devices, chaos. The only people who are able to use smart devices are the ones who projected them. There's no point in trying to sell to the large public a lot of things they will not understand, this will only make them dependent.
- FilterSweep 11y ago> There's no point in trying to sell to the large public a lot of things they will not understand, this will only make them dependent. That's the goal (added emphasis).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- incepted 11y ago> It used to be that when you bought an appliance, you owned it, and you could take it apart, repair it, and plug in whatever accessories you wanted without the manufacturer's knowledge or permission. That's some glorious equivocation the EFF is pulling here. You can still do this today. Nothing stops you from taking apart, repairing and tweaking devices you buy. What you can't get today and that you could never, ever get before either, is the guarantee that the company you bought that device from will keep its servers alive for any given period of time. Anyone who thinks that open source is the way out of this dilemma needs a reality check. The fact that the source is open gives you exactly zero guarantees that a company will keep paying for servers that runs this code. Zero. If you're lucky, someone will pick that source up and deploy servers to run it, but again, no guarantees. > Customers likely didn't expect that, 18 months after the last Revolv Hubs were sold, instead of getting more upgrades, the device would be intentionally, permanently, and completely disabled. Then they were naïve customers. If the terms of service don't include such a guarantee, then you don't have it, period. It doesn't matter if the source is open or closed or if the company that provides the device is worth billions or just an angel funded startup. > In an ideal world, Hub owners would be free to point their devices at a different central server, run by a third-party competitor or a trusted friend, They can do this today, the world doesn't need to be "ideal", there just needs to be a financial incentive for a company to run such software. That's what happens in a free trade economy, supply and demand rule. This economy gives us a lot of benefits but you need to be ready to face the reality that sometimes, it won't give you what you want. > But there's another way to push back against untrustworthy devices, and that's refusing to buy electronics and software that prioritize the manufacturer's wishes above your own. What a great idea. Now, can you give a few examples of alternate devices that give us the kind of guarantee you are advocating? I would certainly love to hear about them. Sometimes, I wonder if the EFF lives on the same planet I live on.
- cookiecaper 11y ago>What you can't get today and that you could never, ever get before either, is the guarantee that the company you bought that device from will keep its servers alive for any given period of time. The thing that's different now is that in the old days, the days when it wasn't possible for devices to phone home, they operated independently and contained the functionality offered within themselves. There were no servers to worry about. It didn't matter if the manufacturer closed a business unit, discontinued the product, or anything else; the functionality you paid for at the time of purchase was contained within the component itself. These days, the functionality is contained in code running on someone else's servers, which may be shut down, disabled, or non-functional at any time. Potential solutions to this: a) educate consumers so that it's obvious when they're buying a device whose primary functions are not self-contained, and so that they don't buy these. b) make some legal requirement that the systems running the primary functionality are online and accessible for at least X time after the last unit is sold, or the code can be loaded onto and executed upon the device in a self-contained manner if the primary functional system goes offline, or similar. c) allow people to reverse engineer the hardware, make alternate firmwares that perform the promised functions within the device itself, require the primary functional service code be stored in escrow in case of shutdown, and, if shut down, then the copyright is automatically invalidated and the code automatically released, so that it can be run and/or modified by any interested party. Legal structures would have to be installed to protect people who do this.
- visarga 11y agoThis kind of behavior is reverse piracy: instead of people pirating Big Corp's music and movies, it's Big Corp that's leaving people without the use of their products. So, the internet gods requested two sacrifices: privacy and ownership. Did I miss any?
- chopin 11y agoSecurity
- WalterBright 11y agoSo my thermostat stops working when the internet connection goes down? No sale.
- altitudinous 11y agoThis is illegal in Australia. A customer can reasonably expect that if they pay $300 for an electronic thermostat then it will function for a reasonable amount of time, otherwise the manufacturer will repair or refund/replace. The reasonable amount of time in this case, particularly for a $300 thermostat, would be at least 5 and probably at least 10 years. There was a case that passed through the courts yesterday, Steam tried to exclude these warranties. They didn't get far with that. Source : http://www.gizmodo.com.au/2016/03/australian-federal-court-finds-valve-guilty-of-misleading-steam-customers/ http://www.gizmodo.com.au/2016/03/australian-federal-court-f...
- lucb1e 11y agoSame in the Netherlands. Not sure there is legal precedence but warranty law says a product should keep working as long as 'reasonably expected'. This means you don't get 1 or 2 years of warranty, but potentially fifty if that would be reasonable. If the seller (they can't forward you to the manufacturer or anyone else, either) refuses however, I suppose there is little short of a lawsuit that will help you through.
- chris_wot 11y agoIn Australia, you make a complaint to the ACCC and they will take all the legal action for you after they investigate. Apple was probably the most famous case of where this occurred, but Samsung, HP and other well known brands are now super careful not to violate the law. It's very expensive and dreadful PR if they do, and they have no way of winning.
- ascorbic 11y agoI believe that's the same for the whole of the EU. The fact they were still on sale 18 months ago would make this pretty open and shut, as there's a mandatory 2 year warranty. The question is whether these were sold in the EU.
- Raphmedia 11y agoSame in Canada (Québec at least). I even had Amazon US agree to it.
- chris_wot 11y agoI was interested in Nest devices, but will now never buy one.
- dclowd9901 11y agoTo me, the solution to this is simple: if you eol a product that renders it useless, open source it. Allow someone else to support it and perhaps at a profit. The same would happen if a phone or cable company decided to drop and unprofitable area.
- vlasev 11y agoWouldn't this be a little tricky if such a step can expose proprietary parts in the closed-off products, given that one can expect a reasonable rate of reuse?
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoGiven that Revolv's server software was presumably running before Nest acquired them, and from all rumors, not improved since, what possible proprietary Nest code could it have?
- ceejayoz 11y agoWho said it was Nest's? Maybe it runs on Oracle. Maybe it has third-party stuff licensed for their use but not open source distribution.
- sirclueless 11y agoThe really hairy stuff is usually not the first-party proprietary stuff (e.g. "This stuff is so important to our business we need to keep an exclusive license.") It's usually possible to make an argument to the right business-person that the cost is not so high when compared with the extra brand goodwill and free maintenance. Rather it's the third-party proprietary stuff. Someone else owns proprietary code you deeply rely on but doesn't share any of your business goals and needs. And when dealing with hardware, there is a whole raft of firmware and drivers that could be licensed this way.
- dclowd9901 11y agoIf you care about proprietary tech, it's not going to be with a product you've kicked to the curb. Besides all anyone really needs to support the hardware is a firmware version that allows net configuration and its api.
- sqldba 11y agoWhat I love is the number of people who keep espousing cloud services of every other nature. "Everything is already there! They're better at security than you!" And then history shows services close down, change ownership, prices fluctuate, and there are inside and outside attacks and data loss. You try to tell people that though and they just close up and repeat the same argument. This is why I think repeatable installs / setups of infrastructure is important, and tested on self hosted infrastructure before bubbles pop.
- chaostheory 11y agoSadly with home automation, most of the commercial turnkey products are cloud based and they can't run locally. Wink, Smarthings, Kasa, Homekit, Hue, Onhub, Nest, Mama... nearly everything relies on the cloud. Hopefully open source can provide a good substitute.
- Semaphor 11y agoHow does hue rely on the cloud? It doesn't even need internet access unless you want to update the FW.
- chaostheory 11y agoYou're right. Hue doesn't require cloud access. Neither does MiCasa or WeMo.
- dredmorbius 11y agoI'm working out a concept based around the long tail of slowly-realised costs. It's another economic market problem, similar in regards to informational asymmetries (all information isn't equally available to all parties), but here, all information isn't equally available at all times. Market perceptions are based on promptly-evident information. If the immediate impression of a good is negative, then even large long-run benefits tend to be strongly discounted. If the immediate impressions are good, then even large long-run negative benefits are discounted. All the more so if those long-run effects aren't trivially evident. Take Thomas Midgely. Invented two compounds both of which had immediately evident benefits: freon and tetraethyl lead. Unfortunately for him, they both also had exceptionally bad long-term costs. I'm not aware of any similar concept in economics, though Gresham's Law is perhaps related.
- milesf 11y agoRemember when Google's guiding philosphy was "Don't be evil"?
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoAlphabet's is currently "Do the right thing". But anyone who knows anything knows that the people claiming the most they're doing the right thing, are usually the ones doing the opposite.
- userbinator 11y agoIt's more like "Do the right thing to make the most profit."
- kahwooi 11y agoThat is google.
- cm2187 11y agoI think it is more generally a warning to anyone relying on the cloud. If you develop an app that is hosted in one of the main cloud providers, not the sort of app you have a team developing actively, rather the sort of app you develop once and forget. The cloud is a living thing and doesn't guarantee stability. First there is always a small risk that they may terminate your account as a result of whatever change of policy. But mostly the technologies on which your app rely (web framework, storage API, cache API, etc) will likely be retired on a short notice. Outside of a VM, the cloud is not the right place to host something you want to run for 10 years without having to take care of it.
- elcapitan 11y agoMaybe a stupid question, but is there a follow-up/replacement to the product they are turning off, and why didn't they contact their customers and propose free replacement? Would be such an easy way to completely avoid this customer relations nightmare.
- StreamBright 11y agoIt is kind of funny that we discussed here a service few weeks back with life time usage granted to the users and my argument was that I cannot take anything like that seriously from a company that was not around 10+ years at the very least. This move from Nest/Google just confirms that we cannot trust these companies with "lifetime" promises.
- tempodox 11y agoNest should be sued into oblivion over this. If they get away with this, it will destroy a whole market.
- johnm1019 11y agoIt's always nice to see the author of such serious articles is in fact human. Can we use this as a way of detecting the robot writers? (is being actually fun hard for AI?) > Customers likely didn't expect that, 18 months after the last Revolv Hubs were sold, instead of getting more upgrades, the device would be intentionally, permanently, and completely disabled. (To be fair, the Revolv Hub design resembles HAL from Space Odyssey: 2001, so perhaps someone saw this betrayal coming).
- ehudla 11y agoRelated article at: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11429829 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11429829
- ed_blackburn 11y agoPretty sure this would be illegal in the EU. Seems a bit flying by the seat of your pants to me.
- facepalm 11y agoI think the lesson is more "don't promise your users a lifetime subscription", because it is unlikely that you will be able to make good on the promise. End of life is pretty common for software products. My Wii doesn't support multiplayer anymore. Most smartphones don't get updates anymore after two years. Sure, we can keep using them, but the reality is it would probably be better to switch them off rather than walk around with countless security issues.
- TillE 11y agoDiablo II is still running after 16 years, with no end in sight. There was a tiny patch just a few weeks ago. It may not bring in any money, but the cost of running it (servers plus a little time from a few employees) is a drop in the bucket to any major company.
- frogpelt 11y agoWe better get used to hardware-as-a-service. Cars will soon be all-electric, self-driving and pretty much unrepairable. IoT and smart devices will push everything to subscription model. Your television and the Internet will no longer be the only place you are served ads. When you reach into the fridge for your store brand dairy product, the fridge will say, "Start living healthier now with almond milk! It's currently on sale! Just tap OK on the screen to order a gallon!"
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tombert 11y agoThis is the frustration I have with "cloud" devices, and why I try to avoid using them. Sure, they're convenient as all hell, but if it points to a webservice that I don't/can't control, it inherently has a shelf-life. The issue is that while I totally could figure out how to set up a self-hosted home-automation thing, I'm not sure that the average non-technical user could, which means these cloud-devices are here to stay.
- mattlutze 11y agoWe're buying products whose core functionality, or for which bricking functionality, relies on software outside the device that costs money to maintain. If you're buying stuff that relies on the cloud to run, you're just buying the plastic and silicon, not the actual capabilities those deliver. Maybe the law needs to define what "lifetime" means, and whether a company that buys another company inherits the lifetime of their products. Maybe Nest should have spent some time and money updating the services so that things would run off of existing Nest cloud services and turn these Hubs in to weird-colored Nest devices. But, the bigger issue is thinking that we're buying capability when we're buying just the plastic and bits through which the capability arrives. If we want to buy the capability, we need to start demanding that again.
- awesomerobot 11y agoThere's no reason cloud devices can't have a limited fallback service. This is just lazy software. We're creating a culture where it's ok to throw fully functional hardware into a landfill because of bad code.